Impact Crate vs Gunner Kennel - Best dog crates review

Which is the best dog crate? The Impact Collapsible Crate and the Gunner G1 are both premium dog crates that serve very different scopes of the market. The are very often compared to each other though in reality serve very different use cases. This Impact Collapsible Crate was used to import a dog to Australia and has been my dogs resting place within my home for many years now. The collapsible function means that it has been fantastic to use when we travel though it isn't a crate that I would use to keep my dog safe within a vehicle. The gunner G1 is crash tested and I use it mainly when there is a real chance that my dog could be in danger from a vehicle rollover or collision like on the back of a quadbike or ATV while hunting.

[@noah_hansen]

Well put together video! When I’m older I plan on getting a Malinois (first thing I’ll do is get it trained) and this video is great for what crate I want to get.

[@WaldoBoiGaming]

Yeah I was literally just about to buy the impact until I saw how loud that was. My dog cannot stand loud noises so thanks man I’ll be investing in gunner

[@belojay2850]

Gunner....plastic=chewable=dog (especially my boy) will chew until he gets out or hurts himself, and has done both repeatedly. (Imact makes more than one type of crate) Impact....."the high anxiety " =solid, thickest aluminum, twice as thick as this model, welded & riveted all the way around, does not break down, offering more strength/rigidity, (also many more "smaller ventilation holes so dog can't get a paw or mouth grip on any part of it. After realizing they're not getting anywhere, they generally accept it and calm down. 10 YEAR WARRANTY...will repair or replace, and that includes any damage the dog could do to make the crate unsafe, or improperly function.

[@standelasanantone2180]

“No performance standards or test protocols exist for pet crates or carriers, and while pet safety product manufacturers claim to test their products, they can’t be substantiated...” - Lindsey Wolko, Center for Pet Safety’s founder and CEO.

[@The_VANtastic_Pack]

Good point on the sound issue. I didn't think of that. We're looking into crates for our pick up truck as well as our campervan. The impact crate would probably be noisy when the dog is in it. I remember when we had a house how my dogs wagging tails would make a lot of noise on the metal bars and I'm sensitive to sounds so we might go the route of the gunner kennels. But the impact collapsible crates are pretty cool too.

[@williamzhou4734]

Where do you keep the crate inside the camper van?

[@MrJol420]

Thanks man. I used your review. Ended up with the gunner. I just moved across the pond from the states to eu. The fact the gunner crate comes in half i think SHOULD BE HIGHLIGHTED. When I'm home I take it in half and the dog loves it. He's not into the cave thing some dogs are. And its so easy to put back together. We bring it it on the interrail, I've traveled many hours in a train and he was asleep the whole time. Its perfect I can really feel comfyerbal bringing him anywhere..I havent go back to the states to visit but one day we will and the crate will come and he'll be so used to it by then I'm sure it'll ease his flying anxiety.

[@odiegomendes]

hey Jack you moved from US to EU?? which company did you use?

[@odiegomendes]

I am in the same situation, I am looking a kennel to traveling internationaly.

[@MrJol420]

@@odiegomendes the gunner crate. I still use it to, I keep the door off and popped off the top and it sits in the living room like a little day bed for him he loves it.

[@BBBYpsi]

I have right now 4 ruff land kennels & I love them. Light weight obviously not as solid as the gunner. But for what I do it is perfect. Gonna eventually get a couple more of them.

[@Lucythegermanshepherd]

Hey great video Pat. After that I have my eyes set on the Gunner kennel

[@PatStuart]

The Rolls Royce!

[@izacshome]

I've known several Mals to chew out of Gunner kennels unfortunately, good fair review of both crates though and I totally agree they are for different use.

[@bruh-ItsTokyo]

Those dogs need serious help since now their teeth are likely dulled out to the gums or close to them, you know how long it would take for a dog to chew through something like that? Those dogs needed some help fr, whoever had them needed to put them in a barred cage 6 foot tall kennel. Where it's room for them to walk, sleep and eat.

