I Analyzed The Boy In White's Scenes & This Is What I Found... | FROM Season 3

[@Lexosxis]

WHAT IF THOSE TALISMAN DOESN'T EVEN WORK AND THOSE MONSTERS ARE JUST PRETENDING TO BE AFFECTED BY THEM . CREATING HOPE AND FEAR SIMULTANEOUSLY AMONG THE PEOPLE

[@drugsarebad97]

I remember saying that before this season even came out hah . Something along the lines of “imagine someday the monsters ignore a talisman and walk inside as a huge plot twist”

[@lavelledavis6474]

Naw that makes no sense

[@emmanuelduran4884]

That’s actually genius

[@Thecatdad007]

Remember when Randall held a Tallisman to a monster at the ambulance scene and the monster said “it doesn’t work that way”. It’s possible. But I think they are more like locks that you can set on entrances and I agree that Boyd set the entity free when he took them.

[@lavelledavis6474]

@ I just think he freed the entity by taking that shit the talismans obviously work smh

[@aliengranpa]

My theory of the overall show: Jade was right in season 1. It's an escape room.

[@Violet_Beauregard]

The boy in white is the soul of Thomas waiting to be reincarnated, that's why he disappeared for a while, because he was reborn as Thomas. He tried to help Tabitha because they are connected. And if you think about it the Anghkooey children are also dressed in white, only they are dirty and messy because their souls were corrupted by the sacrifice and they cannot reincarnate anymore.

[@calinc.4079]

This is actually a solid theory

[@JZmixerbeats]

One of the best theories I've seen ur a genius

[@Violet_Beauregard]

@JZmixerbeats thank you! I forgot to say that my theory is also based on the fact that only some people can see the boy in white, so those people must be connected (as only Jade and Tabitha could see the Anghkooey kids and ended up being connected). So far we know that the people that have been able to see the boy in white are: Tabitha, Ethan, Victor, Christopher and Sara. The first 4 people are all connected thru Tabitha/Miranda... but Sara? Well, if Victor's sister Eloise is actually dead (but we don't know for sure yet cause Victor said he only buried some bits and wasn't even sure it was Eloise) and Sara was Eloise's reincarnation? That would start to make sense, wouldn't it? Were they all part of the same family in a previous life? Also in season 3 Victor turned to Sara when he needed help and Sara seemed to be able to understand him, like a sister would... and the boy in white tried to help all these people, he seems to be a positive presence. Jade hasn't seen him so far, but that could be because since he wasn't successful with Christopher in the previous round, he gave up in him. And when they boy in white pushed Tabitha down the lighthouse he said it was the only way, maybe because he knew only by knowing more about Miranda she could've remembered her previous life.

[@JZmixerbeats]

@@Violet_Beauregard That makes a lotta sense, but Eloise might also be Julie, as Tabitha felt a feeling as if she was Miranda when she hugged Victor and JULIE was there.

[@Violet_Beauregard]

@JZmixerbeats I think the writers left Eloise's end kinda open cause they want to leave us with a doubt on whether she died or not. The fact that Victor said he wasn't sure it was his sister she buried was put on purpose to make us believe she actually survived, so that we won't jump to the conclusion that if Miranda was reborn as Tabitha, Eloise could be reborn and be back in Fromville as well. Omg, so much time till the next season I can't wait 😭😭😭

[@greglegakis4177]

I really hope the writers have a master plan to explain all this stuff and have it makes sense and give us some sort of satisfactory ending otherwise this is going to be just a wild goose chase

[@MrKebabsarre]

not likely, they also made LOST

[@greglegakis4177]

@MrKebabsarre who also made Lost?

[@michaelolasubomibalogun]

@@greglegakis4177 The same guys who make FROM also made LOST

[@DoubleFractals]

I like chasing wild geese

[@MrKebabsarre]

@@greglegakis4177 oh, sweet summer child.

[@jonbuono7826]

The show is written with the intention for the audience to lose their mind trying to figure all this out just as the characters do but fail. Just be like a background character and relax.

[@ElizRued]

Exactly. You got it😂

[@Gamebred13]

😂😂😂😂 best comment I’ve seen 😅

[@yusavelli0448]

but its less fun that way

[@Interdacted]

The writers where the entity all along trying to break us.😅😂😅😂 we're in fromvile.

[@ReaperRells]

If the town of from worked together from day one and shared information, this show would be, at best, 1.5 seasons long

[@mrsw2923]

Exactly

[@jasperhawn]

Fr. Like every damn time a char is ask whats the problem or if they found any usefull information, it would take an entire season for that information to be divuldge only for it to be too late for that information to be usefull. This series overflow with too much false positivity that all logic of basic scientific investigation and problem solving basically fly out the window.

[@Bharatbehhhl]

But how would producers mince money for 3 seasons than

[@LukaDojcinovic-t2u]

Dont be so sure. We all saw man in Yellow killing people who knows to much

[@dhairya8238]

As far as I'm concerned, this is the closest to real life. You realise they're all a different and diverse group of absolute strangers and are focusing on staying alive right? They aren't told that they're in an escape room. When someone tells them this, it turns out to be manipulation. So it's normal that most of them keep it to themselves and are just trying to get by. Let's take the city of newyork for example, surviving in it is torture, that does not mean that everyone you come across in the subway will be willing to exchange information and work with you. People have their own lives, families, problems, celebrations to handle and most of them are dealing with their own monsters. It takes time for people to grow on each other, it'd take longer than usual considering the circumstances that the characters of FROM met each other in.

[@MrJdcirbo]

The boy in white talked to sara when she and boyd were in the forest. He's the one that told them to go into the faraway tree. So, she knows what the biw sounds like, and she hasn't said the voice or voices sound like him. So, I find it highly unlikely that the biw is one of the voices

[@osmellarosa8729]

I think the boy in white is the personification of the tree, and the tree is the personification of the hope raised from the children on the ritual, that's why every time the boy in white appears he leads them to trees to go to places or temporal lines to unravel secrets and save them, but only the choose ones , that's why dale die, is a signal than not everyone can enter, and that explain how Tabitha is teleported in space when te boy pushed her out of the lighthouse, what else can teleport things on from village?..... You're god damn right...the tree

[@polest]

@@osmellarosa8729 and this tree was in the lighthouse pushing tabitha? :D

[@osmellarosa8729]

@@polest in a place like that, seen the things we have seen, u think it impossible?

