I'm Only Keeping 5 Pairs of Boots.

[@roberttudisco6530]

I appreciate how much thought you put into your choices here Carl. Not everything was a heater, but they all meant something super special. While I don’t agree that loafers suck, I get they aren’t for everyone

[@CarlMurawski]

Very classy response my dude, well done! Be well!

[@jeremyt2212]

I don't blame you for keeping those Allen Edmonds, there's nothing in their lineup today that remotely compares to that pair that you have.

[@dannyturner7967]

Actually ae has a new chukka boot that looks very similar to the odin boot

[@johnhawkins3507]

The Patton boot from Allen Edmonds is very similar to the Odenwald boot.

[@colinkelly279]

Glad we got to share in your boot journey and I am sure you inspired a lot of boot buys over the years and helped a number of companies out. Thanks for letting us ride along.

[@drzaius844]

Love your picks as well. The patina on those Odenwalds is incredible. The GS Diesel isn’t the flashiest boot but it’s so comfortable- literally all day walkable on or off trails, and yeah you could even wear them to a wedding. Cheers man! I love loafers!

[@joshmerrell7377]

Thanks for all you do! I have been enjoying your channel for several years now. Your content definitely relates to me as I was in the electrical trade for 10 years and currently in the retail/commercial fuel industry for 14 years. Please continue and all the best!

[@CarlMurawski]

Much appreciated my friend! How do you like the new gig compared to the old one?

[@bryanjones9356]

Huh huh. He said current-ly.

[@mattdalton1]

I hope no one gives you grief, because those are thoughtful choices and they highlight your individuality which is a big part of why your channel is so, so good. This also makes me feel better about buying Grant Stone diesel boots in August. ;-) I really like them so far and can hardly wait for the natural chromexcel leather to darken like yours have. Loafers suck but your boot collection sure doesn’t.

[@raidengreen1318]

I have been wanting a pair of diesel boots and some White's MP boots for a while now. Seeing you keep them definitely makes me want them even more. Loafers Suck.

[@ToughSekai]

I really appreciate people like you who have in-depth reviews on boots. It's helped me not only pick out good, everyday, high qualitly boots. It's also helped me pick out work boots that best suit my daily needs. I work 10 hours a day, so a good, supportive, and durable boot is nessasary. Finding that in steel toed boots is a hassle sometimes of you're not educated in good craftmanship. But i also have to say staying within your budget is a good thing, too. So, being able to make a well-educated decision has helped me pick the most bang for my buck. Yeah, they might not check off every box on the list. But at least the boots i have will get me home and in one piece and comfortable at the end of my day.

[@MrChiumiento]

I love it. This is why I am a Carl patreon and a discord member because Carl is clearly a good person. I had never been a patreon to anyone else for more than 1 months before Carl. The discord is the best also.

[@CarlMurawski]

You’re too kind bro!!!

[@tlove9125]

Loafers suck. I bought my first pair of “real boots” because of you. I saved up for a pair Nick’s. Love them.

[@jeffreydawson4520]

I see zero issues with what you decided to keep cause that’s a killer lineup of boots! I only have a couple pairs of boots now but that’s a couple pair more than the number of loafers I own because loafers suck.

[@False_Idle_Warship]

Very kind, in more ways than one. Loafers suck is a gentlemanly way to describe fugly as all get out. & curating a collection like yours is one of the nicest problems to have I can imagine.

[@SpencerYoung-m8h]

I’ve been debating on selling boots just to get a better pair of work boots as is. Love what you’re offering to people, Carl. P.s. loafers suck.

[@1mooseman]

The patina on those AE boots are beautiful. Makes me think of whiskey, pipe, a comfortable old leather chair sitting by the fireplace. No idea why. It just does.

[@tjs1189]

So hard to figure out the five I would keep from my collection. Mainly because I only have two so I need to buy three more pairs.

[@meganobrien3552]

I just found your channel through this video, and I have to not only agree on the choice of boots, but I also agree loafers suck. I live in FL where boots aren't always economical and not much preferred over sandals, but I still love them all the same! I must own like 5 pairs that I hardly get to wear!

