Identify the Contents of the Pie Without Breaching the Pastry | Full Task | Taskmaster

[@emememememememememe]

*sounds of glass marbles hitting the pie tin* Roisin: I bet it's kidney

[@yellowleo]

Kidney stones maybe.

[@emememememememememe]

@@yellowleo HAHAHAHAHA

[@genericname2747]

I admire the innocence of the first guy. He really was expecting some nice normal pie.

[@emilygriffith6702]

I thought they were pretty amazing and admiral guesses too 😂

[@junghunt8645]

admirable

[@DoobieFerguson]

@@emilygriffith6702 I think in General he had some Major guesses but I wouldn't say any were up to Admiral standards

[@Netbug]

Don't let Frank fool you, he has bodies buried under his house.

[@christianrogers8297]

Memento Mori

[@minutemuse]

Frank answering "steak" for almost every pie felt like someone marking "C" for every question on an exam. You won't get all of them right, but you're bound to get at least one thing right.

[@ravenshade266]

And then the one time he didn’t pick steak… it was.

[@squishmellow3]

And then he reads a question he thinks is easy, picks B, and the answer is C

[@jmcburney658]

"Papa don't breach" prevented a riot.

[@AuDHDarling]

Papa, don't breach I'm in toothpaste deep Papa, don't breach I been losin' peas

[@iandominiclagman7546]

@@WinstonSmithGPT Oooooooo Gonna eat my colgate

[@CyberMew]

What does it mean?

[@Towkeeyoh]

Well deserved round of handshakes.

[@sumedhahaha]

wht does that mean?

[@roosvervelde3180]

Alex has said before that this hot toothpaste pie was the worst thing he ate on taskmaster ever hahaha

[@Andjelka99]

Wasn't the burned porn magazines worst now? But yeah the paste was the worst for a while before that

[@BurnEdOutOne]

One time I brushed my teeth in my studio apartment kitchen and since I left the toothpaste on the stove it was all hot from what I was baking in the oven and it was really really gross. Can Confirm.

[@Thorpefan]

Not a nice time pie.

[@SennaAugustus]

Nobody even compelled him to do it, just went and did it himself!

[@roosvervelde3180]

@@BurnEdOutOne haha maybe that's how he got the idea

[@ScrambledAndBenedict]

Look at Alex's face right before he bites the Toothpaste Pie at 10:42. You quite literally see him go through all five of the stages of grief before biting that pie lmfao

[@dre5379]

To be fair who ever cut open the bottom of these pies to in preparation for the tasks are the ones who breached the pies

[@Bumblesnitch]

I'm with the contestants on the whole accidental breaching thing. I don't think that's on them, everyone else had pies they lifted out of the same variety that held together.

[@no_peace]

Yeah it wasn't fair

[@SharienGaming]

@@no_peace to be fair - taskmaster isnt fair XD

[@smoceany9478]

it should be counted as not getting it but not disqualified

[@ShiningDarknes]

@@SharienGaming no taskmaster is objectively a fair game. All contestants have the same tasks with the same object interactions. If one contestant picks up something and the task says not to breach it and it holds together but another picks it up and it falls apart that is not fair at all and it isn't even entertaining to watch.

[@SharienGaming]

@@ShiningDarknes sorry nope - the entire premise is that the taskmaster rules supreme and can give out points however he pleases in some cases the tasks are modified for single contestants as well, because it is funny taskmaster is not a fair contest...its an entertainment show - its not meant to be fair

[@sparo_splat]

Figured out the loophole of not having to break the pies herself, looked away while Alex ate them, oh I love Roisin😂

[@MuunNii]

Your not discovering a loophole if the judge just doesn't sentence you. "Without breaching the pie" if pay someone to throw a rock trough someone's window it's still breached.

[@halloweenfan158]

@@MuunNii it’s breached but not by you

[@MuunNii]

@@halloweenfan158 Yes, precisely.

[@DrakeOola]

@@MuunNii The rules specifically say "but YOU may not breach the pastry. It is a loophole and you cant change the rules to the way you interpreted it. If I said you cant eat my food then I eat it myself, it doesnt matter what the judge thinks because the fine print was followed. There was no sentence to pass because the rules were followed.

[@MuunNii]

@@DrakeOola there's no specification of whoever breaches the pastry, don't make bs up

[@Kuhndog94]

On behalf of all of the fans in America, I'd like to thank you all for the daily uploads.

