"I Was in Israel on October 7th: Here's What Happened" -Trey Yingst

[@UTU]

At 58:00 he's very wrong, we learned that avoiding the conflict leads to us getting brutalized. What the lesson actually was is - we must initiate the battles as we used to do in the 20th century.

[@jakhaughton1800]

Many people may not know but residents of Gaza went to work on a daily basis to work in the territory of Israel.

[@keithrichardson3942]

Yes and some of them came over the border and went looking for their employers' valuables on October 7th

[@ItamarO93]

Talk about biting the hand that feeds...

[@parkforest434]

Israeli are intelligent until you ask about 76 year military occupation apartheid, and Arab Israeli are treated 2nd class citizens same way how normal white citizens American treated color people in the early 1900s.

[@ItamarO93]

@@parkforest434 Your ignorance burns through the screen like acid made of Stupid. You are so misinformed that trying to explain it to you is as futile as trying to eat a soup with a fork.

[@Lestibournes]

​@@parkforest434Tell me you know nothing but Hamas propaganda without saying that you know nothing but Hamas propaganda.

[@pathwalkerrising-phoenix3683]

I just want to say to Trey, that my wife and I truly appreciate the coverage you provided last October. We were glued to the channel at home here in The US and were amazed by your dedication and information you provided. Your work is truly appreciated. Our hearts and prayers were going out to the Israeli people those first days because just by chance the month before in September 2023 we downloaded a language app and randomly chose to start learning Hebrew. It really touched our hearts that you were there covering the tragedy so that the world could see evil at work and it not go unnoticed. To this day since I heard you mention the Red Alert app during that coverage, I still have this app to hear the alerts of rockets in the air in Israel on a day to day basis, so as to not forget the daily struggle there in Israel. I want to say that in our hearts you are already a legend in the industry and I pray for your safety, well being and continued coverage.

[@yitzchakmordechai]

I was there in JERUSALEM with my family fir the jewish holidays. What a surreal experience, cowering with our kids in stairwells hoping our building wouldn't be hit. Going back for the holidays again this year...bc they cant be allowed to stop us

[@beebeebee7000]

Victory is the only way that you achieve peace. It is the historic lesson of war. This is something that the west does not understand. -DOUGLAS MURRAY

[@JanaLemons-dl7tk]

My husband was a combat veteran and I learned in the hebrew that there is a difference in killing and murder. Having grown up in a small town and being a Baptist girl I was struggling with that. When I talked to my husband about it he said you have to put a rabid dog down. When you have a religion that considers themselves to be the only ones that God favors and they are taught that from the time that they are little and it's OK to lie to an infidel which some believe everyone is but them and they are yelling death to Israel - death to America - you have to put it down - thank goodness for those who have abandoned that ideaology!

[@alisonnovich3256]

If there was no October 7th there would be no airstrikes that have happened this past year. It's really straight forward. The cease fire existed on October 6th - despite the rockets thrown at Israel regularly.

[@teresaaljayyousi8447]

You are uniformed. That’s not true and being the custodian of death against Palestinians is horrible.

[@teddy.d174]

What an incredible interview, thanks to both of you. Trey is one of the very few journalists that I respect and admire. He’s very relatable and his work is exceptional. I’d venture to say that he was born to be a war correspondent. Cheers to both of you and very well done, gentlemen.

[@bearowen5480]

Trey, you have done a fantastic job, both in Ukraine and in Israel, of reporting the reality of war without taking sides. I salute you for your courage as well as your perspicacity. I am a combat veteran of the Vietnam War, an A-6 Intruder fighter-bomber pilot, which gave me a very different perspective of combat from the grunts on the ground who fought the war eyeball to eyeball. In your interview with Jack, I really appreciated your testimonial regarding PTSD. We all experience this phenomenon in uniquely different ways. Your articulate and very personal description of how it has affected you was very liberating for me and I'm sure anyone who has also experienced it. As you described your experience, I tried to put myself into your own bloodstained boots, and it gave me empathy for what you've endured to bring the reality of war home to all FOX viewers. Thank you for that. I look forward to reading your book. Stay safe, my friend! 👍🙏🐻🇺🇲🇮🇱

[@tg8285]

Great reporting ! Only one issue though.. Please call the Hammas what they are...not militants---- > TERRORISTS.

