i need to rant about wish

i'm not mad just disappointed
SPECIAL THANKS TO MY PATRON!!!
Tan the Samurai Puppy
patreon.com/jonahwho
profile picture and avatar drawn by Axjaxx
-KZbin: / @axjaxx9635
-Insta: / axjaxxart
banner made by ArtsBlume
-Twitter: / artsblume
second channel: / @jonahwhotwo
tw*tter: / jonah_who
letterboxd: letterboxd.com...
clock app: www.tiktok.com/@jonahwhoishere
discord server: / discord
love ya!

[@MicaAnneArts]

I think if you look at it as just a movie, it’s like a 5/10. Not the best, not the worst. If you’re looking at it as the movie celebrating 100 years of Disney, it feels like a spit in the face. All of the concepts and scrapped ideas sound so much more interesting! If they went with ANY of those scrapped concepts this movie would have been so much better.

[@ladypool1404]

Agree! All of the interresting and new things were in the concepts. The movie would have been good if they were all in it. Too bad we didn't get that! Also, the real 100 years celebration is the short '' Once upon a studio! '' It has more emotion, passion and respect for animation than Wish.

[@zoey398]

right like i'm so inexplicably annoyed by how they scrapped the original concept. i would have loved the original (assuming it had been done well) even if it was a don't think abt it too much kind of thing. but ofc they had to scrap it for a much less interesting (imo) plot, quirky mc #4 (without any resoning behind her acting like a more extreme mirabel), npc friends, poor planning on music and detached emotions 😭

[@OneTruePeanut]

If this exact same movie, script, art, music everything came out of Dreamworks, or better yet, Illumination, I don't think anyone would have batted an eye, the fact that this bland, uninspired movie was meant to be the celebration of 100 years of an entertainment company that was founded on creative innovation. It's not only an insult to Disney himself but to the last 100 years of Disney animation teams. Dreamworks took the whole wishing star idea and made an infinitely better movie while also using a franchise for it that a lot of people were getting tired of. Disney probably has 1 or 2 more movies to get their act together before they get abandoned by all but the most hardcore Disney adults.

[@briqhtlightss]

I'm still forever mad we didn't get our Starboy idea. Isn't Disney literally famous for their romances??? It would've been so perfect for 100yrs of Disney and yet!!! It just feels like they rushed through the movie rather than actually spending time and love on it. Even the animation feels subpar compared to other Disney animations. And it's for their 100th anniversary! What an insult to the animation industry itself, but also to their own company. Every song feels like it was written in a few hours and they just went with the first draft, the story and the characters feel entirely flat and unpolished -- it's so gross, and it's sad, because like you say, the scrapped concepts were SO much better. Which goes to show that it's not the core artists who are at fault, it's the higher-ups who just want money.

[@CarrieTooTired]

Every day I’m reminded that “when it comes to the universe we’re all shareholders” is the most corporate-coded thing that ever existed 🙃

[@nevaehhamilton3493]

Yeah. It's almost as though they KNEW. This movie is propaganda!

[@CarrieTooTired]

@@nevaehhamilton3493 all the businessmen clapped when they heard the demo

[@amethystimagination3332]

They don’t even pay rent in Rosas, why would there be a stock market

[@natecgames4612]

Using a stock market term like shareholder, especially in a song, highlights the inhumanity of the speaker imo. Especially since it's a kids' movie that's using terms many adults don't know the definition to.

[@parissinclair6513]

I can't tell if that lyric is embracing corporate culture or if the songwriters are expressing displeasure for it (sort of like how the animators of Jujutsu Kaisen, during a time of poor working conditions, chose to animate their own studio's office as a room that gets destroyed in a fight).

[@NoHatDashYT]

ima be honest, the 100th movie should've been a 2d mickey mouse movie with him fighting new and familiar foes bro has been on that steamboat whistling for too long

[@Dioxazine_Stars]

That actually would’ve been so great. Especially imagine if it was done Fantasia style, no talking, just music and beautiful animation.