[@Shanannigan1]

I'm beginning to think that The Boy In White is a Story Walker like Julie, but one who has been doing it for a very long time. In a similar way he shows up at pivotal times, but sporadically, which works similarly to how we saw Julies story walking. We also know that he made an attempt to explain everything to Christopher, but it didn't work. So he seems like he wants to help the people and explain things, but he has realized that it doesn't work that way and he needs to help in smaller ways.

[@SnuffSwag]

I really like that idea. Nice. Makes sense

[@randymcmullen538]

The boy in white told Victor where to hide in the tunnels to stay hidden from the monsters…

[@likeluptid]

I'm glad you showed that picture of Victor waving. I'll bet I've not spoken to one person who has ever noticed the sign behind Victor that tells the name of the motel. We never see it now because it has fallen down. But when Victor was 10 years old, it was there, the Star Magic Motel.

[@StreetDisciple86]

Another thing that makes me think he isn't evil is him apologizing before pushing her out the window. Nothing evil would apologize. I agree with some of the deeper theories with proven easter eggs that the man im yellow is either the man himself or controlled by him. I believe the MIY is none other than Dr. MABUSE. Everything going on in from are all things directly connected with his abilities and powers. Again i do think this is a good vs evil timeloop kind of like Dark on Netflix and how the villain ended up being the very hero trying to stop himself from thw future the whole time.

[@AlexTrusk91]

You know wich cheese they eat there? -Frommage

[@SageGamersX]

Im confused why everyone thought the monsters couldn't run their ridiculously quick🤣 they just pretend that they cant run to scare people i thought we all knew this. Like when that guy gets eaten in the box the mosters tear him up quickly.

[@gaeouhgaeae]

Ye ofc. They don't run cause they are not here to kill. They are here to serve the entity who feeds off of people hope and fears. If people are dead the evil entity can't have fun anymore. Didn't you see the scene with Randall and the ambulance ? The barn ? They could have killed everyone outside if they wanted to

[@SnuffSwag]

​@MC-fb1tj obviously. That was the reason for the comment in the first place buddy.

[@SnuffSwag]

@MC-fb1tj obviously you're speaking of different scenes genius. The conversations about them being able to run only began after the scene you, captain obvious, mentioned. This person is confused why that's new information. And you, for whatever reason, decided to educate him on the scene he's clearly using as a springboard Actually, I take all that back. Without you, I'd have no idea that Miranda was eaten after a monster ran at her, in the only scene we ever saw them running at someone.

[@MC-fb1tj]

@ why are you assuming that the scene I’m referring to is what made him comment initially

[@MC-fb1tj]

@ the first comment is clearly speaking about the monsters attacking into the box not the Miranda scene

[@StreetDisciple86]

The monsters are the people who willingly sacrificed their children to the entity for immortality. They just didn't know they'd become zombie puppets for the MIY, whom i think is MABUSE. The angkooey kids or however you spell it are the sacrificed kids. Their are five kids, if i remember correctly. So 2 parents for each child sacrificed, making 10 parents who lost their kids. Im unsure if the parent's themselves willing sacrificed them or someone kidnapped other peoples kids and offered them to the entity. The fact that Jade and Tabithas kids are one of the anghkooey kids, daughter to be exact, and they tried to save them i believe all the kids were stolen. Im curious whether or not the other 9 sets of parents are stuck in the loop too or if its just tabitha and jade

[@LemonSte]

I think the monsters are those parents that sacrificed the children. they just also stole tab/jade's kid

[@rudeasmith5098]

But didn't Jade go underground and see the symbol while being surrounded by seven (7) slabs with a child on each slab? It is more than five kids, and it is possible for more than one child from the same parents to have been sacrificed.

[@rudeasmith5098]

@@LemonSte Some people were wondering about the grandma creature, I think the townspeople all agreed to do this and Jade and Tabitha sung lullabies to the children because they wanted their child and the others to know that they didn't agree to this. So, the creatures get immortality, and Jade and Tabitha keep getting "reincarnated" in a cycle to free the children.

[@jessn7034]

@@StreetDisciple86 7 kids 14 parents 12 monsters plus Jade and Tabitha. I believe they have changed others into monsters though, maybe people from the past that took the same immortality deal, because we’ve seen way more than 12 monsters

[@kevjd24]

Didn’t Fatima say that they sacrificed their own children? I could’ve sworn she did.

[@DeliciouslyFierceMedia]

I think the ambulance been there before, because I think it's the same abandoned ambulance we see outside their clinic in season one

[@why._ou7994]

but if the boy/entity was trapped when someone put the talisman in the cave then how come victor could see him?

[@jessn7034]

The boy in white is getting older, perhaps he’s the man in yellow as an adult

[@couchtourist256]

BOYD FREED MARTIN AS WELL WHEN HE WAS CHAINED IN THE DUNGEON

[@GraybushThreepwood]

In my head cannon, the boy in white wet himself before being transported and eventually becoming the man in yellow.

[@joeyskywalker1322]

Nah Boy in White and Man in Yellow are two different people

[@jessn7034]

@@joeyskywalker1322 oh dang, where’d they confirm that? I missed it

[@user-nk8qf8nz8k]

​@jessn7034 where'd you get such a retarded ass theory

[@Thecatdad007]

What if the BIW is a fractured mind / split personality of Victor to help him cope and have a friend when he was all alone. What if Victor is somehow the entity and drawings that his mother drew were when she was pregnant with him? Victor being the evil entity killed the whole town and also his mother and then couldn’t cope so split his mind so that he wouldn’t blame himself. Now he’s caught in a moral tug of war between who he wants to be and who he is?