[@izacshome]

@Bruh- my personal Mal ate out of an RTK/RLK in an afternoon. Exercised and worked daily, he just realized he could chew out so then he did. I would guess a gunner would take him a couple of days maybe 🤷‍♀️ teeth are fine. My vet said at his last dental he has some wear but nothing too bad. In my experience barred cages are the worst for crate chewers; they can get their teeth caught in the bars.

[@-lupa6698]

Gunner is all plastic , Not indestructible!

[@hawnma8083]

Thank you for a great review. I was given a gunner kennel and a GSP to go with it. Owner couldn't keep her. But I was considering getting the Impact crate instead and getting rid of the gunner because I wanted something more compact and easy to transport. However, I'm gonna keep the Gunner for quality and efficiency.

[@dug757]

Very helpful review

[@evacherneff5118]

Good video, Pat - I love my gunner but it is huge though wouldn’t change it for anything else!

[@NothenButHell]

I know this is an older video, but I'm looking for a travel kennel for my suv for my poodle and training demo dogs, and I liked that the impact also offers a grooming mat for the top. It's going to be in the car & hotels for grooming competition. I have other kennels for the home.

[@rebeccaperrin7672]

Thanks, super helpful!

[@wonderquesarito]

How big are your custom crates? Looking for something for my dog, who is ridiculously tall (greyhound mix).

[@margaretrichmond3887]

Thanks. I’ll look at the gunner brand

[@salina3112]

I have an Impact crate for a 110LB German Shepard Dog, it’s perfect. Great purchase.

[@emilyhunter5763]

I ordered one and I'm waiting for it to come in do you remember how long it took?

[@honey2618]

what size was the impact crate you use?

[@vspd303]

What size is the impact crate you are showing

[@EBMisKing]

Would a 100lb German shepherd fit in a large gunner?

[@walterjones404]

Wish one would be best for a heavy chewer?

[@jarrodlyerly1075]

I just wish the Gunnar came bigger than large.. 40” long isn’t long enough for my malinois.. impact has 42” and 48”

[@marcusharris8016]

TY…

[@ontopsoon3673]

props to you for having a malinois. I know those are tough to raise

[@LaunchingRockets]

Lord my Mastador fits in a 40” kennel 150lbs lol what kinda malinois you got 😂

[@NBay_]

I was torn on which to pick, and I unfortunately returned the Gunner kennel. Maybe I got the wrong size as I felt the Gunner Kennel didn't provide enough ventilation and it's to confined for the use of a home kennel.-. I bought the true size for my dog's weight and height and felt it was still too confined. Impact kennel for Home use - I did upsize to give him more room. My Mal was far more comfortable in the impact kennel and I felt he was more relaxed instead of trying to dig his way out, drooling and obsessively barking. My Mal is a very obedient working dog and is used to being crated. Maybe I need to upsize on the Gunner Kennel. After hearing your information, I wouldn't mind trying the Gunner kennel again for transport purposes only. During Transport /Airplane will this kennel get enough ventilation, I worry about heat stroke as this kennel is thick and insulated ( not a negative- very well constructed) does it draw in the heat?. Just wanted to share my thoughts. This is a great video and great Highlights on each kennel! Thank you Pat for sharing the information - I feel I might try again

[@patrickfromatlanta785]

In can’t v find v definitive v information check can these be tied down in a truck bed or inside only thanks,

[@KSNT-TheTaint]

What shoes you rockin ?

[@teresamontoya3350]

We purchased the impact crate it’s awesome we have an beast of an husky ❤best investment

[@shandrag6329]

Hi is this crate loud if the dog bangs on it? Thanks

[@sheepdog819]

I need a big crate for my Corso that I can strap into my truck. Wish the gunner was bigger internally.

[@tonys2952]

Have you tried the Variocage or TransK9 crates? Can't decide between those and the gunner for my vehicle...

[@PatStuart]

Nah sorry. I’ve never used one. I’ve seen plenty and they look good.

[@Defender-Guy]

We have a big Impact crate for our Great Dane. It’s bloody heavy but we’re happy with it.

