I Showed EXPENSIVE Silver Coins to a Coin Dealer... He Said This!

[@cowhand6112]

Enjoyed that. Keith is one of those guys that you can just tell he KNOWS what he is talking about and doesn't have to constantly say "in my 90 years of running a coin shop" to give himself street cred. Big thumbs up. Oh, and some really nice silver.

[@CoinCrew]

Thank you

[@NorthCoastBob]

4:15 You hit the grading nail on the head; some individuals forget that grading is merely a formulaic opinion on specific coin aspects. Yes grading is a useful point of reference, but ultimately people are buying the coin itself, not buying a piece of paper wrapped in a plastic slab with a “70” stamped on it. I completely ignore the grade if a coin is slabbed, and won’t pay extra for a graded one. I buy the coin for the coin, immediately take a Dremel to the slab, and free the coin for a more accessible storage solution.

[@aself88]

Love this style video! I'm a stacker collector too and love seeing the vintage stuff

[@jaimhaas5170]

Thanks for sharing the story bout your Dad. Great to hear you had this hobby in common.

[@maxt6036]

Totally the best show you ever made. I have always had these questions, I learned so much.

[@jeffb2456]

Thanks Keith. Enjoyed your conversation and comments.

[@petesquarterlifecrisis887]

Thanks for sharing the personal story with your dad.

[@McSilverWolff]

If we don't get more videos like this in the future, I might die a little bit inside. Hahaha great video brother

[@mandoman3042]

I love the old vintage coins, that's why I would pick the 1789 silver dollar. Thanks to Keith's input.

[@stevec2645]

Great guest, great coins. TY

[@DudeNamedRed]

Great follow up. Numismatics are what I collect. My 8 reales coins are my favorite since i cant afford a flowing hair.

[@DudeNamedRed]

Second time I've seen that artificially toned. I'd send it to PCGS. Keep the case you cracked it out of and prove your old man right.

[@lindathomas2350]

I just love seeing all those coins and learning more about them. It's like getting to sit down with a friend and looking at their collection and hearing the stories about how they got them. Keep it up!

[@doughensley6202]

Seeker love your video and great to see you at the coin shows and I have said hi to you. Look forward to see you at future shows.

[@milessakauye8819]

Hi Seeker, thank you for the vlog! Great story about the toned Morgan with your Dad! Thank you for sharing!

[@WOCassity2]

Great video. Enjoyed this. Please do more like this. Thanks Keith, thanks Seeker!!!

[@RLC-t1x]

Really enjoyed this video. Keith is a good dude and is very knowledgeable with coins. Hope you do another video like this soon! Nice collection btw!

[@evgeniystadnyk4069]

This show is actually very nice and informative. I like the idea of bringing on numismatic touch into it. Numismatic is an interesting investment compared to simple stacking. Nice job 👍🏻

[@silverchupacabra73]

Luv the video, SS! Thanks to Mr. Crew for being available for this too. I really liked the convo between the both of you on this subject. The Draped Bust dollar was stellar, as well as the bulls-eyed toned Morgan (artificial????Are you kidding me?). In the past, I've tended to buy the older coins with great detail, but have environ. damage to them because they still hold pretty decent value! I liked the Coronet! The "milk" spotted round/square brought up a conversation I had with a coin dealer back in Oct. where I had a '84-CC Morgan I was trying to sell that was graded at an MS64 and he wouldn't buy the coin because it had tone marks from staples on the reverse. There was absolutely nothing wrong with the coin except that. I understood his thinking on it too. Aesthetics with coins are a major pull for buyers and collectors. Even if a coin/round has a high grade, little defects can definitely affect buyer interest. I ended up keeping the coin because I wasn't going to sell it for a pig in a poke! Thanks for the vid! Cheers!

[@eb3Variety]

Excellent video. Sorry about your dad passing Great coin memento story.

[@jg29271]

Keith is a great guy. Not sure if this was prepped because not one LCS in my city are paying those premiums for collector coins.

[@Mrs.CoinCrew]

I think he's giving a price that he would sell it for not buy

[@jg29271]

@@Mrs.CoinCrew that’s more realistic I started as a stacker quickly fell in love with the cool stuff paying a high premium and at a tough time I had to sell it was impossible for LCS to pay over spot

[@buildingAbiz]

The draped bust dollar is my all time favorite coin design from the US mint ❤ that is on the top of my want list in also the same grade as yours 🤩

[@richardmetcalf2346]

I was thinking maybe the Morgan's are the same because a troy ounce of silver is about the same size as an ounce of copper. I'd have to test that theory. Hands down your dad's beautiful toner if I had to pick one. It might not be the most expensive, but it is certainly a beauty!

[@waynekolvoord968]

The 1798 silver dollar is a coin that I would really like to own, I am also into the Large Cents, great video as always.

[@TacticalMainframe]

I really love this type of video style. Try to do these often.

[@deca12351]

Great video !!

