Identity Crisis: Are We Israel? Are We Gentiles?

[@brothabrian6004]

And he gathered all Judah and Benjamin, and those from Ephraim, Manasseh, and Simeon 👉 who were residing with them,👈 for great numbers had deserted to him from Israel when they saw that the Lord his God was with him. They were gathered at Jerusalem in the third month of the fifteenth year of the reign of Asa. They sacrificed to the Lord on that day from the spoil that they had brought 700 oxen and 7,000 sheep. And they entered into a covenant to seek the Lord, the God of their fathers, with all their heart and with all their soul, 2 Chronicles 15:9‭-‬12 ESV So couriers went throughout all Israel and Judah with letters from the king and his princes, as the king had commanded, saying, “O people of Israel, return to the Lord, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Israel, that he may turn again to 👉 the remnant of you who have escaped from the hand of the kings of Assyria.👈 2 Chronicles 30:6 ESV

[@JGez83]

@@JeffSmith-it4tmdeal with what Brian posted instead of Gish galloping and red herring like you usually do

[@BibliayFe]

@@JGez83 lol

[@auntieanna]

Also, 2 Chron 11:13-17 & 12:1 and James 1:1 & Mt 15:24 prove the two houses were already regathered by the first century. This also disproves dispensationalism and futurism. But question, theonomy is a different position than torahism. And, depending on how one slices it, they may categorize clean foods & feast celebrations apart from the levitical/ceremonial/ecclesiastical system. So then, can that not be a legitimate expression of faith?

[@auntieanna]

Mr. Solberg.... FYI Here are some torah, reformed type that speak against two house. Mixed bag. kzbin.info/www/bejne/Zp3EYaxqnLZ2qpY

[@ArchDLuxe]

​@@auntieannaJames addresses his audience as, "the 12 tribes in the dispersion," not, "the 12 tribes formerly in/of the dispersion." This proves exactly the opposite of your claim.

[@KatAmanti]

There IS neither Jew nor Gentile! In Christ we are ONE! ❤

[@gooseneckapologeticsbonk7262]

We are unto 1 nation, flock, family of God being grafted in, called by his voice, adopted with christ amen. Rom 11; John 10:16; Rom 8:15; 9:26; Gal 3:26

[@YahElihuJudah1234]

Whether Jew or gentile you are one in Christ it's not talking about every human on this earth is one you need to understand Paul a bit better

[@6969smurfy]

We are to be Echad! Graft into the Family ! Except the YAH/God of Abraham Isaac and Jacob ie Isreal, the Family of YAHisrael.

[@6969smurfy]

If you Except the Son YAHshua Humasheoc as Messiah than you except the Father, YAH God of Abraham Isaac and Jacob ie Isreal. It's. Family thing! Just as Jacob did, YAH calls to YAHisrael. Meaning HIS peiples!

[@veritas2145]

In order to properly understand the phrase, “Jew nor gentile”… you must understand who the Jews are… And who the specific Gentiles are in the context. Most people don’t understand that.

[@jeramilltua-requena1497]

First of all, I just wanted to thank you for taking the time to make these highly-detailed videos in response to certain teachings and taking them step-by-step. As someone who has part of my family who is in the HRM and has gifted me 2 books books to look into on the HRM teachings, I began to feel like I was having a faith crisis. So confused but wanting to please the Lord whatever is true. So as I go through this process in my faith (being 4 years a Christian convert from witchcraft and new-age religion) this has been of such help for me to understand both views better. Thank you so much, professor, your "work in the Lord is not in vain", but "is bearing fruit, in you and all around the world." YEHOVAH BLESS YOU AND KEEP YOU AND MAY HIS FACE SHINE UPON YOU AND GIVE YOU PEACE.

[@tessaelstran]

I can 100% resonate with what you are saying.

[@livenfree]

Well said! I appreciate them very much as well. Did you watch his interview with Katherine Dawkins The former Hebrew Roots member?

[@theomegawerty9688]

Thank you for finally addressing this particular "seminar"

[@tagumpayvela5063]

Can you have a live debate with Jim Staley? Love to see that.

[@dianagreen5289]

Thank you, thank you, thank you for doing this video 💗 Jim staley and his teachings have been a point of confusion for a long time. I knew something wasn't right but I didn't know how to articulate it. I appreciate you taking on these issues with honor and respect. The Lord has used your channel to help unravel a lot of biblical entanglements relating to Hebrew roots movement and or Torahism. Thank you 💜

[@PutOnTheNewWineskin]

Thank you for this teaching, it clears up a lot of things the enemy has tried to confuse me with lately 🙏

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

Glad it was helpful, Jennifer! Blessings, Rob

[@blindvision4703]

@@TheBiblicalRoots what’s the difference, really, between this movement and the Judaizers of Paul’s day? Sure, they may claim that the law doesn’t save you or justify you, but doesn’t it amount to the same thing practically speaking?

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

@@blindvision4703 Yeah, it's really the same theology. The big difference is that the Judaizers in the first century were Jews who were legitimately confused because everything was so brand new and they didn't have a New Testament yet to explain it. "Torah-keepers" today are Gentiles who do have the New Testament and _still_ get it wrong. Shalom! Rob

[@blindvision4703]

@@TheBiblicalRoots thank you. If that’s the case, should we not refer to them as the heretics that they are? Also, I’ve learned in the last two years, give or take, but I have some Jewish ancestry, but I wasn’t raised that way and don’t really keep any of the mosaic laws. Do you think I’m free to keep doing that? or would it be better for me to keep at least some of them to retain the Jewish identity? Graecyn peace. Shalom.

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

​@@blindvision4703 Hello! To say that keeping the law of Moses is required for salvation qualifies as heresy, in my opinion. But not all "Torah-observant" Christians believe that. Many say that keeping the law is an obligation of obedience, not salvation. So I don't like to use the term "heresy." Whether someone has a Jewish ancestry or not, I believe the New Testament teaches that keeping the Mosaic traditions is permitted but not required (1 Cor. 9:19-23). Many Jews who were raised in a Jewish family and have come to faith in Jesus prefer to continue keeping those traditions as voluntary expressions of their Jewish identity, which is lovely. But they do not add a thing to our righteousness and are not a requirement of obedience. Blessings! Rob

[@jolindaflanigan3729]

Have mercy! Wow what leap that Mr Staley made! When you are called a child of God because of Christ , is that not enough. Is that not everything. 😢

[@RUT812]

💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

[@sammcrae8892]

Yes. Jesus! Faith alone in His grace from His sacrifice and resurrection! 🙏✝️👑🙏

[@pede8889]

​@@sammcrae8892and GOING ON GROWING following His commands working out your own salvation in fear and trembling.

[@pede8889]

​@@sammcrae8892if you have no works then your faith is dead. If you do not know Jesus as the only God the only diety then are you really saved ?

[@kiruiandrew1]

All Californias are Americans but not all Americans are Californias. All Jews are Israelites but not all Israelites are Jews

[@letmepicyou]

Wrong. Jews are NOT ISRAELITES.

[@dorinamary7863]

No Jews are Israelite, they say so themselves.

[@darlenecervoni1256]

Herbert Armstrong said this when in Worldwide Church of God to push his British/Israel teaching. I first heard him teach it in the early 80's.

[@dorinamary7863]

@@darlenecervoni1256 "Jews began to call themselves Hebrews and Israelites in 1860." Encyclopedia Judaica 1971 "Esau-Edom is modern Jewry." Jewish Encyclopedia 1925, Volume 5, Page 41 "Strictly speaking, it is incorrect to call an ancient Israelite a Jew, or to call a contemporary Jew an Israelite or Hebrew." Jewish Almanac 1980, Page 3 The Jews were never captive in Egypt. John 8:43

[@johannaholliday9415]

Thank you for encouraging people to critically think and giving them tools to do so.

[@BiblersWayCottage]

Psa 119:140 Your Word is very pure; therefore Your servant loves it. Psa 119:141 I am small and despised; yet I do not forget Your Commandments. Psa 119:142 Your righteousness is an everlasting righteousness, and Your Law is the truth. Psa 119:151 You are near, O Yehovah, and all Your Commandments are truth. Psa 119:160 Your Word is true from the beginning; and every one of Your righteous judgments endures forever. Psa 119:161 SHIN: Princes have persecuted me without a cause, but my heart stands in fear of Your Word. Psa 119:162 I rejoice at Your Word, as one who finds great spoil. Psa 119:163 I hate and despise lying; but I love Your Law. Psa 119:164 I praise You seven times a day because of Your righteous judgments. Psa 119:165 Great peace is to those who love Your Law, and there is no stumbling block for them.