[@loganhuff1004]

I mean they aren’t but whatever dumbass

[@parkforest434]

Anyone or any group has the right to do October 7 everyday until Israel stops the 76 year military occupation apartheid! Israeli are intelligent until you ask why Hamas started in 1987

[@tg8285]

@@parkforest434 i didnt understand a single thing thats written here but ok....does this have anything to do with what i wrote??...

[@andrewsimckes5748]

Israel pulled outvof Gaza in 2005 and the blockade was in rwderence to them importing weapons instead of true aid for the people Also just so you know Egypt had Gaza until 1967 so you should check your dates Jordan had west bank none of thisw countries ever gace citizenshipto the Palestinians ​@parkforest434

[@joge2468]

@@tg8285 He’s contesting use of the word “terrorist.” I actually think journalists should say “soldiers who commit terrorism.” I think it’s important to reinforce that SamaH is the military of a self-governing statelet. Simply calling them “terrorists” implies they are non-state actors. I don’t think anyone should forget these people were elected and are responsible for protecting their citizens.

[@CCSAW-t1m]

Great interview Jack! Nice having a guest who is articulate with fascinating anecdotes

[@mikeblasko841]

Trey is the best reporter ever! Thank you!❤️👍🏻🇺🇸🇮🇱

[@bobmcmillen4502]

Great interview. A couple of great Americans! Thank you both for your service. Reading “”Beirut” now. Just bought “ Black Saturday”. Both of you keep up the great work!

[@jaykay415]

Trey, you mentioned that AlAqsa is the 3rd holiest site to Muslims. I wanted to add: the same location, called Temple Mount by the Jews, is the holiest site for Jews, because (quoting from My Jewish Learning) "Abraham demonstrated his devotion to God by taking his son Isaac to be sacrificed. It is also the site of both ancient Jewish temples. The first, built by King Solomon, was destroyed by the Babylonians in 586 BCE. The second was built in the sixth century BCE and stood for nearly 600 years before it was destroyed and the Jewish people exiled in 70 CE by the Roman Empire. Jews continue to mourn the destruction on the fast day of Tisha B’Av. According to Jewish tradition, a third temple will be built on the site during the messianic age."

[@Standing.W.Israel]

Plus Islam is a lie... Koran was compiled in 19th century by a German academic.

[@nancybarry4150]

Love Trey he’s a fantastic reporter, praying for him to stay safe be open to talk about your mental health. Can’t imagine your day to day stress. Jack is great to do this valuable interview. Will read both books

[@karlamathes5052]

I absolutely love Trey, he has been on the ground since the beginning and has been the best reporter. I’m so glad to actually hear him without the 2-3 time limits. Thank you Trey for your faithful service to all of us.

[@TheHistoryShelf]

Requested the book for review, cannot wait to read it! Thanks for this in-depth interview, Trey and Jack!

[@jocelyndawson755]

Yes!!! I have been waiting for my favorite Pods to get Trey on. So stoked for this one!!!!

[@freeindeed5393]

My wife and I were in Israel on Oct 7th also. It all seems so surreal now. It was our first trip there.

[@theintegralbody6069]

Oh my goodness what a first trip to have. I am sure you got to witness the best and the worst of what goes on in israel and hopefully you will go back and get to experience only the best with peace.

[@jamesgunnyreed]

Trey, You do great reporting from some of the worst and most dangerous places on earth. PLEASE, DO NOT become like all the other so called "Journalists" that push a personal or political agenda... Be true to yourself, and true to your craft. Report the truth and get the best information and facts to the people. You are a great reporter. Do Not become an activist. At least not while on the job anyway.

[@amyellison648]

Just finished Black Saturday. It's awesome! I'm definitely a fan! Awesome interview!

[@vkevpe]

Jack: I love your podcasts and your thoughtful commentary. Love your novels and film productions too. Thanks for that, and thanks for your service to the country!

[@ads06.1]

Amazing interview and discussion Sir & thank you for your service & sacrifice to our nation & for all of us. I have so much respect and admiration for both of you. I look forward to reading the book & again, I very much appreciate all you do for the remaining free liberty-loving citizens of the world.

