IGN Reviews - Max: The Curse of Brotherhood - Review

The Curse of Brotherhood is a beautiful platformer, but its lush graphics only mask the frustrating controls.

[@CollegeWithCorey]

I usually don't buy games like this but decided to yesterday. It's actually a really fun game. I'm really happy with my purchase. For those that don't want to get it because you think it's a little kid game. Yes, the art style is more kid friendly but the game is actually challenging at some points. If you liked Limbo then this is a must buy!

[@Scoobysteakz]

This is a very bad review. 'Can only use a small amount of ink', well, no shit. That's what makes the game challenging. She must have some fucked up controller as well as the controls are extremely simple, and easy to use, hence little to no instruction. This game is fantastic.

[@apexwolf5]

Agreed 100%

[@dimesta55]

This game is awesome. The controls are fine, I didn't have a problem with the markers. IGN please get people that know how to use controllers to review games. This indi game is well worth the money a must buy.

[@skeeter4900]

People have different opinions, obviously hers was different than yours.

[@vartianreznor9018]

skeeter4900 you say diferent opinion but it supouse ign its a web site where profesional people work and its supouse they have to know how to use the control if they don`t know what their doing working there

[@JohnRyan44444]

Omg she seems to be complaining because the game is not easy for them and the it was too challenging. Boo fucking hoo! Yes the game is challenging and there's a lot of trial and error just to solve the puzzles which what makes the game great. Guess people want a game to hold their hand the whole time . For me it should least be an 8 out of 10 in my opinion

[@BizzleReal]

+SamDakota86 do i download it or what is it good ?

[@miggs80]

ChrisPerez86 It appears you’re easily triggered when people have a different opinion than you on games. You must be a real ladies man lmao.

[@OSW]

Cheers. Sounds like it'll be a fine 3DS port!

[@V-Jes]

or wii u or vita even

[@kyloctopus]

mywlan2 Considering Max and the Magic Marker was on Wiiware first, I think it would be fitting.

[@mcdonaldsd5615]

It would be great to guide the marker with the 3ds's stylus or even with your finger on the oled touch screen for the vita!

[@PatrickEsdamX]

Kyle Silva Press Play, the Danish team making this game has been bought by Microsoft, so don't count on it.

[@kyloctopus]

***** At least PC is still an option, it would be a bit better with mouse+keyboard combo.

[@Snowbau5]

I'm having no issues with the controls, the game is fantastic so far.

[@kenshijavi]

This is probably the worst review IGN has ever done! This games was AMAZING in every way!!!

[@carlosvega4735]

Not according to the critics, the game is a 6 or a 7 www.metacritic.com/game/xbox-one/max-the-curse-of-brotherhood The Wii U controller, the Steam Machine and the PS4 all have a touch interface controller These low scores by the critics are just a way to tell Microsoft their controller is missing features

[@kenshijavi]

Carlos Vega have you play the game?

[@AADdope7]

Carlos Vega dont ever listen to metacritic theyre full of shit

[@okidoki3191]

Seriously, game still holds up, controls are great! 8

[@BenjaminAquino]

It is too bad this is exclusive to the Xbox One as I think any type of drawing heavy game would work best on Wii U because of the Gamepad. Maybe then the score could have been slightly better.

[@umarbajwa101]

Yeah, at the very least they could have put it on the Windows Store so that tablets could play it

[@AlphaZeroX96]

The game is not bad at all. IGN is lying to you, see this is why I hate IGN so much. IGN's reviews are taken completely seriously by some gamers, and they end up playing games that are bad if said to be good, or wonderful if the game was said to be bad. Don't listen to IGN!

[@nintentap2ndaccount559]

Its now on switch so

[@patsybob]

At least she doesn't sugarcoat it like most of the other IGN reviewers do.

[@AreYouHappyYet]

Really bad review. This game is really fun.

[@evilfangs]

I loved this game, the controls where no problem for me.

[@CoburnSawyer]

Same

[@bradleyhird1735]

This is a terrible review the controls are fine and the puzzles can be quite hard which is obviously what has trumped her and she's blaming it on the game mechanics 6 out of ten is an absolute shambles this game is a solid 8 and probably one of the better games I've purchased for my next gen console ign reviewer hang your head in shame poor poor review .. But then again what would u expect from ign

[@RejectAllCookies13]

ok I understand the marker isnt accurate but to give this game a 6 is a disgrace

[@hdaviator9181]

I am tired of this "Next Gen" bullshit. What does it even mean? These new consoles are just graphics upgrades. Everything else are just gimmicks. Developers don't just create wonderful games simply because new hardware is available.