[@BiblersWayCottage]

Psa 119:29 Remove from me the way of lying; and grant me Your Law graciously. Psa 119:30 I have chosen the way of truth; I have laid Your judgments before me. 2 Peter 2:2 And many will follow their destructive ways, because of whom the way of truth will be blasphemed.

[@grittupfer7507]

Thank you, Mr. Solberg, for clearing the dust. I appreciate your ministry very much.

[@jirehseiuli6173]

but the thing is according to paul gentiles are grafted into israel as it is written in romans 11: 16-18 For if the firstfruit be holy the lump is also holy and if the root be holy so are the branches. And if some of the branches be broken off and you being a wild olive tree were grafted in among them and with them partake of the root and fatness of the olive tree Boast not against the branches. But if you boast you bear not the root but the root you. and in the same manner Yeshua states in john 15:5-10 I am the vine you are the branches ( refering to both jews and gentiles because believers are under the same vine because we are all one in Christ see galatians 3:28) He that abides in me and I in him the same brings forth much fruit for without me ye can do nothing. If a man abide not in me he is CAST FORTH AS A BRANCH and is withered and men gather them and cast them into the fire and they are burned. If you abide in me and my words abide in you, you shall ask what you will, and it shall be done to you. Herein is my Father glorified, that you bear much fruit so shall you be my disciples. As the Father has loved me, so have I loved you: continue ye in my love. IF YOU KEEP MY COMMANDMNETS YOU SHALL ABIDE IN MY LOVE (what happens when they don't according to verse six they are cast out and burned and what did the messiah command to keep all the commandments see Matthew 5:17-19) even as I have kept my father's commandments and abide in his love. So please consider if we are grafted into Israel and we are told to be holy just like the root (which is the messiah in romans 11) and the root kept the commandment's and told others to do so why don't you?

[@veritas2145]

Those who were being grafted in were the previously Divorced Israelites… Coming back in the Covenant relationship. Go read Hosea 1 very carefully… And also Ezekiel 37

[@pipinfresh]

I'm so glad you are tackling this subject, it was identity crisis by Jim Staley that started my journey into the Hebrew roots.

[@walkinginthegodgiven-jerem5502]

We are Israel. Never loose hope of that.

[@pipinfresh]

@@walkinginthegodgiven-jerem5502 The church is Israel by faith, yes. But we are not genetically Israel.

[@walkinginthegodgiven-jerem5502]

@@pipinfresh my comment, says, ancient and modern Israel were Israel because of covenant not blood line. The Covenant superseded all claims, thus the exiles

[@walkinginthegodgiven-jerem5502]

@@pipinfresh yes but genetically Israel was never Israel by genetics either. The covenant led the way

[@pipinfresh]

@@walkinginthegodgiven-jerem5502 I agree. It's always been by faith. But Israel is made of both gentiles and Jews if of faith and covenant. We don't stop being gentiles just because we are Israel by faith and covenant.

[@mavrickglo]

Jim Staley is either ignorant of or ignoring some historical events. When Pompey concurred Jerusalem he went into the holy of holyes and was surprised to find it empty. No idol. He decided that Jew had a high religion of the mind. And there were many Roman’s who had great respect and gave large amounts of money to synagogues. They weren’t going to become Jewish but they became the God Fearers who became many of Paul’s converts.

[@YahuahsMaidServant]

Please tell me you're kidding... Hope and worship are present tense... You are playing with words... Incorrectly I might add to prove a false point... Both of those words are both present and future tense... I don't agree with the Staley either you both are putting your opinions and what you've been taught by wicked men... You've never answered me in the past about what commands are we to follow... You say there's none right.. because you clearly teach against the ten commandments... You break the first 4 with no problem... And I'm not a Hebrew roots follower I'm a Bible follower... You conveniently leave out Yahusha's sermon on the mount... You will be the least in the kingdom because you teach that it's sinful to follow the Torah... Btw... It doesn't say House of Israel in Exodus and numbers and laredicus and Deuteronomy it says the children of Israel... What about an Ezekiel where he specifically talks about the two staffs when the two houses will reunite do you not believe in prophecy.. I absolutely do not believe the church is Israel The church is grafted in to to the family but be careful what does Paul say both not against the original branches cuz if they were cut off and you replace them you can be cut off and replace again...If people want to be obedient and follow the Torah why do you have an issue because you don't want to follow the tourist so you teach that it's wrong you can't say that it's wrong to want to be obedient to our Father in heaven If you don't want to be obedient that's on you why are you promoting this to everybody as fact when it's not If you read your Bible and not cherry pick like you tend to do as well as Mr Staley tends to do everyone read your Bible word for word ask for understanding from above not man's understanding that's the problem everybody has we look to man to interpret instead of where we need to look I pray that you repent from this ridiculous teaching I understand if you don't want to follow the Torah Maybe you don't have to but for you to teach that it's incorrect and wrong and even sinful to be obedient that's a doctrine right from a sheol... I'm praying for you really I hope that you stop leaning on man for your understanding and lean to the actual scriptures

[@adamguy33]

It's yeshua , not yahushua like you wish because you think Jesus needs yah in front of it. Jesus is a transliteration from the hebrew to Greek to Latin and into English , are you English speaking if so you should us the correct name which is Jesus. And he freed us from the curse of the law just as if I never sinned once because that is the requirements buddy , I'm covered by the blood so I am perfect in the eyes of the Father, yesterday today and tomorrow , your decieved

[@YahuahsMaidServant]

@@adamguy33 no it's not... There was no e in the original language... Not to mention that takes away from the meaning of his name... Yahusha means Yahuah is salvation... Do you research...

[@YahuahsMaidServant]

@@adamguy33 so if you go to China does your name change?? Mine doesn't so why should YAHUSHA AND YAHUAH... IT'S NOT ABOUT ME IS YOU... RIGHT who do you worship yourself or them... Wouldn't you want to call them by their given names... Seems a little selfish to say you're not gonna call them what they want because YOU want to call them something else...

[@YahuahsMaidServant]

@@adamguy33 I also think you need to read your Bible... Where did it say you are perfect?? There was only one perfect and I'm pretty sure it wasn't you

[@adamguy33]

@@YahuahsMaidServant I have and your wrong , YHWH is original and during the time that Jesus walked the earth his name would have been yeshua and the new testament was written in Greek and yeshua in the Greek was iesus and that transliteration into English is Jesus , the lord created all the languages and Dr brown who has a PhD in this field knows that yahushua was definitely never used for the name of Jesus and the apostles all used the Greek translation of yeshua , you have been duped by the sacred name movement people who think you have to spell Jesus a certian way or use some form of ancient Hebrew which even that group is divided on spelling and pronunciations is simply wrong and divisive JESUS is the name of the son the the most high God creator of heaven and earth the one and only thrice Holy God of the universe

[@akb9107]

You’re hitting the nail on the head. This is one of the exact arguments that my in-laws use to defend their claim that “we must become Israel”. They watch Jim Staley. So now I know where they get it. Thanks so much for doing these videos, it’s helping tremendously.

[@straitmind4762]

I'm a Gentile believer who got grafted into the commonwealth of Israel so that now both Jews and Gentiles become one in Christ as Christians or Christ followers.

[@francisdeschamps1130]

Blood lineage is a dead argument people keep trying to rearrange into something that makes sense. It doesn't and cannot . Those who are in Christ are grafted in by faith alone . No descendance can earn you a place into God's kingdom . Romans 9:6 [...] They are not all Israel which are of Israel Romans 11:1 blood descendance Romans 11:26 all Israel will be saved Will the carnal posterity of Abraham make it into God's kingdom I'd they deny the Christ ? Because of their bloodline ? Surely not . Therefore why would Paul say "all Israel will be saved " if it is false ? Only a matter of interpretation. The only way to harmonize scriptures is to understand that we are grafted in by faith WHOEVER you were, Jew or gentile Romans 3:28-29 Keeping the law is not a matter of salvation, it is a proof that your heart has been renewed according to Ezekiel 36:26 , Jeremiah 31:33

[@achristianconvertedtochris5862]

Why do you say you are a gentile?