[@Cardinalspuj]

Trey, love your work! I have listened, watched, and trusted your words from day one. Your work in the grasp of danger has been unreal. Thank you for putting yourself in danger to provide the world its truths. Boots on the ground. Truthful description of boots on the ground in war. May God protect you and your crew every day. Condolences in your loss of grandmother. I’ll bet your grandmother is right at your side. Protection from evil from beyond the veil of mortality. God bless!

[@Pearly44-nm7kn]

Jack, congratulations. This may be your best episode yet. I was on the edge of my seat the entire time. I just ordered Trey's book and can't wait to read it. Again, well done!

[@FlyMc9]

Great interview and must needed conversation. I applaud all your efforts, sir! Thank you. 🙏🏼 💯💪🏼

[@jacobewilson878]

Always amazing interviews and information Thanks Jack

[@therealriverryan]

Fascinating interview. Definitely will get the Black Saturday book. Good job Jack Carr

[@SW-fu4jj]

I have both books. My problem is which one to start first. I hope someday both are required reading at the university level. Awesome interview Jack!!

[@Meg-ts3kx]

Thank you for reporting the most awful day I've experienced in my life. It's insane people still don't now what happened here, they talk like it was conflict or war, it wasn't. it was a massacre. our PR is absolutely atrocious

[@TM-100]

They've worked hard to reconstruct the facts & reality to fit the "cycle of violence" garbage.

[@joelreidy2585]

The media is seriously compromised…October 7th was barely on the news…they went straight to blaming the Jews…again

[@BrandieRaeSlayton]

I'm deeply sorry! My heart is with you 💓

[@joelreidy2585]

@@Meg-ts3kx it was criminally underreported…it was so evil, people think that Israel MUST be making it up…it couldn’t be that a people have that much hate in their heart…the media had a responsibility to show the world how evil Hamas really are…they failed miserably, and, it wouldn’t seem…intentionally

[@joelreidy2585]

@@Meg-ts3kx stay strong

[@Agben35]

Fascinating interview. Great job guys.

[@leahn5288]

Fantastic interview so incredibly interesting to hear him talk, a very brave man! Thank you 🙏

[@Bobbynevovic]

I have been following a few reporters since October 7 including local ones (Israel). I have to say that Trey is one of my favorite, probably top 2. Fantastic job Trey!

[@r_90g2]

More rawness and realism here than the recent civil war movie. And the ability to take a moral stand.

[@MichelleKavarnos]

This is brilliant. Trey is doing incredible work But on Jack's part too. Very thoughtful interesting questions.

[@deborahdoucet576]

I lost all respect for Trey and Fox News when he was criticizing Israel for dealing with the Palestinian “ reporters”,many of whom are terrorists.

[@TM-100]

1:02:30 The MOST holy site in Judaism. If you want to communicate the complete picture that fact is relevant.

[@TM-100]

"Black Saturday" doesn't actually fully communicate the depth of depravity. The title should be more like "Black Sabbath" or something similar. It was the Jewish SABBATH *AND* SIMCHAT TORAH, a Jewish HOLIDAY. All the noise about Ramadan with no respect towards the Jewish holidays. The general world hypocrisy is obscene.

[@jamiewells9388]

Never underestimate evil especially when there's nothing to do only figure out ways to spread its hate. Evil will always find a way in if you don't keep watch full time. God protect 🙏🇮🇱🙏.

[@bjjpenguin]

You're a true dumbass if you think Israel isn't the evil one.

[@abipey]

I bought Trey's audiobook today . I bought Jack's audiobook 3 days ago.. it's a toss-up. Which one you do you read first?. Even though the Beirut book was in the '80s and kind of is the beginning of what Trey is going through. Sometimes it's better to know the ending before you know the history. But it's two books that must go with each other. That is a fact..

[@jbl7092]

Every generation needs an Ernie Pyle to tell them what's really happening on the battlefield, and Trey Yingst is ours. Thanks for such great reporting, Trey!

[@truckwhisperer116]

The second half of this interview is great and extremely real

[@EmmeErin]

Wrong

[@Jazzmar7513]

Trey is a amazing journalist, glad he is with fox

[@Marss13z]

Excellent interview. Just bought the book.