[@shandrag6329]

Hi I’m thinking of getting the impact crate for my Doberman,is the crate loud if the dog bangs on it. Thanks

[@Defender-Guy]

@@shandrag6329depends how much I suppose. The fit & finish are pretty good so not much loose to bang around except the door.

[@ArtEqualsLife]

Just wanted to clarify, that first Gunner kennel you showed was a G1 Medium and not a G1 Intermediate? I ask because it looks like the Intermediate and I'm trying to figure out the right size Gunner for my dog. :)

[@PatStuart]

Yeah I think I miss spoke. It’s an intermediate.

[@ArtEqualsLife]

@@PatStuart Thank you for the info! :)

[@andrewn.5117]

@@ArtEqualsLife what size did you go with? I’m trying to figure out if I should get intermediate or large for my female Labrador retriever. Thanks

[@ArtEqualsLife]

@@andrewn.5117 We actually ended up getting a Ruffland Kennel instead for now. Since Gunners are so expensive, we decided to wait until our puppy is fully grown before investing in one. I was a little too afraid of getting the wrong size too soon. Sorry I couldn't help more!!

[@andrewn.5117]

@@ArtEqualsLife thank you for response

[@kiranwild]

Can you please share the video on the vehicle set up and tips for traveling with the dogs

[@PatStuart]

Yep. It’s coming! Time just isn’t on my side.

[@kiranwild]

@@PatStuart I can totally understand with all the dog activities you are handling

[@jrambo7495]

I want the Gunner but I have hernia mesh in three places and that Gunner would rip them all in one go! There's an identical crate to the impact for way cheaper and it's the exact same product!

[@kylewhitworth8619]

Hey Pat, what method did you find the most cost effective to get the Gunner shipped to Australia? I’d assume the dimensions and weight would be about the cost of the kennel itself to get one out here...

[@PatStuart]

I got them both from people who used them to import dogs in. So I didn’t get them shipped.

[@Blackwatercowboy1]

How do they handle the heat? I’ve seen fans for the gunners and wasn’t sure what temperature they can handle safely with the dog not getting too hot? Any ideas?

[@PatStuart]

Nah I haven’t done any serious testing. The double wall gives some good insulation though.

[@Blackwatercowboy1]

@@PatStuart thanks, love your content. Just came across your stuff the other day.

[@snowygirl131]

Why is temperature not more of a priority?

[@tep_123]

How did you get your hands on the Gunner kennel in Australia? Thanks

[@PatStuart]

I bought it second hand from someone who used it to import a dog to Australia.

[@Neil-ru4zs]

The gunner wouldn't keep my dog contained so I'm looking into the impact. It looks much stronger

[@eddiesup14]

What length is your impact kennel crate ? I have a malingator myself !

[@PatStuart]

That model is 40inches long

[@altitude0632]

@@PatStuart is it the wide and tall model or just the regular 40”?

[@PatStuart]

@@altitude0632 regular

[@MarcusStarksPixels]

I subscribe because of that fire intro music

[@PatStuart]

And now you are my favourite subscriber. Welcome aboard.

[@mutchumbo]

Like that scene from Step Brothers - "Why are you so sweaty??" "I was training dogs..."

[@PatStuart]

I was going to say I was watching cops but I figured it was too niche a reference.

[@Peter-tc3ep]

My Vizsla chewed through the Gunner door in less then a week. It’s just plastic and has lips for dogs to get a grip to chew, wish Gunner offered a metal liner for the door like some other companies. Was hoping impact crate would work well since it collapses for travel, doesn’t sound good from your review. So far only solid heavy metal commercial style kennels work for my dog.

[@PatStuart]

Wowser!!! I haven’t heard of that happening before! Did they replace it?

[@Peter-tc3ep]

@@PatStuart they sent me a replacement door but recommended not using the kennel with that dog, so not very helpful. He chewed the door enough for it to flex, badly cut his lips and face, pop the door open even with the top and bottom locks on it popped right open since plastic bends easy when there’s a weak point. Luckily was able to sell the crate used. There was a few reviews on their site for escaping but they some how get removed, leaving their crates with excellent reviews only.

[@bigrichglynn]

Impact makes a high anxiety crate, you should take a look at it.