[@JerryLubis-v6g]

@@francisdeschamps1130 by faith it is

[@JerryLubis-v6g]

​@@achristianconvertedtochris5862 Romans 2:9-10 (KJV) Tribulation and anguish, upon every soul of man that doeth evil, of the Jew first, and also of the Gentile; But glory, honour, and peace, to every man that worketh good, to the Jew first, and also to the Gentile:

[@LarryCulp-oe8td]

Bot Jews who have been grafted in again, and gentiles who have been grafted into The True Vine, are Elect Israel, the ekklesia of God

[@pastorlordknows1]

I can boldly confess that the Hebrew roots are confused.....am facing problems in Ghana preaching such message

[@jimijames7703]

@pastorlordknows1 May God Be with you. Stand on Truth. We know WHEN the wind and rain comes that if we built on The Rock that we shall be alright Brother. 2 Timothy 3:12 Acts 20:19-31 gives me great comfort. Blessings dear Brother in Christ! From Kamloops BC Canada 🍁 Chaplain James 🙏🏼📖🙏🏼🌅

[@letmepicyou]

The Hebrews are also called Israelites. And the Israelites are the descendants of Adam. That would be WHITE PEOPLE, btw. NOT JEWS. There really is no reason to preach in Ghana. You should be preaching in the US, in Europe, and Russia. You know. Where Caucasians are. Because that's who the Bible is about.

[@BiblersWayCottage]

Mat 23:1 Then Yeshua spoke to the crowds and to His disciples, Mat 23:2 saying, “The Torah scholars and Pharisees sit on the seat of Moses. Mat 23:3 So whatever they tell you, do and observe. But don’t do what they do; for what they say, they do not do.

[@MavourneenKathleen-l5j]

So much of his perspective is Catholic.

[@jasonwthompson5003]

We are grafted in Romans 11 and we are the commonwealth of Israel Ephesians 2:12

[@veritas2145]

The commonwealth of Israel was made up of Israelites. The northern house of Israel was divorced and separated from that commonwealth back in the old testament… But under the new covenant a remnant of them were coming back into covenant relationship. That’s what Ephesians 2 is all about

[@pede8889]

​@@veritas2145amen. Especially the lost tribes and their genetic mixed multitude across Europe , the middle east, Africa , Asia etc.

[@veritas2145]

@@pede8889 this does not include the mixed multitude… The new covenant was made specifically with the house of Israel and the house of Judah. A house is a family of descendants… Lineage. The mixed multitude were not of the lineage of Jacob… The new covenant does not apply to them.

[@pede8889]

@@veritas2145 the ancestors of the lost tribes are mixed in their genetics and their false belief systems.

[@pede8889]

@@veritas2145 it is now a spiritual house. Not genetically Jew and gentile.

[@MannyfromdaD]

1 Timothy 1:4 nor to pay attention to myths and endless genealogies, which give rise to useless speculation rather than advance the plan of God, which is by faith, so I urge you now.

[@chaunceylumpp]

If you belong to Christ then you are Abrahams seed and heirs according to the promise( covenant) Gal 3:29

[@glenmorse9533]

Wow, I used to listen to Jim back around 2014 or so and believed that kind of stuff. I came out of that quite some time ago but still have a lot to learn. Thank you for defending the biblical roots of Christianity, you are a huge help to me with the truth, and I hope many see this and come out of that too.

[@anneolaug]

Happy for you, Glen!

[@RenoValance-df2iv]

Jim said nothing wrong and everything right, Jim is light years ahead in his anointing and brilliance

[@scottbenzing1361]

You have a right to self determination. Choose your status. I choose that I am Israel too, no longer, nor ever will be again a gentile.

[@freedominchrist444]

Try to make aliyah to Israel and tell them that. They will simply laugh. Only true physical descendants could make aliyah to Israel. Israel pretenders wont be allowed to live there. Its just like this transgender mess. U can whole onto your delusion that u r not a gentile and that you are an Israelite but facts prove u are deceived.

[@bugsocsollie1694]

I think you are still missing something vital. We (The Body of Christ Church) are not Israel. Israel is an earthly, Physical nation. We are not a nation, we are a Spiritual Body. Israel's Gospel is not the same Gospel that Jesus sent Paul to the Gentiles with. Two different Gospels for two different groups of people for two completely different purposes.

[@scottbenzing1361]

@@bugsocsollie1694 Oh, you misunderstood. I wasn't talking about the physical place and the physical people. I was talking about the spiritual people. When it's all said and done, "all Israel will be saved". Hence only one group, not two.

[@bugsocsollie1694]

@@scottbenzing1361 but what I'm saying is that it will be two people, not one. Our church today is not the same church as Israel. Two different churches with two different Gospels.

[@scottbenzing1361]

@@bugsocsollie1694 I used to think that way but not anymore.

[@MavourneenKathleen-l5j]

In my Catholic faith, was taught that all those who seek the Truth is what comprises Israel.

[@AProdigalSonReturned]

And if you already believe that the distorted image is the true one, you reject the masterpiece that God painted. My experience is that I saw we are supposed to be Israel (not ethnicay) through the scriptures about half a year before I had ever heard of HRM, Jim Staley, 119 Ministries, or any other teachings on this. I have still never read a word of Batya Wooten, and have never attended a church that taught any of this. While watching people like Jim or 119 Ministries, I always listen objectively. I try to tear their teachings apart. In the end it usually strengthens my case that we are supposed to be Israel (not ethnically). Many people rely on other sources, but I disregard all but scripture. I don't put my faith in historians, commentators, or even studied seminary graduates. Show me what the Word says, and I will adjust if I am wrong. The problem is that many want to feed you only what makes their narrative seem correct. They read three verses, but cover the surrounding ones with their hands. They link verses together that have no commonality, and try to feed it to you as a complete statement. I love to make connections in the Word. The majority of things discussed in the NT were references or prophecies that were made in the OT. Nowhere in the OT does it prophecy of God's law being done away with or changed. There were times when God told people not to keep His laws, but that was because they were breaking them. This is where we are at today. Why bother keeping Sabbath if you are an unrepentant murderer? Why are you bothering to keep from murdering if you won't even keep Sabbath? James 2:8-13 [8]If ye fulfil the royal law according to the scripture, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself, ye do well: [9]But if ye have respect to persons, ye commit sin, and are convinced of the law as transgressors. [10]For whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all. [11]For he that said, Do not commit adultery, said also, Do not kill. Now if thou commit no adultery, yet if thou kill, thou art become a transgressor of the law. [12]So speak ye, and so do, as they that shall be judged by the law of liberty. [13]For he shall have judgment without mercy, that hath shewed no mercy; and mercy rejoiceth against judgment. God wants all or none. Get off the fence. Lukewarm is in bwtween. These are the ones that divide God's law into categories to throw away two thirds. Someone commented that Jim was making it sound exclusive. It is. God has one people. Are we to believe that His people aren't called Israel? Whether spiritual or literal by adoption, would they not be classified as the Children of Israel? Who did God give all of His commands to through Moses? I understand that I can't convince anyone if the Word of God can't convince them.

[@barryblackwood6050]

Double thumbs up. If you listen to Jesus the Law stands with or without Temple & at the well with the Samaritan woman Yeshua intimated Jerusalem & the Jews who had the true (not fake) worship would be able to worship other places in Spirit using Truth. We are purified & grafted into that just as a Jew is sanitised from JUDAISM. This needs discerning for Gal 3 to not be mangled. My prayer is one day soon JUDAIZING will be correctly understood as Proselytism to JUDAISM which Yeshua clearly stated created hypocrites that were happy to make God's Law of non effect. So much so that they couldn't recognise Him...the One Moses wrote about ... Blessings.

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

Thanks, Barry. Almost 40% of the Law of Moses has to do with the priesthood and the temple services. So it is literally impossible to be Torah-observant without the temple (which Jesus predicted would be destroyed (Matt. 24:2; Mark 13:2; Luke 21:6). Much more than a jot or title of the law has passed. "You search the Scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life; and it is they that bear witness about me, yet you refuse to come to me that you may have life...For if you believed Moses, you would believe me; for he wrote of me." (John 5:39-40, 46) Blessings, RLS

[@AProdigalSonReturned]

@@TheBiblicalRoots That's like saying it was impossible for Jesus to be perfect because he couldn't keep the laws for women. There is a difference between done away with, and not able to be done. You believe more than jots and tittles have passed from the law? Is that preterist doctrine? Heaven and earth has passed away? Someone tried to tell me recently that Jesus' death was the passing away of heaven and earth. It's kind of funny, because if we say He is the embodiment of the Torah (the Word, if you will), they will laugh at us even though John actually says He is the Word made flesh. But then they turn around and say Jesus was heaven and earth with absolutely no connections to any scriptures. They don't even realize that their belief makes Jesus out to be a created being and not eternal. In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.

