What Happens If You Destroy A Black Hole?

[@kurzgesagt]

Go ‘beyond the nutshell’ at brilliant.org/nutshell/ and dive deeper into these topics and more with a free 30-day trial! This video was sponsored by Brilliant. Thanks a lot for the support!

[@SpaceWafflerYT]

White hole

[@zzvlr]

ok

[@ishaan-blox]

Yes

[@Iamadalek]

mep

[@Asa-xz7jt]

oh we did break it

[@lelekelelep]

i imagine the animators having so much fun trying to convey how maximum absurdity feels

[@ovencake523]

and then the music artists too

[@bluexix]

Add some bananas here and there

[@mcordonhouston]

The amount of effort is genuinely impressive

[@NoName-bs2hq]

B A N A N A

[@solsystem1342]

We can finally make the maximum improbability drive!

[@hollowshield2315]

the idea of black holes as superprisons keeping reality breakers imprisoned is actually really cool

[@Kartoffelkamm]

Yeah, but reality sucks, so I'd still like to know what happens.

[@suecli8131]

It's true. The giants that used to terrible the earth are now trapped in black holes. Your statement has biblical backing. Check the book of Enoch when God took him to explore the heavens.

[@nathanhudkins]

The title changes dramatically if you add an ";)"

[@ovencake523]

the scp foundation would like to know your location

[@aljosha1994]

I see what you did there @@nathanhudkins

[@rocketpunchgo1]

Learning that a Black Hole's center is "in the future" kind of broke my mind for several minutes. ALso: This animation just keeps getting better and better!

[@accountnamewithheld]

It's because of the relativistic effects of gravity. It's not in the future "per se", but you would experience the death of the universe if you were falling towards one

[@jayer.]

​@@accountnamewithheld At the point where we talk about time in things like this, the definition of time that we use everyday becomes meaningless. Past, present and future happen at the same time. It's the same with space. You're everywhere and everywhen and that all at once.

[@thibvp778]

you don't actually go in the future, time just freezes for you.

[@thelordz33]

Technically, everywhere you want to go is as much in the future as it is in front of you.

[@DarkAngelEU]

@@accountnamewithheld I was wondering this, too. Its gravitational pull would be so massive, everything around it will look like it's going extremely fast. But how does that make singularity lie in the future? Shouldn't it be in the past? We from the outside move on, might even die, before the singularity is reached.

[@likwong1960]

‘Ferb, I know what we’re gonna do today.’

[@BrandonLung]

Copied

[@thatonesigmer_guy]

@@BrandonLung what do you mean

[@andrewyoonhobai8453]

will you all finally eliminate evil vanessa 1800 kills? Is this the day surely?

[@NoxLumen7]

Vanessa isn’t evil.

[@ieatmoney]

@@BrandonLungtheres probably more people that have typed "copied" than what the original comment said. get over it honestly

[@torkin4119]

It's interesting to note that singularities don't break actual physics, more like they break the model we use at the moment to understand physics. This is important, because it means that singularities can and do make sense, the problem is we don't have the right model to understand them yet.

[@drdca8263]

Couldn’t the answer instead be that within the event horizon, there is something other than a singularity? E.g. iirc one idea assuming string theory is that the interior of a black hole is like, a big jumble of the “strings” , which end up (I guess due to having so much energy) having size comparable to the size of the black hole, instead of being of a subatomic size?

[@IdentifiantE.S]

Its sooo interesting

[@erasmus186]

Physics is not a thing, but our model(s) of nature. So kurzgesagt is right. A singularity breaks our models but it does not "break nature".

[@ggwp638BC]

This. My biggest petpeeve with popscience videos is the "break reality" trope. No, it doesn't break reality, it is part of reality. It can break OUR understanding (our science) of reality, but to the natural world itself that's just tuesday.

[@BigWisper]

Would love to see what would happen to sombody if they gazed at a bare singularly

[@NerdsmithTV]

The idea that black holes are a dev workaround for a gamebreaking bug for the universe is a very compelling one.

[@hencethebeetroot]

"Hey, uh, we have a small issue." "What is it?" "You know how celestial bodies use that density method depending on their mass and size? Apparently a large enough body overflows and the density is calculated as infinite." "Oh. Well, I'm sure it's such an insane size that it won't realistically happen in a timeline. Maybe we could work it into a cool end-of-universe thing though." "Except it can happen in a timeline. And it has in tests. And the moment it happens everything collapses because density is infinite and thus gravity is infinite." "The universe is supposed to come out in two days! Just change the formula!" "We've tried. I'm sorry, but changing it breaks everything else that relies on it." "Well I don't know! Just hide it or something. We can do bugfixes and stuff after release, but it has to be at least playable." "What do you want me to do, just create matter voids around them?" "...you know what? Sure. But make it intuitive. Maybe they get larger the more you feed them?" "I can do that. Oh, and we can make them decay over time so that they delete themselves but it doesn't feel unrealistic!" "Perfect. Just get that coded in and we'll call it a day."

[@Gamering8482]

A glitch in a matrix with a cheap fix... the devs of reality must be on a tight budget

[@Avellar3000]

@@hencethebeetroot "hey, HEY... this brain in jar is over thinking... give it some more social medai"

[@interesting5309]

@@hencethebeetroot EPIC, EPIC. PERFECTION! NOICE.

[@kieranmilner4208]

JUST KEEP ADDDING ZEROS ITALWAYS WORKS

[@Matthew12YT]

I love how Kurzgesagt's first reaction to any information is to "nuke it"

[@shronkler1994]

bro think he Douglas MacArthur

[@railworksamerica]

Legalize nuclear bombs

[@areyoukind5645]

Like he's the disgraced former president of the United States

[@is-2heavytank43]

*moar dakka*

[@TheNarutoUzumaki07]

Works like 75% of the time though

[@IrinaYoung-e2b]

It’s absolutely crazy how far humanity has come

[@yitzhakbohadana5102]

We didn't have the ability to do any of this idea only to try to calculate it base on the information we have

[@cowboyjamerson3746]

@@yitzhakbohadana5102duh!! He’s taking about the idea that we know about such things

[@Vincent_C]

Not far or fast enough imo.