[@elizabethweigle6146]

Like an Epic Mickey style movie!!😭

[@NoHatDashYT]

@@elizabethweigle6146 real

[@JeannieInABottle1965]

This is not the 100th movie. It's just their movie for their 100th anniversary. So, in short, there is hope for that Mickey movie of yours to happen!

[@jackalenterprisesofohio]

Even imagine it starts off like that in the credits intro thing, but it then pans out or whatever into the actual movie set in that little skit.

[@mr.duck1248]

Magnifico’s people: *questioning things about the wishes, demanding answers* Magnifico, storming off into the castle “I can help it if mirrors love my face” Like OBJECTION! IRRELEVANT

[@quintenvanuffelen3102]

it's so funny how nimona got a best animated feature nomination and wish didn't, the acadamy just said fuck disney and they're right

[@tny1757]

They still gave Elemental a nomination which is still under the Disney Umbrella despite being made by Pixar. But fortunately a film that actually deserved to win won rather than Nimona or Elemental. The other 3 were well earned nominations.

[@karathewolfsfanficchannel933]

The real funny part is that Disney tried to stop that movie from being made after they took down Blue Sky. This is just like when they thought Pocahontas would do better than The Lion King which went on to become their magnum opus

[@Someguyonline24]

@@karathewolfsfanficchannel933they WHAT?!

[@CoolScratcher]

@@Someguyonline24 yeah, you didn't know that? Animators and writers at the time didn't want to work on The Lion King because it was an original story and "weird" at the time. People thought Pocahontas would do much better. Interesting bit of Disney history lol

[@TOH_and_Warriors_is_cool]

Nimona > Wish Any day

[@AwesomeYena]

I remember at the end asking "why didn't he [King Magnifico] die?" since in the pretty old movies the villains usually ended up dying a brutal death and this was a movie celebrating Disney. I freaked out my parents, though.

[@Dioxazine_Stars]

Lol

[@helixsol7171]

Magnifico wasn't even evil! He didn't force anyone to give him their wishes and forget about them, they knew about that going into it and did it anyway! And nobody was unhappy or suffering or anything, Asha just thought it was unfair that not everyone's wish would be granted, when everyone already knew that! There was no need for any of the events of this movie to happen, Asha is an idiot!

[@JonahWho]

fr

[@DuelaDent52]

To be fair, her main point of contention wasn’t that he doesn’t grant every wish, it’s that he has absolutely no intention of granting certain people’s wishes yet leads them on anyway.

[@wybie3640]

@@DuelaDent52true, plus, her main point was to give the wishes back if he chose not to make them real. So that way they remember their wish in order to make them happen themselves without relying on his magic. I don’t think that makes her an idiot, I felt that was a completely justified choice for her character to make especially when having your wish taken, changes you, like a part of your spirit is taken away. I feel like I watched a different movie from the person who made the comment 😅

[@Rikrobat]

⁠​⁠@@wybie3640 - Except that if the argument is “some wishes are dangerous,” wouldn’t it be irresponsible to give the wish back so the original owner can fulfill it themselves? Also, it sounds like the logic isn’t consistent? If Magnifico only grants 12 wishes a year, then he’d never be granting everyone’s wish; so, people would be giving them up with the understanding that it might not be granted. If a wish is specific and safe enough to be granted, is it guaranteed to be granted eventually? If yes, then how does that mesh with the limited number of ceremonies that happen? Also, if giving up their wish takes away a part of who they are, then why are we shown so many people being perfectly content in the utopia that Magnifico built for them? Kinda starts to feel like “if you don’t like this optional thing in a place where you want for absolutely nothing, then maybe just leave?” Maybe if giving a wish was the only form of “rent” that is required to be in Rosas, then I think it would be different-then it could really lean into Magnifico keeping people complacent by taking away their biggest ambition and teasing them with the hope of having it granted. But if it’s optional, then I can’t help thinking “you agreed to the terms, don’t be upsetty-spaghetti when those terms don’t favour you.” This might be why I’ve seen such varied reactions to how the wish granting works in Rosas and why many people think Asha sucks over it. The movie didn’t convey the terms clearly and consistently enough.