[@barryblackwood6050]

@@TheBiblicalRoots Yes that is true, Rob. But as a bishop lineage described in the ante Nicene Father's stated a 9 bishop lineage were taught by the Apostle John to follow the Mosaic Worship sans Temple or access to the Temple as non Jews... there appears to be a great misunderstanding of the Gospel lived out, This Instruction aligns with what Christ said to the woman at the well in regards to worship.. There is actually no clash at all except for dogma procluding the practice as an evil unnecessary addition as if it was forcing God to save us & also that the letter of the Law applies to those in the New Covenant instead of simply the fruit of Salvation & the works prepared beforehand for us to walk in by faith. Paul's words can be reconciled in knowing JUDAISM of the day to comprehend what actual JUDAIZING is. Paul doesn't have to go under the bus either. The more recent comment above is succinct ...we can't do what we can't but what we can, remembering the Law is Spirit & Life to those who obey it by faith in Christ. Blessings to you as well.

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

@@AProdigalSonReturned It's interesting that when John says that Jesus is the Word made flesh (John 1:14), he does not use the Greek word for "Torah/law" (nomos), or the word for Scripture (graphe): he uses logos. RLS

[@yeshuaislord3058]

I love this channel. I'm glad I found it

[@built4speed101]

Solberg made an interesting point about different nations being followers of Christ Jesus. I would add an additional point. Christ Jesus broke down the middle wall of the partition that separated the Gentiles from the Jews. Think of it in the time of the Tabernacle! There was an outer court for the strangers who believed in YHWH, but they weren't allowed to be in the inner court with the Hebrews because of Ceremonial Laws. But, now in Christ, we both dwell together in One Spirit and in One Faith. Amen Even replacing a wall with a fence, though smaller, still sets up a division in the midst of the Christian congregation. Galatians 3:26-29

[@yeshuaeselcaminoayhwh1861]

He always says the law of moises and never calls it rge law of God... this teacher spends all his time coming after us Hebrews, he is not going after catholics. Moumons or Jehovas witness, only torah observance beleviers, u ever wonder why???

[@biltontruth]

Does that make what he says about Torahism more or less true?

[@yeshuaeselcaminoayhwh1861]

@@biltontruth he has the spirit of Faraoh, what he doesnt understand is the more he comes at us the more we grow in number, he cant stop the profecy, he is conxerned about our growth. He cant sleep at night, and all his time and energy he uses to make videos about us. He should focus more what he believes.

[@biltontruth]

@@yeshuaeselcaminoayhwh1861 was there anything in Robs video that you don't believe is true?

[@jj_garcia7]

​​@yeshuaeselcaminoayhwh1861 You helping him grow by watching his channel lol thanks for your support.

[@jj_garcia7]

​@@biltontruthI wonder if he is going to answer you.

[@brandnewchristian777]

Keep up the good work. I am praying for your ministry🙏

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

Thank you so much!

[@MyLifeShortFilms]

Yaaassssss - I’ve just begun the video, and I’ve been wanting someone to do this on this Staley guy about this teaching.. “identity crisis”

[@playfoya]

Read my recent post @playfoya

[@beckyfrechette4439]

Chris Rosebrough did a long critique back in 2013 or 14 as well (Staley’s video came out in 2012 I believe). Very good!

[@PutOnTheNewWineskin]

​@@beckyfrechette4439hello and sorry to be so nosey, but I got a few Christians who are into the Hebrew roots movement and try to convince me that they are following the right thing... Is there anything you can give me as advice I can use as an argument against this?

[@apologeticevangelist5470]

Another great video!

[@BiblersWayCottage]

Psa 119:29 Remove from me the way of lying; and grant me Your Law graciously. Psa 119:30 I have chosen the way of truth; I have laid Your judgments before me. 2 Peter 2:2 And many will follow their destructive ways, because of whom the way of truth will be blasphemed.

[@LarryCulp-oe8td]

" Therefore do not let anyone judge you on what you eat or drink, or with regard to a religious festival, a New Moon, celebration or Sabbath day. These are a shadow of the things that were to come, the reality, however is found in CHRIST" Closians2:16-23

[@HarryHafsak]

Yeah. So if you read the entire letter you’ll find he is telling the church not to be discouraged into keeping the things God taught. You should read the front of the book. There are three biblical feast days that foreshadow the second coming. Furthermore if you’re are in the shadow of a substance, you are pretty close to it.

[@687christian]

​@@HarryHafsak ceremonial/ritualistic aspects of the Torah are not required for Gentile believers. Obviously, Torah was never abolished in it's entirety. Paul continually reaffirms the "moral" aspects of the Law (sexual immorality, loving each other, giving generously, etc.) throughout his letters. The Torah reveals sin. But he, being versed in the Tenakh, knew that before Israel, there was Abraham, Noah, Enoch, Abel. All these men were righteous and did have the Law of Moses nor circumcision to be considered righteous. The Law was instated for a fleshly people and for a theocratic nation. Thanks to the sacrifice and mission of Jesus, who perfectly upheld the Law's requirements and denied the oral tradition, allows Gentiles to be grafted in. God is not just a God of the Jews, but of the Gentiles. The official nation of Israel did not exist until after Jacob's descendants were liberated from Egyptian captivity. When the Sinai Convenant was given, it build upon the last. If you read the Torah closely, circumcision is a sign of the covenant between God and Abraham and his descendants. The Law of Moses requires physical circumcision to partake in the promises of the covenant and to partake in Passover, which is the only feast named explicitly to be followed. We never once see Paul imploring his Gentile audience to get circumcised before they can be grafted in and share in the promises of God's Covenant with Israel. Saving faith in Jesus Christ is what brings us into the fold. It is a spiritual circumcision. The spiritual reality overtakes the physical shadow. If not one jot or tittle has passed from the law, then Paul is a liar.

[@ashersian2563]

The distinction between the Ten Commandments and the other laws of Moses lies in their origin, purpose, nature, inscription, significance in Christianilty, location in the sanctuary: 1. Origin: - Ten Commandments: Also known as the Decalogue, these were given directly by God to Moses on Mount Sinai and were inscribed on two stone tablets (Exodus 20:1-17; Deuteronomy 5:4-21). - Other Laws of Moses: These include the ceremonial, civil, and moral laws that God gave to the Israelites through Moses, detailed primarily in the books of Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy. 2. Purpose: - Ten Commandments: These are fundamental moral principles intended to guide the ethical and spiritual conduct of all people. They are seen as universal and timeless. (Matthew 5:17-48) - Other Laws of Moses: These laws include detailed regulations for worship (ceremonial laws), guidelines for social justice and community living (civil laws), and additional moral directives. They were specifically given to the nation of Israel to govern their religious, social, and political life. 3. Nature: - Ten Commandments: These commandments are concise and comprehensive, addressing broad principles of morality and worship. (Exodus 20:1-17) - Other Laws of Moses: These laws are more detailed and specific, covering a wide range of topics from dietary restrictions to procedures for sacrifices and festivals. 4. Inscription: - Ten Commandments: Written by the finger of God on stone tablets, symbolizing their universality, permanence and divine authority (Exodus 31:18; Deuteronomy 9:10). - Other Laws of Moses: Written by Moses in a book (the Torah), indicating their role in guiding the daily life and worship of the Israelites (Deuteronomy 31:9). 5. Significance in Christianity: - Ten Commandments: Still relevant and applicable, forming a basis for Christian ethics. Written in the heart and mind in the new Covenant. (Matthew 5:17-48, James 2:8-10, Hebrews 8:10) - Other Laws of Moses: The ceremonial and civil laws were fulfilled by Jesus Christ and are no longer binding on Christians (Colossians 2:14-17; Hebrews 10:1-10). 6. Location in the sanctuary: -Ten Commandments: Placed inside the Ark of the Covenant (Deuteronomy10:2,5) -Other Laws of Moses: Placed by the side of the Ark of the Covenant (Deuteronomy 31:24-26) This distinction highlights the unique role of the Ten Commandments as a perpetual foundational moral code, while the other laws of Moses served to govern the specific covenant relationship between God and the nation of Israel.

[@CarlsonARTS]

Answer this: Matthew 15:24 24 "But he answered and said, I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel."