[@dhalsim-1]

Well, what's known about black holes beyond the event horizon are theories for the most part and probably always will be.

[@stomingaben]

90% of what we know about space are mainly theories. The first breakthrough for me would be having a proper picture of an exoplanet and not just a blurry one pixel image

[@theegg19]

As an astrophysicist, I'm extremely impressed with how Kurzgesagt was able to put this into understandable or simplified terms. Studying the capacity of black holes has always boggled my mind no matter the depths I go into the physics we have now.

[@absalomdraconis]

Honestly, I'm surprised they never threw in white holes, whether for the anti-blackhole (if a white hole isn't the anti-particle of a black hole, then nothing is), or as a comment on the "anything can come out" aspect of a naked singularity. They even mentioned Hawking radiation, and that might _be_ the real-world manifestation of a white hole, and still no mention of white holes.

[@MewPurPur]

White hole isn't an anti-black hole. Also they are sort of complete nonsense that can't exist in our Universe. But just for the fun of it, I'm also curious.

[@ibrahimbenhmida3852]

​@@absalomdraconisantimatter is the opposite of matter only in charge.. same spin.. same masse.. And white wholes are opposite in mass.. Its technically negative mass.. But colliding them together would be impossible i think.. because of how positive and negative mass behave together.. plus they still dont have that much of science behind white wholes

[@eugenejamesbon5791]

Hi

[@Astrialx]

​@@ibrahimbenhmida3852It's definitely not negative mass. And, there is no such thing as negative mass. If white holes do exist, they would be composed of mass, not negative mass.

[@lukasrafajpps]

Just a quick note. Singularity as a point is only for static (non-rotating) black holes. If the blackhole rotates, its singularity has a shape of a ring (ringularity). Another interesting point is that a rotating black hole has two event horizons. The funny fact is that in between the horizons, you don't have to necessarily travel towards the singularity although you can't escape from there. You could live happily there for years but if you crossed the second horizon you have to reach the singularity.

[@fries6402]

replying for visibility- very cool stuff

[@baraapudding]

a ringshaped singularity actually makes me wonder: what happens if you are in the exact centre of that "ringularity"? Because, like Kurzgesagt also explained, the singularity would be your future. But if you are in the exact centre of this ring, every direction points toward the future.

[@gordontaylor2815]

I believe Kurzgesagt has already done a video touching on this - the "Black Hole Bomb" video...

[@lukasrafajpps]

@@baraapudding In theory, you should be able to safely pass through the middle and some think it should serve as a wormhole that spits you out into another universe from a white-hole. But I don't believe such a claims :D

[@GLUBSCHI]

⁠@@baraapuddingas far as i understand, as long as you're past the event horizon every direction you can go will only ever lead you towards the singularity (which is the reason nothing can escape the event horizon). So i don't think it would matter if you were in the "hole" of a ringularity or somewhere else inside of the black hole. I'm not a physicist so i can't tell you for sure but i think that's how it works

[@Ajyaj]

The animations are otherworldly as always, but the soundtrack for this video goes so hard it's like a final boss fight music. Props to everyone who makes these videos possible!

[@lemagicbaguette1917]

Breaking the event horizon is the equivalent of breaking a sacred seal imprisoning an unknowable, malevolent cosmic horror.

[@bafeink2]

Exactly! the music is amazing

[@Jay2480]

*Singularity has awoken*

[@GraniteStateVictoria]

I love how it starts out funny with the silly idea of nuking a black hole then gets unsettling when talking about the effects of a singularity with no event horizon.

[@quickdraw6893]

I feel like this video failed to cover two important notes about those singularities though: one being that infinite mass is impossible and its effects would have to wane at some distance, and second that it is not unlikely that it just forms a new event horizon around its tiny self immediately after the previous one dissipates

[@محمدانور-ح8غ]

I love wars

[@minewithsayo4220]

I absolutely love it how he was so chill at the beginning, but closer to the end he became so chaotic and aggressive lmao

[@inc2000glw]

Yeah something different about this.

[@TotallyGaming1]

Yeah ikr, at the beginning he spoke in a calm, slow voice, but then at the end he spoke in a fast chaotic voice 😂

[@ukslays]

and then he went back to calm when he started the ad lol

[@nathanpierce7681]

watching the video felt like taking crack and then feeling the effects near the end

[@inedibledorito]

The music just amped it up so much as well. Too good

[@Jimera0]

The concept of a naked singularity is just incredible to me. It's a concept reminiscent of cosmic horror stories, as it is something so unfathomably powerful, indescribable, inconceivable and incomprehensible that simple observation of it could potentially cause reality itself to break in ways we couldn't even begin to imagine. And yet, this is a scientific hypothesis, not a horror story. The idea of something like that potentially being possible sends shivers down my spine. While I'd honestly be shocked if naked singularities were actually physically possible in our universe, the concept has an appeal nothing else can really quite match.

[@starsilverinfinity]

Fr, imagine something so unspeakably horrible, dangerous, or just plain weird that the nature of the universe throws all the stops at you possible to prevent it from being unleashed

[@wtfisggon7251]

It reminds me of photons. Observing it changes reality

[@freelancerthe2561]

My brain immediately went "wait..... isn't that an infinite improbability generator?"

[@oceandrop7666]

The real horror comes from the concept of something and nothing and its far reaching implications. Either something came from nothing, which should be impossible. Or something always existed. Either way the full picture of reality is far beyond our current experience.

