Ice Pack Vs. Ice Machine For Total Knee Replacement: What’s The Difference? Which One Do I Need?

[@marytesta3003]

A friend loaned her ice machine to me and then purchased one on Amazon. Best investment ever. I think surgeons should just add 200.00 dollars to their fee and send you home with one.

[@dr.samanthasmith]

I totally agree!! It is so so helpful

[@marytesta3003]

@@dr.samanthasmith It truthfully was better than pain meds. It was relaxing and soothing.

[@pushmepull]

My surgeon does! The ice pad was integrated into the heavy gauze mummy wrap.

[@normapaschich6341]

We had a leftover wheeled walker (with a seat) that made it easy to hold and move the ice machine for both my husband (LTKR Nov 23) and me (RTKR Feb24). A movable platform. Easy to move from room to room or next to sink to empty and refill.

[@dr.samanthasmith]

Genius idea!! I love that!

[@ramullen1]

The hospital gave me an ice machine (Breg) to take home. Stayed cold all night. I only used for 2 weeks.

[@craiganderson5200]

Thanks Dr. Smith, I appreciate the research and advice. I'm recovering from total knee replacement and will be undergoing the other knee replacement next year. I will be going with the Polar Ice Machine.

[@JoanRuttle-King]

Love the videos and purchased your suggested items today to prepare for my husband's surgery!

[@Teleman01]

On my first knee replacement in December I had an ice machine that my doctor let me use. It also provided compression. The next knee I will probably just get the regular ice machine.

[@x2malandy]

You are my WWW doctor. Thanks for all the info.

[@dr.samanthasmith]

You are so welcome

[@RobertEvans-o6m]

Thank u for taking the time to help us❤

[@dr.samanthasmith]

My pleasure 😊

[@richberenson537]

Dr Sam Smith - Thanks for the video on ice machines vs Ice wrap. You did not mention ice machines that can provide compression. What are your thoughts on this topic?

[@dr.samanthasmith]

If you can find an affordable one, I love the compression cooling wraps. The only issue is the incision during the first few weeks might be sensitive to the compression.

[@JoanRuttle-King]

But one question, do you need to cover the knee with an ace under the wrap or is it ok to have it directly on the skin?

[@dr.samanthasmith]

You’ll want to use a towel or sheet

[@teresamichele4747]

The hospital sent one home with me however I haven’t been able to figure out how to use it? It’s not cold on the sleeve when I turn it on.

[@dr.samanthasmith]

If it’s the polar active ice, you can call their customer service for help

[@pugburge2949]

Is there an ice pack you would recommend that is a little less bulky that can be used for travel?

[@dr.samanthasmith]

This is a good one! It’s a little smaller. It stays really cold too. You can use code DRSAM10 for 10% off. www.polarproducts.com/polarshop/pc/Soft-Ice-Deluxe-Knee-Wrap-p146.htm

[@TheKimle]

I have Polar ice machine I wonder if I can buy a time to go with that Thanks

[@dr.samanthasmith]

Yes! They do sell timers if yours doesn’t have one. Here is the link (use code DRSAM10 for 10% off! )www.polarproducts.com/polarshop/pc/Programmable-Timer-Temperature-Flow-Control-p557708.htm

[@TheKimle]

Thanks Dr Samantha

[@teresaspensley5640]

Ice machines are way too expensive. I’m 4 weeks and 3 days TKR and a pensioner.

[@dr.samanthasmith]

They aren’t absolutely necessary but nice to have

[@teresaspensley5640]

@@dr.samanthasmith we were having to go and get a new one every hour. When I took the old one off after that amount of time it was very hot🥲I live in England so not a hot country at all 😂