Ib: NEW ENDING - Welcome to The World of Guertena (Bad Ending)

This is one of the new endings in Ib version 1.04, the latest update.
There are certain requirements that must be met to obtain this ending. To find out how to get it, please view this guide: ibgame.wikia.co...
DISCLAIMER: All the video and audio clips used belong their respective owners, I make no profit from this video.

[@kedamono639]

I love how the Lady in Red looks so bored, tapping her fingers on the ground.

[@kuroha_00]

To be honest, seeing Garry lose his sanity broke my heart, especially with Ib's reaction afterwards

[@themoonlight977]

+Kuroha Chan Same thing with me when i first saw the ending

[@hiiragii]

Ib never even talked in-game bro

[@kuroha_00]

@@hiiragii no need for dialogue to share emotions with the player. also it's been 4 years like tf bro

[@DakotaDoesStuff]

Same I even shed a tear when I saw this 5 years ago

[@BakedBanana]

oh

[@Kaiskov09]

The funny thing is that this looked like a good ending until Mary started using Garry and Ib as toys

[@d4rkpr1nc39]

@theminipyro 123 that's a bot dude.

[@gracemckittrick1877]

lol i dont wanna know what garry was talking about when he said " WHO WOULD DO THAT TO A GIRL? "

[@metro0612]

So from what I can tell, both Garry and Aibee [ Strangely, this is what I prefer calling her as since it seems cute for me ] died by either being killed by those Death Individuals or through natural cause (like illness, starvation or something of the sorts) and Marry, likely having suffered through her own hallucination and really not being human like the two, thinks they're still alive and decides to play with them forever without ever knowing that the two are dead... Wow.

[@matthewyt159oldestchannel5]

Red Tiger My opinion only: Ib is not dead, You can see her rose beside her. Well Garry...... is not dead too because the Lady in Blue painting has his rose and yet it's still whole 😐

[@metro0612]

+MatthewYT159 Videos you probably missed my whole "died by natural causes" bit.

[@TravellerOfDreams]

About the natural causes, time stopped at the gallery, so natural causes might not one of the reason.

[@spoookymoth]

MatthewYT159 Oldest Channel Mmmm, I know this is 3 years old but I love this game too much- You can see that at least 2 petals each from their respective petals had been ripped off, so I doubt that they’ll have long left to live after the ending

[@phantina2536]

we stan a queen who plays with decomposing bodies

[@kristy512]

Is it just me who absolutely adores the interactions between Mary and the other paintings/ sculptures of the gallery? The fact that the painting of the lips had to help out Mary with her pronunciation with the word trash just completely satisfied me. Also with the ending "a paintings demise" Mary is forced to come back instead of leaving for the real world. I just find it cute that the gallery is basically one big happy family and Mary's basically in her rebellious teenage phase with her desire of wanting freedom and escaping.

[@KittoChan9]

That's the main reason why this is my favorite ending. It's just ..fun!

[@cooldoesminecraft4286]

agreed

[@kedamono639]

I never thought of it that way. It IS pretty amusing.

[@theabsolute23]

I don't think she comes back in "a paintings demise". It's implied that she dies alone, forever trapped in the dark gallery in that ending. The dark gallery doesn't want her back, it literally says "no going back, no going anywhere." It's an extremely shitty ending for mary, not cute at all. The gallery kills her and leaves her horribly alone in a pitch black room.

[@ninepillarsofsalt]

It makes me want to see more of the paintings' interactions

[@EternalSkyDreamer]

Am i the only one that who noticed that the lady in blue is holding garry's rose?o.0 . Garrrryyyyy :'

[@rosesarenice8997]

I did!!

[@EternalSkyDreamer]

***** I guess something like that happened but since there were blue petals lying on the floor,Lady in Blue propably killed Garry..D:

[@cozmicjules]

oh my god. IM GONNA LOOK THIS TIME

[@kkyumiibear]

I noticed

[@learose989]

*You noticed and you feel depressed*

[@brandontherabboat4850]

You know, this actually touching in a creepy, twisted way.