[@Nibsipipsi]

Sorry to be a buzzkill, but in this video they kinda forget what a singularity is to begin with: a kind of divide by zero error. It's just a hole in the mathematics we use to describe gravity. Singularities aren't physical. You can't have a naked singularity because they don't exist. If we have a theory of quantum gravity, that might explain what would happen if we push a black hole past its breaking point (if there even is such a thing). There is no such thing as breaking reality however.

[@TimeBucks]

Absolutely phenomenal video

[@saijeevan2723]

👍

[@newlineschannel]

IKR

[@ranatahirashfaq]

Nice

[@pynapvbnswamy9462]

Timebucks gives us good earnings.

[@farmankhan6283]

Nice

[@vh8542]

I submitted the question on if there is anyway to destroy a black whole to Startalk. It actually was selected but the answer was pretty short and no theorizing as to what would happen with certain strategies. So this is nice to see :)

[@kapja]

Props to the cameraman who waited for 10^44 years to record a blackhole evaporate

[@skyellama8374]

If future humans can get black hole bombs to work, doesn't that mean we'll have energy to survive as long as the black holes, if not longer? Long after the universe has gone dark?

[@Josep_Hernandez_Lujan]

Cameramen never die

[@oicmapper]

He just went to the singularity point

[@HI-ej8rl]

Cameraman 😆😆

[@inertiaking1]

​@@skyellama8374yeah until the black hole evaporates, and then we'd need to find another

[@Untoastedbagel1271]

How someone managed to explain black holes in a simple way is beyond me

[@riceballs_walmart]

This looks simple becuz it's just theory part the real physics is when mathematics comes on, and that's where no one is interested 💀

[@justlivinglife6315]

@@riceballs_walmart that's what i said this video is basically science fiction

[@Boltclick]

@@justlivinglife6315 It's not exactly science fiction, it's more of just seeing what would happen if you inputted massive numbers into those physics equations. They just omitted the calculations. Now the validity of those physics equations is something else, as particle physics and theoretical physics are both fields that have frequent breakthroughs and rewrites of what we thought was set in stone.

[@QueennakLifestyle]

@@riceballs_walmartM=E/cc E=mcc

[@aRookieGod]

@@justlivinglife6315exactly

[@BibhatsuKuiri]

as a physics student this was quite a stressful video to imagine. but as always 10/10 on overall video production

[@namantherockstar]

Nutshell inspires me.. My parents said if i get 40K followers They'd buy me a professional camera for recording..begging u guys , literally Begging.

[@queentory5411]

​@@namantherockstarI just followed you, I hope you follow your dreams and succeed 👍🏾

[@plantarum3276]

Yo if you are a physicist maybe you can answer my question... When a black hole shrinks over time - that must mean there is a point where its mass is no longer able to create an event horizon right? That would mean that at some point the singularity would be visible and maybe explode bc there is not enough gravity to compress itself, right?

[@pgonarg1]

@@plantarum3276 Not a physicist, but as I understand it, it would simply evaporate in a burst of energy

[@leonhard.doerflinger]

​@plantarum3276 Any mass can have an event horizon. It just gets smaller if your mass shrinks. However, there appears to be a lower limit that arises from quantum physics. Once that has been reached the black hole emits a photon whose energy corresponds to its remaining mass and it is gone. Sadly this is not very interesting, but that is probably the way all matter in the universe will ultimately go. At that time we will have reached the heat death of the universe.

[@RealCristonCade]

This channel is directly responsible for 97% of my rabbit holes on YT

[@triskit7626]

I love how the beginning was chill and contained simple explanations, then the Music in the end Being so Dramatic and how Kurzgesagt was basically like, "Everything has lost its meaning, The Universe becomes the definintion of Chaos and Absurdity"

[@nathanpierce7681]

this is the moment kurzgesagt became bill cipher

[@sebastianthegoat4265]

Kurzgesagt literally became the embodiment of Nihility lol

[@SLAMMMERMANS]

so true axolotl my time has come to burn I invoke the ancient power that I may return @@nathanpierce7681

[@RemedieX]

​@@nathanpierce7681 Gave me those vibes too, but controlled. Even scarier

[@marcusgilbert6350]

God Emperor Protect Us

[@sarvajithmahendra7883]

Imagine how good a space book would be if kurzgesagt made it, with the graphics and the concepts it would be incredible.

[@gcat360]

Is there not one?

[@lunchpaper]

they already made a book but i dont think it just covers space and its not up to date

[@sarvajithmahendra7883]

@@gcat360 no sadly

[@DavidJanssen-ec8sn]

We need that book now

[@gcat360]

Rip

[@pamdaza422]

I love how black holes are so simple but so complicated at the same time.

[@renascitur7051]

no@Noah-jq1ff

[@IlovecheeseIwantcheese]

@Noah-jq1ff Oh shut up,allah is just not even exsist.

[@Plmxdut]

@Noah-jq1ff Shut

[@pr0xZen]

They're the ultimate dark n broody 6ft7 goth adonis brad pitt kinda thing.

[@Plmxdut]

@@pr0xZen xD

[@pulsar-photon]

“revealing a naked singularity might destroy all fundamental rules of physics” *you know what let’s not do that.* thank you steve 😇

[@NickAndriadze]

Genuinely one of if not *the* most artistically rich and expressive videos this channel has ever created in its decade+ long lifetime, I applaud.

[@lapis591]

'Artistically rich?' It looks like it's from Brain Pop!

[@slendrfrut]

@@lapis591 yeah uh, you might wanna go back and see how Brainpop looked. The two have nothing in common. This video is very artistically rich.

