Ibn Khaldun, the Historiographer

[@CaspianReport]

Great video! Would you be interested in a collaboration ?

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Hey, man! Thank you for writing. Big fan of your videos. Sure, what do you have in mind?

[@iraqimapper8625]

Can't wait the master piece you guys will make :)

[@Solon1581]

Now THIS is a crossover I'd like to see.

[@Omegaeon1]

This would be awesome

[@alexandrub8786]

*Top 10 crossover in anime*

[@MythologywithMike]

I'm studying history in college and we talk a lot about some of the early historians like Herodotus and Thucydides. It's interesting to hear about historians from the Muslim world and how they shaped our modern view. Great video man!

[@chiron14pl]

I'm working my way through Ibn Khaldun's "Muqaddimah" and find it excellent and truly the origin of modern historiography.

[@tale.whisperer]

I just placed an order for the book on Amazon and I am really excited!

[@servantoftheexpander9688]

He also founded sociology and he mostly talks about sociology in muqadimmah and it's really fascinating.

[@chiron14pl]

@@servantoftheexpander9688 Yes, he's truly a scholar who anticipated so much of our modern approach. I highly respect him

[@Diego-zz1df]

I bought it after hearing about what a great book it was, but the first time I read it thought it wasn't that interesting or impressive. That was a few years ago, before I developed an interest in medieval history, particularly focusing on the Byzantine Empire and the Mediterranean world. So I picked it up again, am currently through a 2nd read and NOW I get what the hype is all about. Kinda feel like a total fool for dropping it in the first place, but having some knowledge of medieval history and culture really lets you appreciate the significance of Ibn Jaldun's work, it's scope and depth. It also contributes to clearing up misconceptions about medieval thought and culture.

[@np5229]

4:58 Timur: *Exists* Al Muqaddimah: *Anger*

[@ZhiHinFong]

Fr

[@aminator1]

Im learning so much from this channel, that quote from Ibn Khaldun's book was so wise. Thank you

[@sheesmustafa9522]

I am currently reading Al muqadima and it's a masterpiece

[@irfanifteqarali5388]

👍

[@Abdullah-Md]

Are you reading hardcopy book or online pdf?

[@manetho5134]

A video about Ibn Battuta and his travels would be amazing

[@omerkeremtastepe2271]

Dude why dont you have a million subs your content is gold worth.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Because the world sucks. T_T

[@Peristerygr]

Because he has apostate prophet attached so many ignorants go there and assume that this channel is a world taqiya masonic conspiracy! Yes masons are muslims promoting the idea that they are jews. Blaming the jews and covering tracks in one ;).

[@daimon7421]

@@Peristerygr what the actual fuck

[@SeptimiusAfer240]

Great video. I hope that you will talk about his various roles in the politics of North Africa and Andalus. Ramadan Mubarak from Tunis.

[@kareemtheeb1478]

What a name. Aksel ben salama😂😂😂. How did you combined both of them together?.

[@al-muwaffaq341]

Can you make a video about ibn Batutta

[@bereftspud279]

Great video as always! Always good to see Islamic history covererd!

[@sheikjamal786]

Thanks!

[@tusharbhosale599]

This is such an awesome video. Great going....

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Thanks, man! :)

[@Omegaeon1]

Greetings from Al Djazair « Algeria » 🇩🇿 :) I’m berber.

[@Abdoabdo-ix7ds]

Love from libya😍😍😍 🇱🇾🇱🇾🇱🇾🇱🇾 I am arab😍😍😍 berber and arab are brother

[@Abdoabdo-ix7ds]

Love from libya😍😍😍 🇱🇾🇱🇾🇱🇾🇱🇾 I am arab😍😍😍 berber and arab are brother

[@overmanonfire]

Greetings from Saudi to the the brothers

[@theballroom98yearsago51]

A race doesn’t matter

[@funandfun-xy4ez]

We say Dzair bro

[@Aisha-tb9ye]

Keep up the good work ! I’ve been looking for a channel that does videos on Islamic history for awhile now and your quality of content is great.

