Outspoken, fair and sincere as as always, justice katju. CJI Chandrarchud has disappointed millions of Indians by inviting Modi for the Pooja. Hat's off your honour. Stay blessed sir.
@jagan2933Ай бұрын
What sincerety. Let this Govt give him some judicial appointments he will keep quite. All are not that dumb to just open their mouth and listen to such pure political rhetorics.
@ramakantvadje921618 күн бұрын
😢😮 😢
@nanjarajshivaiah8985Ай бұрын
This interview should be telecasted repeatedly in all prime time news channels for months together for people to get enlightened, modiji ki khopde and mentality of people and politicians alike was spot on, economical dhanda sahi jaga par .... is hitting people..❤❤❤❤❤❤ katju,
@agnescraig2912Ай бұрын
Could not spell "Khopde" in my earlier comment. Lovely turn of phrase.
@jasn9900Ай бұрын
We thought Chander choure was a good person , Really, ChanderChoue was CRUPET as other BAD PEOPLE !!!!!@
@ramasubbareddybollavaram9930Ай бұрын
I had utmost respect towards CJI.
@ParveenKumar-ek7ufАй бұрын
Huge respect for justice Katju, revolutionäre man, he is right 100%. Quote of today, India not fit for democratic system, poor, uneducated and caste system.👍🙏😍✋️
@fullonhostelАй бұрын
Each word makes sense. He is absolutely right. He is an educated and highly acclaimed and accomplished man.
@pauldsouza6987Ай бұрын
Hat's off to Justice Markande,for his fearless comments,a big setback to the Judiciary.
@ebenezerking475Ай бұрын
They will see your name, and never care for your words. This country has gone to that extended in division in religion and in many classes,just with in 10 years. The impact they made can't rectified for a long decade. Me too had many experiences.
@karrystewartАй бұрын
All these politics are just enjoying Taxmoney for their lavish traveling abroad, hotels, escorts, sexpleasure etc all criminals politics
@AEdward-ve4wtАй бұрын
@@ebenezerking475..Remember Hitler, Osama Bin Laden, Sadam Hussain etc they also thought themselves above the Law and God and harmed humanity but eventually met with their drastic end, no crimesters nor criminals are above God. Wait and watch God's wrath.
@ebenezerking475Ай бұрын
@@AEdward-ve4wt what's the point of God's wrath after spoiling a mass generation and the impact which created cannot be rectified in anyway possible for a long decade to come.
@Ram-cr1hlАй бұрын
It is ridiculous for the PM to do Pooja at the residence of CJI. Wherever he had done similar poojas it was followed by disaster. This happened in Ayodhya Parliament House etc
@scissors2needlesАй бұрын
"Disaster", isn't it u wr wishing 4? U shud b happy that he is making moves that'll lead to disaster for him.
@risukyndiah4502Ай бұрын
After long time sir katju come back
@rashmikrishnamurthy7725Ай бұрын
Sir Markandeya Katju, welcome back, it's a pleasure to hear Frankly views. Keep it up! 👍💪
@gitasingh1437Ай бұрын
Absolute Respect to Justice Katju who is just not a Judge but a highly intelligent Patriot . He is absolutely a 100% correct on Modi / Rahul and the rest of the politicians . Respect for this great man . Thank you .
@anilbhati1671Ай бұрын
But his language and way of talking is not good.
@revathiiyengar1058Ай бұрын
PM ....even with Rajan Gogoi on Rafale case. He probably meets CJI's to instruct on the ongoing cases. Politicians think they are above law and order.
@anti_que_loverАй бұрын
Google plz.
@amisogleekАй бұрын
Education make lot of difference and especially in the office of the highest post. He is trying to win over and in the bargain tainted the best institution of our country.
@SanjayMalik-u9hАй бұрын
@@anilbhati1671truth is important and speaking when a terrorist is PM
@lalramchandrasinghdeo1483Ай бұрын
After ED, CBI, Election Commission, CAG, now Judiciary is losing credibility.
@mohmadsidiq9374Ай бұрын
100% Right
@mohmadsidiq9374Ай бұрын
100%correct
@samuelkoshy7465Ай бұрын
You are absolutely right. People should think of this
@ilhamnaseem6048Ай бұрын
Absolutely right
@balrajsharma7114Ай бұрын
@@lalramchandrasinghdeo1483 100% TRUE.
