i liked the attack on titan ending.

[@Mr_Einiosaurus]

Me when positive review= no views. gotta love the youtube community

[@gamincommodity]

I did also just upload it lol but ty

[@solotopp]

I can't imagine people asking for a darker ending; it's dark as is. 80% of humanity died. Countless characters dead. To top it off, the ending shows how even after all of the struggle, eventually, humanity just goes through the same cycle and destroys itself. The show literally ends with a nuclear war, just showing the human conditjon will never change. Pretty dark ending imo.

[@chosenrubric7308]

People who dislike the ending aren't generally asking for "just a darker ending". They just wanted a more coherent ending thematically and character-wise according to the set up.

[@bd_bandkanon]

I'm gonna be real. For the entire course of AoT's runtime, I didn't give a single crap about the series. namely bc all the fans I came across were just in it for the action and the character deaths and "oo it's so dark it's so gritty". The hype was just annoying to me. It was only after the uproar about the ending that I decided to binge-watch the series, because I wanted to know what the fuss was about. Nobody told me about the nuance, the symbolism, the intricate storytelling and the character depth. Nobody told me that the characters actually successfully lived on in spirit past their expiration, unlike with so many other of those "dark and gritty" franchises with their propensity to kill off characters for shock value and forget about them almost immediately. If someone had *told* me about that, I would have been interested in AoT from the get-go. I appreciate the ending and the uproar it caused. If not for that, I would not have been exposed to this absolute classic.

[@RPCristi29]

Man... you are better than 50% of the youtubers, i like your humor and editing. You deserve some subs tbh, keep up the good work

[@gamincommodity]

Ty!!

[@AtenaHena]

“Better than 50%” doesn’t that mean you’re calling him average? 😭 agree with every other statement

[@RPCristi29]

​@@AtenaHena​ My idea is that there are a lot of small content creators that are underrated af. For example, he has almost 1.5k subs, there are approximately another 20mil youtubers that have over 1.5k, and approximately 28mil youtubers that are between 100-1.k, so he is at a very low subscribe number... he is 50% better at subs but, 80-90% better at the other statements

[@HK-07]

I want that twink and his best friend to kiss during the ending

[@5001Fergies]

there was genuinely one point where they looked into each others eyes for just a bit too long and i was like “are-are they gonna kiss” 😂

[@dineongoepe7857]

To be fair, Reiner outside of being a warrior/soldier has always been depicted as a weirdo, so that scene of him sniffing Historia's letter didn't surprise me at all. Anyways, W analysis of the finale. I agree with all the points you went over. I find myself loving that finale more and more as time passes.

[@Haha_You_Fool]

I like the idea of Reiner being a goofy weirdo in his final moments to show how he’s finally able to move past his trauma, buttttt being a pathetic creep like that doesn’t really gel with me or fit with his character all that much imo. Kind of sours the fantastically beautiful resolution to Reiner’s character earlier in the ending for me.

[@gamincommodity]

i guess i understand but for his final scene to be a gag just kinda felt like they did my goat wrong idk

[@dineongoepe7857]

@@gamincommodity Fair enough

[@3rd.Eye.Saw.Destruction]

Your humor and tastes and the people you’re connected to I legit feel like you are my long lost brother

[@gamincommodity]

What kind of woman is your type?

[@3rd.Eye.Saw.Destruction]

@@gamincommodity I would say an older woman, probably has a kid who I can learn from and tend to. Honestly tho I want a woman with a different form of autism than I have who is genuinely caring and considerate and wants to involve you in her interests and will try her best to be interested in yours. Someone who would be ecstatic to watch berserk or claymore with you just to hear you gush about the lore and talk about different motivations of characters etc.

[@gamincommodity]

@@3rd.Eye.Saw.Destruction brotha the answer was a tall woman with a big ass

[@yelsahblah3270]

I saw your other meme video yesterday and thought it was hilarious. Though I had been hoping to hear your thoughts since it's been fun for me to see what others thought of the show since finishing it myself. I didn't spend time on forums, chatting with other fans or even looking up theories as I didn't want to spoil anything. So when the end came, I wasn't surprised. My mom and sisters and I had more or less guessed that Eren was going to kill as many people as he could so they could live peaceful lives. They were all he cared about. So while it was hard watching him be so mean and angry I found his breakdown scene so cathartic. I was so excited to see him being himself again. Like it was such relief to see that under all the dark brooding Eren was still the crazy, emotional brat I knew and loved. Also it was so frustratingly obvious he loved Mikasa it's weird that anyone was surprised by it or was mad there was romance. I'm just baffled by the hate. I loved it. I think people got caught in their own theories and predictions and forgot it was someone else's story to tell. Either way this was a fun video. Could have done with that weird Mappa animator dub meme but otherwise it was good.