[@TM-100]

29:20 Closed captions put it EXACTLY! *"TWO WINKS!!"* EXACTLY 💯!!

[@jillclark6076]

Trey us tge best reporter in America. May gyod keep him safe and preserve his life.

[@Lime61318]

Fantastic interview thanks for sharing!!

[@ilana]

"It could only be worse". Yes, this mam spent a fine amount of time among Jews.... Great interview!

[@jaredchandler4491]

I failed to say-- Excellent interview Jack!! Your questions brought out more truth 👊🏼 Well done, Sir- From Chaos Comes Truth😎

[@kathyBenHaroush]

thank you

[@Teek4Tat]

He is a serious person , who reports the news … he doesn’t put a spin on it that some tend to do . I’m not a fan of Fox News 90% of the time . I do however appreciate Treys reporting.

[@elizehauptfleisch7542]

His totally right about non peace. These people have been fighting for long.

[@camron1501]

Thank you.

[@christywilson694]

GREAT INTERVIEW!!!!

[@TM-100]

1:13:47 C'mon, they have tens of thousands of missiles. It's MORE THAN "deterrence". It's disarming or at least greatly reducing their fire power

[@matteast]

Lucky he survived the hanibal directive.

[@claudiasz26]

Just ordered the book… excited to read!!

[@thedarkprinceza]

There are too many ads in this video and many are even mid sentence. I couldn't watch all of it.

[@nocnamora3999]

2 hours wtf!!

[@yachinyphotography]

I fought from this day for 5 months. Volunteering as a civilian for tew weeks and then recruiting into the idf again after 9 years. I can tell you that:! Israel is the best country, the idf is the best ,most human, strongest army. We will never forget never forgive. But the rest of the world is a huge disappointment!!!!

[@jasonkatz8]

Great journalist thanks Trey

[@rabbimoshegreenwald4017]

Good interview! One thing about the Hamas “militants”. The distinction between militants and terrorists lies in their methods, goals, and moral boundaries. Militants are individuals or groups engaged in armed struggle, often pursuing political, ideological, or territorial objectives, and they primarily target opposing armed forces or infrastructure. While their actions may involve violence, they typically adhere to some form of combat ethics or justification within a larger conflict. Terrorists, on the other hand, deliberately target civilians, using fear and indiscriminate violence as tools to achieve their aims, often prioritizing chaos and shock over any ethical considerations. This is exactly what took place on 10-7-23. Labeling all violent actors as "militants" minimizes the moral gravity of terrorism and the unique threat it poses to innocent lives and societal stability.

[@courtneybass]

Is the ongoing Pal "genocide" not real? Sincere question. We desperately need trustworthy, brave journalists to share truth on these wars.

[@TM-100]

1:26:00 *TERRORISTS* Call a spade, a spade...

[@Buildinc1]

Agreed , but that depends which side of the fence you are sitting .

[@DanSygitowicz-ys5pb]

Great interview! I've always respected Trey and his reporting. I wonder where we'd be today if the US would have had a strong response and support of Isreal..

[@jewishlifenow8852]

Excellent interview💙

[@T0mmyTune]

11:11:28 Trey is the best salesman for his book. This chapter in the Podcast on, "Empathy in Reporting", closed the sale. I just bought his book. I know it will be a good read.

[@TM-100]

1:03:17 Saudi Arabia was about to sign peace with Israel. Iran had what to do about that

[@Motivationbycianj]

Great interview respectfully

[@dude3678]

Trey is what journalism should be. Anything else is tabloid bullshit.

[@scottchenoweth4937]

I refuse to TV, but Trey impresses me.

[@christinadooley344]

Great insight into Black 🖤 Saturday 😢

[@jebeau2566]

Have some empathy❤ quote of the day

[@SW-fu4jj]

Jack.... dude podcast GOLD!!

[@RP-ue9wy]

The production level is out of control!!!

[@LBan-x4s]

Jack, what have you learned about community defense from this story? Warrior in a garden. Oct 7 style attacks is not a zero probability event with all these new people coming into the country.

[@Standing.W.Israel]

Yeah, so many think we in the US are fitting to have our own Oct 8.