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

H Nicole! That's not a question, it's just a verse about Jesus' orientation during His earthly ministry. And that, of course, changed after He was resurrected and the New Covenant began. Then He said, "Therefore go and make disciples of *_all nations,_* baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, 20 and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you" (Matt 28:19-20, see also Acts 1:8). Shalom, Rob

[@veritas2145]

Just like I thought… He has no real answer for you. God doesn’t lie… Nor does he change. He came for Israel. Period

[@elliot7205]

​@@TheBiblicalRootsso he told his disciples to carry on preaching the law of Moses then?

[@deespence8629]

I grew up in the world wide church of god. They taught this nonsense! I think Armstrong got the idea from a group called the British Israelites. They said England was from the tribe of ephraim and America was from the tribe of manessah… I’m so thankful Jesus brought me out of those lies!

[@Briand-ei1gs]

God is revealing Israel's lost identity. The scales are falling from our eyes Those wicked inpostets in Palestine are of Cain Esau. White people are the sons of Adam. God is doing this and it will not be stopped. It is going to be fun watching it all go down. All the kabbalh based lies coming from. 501c government churches the last 50 years.They are going to come crumbling down. Even with power and control over all our nations and the ability to even control all the media it will still fall

[@paulamathis4617]

My parents were also of this church, i am so blesses to finally find this video. Its nonsense.

[@deespence8629]

@@paulamathis4617 agreed

[@BiblersWayCottage]

Mat 23:1 Then Yeshua spoke to the crowds and to His disciples, Mat 23:2 saying, “The Torah scholars and Pharisees sit on the seat of Moses. Mat 23:3 So whatever they tell you, do and observe. But don’t do what they do; for what they say, they do not do. Mat 28:18 And Yeshua came up to them and spoke to them, saying, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to Me. Mat 28:19 Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, immersing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, Mat 28:20 teaching them to observe all I have commanded you. And remember! I am with you always, even to the end of the age.”

[@RandomTChance]

Keep it coming Prof! 🕊️

[@gibbygirl6214]

Thank you so much for breaking down the beliefs of the Torah movement. I almost fell into it. It seemed a little off to me but I couldn't figure out what was so wrong about it. Thank you for clearly explaining the difference.

[@brandnewchristian777]

A scripture that adds to what you said in the great presentation is John 10:16 when Jesus Himself said- "And other sheep I have which are not of this fold; them also I must bring, and they will hear My voice; and there will be one flock and one shepherd."

[@bugsocsollie1694]

Yes, but just to be clear, this is also not referring to Gentiles. It's referring to Israel scattered abroad. It's who Peter was writing to and to whom James was written to. Paul was sent to the Gentiles after Israel fell in unbelief.

[@6969smurfy]

Yea? This is way out.of of contacts. It would serve you Well to do a word Study. The word "One" is "Echad". It's a Blending in perfect Alignment, an Archery Term for Hitting the Mark.

[@veritas2145]

@@bugsocsollie1694 those Gentiles that Paul was sent to were the scattered Israelites. One of many proofs is first Corinthians 10: 1-2

[@bugsocsollie1694]

@@veritas2145 There were many scattered Israelites among the Gentiles. 1 Peter was written to them. That's also who Jesus was referring to when He said that He had other sheep not of this fold. But they are not Gentiles, they're still Israel.

[@veritas2145]

@@bugsocsollie1694 I understand that Peter was writing to scattered Israelites… But Paul was writing to scattered Israelites as well. They were ethne(poorly TRANSLATED GENTILES). 1 Corinthians 10:1-2 makes it very clear that those Gentiles that Paul was addressing were in fact Israelites.

[@jonuvark2385]

Really good! Staley is very confused. He has a wonderful family. I hope they can discern his folly and bring him back to truth.

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

Hi, Jeff. Don't forget that the covenant spoken of in Exodus 19:5 is the one Yahweh called "my covenant that they broke, though I was their husband, declares the Lord" (Jer. 31:32). This is why God, in His mercy, brought us a New Covenant! Blessings, Rob

[@jimijames7703]

Jeremiah 3:8 Jeremiah 3:16

[@yosefyahu4778]

The Bible itself make is quite clear Mr. Solberg the distinction between "The House of Israel" and the "House of Judah!" Why do you misrepresent scripture? We must be grafted into Isreal, Just as Ruth the Moabitess! She is a picture of the Gentiles joining Israel, not Israel joining the Gentiles! You have it backwards Mr. Solberg! Have you not read Romans 11? 25:15

[@orlandonava9397]

Solberg - “Lost tribe of Israel does not exist in the NT”. Matthew - “These twelve Yeshua sent out with the following instructions: “Don’t go into the territory of the Goyim, and don’t enter any town in Shomron, but go rather to the lost sheep of the house of Isra’el.” ‭‭Matthew 10‬:‭5‬-‭6‬ ‭ *micdrop

[@sharonlouise9759]

This was so incredibly thorough! I appreciate all the time you put into it. He was just making stuff up. I probably would have gotten out of my seat and left. Bless you for your ministry to help those trapped into having to keep the Torah. Your information helps me as I encounter a Calvinist who believes we are to keep the old covenant law.

[@gooseneckapologeticsbonk7262]

We are unto 1 nation, flock, family of God being grafted in, called by his voice, adopted with christ amen. Rom 11; John 10:16; Rom 8:15; 9:26; Gal 3:26. Just wish we could work past all this and come together under Gods authroity being obedient in faih growing and standing firmly behind his will for us to be a light unto the nations so that all may come unto Him and His Glory.

[@gooseneckapologeticsbonk7262]

What we will sadly see is people agree w this but when applied properly disagree with its consequent.

[@MOUNTAINZION-kp6gi]

God bless and protect you and give you more knowledge

[@yeudybarbozacastro2564]

Thank you so much Rob. Been following for a more than a year now, and curiously this "documental" is how I was introduced to torahism, which then led me to your work. I know it took a lot of work from and I really appreciate it. God bless you and keep it up 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@HarryHafsak]

It’s not about being REQUIRED to keep the law. It’s about doing it out of obedience in love for God. No one is under the law. I don’t keep the sabbath in fear of being stoned to death if I don’t. I keep the sabbath because God ordained it and commanded us to remember it. The same reason I observed the feast of unleavened bread. Because that’s what pleases God, not that it was required by mosaic law.

[@AaronThinks]

Galatians 4:9 calls the observance of feast days weak and worthless. Where does Paul instruct the church to observe feast days to please God?

[@ashersian2563]

The distinction between the Ten Commandments and the other laws of Moses lies in their origin, purpose, nature, inscription, significance in Christianilty, location in the sanctuary: 1. Origin: - Ten Commandments: Also known as the Decalogue, these were given directly by God to Moses on Mount Sinai and were inscribed on two stone tablets (Exodus 20:1-17; Deuteronomy 5:4-21). - Other Laws of Moses: These include the ceremonial, civil, and moral laws that God gave to the Israelites through Moses, detailed primarily in the books of Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy. 2. Purpose: - Ten Commandments: These are fundamental moral principles intended to guide the ethical and spiritual conduct of all people. They are seen as universal and timeless. (Matthew 5:17-48) - Other Laws of Moses: These laws include detailed regulations for worship (ceremonial laws), guidelines for social justice and community living (civil laws), and additional moral directives. They were specifically given to the nation of Israel to govern their religious, social, and political life. 3. Nature: - Ten Commandments: These commandments are concise and comprehensive, addressing broad principles of morality and worship. (Exodus 20:1-17) - Other Laws of Moses: These laws are more detailed and specific, covering a wide range of topics from dietary restrictions to procedures for sacrifices and festivals. 4. Inscription: - Ten Commandments: Written by the finger of God on stone tablets, symbolizing their universality, permanence and divine authority (Exodus 31:18; Deuteronomy 9:10). - Other Laws of Moses: Written by Moses in a book (the Torah), indicating their role in guiding the daily life and worship of the Israelites (Deuteronomy 31:9). 5. Significance in Christianity: - Ten Commandments: Still relevant and applicable, forming a basis for Christian ethics. Written in the heart and mind in the new Covenant. (Matthew 5:17-48, James 2:8-10, Hebrews 8:10) - Other Laws of Moses: The ceremonial and civil laws were fulfilled by Jesus Christ and are no longer binding on Christians (Colossians 2:14-17; Hebrews 10:1-10). 6. Location in the sanctuary: -Ten Commandments: Placed inside the Ark of the Covenant (Deuteronomy10:2,5) -Other Laws of Moses: Placed by the side of the Ark of the Covenant (Deuteronomy 31:24-26) This distinction highlights the unique role of the Ten Commandments as a perpetual foundational moral code, while the other laws of Moses served to govern the specific covenant relationship between God and the nation of Israel.