[@volksturmgher5936]

​@@lapis591brain pop has a boring not very fun view, kurgesagt how ever has a view that makes stuff fun, sometimes i even go to sleep to them

[@johanneshartman4618]

you need to be born again trough adam alot of people spiritually died, trough JESUS CHRIST alot of people got spiritually saved if they believe JESUS and get baptized and receive the HOLY SPIRIT!! follow JESUS and do as i told you///////

[@ic4192]

​@@johanneshartman4618nah

[@chadmiettunen]

I listened to a podcast recently that posited the idea that prehistoric black holes, that were formed shortly after the Big Bang, may have shrunk down to the planck scale and are stuck at that size; too small to interact with anything or disappear completely. If there are enough of these tiny black holes floating around, they could be a candidate for dark matter. Collectively they have a bunch of mass, but are individually too small to interact with matter.

[@doomsdayrabbit4398]

The dead pixels of the universe.

[@paulrussell9632]

I feel like we must've listened to the same podcast. Was it the recent Radiolab episode about the Tunguska event?

[@Purrfect_Werecat]

they would have had to be pretty small to begin with wouldn't they, since it takes so stupidly long for one to evaporate away even a little

[@JeffersonTryHard]

Holy cow that's such a crazy idea from speculation. Someone needs to look into that possibility wtf

[@EbolaBearr]

@@Purrfect_Werecat Could be quicker under the conditions of the young universe, I don't know anything about that stuff though

[@fishnugget3672]

This is by far my favorite episode. Chaotic and the music fits so well with the chaotic nature of breaking physics

[@stevencraeynest7729]

it seems also to be the most scientifically incorrect

[@hirocheeto7795]

@@stevencraeynest7729 They've got their sources linked in the description. If you have issues with it, I suggest actually confronting it directly and saying what's wrong, how, and what would actually be more accurate.

[@fishnugget3672]

@@stevencraeynest7729 it is also purely theoretical

[@neverpure20]

Just the right amount of characterization and the right amount of hype music. Perfect visuals as always. Just Brilliant.

[@pankekboi8511]

Kurzgesagt is exactly the type of channel to make a black hole on their own

[@Joseph-ht4iw]

too bad@@ruthbower6075

[@raffimolero64]

That would be "I did a thing" or "styropyro"

[@eminkilicaslan8945]

Them or Vsauce

[@RyanGambles11]

The idea that there are literal points in our universe where space and time do not exist is extremely fascinating.

[@SublustrisAvis]

And are also most likely false, like all paradoxes are

[@RS1SCH7]

Theoretically

[@scptime1188]

well, probably not literal, it's just our theory breaks at that point so we replace the "??????" at the centre of a blackhole with the logical prediction of our theory, a singularity. but that means the theory is probably wrong, or more likely, incomplete

[@Ottee2]

Yes, it's hard to fathom such a state. Even calling it a state is a misrepresentation. My mind struggles to grasp the singularity, but to no avail.

[@MrTomyCJ]

Are we sure those counts as being "in", or "part of" the universe? They sound like what was before the big bang, not part of the universe by definition.

[@razzymazz]

From animation, to original SFX, to all the information you would need to know in a 8 minute long video, this channel finds a way to create fun and entertaining videos while giving out very good info told in a very good way.

[@IdentifiantE.S]

Its really interesting

[@razzymazz]

okay @Noah-jq1ff 😅

[@qusaysyrienalahmad]

0:29 "Boom."

[@catpoke9557]

I like how black holes are so absurdly powerful that they just had to settle with shaving the top off as 'destroying' the black hole

[@andreabardelli3137]

I wonder if stripping them of their event horizon actually prevents them from evaporating thus making them eternal

[@catpoke9557]

@@andreabardelli3137 That would be hardcore

[@jb76489]

@@andreabardelli3137Why would it do that?

[@richydre481]

Because the event horizon is the thing decaying to hawking radiation, not the singularity. This should mean, that most likely a naked singularity would be eternal. We can't know this for sure, as no black hole will die within the lifetime of our civilization.

[@buttersponge39]

​@@jb76489not a physicist but from what I know the Hawking Radiation is what happens when a particle and antiparticle are created out of nothing. Normally they cancel eachother out and nothing happens. But when one particle is inside the event horizon and the other isn't, one particle "exists and the black whole "pays" the energetic toll for forcing it to exist. This is a very simplified explanation so I recommend you look into Hawking Radiation for more info

[@Crimnox_Cinder]

Oh my god this episode was phenomenal! The music, the facts (and conjectures), the visuals! It all painted black holes to be a sort of prison for the Eldritch reality warping singularity. Truly sublime, every video you guys put out is just amazing. Thank you.

[@doratheexplorer9391]

​@Noah-jq1ff not interested bro😒

[@tomv2359]

All their videos are amazing of course but I am also in awe by this one. This was so, so good.

[@Diospepreco]

Same here. I love all their videos, but this one is truly something else.

[@doantranvan1844]

ok

[@hussainmahmood14]

@Noah-jq1ff thank you i am muslim and in some videos i do the same thing as you keep it up inshallah you will enter the highest jannah al - firdouse inshallah you will get reward

[@carlosfer2201]

This may be the most visually impactful video you guys have made so far. Space is amazing.

[@menegy2982]

I know what im doing today. That singularity wont know whats coming.

[@avpultramanxX9]

Whenever I want that sense of existential dread I skip Lovecraftian horror and simply watch a ten minute video on black holes and immediately get a deep sense of fear that will never leave me questioning my perceived reality in a way that can't be done any other way. Thanks.

[@_________________________.-]

Same same

[@johnladuke6475]

I don't feel the same dread... I get sad that I'll never be able to go and see such a thing for myself. Even taking a picture is pushing the limits of what we can do right now.