[@SunMysts]

I REALLY want more information about Guertena. Mary is probably the most docile thing he's created in a way. She's like Pinochio. So she can only act human to an extent, living in an art gallery. I won't say she's outright evil. She was desperate to hold on to her friend(s) in any way she could. Even if she isnt human, that is very relatable. but how could Guertena even make these things come to life?

[@emmmmz]

When garry found out Mary's secret, the ears heard and told the lips, in which they told mary. The dolls did that hoping to drive him so insane he forgot about it.

[@Dracomut]

The perfect ending to make you lose all symphathy for Mary

[@fehix1196]

Together, Forever she’s a candy thief

[@Kingjaymes1234]

No, you can't after watching a paintings demise

[@d4rkpr1nc39]

You have to see it in her eyes: she's a painting. Therefore, morality isn't something she knows of, specially if she doesn't know who are dead and who aren't.

[@mellhurstg4148]

Just because she doesn’t understand they’re dead? Mary stayed with them here. Good girl :)

[@erisandrews911]

@Sarah Arnold The names for the bad endings are: Ib All Alone Together, Forever Welcome To The World Of Guertena. The Painting's Demise (There's one called A Forgotten Portrait, but I don't know much about it) Good endings: Memory's Crannies/Memory of A Fragment The Promise Of Reunion Ib All Alone: Garry dies when Mary takes his rose and returns Ib's, so Ib gets revenge and burns Mary's painting, thus killing her, and returns to her world. With both Garry and Mary turned to paintings, she forgets everything. Together, Forever: Garry dies, but before Ib can burn Mary(or she chooses not to) she returns home and forgets everything. However, Mary goes with her, and(though Ib does not notice anything unusual) lives with her forever as her sister. Creepy, right? Welcome To The World Of Guertena: Do I have to explain? :3 The Painting's Demise: May not be exactly accurate, but- Mary escapes without Ib and Garry(?) and wanders through the gallery in the real world, calling and searching for a way out. But as her heart is painted, she can't leave, as paintings belong in galleries. The screen gets darker and darker as she calls, so I can't determine exactly what happens after that. I assume she recreates the world Ib was sent to in the gallery to bring others to it, maybe hoping for a better ending? Not sure Forgotten Portrait: Similar to Ib All Alone, I think. I haven't gotten this one yet, so.. Just look it up? :33 Memory of a Fragment/Memory's Crannies: The second-best ending. One of the two better ones. Ib and Garry both escape, leaving Mary behind. Ib runs into Garry at the real gallery but remembers nothing. I don't like it because you get the feeling that everything Ib and Garry went through was for nothing, as she forgets it all anyway. I think the way to avoid this is to give Garry your handkerchief. The Promise of Reunion: Best Ending. Ib and Garry escape the hellish gallery and return to the normal one. Ib finds Garry examining a sculpture and talks to him. Garry is about to say farewell and part ways with her, and although she never introduced herself, he says "Goodbye, Ib," then stops short, asking if that's really her name. When Ib says yes, Garry finds the handkerchief with her name on it in his pocket and remembers everything, promising to see her again someday, and departing. Hope I helped? :33

[@staryumi2315]

Forgotten portrait is that you have to get the lighter and eat the candy after you burn Mary when you jump into the painting,Gary will be a painting called:Forgotten Potrait,the painting is in where the game started when Gary was standing in that position,last Ib keeps looking at the picture until Mum calls her,she keeps looking and looking at it,when mum calls her the second time,she followed her mum.

[@SaintCharlos]

_I think Together, Forever is a good ending._

[@vincikeeper1581]

I actually liked Together , Forever .

[@natiao3589]

You're wrong. In 'Ib all alone' variations Ib always stays in the cursed gallery, by: -following Fake Mother instead of following Garry when they find the Fabricated World painting, - following Fake Garry (when the real one is actually dead and Mary is burned) instead of jumping through the Fabricated World painting, -stepping away from that painting instead of trying to jump through it (Garry must be dead, we do not have to burns Mary's painting), -getting asleep forever, during a dream of her last birthday before she went to the art exhibit, on this bed-like thing in Dungeons [it's called 'Final Stage' or sth](v1.04). Plus, there's a fanmade ending ''Sacrafice''. In shortcut, in this ending, we can safe both Garry and Mary by sacraficing Ib.(GreenEdition).