[@kevinvandevender]

A couple of these were definitely not a surprise, but the AEs were a surprise to me! Personally I think you would benefit from a nice casual loafers but hey, you think loafers suck

[@CarlMurawski]

I do. I really, really do.

[@williamswiger7547]

I have had several pairs of AE over the years and always end up donating them. My problem with every pair was the loose grain they develop after minimal wear. Just looks cheap to me. You get grain break on all boots to an extent but AE leather is a wrinkle monster for me.

[@pherble]

I ordered the Pullman (then Gr**ser) back in June when you did the video on it as I'd been looking for an engineer that I was confident would fit and was unique. I'm glad to hear it just wasn't a drop that would never be heard from again. Mine is still in the production queue, and worst case may be February, but I look forward to when they show up. Thanks for the original collab, and the vote of confidence you are still showing in this video.

[@HARMAN7777]

I'm heart broken that the tanker boot didn't make the cut! 😢 And just so you know loafers SUCK!!!

[@TechnoLawyer]

I have that exact pair of Odenwalds! Love them. Also have a pair in black. Bought them back in like 2015.

[@Sneka97]

To be fair it's a nice and well rounded collection with different styles and not much overlap. My favorites are the Grant Stone because, as you've said, they may not look like much but damn they go with everything. And although i don't agree, loafers suck haha

[@shirayasha]

Agree on that choice as well. Versatility means so much for a boot (can be dressed up and down)

[@redmond9653]

I used to think I had wayyyy too many Carhartt jackets but now I really wish I had my old embroidered Carhartts from my first job back!! Don't get rid of anything you might regret later! More often than not I get rid of something and a few years later I wish I had it back.

[@MPS186282]

Loafers suck... Boots rule!

[@CarlMurawski]

AMEN!

[@ArtbyPatrickPetruccello]

LOVE the Odenwald! Agree for some reason they just hit right..I have gotten a lot of compliments on those..more than my Aldens, Vibergs and Trumans.

[@joemoore7197]

Thanks for making me watch a True Classics ad before this video. True Classic sucks, and Loafers suck.😁

[@CarlMurawski]

Hahahaha I have no control over the ads! It's funny that they dont seem to care either.

[@thejiraffe4966]

Really grateful for your input on boots. Helped avoid overspending, especially because loafers suck

[@acbk2b]

I agree loafers suck for some things, but man is it nice to have a pair or crocs (or something) or something for stepping outside real quick

[@genekieffer3877]

I agree some loafers suck, but the right ones are nice for a casual look plus easy on off. I got a late start putting a rounded shoe collection together but im close to having a pair of shoes/boots for whatever event may come up. Thank Carl for helping us all Own Better, Look Better and Live Better

[@habibullahas-safaasabahsha365]

I have a pair of Broadwingers that are made by 1 man up in Washington. A true craftsman who makes a stunning boot that truly looks and performs like no other

[@strengthandbulkMadness]

Good choices! White’s Semi-dress last/fit is hard to beat so it’s no surprise you are keeping the Bounty Hunter’s. One engineer, service, cap-toe, dress, work pretty much covers it.

[@KM-ru4fm]

So happy to see the diesels on here! Makes me more comfortable moving forward to buying them. Loafers suck!

[@marlenakauer5262]

Great job thinning the herd! You picked some great ones. Thanks for your generosity! Loafers suck! The one place we disagree haha. I’ve got a pair Alden’s I picked up second hand on Ebay and plan on getting a pair from Oak Street Bootmakers. I got their camp Mocs and wear them all the time. Especially gardening!

[@MOFsquadron]

The oldenwalds are probably my favorite pair I've ever seen you wear, right up there with the Nail Shanks

[@TheSuperlativecritic]

I just bought a pair of Grant Stone Brass in kudu leather thanks to all the praises of all the boot experts. It's my first pair of high-end boots, and I'm so glad to hear that Grant Stone made your list that you will keep. My first pair has to be universally considered the best bang for your buck. I have a collection of high-end watches, so I can relate to culling. However out of the 5 boots that you picked, their features are relatively all equal compared to the variability that exists in watch types, so the fact that Grant Stone made the list is pretty cool I think.