[@srg6591]

Your theory would suggest that the monsters would also be part of this mind/split personnality of Victor which can t be as we see the same famous smiley monster, who got killed live by Boyd, kill his mother

[@Thecatdad007]

@@srg6591not at all. He would control them with the evil split personality. People with these disorders commonly don’t remember what the other personality has done.

[@srg6591]

@@Thecatdad007 wrong. We see a scene when victor is in tunnels with his dad and 1 of the monster says to him to not come back there or else he ll have to stay there forever, he doesn t control them... and I know you re gonna say that it is his EvIL SpLIt personnality that controls them but nevertheless the monsters would recognized him for his appearance and not threaten him

[@StellaKalagbor]

Man you said it all, BIW might be his good side and was trying to help everybody by telling Christopher wat to do but victor heard it and kill dem all, that’s why sera said his not a little boy

[@StellaKalagbor]

@@srg6591if they don’t threaten him den we might suspect something right? Dey don’t want us to have any clue

[@billxar7989]

I think the boy in white is Thomas’s soul/ghost..Victor said that he didn’t see the biw for some time before the Matthews came to town,probably because at that time the biw was Thomas in the real world…he also appears to be notably different from the anghkooey children so he’s not a sacrificed kid but probably a good entity/ghost of a boy(Thomas and previous reincarnations) who died in the real world and is also somehow trapped in fromville..the fact that we never learned his name until now it’s also a sign

[@kevjd24]

The boy in white is not evil. Your theory is wrong. He is the only good entity there and is clearly in a power struggle with the evil entity. And the voice on the radio was the man in yellow.

[@joerod2019]

Wow.....great point pm the talisman hut. Also Sarah said they are laughing for setting it free...for "bringing them back" to town

[@byankahoffman2670]

I'm sure she means the cicadas and the entity tied to the music box and all the "my blood is your blood" situation.

[@couchtourist256]

THE TALISMANS WERE ACTUALLY KEEPING SOMETHING IN THE CAVE

[@GraybushThreepwood]

This would be a cool twist. A season too late, sure, but it'd be a step in the right direction.

[@KingOfWinter]

@@GraybushThreepwoodI don’t think it would necessarily be “too late”. It’s obvious from the beginning that the town is messing with them so they could play it off as the monster that’s always watching them and laughing and talking to Sarah. So he’s always been around we just didn’t know how big of a deal he is.

[@The_Barefoot_Wrestler8824]

everything sounds good you are saying but one fault in the theory is when the monster told victor if you keep coming down here we will make you stay. if they boy in white controls them, they cant make that choice.

[@lisahuber9329]

I think they were just fucking with him

[@Ash.Crow.Goddess]

Agreed. I immediately thought "He knows full well Victor is there." The BiW doesn't need to see or hear someone to know they are there. But I also think there's a parallel with Jasper.

[@RahYisrael99]

That one line alone let me know that the monsters are in full control. Then, in hindsight, when Boyd killed Smiley. The monsters could have stopped him, but they did not. Cowboy was behind Boyd the entire time. They let him off Smiley and get back into the post office unscathed.

[@wazindo]

Also Victor saw the BIW way before talismans. He would probably know(and likely forget) that the talisman hut was to trap something

[@lateef9425]

I honestly think that the show runners are manipulating us , leaving crumbs and little (filler) details that make you talk about them more and more and overthink everything. This show relies on audience that bring theories to their front door. They will entertain those theories the next season with more crumbs and little filler details. At the end , this place they are in, doesn't have explanation. They may or may not leave. And that's the end of it.

[@yusavelli0448]

like Jim said there's too many monsters and bad entities in the town... we need a good entity or someone with a tank to drop in the town

[@ibabyvamp]

but if he changed his voice to sound like the anghkooey children that means he can sound like anyone?

[@kevjd24]

Yeah that’s why the boy in white has to be good. Otherwise everything is evil. And you need at least one protagonist.

[@GREATESTHITSREPLAYY]

Anyone noticed that Monsters can run? Remember that scene when Mr Smiley attack Victor's Mom😢😢 i think they pretend to fear talisman too

[@MC-fb1tj]

Exactly

[@kevjd24]

Why would they be pretending to fear the talismans? I have seen this theory multiple times and it doesn’t make any sense.

[@GREATESTHITSREPLAYY]

@@kevjd24 The town holds many secrets, which is why I believe the creatures only pretend to fear the talisman. Remember that scene when they told Boyd to leave with the ambulance and let Randall stay behind? Randall held the talisman in his hand and threatened to make them back off, but one of the creatures responded, "It doesn't work like that, Randall." The creatures give people hope only to crush it more deeply. Sometimes, I think that when Boyd hid in the cave and they left him alone, it wasn’t just the talisman that saved him, but perhaps something else. He believed the talisman protected him, and so they allowed his hope to remain. The creatures don’t kill people because they’re hungry; they torment them because they want to instill fear. From my point of view, that’s why they don’t run, even though they could. Here are my reasons for believing this theory: 1. They kill Tian Chen to break Boyd's spirit. 2. They injure Randall but don't kill him-they leave him with wounds. 3. When Victor steal the doll in the cave, one creature says, “Next time you’ll have to stay, Victor, if you keep coming here.” 4. They had several opportunities to kill Boyd, but they didn’t.

[@kevjd24]

@@GREATESTHITSREPLAYY The Talisman only protects a closed space or structure, like a house. That’s why they said it doesn’t work like that to Randal cuz he just held it up outside. They clearly have a plan to further torment Randall. Or they just want people to look at his mauled face to instill fear, like Boyd says. They don’t kill Boyd and kill Tian Chen in front of him because they are trying to break him. They want to kill the town’s hope and Boyd is their leader and gives them that. None of your examples have anything to do with the Talismans. And everything so far indicates the Talismans are their only protection. Boyd even said the Monsters changed after they got the Talismans. He said they used to shriek all night long, but when they got the Talismans they stopped. I have yet to see a shred of evidence that supports this theory.

