TØP Fan Listens To Tally Hall For The First Time | Justin Listens To

[@JLAnderson_Music]

Hey! By popular demand, we did a part 2: kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4mthaWfgMp0iLs

[@Fnaf_weekly]

We need you to listen to two wuv, it really slaps (tally hall)

[@BanAnna_AGC]

If you like a tally hall song.... There is no turning back.

[@Protonyx]

Never meant to know, 13 + ruler of everything, spring and a storm, and “&” are my favorites

[@StarStormz_]

YOU ARE SO RIGHT YOU ARE SO CORRECT THIS IS THE COMMENT EVER

[@somerandomkickball]

This but turn the lights off instead of spring and a storm

[@Manich_21]

hey ruler of everything is just one of the best songs, like turn the light off

[@LemonAid_osc]

Good day

[@A-6flicks]

SAME SO ACCURATE

[@ilikecatsandtos2]

Fun fact, Turn The Lights Off is about the fears and challenges of puberty. The girl turning into a monster is a symbol of his first sexual thought, and him becoming a monster symbolises hair growing in unknown places.

[@bealea1127]

It is!

[@user-h720]

Oh, so that's why the rollercoaster cart looked like a p...

[@everythingpizzaandknuckles6268]

Fun fact about The Bidding: The song is written in A Minor, but after the 2nd chorus switches to A Major

[@greenbeanbanshee]

It was written in a minor???

[@pebblbead9970]

​@@greenbeanbanshee Man, everyone is using something to write nowadays, just write it on paper! 😤😤😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨 /s

[@THE_funnyalt]

@@greenbeanbansheeyou don’t write in minors?

[@mategetsnosleep3612]

I was wondering when it would change but it was very obvious.

[@KARLMARTIN8595]

@@THE_funnyalt out of context is crazy

[@ombrezz7030]

11:33 wow that was the perfect pause

[@floppy_the_froggo]

“Out in the twilight” is my favorite song by them it’s just so perfect

[@sbubbt2318]

out in the twilight

[@floppy_the_froggo]

@@sbubbt2318 oops

[@L3_cHat]

Same it’s just so good

[@grayanddevpdx]

You should listen to Miracle Musical. Four of the five guys who were in Tally Hall created Miracle Musical, and it sounds like a more modern and slightly darker version of the stuff they do here.

[@soulovenn]

Oh, If you love Tally Hall you should give Chonny Jash a listen, he covers loads of Tally Hall music and Miracle Musical music (YOU ALSO NEED TO LOSTEN TO MIRACLE MUSIC IF YOU HAVEN’T)

[@NTotallynotme]

Wow. Didnt expect you to listen to my favorite band. The people on the band has made other things after it went on hiatus (the hiatus never stopped) like the band miracle musical which has the entire band except one of them. they made Hawaii part II and it is an experience on top of being my favorite tally hall related thing. Rob canter (the main singer) made two songs (shia labeouf live and Christian bale is at your party) on top of making the album not a trampoline. Joe hawley (the guy Who made some of the more experimental songs and Hawaii part II) also made an album called Joe hawley Joe hawley.

[@TypoRaccoon]

Andrew also made sketches 3d

[@twelftheagle3043]

And Ross made a lil somthin

[@tom-on]

​@@twelftheagle3043and got a PhD

[@twelftheagle3043]

True ​@@tom-on

[@kiwiz8154]

If you end up liking tally hall you should listen to the miracle musical, I love it even more than tally hall and the lead singer is the singer from tally hall. It is even more of an acid trip, but more 50s like playing in the sand exept for one

[@amukhrai2263]

So in 5:21 if we reverse it,it says "Wouldn't the world be better if we took nonsense more seriously?" Like Damn

[@H34RTSF0R_SAM]

Wouldn’t the world be better off if we took nonsense more seriously?: ❌ Ylsouires erom esnesnon koot ew fi ffo retteb eb dlrow eht t’ndluoW?: ✅

[@Snam___69]

YES! If you want to listen to more tally hall please listen to 1-13 + ruler of everything (13 is the intro for ruler of everything) 2-hymn for a scarecrow 3-& 4-fate of the stars

[@LynnDIsaster]

YESSSSSSSSSSSSS

[@Extremelysloppyproductions]

Well hello there

[@Snam___69]

@@Extremelysloppyproductionshello as well

[@LemonPartII]

@@Snam___69also hello

[@Snam___69]

@@LemonPartIIhello why is everyone here lmao

[@HoneyAnimates]

If you do listen to tally hall again I suggest Cannibal, Ruler of Everything, Hymn for a Scarecrow, Taken for a Ride, and The Whole World and You! :)

[@asherrives]

Spring and a storm is one of my favorite songs of all time. Totally stoked to see you listening to them!