[@TM-100]

*WAS THIS FILMED BEFORE OR AFTER THE IRANIAN BALLISTIC MISSILES WERE LAUNCHED AT ISRAEL?*

[@Lindalou1]

God protect you trey ❤🙏✡️ thank you ..stay safe 🙏

[@itsallmyfault264]

There is nothing that makes me quit a video faster than an ad every 2 minutes 🥴

[@JohnCunningham-y2t]

Vote Trump / Vance to save our country and Israel. 💪🇺🇸🇺🇸🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇺🇸

[@roishick]

Hi Jack, Unfortunately there are a lot of amazing stories from October 7, one of them i think you will be very interested in. Its a special Forces guy who saved his family and killed 14 terrorist just with a Gluck and 7 magazines. At one point he was sure there all going to be captured and they decided as a family that its better to die then to be captured. kzbin.info/www/bejne/qXeaaKCYbM2Ehcksi=nMKlM8c28llbs2cu This is from an Israeli news Chanel and its in Hebrew. Maybe you can use the caption with English to understand.

[@jeffashley766]

Keep up the good journalism! We lack good journalists these days..to many are biased liberal or democrat leaning and its gross..I hope soon we can start having presidential debates on the JRE ir shawn ryan podcast

[@L-ep1zz]

Highly informative portrayal of professional & personal challenges faced by journalists in war zones. Pls cover Ukraine.

[@TyEMW1014]

Nova Rothchild trying to steal somebody else's identity in an unseen world is what happened.

[@yachinyphotography]

I stand with Israel.

[@jrapp1468]

Tells us almost nothing new about Oct 7th, talks about himself the entire time…

[@TM-100]

It's his book 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@jrapp1468]

@@TM-100 title is misleading.

[@AdamZiegler-c6c]

Just bought the book which will deliver soon and I'll likely read the day it arrives but I don't know if I want perspective from Hamas' personnel as if their opinions or reasons for committing genocide is equivalent to the IDF.

[@guiguitehila]

There wern't inteligence failiers. The failier was in descition making. The intekigence was spot on

[@TM-100]

The amount of ads on this video is really awful

[@user-bo8nb2mi]

How many militants?

[@AmyLLevi]

Shema Yisrael Baruch ata Adonai Eloheinu melech haolam, May G-d hold and keep you now and forever.🤦🏻‍♀️🇮🇱💙

[@animula6908]

I just bought the book

[@teresaaljayyousi8447]

The great March of return was not a f😮cking war.

[@bobcougar77]

"buy my book" interview

[@joanofarc6402]

37 minutes in, he still hasn’t started the actual story. Omg. 😱

[@TM-100]

It's called background

[@ashpaati]

Great interview and I commend Sheryl for doing what she has done with the documentary and that was certainly not easy given the atmosphere in the Silicon Valley. However she didn’t talk about the religious tenets that create such monsters who use r&@e as a tactic. That is a fail.

[@Kvell55]

He’s trying to makes a moral equivalency between the sides. There is good vs evil. Pathetic.

[@theantagonizer958]

Trey is a great reporter but could do without the comments that runs the interview

[@jackiedavison9898]

It's all written in the bible and how this all ends. God defeats His enemy's on the mountains of Isreal. You must be born again. Call out to Jesus and asked to be saved. Know and admit that your a sinner and repent. God bless.

[@andrewrae9850]

Pretty good reporting considering the alternatives. Still a long way from as good as it should be. I’ve never seen this reporter before but I look forward to seeing more. However it doesn’t take long to see that Trey is also biased quite clearly. ( I don’t think it’s important to clarify what those biased notions are tbh) What are the motives behind people and their biased notions. I think this question is irrelevant. It is however, sadly disingenuous to try and cast yourself as the true source of the facts.m or ‘trueist’ ! Just because you don’t fabricate facts, doesn’t mean you’re being honest. The profession of journalism requires at its core, a compromise of values in order to have access to all sides of a story. THIS fact, fundamentally undermines anyone who tries to claim that they have the cleanest truth. That is fundamentally a clear unequivocal lie. I am gonna buy your book still though man! I enjoy your work all the same. 👍

[@Keenafy]

These tv interviews man

[@jackreacher.]

1:41:28 '' ...solution .... '' ; The TWO STATE SOLUTION found closure in the American Revolutionary War.