@ignasiadesouza3920Ай бұрын
Ms Neelu Vyas I love the way you conduct your self and choose right words without being rude or irritated and putting the actual rude ones in place.
@godschild1233Ай бұрын
Absolutely. I second you !! Want to see more of her ❤😊
@mervtripperАй бұрын
GREAT RESPECT TO JUSTICE MARKANDEY VYAS LOVE THIS GUY . SPECIAL THANKS TO HW News' Neelu Vyas.
@thepeacefulwarrior2879Ай бұрын
Unfortunately, we Indians have never been a discerning lot. We fall prey to a lot of nonsense, empty slogans, etc.
@akshayrvndrnАй бұрын
Teuet
@curiosity465Ай бұрын
National average IQ of India is a mere 77. This explains your comment.
@whykoksАй бұрын
यहां के लोग बड़े डरपोक भी हैं, जरा सा भी रिस्क नहीं ले सकते
@ecomatters3416Ай бұрын
True.. we tend to trust blindly.
@moneeb4748Ай бұрын
Very true our ppl are innocent as well as less literate
@anadimohan1909Ай бұрын
Million Salute to Justice Katju I fully agree with his assessment
@Ravikumar-cl1zuАй бұрын
Justice Katju is absolutely spot on. The only man I came across with forth right views on Indian democracy,politicians and the total system. I belong to Mr.Katju's camp. I think me and Mr.Katju are the only members of this group !
@dip-treeАй бұрын
At any cost, please don't pray to have any 'dictator', like Justice Katju wants. You and the generations to come will regret it very much. Fortunately, the younger generations (world-over) are starting to fix the old-view 'kingdoms'. We do not need large-scale governments and 'leaders' to lead people. No we are not talking of anarchy ...
@agnescraig2912Ай бұрын
@@dip-tree Whilst I liked your comment. Talking about a dictator by Mr. Katju was because of the Stone Age mindset of Religion based on caste and Communalism. Education has not been able shift this entrenched attitude so strong measures are needed to address societal development.
@dip-treeАй бұрын
@@agnescraig2912 But two wrongs wont make one right. What we need is a more intelligent approach to having peace in society. Humanity has been (for most of history) under the grip of dictators, big or small, and brainwashed us into thinking that we need 'rulers' to maintain societal peace. The aspect of caste, religion, race etc have been used by 'dictators' and the 'elites' who helped further their own selfish interest. Fortunately a new world order is silently growing, (an example is the open-source movement) across the world, and although the common person many not know about its existence, it is drastically transforming our society away from the regimes of 'kings' and 'monarchs' (or present day mega billionaries / corporates). As a die-hard optimist this has beem music in my ears for some time, and the young people of the world are becoming smarter to take the world in this new direction of peace, harmony and sufficiency.
@bravikumar8950Ай бұрын
Great interview with justice Katju. Hat's off to Justice Katju for his daringness.Appears that his opinion is almost close to the truth.
@observer6855Ай бұрын
How I wish we have many more such enlightened individuals in our country. Its always nice to listen to Justice Katju and to Neelu Vyas.
@RizwanPathan-d5sАй бұрын
India need highly educated decent honest and humble PM with zero criminal record
@chimugeorge2354Ай бұрын
Very honest and straight forward man. What he said about Modi is absolutely right. He is trying to win over judges. Shame on CJI
@nagarajprasad9105Ай бұрын
Beautiful analysis by the retd justice. Thank you for the interview conducted I agree with the views of the justice.
@hassank956Ай бұрын
Every time in history, there will be someone to openly say 'THE KING IS NAKED*. Justice Katju has come out as a responsible citizen of India at a suitable time
@edmondsanneedmonds2384Ай бұрын
Ms Neelu I love the way you conduct yourself. I love the way you smile. God bless you
@hassobhatia2885Ай бұрын
CJI should make a statement in the Court, on the public record, explaining the circumstances of the puja meeting, clarify whether PM was invited or not, etc..don’t expect Modi to observe the ethics…
@mridul8830Ай бұрын
CJI has no moral responsibility to answer on this as it is personal visit on a festive occasion.
@adv.madanlal13Ай бұрын
Yes, he is not responsible to answer anybody to give account of private visitors to his house or residence. BUT PUBLICIZING his own visit toCJI residence shows that he has succeeded in getting CJI trolled ridiculously this way when both positions do not approve mingling by any mode... Atleast, his is not a public Mandir of God....