[@Kingjaymes1234]

Together forever is literally the second best ending, then maybe memory crannies, and that is with taking this ending as them truly dying, my theory is that they become pretty much like Mary, and that they are just trapped there like Mary, Mary may be naive, but she is aware of death, which is why she wants to get rid of the lighter, it can kill her, and she thus knows of death, and why would she use that wording if they were dead, she wouldn't really have a reason to then

[@katiebeckhardt4973]

I think this ending really got to me . It made me like tear up because only Mary lives while Garry & Ib died . But the other ending where Garry dies made me cry too .

[@BlazeMaster]

I think I know why both Gary and IB ae dead the painting ladies love to pluck the rooses by playing love me love me not

[@SpiffyMario55]

Is it actually possible to hate someone's guts and still feel bad for them at the same time? Because my feelings towards Mary are rather *ahem* mixed, to say the least.

[@pocketmirrorarchive]

One of my favorite endings. Old Doll remix, saddening broken hearted Ib, Gary dead, the dolls and everything... Its amazing. We asked for an ending with Ib and Gary and Mary together, and we did! Just a super sad yet amazing ending. Great video, awesome ending.

[@blackpants7385]

Look at Ib's flower. She's no better than Garry like that.

[@Sylfrus]

OH MY GOD I KNEW I HEARD THAT MUSIC FROM SOMEWHERE! The music that plays when Mary walks into the room again!! That's Old Doll from Mad Father!!

[@ewaforevah]

She's a very complex character I know, but that's because you haven't much time to get attached to her. Now you can with this new updates. In A Painting Demise or when you talk to her... Oh I'm feeling so terribly sorry for her :( soo sad that you can't save Garry, Ib AND Mary...

[@makinru6178]

I hope there's a part 2 of this game. The good ending was The Promise of Reunion and it mentioned They'll see each other again! -I was thinking about the part 2 is that Ib is grown up and an artist (which she's inspired by Guertena)- Or maybe the Forgotten Painting which garry is trapped inside a painting and ib can't remember she has been together inside the gallery place. But she keeps remembering garry but cannot succeed to remember. She went to the Big painting Farbicated world and remembers a glimpse of him. She let herself in the painting and finding a way to save him. I really don't know much about the story though but it's just a try :p

[@Alice-fd4ln]

WHAIT A SECOND! Is that the "Old Doll" song from mad father? I am pretty fucking sure it is! What?

[@FlowerEmblem]

Ib and Mad Father both got the same OST from a free music source.

[@TheGamerGeek128]

Well... people wanted an ending where Ib, Garry, and Mary are together forever.

[@user-wl6gv3ke7u]

Mary : let’s have a welcoming party! Me : oh this might be nice, although Garry is insane and Ib kinda gave up but still there is a cha- Mary : Introducing my new friends,..... *Ib and Garry!* (showing a dead body of Ib and Garry) Me : Holy ~sht~

[@squares4u]

What is that horrible creature in the frame that climbs out to get Garry?!

[@brandontherabboat4850]

squares4u It's apparently called "Red Eyes".

[@meowdy6922]

That slow theme that plays makes it even more creepy

[@sjcrocker98]

In my opinion, as long as everybody is happy - it's a good ending.

[@ninan8985]

They look more dead instead of happy to me

[@sjcrocker98]

Hehehe...

[@ninan8985]

:)

[@sjcrocker98]

Sorry, mind kinda slipped their xD

[@nancybeltran8601]

Nah it's a happy ending. They're probably resting. They need sleep after their awesome welcome party! Of course they'd be tired. What's the point of having 2 dead bodies around? They'd stink up the place. The only reason this is a 'bad ending' is because they can't go to the real world.

[@Kagefake]

A creepy theory comes to my mind...in a bad ending, Garry dies and becames a paint, right? Well, in this ending, could Mary have killed Garry and Ib, hoping that both became paints (or another work of art), after dead? Maybe that "forever" means something like this...

[@cassandrabelyeu2419]

Maybe that's why they're lying there with mostly intact flowers, but not moving. She could be protecting the flowers from getting damaged, but deliberately letting them wilt, so Garry and Ib act sort of...wilted. I wonder if they'd become paintings if she dried the flowers and put them in a box. They'd be preserved that way.