[@tapist3482]

​@@johnladuke6475 Existential dread is not necessarily fear, but a subtle sense of uncertainty, feeling your whole being belittled, that you start to question why you're brought to this universe. The sadness you feel is just that, I believe. Cuz I experience the same. I always wonder, the physics seems almost set just to prohibit us from exploring the vast 99.9999…% of all the possibilities in a Universe that is just out there for us to observe. It's almost a ridicue, a reminder to how tiny and powerless we are. Why are we still here then? Just to suffer?

[@eventhorizon2264]

Same here my special interest is black holes and astronomy

[@thomasplinguidy4588]

The most chilling creatures in Lovecrafts work are these incredibly powerful and haughty extraterrestrials who -as they say- care less about humanity than the dirt under our shoes. But the horror fades at some point you notice two things: 1. They prefer to take privileged white young men with money and from good families to drive them crazy. 2. For the fact that they despise humanity so incredibly, they hang around with us very often and for a very long time.

[@ShawnSansonetti]

This is still one of the best channels ever invented. Thank you, Kurzgesagt!

[@GeneralStriker]

69 likes

[@nopenope4402]

Too bad they're grossly inaccurate on this video. There's no such thing as a singularity in real life, that simply means the mathematics has broken down and is no longer valid. A shame they constantly provide such great useful information until this video full of junk information that you cannot even claim is even the slightest bit scientifically accurate.

[@thefinalgrimswald354]

@@nopenope4402🤓

[@lombardo141]

@@nopenope4402you do realize that most of the information we have on black holes are either hypothetical or unproven theories. You can’t prove there is no singularity in the middle of a black hole either because no one ever went there. Take a chill pill buddy.

[@complexcreations5309]

You do know that they openly cite their sources and that every one of their videos is thouroughly checked by scientists, right?@@nopenope4402

[@KnowledgeCat]

Absolutely mesmerized by this video's artistic depth and expression. The animator's portrayal of the black hole is stunning and deeply moving. Fantastic work!

[@TrIIden]

Ok.

[@nidungr3496]

8:25 I want to pet it

[@TrIIden]

@@nidungr3496No you don't.

[@zes7215]

wrrr

[@ShareAMeal77]

You can't be real.

[@solarduckspace]

Wow, this video really blew my mind! It's fascinating to think about the immense power and mystery of black holes.

[@dominikbeitat4450]

There was a PBS Space Time video where Matt explained how black holes might not be able to fully evaporate. Something about Planck scale shenanigans suggests a (really small) lower size limit, making them a possible candidate for dark matter. It's like a hydra, the more we know about them, the more we DON'T know about them.

[@cryonim]

You can apply the last line to most things in general, apart from just physics I mean.

[@gordontaylor2815]

Knowing what we know about quantum physics suggests that "true" singularities (i.e. matter compressed to a mathematical point of infinite density) can't really exist - any "real life" singularity SHOULD have a finite (if really small) size and finite (if really high) density just from the uncertainty principle. The problem is we can't do any better than this because we don't have the necessary theories of quantum gravity to explain what happens during the black hole collapse yet. (And that doesn't even get into the "fuzzball" possibility from string theory...)

[@goog353]

obviously the animation is great, but lets take a moment to appreciate the music in this episode. Absolutely amazing.

[@DavidJanssen-ec8sn]

Yes especially the Intro I love it

[@steampunkwhale2280]

The other black hole videos have great soundtracks too

[@david05]

It kept me on the very age of the chair

[@Elearen]

That middle section had no business being so epic

[@Astrosimi]

The soundtrack to the Black Hole Size Comparison video is one of the best they’ve ever done

[@geralt36]

The animation is truely next level! The amount of creativity involved in showing something so difficult to fathom or make any sense of is just out if this world. Really amazing work!

[@futuristicbus61]

Dude I love this channel. I only watch a few Kurz videos a year but they’re always so interesting

[@BrandonLung]

Same here

[@grfrjiglstan]

I love that there’s just millions of actual holes in reality, and we don’t talk about it more often.

[@dfonorow]

Way more than millions. Most scientists believe that each galaxy has a black hole at its center, and there are estimated to be 200 billion galaxies in the universe!

[@Kitty_Cosmic]

@@dfonorowI think they were talking about, OTHER type of holes we should talk about ;3

[@sixeleven637]

@@Kitty_Cosmicwhich hole🤯

[@alenko4763]

@@sixeleven637 The poopoo holes 😮

[@kevinhendriksjeuh]

Also, their time here is massive. Like we cannot comprehend just how long these things will be there.

[@gso619]

"You break a stick, you now have two sticks. Stick always wins." was a very profound look into black holes, apparently.

[@quickmythril2398]

of course, it's impossible to destroy something that doesn't exist in the first place. >_

[@mityaboy4639]

well, break a stick enough times and you will end up with thin disks / or fine powder (depending on the way you ‘break’ it) i guess you will win eventually, which means it only needs determination and means of breaking it further and further. and when you look at the dust… its going to be hard to argue that the stick won… :) there is always a limit when things stop being a thing and they become something else. like those sticks… two sticks… 4 … etc… but at point it takes on a new form and becomes sawdust

[@Joseph-kd9tx]

burn the stick

[@OzOMega]

​@@quickmythril2398black holes denier, wow!

[@Zaczac111]

@@Joseph-kd9txStick is now many tiny stick particles. Stick always wins!

[@clevergirl4457]

Another Kurzgesagt video this month!?! What a treat! Looks like you guys couldn't resist making another black hole video after all...😅

[@hunshown]

They just cant resist black holes🩻🩻💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀☠☠🐵🐵🐵🐵🐵🐵

[@JayDavies-w6q]

​@@hunshown😟

[@tylerfloyd6908]

haven’t come across a channel where i binge watch all the videos in YEARS like i mean new fresh ideas that are always engaging and interesting and every time this amazing team puts together a new video you know your gonna learn something in a fun way.

[@Froany]

This channel's ability to walk you through the deep rooted understanding of a subject and take it to its extremes is un-paralleled!! They are really helping you truly understand these logical steps. It's so accessible, too! Of course I'm getting the pin to support them!