[@MC-fb1tj]

@ the town supposedly feeds off the peoples hope

[@orangelightening]

I could be wrong, but i think people are overthinking it. I think the moment Boyd freed the entity was when he killed smiley by doing the whole "my blood is your blood" spiel I also don't think the boy in white in evil or bad, i think he's good, and trying to save the children however for reasons unknown he doesn't just come out and tell people what they need to do, he makes them try to figure it out themselves, maybe he doesn't help them more because people wolud under normal circumstances be skeptical of him thinking he's maybe an evil entity like when Sara hears the voices, or when Elgin was seeing the creepy kimono women. Also, the boy in white told christopher outright what he needed to do, that he needed to go to the tree in order and christopher obviously refused to go. So i think the boy in white is no longer telling people what they need to do because the people are obviously more motivated trying to figure things out for themselves then when he tells them and more things happen. Like Jade, Boyd, and Tabitha are the ones trying to figure the town out and trying to figure out how to get home and such but Christopher was having things handed to him on a silver platter and he squandered it and refused

[@Life_starting]

Exactly my 💭 thoughts

[@DRandR1productionz]

if you remember victors flashback I think reason the BIW doesn't just tell them is because he told Christopher once already and he got angry victor then ended up tellin his mum and she failed which is why everyone ended up dying think the BIW wants people to figure it out because then they'll believe it after solving everything themselves

[@VaporeonEnjoyer1]

The boy being evil makes no narrative sense. He's the personification of hope or goodness or light or whatever, the positive force, counterbalancing the evil man in yellow. It's Jacob and the Man in Black all over again.

[@LordGreg-n4i]

The cold hard truth is the writers have no clue about the boy in white. The boy in white is simply a kid who accidentally made his way onto the set while searching for a Pokémon. When the kid finally found his Pokémon he realized he stumbled onto to the set during filming, and because it was too expensive to redo the scene, the producers simply decided to keep him in the series. Bottom line, it is clear they are making stuff up as the series progresses. The time travel stuff probably came about after the writers met at Hooters with the Smily Monster actor. This actor probably said he was paying for all drinks until the restaurant closed. After the writers got drunk, woke up with a hangover, and said, "Oh damn, we are late for work, so let's quickly make up some confusing time travel stuff. " The Smily monster actor probably passed out naked at the writers' home and when he woke up the next morning with no clothes, he stated he was about to go to the police only for the writers to say ok we will put you back into the series. That is why the Smily face monster is born with no clothes on. The actor went straight from the writers' home to the set.

[@sebastiandjo]

Lmao.. I'm dead 😹😹😹

[@LastReality-11]

Thats one of the best theories so far , I always thought that something was wrong with the boy on white (and btw you sound like Gru from despicable me )

[@jackwilliam4436]

Talisman theory : Julie used her Story Walker powers to steal the talismans (triggering the Creature to change and leading them to search for the talismans). Shortly after, they crossed path with Boyd and, while trying to escape, he fell in that tree trunk. Why were the stolen talismans in the tree trunk ? Julie's Story Walker powers allowed Julie to know Boyd would be there at that time and she placed the stolen talismans there for him to 'accidentally' find. After all, she already helped Boyd, when he was stuck in that well. Maybe, Boyd is the only 'unknown variable' Julie can change, when using her Story Walker powers. Maybe, she can't change anything, except when Boyd is involved ? If she were truly incapable of changing 'past chapters' there is no way she could have ever helped Boyd when he was trapped in the well, so she can change 'past chapters', but only under very specific circumstance and, most probably, only when she is Boyd's only chance.

[@rudeasmith5098]

Something you said about the BIW appearing to Victor, while he was alone but then you contradicted that statement by saying the BIW was freed because Boyd found the talismans in the cave? The BIW and "the entity" are two different things, I get what you are trying to say here, but the entity is something that Martin may have alluded to in the underground dungeon scene to Boyd and Julie. The MIY spoke to Jim on the radio and phone, he is the entity responsible not the BIW, I believe until it is confirmed to be otherwise. Ultimately the BIW IS a gatekeeper, he is there to observe and "help" when he wants to and because FROM is a game that you have to abide by with very unfair rules. Also, I don't believe that is a "red jellyfish" but a representation of how the monsters grow out of the pods right before that come out, maybe. I do understand from the cave drawings that anything in red is bad news, so the fact that the lighthouse is red is adding to the mystery! I do agree that the BIW helps with navigation in the faraway trees and sends you where you have to go next to progress in this game, too bad for Dale! Also, that night with the ambulance, I believe the BIW gave the creatures some victims in exchange for Miranda coming back with Victor and maybe Acosta because they needed an extra person because Tilly was going to be gone soon. Those medics were fresh for the taking for the creatures. I do agree 💯with you that the BIW is highly manipulative and can either harm as well as be good, but I still believe he is good overall, he just can't say too much and give anyone an advantage because then the game would be figured out too soon. My basic theory about the BIW is why is he in white? The Anghkooey kids, the girl Miranda saw in her dreams wearing a dirty white skirt and him wearing clean all white clothing? What is the symbolic reasoning for this? I was thinking he was not sacrificed but I'm not sure because he can go into dreams and the "real world". He could be much older than his appearance, but he has been a "ghost" or "entity" for a very long time and since he has started to "age" in the show I'm hoping we will see who and/or what he truly is. A very good video, lots of great points and insights.

[@ayova61]

I think the boy in white is the second child (Victor, Ethan) who after they sacrificed the daughter , they sacrificed themselves instead to let their son not feed the entity w his soul. this created an atypical curse in which the souls are constantly reincarnated to provide children for future cycles in perpetuity. The chained man is the boy in white as that is his true age. I believe the BIW is a powerful figure and a necessary balance to the evil. We know the chained man has the power to preserve characters via the cicadas - Randall and Boyd were both spared and the cicadas killed smiley. Therefore the chained man is the accompanying component of the town but the MIY has tried his best to control him

[@rahbeeuh]

Just in case you forgot, the chained man's name was Martin ​@@ayova61

[@TheRidg11]

You have some wild theories and I love it haha, its obvious you are one of the only youtubers that hasn't read the leaks and for that you get 100% of my respect 👊 most have miraculously started to figure everything out for episode 10 now the leaks are around 😅 what a coincidence

[@ThePrimordialJunction]

I’ve heard a lot about these leaks! Though haven’t seen anyone out right spread them around. Any leak would only be for season 3. I don’t believe they have season punched up yet. Most likely they have a loose outline. The thing is at this point it writes itself. The ending has been telegraphed to us. In season 1. The first 6 episodes and Jades visions in them. The visions make sense, once Jade has that scene in the finale of season 2 seeing what the sigil represents. The three tree roots. So if unending life is one of the possible fates here. And another possible fate here is ending up like a puppet on strings for the evil entity. To be used to torture the other townspeople. So maybe the visions mean if humanity doesn’t stop this entity. Then a world tree will grow unleashing this evil entity. Which will give it the ability to influence the real world. Enslaving humanity… civil war was fought over slavery after all.

