If Arthur didn't stop Bill, we could have had a happy ending

[@alexfill86]

Would like see the dialogue where Arthur didn't step in.

[@starthurmorman]

was wondering what would happen too

[@NHSofEngland]

People who deluded themselves with “happy endings” forgot RDR1 itself existed 8 years prior. Arthur would have been shot like a dog by the Pinkertons, and adds to the footnote of plot devices set for RDR1. And that’s your “happy ending”.