[@SuperBearPoo]

I'm pretty sure that it wouldn't be possible for last gen consoles to fit as many zombies on one screen as Dead Rising 3 has. Thus, not just graphic upgrades.

[@hdaviator9181]

Mayo Rice Putting more zombies on screen doesn't change the way a game is played. It just means you have more things to kill. These "journalists" keep saying that next gen is some sort of magical moment when game design is going to change. I am just saying that is bullshit. Also, more zombies on screen are not necessarily a next gen feature. I mean, they could have done that on PC 2-3 years ago if they wanted to.

[@SuperBearPoo]

PC doesn't have generations. "Next gen" is obviously only referring to consoles.

[@hdaviator9181]

Mayo Rice But you see, that is what I mean. Its all bullshit.

[@farmeryaeg]

I actually liked the controls in this game. It took me about 4 levels to get used to, and I never had a problem afterwards. The chase scenes, in my opinion, were where this game shined--as well as the last scenarios with your brother. The boss battle was a tad tedious, though.

[@evilfangs]

Didn't even take me that. The controls weren't a problem for me.

[@isse24]

I think that ign is starting to hate games that have actual gameplay in them

[@divine942]

This is such a terrible review this game was my childhood and I still play it to this day, it’s not meant to be an adult role play game it’s meant for you teens and kids, in my opinion it’s a great game

[@thekingcastle]

This game is a work of art, shame there's not a second one

[@jayblueridgesumilhig]

This game should be on PS VITA, it'll work well w. the touchscreen and touchpad

[@abeisodd]

Just finished the game had my doubts in the beginning thinking it was a generic 2d platformer but marker adds a whole new depth to it it's a must play super fun.

[@thekingcastle]

This game is underrated

[@pilksuk]

On 3DS, Vita or even Ipad this game would make more sense and be a lot more enjoyable.

[@GameBantz]

Deserves at least a 7, 6 is too harsh.

[@dennismylastname5031]

obviously not for her...

[@Assassin11223344]

If this was released for ps4 then ign would have given a 9 or 9.5 for sure.. :D :P

[@GameBantz]

***** the controls feel like an extension from your body and continue Nintendo's seamless gameplay to story integration YADA YADA YADA

[@skeeter4900]

BlaZe Sachdeva The ignorance is strong in this one.

[@hjclevel]

This game works fine on the xbox. The controls are very easy to use. I dont know why this lady had a big issue with game.

[@Specialist01]

I didn't have any problems with the controls of this game. It sounds to me like she is just too incompetent to correctly play the fucking game. I liked this game a lot more than I thought I would. Don't let the crappy reviewer deter you from playing this great little game.

[@AlphaZeroX96]

Cad80 24, the controls on the 360 version are not horrible. You're just not good with it or didn't get used to it.

[@stampiboy1]

I just completed this game and come her to understand WHY NO ONE IS TALKING ABOUT THIS AMAZING GAME ! its in game pass i usually download games from gamw pass , ea access , gold , free games and demos just to have a full library of games , but this kids game was a surprise ! I did not expect it to be so challenging at some points) and im not talking about fast phase moments no , i talk about parts where no one is chasing you ,you got ALL time in the world but you sitting there and thinking what the hell)))

[@claimingagate]

The minions are frustrating

[@bakangrabai8078]

When are they making a sequel? This game is very similar to Planet Lana.

[@filiphowaniec9513]

Sadly there will be no sequel,press Play was sold.I Remember playing this game back on 2013.Greetings from Poland

[@Alekouzos]

whaaaaat? Only 6? Wtf people? This game worth at least 8. Very fun to play and not so hard. Enjoyable.

[@CloudCuckooCountry]

I want to posit that Kinect probably wouldn't have made drawing any easier.

[@LittleLionRawr]

This should have been on Wii U..

[@ldavidson11]

Bad review. ... this game is awesome. . Great controls, great graphics, worth every penny 8.5/10

[@AshXXMayftw]

Would have been perfect on the WiiU.

[@kaiserxblue]

Let me guess, cause it's a "kiddie" game?

[@AshXXMayftw]

Deathstroke No because of the gamepad. You could draw using the touch screen.

[@AshXXMayftw]

***** They could have done what Rayman Legends did, make each level on rails where you have to interact with the game and on the WiiU version the game is also playing on the Gamepad.