[@MiddlingMarksman]

I appreciate the breadth of your boot knowledge. Always great to see new and sometimes obscure boots. Especially since loafers suck.

[@daddyt4851]

You have some very nice boots Carl. I still have several pairs of White’s from my smokejumping days. I agree Loafers suck.

[@OhBraveSrRobin]

I was lucky enough to be able to grab the Nick's engineer boot. I can't wait to have them and see what kind of adventures we have together. Loafers suck, are words to live by!

[@RossSchell]

I Just got my 5th boot! 2 Wolverines1000 miles, Thursday vanguard, and 2 Blkbrd boots. 2 were used purchases off eBay and started me on my heritage boot journey. My point is sending on a pair of heritage boots is a great way to share why we love boots so much. Oh and loafers suck.

[@NotRorygreen]

Mate! Firstly, I love your videos, and appreciate all the effort you put into them blah blah blah. You already know you’re a piss ripper of a bloke. I found your channel about 6 months ago and I am the best dressed landscaper in 🇦🇺 and most importantly I’m more informed about my purchases. Love your work big fella, keep it up 👍🏼

[@Bozotheclown-hc9tx]

That pair of nail shanks is THE MOST beautiful boot i have laid my eyes on. WOW!

[@dariusdespain1210]

I need to clean house with my shoe/boot collection as well. I admire the thought that went into your choices and it's inspiring me to make a similar change. I will admit I have a few loafers in my collection too and I find most of them to be very comfortable for summer wear, so I disagree that loafers suck, but I'm leaning toward the boot world even more so I respect the opinion.

[@CareBearBedTime]

Loafers suck, you’re the reason I started on my boot collecting journey, you’re the man

[@SoobinOh]

This really validated me going with Grant Stone Diesels as my first Goodyear welt boot! It took a long time to make that decision. Loafers suck!

[@kornfedboy]

Carl, I think the idea of minimizing your boot collection is very admirable. I have been trying for the last couple years to keep in mind, your phrase “own less, but own better”. To be quite honest, it’s very challenging, moving towards this minimalist idea of living. My work is divided between playing music where I’m wearing dress clothing and dress shoes and even dress boots, and my other day job, which is essentially finish carpentry (I’m a luthier). I have sold a number of my cowboy boots, as well as my lace of work boots and dress shoes but it’s hard to let go. I’m always thinking of comfort. Oddly enough while playing a private function, I am noticing the footwear of the various people; a lot of loafers since it’s late summer. Years ago I tried that look and style wearing both Allen, Edmonds and Alden’s and I just did not have the arch support or comfort I would like to have had. So I have to agree with you that loafers suck!

[@vryce6322]

Thank you for all the great information and for your generosity. I do agree that Loafers Suck.

[@npercic82]

Loafers suck! I love that your keeping the Diesel. I have a few pairs and they are by far my favorite for being so sleek and versatile!

[@tarasmathers7423]

👏👏👏....bravo Carl my friend. I love the reasoning behind the selections. I gotta say those GS "Diesel's" are primo-patina level. I never knew they could look that good. And those "Bounty Hunters" have sold me on the unstructured toe. I'm really happy to see how far things have come for you. Here's wishing you all the best. P.S. Loafers suck bad....

[@ronaldbrashears9866]

Love this! I’m always looking forward to you’re content

[@billcody1461]

The boot king! Love how you also find the small builders. Loafers suck

[@larryvelasquez662]

This was one of my favorite episodes. Enjoy your channel.

[@marcosgiberson4128]

Thank you so much for all that you do, with out all of the info and love you put into your videos, a lot of us would be lost and loafers suck

[@eleven.eastgate.twelve967]

Give thanks for being an example of a Boot Addict and thinning out your collection, I gotta do the same... kinda suprised your letting go of your "chunkified" Iron Rangers recrafted by Northern Republic. Topshelf collection Sir!