[@v69alix]

same! Spring and Storm as well as Never Meant to Know are some of my favorite songs of all time

[@candy_shark]

SPRING AND A STORM!!! I LOVE THAT ONE ITS MY FAVORITE!!!

[@esperscornerofyt]

I never hear people talk about spring and a storm or misery fell (they both popped in my KZbin recommended playlist and I am hooked)

[@roseanimates6225]

mfw one time i tried to sing

[@v69alix]

@@roseanimates6225 mfw about spring and a storm

[@candy_shark]

SEEING SOMEONE LISTENING TO MY FAVORITE BAND FOR THE FIRST TIME AND LIKING IT IS SO COOL TO ME 🎉🎉

[@pizzarellayt]

Glad you enjoyed! I think why they're so good at harmonies is because they're Beatles fans, especially Joe (red tie). Could you add Red Vox to the list? They're not too well known outside of Spotify plays, but I think you'd love them if you like psychedelic stuff.

[@yelrabmena1]

if you liked Tally Hall i recommend listening to Miracle Musical, a side project made by Joe Hawley which includes 4/5 of the original tally hall members (including Joe himself)

[@Hiushisan]

I highly recommend the music video for Tally Hall's song Banana Man. It is delightfully cursed :)

[@martalemos7187]

There’s an artist called BLUNDER that maybe you’ ll enjoy! He’s not very famous but he makes great music:) if you do listen to him don’t listen to the top 3 since it’s with another person but listen to his songs he did on his own!:)))

[@scrunkliestscrimbo9981]

Tally hall is one of my favorites! I heavily recommend listening to the song "Never meant to know" Because it's really good imo

[@LynnDIsaster]

Recommendation: Fate of The Starts - Tally Hall Also, the 2019 single was made in 2008esc

[@LynnDIsaster]

(I Know) It's Just The Same Too!

[@bealea1127]

&, The Bidding, and Turn the lights off are my favorites.

[@StuffyStars]

I love Hymn for a scarecrow ,a lady ,fate of the stars,rule of everything ,& two wuv (there basically all my favs other THAN be born) (I’m a big fan of them & they’re side projects) It’s also funny how Joe was the lead singer for the songs he listened to (I’m 99% sure)

[@candy_shark]

YESS!!!! SO GLAD YOU ENJOYED MY FAVORITE BAND EVER!!!!!!!

[@SeanyboiVR]

Ruler of everything, &, turn the lights off, and. Good day. Are my favorite tally hall songs

[@sheedays]

I highly recommend Ruler of Everything, Spring and a Storm, Hymn for a Scarecrow, Fate of the Stars and & (ps: 13 is an opening to ruler of everything so listen to that before, it’s only 13 seconds long (and the 13th track on the album))

[@Spamtonthedude_]

He should also listen to the whole world and you

[@kween4aday]

two wuv, welcome to tally hall, ruler of everything, cannibal, and hymn for a scarecrow are all really good

[@valleyofghouls]

i’m reading through the list right now and seeing ghost made me so excited! i cant wait until you react to them, like many others you might end up falling down the ghost rabbit hole (it’s great i just cant escape) but honestly discovering ghost is honestly one of the best things that’s happened to me 😭

[@valleyofghouls]

also excited for gojira, muse, mastodon and lorna shore :))

[@ilikecatsandtos2]

Love Tally Hall. Try Miracle Musical next!