[@eduardogatoify]

i bet my ass off, if this was a ps4 game this would be a fuckin master piece for ign

[@sombrerosamurai]

Its a puzzle game, they are always difficult and rating it a 6.0 because it was too hard is a bit silly. Maybe somebody who likes puzzle games should review it. I am not a puzzle game fan myself but me knowing this was a puzzle game when I picked it up I knew what to expect. I think a 7.5 is more of a realistic rating.

[@BizzleReal]

+Brandon Canterbury do i download it or what is it good ?

[@sombrerosamurai]

Bizzle If you like puzzle games I'd say depending on price to. The game is good enough at 15-20 dollars

[@BizzleReal]

Brandon Canterbury are you stupid they created uttorent for us to download games for free

[@BizzleReal]

cad80 24 bro than tell me what Anime game shuld i play name a goood ANIME game i shuld play any ideas ?

[@BizzleReal]

?

[@rstelford3532]

This reviewer had a very different experience to my own. I got this on a whim on Xmas day when my nephews and niece came round and we had a ball. They picked up the controls no problem (they're aged 6-12) some of the puzzles were above them but for the most part they were fine. I'd give it a solid 7.5. Nice little surprise.

[@tanka9976]

still better than killzone and knack. #failstation

[@Xburnerfy]

How much is Microsoft paying you? Seriously i want to know.

[@gamingmurshid]

knack is still better than the fighter within. #fuckyou i am hating on u not xbox xbox is great

[@DEVIL9999ish]

U Mad ?

[@gamingmurshid]

not really.

[@V-Jes]

gamingmurshid yes xbox (original) was great but didn't have many exclusives

[@EB_SEB]

Just purchased it on the Nintendo Switch. I'm pretty sure the mechanics, thanks tongue touch screen, won't be a problem at all. Really looking forward to playing it once the download is finally completed.

[@brandonow82]

Max's cool hair alone makes this game a 7!

[@stillirise85O]

This is a good game... This score is too low. This is a creative, entertaining and fun game to play. Don't miss out on a good experience Because of this review. I have a feeling that if this was a Mario game they would have given the game a 9.5.

[@cravis123]

This looks like "The heart of darkness" from PS one. That was really great!

[@valliathan1]

Poor review...this was an interesting game after a hectic day and relaxing on eyes.

[@Hfajardo97]

This game is meant for the Wii U and PS4 more than the Xbox One. The Wii U with the gamepad could have made this work better and the PS4 with the touchpad would have worked the best or even with the PS Vita. The PS3 with the motion controller would have worked great too, same with the Wii. Again, anything but the Xbox One.

[@yornkunitachi]

No this game should have never exist anyway it's a rip-off of Meet the Robinsons.

[@obuix2005]

u forgot the kinect , and the touch-pad on the ps4 cant do shit its too small and only good for basic commands .

[@delirium4327]

the ps4 is strong with this one.

[@TheMasterpieceArtist]

if this was made by nintendo they wouldve given it a 10 skyward sword had broken controls and they gave it a 10

[@tmlguy24]

Great game! Controls are fine great pick up :)

[@khaliljack6138]

No IGN it's deserve at least 8/10

[@ultracastillo]

is she the voice of ruby from max and ruby ???

[@MrSomeGamerdude]

"...it feels weird that this Xbox Exclusive..." it looks weird being on on xbox too when i saw the maker and hearing the exclusive part.

[@Famitrack]

This game would work better on the WiiU or 3DS. Vita too.

[@kevinkevinson2107]

...Why?

[@Famitrack]

Think about it for a sec what do all those consoles have in common? ...... Figured it out yet? .... Still thinking? .. They all have a touch screen. Think game would work extremely well with a touch screen because it allows you to be more precise then using an analog stick to control the pen.

[@kevinkevinson2107]

Sonic The Hedgehog Oh. I realise how stupid I sounded their. Yes, I agree. Maybe Microsoft will have a windows 8 version for its tablets. Even though the movement controls would be bad, the pen controls would be improved. I thought the stick worked fine though.

[@Famitrack]

Yeah the stick isn't bad but this game would have been awesome with a touch screen.

[@delirium4327]

The controls on the xbox one aren't difficult to manage.... could be better with a stylus though.

[@ClammsCove]

one of the worst things someone can do in an objective review is giving an opinion of the levels and stuff like that.