[@andylehman1705]

That is the fun problem with getting new boots to often, breaking in 3 boots the same week can be hard. I wouldn't do this with loafers because loafers suck.

[@midorimidori1850]

Loafers suck! - The Diesels are what got me into your channel a couple of years ago and I’m glad they’re still kicking around.

[@michaellorenzen8200]

2 pairs of Danner Ultralight 2s (USA MADE) and some sort of Vans or similar for around the house I did this for years and leap frogged the boots every 2 days IMHO these boots were hands down the most comfortable boots straight out of the box and with time became more comfortable ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

[@mutecommercials]

5!? That's mighty fancy of you, I have 2, my Walmart Hermann Survivor boots, and my Solovair.

[@xxflamezxx1able]

It's awesome to hit a hard reset from time to time, I did that with all my old denim and tees that I honestly just kept but never wore and I have been very slowly rebuilding my denim collection with my new updated style and more intentional pieces. Whoever gets those Lofgrens hit the jackpot, I have been wanting a pair of engineer boots for a year now and I might go with a wesco pair but damn their lead time is insane. Also, loafer suck lol.

[@chefrichh]

I'm very impressed you are able to scale down to just 5 pairs of boots! This is very inspiring video! As always LOAFERS SUCK!

[@thec.tysonsynopsis7280]

If you like the bounty hunters, you'll love the 350 Cutters from White's. Best "non-handmade" boot on the market IMO.

[@kram364]

Those Kreosote Nail Shanks look incredible. Definitely a keeper. And loafers suck.

[@spikebebop5849]

Great video. Im relatively new to the casual boot world and, have learned a lot. Thanks for the informative videos. Loafers suck.

[@johnjameson523]

Loafers Suck.... Thank you Carl for the videos. Look forward to them all the time.

[@twilightkids]

Loafers suck! Love (and a little surprised!) to see the Whites in your list! Just got a pair of semi dress boots with unstructured toe for the Thunderdome and can’t wait to wear them!

[@mactravelandfinance]

Loved the video. Have a great day Carl!

[@jayson_da_ruler]

Thanks for all the great content over the years! Loaders suck sure. Your videos inspire me to make the leap for my first pair of Nicks! Keep up the great content! Appreciate you!

[@krazmokramer]

LOAFERS SUCK. Carl, I gotta say, that give-away and the boot give-away are VERY generous of you! Now having said that, being turned down for a pair of Nailshank boots and being told to go to Brian The Bootmaker would work for me. I have a pair of Redwing Chukkas that Brian re-welted and re-soled for me. He does excellent work! I would gladly wear a pair of Brian's boots. I'm not hanging out on YT very much anymore. I drop into your videos every once in a while to smash that "LIKE" button, though. Thanks for your correspondence in the past. I hope you have a great holiday season!!! Doc

[@1eparry]

I had a feeling the Diesels would make the list. Good to see!

[@danielirvine7468]

WOW something about the whites bakers bounty boot I freaking love . Maybe it’s the non structural toe box?

[@robertbaltierra4415]

Carl, I think you convinced me to buy more than a few boots and given plenty of knowledge along the way. I can’t say that loafers suck as I’ve never worn them, but I’ll take your word for it.

[@nvrp813]

Great video. Agree with keeping the Grant Stone. All other brands loafers suck

[@tacticalspork1]

I was researching some work boots and ran into your channel haven’t stopped watching. I chose the Iron Ranger probably because I didn’t know Grant Stone existed, was new to the game at the time. Just got measured for my first pair of Nicks and order is placed. Loafers suck.

[@Claytonboots]

Loafers suck, there’s a place for them in a dusty corner of my garage. Love your content!! My favorite video was the Indy wardrobe. It started my journey into boots.

[@ardbeg9143]

Great choices! I've wanted to get a GS Diesel boot for a while but can't decide on the leather. Also, loafers suck! (Except Grant Stone's)

[@piggymito]

It's interesting how you talk about "getting to know your boots". I had a pair of 10 hole steel toe commando sole docs for school. I got them when I was 15 and they went in the bin about 20 years later, it was like loosing a friend. Just bought some thorogoods recently which are a rare choice in the UK and I pretty much wear them exclusively now.