[@KARLMARTIN8595]

Mainly, i heard out from Jack Stauber, but i had now gotten into tally hall, and now im in for tally hall (i also keep track of jack stauber)

[@Biggestsmalldeal]

the way they combine the guitar with the synth piano just sounds magical

[@manhap9754]

woahhhh super neat to see you checking tally hall out!! i’ve been a fan of tally hall for YEARS now and they’re definitely up there in my favorite bands lol. i absolutely recommend checking out more of their music, especially ruler of everything, &, hymn for a scarecrow, and the trap! also, if you end up enjoying tally hall, i STRONGLY recommend checking out miracle musical, which is an album one of the members did as a solo project that is easily one of my favorite albums of all time!! also also, you’d prolly like the band rainbow kitten surprise, and dear and the headlights!! both of them are two of my favorite bands of all time and they have a really neat style of music, very indie/folk/rock ^^ anyway, great video!! thanks for checking tally hall out, and if u end up checking out more of their stuff i hope you enjoy!

[@mintsuper_cat]

Hey man i HEAVILY recommend that you listen to mircale musical's album "Hawaii part II" including their hidden song "variations on a cloud" and tally hall member joe hawley helped make this album and it has great music and lore which had built its own fandom without trying

[@dunewind]

WAH YOU FIANLLY GOT LOS CAMPESINOS AMAZING I would suggest Avocado, Baby as a song rec! If you've enjoyed Tally Hall, try Miracle Musical, theyre a band consisting of Tally Hall members 👍I would suggest listening to their only album at whole at some point if you enjoy it, because it has an overarching story. And listen to more Tally Hall!!

[@theai_1]

Next you just need to listen to Chonny Jash's covers of these songs (other than Turn the lights off, he hasnt covered that one yet)

[@greenfromrainbowfriends1528]

chonny jash jumpscae

[@sentrosity9176]

He’s kinda mid tho

[@greenfromrainbowfriends1528]

@@sentrosity9176 YOU'RE kinda mid. /nsrs

[@ItzGoofyOliver]

for crywank you absolutely NEED to listrn to Privately Owned Spiral Galaxy, Lovejoy actually made a cover of this song and Wilbur covered the song quite alot on streams as well

[@jesterlenore1475]

Omg yes that's my favorite song by themm

[@Bytheway-2004]

Do Out in the twilight Welcome to tally hall Ruler of everything & Thanks!

[@JLAnderson_Music]

Did 3 out of those 4 in the part 2!

[@Bytheway-2004]

@@JLAnderson_Music ok!

[@chefalamode3182]

More Tally Hall would be amazing! I'd recommend these: 13 + Ruler of Everything (13 is basically an intro) & Banana Man They also worked on a side project called Hawaii Part II which is a concept album released under the name ミラクルミュージカル (Miracle Musical). I'd highly recommend it if you haven't seen it. I'd recommend these from it: Black Rainbows Murders (POPULAR TIKTOK AUDIO) Time Machine Dream Sweet in Sea Major Variations on A Cloud (a single that has musical aspects of Hawaii Part II and other Tally Hall music)

[@mothknight7050]

Sorry if this comment sent twice but you definitely should listen to the crane wives!! They have very vibey music and unique chords and instrumentals, plus their two vocalists have super powerful voices and the messages of their songs are very interesting and cool!! I haven't seen any channel like this listen to them and I'd love to see your take especially on their chords and stuff

[@JLAnderson_Music]

They are on the list!

[@dpert7299]

I am a big fan of the crane wives!! 😄it's amazing to find other fans

[@stitchgor3]

@@JLAnderson_Musicooo yay!

[@MarcyTheKindaCoolWizard]

i adore seeing people react to music i love and see them just nejoy themselves so much! If you are interested, once oyu've listened to most Tally Hall, i HIGHLY recommend Chonny Jash's "covers" of Tally Halls songs, plus his original album "The Gothic Whre or The Lyric Hunt"!

[@oliver_garden1355]

If you don’t have it on you list (and I’m sorry because it’s already a big list!) you should do Rufus Wainwright! I absolutely adore his song Peaceful Afternoon. ALSO! Miracle Musical is also Talky Hall, it’s just a different project. I also recommend that! Can’t wait to finish this video! (Sorry for the long comment😅)

[@Dry_Bones_Stan_]

you should listen to miracle musical, theyre an offshoot of tally hall who have made an album which is my personal favourite akbum of all time its ge uienly so good, id reccomend you listen to the entire album since uts meant to be listened that way, great video

[@sinistermrz]

WOW my favorite band!!! If you are interested in more of their artwork (actually less popular but they are like hidden gems) i'd recommend listening to Cannibal, Fate of the Stars and songs from their demo albums. Many of the band members actually have their own solo projects and did collab after Tally Hall (for Miracle Musical and solo projects), wich are very good too!!