[@evarosario5497]

OM.G. THIS SHOW IS ABSOLUTELY, INCREDIBLE. I LOVE THIS SHOW I WAS SO SHOCKED 😲 WHEN I SAW THE BABY, IT TURNS OUT TO BE SMILEY. I HAD TO WATCH IT 3 TIMES TO MAKE SURE I SAW THE SMILEY. SEASON 4 IS GOING TO BE A WORTH WAITING FOR.❤❤❤

[@whatitdo8422]

2026

[@DeliciouslyFierceMedia]

I watched it a couple times too, It was amazing & completely mind blowing🤯

[@byankahoffman2670]

Boyd freed the entity, bringing it back to town when he brought Martin's blood with him, gave to smiley and they breaking his gallbladder making the cicadas appeared. I dong know if all those things needed to happen, but the talisman he had way before the show started and was never referenced. This Sara said "tehyre laighing at you for bringing it back to town," was in season 2 episode 10. No way she's talking about the talismans, she's talking about the cicadas, the music box entity or whatever is tied to the "my blood is your blood" thing.

[@nicocba2OO7]

The Victor and the BIW have not seen each other for a long time was a line added just to justify the BIW actor got older, but the truth is the last time they saw each other was when the BIW told Victor to go into the farway tree with Julie the night of the Colony House m4s4cr3. That is only 15 days ago in the series timeline lol! your theories never make any sense, but they are funny and you always make me laugh.

[@RahYisrael99]

Maybe he's speaking on the fact that he hasnt seen him regularly in years. When Ethan told Victor he was seeing the boy in white, Victor said to tell him I said hi. That was in season 1.

[@ElizRued]

No, he meant he didn't see him BEFORE Ethan got into the town for a long time. He stopped seeing him as a teenager I guess.. ?

[@nicocba2OO7]

@@RahYisrael99 maybe maybe maybe, nothing... this doesn't need fan justification, they added those lines to deal with the fact the boy crew up and got older, period... god I hate fan justification, especially onto obvious stuff

[@lavelledavis6474]

It’s been longer than 15 days you’re time scaling is all fucked up lmao

[@nicocba2OO7]

@@ElizRued nah

[@likeluptid]

I think you've confused 2 very distinct personalities that are working against each other in many ways like a chess game. The Boy in White and the master of that realm keep on appearing to make moves and countermoves against each other. And the Boy in White is impressively masterful now, as if he kept learning each of the times he lost. You can see the final 2 moves from 40 years ago. The Boy in White gave Christopher information that would have ended the existence of the nightmare creatures, but Christopher didn't respond the way that the Boy expected. Miranda made a run for the Bottle Tree, and when she came within 5 seconds of ending the nightmare creatures and the cycle that keeps coming around, the nightmare creatures responded with rage, sweeping through the town, finding every hiding spot, and brutally tearing people apart. When the population of the Town was beginning to grow again, and time was approaching for the Boy in White to bring to town the parents who loved and comforted the children offered as a sacrifice, he brings Boyd and his family to Town. Boyd is an organizer. He finds animals in the forest. (That might have come from the Boy.) And one evening while Boyd is in the forest, the Boy sends his dog to Boyd, expecting Boyd to follow the dog and get lost in full view of the nightmare creatures. That way, when they chase him, he will duck into the cave and notice the creatures break pursuit. And that's how Boyd was manipulated into finding a way to protect the town from the creatures. Very smooth move! As Boyd is approaching the Town with the talismans, the entity has made his countermove. Abby, suffering mental breakdown, is on a shooting spree, killing the people that the talismans are meant to protect. She takes down several people before she's taken down herself. Then comes the day that the Boy in White is bringing to town the reincarnated mother and father that tried to save the children trapped in a tower. But before their arrival, the entity speaks to Sara with with many "voices," gaining her confidence first by claiming to be just like her and the Townspeople, trapped in the Town. And it lies to her, saying telling her that "2 cars were coming, and to stand out near the edge of town and I would see. They said it happened before, that 2 cars came on the same day and everyone died. They said it was because of the people in the cars, but if I did what they said, that's we'd be safe; we'd get to go home." It deliberately misled Sara into thinking that "the people in the cars" that were coming were as dangerous to the entire Town as the people in the 2 cars that had arrived the same day years ago. Of course, the entity is interested only in killing Tabitha and Jade, but it was wise enough not to reveal that. That's why it tricked Sara into thinking that everybody in the 2 cars were dangerous. Ethan Matthews would be the easiest person to kill, but Toby McCray became the most accessible 1st. She killed him; made it appear that the nightmare creatures took him out; and no one was the wiser to suspect her. The whole thing was botched when Sara tried to kill Ethan publicly. The first time Jim meets Victor, he threatens Victor warning him to never come near Ethan again. The very next day, Victor is in the forest with Ethan. When Jim comes close to discovering them together, the Boy sends, not 1, but 2 dogs directly to Jim. He's protective of Victor. He's also very protective of Boyd. He won't reveal himself to Boyd, but he keeps Boyd safe. When Boyd gets too close to the lighthouse, the master of that realm, the "entity" becomes angry and begins whipping up a lethal storm. The Boy shows up, but avoids Boyd's line of vision, and he speaks to Sara telepathically so that Boyd doesn't hear him. He directs them to a nearby Faraway tree. The storm is immediately stopped when Boyd is closer to Town, in a well in a dungeon. When he comes out, the Boy sends his dog to Boyd again. It leads him through the creatures to the Clarity canned good truck where Victor and Tabitha are hanging out. Those 2 are together because the Boy arranged it, hoping to wake up Miranda. When Colony House was attacked, Victor was directed by the Boy in White to a tree that brought him to the tunnels. And Victor was shown where to hid so that the nightmare creatures won't find him. He was there for 3 nights and 3 days, while Boyd was in the forest for 3 days. Even the sight of a trapped child in the tunnels did not awaken Miranda. The Boy kept showing Jade visions of his previous lives, waiting for Jade to intelligently realize that they were all him. And it kept showing him the roots of the tree that he saw when he was with the kids being sacrificed. Miranda already remembers her previous lives, "each and every one of them," so the Boy kept hoping to awaken only Miranda; then Tabitha would remember everything too. She kept seeing visions of the children. The Boy even sent Tabitha to Camden, Maine deliberately, hoping Miranda would awaken by the time he brought her back to the magical realm. (Yes, she was coming back. The entire purpose of her being there was to save the children and end the cycle, and that had not been done yet.) Meanwhile, Martin, who has repeated to Boyd what Abby said on the day of her shooting spree, transfers a curse in his blood to Boyd, and Boyd releases that curse into Smiley, and Smiley's corpse releases the curse into the town. Throughout the entire series, that's the only seemingly out of place thing that the Boy has done. It looks like he deliberately put Boyd in a situation that he knew the entity would take advantage of. When the curse was released into town, the "rhyme" came true: "They touch, they break, they steal. Nothing here is free. Here they come. They come for 3 unless you stop the melody." They touch Kenny, break Paula, then steal the souls of Julie, Randall, and Marielle. Boyd goes to the dungeon and destroy the music box and everything seems to become normal again. And the sound of cicadas leave the town. Boyd steps out the dungeon and proclaims to the entity, "You don't break me." Then he notices the dog belonging to the Boy in White standing beside him. Then it runs away. I don't know what this means yet, but it appears that the Boy in White might have tricked the entity into something that will come back against it in the future. That's the only thing that the Boy has done that's confusing. In all other instances, his actions benefitted Jade and Tabitha first and by extension the entire Township, and he's working on benefitting the spirits of the children murdered in the tower. And he takes care of his friends. The entity has no problem removing anyone that might threaten its selfish interests, even torturing people as it tortured Sara, Marielle, Randall, and Julie. You never see the Boy in White do that.