[@michaelfinn1803]

Great Video, really enjoyed it .. thanks

[@M_R23]

Great Video Keith/Seeker

[@everettwhite9874]

Enjoyed the show with Keith. My favorite was the toned Morgan. I just love the toning on that one. Seeker are you considering sending it to PCGS? That one is a special coin to you but I get the feeling that it would get a higher grade, but that you have a special bond and unique memories connected to it with your dad. Just my thinking. Those are nice coins. Finally, seeing that milk spot probably makes ya want to holler.

[@basementjackal]

Another interesting video. The 1798 is the bomb Keep up the good work

[@jm8691]

Sorry about your dad. In Lost mine in August. He was a metal detector and flung some neat stuff.😊

[@doughensley6202]

Hey Keith .. great to watch your video. This video was awesome. I have seen you at coin shows abd have said hi and always great to see you as well. :)

[@maskedman1337]

Thanks for sharing that heartfelt story about the 1879-O!"

[@steventogami898]

Good video. Keith is very good just looking through a video, and pretty accurate in his grading.

[@mikeleverenz9949]

Another great show,very interesting

[@Sim_racer_40oz]

Oh nice 👍 I have the complete zombie bucks collection with the copper

[@steventogami898]

That Coke bottle cap is so cool! Coke memorabilia collectors would show interest, and might pay more.

[@StephenKozlowski]

Thanks for sharing

[@ezal3634]

liked it. the 1798 washington held it is my favorite

[@nicolasrossi5978]

Fun stuff. My preferance is for the more traditional numismatic pieces, but all were interesting for various different reasons. Thanks for sharing.

[@SilverSaxon]

I thought I was a coin collector for years, but financial circumstances largely prevented me from actually collecting. But a few years ago, I learned about stacking and realized that I have always been an opportunistic stacker at heart. As a paperboy, I was always checking my change for silver in order to grow my stack.

[@mykittenisagrandmaster4381]

Spiderman does sell really well I've seen them go for around 100 or maybe a little under for the Tuvalu ones

[@ronaldperry]

Great channel ❤

[@jdoggwhitetrash]

Great video Silver Seeker and Coin Crew aka Just A Guy. Thanks for sharing. Large Eagle in PCGS slab is AWESOME.

[@Blue_Siberian]

loved the center toned coin definitely in my opinion natural toning great story 👍

[@cerealaugher]

I been collecting since 1995 I mainly collect vintage silver art bars. I went to a few LCS's, and they all said the same thing about my silver art bars, it's just silver and they offer $1under spot, I told them I will sell all my silver, after I melt it down.

[@marks.schwartz8468]

Keith and Silver Seeker have got a hit format doing these !!!

[@MAGA_Extremist]

I guessed the grade of the draped bust dollar I have one from 1795. I enjoyed looking at the older coinage ❤ honestly I enjoyed all of them but my heart is with the old ones

[@SW-rb9cr]

Nice, I love Morgans, and I would keep the Hulk and Spiderman.

[@Fxe9r]

I think 🤔 that Spiderman is awesome and would bring in a pretty penny my buddy.

[@goldsilverjunkie]

I’ll tell you one thing if a coin gets slapped with the MS 70 and then down the line it starts milking or toning I believe that it shouldn’t affect the value once a coin is slapped that’s it. That’s what it gets that grade.

[@SilverSeeker]

It's all about what people are willing to pay my friend. If you were in a coin shops and there were two of the same coins, with the same grade and the same price, but one had milk spotting on it, which one would you choose?

[@goldsilverjunkie]

@ exactly!! but what if there was only one😂

[@wapphigh5250]

Can you please do one of these with Keith on 1986> current slabbed Silver eagles?. Thanks!

[@donaldinnewmexico]

Hi Seeker. Good video. It is impossible to grade a coin in a video. Keith did a good job under the circumstances. Thanks.

[@SilverSeeker]

Thanks, I agree he did a great job under those circumstances.

[@MissouriMetal]

3:24 the random it’s Wednesday my dudes 💀

[@fbazzrea]

i appreciated the dealer's opinion on the modern limited mintage coins. i have paid a lot of premiums for modern limited mintage coins but dont know if they hold much premium yet in the mkt. sounds like age helps even modern coins. thx

[@michaelfinn1803]

I would like to know the value of each coin , thats always nice, kinda like that antuiqe road show , everyone is always wanting to know the price x

[@Quahogstacker]

That 1996 Spider-Man is really nice

[@jaimhaas5170]

yeah that really caught my eye too. What is the price on something like that?

[@Quahogstacker]

@ I just looked it up I found a 2 coin set wolverine & spider-Man $600

[@Rbarker198]

My fav is the 1879 Morgan simply because the link to your father. My dad is my best friend and I treasure items that he's given me over the years.

[@MikeGreen-nv3hc]

Really liked the coins I have morgan and peace dollar that toned like yours and they where glued on a board but toning looks like the one you had graded with your dad

[@colebesaw5225]

Love the marvel stuff. Especially the “vintage” Spider-Man.

[@Larry-dt7kz]

1798 !