[@Rayney_Day1]

I love tally hall sm and I agree with you full heartedly. I cant wait for lemon demon to be selected :D

[@IsabellaHall-d6h]

The way you reacted to hearing each song, the head bopping, the analysis, it made me feel like i was listening to the songs for the first time again with you. Great video. Glad you liked the music!! Tally Hall is my fav band rn.

[@Miles-i1q]

AHHH as a tally hall fan, I recommend a more popular song of theres, “The ruler of everything” which I feel like encapsulates the band fairly well and sort of matches the vibe of most of their songs.

[@joshkorte9020]

Now that he's done Tally Hall, he needs to do Mirical Musical

[@gvnlessktchn]

hiii!! i absolutely adore tally hall and it’s always rlly cool to see people’s reactions to their music! here are a few of my recommendations if you wanna listen to more :D - greener (MY ABSOLUTE FAVORITE, super underrated) - welcome to tally hall (serves as an intro to the band so it’s good if you’re interested in learning more abt the members) - two wuv (not much to say abt this one, it just slaps) - haiku (another really underrated one, the little comments from the audience make me laugh every time and the meter of the lyrics is really cool imo) - 13 + ruler of everything (ruler of everything is an absolute classic, and 13 serves as a sort of intro to it) - never meant to know (again not much to say abt this one) - & (one of my favorites, there’s just smth abt the vocals that makes me happy) - cannibal (such a bop, not much else to say abt it lmao) if you wanna narrow that down to a few songs my absolute top picks out of those are greener, welcome to tally hall, ruler of everything, and cannibal :D

[@jackc4978]

The strokes, they go absolutely insane

[@Mack10011]

it made me happy seeing how happy you got during the bidding. idk your channel, this is the first video i've seen of it, but it's amazing to see how much joy someone can get from a simple song :)

[@mvvictorvm]

If you really enjoy tally hall, I'd also recommend Miracle Musical which includes some members from tally hall

[@NathanBadger-m8p]

0:47 I LIKE TO SAY HELLO-

[@ThatMoonShroom]

The song "&" by them is AMAZING

[@inconnn]

you should listen to the album hawaii part ii it's a project mainly by one of the people in tally hall and i think a few others in the band also joined in. it's super good imo tho u should listen to it all in one session. it doesn't make as much sense if you just listen to one song.

[@jharuldsmythe]

the bidding is absolutely incredible, but now i cant unhear the edit called "Cardboard Box" which i highly recommend as well, its so damn funny

[@gamersgambit7517]

Welcome to Tally Hall! A statement, greeting, and a song suggestion!

[@stitchgor3]

Even tho it’s cliche the bidding is deff my fave tally hall song lol! If you didn’t know, a few of the members have a side band called Hawaii pt ii was INTENSE lore and crazy music

[@endymonyt4268]

if you like Tally Hall you might like Chonny jash who has done covers of Tally Hall but also a lot of his own stuff.

[@delculture]

do will wood !!!! i recommend laplace's angel, love me normally, and thermodynamic lawyer !!

[@Soda_Fizzy]

Welcome to Tally Hall and Good Day were my first introduction to Tally hall, so that would be a good few songs to listen to.

[@nathangood3120]

Banana man got me into Tally Hall and I don’t regret being a really big fan

[@pillblenderyaoi]

MISERY FELL AND CANNIBAL ARE MY FAVORITES THEIR SO DJDJDJDJDNDN /VPOS

[@hylark4091]

This is so good, I’m definitely gonna check some more of them out You should also add Legbone to your list of music! It’s a tiny punk band that absolutely rocks

[@norm_selling]

If you're taking any suggestions for the wheel and you enjoyed tally hall then i suggest Hawaii pt.2 (more specifically "dream sweet in sea major" "time machine" and "variations on a cloud") and chonny jash (more specifically, if you can fit it in one vid "the heart acoustic, the mind electric, the soul electric" "welcome to tally hall" "ruler of everything" or "ain't no rest for the wicked")

[@foxxboi1]

I would like to see you listen to the hawaii part ii album (a side project from some of the members of tally hall)

[@fyreice3697]

Oh I love to see how much you enjoyed these, smiled through the whole video. Thanks for sharing!! :D I love tally hall

[@Dr._Geno]

if you want more, check out some of the other projects form the band members, my two favorites are miracle musical, and joe hawley, though those are not everything, at all. edit: I'm not sure, but I think it was MTV that said it best, Tally Hall is like Queen meets The Beatles meets Weezer.