[@lamented-musings8932]

Did you see the deleted scenes? Those will make you more mad because they are BETTER than the finished product.

[@JonahWho]

unfortunately i have

[@SweetOrangeGirl]

Those deleted scenes would’ve been amazing to see!

[@Muna-Jlore0997]

@@JonahWho can't blame you, man. i was furiously mad as hell.

[@Hyperfrogge]

I was pissed. I would actually love to see the star boy🥲 Also Disney basically ran on romance movies so it would have made sense they made the 100th anniversary movie a romance movie. I know a lot of people said they don't want anymore romance, but like- it looked so much better😭😭😭😭

[@lamented-musings8932]

@@Hyperfrogge I agree. Romance was such a big staple of classic Disney so it's dumb that they thought romance would ruin their movie. Also no broadway style musicals? Terrible choice.

[@LilacVenus]

I saw your revision of the lyrics first before finding this video, and I was pleasantly surprised you were 1. a dragon 2. able to use your expertise to concisely explain the problems outside of "movie bad lol"

[@mixedbagmixesmusic1967]

This.

[@Maria-sq4jl]

SAME

[@giovanmorabonilla6400]

Sameeee

[@jackpijjin4088]

It's a movie about a big rich man taking in all the ideas around him, hoarding them, and keeping others from enjoying them, while claiming to be "making dreams come true" in a land that might be considered the 'happiest place on earth". HELLO.

[@DuelaDent52]

I know, right!? The critique writes itself and they do nothing with it!

[@havinghope6315]

So a play on Disney itself?? How it swallows up movie ideas and owns rights to so many stories characters and concepts, not only creating a lot of nice things but ruining many other iconic and classic concepts and stories, plus it buys up land, makes people pay 💰 quite a bit for what it gives, and treats its employees like crap? Just curious.

[@zypher9690]

I swear the song writers were drunk when they wrote some of these songs. 🎵we drink beer, in the city of rosas, there’s a huge alcohol drinking problem 🎵is still the funniest rewrite even though it didn’t make it in. lol the rewrite was great btw!

[@miphiaoo]

WE DRINK BEER🗣‼‼IN THE CITY OF ROSAS‼‼🔥🔥🗣🗣

[@Punk-possum]

If they wanted to imitate Mediterranean culture they should've genuinely written this

[@sofiamorgan3756]

You know what’s crazy, this movie was nominated at the golden globes instead of Nimona. Good thing the Oscars didn’t do that. Also, I hate that Asha has no flaws because without flaws, it makes her character bland

[@apickle4835]

fr, I watched Wish for the first time with a friend, and then we watched Raya immediately after. It was my second viewing and I was trying to figure out if Raya was just way better than I remembered or if you could simply show me a cool looking rock and I'd find it more interesting then Wish.

[@karathewolfsfanficchannel933]

I couldn’t even finish raya but after watching this movie I was able to sit through the whole thing.

[@moon7shinev150]

I get wanting a 2D and 3D blend for the animation but they had the perfect animation that they could've used from the short Paperman so I don't know how it ended up looking like this

[@emmu__]

11:04 man just randomly busted out the most beautiful version of 'welcome to rosas' out of nowhere

[@mixedbagmixesmusic1967]

I know, he got pipes.

[@radcircles3642]

The concept art for wish shows that it had some really good ideas. Like the star boy and Asha romance could have been so sweet. We could have gotten the first villain couple in Disney history. But Disney doesn't take risks anymore they just want to make something that's marketable.

[@havinghope6315]

Well I guess they failed 😂😂

[@jaycobsanimations]

Thank you for calling out the awkward silence at the end of the musical numbers 😭 Also yeah I agree with you on the 6/10! Not the best movie but not the worst. I enjoy these relaxed genuine reviews dude!

[@SeptillionSeven]

11:03 random quiet beautiful singing

[@JonahWho]

aww shucks

[@juanca2567]

@@JonahWhoIf they included the Star boy from the concept art, you’re singing sounds like the perfect fit for him. I imagine it like if Asha were crying in a corner, the Star Boy would be singing like you did to comfort her in a time of need.