[@jonuiuc1]

I do this sort of thing (cutting down on inventory), but with types of bags. Camera Bags, Travel Bags, Daily carry slings. I gotta try em out myself before I can decide if I like one thing better than another. Before I settled on Camera stuff, I did that a bit too, but cameras lenses get pricy, so you have to narrow it down quick. If only I could pare down my watch collection though....

[@michaelfridman2470]

Kreosote does do some great work, I am impressed with his growth over the past few years. Loafers suck.

[@Murphy2043]

I know how you feel, Carl. I did the same thing with loafers.

[@StrayReviews]

The best boots are the ones you’ll wear. Great choices!

[@Hsquared]

Loafers suck. These are all lovely boots. Love those engineers boots you have. Might have to save up for some of those myself.

[@bartmotorcycle]

Man those AE's are sick

[@BurkeTrue2]

Thanks for all your excellent advice and information and yes I can confirm that LOAFERS SUCK.

[@bkgloverjr]

Loafers Suck, but sometimes wearing a pair of Heydudes to let your feet heal after wearing work boots on the job from 5am until 9pm daily

[@ibmrduck]

Loafers Suck. My list of boots to buys grows everytime I watch another one of your video. Thanks for all you do.

[@joefleming2053]

Ya know, I may need to grab a pair of those Grant Stone Diesel’s for when I travel. You’re right about needing one versatile boot that will work in any setting.

[@TheHawthorneCrew]

I feel like this video is talking to me to do the same thing in my own collection. Lots of boots I don’t wear and could certainly be put to better use with other to appreciate them. Loafers suck and I am constantly reminded why I have never owned a pair and never will.

[@taifu13781]

Loafers suck And I commend you sir for seeing you need to clean house; it’s a bonus that we know you take care of your boots so others will be getting great boots!

[@marklerfald]

Great topic and choices. Thank you. Loafers suck.

[@Mrfaux1]

Been a fan for a long time been changing my wardrobe towards spending better and living better, specially on choosing shoes because loafers suck

[@jans5216]

Loafers suck. I ordered also the White's Bounty Hunter in Horsehide and i am really excited to get them.

[@dropthehammer-k3n]

Man oh man.. those Nailshanks.. I should have ordered them a year ago, when the wait list was 36 months..now it's at 42. That said... they could be a nice retirement gift to myself, as I'm 63, and plan to retire at 67 lol..Love those White's semi dress as well. I have no idea how you can narrow your 'keepers' down to 5 boots. ps.. Loafers suck.

[@mattlavigne8541]

I've never worn a loafer and I can be lazy at times, but loafers suck. Thanks Carl for all the wonderful videos!

[@Firedragon7929]

I am impressed you were able to get rid of so many great boots. Loafers suck

[@williamswiger7547]

I am in the same situation with way too many boots. Problem is I actually like all the boots I have but have been collecting for many years. Have donated a bunch of good boots but want some money back if I let any more of them go. Guess I could let all the Red Wings go as they are the cheapest ones.....lol

[@jeremyl.7563]

Loafers suck! You know out of all the gear and all the boots those nail shanks well that has been my favorite that you've showcased, however I will definitely add those Allen Edmonds to that list those are so rad!

[@RoadToHeritage]

Loafers suck! Great video Carl and I don’t blame you. That’s too many boots!

[@jasonb7884]

Love your channel! you are the reason i have two pairs of Nicks and two pairs of Whites

[@marlinspike1235]

Hi there, I dont think that loafers suck. I live with the environment of cold winters and hot summers so they have their place 😊

[@delwyngoh1864]

Loafers suck. Thanks for sharing your top picks! Got my attention to whites and grant stone diesel.

[@fbiker79]

First all all, thanks for sharing your top 5. I don’t have many boots, but I can’t imagine getting the collection down to five only. Not surprised to see the Grant Stones there, they are solid boots for sure and Loafers Suck.

[@rmail25]

Ya love to see another boot video! Love your picks, loafers suck, and I need to go out and get a pair of those Whites!