[@Artur_M.]

Timur the Jerkass. :) Seriously though, great video! Very interesting topic and excellently presented. The detail I love the most might be that little animated timeline at the top.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Aw! You made me bring it back. I had actually deleted it from the next video because I didn't think people found it that useful.

[@Artur_M.]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT Thank you for replying! I hope I'm not the only one who likes it.

[@Btgaoi]

I love videos on philosophers and their works..we need to hold intellectual part of Islam very strongly now.

[@aaronlink1032]

Great content & presentation Just one small observation ... The castle showed in 3:10 isn't in Frenda as mentioned .. It is the the Santa Cruz Forteresse .. in Oran about 150 km North of Frenda

[@AncientAccounts]

So he's like herotdus mixed with marco polo but muslim?, thank god (or allah hehe) for this channel, i would never lnow stuff like this

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Hahaha, we have a few other guys (Masudi would be Herodotus and obviously, Ibn Battuta would be Marco Polo) who fit those descriptions better. I don't really know who to compare him with.

[@AncientAccounts]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT i would add ibn battuta, recently read his Travels, i agree

[@Peristerygr]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT So Xenophon is probably the guy to compare him with.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

I don't really know enough about him to compare with Ibn Khaldun. I guess, Ibn Khaldun was a historian like Herodotus but his primary legacy is because of his work in economy and as a historiographer. He taught HOW to read and record history, rather than actually record it. He did record it but that's not why he remember him.

[@Peristerygr]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT Xenophon actually did or tried to do in historiographyy what Ibn Khaldun said a historian should do.That's why I mentioned him.

[@Duckie0.]

After a long struggle, I finally found ur video and I'm here now. Much appreciated, JazakAllah ❤️

[@osheenkelana]

MALAY SUBTITLES Part 2 of 2 04:29 hantar bencana yang berlaku, Mongol Horde & The Black Death. 04:33 Ibn Khaldun menyajikannya cukup lama. 04:35 Namun, dia mendapati dirinya terlibat dalam intrik politik sekali lagi. 04:39 Pada tahun yang sama, 1384 CE, kapal yang membawa isteri dan anak-anak Ibnu Khaldun karam 04:44 pesisir Iskandariah, tragedi yang tidak seperti yang dialami oleh Ibn Khaldun. 04:47 Selepas itu, Ibn Khaldun bersara dari jawatan politik dan pergi mengajar di pelbagai sekolah 04:52 dan universiti di sekitar Mamluk Mesir. 04:54 Pada tahun 1400 M, Timur yang Lumpuh atau yang saya suka memanggilnya, Timur si JERK, menyerang Damsyik. 05:00 Sultan Mesir, membawa Ibn Khaldun bersamanya untuk menangani Timur. 05:03 Namun, tentera Mamluk dan sultan kembali ke Mesir, tetapi Ibn Khaldun ditinggalkan di 05:08 bandar yang dikepung. 05:10 Bagi pihak elit kota, Ibn Khaldun pergi berunding dengan Timur. 05:13 Dia menghabiskan sekitar tujuh minggu di kemnya dan membincangkan pelbagai topik dengannya. 05:18 Ini hadir dengan terperinci dalam autobiografi Ibn Khaldun. 05:21 Timur dikatakan telah memperlakukan Ibnu Khaldun dengan hormat dan bertanya kepadanya mengenai keadaannya 05:26 Maghreb, Afrika Barat Laut. 05:27 Ibn Khaldun membuat laporan yang luas tentang hal itu, kerana dia adalah kutu buku yang sangat besar! 05:32 Kerana nikmat ini, Ibnu Khaldun meminta Timur untuk memperlakukan kota dengan baik dan membiarkannya kembali 05:36 ke Mesir. 05:37 Timur membenarkannya dan kemudian dia memecat Damsyik dan membakar masjidnya yang besar kerana bagaimana lagi 05:42 akan memastikan bahawa dia dikenang sebagai Timur si Jerk. 05:45 Ibnu Khaldun kembali ke Mesir dan menjalani sepanjang hidupnya dalam pelbagai jawatan, ilmiah 05:49 dan politik. 05:50 Dia meninggal pada 17 Mac 1406 CE. 05:53 Warisan Ibn Khaldun, di dunia Eropah dan Islam, mungkin tidak seperti orang lain. 05:58 Dia menulis di Al Muqaddimah, 07:13 Dengan cara ini, Ibn Khaldun mengusulkan sistem untuk sejarah, dan bukannya siri linear 07:17 cerita yang disebarkan dari satu ke yang lain. 07:20 Pada kali pertama saya membaca buku, saya tidak dapat menjumpai cerita yang tidak saya persoalkan. 07:24 Ibn Khaldun memperkenalkan cara baru untuk memikirkan sejarah dan untuk itu, kerjanya akan dilakukan 07:28 sentiasa hidup. 07:29 Dia memberikan banyak hal kepada dunia, bahkan Ronald Reagan memetiknya untuk menyokong apa yang diketahui 07:33 sebagai ekonomi dari segi penawaran dan mengaku telah melihat idea kenabian untuk masalah fiskal 07:38 kapitalisme dalam karya-karyanya tetapi mungkin perkara terbesar yang diberikan oleh Ibn Khaldun kepada dunia 07:43 adalah Al Muqaddimah. 07:44 Tidak, bukan buku, maksud saya nama saluran ini. 07:47 Jumpa awak lain kali.