[@CoinsAZ]

14:21 Gorgeous coin

[@briankerr4512]

Milk spotting on the square coin would be a detraction but milk spotting on a coin like a maple does not bother me at all because coins like that are not some collectible thing. Milk spotting is just further proof that it is silver.

[@9171891]

Thanks for sharing the coins and Keith's opinion. Perhaps you could use a scope for coins when showing and talking about grading. (sponsor maybe) As a newbie to see the details better would help in understanding grading. The point you make is clear without. Just a thought, certainly not a criticism. Thank you for your videos.

[@ERtony24007]

Thank you for sharing. Marvel coins very shiny

[@user-j4200]

The silver and copper rounds are the same size but the thickness on the copper is more. You stack 10 silver rounds and 10 copper the copper stack will be taller.

[@emilevoyer123]

Thanks for a great video.

[@davidf3883]

Could you show us something from your personal collection? Just kidding :)

[@pjs139]

I don't know how you trust sending off you silver to people you don't know. Good video. Also, can you explain the grading?

[@TheLehrke]

Morgue Anne 'error', regardless if intentionally done, are sweet.

[@Tracy-wr7mj]

good video..yes it is reality when many pretty new silver are only going to get around spot unless you can wait for that one who would pay.

[@Wes_Stacks.]

Nice pieces for sure

[@SirWalter-eb9ht]

enjoy your videos. the 1835 Large cent looks as though it has rotated dies as well as Large 8

[@scottgrayson9668]

Just checking out your coins nice collection like Keith hopefully you will bring Keith back thanks

[@jacktregellas4355]

Thanks SS I have the marvel coins, and I need to look them over again.

[@Stackitupmetal]

Note: coins not for sale .. private collection

[@douglaslegvold9215]

Milk spotting affects sale ability ok. Maybe not grade.

[@razorready]

Love the trade dollar and the 1798 dollar. I do not collect the fancy one ounces for the same reason that Keith would have a hard time selling. I'm a bars guy lol meaning I collect boring silver.

[@jimshepard8822]

What do you think about the. RED BOOK, guide to American Coins. The price guide, is very deceiving, either that or all coin Shops are lying to me about values ! I’ve spent a lot of money on rare and valuable coins, to find the publication is false on many estimates.

[@Richmart1955]

❤ interesting

[@joehrlein847]

Informative. Thanks

[@maskedman1337]

"Vintage coin"? That trade dollar is straight-up antique coinage, a dozen decades older than "vintage."

[@clapclapscream]

Let’s go I guessed the VF20 on that eagle

[@justacinnamonbun8658]

I don't buy any of that stuff for my stack or collection. But to flip for a good profit I would definitely consider purchasing. I'm one of those "silver is silver" people. Maybe I would be interested in pre-1800 coins. But definitely not anything with Spiderman or Coca-Cola, just not my thing. Once in a while I'll see something from MK BARZ like the 4 reales Spanish replicas that look cool, or Egyptian mythology pieces. I find those way more interesting than the Marvel stuff.

[@dougvanallen2212]

My favorite was definitely the dollar that George Washington held by far

[@bobblenuts]

Probably would not buy one, but liked the Coke silver. The round toned coin was my favorite.

[@2manyhobbies971]

Big fan of all three old dollars…….

[@JesusisMySavior581]

awesome- still learning

[@Clintscollectiblez]

What causes those milk spots? I got a proof coin from us mint that had a small spot on it like that

[@Mrs.CoinCrew]

Ms64?

[@Revenant_Dancer]

If you pulled spot removed out of the slab would it sell for more ?

[@redhairedredneck]

That draped bust! Wow! Zombucks are so cool, too! I'm not a fan of the Marvel stuff. To each there own. Different strokes for different folks! I've been a long-time subscriber Seeker, and I want you to know I truly appreciate all your hard work and effort. Thank you for all you do, sir! Fight like you're the third monkey on the ramp to Noah's Ark, and brother, it's starting to rain!

[@randyman828]

96 Spider

[@Col-shaolin]

People may not buy milk spot silver simply because they think it’s ugly.

[@helenbrooks4787]

Well, who is going to want to buy it? No coin dealer will want it, because he will never be able to resell it unless it's his last piece of silver for sale.Everybody, naturally buys things for the looks of anything they buy.

[@TacticalMainframe]

The early dollar was my favorite

[@joestosez]

Why does the toning add value?

[@TimothyOconnor-yg6mj]

Will you do one for Intaglio mint 1 and 2 oz tribute rounds

[@The1guyUdontreallyremember]

Sad that the coin you dad had got that grade man how could someone intentionally fake that man hopefully at some point it gets the real grade but cool coin Seeker!❤

[@The1guyUdontreallyremember]

You should make a silver asmr lol

[@zdiver1]

I have the whole Trump coin and bars collection have 5 of each in one ounce silver and see as of today cannot order not available. is it already collectible?

[@leechild4655]

Trade dollar looks nice but may be a dipped EF? I could be totally wrong cause you cant grade a coin using pictures or video. My guess if slabbed PCGS its a Details EF. If not graded cleaned its as high as AU 53? Only guessing from video.