[@Life_starting]

To my theory, the talisman kept the children's soul limited within the cave. Not the entity. And i think that martin passed on the curse on boyd when transferred to smiley, this let the entity release or curse release! Towns people are those monsters walking at night, who can regenerate even if their body is killed (obviously not possible) and people who die in the town, when reincarnate, return to the town again repeating its cycle to consume the energy to keep the town alive (like supplies and electricity)

[@hard_at_work]

I don't know.. I commented on the official MGM channel last time that it really had a Jacob's Ladder vibe. And talking about sacrifices, energy displacement, time travels etc. I still think at the end the story's ultimate ending will be about surrender and acceptance rather than control. It's already been said that the children made the faraway tree and that currently the Fromville town is changing as becoming more purposed. Maybe even more of a shift as all the beings and characters feed of each other. The more relevant or knowing some become like Ethans sister the more forgetting of the past Ethan himself is presented as. Maybe the true eye of the storm in the center of Yin, Yang that which makes all balanced but is the behemoth in itself.

[@gnrsnticolover]

i think voice behind the radio was man in yellow because when he killed Jim he said he warned him and it could be only then and when someone pretended to be Thomas

[@LastReality-11]

Yes

[@ikindaloveetsy5348]

Thank you so much!! I’ve been saying that the cave girl is Eloise since they showed her. She’s the one having tea parties with Jasper. She’s the reason Victor is always in the caves. He comes to see his sister.

[@ElizRued]

Which cave girl?

[@ikindaloveetsy5348]

@ the girl Victor and Tabitha saw when Tabby fell through the floor

[@gnrsnticolover]

what if the man in yellow is the sherif of monsters

[@centipedekid9824]

What are you talking about? Victor visits the tunnels while the monsters sleep. The truck isn't that far from the cave. It's more likely that he kept coming back that's why they told him if you keep coming back that one day they won't let him leave.

[@woodbridgesfinest1904]

I hope they reveal something about the Boy in White regarding this. I wonder if he blighted Victors memory to stop him from warning people in the future.

[@LolLol-rw9mg]

Bro's blaming everyone, literally every video on his channel is blaming every character of the series 😂😂

[@magicker8052]

Remember. Monsters: "if you keep coming down here we are going to make you stay"

[@Marshmellowtoast2]

The BIW told Sara to get in the tree, Sara told Boyd and Boyd ended up in the well. BIW was not counting on Julie giving Boyd the rope to climb out. And martin said he will be back soon

[@withcharmtospare]

3:53 I dunno what it was this season, 3, where Victor and his Dad are in the tunnels, gave me the idea that he had been there before. He didn’t seem surprised they were in the monsters lair WITH ppl stuff. It made me think they have their faves each cycle. I wonder if it’s their prize for taking their faves.

[@Shaq2k]

About the killing of Smiley.. why don't they pursue that lead as well? They could have developed a way to kill ALL the monsters. But no

[@chaseclarkemusic]

Forreal, i dont know why they stoppwd after that, they used a sillt bullet and thats it why didnt boyd try it again and again

[@Life_starting]

I think monster was not killed but that body was damaged only, due to which, that curse of cicadas or we can say the things worsen, and as last episode shows, that smiley reborns, which refers that monsters if die (body) then they will regenerate again!

[@Wickedkingzed]

They should not try and kill a monster will just be reborn and the townspeople will suffer cause of this like what just happened to Fatima they must figure out how to escape or free the kids souls only way out

[@venod3134]

The townspeople aren't being "stupid". They are being logical based on what we know about real life. There are no such thing as "monsters" so even seeing them it is hard for them to believe.