[@gamincommodity]

Totally forgot to reply to this-sorry I’ve been busy lol. I swear I was gonna. I wanna make ‘interludes’ my channel’s schtick so ty for the feedback on the MAPPA dub thing. I think going forward I’m gonna make them shorter, like a minute long or less.

[@namelessmonster-fr124]

No I don’t want that, people liking the aot ending? I want them to hate for another 10 years atleast

[@usagibun7639]

this is such an underrated video wtf you seem like a creator who should have millions of subscribers what

[@iwazoi]

Your content walks the line of thoughtful analysis/media consumption and incredibly funny humor SO well. I’ll be subscribing to you, and I would love to hear your thoughts on more stuff in the future.

[@gamincommodity]

thank you!! after the loser anime thing ive got some more backlog stuff i wanna push out :)))

[@loganshalloe5927]

Really enjoyed the vid. I'll point out that titans are not really implied to return when the boy enters the tree. Zeke explained why Ymir became a titan, and it was due to her desires and emotional state at the time, fearing death. This boy has a dog companion instead of being hunted by dogs, and he is exploring like the scouts instead of running for his life. So anything could happen, it is completely open ended.

[@gamincommodity]

Yeah I guess we’ll see with time, Isayama hasnt disclosed what this newest chapter is about so im excited

[@loganshalloe5927]

@@gamincommodity I believe it's confirmed to be about Levi

[@kush2319]

FINALLY SOMEONE THAT GETS IT ok so i just finished the video wow, you really verbalized everything i was thinking. eren being "pathetic" was armin breaking him out of the shell he had put around himself and getting his childhood friend back. the scene with armin as a whole really. also LMFAO the eren is a bird thing was so fucking funny. subbed fr

[@SushiGhost97]

Good video. Still don't like the ending personally, but I get why some do. Still the discussion around the ending is always interesting and I enjoy hearing others opinions on it.

[@BILLGOTPILLZ]

I wish eren would’ve got his W by living but as a normal person I respect your take on this an we need more from you🗣️🗣️🗣️

[@texenl555]

Yo great video ma bre, keep cookin fr

[@gamincommodity]

Ty!!

[@anjansharma8631]

Here take my subscription and like I hope it helps you get to a million subs

[@kiarashtaheri7478]

loved your review

[@ryanalamo3851]

The Paradis getting peace kinda breaks down when they end up as a fascist, military state. Like the characters never effectively disprove the Jeagerist argument, and the show never appropriately mourns 80% of humanity's death. And the reason the Mikasa line sounds so weird is that the Eren-Mikasa thing is mostly portrayed as unrequited love. And for that to be Eren's big regret instead of all the death and friend endagerment seems wrong

[@usagibun7639]

yup, it is clear that he prioritizes his personal goals for him and his friends over humanity. I still think that's the point of his character, he's selfish. historia had a similar development, she doesn't care if she's the worst girl in the world, she's going to live for herself like ymir told her and she ends up okaying the rumbling w eren. the story from beginning to end is meant for you to question who's the “good guy” or what it means to be “a good person”. the show doesn't shy away from the harsh reality of these characters bad choices. sure you can argue they might look cool doing it, but I think that's also a nod to the question of whether there is such thing as a truly “anti-war” film/show. As for the fascist military state, there's a clear side eye from sasha’s family that openly talked about getting out of the “forest” that is war and violence. just because some characters we like end up fascist doesn't mean it's portrayed as a good thing. It's actually quite realistic that in a fascist society a lot of ordinary people we once knew and loved become apart of it, and its disappointing and scary.

[@qaqeb5225]

​@@usagibun7639bingo!

[@seg162]

It's clearly not his "biggest regret". He immediately points out how all the people he killed didn't want to die when Armin tries to encourage him to find a way to change things. He enumerated his sins prior to the beach scene-- he outright lists out the endangerment of his friends-- and trembled when he tried to explain that he indirectly killed his mother.

[@vondas1480]

They’re not though. Every paradisian only just learned about the concept of race and the first thing they’re told and repeatedly shown is “everyone hates yours”. It’s pretty disingenuous to call them racist. And yes they are certainly being ruthless because at that moment all it would take is some crazy traitors (the alliance) to ruin their salvation, there’s no indication they would act that way after their survival is assured, and even if it was Eren and historia would be there to reign them in.

[@usagibun7639]

@@vondas1480what who called wha racist?