[@aleyyanajhwa5776]

Terima kasih sudi terjemahkan dalam bahasa Melayu.

[@houjisaifeddine5524]

you'd think that after over 600 years, people would have learned a thing or 2 from his ideas, like always checking sources and thinking about stuff logically. but no, we didn't. in fact, i think we are even further from that than the people of his era ....

[@alexandrub8786]

Ramadan Kareem (Edit: ) and a good weekend for people like myself.

[@overmanonfire]

by far one of the most respected Islamic-Civilization scientists his analysis on how countries rise and fall, how dynasties rise and fall, the relationship between the city dawdlers and the Bedouins, the political analysis, and the laws of history he put, said was correct up to the age of gunpowder

[@indicaedits8692]

The legend,The Father of Sociology and Father of Science of History-Ibn Khaldun. Great Video bro Love from India.

[@stingrayplays]

Wait don’t you hate us

[@chits28]

We had Muqqadimah on our reading list during masters in sociology but no one read it😅 I think I'll revisit the book now

[@ILoveMaths07]

That's a shame!

[@petehoffs8804]

👏👏👏 Great introduction, wise words. Great name for a KZbin channel, respect for your inspiration

[@the_major]

Great episode! Keep up the good work!

[@greatunknown109]

I love your chanel. Thank you for making islamic history accesible for us westerns.

[@arbazalware901]

I love this channel, fucking underrated.

[@MrMShake]

That quote at 6:00 pretty much sums up the state of the Muslim world today. History tends to repeat itself.

[@jsoth2675]

It would be cool to see a video on khaldun and timurs time together. In particular if he recorded it in detail. Either way thanks for your time and content. It is much appreciated.

[@rayhanmuhammad8834]

you just earned a subscriber with this video bro, brilliant job really

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Thanks and welcome!

[@pyeongeokan]

Thank u very much for your sharing. cheers!!

[@AmerAhmad]

Painting shown at 2:06 is of the Mughal court in India so not accurate here. Very well researched and narrated. Thank you Amer Ahmad

[@ragibshahriar5977]

I liked the video for the last quote. Hope to see your channel grow more.

[@edenromanov]

04:40 Man poor guy, may he and his family R.I.P. 😢

[@supremelordoftheauspicious2928]

How did i not get any notifications for this, I just remembered it's been a while since you last uploaded and checked your channel

[@guledaden960]

Good job keep up the good work😇🤗😇🤗🤗🤗😇😇🤗🤗🤗🤗😇🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗😇🤗🤗🤗🤗😇😇😇🤗🤗🤗🤗😇🤗🤗🤗🤗😇😇🤗🤗🤗😇🤗🤗🤗🤗😇😇🤗🤗😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇

[@Condobius]

Excellent video!