[@pizzashits]

The Bidding is torture everytime i listen to it but only bc I remember seeing a really fucking good edit on tiktok a while ago that used this song and i cant find it anymore. I cant even remember what the edit was of for the life of me (some sort of anime i think?), but i just remember it was absolute peak. (Edit: IT WAS FUCKING FNAF!!!! AND YEA ITS GOOD, ITS BY nightmarishtongue)

[@floppedpieface3881]

You should definately add greta van fleet to the list they are amazing

[@JLAnderson_Music]

Saw them live when I saw metallica and my girlfriend loves them, so they do not qualify for the series

[@floppedpieface3881]

@@JLAnderson_Music That's really cool to hear!

[@LoganWasHere224]

I love both artists

[@Gardentheater1507]

I highly recommend Chonny Jash's cover/remix of The Bidding

[@waltzinbmajor]

listen to joe hawley!!!! he's a member of tally hall and also has his own album called joe hawley joe hawley!!!

[@feddyfazdaddy]

i love this guy so much your my best friend now

[@heyitsuhhh306]

If you haven't already, I recommend Will Wood (and the Tapeworms)!

[@goofyness]

u should check the bidding 2006 version, it sounds much more aggressive and dynamic and the guitar in the end kinda strikes

[@rat-princess]

11:30 pauses right before the drop is def gonna get him taken for a ride

[@ironpiyepic2666]

Tally hall is weird, especially since each member of the band has made albums and has their own spunk. The thing with their band is it is definitely a grab bag of different types of music so selecting a few songs really doesn't show their potential

[@speeri726]

Would love to hear your thoughts on Supertramp, especially their album Crisis? What Crisis?". Love the react content! Keep it up!

[@Ihaveabasicname]

Please look into Aidan Swift, I love his music and have for many months now and is SUPER underrated.

[@Yodoggie_]

Could you put Will Wood on the wheel? also for more tally hall listen to ruler of everything, banana man, and &, those are some of my favorite songs

[@JLAnderson_Music]

On the list already!

[@Yodoggie_]

@@JLAnderson_Music ah ok cool

[@p1xelat3d]

Tally hall is one of the most well documented bands of all time That's why finding die hard fans of them and their solo projects is surprisingly easy

[@Kamisokei]

I highly urge you to listen to Miracle Musical/Hawaii: Part I I which is made by 5/6 of the people on Tally Hall!

[@DripssopGaming]

listen to hawaii part II

[@haileykendall4336]

add the wrecks! i love them!

[@thumpi]

You should def listen to Hawaii: Part II by Miracle Musical in its entirety

[@justsomeguy6110]

If you want to listen to more Tally HallI think you should listen to "Welcome to Tally Hall" Edit: I should probably say that the music vid plays a shortened version of the og song

[@montrix_GD]

him complimenting a song while the video is an absolute pandemonium in hidden in the sand had me unironically laughing for some reason

[@misteruncanny]

Cant wait for Gorillaz

[@tidectrl]

try chonny jash he made tally hall covers but also doesnt other covers and originals

[@JLAnderson_Music]

On the list

[@roxepy7618]

dont know if youre still taking suggestions... butttt ifffff... PLEASEEEE LISTEN TOOOO 'Car Seat Headrest"

[@Dynonekus]

Personally, I'd recommend Welcome to Tally Hall Cannibal &

[@cheesecheese6459]

good stuff mate

[@kewlusername]

16:08 the bidding reference?

[@stitchgor3]

Love tally hall:)

[@SteamedPoi]

Hey, if you want to you could check out Will Wood. He makes a large variety of music and pretty much all his albums are different, i dunno his music is just fun

[@JLAnderson_Music]

On the list!

[@SteamedPoi]

@@JLAnderson_Music

[@willyoustay]

have you listened to Streetlight manifesto? amazing band

[@Dreameraw]

Please listen to hawaii part 2

[@zkeorys]

You should react to Miracle Musical's Hawaii Part II.