@hassobhatia2885Ай бұрын
Obviously you’re ignorant of the role and responsibility of the CJI under the democracy like India. Otherwise we’re just like Russia,everyone under the Putin thumb..
@BunnieLabeyrieАй бұрын
@@hassobhatia2885 he has no balls to make a public statement
@mridul8830Ай бұрын
@@hassobhatia2885 does independent working means that he even cannot have have personal space with members of other constitutional power. To what extent do we have restrain their personal life. Now people will question if marriages are happening between families of the three constitutional powers. As long as their official duty is affected and justice is hindered people should not misinterpret and question their integrity.
@hassank956Ай бұрын
Can't help congratulating Neelu Vyas for her esteemed efforts to conduct such a meritorious interview with a man like Justice Katju. Hope India's people will open eyes and raise their hands at appropriate time
@ronicabehl4814Ай бұрын
Hatss off to such dedicated judges we had This is history now
@taheraabcd4660Ай бұрын
Wah wah best interview aapka last clarification of u r remark bahoot acha jawab diya Mashaallah
@Ravikumar-cl1zuАй бұрын
Keep bringing Justice Katju in your programmes. Consolation that still one or more people are still left in this country with un compromised and forth right views
@JosephAlexander-ve2ezАй бұрын
"I disagree with Justice Katju's views on Rahul Gandhi, who is fighting tirelessly for India's people and their constitutional rights as the Leader of the Opposition. Rahul's commitment to equality and his stand against PM Modi's cronyism make him an exceptional leader."
@saachhnАй бұрын
Rahul on bail in moneylaundering case, don't forget Again his British passport, case in Delhi high Court 😊
@OceanstaАй бұрын
Bhai sab mile hue hai. But i would still vote for RG any time of the day.
@agnescraig2912Ай бұрын
If you disagree and feel Rahul is the Moses. His entitlement to the Congress Presidency was not allowed to be challenged. Power is intoxicating and pls do not delude yourself.
@vincentalmeida705Ай бұрын
Alas ! What an Utter Disaster ❓❓❓❓❓❓Met PM with CJI SC Mr DY Chandrachud for Ganapathi pooja at Mr Chandrachud's official residence at the backdrop with inimical/malafide intention. This intention may be fulfilled ahead in the time to come. (Reproduced)
@anandkarole8351Ай бұрын
Absolutely right.. Rahul gandhi is pure hearted person.. No doubt about it.. God bless him
@OholebOholebАй бұрын
Thank you sir . For your speech on true leadership. Love for people and work for people of India. Is a very strong point
@rameshsaligram3450Ай бұрын
Justice Katju been always very candid.... A few can be... Namaskar to him
@agnescraig2912Ай бұрын
Justice Katju would be forced out by Modi Shah by all means available to them. Need more honest ppl like J. Katju
@muraleedharannair5960Ай бұрын
Absolutely correct the facts. Congratulations
@DailytreatszАй бұрын
Love this interview ❤❤❤❤ Huge respect you CJ Katju Sir ..our country needs revolution to come out of communal thinking and realize serious needs to solve poverty , unemployment, heavy taxes and education system
@indradevabhakt6244Ай бұрын
Hw was not a CJI(Chief Justice of India),..he was Chief Justice of Madras High court.
@Lazarus365Ай бұрын
Too late. It's not possible anymore. The people of India are already divided. This won't change for a million years. "We are like that only"
@bhimraorangari-fj1vzАй бұрын
EVERY HONEST N NATIONALIST INDIAN MUST AGREE WITH THE VIEVS OF JUSTICE KATJU.
@cause1515Ай бұрын
Wish justice Katju is Indian President, rather than the rubber stamps
@shantikiran2562Ай бұрын
It’s disgrace for Modi to visit CJ of India. He should have gone to Manipur.
@sarahbutler2691Ай бұрын
Right
@daviddennis1644Ай бұрын
CJI Katju sir ji, love the authority and transparency you talk with. Simply love you ❤
@sunilkirby7860Ай бұрын
Very strong views about political parties.