[@giovanmorabonilla6400]

​​@@juanca2567 That would have been perfect

[@fierygamer582]

I read a comment that said Rosas was a confusing name. In Spanish, Rosas means Roses or Pink and there isn't any of that in the movie. I agree with this, why name the Rosas if there isn't any roses or pink. I am no language expert but they could have named the town that could be associated with wishes or magic as that is what the movie revolves around.

[@takkycat]

The "ceremony" line sounds like when you are just making up a song on the spot while bored. The timing and spacing just sound off and unpolished.

[@Satan.Himself]

Wish’s animation style looks like the sims 4. I’m sorry but it really does..😭😭

[@AwesomeYena]

XDD

[@SweetOrangeGirl]

Nah, don’t do Sims 4 like that 😂.

[@vuthu2631]

Sims 4 with DLCs and CCs is better tbh

[@Satan.Himself]

@@SweetOrangeGirl I will do sims 4 like that✊

[@Satan.Himself]

@@vuthu2631 absolutely

[@kumosukesaiko4231]

i dunno man, 6/10 was mighty generous

[@korahholl810]

So true

[@stxrl1ng]

The worst part is king magnifico was basically seen as free wishing machine and just doesnt feel like a true villain? like my guy just needs a friend who doesnt ask for a wish right after he says he feels like people only see him for the wishes or whatever. You know what did "Evil wish granter" right? MADOKA MAGICA, AN ANIME HAD A BETTER WISH BASED VILLAIN THAN DISNEY sorry if rhis is like poorly written im v out of it

[@peachiekeenmachine]

Did people not know that Chris Pine has experience as a voice actor????? Like, him being fairly talented shouldn't have been a surprise lol. Rise of the Guardians is on of my all time favourite animated movies, and he voices the protagonist in that. He also has a minor part in Spider-Man: Into The Spiderverse, and in terms of musicals he played a small but iconic role in Into the Woods lol. Like, he's not the best va I've heard, it's obviously something he dabbles in rather than a specialty, but in my opinion he's genuinely good!

[@Ceranyx]

Watching a rainwing angrily rant about a Disney movie is a wonderful experience (Btw I love the design of the character makes me wanna draw fanart)

[@lavendermarshmallowplant3229]

I have my grievances with Raya, but it benefited from letting the audience explore the vast world it was set in. It knew what it wanted to be--be an adventure epic that showed different environments and cultures. Wish wanted to be a simpler story in a simpler setting that harkens back to their roots, but it lacked the charm to make up for that simplicity because it constantly tried to emulate its predecessors while forgetting what it could have to set itself apart.

[@mariatorres-by6du]

The opening with a book is a reference to the classic Disney princess movies, they always opened with a book (wich I think it was a real book not an animate one). That's also why Shrek opens with a book, because is riffing on Disney. (Love the review, I'm glad I found your channel)

[@YAPPSIFER]

i deadass did not know you were the same guy as the dude who fixed the lyrics

[@emilylike-the-soup2502]

4:24 - So, you could say … “I want something more for us than this”?

[@JonahWho]

get out

[@batzdites]

HELLO

[@SweetOrangeGirl]

He has to make a wish first, then say the line!

[@Jules-qy5kz]

What if they made Asha as someone who was very outwardly nice but in reality is rude and self centered, all she wants is to grant a wish etc? I think that would be interesting because her personality would subvert expectations and we could see her personality change as she grows, maybe learning that maybe she doesn’t need magnifico’s wishes. Just a thought I had about the story!! :D

[@unicornpupart]

i rant about wish too it literally gave me a headache oh my gosh

[@AlekMax64]

I’m new here, is he like, a rainwing? Because if so, that’s very cool and I like it.

[@justaguy6216]

Hey hey don't be so mean, disney is a small indie company.