[@HAKIMEOVER9000]

The crows told the monsters that the ambulance was coming

[@gonz702]

👆

[@gaeouhgaeae]

You still don't get it ? There are no monsters. They are dead and used by an evil entity. The evil entity know everything about the people in town and whatever is happening (Taby in the tunnels, Thomas on the phone, voices in their heads, SARA WHO HEARS FROM FATHER KATRI ABOUT HIS BURRIED BAG), what else you need to understand. They don't need crows lol. Crows are just here to scare them. I don't think they need crows or a mole like you were all sayin for a whole season (Donna is a mole blablabla Tillie is mole everyone is a mole

[@brockweaver346]

1:19 the voices didn't tell her Fatima was though, Sarah taking Elgin's eye is what gave her that information

[@dontlettheworldrot3058]

Sara also said "i dont think thats a little boy" What exactly does this mean? Every dialogue in this show means something...hmm

[@edoboleyn]

I think she understands that while he takes the form of a little boy, he is not really a child. Good or bad, he has other motives.

[@YuShiiesty]

I IUST HAD A THOUGHT, THE TREE IS MADE OUT OF HOPE, AND VICTOR CUTTING DOWN THE TREE WOULD MAKE THEM LOSE HOPE, SO IF HE CUT DOWN THE TREE THEN MAYBE THE TOWN CANT FEED ON HOPE???? JUST A THOUGHT

[@YuShiiesty]

@ right, but if the monsters feed on hope then if there’s no hope then how will they be fed ? to assume you know without any context defeats the purpose of a theory..

[@YuShiiesty]

@ I know that 😂 I mean they’ll have nothing to feed on if the tree is gone. but I understand your point, but we don’t know whether the boy in white is good or evil.. we can assume good, but when. victor is chopping the tree down he was adamant on not cutting it down, which would make me think either it’s a good or bad thing. which we don’t know. that’s all i’m insinuating

[@SteveOnTheEastCoast]

Ugh. I'm looking forward to your thoughts on the antagonist(s) in tonight's episode.😅

[@kzpm9796]

Oh no 😅

[@owowhatsthis555]

you know another interesting thing I saw was the ambulance on the stairs of the lighthouse when rewatching the season 2 finale a few days ago

[@gamelover2222]

The boy is getting older, if he gets to pick his shape, why would he choose to look older? It has to be his main body. Also, who would trap the boy if everyone in town died besides Victor? I like the idea that the boy was trapped with the talismans since Boyd was thinking about doing that and he was discouraged from making his trap. Too many riddles!

[@JeryWorld2025]

We never saw Victor sister die, ghost or body. She could have done it when she got older. I also think the biw appears older to Victor is that Victor is starting to see the truth about the biw. Biw set Victor up to lead his mother to her death. He’s starting to realize this, they are not friends.

[@Sbeve_One]

Boy in white is probably like a overall manifestation of all the kids souls in one body

[@RobertMitchell-su7em]

Another great video!!!!!

[@NEWZ_EDITZ]

THE BIGGEST PROBLEM WITH THE PEOPLE OF TOWN IS THAT THEY DON'T HAVE A MEETING

[@dwayneepinas8074]

The thing that annoys me is that nobody is talking about the electric cable that eventually didnt connenct to anything...

[@i_have_a_gears_tat9675]

the boy in white is actually martin the man chained up in the tower....

[@Life_starting]

Who said that

[@62chipo]

i think boyd is the entity or at least he will become the entity. he wears yellow, he is progressively having more and more of a "bad day" and they are pushing and breaking him into becoming the entity

[@damientom]

The "jellyfish" is a depiction of the monsters resurrection, not a jellyfish.

[@jm-po6bs]

I’m glad im not the only one saying it, way too much manufactured drama!

[@chessbrilliance8783]

It's funny because the way you talk is as incomprehensible as the show itself.

[@alecparrott4079]

Hey man. I think a lot of your theory relies on the boy in white being able to project his power beyond Fromville, but that wasn’t the boy in white. In the credits, there is a credit for a character called “Fake Boy in White”. However, I think you’re onto something with the boy in white being related to the man in yellow. Perhaps it’s the manifestation of the sacrificed children’s hope.

[@justkim9827]

The "Fake Boy in White" was probably referring to the boy that Tabitha ran up on in that ice cream shop.

[@venod3134]

I thought the kids were a part of the sacrifice. So I dont see Eloise being one of the monsters, she wasn't sacrificed.

[@ronoakforest]

I like your theory, however, Miranda already had visions and dreams about From before she arrived there. in his Maine house basement Henry told Tabitha that Miranda said she was chosen as others were chosen before her. If you are correct about the boy in white bringing people to town, he would have known this about Miranda instead of putting his faith in Christopher. Even though the boy in white lead Tabitha around Maine, it wasn’t the boy in white who lead Tabitha to the bunker to find Victor for that final Miranda memories connection, it was one of the children. The children can’t leave From yet, but the boy in white can, possibly he only could through Tabitha leaving. The children can’t communicate like the boy in white can. The boy in white wasn’t tortured and murdered like the rest of the children; he isn't wearing tattered clothing. The boy in white is just a helper to the children in the same way the Kimono helps evil. For all we know the boy in white is the one who told the children the story giving them hope. There were x10 white stick figures around the stones in the cave painting; x7 probably the children. one of the other stick figures could have been that girl Tabitha saw at the red stones in her childhood nightmares… Kimono has her own agenda. She saved Elgin from the music box while he slept in season 2--pushed him under water to wake him up so she could use Elgin for her own plan.

[@MrEleeo]

Let's assume the entity has a small level of memory or intelligence suppression. That would help explain some of the things going on with the characters 😅.

[@matheussberant]

Crazy plan here: Build a fence around the town and put some talisman at night, start expanding the circuit until the caves the monsters come from are surrounded, now just leave the talisman there and you will have no more monsters.

[@jackwilliam4436]

No. You would need a dome and no underground access.

[@mjolnir6685]

Nice plan😂😂😂

[@centipedekid9824]

They'd either tear the fence down or climb over it

[@simplelife6827]

The queston should be who trapped the entity in the cave, and how?