[@rinsedpie]

Very happy with your work

[@vivid-anna]

Thank you for this video it helped me understand my Islamiat chapter Ibn Kaldum

[@mohamedred5746]

Do video About Ibn Battuta

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

All in good time, my friend.

[@marumakoto]

Intensive and comprehensive. I just subscribed.

[@TahaTaha-sz3zk]

Thank you for all you none bias posts

[@حسنعباسجاسبجبار]

Aronld toynbee the most famous historiographer in the last centuries said that ibn khaldum is most genius person on history of humanity

[@ravisekharsridharreddynedu8538]

AT s 21 civilizations Ranke- no interpretation Neibur---- legends have a grain of truth Oswald Spengler---1Decline of the west Karl Marx----a Ll around economy or money Sociologist Darendaaj--- for power with immediate boss or authority not distant one I K---- about tribes etc

[@takshashila2995]

Do a video on Mansa Musa and the Trans-Saharan Trade.

[@islXplore]

Sorry but the picture you are showing at 3:08 is not correct, it shows Santa Cruz Spanish fort in Oran (Algeria) not in Frenda ...

[@Nedwin]

Anyway, his book is Muqaddimah and it might inspire Syawish in naming the channel 😅. Nice sharing.

[@Diego-zz1df]

Have you considered doing a video specifically about his book, the Al Muqaddimah?

[@Le-Chiffre001]

Can someone send me a link to Ibn Khaldun’s autobiography!!!

[@waleedshd2601]

why Indian background music

[@rayyansobrany9759]

Can you do these profile video for caliphs like: harun al rashid , abd al malik or Suleiman the magnificent?

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Over time, yes! I will. It's on my list. I have a very short attention span so I can't stick to anything for long.

[@rayyansobrany9759]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT you teach Islam frim a secular point. No offence; I'm not a fan of wahabbism Honestly I won't conisder wahabis as Sunnis because Sunnis. Celbratrate mawlid un nabi Muhhumed pbuh birthday Have waliallah( saints most notably sahik abdul qadir jillani ra and for him sunnis fast on 11th rabi al thane) , Sunnis have a practis of mysticism of; givng out taweze( like ammulates), doing special rituals and prays, and visting shrine or graves. This is called Sufism Wahbis don't belive in any of this Sunnis like to follow; muhhumed saw, tge sahaba , imam like Imam Buhari and scholars Whabis primary person to follow is abdul wahab and his opinion on islam.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

I'm not really very religious, like I have said before but I was raised on the Wahaabi point of view and I have to disagree with you here. Never, through my 23 years on this planet, have I ever heard a Wahaabi quote Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahaab. Mostly, I only hear them quote things from Bukhari and Muslim. Like I said, I'm not very practicing so it doesn't matter to me but when I do participate in religion (like in Ramadan, for instance) I do it the Wahaabi way.

[@thewolf1801]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT wahhabis are not muslim

[@abdalrahmanalassaf7989]

Amazing!! Stay like that!

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Aw! You too!

[@rockingrollin425]

Does anyone know which translations of Al-Muqqadima are reliable and could be found online? English or Spanish work equally fine.

[@abusalehcameraman9728]

Where can I find IBN khaldun book al maqdimah

[@Sandra.Molchanova]

Just a small stylistical note: don't say 'people died THANKS to the plague', because it would seem that you're glad all those people died. Use 'because of the plague'

[@myonlinechannel9257]

Good work keep it up. It use full information.

[@kemalrizaldy8307]

4:58 Timur: *Exists* Al Muqaddimah: *ANGERY*

[@warren411]

They said he wrote about the Voyages of Massa Musa. One of the richest king in Africa made ship voyages before Columbus. Is that in one of those seven volumes or a different book because the writings are kind of incomplete when it comes to Massa Musa

[@rayyansobrany9759]

I guess this is your favorite episode so far because here is were you get your channel name.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

I knew what the channel would be named as soon as I read that book for the first time.