[@dlaBerAuoY]

i cant even be mad about the chatgbt lyrics "ooh im a star" is so bad that is funny

[@bluedemonslayer1]

it’s not Disney’s 100th animated movie, it’s their 100th year

[@DrizzingSakuras]

One of the dumbest things in the world is asha's name itself. Whats so bad abt it you ask? ITS LITERALLY THE WORD "WISH" TRANSLATED INTO HINDI (आशा) 😭 Edit: also its not "wish apon a star" wish, it's "I wish I could.... or I wish you were...." wish. It's so obvious they just put that shit through Google translate

[@StackerRox]

THE CRICKETS PLEASBDUWIDJEB 💀💀💀

[@alexb859]

Awesome video!!! In my opinion wish is one of those movies that is so Bad that it's good, I haven't watch the movie itself but I do like the songs, like they are actually so badly written that in my opinion they are automatically good, like when in one of the Songs a Deer literally says watch out world head I are 😆 but my main gripe about the movie is the story telling, mainly with Asha wanting all wishes to come true, and King Magmefico (I think that's how you spell it) is a guy who only grants wishes that are good like helping the elderly, becoming a movie director, being a Knite that protects the Kingdom, ETC, but Asha wants for even the Dangerous wishes to come true, so I feel like the Lesson in Wish is dangerous, but the Songs they are badly written yet funny :) and I respect your opinion on this movie :)

[@DrawciaGleam02]

"Magmefico" 😆😆😆

[@westerfrost3701]

*Magnifico

[@alexb859]

@@westerfrost3701 thanks :)

[@westerfrost3701]

@@alexb859 You’re welcome.

[@75things75]

I loved this video, like all of yours. I agree with some of your points but unlike the general consensus, I liked this film. I've heard that Disney Animation was passionate about this but Corperate Disney drove this into the ground and ruined it. I found this quite entertaining and a great celebration of 100 years of Disney. Also, you're amazing at what you do, and I aspire to be as great a creator as you someday. In fact i think you commented on one of my first cringey videos about 2 years ago, and now, my videos are... slightly less cringey but nowhere near as great as yours. Keep doing what you're doing man, you're a genuine, incredible person who's incredible talent gets overlooked by many. :)

[@PixPlaysoyeaaaaa]

Chris's smooth vocal chords were the only thing that kept me sane. (Not only me, right :)? and also that scene where Asha just wrecks Magnifico with a bookshelf that was really funny for some reason-

[@em-nn8tt]

This movie looks like the sims 4 with gshade lol

[@user-yz8sg2wr1n]

actually seeing his face on Jonah Who Two is so much better. I genuinely forget this is his main account

[@Aphelia.]

Dude you are a dragon this is so cool. I love your persona

[@yarn1471]

I found u through the second channel rewrite video. I love your videos so far, I watched these 2 and bolt one ^^ Also I really like your dragon sona

[@emperorbelos6835]

I just watched it too and I will die on this hill “this is the thanks I get” is a good song and I’d prefer over other Disney songs

[@westerfrost3701]

I like it, too.

[@peachiekeenmachine]

As a writer, the lyrics in this movie caused me physical pain :')

[@beckheorshepls5397]

I watched this movie halfway through one night before getting bored and the next day I couldn't remember any melody from any of the songs at all. It was that forgettable

[@Breadestboi]

That’s it! I say the community comes together to remake wish!! WHO’S WITH ME!!!!!!

[@nimrahkhan8671]

This whole movie is a marketing ploy

[@starpower1884]

i'm so upset cause I really love Asia's design but her personality just being the adorkable basic disney princess, along with the rest of the movie being bland/ bad just is so sad. She has one of my favorite of the princesses designs ☹️

[@clementine7750]

absolutely living for the monty python references. ni!