[@abbiesullivan8804]

I heard the music speed up and I was like "OH CRAP!!!"

[@ViewtifulShishigami]

This is a nightmare, forget bad ending, this is nightmare fuel creepy ending T.T

[@aiueaaa]

Mary's Happy End

[@shadesnow5357]

at the end,is gary and ib dead? if so,mary is 100% innocent if not,shes still innocent

[@Starlight-Tale]

Well, she gave the blue rose to the blue painting lady, didn't she? So not really

[@waltergilman2969]

Welcome to the World of Guertena 😭😭😭😭😭😭🔥🔥🔥👍👍👍

[@ShmewyyShmew]

This is what I think about this ending. Mary wanted to get out soo bad but she couldnt unless one of them stayed behind (Or died). Since Ib was here first friend she ever made she wanted Gary to stay behind. When Gary became like this Ib wanted to be by his side, since he was always by her side. Mary saw this and thought, even if Gary stays, Ib would still want to go. When she saw she didnt, she stayed with her because she didnt care if she went outside or not because all she wanted was a friend

[@lancewehadabondingmoment6517]

i love this version of old doll, even tho it ain’t that different its more rustic and creepy

[@xmichimiyux1960]

When Mary said, "Foreeever!" I thought of Spongebob saying, "FOREVER." over and over in that one episode. .-.

[@mikuappendver1086]

same

[@ThePikachuKingRJ]

One Eternity Later...

[@TeamRose789]

"Welcome to the World" of Guertena makes me hate Mary. "A Painting's Demise" makes me feel REAL sorry for Mary. Anyone had the same impression?

[@MorinoEdits]

This is most likely the most creepiest ending to a video game yet. I actually like the idea that the game was re-vamped to be much creepy and darker than the original, and this was an interesting ending. The creator did a wonderful job of giving a chilling sensation to the audience.

[@awesomesauce6787]

well, im glad im on thanksgiving break. because its not like i need sleep after seeing THIS

[@yinichigo]

that doll in the painting is going to give me serious nightmares for some unknown reasons.....

[@Sinister_moonlight]

Wish there was an ending like when Garry is dying and Ib stays with him. Like that Fan made ending. Where they become a beautiful painting togheter.

[@HissinSpit]

Of course I decided to watch this right before bed. I'll have such sweet dreams tonight for sure!

[@ceciliamichaelis7866]

((My sister texted me "I'm MAAAAAAAAARY!" from her friend's phone once. I screamed and ran away.))

[@musicbunny29]

I suppose they are still alive in that one particular scene (though just barely), but you can assume they won't be after the paintings and statues are done with the roses.

[@WonderingCarly]

Man it's been awhile since I seen this game only for it to appear in my recommendations

[@darrelsam419]

This ending is even sadder and more disturbing that all the older endings. O.o

[@Kingjaymes1234]

And then there is a painting's demise

[@warmnoodlez]

Man, I thought it was really heavy, they stayed there forever and mary became a psychopath :(

[@wotarosensei7273]

I cried like a little girl…

[@AAAAAAAARRGHH]

Geez what an disturbing end, and then this perfect fitting, insane music... >_@ im so glad i got the good end^^

[@sip9124]

a painting's demise requires making mary angry by not talking to her for a while.

[@dianeguay7618]

Does anyone realise that old doll in imstrumental starts playing?

[@ibthaawesome8365]

+Admin and the countries! :D Eveyone did...

[@dianeguay7618]

Oh...

[@thaodinh04041977]

I did!

[@8man_]

I though Mary didn't want them dead but she fed their roses to the lady in red and the lady in blue

[@emmaruddat538]

The music for this ending is used in both Ib and Mad Father.

[@minerofskies2451]

Mad Father is made by Sen and Ib is made by Kouri. The reason this particular track is similar in both games is because creators used the same website that offers free BG music.