[@tronghuoa1437]

Wow, when he says names in Arabic seems like he's so familiar with the names. unlike any other westerners who try to pronounce a Arabic name.

[@digitalarchive4826]

He's Pakistani, and Muslim. Makes sense he'd be familiar with Arabic I guess.

[@TrumpCarson]

Hey would you consider the Caliphate's as a theocratic monarchy? If not what would they be?

[@TrumpCarson]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT I agree

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Sorry, that comment wasn't in the right place, for some reason. It was not quite a theocratic monarchy because the caliph didn't command the same respect in Islam, as say, the pope does in Catholicism. After the first four, it was a usual monarchy.

[@TrumpCarson]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT Oh i see, thanks for clearing that up for me! Great video as always man.

[@meowung9848]

Where I can get a map there 0:45, is there a link address ? Can i have it, please ... Great video btw :v

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Not yet but soon, my maps will be available.

[@michaelney2732]

That :v, pasti ini pasti

[@CerebrumMortum]

Came here from the Cynic Historian, LOVE your channel!

[@lepsacademy]

Informative

[@MrCerneus]

Okay asking for a friend: does some one know if there is a audiobooks version of one of the of Ibn Kaldoun? If so could you send me where to find it

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

If the video was sponsored by Audible, I'd recommend looking there but they didn't sponsor me so fuck those guys!

[@timurpodcast4379]

"Timur the Jerk!!!" Haha!

[@EasternRomanHistory]

Really interesting video. Will you do a video on Al-Tabari?

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Yes! I will.

[@EasternRomanHistory]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT He is a bit like the Livy of Islamic historians.

[@fire_lord862]

Video: "Timur the jerk!" Me, a fan of Timur: *surprised Pikachu face*

[@gequitz]

Wait til you hear about Delhi 1398

[@fire_lord862]

@@gequitz He was a Mongol afterall, it is not entirely wrong to say that he is the Muslim version of Genghis Khan.

[@anwarshafee6403]

At around 2:04 you showed a picture that is clearly from the Mughal period in the Indian Subcontinent. Was this done intentionally or a mistake?

[@carolineaustin4138]

I like your KZbin videos a lot but the narration is too fast. I wish the speaker would slow down just a little to help the listener take in the information. Thank you.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Yeah, sorry about that. I've improved in my later videos.

[@austinxd9193]

amazing

[@gogodaal7273]

Timur the “lame” his name is already an insult

[@Eddy-Cool]

I do think that timur was a jerk (he burned the grand mosque, being a muslim himself) But the presenter/uploader shouldn't use such derogatory words or include personal opinion in neutral documentary-style videos. the viewers are thoughtful enough to figure such things out for themselves!

[@youtubeaccount3230]

Those mongol rulers were fake Muslims

[@megiwara_ya5787]

Thanks it will help me.!

[@ahmedshah9777]

Wonderful..... I will suggest my all friends to subscribe your channel

[@TheNomadicProfessor]

Timur the JERK! Love it.

[@ariparrinha8467]

Could you make a video about Charles Martel and the miracle of Ourique?

[@TimmacTR]

So, you didn't say why the French invaded North Africa?

[@slayerofcrusadersandsmallh6404]

All of africa

[@dzalm9274]

hello from land of bereber tamazight algeria 😊

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Hello!

[@danishfz14]

Can I use this video on my page of Instagram to aware people about him ?

[@Kuwait_Anezi]

The best historian in the world

[@oussamasiab5509]

Temur"lame"i could not agree more on that nice one ;)

[@supremelordoftheauspicious2928]

Oussama Siab He was literally lame tho

[@oussamasiab5509]

@@supremelordoftheauspicious2928 XD yes indeed

[@Brahmdagh]

He also roughly touched biological evolution.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

He did. One thing I really found fascinating about him was that he talked about things, like human nature, from a very evolution-like perspective.