[@educational4434]

And what will God do to you if you do not keep the Mosaic law? You say you are doing it out of love. So what if you decide for 15 years not to obey the law of Moses? During that time you would not be loving God, correct? And what will he do to you salvation-wise seeing as you have not kept his law?

[@ashersian2563]

@@educational4434 (1 John 2:3 KJV) And hereby we do know that we know him, if we keep his commandments. (1 John 2:4 KJV) He that saith, I know him, and keepeth not his commandments, is a liar, and the truth is not in him. (1 John 2:5 KJV) But whoso keepeth his word, in him verily is the love of God perfected: hereby know we that we are in him. (1 John 2:6 KJV) He that saith he abideth in him ought himself also so to walk, even as he walked. (1 John 3:4 KJV) Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law: for sin is the transgression of the law. (Romans 6:23 KJV) For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord. (1 John 1:9 KJV) If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.

[@ashersian2563]

@@educational4434 Empowerment by the Holy Spirit: - The New Covenant brings the indwelling of the Holy Spirit, who empowers believers to live according to God's will, thus enabling them to keep the moral principles of the Ten Commandments. - Ezekiel 36:27: "And I will put my Spirit within you, and cause you to walk in my statutes and be careful to obey my rules." - Romans 8:4: "In order that the righteous requirement of the law might be fulfilled in us, who walk not according to the flesh but according to the Spirit." (1 John 3:4 KJV) Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law: for sin is the transgression of the law. (1 John 2:3 KJV) And hereby we do know that we know him, if we keep his commandments. (1 John 2:4 KJV) He that saith, I know him, and keepeth not his commandments, is a liar, and the truth is not in him. (Romans 6:23 KJV) For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.

[@michamay755]

Mike Hoggard did several videos on Jim Staley and Hebrew roots and quoted Staley as saying "Jesus" came to him (Staley) and told him that the church has had everything wrong for 2000 years and that this "Jesus" - familiar spirit - was giving Staley the correct gospel. Also, Staley admitted his wife saw this entity behind him and was terrified. The Hebrew roots is not only another gospel, it is a doctrine of demons.

[@beckyfrechette4439]

Yes his testimony is a bit…off

[@RUT812]

@@beckyfrechette4439 𝑨 𝑳𝑶𝑻 wrong

[@larry7781]

I sure do enjoy your teaching

[@reboottheroot7803]

Mat 5:19 Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven: but whosoever shall do and teach [them], the same shall be called great in the kingdom

[@yosefyahu4778]

And heaven and earth are still here!

[@BiblersWayCottage]

Matthew 23:1-3 all they tell you from the seat of Moses do and observe

[@sarapetrucci4285]

Thank you for this teaching🙏🏻

[@kiruiandrew1]

Prof. What could this verse means Matthew 10:6 But go rather to the lost sheep of the house of Israel

[@BiblersWayCottage]

Here is a clue Genesis 48:19 Jeremiah 3:8 Romans 7 Romans 11:17-26

[@jesusnameaboveallnames7369]

06.24.2023 Your followers love & [respect!!!] you as well, Brother Solberg. I was caught up in the HRM for about year or so, the year before Covid. I was made to feel that Christians were horrible, calling Jesus by that name rather than Yeshua [or other names] was totally off the wall, not following any of the Laws of Torah was close to sending me to hell, not keeping the Fri-Sat as Sabbath, same thing. I could go on & on, but many did not like Paul. Said Paul's letters gave them a headache, etc, etc. But the one they had issue with me right off the bat was my screen name. 👑JESUS IS LORD👑

[@BiblersWayCottage]

What if you were dealing with tears or teenagers in spirit in a new walk God has opened many eyes too… Gods commandments are not burdensome but a blessing If you love Me keep My commandments

[@bartreauconstruction]

Why are there so many commercials on this video? I watched 3 hours of Jim Staley's teaching with 0 commercials, and every 5 minutes there is a commercial for your video... I agree there are some questions when it comes to Staley's lesson, but over all it fits with the words of the Bible

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

Hi, BC! Sorry for all the commercials. We need to monetize our videos to help cover the costs of production. And KZbin doesn't really give creators much control over which commercials are shown or how often. Blessings, RLS

[@bartreauconstruction]

@@TheBiblicalRoots do you not have faith that God will provide for a message that glorifies Him? You can't worship God and money

[@nataser2011]

God bless and your ministry! Keep fighting the good fight!

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

Thank you! Bless you, Rob

[@shawnhollahan590]

You had me until you started mocking conspiracy theories. 98% of conspiracy theories turn out to be true lately so I wouldn't be so quick to mock them. Secondly. I'm of Irish heritage and it has been shown that many ancient gaelic words are both similar in pronunciation and meaning to ancient hebrew thus indicating truth to a 'conspiracy theory' that we are descendants of the tribe of Dan.

[@joe1940]

Replacement Theology isn't Biblical. Some of it was rooted in antisemitism, but most of the people who pushed it couldn't imagine that Israel would become a nation again and needed a way to explain the scriptures that talked about Israel ( the Jews) coming back to the Lord in the last days.

[@gloriauselton9897]

You are so right! I was in the World Wide Church of God for many years from a young woman. I was shocked to realize how Biblically off we were. I didn't realize that Mr. Hurbert Armstrong was replacing the Jew's roles with his gentle church. Replacement theology.

[@letmepicyou]

The Jews are NOT ISRAEL. Just because they named their stupid country that, doesn't make them the Israelites of the Bible. They are NOT ISRAELITES and they are NOT HEBREWS.

[@wildrover9650]

Do a teaching what the NEW ONE MAN is please

[@peterhook2258]

Correction. Mormonism believes Christ didn't only teach in the USA but everywhere...so all peoples had a visit and records will eventually show it (per Mormonism). I study a lot of faiths including Mormonism and wanted to clear that up (as I believe Joseph Smith a prophet). I am really enjoying this guys teaching and study. I do believe he is doing God's will for us.

[@therevivalchurch4953]

Last year I took time stamped notes on all 3 hours of "Identity Crisis". His video has led many people astray, yet it ain't hard to look up and debunk his claims. I REALLY appreciate your videos. I hope more people will listen to them.

[@RenoValance-df2iv]

How n what is so drastically leading one astray 😂 this is nothing more than persecution towards Jim. I don’t see this guy going to Jim privately and confronting him with his problems. I dare him to debate Jim. Jim would leave him speechless

[@cornelisdevilliers4177]

Your statement that Gentiles do not include people from Israel ? Look how Paul defines these Gentiles : Therefore remember that at one time you Gentiles in the flesh, called "the uncircumcision" by what is called the circumcision, which is made in the flesh by hands- remember that you were at that time separated from Christ, alienated from the commonwealth of Israel and strangers to the covenants of promise, having no hope and without God in the world. But now in Christ Jesus you who once were far off have been brought near by the blood of Christ. Ephesians 2:11‭-‬13 ESV Now my dear Rob - it becomes evidently clear - these gentiles addressed here , is from the lost tribes of the House of Israel . AT THAT TIME , is the definitave phrase . So were do we find this event " AT THAT TIME " I know Ephraim, and Israel is not hidden from me; for now, O Ephraim, you have played the whore; Israel is defiled. Their deeds do not permit them to return to their God. For the spirit of whoredom is within them, and they know not the Lord. Hosea 5:3‭-‬4 ESV The divorce decree of God against the House of Israel , Jer 3 : 8 and they being declared "defiled " here in Hosea 5: 3-4 , not allowing them to return to God . Deut 24 : 1-4 But now this divorce decree had been annulled in the death of Christ - making it possible for the House of Israel that was divorced , to become part of the kingdom again . So you may consider your understanding of gentiles as only from the other nations . This is shown by Paul to be wrong . This is also plainly expessed in Rom 9 : 24 - 26 . Again gentiles mentioned here are indeed from Israel . Maybe an appology to correct your statement ? Take care and God bless Niel

[@l1Experiment]

AMĚN BROTHER SOLBERG, keep up the good work!!! AMĚN AND SHALOM SHALOM...

[@brigitteludwig4572]

Good Video, i love the Truth MisterSolberg

[@GarySpryJr]

26:14 "We have to go back to the Bible to let it define itself." "Here's what Wikipedia says.." Uh, does he not realize that Wikipedia is not the Bible?

[@yahuahisking8179]

Did this twat actually say that in the video?!?!? I haven't and won't watch this, as I don't listen to man, I fear Yahuah!