[@DireWaffle404]

I always trust Kurzgesagt to keep my grounded with a does of existential terror of "what if a singularity just rips apart physics"

[@lihan6870]

imagine if some aliens 3000 light years away decided to troll all of existence by stripping a black hole. Crazy

[@eamonndalton]

i fr thought of this lmfao@@lihan6870

[@eamonndalton]

if they were advanced enough to know how to to that, they'd be advanced enough to know how stupid it would be. Only humanity level stupidity would be the reason why a black hole is stripped lmao.@@lihan6870

[@thoatran2718]

ok

[@Jeracraft]

"Black holes are where God divided by zero." - Albert Einstein

[@qaskas]

"I didn't say that" - Albert Einstein

[@stanleybochenek1862]

Just use shitton of antimatter -me

[@hinkles73]

100th like! great einstein quote :)

[@flaviorian5578]

I don't think Einstein said that, but it made me laugh, so I'm liking

[@senorpepper3405]

So, neutron stars, God divided by an extremely small number? Like...by 1/1 × 10¹⁰⁰ ?

[@iqbit]

Can't wait for more form the Kurzgesagt Labs!

[@jessedampare1379]

I love how you went to the utmost edge of insane physics, and still made it in according to physics. Beautiful

[@sriramradhakrishna878]

Imagine being the physicist in charge of an event horizon breaking experiment. Real Oppenheimer moment right there.

[@Pho7on]

If you had the power to create a black hole with the mass of the moon, you'd have the power to annihilate a continent.

[@bestaround3323]

​@@Pho7onyou mean a planet or star

[@emeraldwarrior588]

"i have become death, destroyer of universes"

[@AvoidMyHitz]

​@@Pho7onyou mean, destroy half the galaxy.

[@natterbot]

The only way I've heard singularities effectively only existing 'in the future' explained in a way I've understood was that at the moment a singularity would be created because of the immense gravity warping space-time that moment is stretched indefinitely. It's nice to see it explained in a similar way again and as always kurzgesagt is greatly informative.

[@Chicken_Sithlord]

Whoever made the song made a boss battle song damn. And the animation is so good and smooth. Good job!

[@vihakingwhimsicalflame]

This is terrifying lol why do you guys love being so amazingly destructive i've been following your channel for years and it just seems to get better and better, wow

[@MoonlightLucy]

@@supernatural_forces dude wtf

[@LostSwiftpaw]

R-RAINWORLD PFP!!

[@MoonlightLucy]

bruh you must have never seen another kurzgesagt video before, what's terrifying about this?

[@TheSpooncer]

The video didn't even finish when you wrote this comment...

[@Ice_elite]

What was the first comment you wrote on. The channel

[@kariduanimations]

I heavily suspect there’s some weird physics rule we haven’t discovered yet that makes naked singularities impossible, like a process that makes it so that you can get rid of the event horizon, but it takes as long as it takes for the black hole to evaporate on its own to get rid of it, so you never get to the naked singularity.

[@Da0yster]

It's just as likely that there is no such thing as a singularity to begin with. The concept of a singularity occurs because our math breaks past the event horizon. However discovering new math could change that. It's potentially similar to how there was a singularity past Mach 1 originally when calculating air resistance on planes. Then we actually went faster than Mach 1, learned the singularity was the result of a flawed model, and had to redo all the equations for calculating air resistance because it turns out air behaves differently than our equations predicted once you reach the speed of sound.

[@blam320]

The Event Horizon is a region of extremely distorted space time, not a literal boundary. Hence the difficulty in defining it. It would be impossible to “break” or “remove” it in any way.

[@superslimanoniem4712]

​@@Da0yster we had bullets before planes, and they go supersonic. It was thus very likely to be known to be possible, just impossible to calculate.

[@clh2533]

its like how if you try to separate 2 quarks the energy used to pull them apart will spawn a new one

[@nehpets216]

Or it's the start of the Big Bang as we understand it since Time becomes wonky / didn't exist where the explosion happened while the Infinite Density of whatever exploded created our set of physics. We may find something that counters that view of the Big Bang but at this point it seems the most likely.

[@iamthatakhil]

The more I read and know about black holes, the more I appreciate Christopher Nolan and his Interstellar. How scientifically accurate and logical he tried to make it! Kudos to your team to make everyone try to understand it!

[@sabin97]

to be fair you should appreciate his scientific advisers. advisors? the people informing him on the science....

[@5k_vx]

I damn love damn Inter damn Stellar damn because damn it damn was damn so damn good damn. Holy damn shit damn it damn was damn so damn damn amazing damn.

[@Vicioussnakeboy]

​@@5k_vxIn this reply you sound like an AI I accidentally overexcited

[@5k_vx]

@@Vicioussnakeboy I know, that was the point

[@Vicioussnakeboy]

@@5k_vx jokes aside, my AI did get annoying after doing it for a while lol

[@ezrah1367]

5:35 this music is so cool and fitting!

[@Pluneto]

This has to be most awe inducing video by you guys. Exploring these concepts and theories of the most extreme scenarios is what inspires me to understand more about how the universe works!

[@gamingfireplayz2256]

Exactly, it’s brain melting

[@aaronperelmuter8433]

If that’s true, I’d strongly suggest you don’t attempt to do so by watching vids here. There were SO many concepts mentioned that are either 100% theory and absolutely no possibility of happening in the real, physical world, there were several concepts mentioned which go against the mainstream current understanding and so on. Do yourself a favour and go check out PBS Space Time. It’s hosted and written by an actual professor of astrophysics, and they have REAL graphics and an actual human being, not just this lsd inspired cartoons which are constantly shown here. I’m saying this for your benefit, if you really are inspired to learn about this awesome subject matter, don’t do it here, you’ll seriously regret it a few years down the track when you find out you’ve been misled and lied to and must relearn a shitload of the stuff you thought you already knew.