[@iaintdonknow]

Also European countries!

[@MadcapShambleton]

Canadians too, mate!

[@MegaOgrady]

The world*

[@aguccy]

Same. Living in Netherlands here, loving the content and humor.

[@fhinnes]

But you do know that they've upload the entire episodes, right?

[@elizaheathen]

the sheer anger from romesh and josh is fantastic looks like the start of how family games are ruined at christmastime

[@Jerry_Bean]

Nahh the people that start it is the people who are anal about the rules

[@kisatorimuru6627]

I love how they both turn to look at Roisin at 8:37

[@XIIIMPC]

So synchronised!

[@xipheonj]

That was one of my favourite on camera (fake-for-comedy) arguments I've ever seen. The best part was them instant bonding at the end over a bad pun. Perfect argument with a perfect ending. This video summed up everything great about this show.

[@discordpensiveemoji]

I love this task. Roisin's method really is a marvel. Edit: Also really lovin Tim's reactions to the breaches.

[@cyprel]

Yeah, and they joke about her turning around, while I'm sitting here going "well, yep, that's completely consistent with her (possibly insane) definition of breaching"

[@turntsnaco824]

Really missed the opportunity to say "a real marble"

[@mimidoll13]

I actually gagged when Alex bit into the toothpaste pie. I'm nauseous now.

[@SuperG0alie]

not just bit, he SWALLOWED it!

[@Meton2526]

YEAH you're nauseous.

[@brcarloseduardo]

i stopped the video. that was disgusting, Alex is a true hero kkkkkkkkk

[@barbarad3869]

Same

[@christinebubb6658]

This was, hands down, without a doubt, my favorite cast! When Josh had to count the beans and the spaghetti-o's, I was dying!!

[@sometroii6561]

I'm with Romesh on the pie breaching. Picking up is a normal use-case for a pie. If the pie falls apart when picked up normally, it's the fault of the pie maker. Whoever made that pie set it up for failure. You could say that the pie breached itself when they picked it up, you could say that the person who made the pie breached the pie, but you definitely can't say that the people who picked up pies that fell apart breached the pies.

[@SahiPie]

Look at it this way: Had the individual not picked up the pie, the pie would still be “unbreached” so hence, the individual was the one who had breached the pie. Case closed.

[@sometroii6561]

@@SahiPie Nope, it was breached before he picked it up, picking it up simply revealed that it was breached.

[@shavansky3393]

Exactly! If I don’t tighten the screws of a bridge and a car drives over it, making the bridge collapse, it is not the fault of the driver, but the fault of the engineer 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@morgangore1193]

@@shavansky3393 are pies designed so that they can be picked up? I'd say no.

[@palladiumargon8154]

@@morgangore1193 shut up mate

[@junnagels]

Greg: Do you want to see a breach? This is a breach! **ADVERTISEMENT POPS UP**

[@BhargavSushant]

That is technically a breach

[@Ibringyoudoom]

Roisin is the real winner of this just because she got Alex to take a bite of the hot toothpaste pie LMAO

[@Sunset553]

I forgot about the pie difference, so as an American, my mouth was watering for dessert hoping for peach, berry, and cherry pies.

[@jadahendrix8058]

Same I was very confused

[@Sunset553]

@@jadahendrix8058 our chicken pot pies are like their meat pies.

[@raphael122]

So, I guess it wasn't a nice time pie?

[@wisedred]

Dude I live in France and even though they live 2 hours away from me, I expected no more than you. The old guy seemed crazy from the start, with his weird meat combos.

[@jawstrock2215]

either way, you wouldn't have any of those XD would have been jelly beans, concrete powder, wood chips, coins and and 3dprinted item pies :D

[@Druid_Plow]

"You want a breach? Here's a breach." GRUBHUB COMMERCIAL WITH LOUD ASS TRUMPETS!!!! Breached my flippin ear drums didn't ya.

[@welheizel9682]

'' you would've thought that dogshit was steak '' got me

[@UpWithTheBirds23]

Steak

[@sarahmccormack6318]

It was so unexpected and savage 😂😂😂😂

[@titirenee]

got me laughing so hard

[@Minotauronabike]

Classic Britishism - sees toothpaste and can't identify it.

[@profoundwanderer1441]

HAHAHA!! 💀💀💀

[@maple2524]

Top banter

[@user-xv1cs9mm9d]

Really was concerning

[@hundragant]

Lmao! That's gold.