[@michellenguyen5043]

Garry was in the doll room from his point of view everything are dolls which is true. But for Ib everything was bunnies :/ she was hallucinating

[@zenom182]

It's Old Doll. It plays in the carrie careless too, but now it's in the music folder too

[@minerofskies2451]

Actually, as long as you follow the requirements (boosting your doom level, boosting your bond level with Mary and keeping your bond level with Garry as low as possible) to get this ending, it doesn't matter which option you choose to address Garry. : )

[@ascellaraph]

It's called Old Doll (or Old Puppet) from the Carrie Careless Storybook and played in Mad Father as well. It's so sweeet~

[@siennaespinosa5954]

Yeah, the Lady in Blue is holding Garry's blue rose (maybe she's playing with it? Loves me Loves me not) and Ib's red rose is on the ground (maybe slowly withering)

[@the-crimson-echo]

Is it bad that this is my favorite ending...?

[@minerofskies2451]

It's my favourite as well..

[@the-crimson-echo]

Rayan Fakih Good, just checking.

[@MarioKartWiiGamer]

well, i dont know how you prefer Garry and Ib to be trapped in this world and becoming insane over Promise of Reunion for example? you could argue that three are all together and noone is left behind but the only ones that seem happy about this are Mary and the Creepydolls

[@myancienttrashpile]

Marvin G. i think its the creepiness we like. like of course promise of reunion is cute and all, but this one was so creepy you can help not liking it.

[@the-crimson-echo]

Exylnn Someone sees my point.

[@astaraelsget]

It's like a Nick Jr. show from Hell....

[@doveykinsss3337]

*if Sans were in the problem that Garry was having* Sans: why is there a doll coming out of the painting? *slowly the doll comes out of the painting with each bell, making the room grow dark, darker, yet darker* Papyrus: WHY IS IT SO DARK ALL OF A SUDDEN?! Sans: I dont know what your talking- *the doll is almost out of the painting, its face right in front of the 2 brothers* Sans: oh... *the room is now blinding the brothers with a red light, their screams are heard* me: OK! WHO HURT MY SUNSHINE AND HIS BROTHER?!

[@kaykay-chan3689]

I heard the mad father old doll song in here I love it I feel that it fits perfectly in this scenario.

[@Call0045]

Well IB always used this song, see the puppet show cutscene.

[@3neelh]

My friend was trying for a new ending and we got A Painting's Demise. I'm glad she didn't let me watch this when this game still terrified me.

[@musicbunny29]

You can kind of guess that they end up dying though, their roses being with the statues and paintings and all.

[@blindga]

Bittersweet ending. Garry got possessed, Ib lost the will to live, and Mary trapped them both in the painted world; resigning to the fact that she herself will never realize her dream of going outside. At the very least they can all live together from now on, or at least for a few minutes before the monsters destroy Ib and Garry.

[@Kingjaymes1234]

No, the other paintings are like family to Mary, i don't think they would do that because it would make Mary sad

[@DisillusionStarFruit]

There. That's the happy ending you all wanted with the three of them. I just wish it didn't look like they died....

[@KokekokeKokekokko]

Okay, maybe they're not dead, just unconcious. But still, that's just mean they are dead inside ('the disease unto death', called despair)

[@amancastillo6104]

This ending was more of a creepy ending in my opinion.

[@santiclausi7184]

WHAAAAAA! it's so creepy that I wanna cry!!!

[@pocketchia374]

The music at the end... I need it.

[@FwippyFwop]

+Ginger The Espeon "Old Doll" From Mad Father

[@TheForrestHump]

You need to make sure your affection point with Gary is as low as possible along with breaking as many things as possible. Then: If your affection point with Mary is low, you get A painting's demise or otherwise, this ending

[@AngeliqueNade]

From the looks of their roses lying around, being that a Blue Lady had Garry's and a Red Rose is wilted in front of Ib, I'd say yes. As for why, who knows? One of those twisted ideas of thinking lifeless bodies can still be good friends I guess.

[@pieguy254]

breaks my heart for garry, watching this

[@leafydahon]

And you know when shit gets real when Mad Father OSTs start playing ;w;

[@LegionOfMany112]

Garry is insane, his mind cracked beyond repair, driven deep into the abyss of insanity. Mary is fucking insane in the first place Ib is depressed to the point of not giving a fuck and becomes a vegetable. BEST ENDING

[@musicbunny29]

I would assume the paintings and statues would destroy their roses, eventually killing Ib and Garry. But it's nice to be optomistic :L

[@Greninjaslash]

Why am i watching this video. This is so sad!