[@Brahmdagh]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT please make a video on that aspect.

[@kareemtheeb1478]

@Corporate slave He said bad stuff about Arabs, berbers, eu, blacks and indians. He was not racist. He talked about everyone.

[@vals4207]

Hey ! Great content, but i would love if you put sources in description or pin it in comment section

[@Wonder_Chariot]

me who's names Taimoor, everytime I watch Al Muqaddimah 😢😢 #JusticeForTimur

[@akkisam6625]

Can u make a video on ibn sina

[@abdellahbenoudi1382]

WE ARE NOT BERBER, WE ARE AMAZIGHAN.

[@nggaknormal]

So... I guess you won't make video about timur?

[@solomonb486]

Al Muqaddimah, do you think ibn khaldun is similar to Karl Marx?

[@AngryHistorian87]

Timur the Jerk? I’m sensing a major Ibn Arabshah vibe here. Are you sure you ain’t related to him? 😆

[@pokerzlife7594]

Cat Steven has shared your video in his Facebook page. Congrats.

[@rulde]

Lower the (S) sound Please it causes earrape

[@austinxd9193]

please try Islamic history in Al Andalus and India

[@sociology401]

informative

[@sharifmasum6360]

Can you give me the link of the book Al-Muqaddimah, english translation of course, you think the best

[@Abdoabdo-ix7ds]

Where are you from bro? 😍😍😍

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Pakistan.

[@Abdoabdo-ix7ds]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT love from libya 😍😍😍😍😘

[@Abdoabdo-ix7ds]

Bro ibn khaldoun arab descended from Companion wael ibn hajr 😁😁😁😁 @@AlMuqaddimahYT

[@shrivj6627]

Give respect to emperors what ever they did or didn't but you shouldn't be treating them badly 😠

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Why? If an emperor killed millions of people why should I respect him?

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

Are we supposed to respect Hitler too? What the hell, now?!

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

@not harambefan I know, man!

[@shrivj6627]

@@AlMuqaddimahYTI understand Y your emotional but this is my openion they may be bad or good but who are we to comment on a person who lived several hundred years ago the history may have been manipulated for instance let's take Genghis Khan he is a great conquerer who United large parts of Asia he was tolerant to religion promoted fare trade and ensured safe passage for travelers and his good deads continue but what the writers of history (Western world) depicts him as a tyrant because they were on the receiving side of the arrows that Mongols unleashed and Alexander the great as a great ruler where his negative deads are completely forgotten. let's take these same European people itself as example what they did to the Roman empire.they are just humans whenever we humans find opportunity we will try to do good for our ownself and not to others we are not Gods we are just humans only the fittest can survive the battle I am an Indian yes Delhi was sacked by timur but Delhi sultanate was corrupt and it paid the price as a ruler he should ensure the safety of his subjects but he didn't and the people Paid the price with there life .He(Timur) he was also a normal human he rose to power from very humble origins and you would be familiar with the story of y he got the name timur the lame. He achived great things against all odds if he is an jerk then no one would have joined his ranks as soldiers who risked there Life for him . I myself won't disrespect anyone because I myself don't know what was his true circumstances and y he killed so many people that only him and his generals knew but one thing that I knew is even to lead a small following is difficult governing an empire like his is not a mean task and there is always two different story for every single incident in each story the other will be wrong guy so it's very difficult to judge anyone from what we hear unless we are at the incident so y comment on things that we don't know and this is just my opinion yours could be a different one if you felt I am wrong on this your most welcomed to correct me on this subject.And this is my request your a KZbinr your videos will reach several thousand of people so please don't use any tough words on anyone on your videos.(I am weak in English and don't know if I explained it properly but tried)

[@shrivj6627]

@@AlMuqaddimahYT by the way I love your videos there are several videos about the European rulers but not as many KZbin explaining about rulers of the Muslim world. Waiting for more videos from your side

[@-gamergc2127]

استمر متابعك من بغداد