[@Edigor100]

tasted toothpaste and STILL couldn't identify it

[@BlazeMakesGames]

the old set feels so claustrophobic now lol

[@vincentodomscatl24]

Just found out about this today and it's pretty addicting I must say. Never heard of it before, good, funny show.

[@qwertyTRiG]

There's full episodes on KZbin.

[@OranDoesThings]

Greg: "So if you look into somebody's window, that means you've burgled them?" Me: "Well by your definition Greg, apparently if a building collapses across the street, you're guilty of breaking and entering."

[@kayday1996]

You will have to touch it first

[@Ithtorukk]

Nah, Greg's definition requires action on their part. "If you knock on the door and the building collapses". They were perfectly fine until they were picked up and the bottoms fell out.

[@MuunNii]

@@Ithtorukk his pie was the least breached pie. The last ones *were breached* , by other people sure, but still breached.

[@MuunNii]

@@kayday1996 so if I throw a ball trough the window it isn't breached? You lot need to step up and get your grades up there. English really isn't that hard of a language.

[@kayday1996]

@@MuunNii ???

[@LindsayRaeToro]

the first series will always be one of the best, its such a treasure

[@literallymalware]

One of the loudest, most rioting episodes comes from "guess the pie" lmfao

[@kayleighlehrman9566]

Josh and Ramesh chewing into Roisin before her go was incredible, Taskmaster successfully turned them against themselves.

[@cody6685]

I have already seen Alex eat the pies four times, but here I am.

[@telegramaph]

"Papa don't breach" 🤣🤣🤣 Legend!

[@smilesfordays]

Ramish is just the best for angry commentary. I love it even more than James and that’s saying a lot.

[@mikewazowksi7938]

romesh

[@damightyshabba439]

You gotta give it to Alex Horne - I mean... he goes whole hog when he does this show. SO many others would just say.... "Erm.... NO". But he just does these tasks like its just another day.... On stage I don't find him that funny, but on this.... maximum respect (across all episodes). AND he usually keeps character as well....

[@-Offstar]

100% don't think it's fair to count that as a breach. The pie falling apart was 100% on whoever put it together not him. That's like me going out and buying a car then the engine falls out of the car and the dealer that sold it to me telling me well it's not their problem I'm the one that broke it.

[@amazingabby25]

Yeah hot toothpaste wouldn’t hold like that

[@haroldreighn7262]

This is by far my favorite task so far. Incredible to watch.

[@trcr5473]

That was some serious commitment to eating the nastiest pie

[@Kami-mk7tu]

Plot twist they didn't replace the pies for each person and just refilled it and glued the pastry back together.

[@Katt1n]

How is that a plot twist?

[@basbloem8259]

@@Katt1n because obviously the whole plot of the story was that the pies were fresh pies for each contestant! So the twist was that they didn't, I guess? I'm just going on @Kamiel's logic here

[@DrakeOola]

@@basbloem8259 No. The plot twist was the fact that the pie lost structural integrity and the gap grew wider making it more obvious that you could peak in from the bottom and still follow the rules. That means the first contestant had it the worst and that's probably why he did the worst as his only option was to follow Roisin's logic which he unfortunately didn't think of. His pies were definitely more solid and lacking the peep holes like the other contestants had. It also explains why the latter contestants had the bottom of their pies fall apart. They didn't exactly treat the pie any rougher than the other contestants yet it fell apart as soon as they picked it up. Of course, they'd need new pies after it fell apart or they ate it anyway but that just further adds to the inconsistency and hence adds another layer of unfairness.

[@basbloem8259]

@@DrakeOola woooooosh

[@nommyyt]

One of my favorite tasks! So simple, yet so clever in both presentation and the possible solutions. Also just plain hilarious.

[@TheWalkingJewels]

That hot toothpaste makes me gag everytime.

[@GacPrime]

This was a nice-time pie.

[@wtechboy18]

Watching these videos is just a spa day for my soul.

[@guhjjify]

7:00. The toothpaste has steam coming off it.

[@ftd888]

Josh and Romesh didn’t “breach” the pies. “Breach” implies intent, and the pies clearly “broke” when Josh and Romesh picked them up in a normal manner. To build on the taskmaster’s example, the driver was clearly at fault. However, no reasonable person would see the accident and say, “wow, what a terrible breach,” or “wow, the car really breached that house.”