[@sherirottweilersforever7772]

@@bigrichglynnthat is what I need. My Rottweiler smashes all kennel doors open so I need a very strong door.

[@dianabak9100]

A Mal can fit in a medium for traveling short distances. My 55 pound dog is in an intermediate comfortably and I would go up to 65 in that. Medium up to 45 imo

[@juliecoffey3535]

I have 3 Malinois biggest being 65 pounds and they all ride in the gunner crate you mentioned. I keep it in my car. They have ridden hundreds of miles. They are heavy to move into hotel rooms but the crash rating is ok enough for me to move a heavier crate than aluminum any day n

[@MrCal93h]

Hey Pat, anywhere in Australia to purchase crates like these? Cheers

[@PatStuart]

Unfortunately no

[@annie4horses]

Impact Dog Crates will ship internationally 😊

[@jen1836]

Is the Gunner available in Australia yet?

[@PatStuart]

I don’t think so.

[@jen1836]

@@PatStuart yeah couldn't find it anywhere other than importing it. Found another brand here that is also crash tested so might look into that one.

[@JLynchJr86]

What is the other crate that is crash tested? Gunner and what?

[@PatStuart]

It’s the Vari Kennel. I’ve since learned crash testing isn’t necessarily crash testing if you know what I mean? I’m going to make an update to this vid in a few weeks.

[@hs_alduri]

Please help me I have a German shepherd she’s 60lb and I’m trying to fly overseas my flight would be total of 22hrs with 2 stops. Going to be long fly. What the best to buy for her

[@TheAllDogProject]

I would not fly a new dog that long. Work up to that.

[@hs_alduri]

@@TheAllDogProject otherwise I have to sell her, I’m moving out to a different country.

[@joseph5080]

What crate did you use?

[@6botty]

Impact could coat the metal with silicone for noise

[@tashm470]

I habe 100pound dog with anxiety. How big

[@lydiakunzler9358]

Where I own smaller dogs, my biggest downside to the Gunnar is they don’t make crates for smaller dogs

[@codyseverinsen5742]

They sure do

[@codyseverinsen5742]

Gunner offers multiple sizes for kennels

[@travismcdougall1599]

Gunner are impossible to deal with from Australia. Won't ship, won't help, won't do anything outside of the US

[@AmyChen-su6vn]

hey, friend. why not consider other kinds of dog cages? we are a manufacturer of various kinds of pet cages in china, please someone needed, please contact me.

[@shakespearethemagificent8006]

This brings back a lot of personal trauma… I was trapped in one of these for like almost an entire day while my owner was tripping on acid.

[@monicacousin2590]

Dog Daddy sent me.

[@teresamontoya3350]

Mine is different more locks

[@matthewmaldonado3213]

My dog eats through everything and anything I don't know what cage to get him

[@SawyerMartoglio]

The impact makes a high anxiety crate.

[@BowWowBills]

You’re sweaty AF 😘

[@jordbjor1]

Australian reviews are better 😆

[@samhixon3593]

Having owned both i must say i love the Gunner the "Impact" crate is absolute trash. More expensive and no warranty! Gunner crate has a trsnsferable warranty. And yes likenhe says crash tested.

[@juanbarberis7192]

Aussie...Aussie..Aussie : 0

[@standelasanantone2180]

MANY pet safety devices have been "crash tested" but that does NOT mean they PASSED or received a seal of approval...!!! Subconscious bias or just ambiguous verbiage...???

[@rguinness]

Gunner crate has actually been crashed tested and is one of only two that have ever been certified by independent testers. kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z3e3dpqtarGeZ5I

[@-lupa6698]

Gunner crates are All plastic , Not indestructible!

[@Alpha8ter]

Too bad they are both wayyyyy over priced smh. Worthless kennel companies taking advantage of dipsticks lol

[@pluckin1369]

Dog jail

[@Spinjastar]

It's sad how racists have ruined the beard hat shades Trump 2020 combo...

[@bobsmith-ji2uh]

What?

[@kmook926]

Beta males ruined beards long ago.