[@kafei-creme]

I can't manage to have it, Ib automatically slaps Garry even if I increased his doom counter and have a good bond with Mary...

[@saraharnold7687]

This ending has really got that creepy sense to it!

[@DetectiveNyx]

It's not from either. Both tracks were in the public domain on a website.

[@Kaitn13]

I totally agree. If we only knew a bit more about the way that world works...

[@polo7789]

Best ending, everyone is happy and together.

[@TheCosmicDiamond]

OLD DOLL IN THE ENDING

[@cloudsumaya]

I miss Ib I want to play it again ..Garry 💙😭

[@sofii9260]

hi, excuse me! do you have the link for download of this version? the vgperson's translation has a font which is very hard to read, and i'm still learning english :(

[@BakOnYou]

i actually love that ending o_o. Mary isn't alone, Garry and Ib are together! xD

[@caramelpie9782]

i love how yandere mary's face at 10:17

[@hibariXlove]

I'm not sure about this ending... But it is a bad ending indeed. If you look closely at the ending picture there is lb, basically lying on the ground like lifeless doll and her rose is seen right in front of her with a little petal. Since Mary already took one of her petal in the beginning, if you checked she only have 5 petal, and two more is next to the Mary so I'm guessing that the rose has been damaged to much as to make her unconscious like Gary in the beginning of the game. Now, for Gary, he was insane because of the creepy blue dolls so even though he might be better situated at the moment.. I doubt he will last long since the blue lady in the painting is holding his rose and some of his petal has been torn out already as well. So if Mary keep on 'playing' with lb and Gary they will soon go to 'sleep' and maybe they'll be a 'forgotten portrait' from the outside world? ..But I'm so glad I found this ending because this is such a great game and I'm so sad that there isn't an ending where everyone leave!

[@AnalysisMaster]

It's hard to say if Ib and Garry are dead or still catatonic at that point, but even if they were still alive they wouldn't have long to live anyway.

[@Sylfrus]

Well, take into context the music that was playing. Perhaps they're not dead. Perhaps they've simply been turned into mere dolls. Mary's playthings. After all, Mary interacts with them as if they are alive yet it's clear that they're not moving. Similar to what a child would do with a doll. Maybe, in time, Ib and Garry will turn into a blue doll. Maybe all of those blue dolls are in fact other people who succumbed to this world before them. Fuck I think I just partially blew my own mind.

[@maddiewilliams9377]

Am I the only one who would consider this a "Good Ending"? I also consider "Together Forever" a good ending.

[@Deathbydietcola]

I Actually Love This Ending...

[@Animefreakee]

They're not dead; both of their roses have most of their petals, so they're just unconscious... the Lady in Blue isn't even plucking off Garry's petals. Ib still has her rose. I think Mary just wanted to keep them like that (unconscious) to keep them from running away. You know, in case Garry ever snapped out of it, or if Ib regained the will to live. Or both. Then they would leave. And Mary, well, she wouldn't like that... she wouldn't want to let both of her "friends" leave again...

[@michellenguyen5043]

omg the music near the end is from Old Doll from Mad Father

[@nonkapu]

I think they are dead, or atleast unconsious because near the end, you can see how Garry's and Ib's rose pettels are thorn from the rose itself.

[@QuintaFeira12]

She wants to become alive by taking someone's life as her own. She's no more alive at the end of this than she was before.

[@snowlondon8642]

I'm not a fan of the dark endings, but I do like the sad ones (Like Memories' Crannies, Ib All Alone and Forgotten Portrait)

[@minerofskies2451]

Her rose, along with Garry's, still have some petals left.

[@animefreak3972]

Omg the song at the end was from mad father and it was called old doll it was from the bad ending

[@renrenrenrenrenrenrenrenrenren]

I think the Ladies might have gotten to their roses... you can see the Lady in Blue holding Garry's..

[@shiverkittens]

Actually, there is. In one of the 'Ib all Alone' endings, you and Garry both make it to the portrait, Garry jumps in and then your 'mother' shows up. They both urge you to go with them. Depending on the choice (Go with mom or jump in painting w/ Garry) you get a different ending.

[@Adamskaish]

See Mary, you don't need art for friends, you have KZbin!