[@aumsharma8783]

9:50 in defense of this song (At all costs) the lyrics written here are in weird order, they sound quite good in the song (except: fElT tHiS nO i hAvEnT)

[@ladypool1404]

I watch it 2 times; first because i was curious and second to really see if it's that bad... yes, it is! Nothing made me laugh or cry, Valentino was annoying, the star was cute but not very bave (Would been better as the Starboy AND having a romance with Asha. Too bad we didn't get that!) Magnifico became evil out of nowhere; his song is catchy but not as iconic and exciting as Be prepared or Hellfire. The queen was not memorable or developped, she would been so interresting if she was evil like in the original plot. Also, first evil couple in a Disney movie; that would be awesome! Asha's friends were just a reference, none of them was likable or funny or charming 😐 The action is good and the music too. The rest... meh. If i have to rate it, i give it 5|10. Not great but not awful or boring either. Although, i won't rewatching it a millions times like with: Aladdin, Lilo and Stitch, Treasure planet, Atlantis, Mulan or Hercules.

[@kinitoswebworld]

I looked up 'this is the thanks i get' and the first thing that popped into my brain was 'fly my little akuma and evilise him' T_T

[@castroelishajanellem.2490]

I think someone already said this somewhere but I feel like everyone in this movie is a background character from shrek....

[@bagelisdead]

Welcome to Rosas isn't that bad of a song. But it's an exposition song that basically repeats what we were already told from the storybook intro? So storytelling-wise, the song is kind of redundant. It would've been better if it was a song that introduced to us who Asha is as a character (like "Belle" from Beauty and the Beast, which also had a storybook intro in stained glass window form).

[@Marx-XIII]

This is the Thanks I Get makes me want to walk into the ocean and never return :')

[@xzyphiria]

wow i came from the rewriting lyrics video on your second channel and did not expect it to be a furry at all. you have the last personality that i would ever associate with a rainbow dragon on the internet but i am so for it and im 1000% subbed + ready for more

[@TheRealPello01]

I’m I path of titans player and I already know Asha is comparable to the Official Allosaurus. Allo in PoT is a average Dino, so Asha is your average Disney channel protagonist

[@Violet-Sky-4580]

like i wouldn't want to be wished into being a goat

[@gullybonesart4670]

Off topic from the video, but I love your character design! It reminds me a little of the rainwings from WoF :3

[@catdownthestreet]

I honestly didn't have much to say about Wish simply because I enjoyed the jokes and the references to previous Disney movies were nostalgic. It wasn't a terrible experience either, probably because I had no expectations for it going into the theater. I didn't even know it was the 100th Disney movie. I just knew it was a movie and I happened to enjoy it. If you just watch the movie as a movie it's actually not that bad. Remember that that doesn't erase the issues it had overall. Just... one thing I feel I need to say is that this is an excellent reminder for us as viewers to stop going into movies with expectations that are shaped by people who already watched it. Let yourself experience things naturally. I definitely wouldn't have enjoyed any part of Wish even a little bit if I'd listened to everyone online saying it was just plain bad. It was pretty underwhelming from the perspective that it was a celebration of the films Disney has made, but that doesn't make it horrible. Flawed (probably written partially by AI), but not horrible. (Somehow I can smell the hate coming my way for saying I enjoyed Wish.)

[@bellanolan4092]

Tbh i was really disappointed when the star didnt talk, i mean, in the trailer it had line so why didnt it in the actual movie?

[@jaredandell126]

Saw the video on your second channel, wanted more, saw ragon appear, instantly subbed to both channels

[@li_rocchi_]

just so u know, its actually the 62nd film not 100th, but its been 100 years of the animation studio xx

[@nimrahkhan8671]

MEDITERANIAN?? I THOUGHT THIS WAS LIKE AFRO-CUBAN?!

[@erimcfairy9353]

this could have been better is if Asha had an actual reason to rebel. Instead of "he doesn't grant every wish and that's bad" what if he only granted the wishes of the rich and powerful?? Or granted wishes in exchange for favors, gifts, or cash. Then she'd have a reason to be upset, then he'd actually be evil, it would give the movie a plot that makes sense, while also being an allegory for real world problems. But... that plot might hit a little too close to home for the execs

[@lanealush48]

and it hurts even more, because you can tell a lot of the people working on it were really, truly good at what they did, but they were probably crunched for time and given stale material to work with :/

[@karathewolfsfanficchannel933]

The 7 dwarf friends are a waste of great character design (except the sleepy one his design blows) Also that scene where the whole city sings reminds me of all those women sang Creep by Radiohead

[@miadaorerk1681]

managed to get here after hearing your rewrite of welcome to rosas and you get a subscribe 🎉

[@gullybonesart4670]

9:00 considering who wrote the songs in the movie(Julia Michaels and Benjamin Rice), they really are pop songs in this case. That’s why the lyrics feel so clunky.