[@toommyg26]

This dude must just want to be heard for youtube money. He said the lighthouse is owned by the "red jellyfish "

[@skotmatthews8940]

I never understood why the biw would push Tabitha out if he wasnt trying to help but this gave a pretty good explanation

[@mike_0213]

You think it is the whole "Good vs Evil" going on in this series? Is the boy in white good or bad. Is Victor good or bad? So many questions and well over a year to wait for some more answers.

[@dionh1]

Its the yellow guy(doctor mabuse)

[@adithyants2881]

I have a feeling that the makers of this show might be wondering and asking eachother "wtf are we supposed to do with the new yellow guy we just introduced for the season 4 hype?"

[@Hummdulala]

They wouldn’t bring him in if they didn’t know. Also he’s been there since season 1-2. (The man on the phone)

[@brockweaver346]

Me and my girlfriend always say if these people would just talk to each other they'd have been home by the end of season one

[@Manananggal-oe8gs]

What if the BIW purposely sent Tabitha outside so she can get Victor's dad with her back to Fromville.

[@TheSP4RH4WK]

I recently saw an interview with the cast and show runners where they said ultimately this show isnt about the answer to a puzzle, but is a relationship drama set to a horror theme. They fear we will be disappointed with the "answer". I have to say though the performances in this show are top notch. From Victor's overall nature to Boyd's breakdown in the barn (of which the ONLY other scene reaching close to the intensity was in Punisher during the dinner table scene) we are witnessing the reasons why movies are now spectacle... because we need the GOOD writing to last seasons =)

[@rubysultra]

The ending? Is going to be Victor in an asylum/hospital with drawings of Fromville. Everyone will be family, other patients or staff from the asylum/hospital. That is the only ending i can see that makes sense.

[@YXEFlatl1ne]

I swear. Too much is happening and zero answers. It's like a 100/2 ratio. Not ONE single thing from season 3 was answered before finale. Smh

[@YXEFlatl1ne]

​@@rubysultraThat would be the only reason to explain why there are so many unanswered questions, because if he's just crazy than none of it really has to matter or be answered. Wow

[@YXEFlatl1ne]

Yea this one def ain't on the actors! Every actor on here is damn near award winning 10/10 , except maybe the Latino wife. Seems a bit to 'desperate housewives' lol.

[@lynseygabriel167]

" because of people are idiots" sent me 😅

[@ravenouscadaver8]

its hecking sus that the BIW sent Tabatha out shes meets Victors dad and theyre yoinked right back to Fromville.

[@manasalal_Vlogs]

I feel like the boy in white is martin

[@greglegakis4177]

This show is so complex and convoluted. It makes the movie "Inception" seem like a nursery rhyme.

[@rdash-q4v]

I’m sure writers has no clue how to connect the dots, they are taking insights from these decoding for sure😅

[@ManLikePaul1]

I subscribe to him being evil all along 100% they will use that plot twist and I am here for it

[@michaladamec1618]

i believe everyone in white equals good and every other colors like red, black, yellow represents the bad entity...

[@dellacahill9110]

The milk man and nurse monster are in white……

[@dgrimm3949]

It was never said that the BIW kept Victor company after the massacre, the one laughing because he was set free was the MIY

[@Meleny95]

I think victor just told her about the path to the lighthouse, not that she has to free them.

[@CozyMutha]

I dont think the voice from the ruins was the same OR the boy in white because she specifically said it was "different this time", she said it was a completely different gender as well...I think there are different ones maybe from different time periods

[@tubepayne22]

Hold on now...idk how it's connected but the civil war guy jade sees. Look at him. ...missing a eye and drinking blood...what a clue to what's gonna happen with Elgin and Fatima???!! I mean lol

[@pamjam2567]

When the biw is telling Christopher to go to the tree she is shouting everything lies here! So he thought the biw was lying, but everything else.

[@teodoradamyanova9636]

This whole video is full of far fetched theories. There's an evil that we see representation of all the time through the monsters, visions and the pain the residents inflicted on each other (sometimes by accident). And then we saw what we'd assume is the "big bad" as the man in yellow. There must be a representation of hope as well. The boy in white sent Tabby back to Camden in hopes she'll remember (what the children wanted her to do). The children were trying very hard, but she wasn't remembering so the boy in white decided they needed to take a more drastic measure. Sending her back into the real world to find the connection between herself and Miranda, knowing she'll be back as the story is not over and she needs to be in Fromville in order to save the children, the boy did what they thought would help her remember and speed up the process of learning the story on her own. The boy himself told Victor he tried by telling the full story to Christopher, but he didn't believe so now he knows they need to find out on their own.

[@Thechosen1-r8p]

What if the red jellyfish is Cthulu, he is capable of all the abilities shown in this series so far

[@LaWrld777]

A lot of negative on the boy in white is very loose.

[@raydiog]

I bet the cast and writers of this show watch your videos and laugh

[@raydiog]

Btw... I love your videos

[@randymcmullen538]

Take the Polaroid into the caves to get pictures of their drawings so they can study them

[@KingOfWinter]

What!!! Why do that when you can waste all your pictures making a collage like a 16yr old girl lol

[@aretnap3653]

If I Were "Trapped" in "FromVille"...I'm Using TheAbandoned Vehicles & "Modern" Vehicles to Make an "After Dark" *Twisted-Metal-DeadRising* "Monster" *Mow-Down-Machine!* (While Blasting 'WhiteZombie's' "LaSexorcisto" Album Through a P.A. Sound-System Installed On TheVehicle!) TheTownsFolk Might Hate Me...But They'll Hear Me Coming, & Know I'm "Clearing" TheTown! *"This Is Black...SunShine!"* "Sweet Is TheRIDE!" 😜

[@beewest5704]

Sounds like Stephen King plot. 😂😂😂

[@KiranSharma64414]

What will happen if someone make a iron man suit and start massacre on those monsters

[@FromilyTheory]

Did you notice The red baby/smiley hatching was the red squid monster in the cave drawings?