@KrishnaWithaKrrrАй бұрын
One of the great stalwarts of indian democracy Justice markandey katju . Much gratitude and respect to last remaining true patriots like him who hold up the integrity of the nation and the justice system 🙏
@kulvinderbrar-z1wАй бұрын
Neelu jee I would like to applaud you for your untiring efforts in getting responsible and conscentious individuals on your platform. We cant thank you enough
@cantradingАй бұрын
Always stand with truth thinking about people only people
@rubiovaz8988Ай бұрын
My full support to this Judge Katju He is a true judge and 21 gun salutes to you. You have made my day for dissecting our corrupt system. God Bless you SIR ❤
@kaleemhereАй бұрын
these are the great people of INDIA. Very good advise by a Senior most respected man.
@mubinexyАй бұрын
He is one the super courageous person ever in the system of judiciary in India… this man is a real 56” heart and balls of steel not the phattu pheku who couldn’t even go to manipur till today
@brksk4309Ай бұрын
Shameless pm and cji. They think they will carry their post forever. People are not fools.
@Lazarus365Ай бұрын
No. The people of India are truly fools otherwise they wouldn't have tolerated all the horrible things that are happening. Things have gone from worse to bad but life goes on as usual.
@batochang2392Ай бұрын
Rightly said
@lightx6363Ай бұрын
Fools😂😂
@amospame627Ай бұрын
Exactly agreed to Sir Katju, as his retirement is approaching, he is trying to mix some masala, so that he may get a lucrative appointment after his retirement from CJI.
@Lazarus365Ай бұрын
Looks like some BJPig was given a bitter pill to swallow and could not get it down. He should repeat it for you.
@SanjayShah-gv6evАй бұрын
Sir Don't assume , there must have been some reason,or else this CJ, would not done it for some favour from politicians.
@sureshmayura2781Ай бұрын
If so let the cji make a public statement in the court explaining the reason weather modi himself came or was invited to attend the pooja.@@SanjayShah-gv6ev
@sunilprabhu9839Ай бұрын
Yes we are from Maharashtra,CJI's birth place is in Poona,(Maharashtra) of which soil History is that, during Peshwa Regime of Marathas Dynasty then Independant Judge Ramshastri Prabhune ordered Dehanta Prayschit(Death Penalty) to his own ruler Raghobadada Peshawa on accustion of murder(assecination) of his own nephew Narayanrao Peshawa,..(wait & watch )Right from begining P.M. is trying to get rid of Judiciary i.e. Third Piller of Democracy once in the hands of New President of India , once in the hands of Law Minister & finally by eliminating the power of constitutional representation of Judiciary while selecting the members of Election Commission of India.Jay Hind Jay Jawan Jay Kisan ,Jay Sanvidhan.. @@SanjayShah-gv6ev
@abdulaleem-ci2chАй бұрын
Sir zindabad
@shrirangtambeАй бұрын
I am in love of justice katju. 😝☺️ He is the BOSS.
@danbose6540Ай бұрын
TRUE 👍
@PrudyBarrettoАй бұрын
Very True Justice Katju
@ratnamani8228Ай бұрын
It was deeply disturbing and made me question if this System is even Fair or rigged from top to bottom. 😢
@rajachowdhary7052Ай бұрын
pahleeee systemmmm kyaaaa imandarr thaa.
@bhawaniinspiredАй бұрын
Rigged top to bottom.
@agnescraig2912Ай бұрын
@@rajachowdhary7052 No said Mr. Katju. Modi aur Rahul kae khopadae mei kuch nahi hai.
@amanchandrani4498Ай бұрын
@@rajachowdhary7052 tum pehle purane heeeeeeeeeeeeeee kartey raho. Kabhi kuch thik mt hone dena.
@AuthenticallymadhuraАй бұрын
Yes it was uncalled for
@WilliamDias-j6rАй бұрын
It was very enjoyable video. Great. Ythanks Madame Neeluji.
@tamilkodimАй бұрын
Very good and thought -provoking discussion !!!
@nengsuanhangshing8899Ай бұрын
May you live long Sir Katju ❤ God bless you dear Neelu
@sonalmore6672Ай бұрын
High Respect to Sir Thank u Nilu ji for getting him for an interview.
@estevendsouza279Ай бұрын
The politicians & Judiciary have sold our heart and personal values as leaders of the Nation.
@sunilnandal6739Ай бұрын
He is talking truthfully.