[@tonevlone4009]

lookup Jay FR topic - Will You Remember in the tab up top off top?

[@gyrthez246]

Thank you Kurzgesagt for singlehandedly feeding my anxiety disorder with new fears while also debunking those fears in a digestible way that makes sense to average people.

[@ForeverTemplar]

Eh, what of anything here could possibly scare you? And why are you watching it if it you know it'll trigger you?

[@gyrthez246]

@@ForeverTemplar It's not this that scares me but the knowledge that the stupidest people on our planet also happen to be some of the richest that would attempt doing something like this in the very distant future. I watch because I love information and theory.

[@vael123]

just say youre american and move on, all you comments are just basically normal people toughts and issues that we take for granted and not turn into words. but americans....@@gyrthez246

[@kennethHorning-Alvia]

you wouldent understand obviously. think for a bit, will you?@@ForeverTemplar

[@BuddhismWisdoms]

The sheer creativity in this animation! I can almost picture the animators giggling as they brought this ridiculousness to life.

[@Nerdy31]

Thank you for being here for the hardest moments.

[@datboiyt7112]

It’s insane that something like a black hole exists and is a real thing. it seems so unreal, yet it is

[@vortex_711]

Science and rules of physics in our universe have been created by Allah (SWT) and its mentioned multiple times for as many topics, such for this, our Prophet (saas) have indeed reached the boundaries (end of space-time) read by: --- Sûrat An- Najm ( The Star ) LIII, Chapter: 53 1. By the star when it decends 2. Your companion ( Muhammad) has neither gone astray nor has erred. 3. Nor does he speak of ( his own ) desire. 4. It is only a Revelation revealed. 5. He has been taught ( this Qur’ân ) by one mighty in power [ Jibrîl ( Gabriel ) ] 6. One free from any defect in body and mind then he ( Jibrîl - Gabriel in his real shape as created by Allah ) rose and became stable. 7. While he [ Jibrîl ( Gabriel ) ] was in the highest part of the horizon, ( Tafsir Ibn Kathir ) 8. Then he [ Jibrîl ( Gabriel ) ] approached and came closer, 9. And was at a distance of two bows’ length or ( even ) nearer. 10. So ( Allâh ) revealed to His slave [ Muhammad through Jibrîl ( Gabriel ) ( as ) ] whatever He revealed. 11. The ( Prophet’s ) heart lied not in what he ( Muhammad ) saw. 12. Will you then dispute with him ( Muhammad ) about what he saw [ during the Mi‘râj: ( Ascent of the Prophet to the seven heavens ) ] [ 1 ] 13. And indeed he ( Muhammad ) saw him [ Jibrîl ( Gabriel ) ] at a second descent ( i.e. another time ) . 14. Near Sidrat- ul- Muntaha ( a lote- tree of the utmost boundary over the seventh heaven beyond which none can pass ) . 15. Near it is the Paradise of Abode. 16. When that covered the lote- tree which did cover it! [ 2 ] 17. The sight ( of Prophet Muhammad ) turned not aside ( right or left ) , nor it transgressed beyond the limit ( ordained for it ) . 18. Indeed he ( Muhammad ( saas ) ) did see of the Greatest Signs, of his Lord ( Allâh ). Also: Sûrat Al Ma'arij. ( The Acent) Chapter 7. A questioner asked concerning a torment about to befall 2. Upon the disbelievers, which none can avert, 3. From Allah, the Lord of the ways of ascent. (Tunnels through space) 4. The angels and the Ruh [Jibrael (Gabriel)] ascend to Him in a Day the measure whereof is fifty thousand years. --- Today we know that and space is flexible and time could be dilated. Which mentioned in Quran, a day in the heavens (Space) could reach 50,000 years of our counting on earth And when the star descends, it could reach the blackhole threshold. Do not be like those who denied the truth. Follow God by doing the goodness and do your prayers daily, ask God the right path and he is the most Leistenful and Merciful

[@TheBloofyx]

What's funny is it's just gravity but also the next step in our understanding of physics

[@adrianpoltorzycki1211]

This and what started the big bang make me question reality

[@betinhoeur]

Your own existence is also kind of unreal, so cheers mate!

[@Lol-ux7ki]

Or is it real?🤨

[@demon_xd_]

ah yes, extremely dangerous experiments involving the very thing that breaks our understanding of physics; truly peak Kurzgesagt

[@Comment27560]

Alternate: "how to destroy black holes by using imaginative methods"

[@azeemtravadi6128]

read death's end by cixin liu they put a black hole in an oneil cylinder

[@yesiasked]

🤓

[@demon_xd_]

"🤓" -🤓, c.2024

[@pelagiushipbone7968]

Anyone notice the upgrade in the animation that was already spectular? This channel never ceases to amaze

[@zackf13]

It's incredible to see how far the quality of these videos has come

[@EntropyBBall]

Huge level up in animation and they went crazy with it! Love it!

[@quickmythril2398]

lol, HD Remastered Edition of little duck blobs? amazing... they are truly brilliant liars, i mean artists.

[@dreadavis9751]

I think when many black holes combine and when they reach a limit, they explode like big bang

[@GIRGHGH]

If falling into a black hole accelerates you into the future, and black holes evaporate in a finite amount of time, doesn't that mean nothing can ever reach a singularity?

[@NerdyCrow17]

I see it like this, when you fall on the event horizon, you become part of and are rapidly going to a future in which the black hole becomes so small it disappears, but you are still part of it Basically, the black hole is also falling into the singularity, and the moment it dissolves is the moment all of the object inside the black hole hit the singularity

[@Darkregen9545]

You can reach it time is just distorted. What we see is anything that isn't light go to the center and vanish because your matter is crushed in the atomic level down to every atom and become a part of the mass of the black hole enhancing its gravitational pull and mass that's all compressed.