[@Nintendude4life]

Reviews by their nature are subjective you fool. It's someone giving their opinion on a game. Many others may have a different opinion about the controls because it's subjective sometimes.

[@ClammsCove]

Retcon but they're not supposed to be subjective, if you're rating a game people might be stupid to follow before thinking of buying a game you have got to be as objective as possible.

[@Nintendude4life]

You give subjective points and back them up with objective facts, that's a review.

[@bchwil]

MrRorschach93 People shouldn't read one review and go "I'm (not) buying this game" They look around and if the general consensus is bad then dont get it

[@hens117]

she just bad at the game, i have it and it pretty easy to use.

[@Hijynx87]

Wait they didn't use the Kinect for the drawing......and it's an xbone exclusive?! =p. This game should have been on 3ds, Wiiu or psvita.

[@up-art2212]

Perfect game. Controls are fine but you need to know how to use rhe sticks fast. Very fun platformer.

[@EvilLeBron]

THIS IS XBOX?!?!?! Holy shit, I thought this was a WiiU game. Thank Galactus for PS4

[@TheMaestro116]

***** Flower looks better imo. But then again, few can beat thatgamecompany in terms of art direction and atmosphere.

[@Ridion21]

***** FLOWER?? no no no no no. It looks 100x better than this shit.

[@EvilLeBron]

Batnab No really?...I didn't get that when I watched the review. So insightful

[@EvilLeBron]

AADdope7 You have succeeded in being a fanboy...your prize is in the mail.

[@xxaleuthewolfxx]

Ridion21 They look almost the same, I'm not trying to start a fight, but I have seen both of them while they're being played and they look almost the same, plus they're both indie games, don't expect much of a difference in the graphical aspect on them

[@TheFaustusPHD]

This is definitely not my style of game, but I really enjoyed it, collectibles, mission replays, puzzles. Not too bad for a cheap download game. (better than some retail ones that I have bought)

[@yornkunitachi]

So you gave Knack a 5.9 while this is 6.0? WTF?!

[@RaptorPegasus]

1:59 Painfully obvious that you missed for the sake of the (incredibly unfair) review

[@jakemike4116]

just finshied playing the game it was amazing i hope they make a sequel to it :)

[@dockingtwo3403]

Jake Mike I think that it is a sequel but I’m not sure. I remember seeing something that said this a sequel or something

[@Wazoo3000]

I guess People can't complain about Knack anymore. ^_^

[@HippyGoLuckyHomestead]

Not perfect but I'm loving up fun and difficult

[@Shauniny]

I bought MAX: The Curse of Brotherhood yesterday, it's fantastic! Vibrant colours and beautiful level design. I keep hearing about "the marker is horrible to control" do you know how to use the controller? It's completely fine! Definitely a must buy for its price!

[@vids2002]

For those saying this would have been better suited for other consoles should know that integrating smart glass easily would make her biggest gripe null

[@SIsForSteppi]

I'd definitely give it a 7-7.5! It's extremely satisfying and even reminded me of Limbo at some points (Not only because it's a 2D game..). I also think, the amount of Ink was always well thought-out!

[@Requ1escat1nPACE]

I dream of the day when IGN stops trying to review games and just sticks to news. That's what their good at.

[@clubdudv9143]

Sure this game is not perfect, but damn kind of a harsh review!! I thought this was a really good platformer. But I guess we all have different opinions.

[@tannerjorgenson]

IDK.. I kind of disagree with this review. I really enjoyed the game. Maybe this girl just sucks at it lol.

[@geebaucham]

This game was fricking great! So rewarding to figure out tough puzzles. Story does suck because it's so shallow, but it's a solid 8 for fun factor and the undying urge it gives you to push on and conquer your next challenge.

[@GameTerminal]

how in the world were the controls a problem for her?? my 10 year old nephew got the hang of it within the first few seconds.. and the point of not having enough ink is for the challenge---it's supposed to challenge you. guess the reviewer doesn't like being challenged...

[@ganglewak]

Just started my 2nd playthrough to collect the evil eyes I missed, love this game!!! hopefully a sequel is being considered

[@AreYouHappyYet]

The controls are fine. The game has almost a perfect 5 stars out of 3 thousand votes on Xbox LIVE. I have to admit though it would of been cool if they used smart glass or kinect for the markers

[@FatPlatypuss]

I can imagine the horrificness of using a thumbstick, max and the magic marker for wiiware was good though

[@JamanWerSonst]

This should be on WiiU or PsVita.