[@fedos]

verb: breach; 3rd person present: breaches; past tense: breached; past participle: breached; gerund or present participle: breaching 1. make a gap in and break through (a wall, barrier, or defense). "the river breached its bank" Intent is not implied.

[@sometroii6561]

@@fedos He never made a gap in it or broke through it though, all he did was pick it up.

[@fedos]

@@sometroii6561 And the pie breached when he picked it up. It doesn't matter if he intended to breach it or not, the rule was violated.

[@sometroii6561]

@@fedos Lets say that I rig the power button on your computer to blow up your neighbors house when you press it. You press the button without knowing it, and your neighbor's house explodes. Who blew up your neighbor's house, you or me?

[@samakiraroyjanssen6326]

@@sometroii6561 3rd degree murder exists. Both of you did

[@ryryaubaub347]

Oh my god the breaching conversation had me rolling

[@MuunNii]

He was right though? If you pay someone else to break a window, it still breached, innit?

[@ryryaubaub347]

@@MuunNii 100% looking at the already exposed parts= not breaching everything else that damaged the structural integrity of the pie is breaching

[@Thorpefan]

Legit in the top 3 tasks of all time.

[@RatRatRattyRatRat]

In fairness Lifting something and it breaking isn't a breach by definition It's just it falling apart However the holes being present in the pies is actually a breach by definition

[@iratejester]

But then we got the problem of them breaking the rules even if they don't participate

[@jabbathehut1871]

5:22 I don't want to quible, means, I want to quible. Still, breach means break. Looking does not mean breaking. 8:42 Yep. 9:04 9:39 Oh, she's worse. The rest of them are breachers. 13:30 Extreme mint is how toothpaste tastes like.

[@tesscrelli783]

Ah I watched one video and now I'm lost in the neverending rabbithole of taskmaster videos

[@harshiita9635]

Any thumbnail that has ALEX in it.... You know.. He is gonna suffer and it's gonna be incredible 😅😂😂

[@FAB1150]

The hesitation before biting the pie lmao

[@augustinaslukauskas4433]

"That's AhLoT of pies" - that's peak comedy right there

[@thegazebros8566]

Before I even started the video I thought to myself "One of those pies is going to have a picture of the task master." Bingo.

[@addiemiller9677]

Bravo!

[@elviratornay2070]

you are the true pie whisperer

[@Sootpelt]

I was gagging watching Alex eat the toothpaste pie. Poor fellow!

[@kevinhoulihan7666]

This one's so good, it's such a journey

[@saltshaker6017]

some jokes really hits different when you know the context of what they are saying.

[@Shizzmonger]

looking forward to when we have an audience and they can sit close together again

[@CyberFlash]

This is my absolute favourite task 😂😂😂 love it when they get riled up

[@TheFray331]

great, now I have to watch series one again

[@DecayConstant]

I literally gagged watching him eat the Toothpaste Pie.

[@nomadicroadrat]

This task brought a melt down and shows how easily one can be sane at one moment and go completely mental the next. I laughed so the nurse had to come and sedate me.

[@d_boi9345]

Alex Smashing pies was way funnier than expected

[@Rynosnoborder]

Can we talk about that moment where Roisin tells a joke and everyone responds by fucking laughing then shaking hands? That was one of the most British things I've seen in a while. 9:04

[@andrewrobotbuilder]

I really enjoyed this without the overlapped take laugh track. More like this!

[@dujezarkovic2384]

Holy shit, this is an amazing concept for a task

[@wiseassokaythen]

“frozen peas mate” was honestly so badass.

[@solidmoon8266]

Romosh always looked like he's one sentence away from exploding and here it went.

[@BrandonPaulLee]

Most of these come down to involving someone else to do work. But "mint pie" got me 😂😂😂

[@mayanganggarani]

season 1 will always have best place in my heart. i just love it, and the task felt very folky & original.

[@tsotate]

I'm surprised that Greg didn't react to Josh's "pie flavored pie", since it was a clear reference to Greg's own standup.

[@nk-dw2hm]

Alex ate entirely too much of that toothpaste pie

[@TheKopakah]

10:19 I love that moment

[@juhaniu6371]

Damn i love Roisin - After i saw After Life and then saw her at taskmaster - i became a fan - Just love her Greeting from Finland =)

[@crazydragy4233]

Oh this episode was such a hoot. Had me wheezing for minutes xd

[@fivemjs]

I forget that some countries prefer savory pies. Here in the states when we say pie it’s dessert and there’s Usually fruit or chocolate or something else similar and I kept getting thrown off when they were listing meats.