@RUSSELRAJ-o9tАй бұрын
Very harsh words but it is true true true
@vazhayilshahnaz8656Ай бұрын
Rahul is educated this man is saying stupid for Rahul
@agnescraig2912Ай бұрын
@@vazhayilshahnaz8656 Education does not buy you values and an enlightened Mindset. Education in India is purely an economic issue out of the Poverty trap.
@digvijayurfduggu986Ай бұрын
If the intemperate views of Justice Katju are set aside , whatever he has said about the Indian politics and politicians is absolutely true..
@atompf24Ай бұрын
The only positive and hope in this debacle is that younger members of the judiciary take heed and don’t repeat these huge “mistakes”!
@mdsajid853Ай бұрын
It's lovely to listen justice Mr Katju
@elvisambrose4461Ай бұрын
Absolutely right whatever he has said is true.
@raheemkhan8509Ай бұрын
Justice Katju a great person.
@smsmahal3805Ай бұрын
All praise for daring, impressive views expressed by Justice Katju.We need such persons to lead the country.
@KrishanLal-b5iАй бұрын
Shri Katju has spoken truth-most of the politicians have their own interest for enjoying power.
@abidaunissa4508Ай бұрын
Bilkul correct sir
@lourdesrodrigues4389Ай бұрын
Indian people have lost faith in judiciary
@dip-treeАй бұрын
The country has been hijacked by elites (judiciary is one of the many many ways of the elite) - and this has been for long long time. Time for a reset.
@ecomatters3416Ай бұрын
True to a large extent.
@krbaskaran7148Ай бұрын
Loosing trust with what is happening.
@adwait73Ай бұрын
How ridiculous, when culprits move Scott free and justice is delayed and derailed, Judiciary is entangled in red tape and bureaucratic undue protocols. Justice is no weapon to protect the society. This is since ages are you realising it now
@itsallaboutmindset8278Ай бұрын
Not at all. Only those blinded by extreme left and opposition's godi media are facing this problem.
@CommanderAnuragSaxenaАй бұрын
Excellent discussion with Justice Katju. His views are very correct. Indian political system has failed and we are being ruled by extremely unscrupulous politicians.
@sreenivasraodonaparthy7608Ай бұрын
It's really ridiculous PM going to CJI house for puja. Very Good Comments made by Justice Katju
@agnescraig2912Ай бұрын
CJI was always a pro Hindutva fan like Modi but tried to camouflage it. But approx. two months from retirement so openly jumping ship is fine.
@kuldipsamra5119Ай бұрын
Million salutes to hon Judge Katju Sahib for daring to speak the bitter truth. He deserves to be the present Chief Justice of India
@anti_que_loverАй бұрын
Google.
@musicmania1959Ай бұрын
Justice katju is the most upright and forthright civil servant of India .
@bhupindersing6347Ай бұрын
Katju is right to some extent because present political set up is dishonest and even democratic sytem breeds corrupption. Possibility of fair system of governance is not in the offing in near future. We h a ve to bear with till some revolutionary concept develops.
@jeevanrai544Ай бұрын
What a great man. salute for you. You must speak every day. Today l found you are very true for now.
@elizabethrodrigues2100Ай бұрын
P..M has has sent the message to the nation by posting his pooja activity. What has CJI to say and justify about about PM tweet.??People are waiting to hear from CJI.
@agnescraig2912Ай бұрын
CJI will do the 3 monkey gesture see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil
@sunilkirby7860Ай бұрын
I salute Justice Katju Markande for his integrity, ethics and high degree of judicial standards,
@khesohaba1084Ай бұрын
My respect for Chief Justice has gone to ASHES 😭
@kamalsinghgaira3881Ай бұрын
According to you people, CJI along with then PM Shri Manmohan Singh doing iftaar party was a secular move. Whoever is the Old man, he clearly lies that he never seen such unprecedented event in past.
@mohammedshafiuddin9735Ай бұрын
I agree to the former judge. 100 percent.
@varghesemathew7090Ай бұрын
What a wonderful, amusing talk by Justice Katju who is is hitting hard on the corrupt political system and politicans of India.🤣🤣
@roquedourado8795Ай бұрын
I salute u Sir , U r 100% correct may u long live.