[@aaroncomoletti1663]

Good game I just wish they gave you an option on how to complete with the lines

[@tanner1ie]

Bakes Cakes More people want a PS4 than an Xbox One, so what does that say about the Xbox One? :) .

[@tazzybakes1169]

I honestly think said reviewer is being way to up tight. I been there since the almighty Mario brothers and this a an amazingly refreshing twist to the platform genre. It offered fun fun fun at every turn and I compliment the dev team for the sublime implementation of it all. P.S. The game is no where near frustrating as the review made out. Platforming fun for every one !!!!

[@Mkvkuv]

beautiful game marred by terrible UI. this game should of been for the wii u or ipad

[@GerrardtheGrimmNo1]

I don't think you really know what 2.5D really means. This is full 3D just performed mostly from a side scroll view. From a motion designer that would mostly in 2.5D you need to know what your talking about. Sorry, I get peeved when people use that term so loosely.

[@cjworm4706]

This game is great. I have no idea what she is talking about with the awkward controls. Graphics are gorgeous.

[@RealCoachMustafa]

I didn't really like Max and the Magic Marker, and this game looks like the gameplay is even more clunky. Looks like an upgrade in graphics, but downgrade in functionality.

[@joeydaniel3053]

whats the name of the background music at 1:18 - 1:55 ?

[@GNOLEB]

I know right I want to know

[@shoopdawoop70reviews]

This would've been much better on Wii U or PC...

[@Saturn867]

Put Mighty Max and Inkheart together and you'll have this.

[@john_hunter_]

Why the hell isn't this on Wii U?

[@staineddiapers7708]

Hey guys I just got an xbox 360 for Christmas! My gamertag is The Bloody Pads I have madden 07, NBA2K8, and Tony Hawke! I cant wait!

[@e12lfd]

play the game before you comment. awesome controls and well executed gameplay. would have been fine for any console, however Xbox has exclusive. who cares. great game and fun, especially for the price.

[@CodyElford]

This game screams 3DS and PS Vita

[@sebdzn]

Ign are horrible with rating games same thing happened with Knack and Knack is a great game

[@SirThorney]

Knack is a horrible attempt of bringing back the platformers of the PS One.

[@AwesomeAsh199]

George Thorney yea sure but wait for a new ty tasmanian sly cooper ratchet and clank jak daxter and a new crashbandicoot with next gen graphics with pixar like cutcenes and gameplay.

[@SirThorney]

We can dream

[@Clesarie]

Knack is a pos so I question your opinion.

[@tanork47]

"it's wierd that this xbox exclusive did't use the kinect for drawing" O NOOO That would have been worse far worse. I enjoyed the game for it being free for this month so if you want some fun or cheevos here u go!

[@slade6alpha]

Why are people talking about it getting ported to other consoles. It's owned by MS...

[@FocusBeDrifting]

"Seriously Satisfying" - Blond Girl

[@HeyMyNameIs...]

The controls are bad well with with kinect it will be better right? Right? NOOOO!!! Let's just say go watch the vs episode with geoff and micheal or buy the xbox one and play peggle 2 with kinect it's a NIGHTMARE :0 !!!!

[@nickwick35]

this is exactly what the chick that reviewed wonderful 101 said -.- I think it's a great game!

[@JaKamps]

I couldn't tell it was next gen. I thought it was just a nice looking XBLA at first..

[@i_am_x_wild]

It didn't use kinect cuz kinect doesnt work properly. Which probably was a saving grace.

[@vaasmontenegro3993]

i h8 exclusives. this game would have been hit if in tablets or wii u or even ps vita. microsoft must hav introduced a platformer with kinect or voice controls

[@miketantalos7827]

I found no problems with the controls at all and the entire play through was very enjoyable. Cant count on IGN reviews for shit anymore.

[@IRahkuBz]

should be 9/10

[@jakekbanx]

This review frustrates me. I loved this game. The puzzles are interesting and fun. So refreshing to just enjoy some nice art and some thoughtful puzzles rather than another FPS. I never found the controls to be a problem even once. Everyone likes different think I guess. I'd love to play more though if there was DLC or a sequel.

[@Litu_Hawk]

The game controls are ok, and the controls are not frustrating at all

[@Chrisclerk]

This would be good with a tablet or the Wii u controller, or as you said a second screen function.

[@SteelGoronNidoking]

Seems like the xbox one isn't the best system for a game like this. It reminds me of the trine games, is that just a coincidence or is it made by the same developers?