[@hopewalker5764]

Chicken pot pie would like to have a word. So would shepherd’s pie.

[@OmniscientWarrior]

@@hopewalker5764 Or cottage pie which is actually more common and Americans call a Sheppard's pie.

[@no_peace]

@@hopewalker5764 where i live we always call savory pies like that pot pies to differentiate them.

[@screamtoasigh9984]

@@hopewalker5764 POT Pie. Sheppard's pie isn't a common American thing. Plus it's with POTATOES ON TOP IT'S literally not a pie. 🙄 what they are eating are hot pockets with pastry dough. I might as well be a knish, samsa, Jamaican pattie or samosa. That's closer to what they are looking at

[@ProfX501]

@@screamtoasigh9984 You realise that whatever definition of ‘pie’ Americans use came after the British usages? By your logic one could just as easily say that American pies are really just big tarts (which, really, they are). And no, I’m not British.

[@sbilldmilk]

This is the funniest task I've seen

[@kaiejohanson1635]

Will it pie? Even without this task, the British have some crazy filling ideas

[@MrShenhai]

But still not as crazy as Good Mythical Morning filling ideas!

[@masterskywalkertherearetoo7186]

*lights cigarette 7:25 „you breached it man...“ I love Tim so much

[@BurnEdOutOne]

One of the best tasks of all time.

[@josephbach1]

Thank you taskmaster for showing me romesh. I just bought his comedy special he is soo funny. Without you i would've never learned about him.

[@gawni1612]

This is the first taskmaster to make me actually gag.

[@mikedome9475]

0:55 Peter Jackson? haha so cool

[@emmajean8631]

Some excellent Shall I Be Mother-ing happening at 9:29

[@dmvtiedye]

Greg says "you wanna see a breach, this is a breach..." And a burglary ad comes on 😂

[@OmniscientWarrior]

A breach within a breach.

[@Selfg12]

bro he was HEATED. lmao

[@chaykuh]

Alex hesitating on the toothpaste pie 😂

[@Fjottle]

I'm gonna need a recipe for that Toothpaste Pie

[@PhoenicopterusR]

You'd have to breach the pie though, and that's against the rules.

[@sharkygirl8264]

I never knew Alex had a gap tooth, I think this is the first time I've seen him laugh

[@RikuHino]

To be fair when he lifted the pie and the bottom came off id say that isn't a breach. The car through the house example isn't sound. Reason being the house is stucturally sound. That pie on the other hand was not. It should have been the fault of whomever made the pie. Example, if you buy a bucket of paint and you lift it. If the bottom falls off with all the paint is that your fault. Or is it the fault of the wherever you purchased it from?

[@imbleu1067]

If only Alex ate the marble pie

[@Noodles-_]

Loll

[@DesuFollower]

But he did, haven't you seen his teeth?

[@darrylhamlin7475]

@@DesuFollower No they just look like that because he’s british.

[@MuunNii]

@@darrylhamlin7475 bri ish, mate

[@kritz9997]

Poor Alex, he suffered eating all that toothpaste only for her to still guess wrong.

[@druid_zephyrus]

Little Alex Horne is a fucking legend. Knowing and still biting. He may be called little, but there is some big...

[@bencressman6110]

I fucking killed myself when Alex ate all of that toothpaste!!! 😂 The commitment !

[@FrozenShadow007]

This is one of the better tasks I’ve seen so far

[@pauljmorton]

I'm with Romesh. The task says, "without breaching the pie", which thanks to English grammar means "without you breaching the pie." The task is not "without the pie getting breached."

[@nottechytutorials]

I don't agree with the ruling. One of the taskmasters (not-Alex) says to one of the men that when he entered the room the pie was intact and when he left the pie was breached, if that was the case then a breach regardless of who done it still breaks the rules.

[@ShopMom]

Oh no! Him eating the warm toothpaste pie, I had to keep from wretching!!

[@monaelisa8713]

I can't *not* gag while watching Alex eat that toothpaste pie 😨

[@arosegaming4793]

"Wish I'd done that now" mate that airport idea is brilliant

[@josemaria8177]

Probably my all time favourite task

[@prysthaea7735]

Watching Alex suffer is one of my favorite pass times.