@vinijain1008Ай бұрын
Rahul is better than all of them, for sure
@vidyadharnprabhuАй бұрын
Because he met Ilhan omar @ US??😀😀
@Surrey89Ай бұрын
@@vidyadharnprabhuhe practises inclusive politics. Tum nahi samjoge.
@vidyadharnprabhuАй бұрын
Inclusive politics of meeting anti nationals😀😀
@alecpatersen1847Ай бұрын
@@vidyadharnprabhu Unlike Modi, He didn't go to Pakistan just to have Biryani with then Pakistan PM.
@unkalpaddy16121Ай бұрын
Rahul is the best ganjedi in indian politics
@sunilkirby7860Ай бұрын
Absolutely honest, It is absolutely very difficult to hear the Truth, Justice Katju Markande is showing the mirror to the politicians.
@JuliusKachhapАй бұрын
Hon'ble Justice Katjoo is Bold and COURAGEOUS to condemned CJI to allowed Modi PM to participate in the Ganapati Puja in the residence of the CJI is highly improper & vehemently condemned it.
@neerajpandey6113Ай бұрын
AA GAYA GAWARO ABBU K LIYE , LIFETIME CONGRESSI SLAVE
@luciyafrancis3530Ай бұрын
I wish Modi and CJI should watch this without fail.
@sethuramannil280Ай бұрын
Free Speech & Autonomous/Free Judiciary is ESSENTIAL for any nation's peaceful existence Politicians/PMs/Ministers come & go Free Speech & Free/Autononous Judiciary are NECESSARY
@merwynalmeida6687Ай бұрын
Agree with him 100%
@juliepereira5140Ай бұрын
God bless you Sir for being such a truthful and sincere Chief Justice of Indian
@haunknaga570Ай бұрын
Worth learning about the working of Indian multi-political politics.
@viswaghosh1Ай бұрын
CJI Chandrachud should feel ashamed and apologise to the people of India for violating the trust placed on him and his office.
@agnescraig2912Ай бұрын
Have always had mixed feelings about this highly educated man vs uneducated PM Modi. CJI a soft pro Hindutva follower.
@thomasthekkinethpoulose9497Ай бұрын
❤The last question and the answer in the conversation is a fitting reply or comment and this is worth listening.
@nishithpadman3939Ай бұрын
Modiji lost contact with common Indians and people are desperate with excessive fuel price and GST are breaking the back of Indians.
@krishnanpksr3841Ай бұрын
How sad people keep talking about gst by gst taxes are less earlier we were paying cental exesice duty sales tax vat etc Ye learned man tell me how. Much tax is by central and state on petrol and diesel
@sridharl1389Ай бұрын
The Central BJP government is Not against the GST implement on fuel prices. Only the INDI allaience party States are only against this in GST council meeting and Not taking any steps in this matter.
@neerajpandey6113Ай бұрын
AA GAYA EK AUR GAWAR ,TERE ABBU K IFTAR PARTY ME SAB JAATE THE
@gopalmadduriАй бұрын
@sridharl1389 This is a cheap argument. In 10 years, who stopped BJP from implementing GST on petrol.
@hsuyaarchives2526Ай бұрын
@@gopalmadduri states
@chrislobonnnАй бұрын
Absolutely right Sir
@CredenceGlocalАй бұрын
Grand Salutations Honorable Sir 🎉🎉 May you Stay Safe, Healthy & Blessed till eternity. What an iron man you are Sir. Proud to have you known as the Chief Justice Of this Proud Country ...!! Sadar Naman Sir
@baskerjohn3574Ай бұрын
Former Cji is absolutely Right.
@RattanLalHanglooАй бұрын
Absolutely true
@razaliagha3805Ай бұрын
Had very regards on Cji chandrchud. But now have lost faith.
@agnescraig2912Ай бұрын
Another gullible Indian. Never trusted CJI a media savvy man with a pure Hindutva ideology.
@lekhaselvaraj5687Ай бұрын
Justice. Katju has spoken my heart out
@anjlinfernandez7949Ай бұрын
Very good analysis. Katju Sir should have been the President of our Nation. A genius & a non-biased great personality.
@danielgeorge4964Ай бұрын
Yes sir what you say is absolute right .we appreciate your speech.
@tufailahmed7328Ай бұрын
Jai Jai Markandey Katju ji!!!After a long gap of many years again to listen you in same tone and vigour wonderful pl keep up