[@Ghost-pd1mz]

You cannot reject the son and claim to believe in the father. If you reject Jesus Christ as religious Jews do, then you have no connection to God.

[@toddott633]

52:19 You mentioned that the Old Testament sacrifices were never resurrected. When the burnt offering of offered the flesh of the animal is transformed and rises as a could of smoke, as if the animal were being resurrected.

[@aclark7970]

You quoted from "Easton's Bible Dictionary" in your program today. I hope before the next EASTER that you celebrate that you will also reference their definition for this word. In case you don't feel like looking it up, I am posting the entire entry to you which prove contrary to your earlier statement that it is a word REFERENCING THE PAGAN GODDESS OF SPRING! Passover is the word used in the Greek text of Acts 12, of which you should be aware having an advanced degree in theology. Hopefully you will repent, admit your error and acknowledge that the word EASTER has no place in the Christian's vocabulary and should not be applied to the celebration of Messiah's resurrection: Eastons Bible Dictionary Easter originally a ***Saxon word (Eostre), denoting a goddess of the Saxons***, in honour of whom sacrifices were offered about the time of the Passover. Hence the name came to be given to the festival of the Resurrection of Christ, which occured at the time of the Passover. In the early English versions this word was frequently used as the translation of the Greek pascha (the Passover). When the Authorized Version (1611) was formed, the word "passover" was used in all passages in which this word pascha occurred, except in Act 12:4 . In the Revised Version the proper word, "passover," is always used. www.biblestudytools.com/dictionaries/eastons-bible-dictionary/easter.html

[@r.a.panimefan2109]

Thing is ur wrong brother. I say this for your own peace of mind. Many conspiracy is untrue Easter is not pagon. It's real name is pasha. It was a passover celebration Easter yes the word is based on a goddess.... Um so was summer So wad the sun So is each day of the week Not just that the Greeks had a very active imagination Pain Nessesity Divine retribution Strife Hate Anger On and on and on I could go They are all. God's. So is panic. 😅 Yule is old norse for winter. ? Was there a nasty festival ya. But if there was a weather event pagans held a festival. Pompie. Hephaistus is angry. Oh ya eruption happened on his festival. Association causation fallacy

[@timw6110]

What we need is more debates. What needs arranged is a face to face midrash discussion with Jim, or Steve from Torah family, or Michael from olive branch.(sorry for not using last names for “credibility”). The structured debate was excellent with David gilbur on sabbath. Please arrange this. Im sure everyone is in agreement with this!

[@hopefulvoyage]

Wilbur..sp

[@jimharmon2300]

Debates are for entertainment only . Don’t think anyone is persuaded in the other direction. They leave with the same belief they came with .

[@timw6110]

@@jimharmon2300 most….not all. Seeds of truth take time to grow.

[@kdslight]

So great!

[@joanna6588]

Very helpful. Thank you.

[@Jazbo777]

If we are suppose to break the laws of G-D because the messiah already died Then why were the apostles still keeping that law ?

[@28calethea]

There was no in fighting God split tore the kingdom from King Solomon because of Solomon’s sins

[@billyhw5492]

Why can't you say Sabbath in English?

[@tonysmith131]

The Black Hebrew Israelites are telling the truth, by referring to the scriptures. Let take the Book of Deuteronomy and in particular Deuteronomy 7 6-7 , 14:2 , Jeremiah 14 2 KJV, 1 Peter 2:9 and Amos3:2, 9:7 KJV. The scriptures. tells you who they are and what will become of them in the later days. Deuteronomy 28 and Leviticus 26 KJV. This Biblical facts! What he is saying is not true and neither is the other gentleman that he is referring to. The Jews are all Black ! Revelation 2:9 and 3:9 KJV.

[@scottmoran9338]

Hi Rob A couple of things that stood out as I watched. Regarding the word Jew, I’m not too sure you could say the New Testament ever ment the whole kingdom of Isreal as you suggest. My reasoning is the new testament is written at a time where the Pharisees and Sadducee’s would never of included the northern kingdom as part of their tribe. The Northern kingdom more likely referred to as dogs or in a second class way. So tho we might refer nowadays as Jew meaning the whole kingdom, at the time of writing I can’t see this being the case. Also when you said Paul interchanges between Israelite and Jew as you say in Philippians, he is using each in a different sentence highlighting a different context. Citizen of Isreal, pointing back to heritage when all were one. I note he does not include ‘house’ in this sentence = Israelites Tribe of Benjamin, being house of Judah = Jew So in summery as much as you see some faults, I think you commentary can also mislead in the same way too by making errors where there are not. A open discussion type format between you two would be a good watch. It would be good for you to put your concerns to one another on your viewpoints and let the other answer. And also to see where you both agree, and where you both disagree. That way maybe we can all grow and learn from one another. Rebuttals videos I’m afraid do more to divide the kingdom than edify and bring together. After all one only rebuts from one’s own belief and interpretations. On a side note, how about a few less adverts on the next one. Every 5 minutes seems a bit extreme and you don’t seem like your that hard up for cash😉 Shalom

[@jimijames7703]

@scottmoran9338 May I take a moment to point out why I believe you actually have faulty logic in a different way than may be expected? You ask Rob to put less adds on his channel-like he’s able to control the amount-he doesn’t have the time to manually control the number of adds. Secondly did you hear anything on this presentation?

[@jimijames7703]

@scottmoran9338 Do you think Paul was being divisive when he stated “Now I urge you brethren note those who cause divisions and offences contrary to THE DOCTRINE which you learned and avoid them.” How about about 2 Timothy 6:3-5 ? What about when Jesus said “HYPOCRITES” How about John saying “Brood of vipers!” ?

[@beckyfrechette4439]

Im guessing you are in the Torah movement yourself?

[@codyalexander3290]

@@beckyfrechette4439the Torah movement is a beautiful thing

[@beckyfrechette4439]

@@codyalexander3290 its a false gospel that Im so glad to be delivered out of.

[@keittkatranch5167]

Believing Jews and believing Gentiles form spiritual Israel.

[@bugsocsollie1694]

That's not true. Paul's Gospel is different than the Gospel that Jesus preached and sent out the 12 and the 70 to preach to Israel only. Paul was sent to the Gentiles because Israel fell in unbelief. Salvation WAS of the Jews, but because they fell, salvation has come to the Gentiles. Romans 11:11 Two different Gospels for two different groups of people for two completely different purposes. We both (Israel and the Body of Christ Church) have an inheritance in Christ but it's not the same inheritance.

[@veritas2145]

@@bugsocsollie1694 those Gentiles that Paul was sent to were the previously divorced and scattered Israelites primarily of the northern house of Israel. Go read first Corinthians 10:1-2

[@jacobstrouble4273]

This fellow is presenting a straw man argument to decieve the listener into disobedience. The gentiles grafting is into the common wealth of Israel. Israel are those who have the testimony of Yeshua and keep the commandments of God. Simple. This fellow and his doctrine is grafted into Rome. Anytime someone spend half an hour explaining the simple truth you know hes full of it.

[@yahuahisking8179]

And further, by these, my son, be admonished: of making many cepheriym there is no end; and much study is a weariness of the flesh. 👉Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter: Fear Elohiym, and guard his commandments: for this is the whole duty of man.👈 For Elohiym shall bring every work into judgment, with every secret thing, whether it be good, or whether it be evil. QOHELETH (ECCLESIASTES) 12:12-14 את CEPHER This is pretty clear to me!

[@dorinamary7863]

People misunderstand this. It doesn't say the Gentiles are grafted in. It says they are grafted "back" in, or grafted in "again". That changes everything, no? How can you graft into an olive tree anything that isn't an olive?

[@jacobstrouble4273]

@@dorinamary7863 Go back to the Abrahamic Covenants or Covenants of promise. Given before his circumcision meaning that this covenant announced the grafting of the uncircumcised which is fulfilled at Sinai with the mixed multitude being recognized as fellow heirs provided they maintain covenant fedelity. That has not changed as Gala 3 tells us that that Covenant with Abraham by God through Christ has not been annulled by by the failure golden calve. Because it was by promise. So if it were not for The covenants of promise today's gentile would have no way to legally graft in. Because there is 0 covenants given to gentiles. Jer 31:31 makes this clear ahead of time. The guestion of "law" or no "law" was on the minds of the Jewish and the gentile as it is today and Paul over and over points out that Messiahs work on the tree restores the covenants of promise which includes the festivals, or high Sabbaths, weekly Sabbaths and the Ten words and assorted agrarian laws or statutes. But being that most of the believing community does not live in Israel the ten and festivals should be observed like in Acts. Shavuot or pentacost, Passover and the fall feasts as well as the Sabbath are all kept by Paul and the gentiles he ministered to. So if there was a change at the cross then Paul and the Jerusalem council never got that memo. Simply put, they all observed the covenant requirements in the Torah that were agreed upon in exodus 19-24. Because the Aaronic sacrificial system was allowed to perish like John who was the last living corrupt Levite Cohen or priest. Now you why John was left to give up his spirit. Symbolically representing the sacrificial system no longer had a place with Yeshua being the High Priest of the Melchizedek priesthood. Please read Acts and see for yousrelf the gentile conversion/grafting process unfold.