[@iateyursandwiches]

6:10character arc...she has no character arc! Lol

[@171QA]

I agree with all of your points.

[@Muna-Jlore0997]

i swear, WISH looks like they stole the idea from a low budget movie and trying to make it better. look, I have seen generic films in my life time, but nothing gets this bad as WISH.

[@LucaMations]

I have 2 questions: whens your next Q&A and will u ever talk about Zootopia?

[@pudz2611]

Wish is blatantly a Disney movie from the app Wish☠️

[@JeannieInABottle1965]

10:20 - 10:25 = I feel like that set of lines sounds fine, but it's no "Encanto". I guess, I don't fully see your point here, but I do see that line sounding better if it was "and he built Rosas a long time ago" so maybe you complaining about the lyrics has some basis. But, I will say, that villain song sounds weird and the silences are weirder. (Sure, those silences work in a live stage musical. But NOT IN A MOVIE!!!) Anyway, I'm glad I didn't see this one in theaters now that I've heard all these awful things about.

[@jesunclaro1592]

At All Cost wasn't meant for Magnifico and Asha, it does not fit them at all. We have been robbed off of our Starboy 😢💔💔

[@einelight8255]

As a movie on its own. 3/10 max. The music wothout the words, a bland but basic story, VA's are sometimes ok, animation is...passable at best. As a 100th special Disney movie, its an abomination that belongs in the Hellfires with count frollo.

[@callmethecommentcountess9329]

OK

[@peonylarkspur645]

Psych the musical did a better job utilizing the musical format and it was a TV comedy

[@RandomguyfromtheinternetN1]

It’s my b day and also worst movie of 2023 ngl

[@westerfrost3701]

Happy belated birthday!

[@RandomguyfromtheinternetN1]

@@westerfrost3701 thank you so much!! And yes it was late, but still thank you so much 😊

[@westerfrost3701]

@@RandomguyfromtheinternetN1 You’re welcome!

[@pineapplepotato6985]

Yayyy good video!!

[@kizen06]

wow seeing the scenes of other animations like encanto and moana right next to wish only makes it even more clear how the animation is bland af

[@MarzBarz71222]

the only song i think is any good is "at all costs" and i honestly hate the second chorus that the main character sings because her singing sounds so forced and uncomfortable, and the lyrics make no sense. but their voices sound good together, and the song itself could be put into different contexts and still used effectively

[@gregorybronstein]

lol it’s not their 100th film.

[@JonahWho]

whoopsy i meant it's their 100th anniversary

[@Thinkaboutit_ofiicial]

Lol I fucking hated this movie

[@Yusuketh443]

hi :3 UwU

[@reidleblanc3140]

saying a piece of media is mid and uninspired really should not equal disallowing people to enjoy its good parts. i wish people would get over themselves (pun not intended). why do they insist on only enjoying cream of the crop material? this movie sucks, and that's exactly why i hope someone out there enjoyed it. then it was a little bit less of a waste.

[@JonahWho]

yeah, i hope someone else enjoyed it too.

[@TheDrOfPwn]

u REAAAAAAALY should write scripts for these reviews........ just an idea

[@JonahWho]

i usually do. just tried something different this time

[@theJF7]

A good idea for full reviews in general, that I can agree on. However, to be fair, this felt more like a off-the-cuff rant/drive-by rather than something more official. It's an interesting set of angles and takes that I haven't quite seen in other reviews so far. This indicates to me that some value is still present, scattered as it may be. But that's just my two cents.

[@robertthechannel1799]

Am I really the only one who unironically liked this movie?

[@ashketcum1730]

No

[@WitchKing-Of-Angmar]

This is what your kind of group asked for in media. Representation and nothing else. Also thou art a cartoon dragon.