[@kiarashtaheri7478]

I loved the ending too and a lot of people forget about the amazing action. I loved how the story ended my only problem was with the things that they didn't show like I really wanted to see what did eren say to others ( jean, conny, reiner and historya) and thanks for including erwin's speech ;)

[@TheMrTangamandapio]

based, good take and good explanation :)

[@lollybirdy]

I'm of the opinion that there was no ending that wouldve satisfied everyone. You cant do that when you have a very.... Opnionated fandom all with different opinions and ideals. Its just not possible :/ Edit: but the true dark ending of aot was originally gonna be that they all died. Maybe we need to draw that 🤔

[@johnnyhall9154]

It was the ending AoT was building up to. It's sad but with warmth

[@slycooper9531]

Yo thought this would be a time burner video but this was actually a great analysis/ interpretation. Half of my enjoyment of the ending comes from the show and the other half from the meta nature of the show which includes the work of reviewers like you. Thank you.

[@maxypad3379]

cant believe kirito commited genocide

[@allergictocod]

Love this commodity guy

[@gamincommodity]

love this 'allergictocod' guy

[@sadmanshakib7646]

Dude honestly, I loved the ending. When he did the whole "I don't want Mikasa to find another man" bit, it hit me that well he's still human. like it or not, our flaws make us human and it was refreshing to see this cold, calculating man just break down and admit he's one of us.

[@gamincommodity]

Agree

[@abdelbouzazia4955]

He never wanted to be this way his understanding turned him this way but at his core he was still Eren a normal man with overwhelming powers.

[@cameronwallace8265]

I love the ending too. Sure, there may be issues with some aspects of the execution, such as conveyance and pacing. But the more I think about it, the more I love the themes and character moments, and everything that it's going for. And when I rewatch it, or think about it, I'm not going to think about some parts that were confusing on a first watch. Or about the pacing that might still be a little bit too fast. I'm going to think about everything brilliant that the ending went for, and the emotions that it carries.

[@يومياتأمها]

I LOVED THE ENDING TOO, i meant. To some extent.

[@seg162]

* Eren doesn't forget why he did the Rumbling. I don't know how long that misconception will last, and I'm 80% sure it's caused by crossed wires beckoning the end of SAO's Aincrad arc. He says that he doesn't know _why_ he wanted to do the Rumbling. But he certainly knows that he did want to, and thus "had" to. Visual cues of his father's memory of his birth instruct the reader that this desire for freedom that led to him ideating the Rumbling was something he was born with. * I maintain that the nuances of Eren's words as he stabbed Mikasa's kidnappers can be significantly better understood by contrasting them with what they were _supposed_ to be, as per the original draft of chapter 1 where this incident was supposed to be exposited. There, he stabs them while rhetorically asking how they could do something like this to a little girl. It's decidedly more heroic than, albeit equally frantic as, what we get in chapter 6 of the serialization-- there, he... well, says about what you clipped, his focus being on dehumanizing his targets rather than lamenting their depravity. He doesn't even call them "evil people"-- he rationalizes to Grisha that they were "beasts in human clothing". * I like your interpretation of Armin's socking Eren, and particularly how you worded it. I came to a similar conclusion not long ago, that Armin punching him was what got Eren to open up.

[@loganshalloe5927]

13:15 no he doesn't. He says he did it to see that sight, but doesn't know why he wanted to see it.

[@gamincommodity]

I think the overall idea stays the same-Eren was always just blinded by rage

[@loganshalloe5927]

​@@gamincommodityyep

[@ommzi6428]

I am sicj and o have a head ache :(

[@tragicworld]

W review

[@gamincommodity]

ty tragic

[@danck941]

So the author is writing more chapters for AOT? I thought the story was over. I read some where that he was doing a bonus chapter, and a Levi series, but I didn't know about other chapters too.

[@gamincommodity]

Yeah hes doing something im not sure the full extent of what though

[@danck941]

@@gamincommodity Sweet.

[@mauratlantean3002]

I liked the ending, even as a manga reader I was actually hyped up during the entire thing. The only problem I had and still have with it is Ymir's motivation ( How she needed to wait 2000 years and to see Mikasa kill Eren in order to be free), It just felt off and kinda devalued everything the characters have been through. Still if you ignore that, the ending is great! I am also glad Isayama changed the script for Eren and Armin's conversation, it hit so much harder

[@generic1588]

This is so real

[@camerontrinh6132]

Does anyone know the song at 10:58

[@gamincommodity]

It’s ‘under the tree’ instrumental slowed

[@camerontrinh6132]

@@gamincommodity ty🙏🏻

[@gamincommodity]

@@camerontrinh6132 subscribe

[@camerontrinh6132]

@@gamincommodity fair enough

[@DankHarvey-cw3hw]

139 Likes fr

[@manumudgal5776]

No one gives a damn about anyone opinion.