[@timarnett672]

WOW? THE STRANGER AND THE GENTILE, ARE NOT NOT SYNOMYNOUS TERMS? IF YE READ EPHESIANS 2, PAUL MAKES IT CLEAR WHAT A GENTILE IS EPHESIANS 2:11, 12 11 Wherefore remember, that YE being IN TIME PAST GENTILES in the flesh, who are called Uncircumcision by that which is called the Circumcision in the flesh made by hands; 12 That AT THAT TIME ye were WITHOUT CHRIST, being ALIENS FROM the commonwealth of Israel, and STRANGERS FROM the covenants of promise, HAVING NO HOPE, and WITHOUT GOD in the world: YOUR TEACHING IS VERY DANGEROUS.

[@loving_people]

The northern tribes were not Jews.

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

Actually, according to the Bible, all twelve tribes were called Jews. (Esther 3:6, 10; Dan. 3:8, 12; Ezra 4:12; 5:1, 5). RLS

[@jimharmon2300]

@@TheBiblicalRoots Are not all these verses speaking of the ones that were from Judah ?

[@RenoValance-df2iv]

This bloke is misconstrued what Jim was pointing out.

[@CupOJoeOuttaIdaho]

They came back in Acts and the OT age (old heavens and earth) Revelation is about the first century and closing out the OT age

[@lavieenrose5954]

Amen my friend ❤

[@educational4434]

It's weird that the person being discussed here even resorts to two house theology when it is unnecessary. Because what the scriptures actually describe is that the gentiles are grafted into Israel and are therefore part of spiritual Israel due due to their belief in the promise to Abraham as expressed through Jesus. It's that simple. There's no complication here. If you have believed upon Jesus then you are Israel

[@Lotsajoyus]

The “root” of my faith is in Israel, not Rome.

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

Amen.

[@theportroyal7626]

Really appreciate your work Rob, just wondering if you’re planning on doing any content related to rejecting Orthodoxy/Catholicism? Not a lot of Protestant content out there, and the small amount that there is doesn’t go very deep, it would be awesome to hear your take on things! Praise Jesus!

[@luislopez-kw4qq]

I like to say that is important to read the word of God in, Galatians 4:21-31... like Isaac we are children of the promise.

[@BelindaTN]

Thank you for this. And good job.😊

[@elijahirvin5911]

Ephesians 4.17-4.24. what is righteousness and true holiness. Torah

[@danieljohnson5742]

Still doesn't change the fact that Israel was never a ethnic designation only it was a covenant designation through faith

[@gregorywilliams3769]

I came to Christ by Faith.

[@walkinginthegodgiven-jerem5502]

A great book for traditionalist to read is the book Dietrich bonehoffer called. THE COST OF DISCIPLESHIP by Eric metaxas Phenomenal book, cheap grace and trampled grace is what 99% of the church world teaches. Bonehoffer teaches amazing and every believer must read this book.

[@Jazbo777]

This is the first time my husband and I have ever heard of or listened to Staley He does sound alittle confused in your clips of him But you sound very slippery to us also😅

[@zionhillhill9913]

The Biblical Isrealites were a lineage, not a country. The Roman empire is modern-day Europe. Eden (Aden) is in Africa, still on the Map. Revelations clearly state that you will be judged by your works, so I don't understand the doctrine of "Saved by faith and not works."

[@elroi8325]

Thank you prof! Praise God for you😇

[@matthewjohnson6360]

Jim is SDA

[@grittupfer7507]

I found this video helpful and important. You are so kind and wise. Thank you for correcting false teachings.

[@timeless1563]

When ppl find out that I don't do easter or christmas, they ask me if I am Jewish. I say no. I say I'm like Abram/Abraham. I'm a Hebrew. I've crossed over as Abraham did. He was not a Jew nor an Israelite. He was a man who heard the call of our Father telling him to turn his back on man's ways and walk in His Word. To obey His Word by following His Instructions, which by the way are NOT Laws (mans mistranslation). Man's doctrines are laws. Not the Father's. I haven't watched this whole video yet, but my heart dropped when I saw the title and read some of the comments. Ppl have been so conditioned by man. Mislead by man made doctrines and traditions. I know. I was once there. Since 2013, layers of religious doctrine have been peeling away and I have been released from false teachings. What most ppl don't realize is that all 41,000+ religions were cultivated by the teachings and traditions of our Father and what Yeshua exampled. But they were changed into something more "manageable" to allow control over people and to also put a veil up between them and Truth, His Word. Which by the way has NEVER changed! But man changed it. This false teacher and those that believe the words that are spoken in this video...I believe that not all is lost. This man and all those still shackled to man's theology will one day have eyes that SEE and ears that HEAR. I just hope it is before his return.

[@TheBiblicalRoots]

Thanks for sharing your story, Timeless! It is a lot more common than you might think. And, with all due respect-and I say this out of love in the hope that you can see it-you have not been shedding "man-made doctrines." You've merely switched from one set of "man-made doctrines" to another. I say this because the new view you've come to embrace was taught to you by a man. (Based on the language in your post, my guess would be Jim Staley.) I would really encourage you to spend a few hours working your way through the Gospels all by yourself, focusing on the words of Jesus. Because in them, you will find life. Blessings, Rob "You search the Scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life; and it is they that bear witness about me, yet you refuse to come to me that you may have life." (John 5:39-40).

[@timeless1563]

@@TheBiblicalRoots Thank you for being more respectful than my immediate family who are still shackled to man's doctrines.

[@yahuahisking8179]

Well said timeless! And further, by these, my son, be admonished: of making many cepheriym there is no end; and much study is a weariness of the flesh. 👉Let us hear the conclusion of the whole matter: Fear Elohiym, and guard his commandments: for this is the whole duty of man.👈 For Elohiym shall bring every work into judgment, with every secret thing, whether it be good, or whether it be evil. QOHELETH (ECCLESIASTES) 12:12-14 את CEPHER The word is SO clear, just read ALL of Ecclesiastes, and then it boils down to the verse posted above.... Revelations is pretty clear too, the ONLY ones entering in through the gate, to eat of the tree of life, are those living in obedience to Yahuah!

[@timeless1563]

@@yahuahisking8179 ❤️ Shalom

[@yahuahisking8179]

@@timeless1563 shalom!

[@shawnhollahan590]

Ok.. I listened all the way thru. I think you're great. This makes a huge amount of sense Coincidentally I read Hebrews 7-10 today which talks about this. I have friends that have adopted Jewish ritual and calendar as christians and they are projecting 'holier than thou' attitude. I'm glad to know the truth. Thank you.

[@saramartin623]

You have been deceived into thinking being holy is a bad thing when you say that. We are supposed to be holy, please see the proving scriptures Leviticus 11:44 For I am the Lord your God. Consecrate yourselves therefore, and be holy, for I am holy. And you shall not make yourselves unclean with any of the swarming things that swarm on the earth Leviticus 11:45 For I am the Lord who brought you up from the land of Egypt to be your God; thus you shall be holy, for I am holy.’” Leviticus 19:2 “Speak to all the congregation of the sons of Israel and say to them, ‘You shall be holy, for I the Lord your God am holy. Leviticus 20:26 Thus you are to be holy to Me, for I the Lord am holy; and I have set you apart from the peoples to be Mine. 1 Peter 1:16 because it is written, “You shall be holy, for I am holy.” Leviticus 20:7 You shall consecrate yourselves therefore and be holy, for I am the Lord your God.

[@lindarobey8935]

There are no "lost" tribes of Israel. God knows where all the "so called lost tribes" are.

[@dotero1817]

You were being kind when you said he's speculating.... it's blatant storytelling with no biblical foundation to support it, as you and others in the comments have so aptly proved. Thank you for this excellent teaching! God bless

[@mi66gt80]

Who is it that Jesus is talking to in Matt 7 when he says get away from me you workers of inequality?