[@GIRGHGH]

What do you mean "the black hole is falling into the singularity?"

[@NerdyCrow17]

@@GIRGHGH it's not exactly how it works but it can help you understand With time, the black hole gets smaller and smaller until it disappears With time, you will fall into the singularity in the future What stops the moment you touch the singularity to be the moment the black hole disappears You both touch the singularity at the same time The black hole gets infinitely smaller (a singularity) You get squished into a singularity Think of it like a prison that is VERY slowly getting smaller and you are sentenced to death by being squished, the walls won't kill you, only in the future when there is no more space left for you, when you die and the wall touch each other, there is nothing inside the walls, so it is no longer a prison

[@Tounushi]

@@GIRGHGH A black hole is compression of spacetime brought to its logical conclusion. As gravity is spacetime compression and the singularity is infinite curvature, spacetime flows into the singularity; the event horizon is simply the point where the speed of this flow is faster than the speed of light. Hawking radiation also manages to rob energy/mass from the black hole at cosmological timescales if it isn't fed, so it constantly contracts until it draws in more matter or energy (including cosmic microwave background radiation). And it will continue to contract at an ever-accelerating pace (from grass growing to snail's pace) until the final moments of evaporation are like a supernova. It'll just take a googol years to reach that point.

[@UshankaAdam]

This went from "black hole be gone" to "spacetime bending existential crisis fever dream"

[@ghifariasoka8272]

The pipeline of all Kurzgesagt video

[@ah7maw265]

I got the vibes from you writing "fever" Lol thanks for your comment , it's underated

[@pouriya8587]

What a method to convey increasingly complex concepts. Physics breaking down has always meant our understanding of the universe failing us. It has always meant progress. You could refer to the gold sheet experiment of Rutherford as breaking the "physics". What you do here is amazing. Thank you.

[@johnladuke6475]

I get what you mean, but I've always interpreted "physics breaking down" to be more than that. Not so much that our understanding of physical laws falters, but that the environment becomes such that our known set of laws becomes abstract and meaningless. A world where any set of rules or laws would need to be discovered from scratch and could completely contradict fundamental principles of the original physics that got broken.

[@Tr3k22-hr]

wow i cant believe that just ripping the kind of "shell of the black hole" off will break the very vicinity and fabric of the very physics that hold the universe up.

[@rayoflight62]

I wanted to add, The nature of a "singularity" is a mathematical one. Sort of when you divide a number by zero, basically you break our arithmetics and the result can be whatever you like. The "event horizon" is the last region of Space around the Black Hole where our mathematics still apply. Beyond the event horizon, while our maths doesn't work, phylosophy still does. I see how you wonderfully expanded the concept with this video. Thanks! Anthony

[@quickmythril2398]

you hit on a key point here. it's just math. not any real thing that we have evidence of. black holes are just like dividing by zero. you can talk about it as a concept, but it's essentially meaningless. it has no basis in reality.

[@piotrd.4850]

@@quickmythril2398 Except, we know black holes exist.

[@cthuwu2138]

@@piotrd.4850 we know that they exist, but as far as I understand, anything inside of the event horizon doesn't exist, at least in the sense that anything inside of the event horizon no longer follows any of the rules that we use to define "existing"

[@mopnem]

What's your definition of philosophy in this context?

[@andrejcop3229]

We can describe infinites, limits and black holes for that matter pretty well with our math. Just not with a high school math lol

[@JoltFlyer]

This video did not only break physics, but it also broke my mind in a good way

[@marianabravo1940]

5:32 my jaw is literally on the ground and omg the soundtrack???!?!? makes me feel so insignificant and at the same time so fascinated and terrified KURZGESAGT YOU NEVER FAIL TO AMAZE !!! i learn so much from you, thank you for your videos you guys are AMAZING!!!

[@ThatNeonLight]

THANK YOUUUUUUU OMG AS SOMEONE WHO IS IN A SYMPHONIC ORCHESTRA; MUSIC LIKE THIS FEELS LIKE YOU'RE FLYING IM MESMERISED WORDS CANNOT DESCRIBE HOW AMAZED I AM

[@lauriea7114]

so true am dieing

[@rip_dino-xl7dw]

Animations are crazy! Great Video

[@starwantrix5324]

I often think that black holes are like bugs in a game, something broke, some paradox, star got too much mass it collapsed into a black hole, it mesmerizes me that such things exist. Universe is quite magical

[@nyx-edits3935]

Black holes be patching up stars for us 🗿

[@maxave7448]

Perhaps we are living in a simulation and when massive objects collapse in on themselves, because the density becomes so huge, some floating-point error occurs during the computation which returns an infinite density (thus creating the singularity) and creates a black hole 🤔

[@PURENT]

@@maxave7448 That's not what a floating point error is. Floating point error is when there is a lack of adequate precision which leads to errors when performing math. If you want an example, take out your smartphone, open the calculator, divide 1 by 2, then divide the result by 2, and repeat over and over until you get some very tiny number that can only be displayed in scientific notation. Then start multiplying by 2 over and over until you get back to 1. You will find that you won't get 1, but actually a number like 1.0000269312. That's floating point error, the small numbers could not be represented with enough precision and then when you try to reverse the process you end up with the wrong result.

[@anthonycaruso1781]

What bothers me about videos like this is that they fail to acknowledge the fact that we just don't know so much about how the universe works. The laws of physics don't "break down" inside a black hole, it's just that physics as we understand it doesn't work under certain conditions, but it works under most normal conditions. Our understanding of the laws of physics are incomplete, they're wrong. The way we think the universe works doesn't work inside a singularity, so we say it 'breaks the rules', when in reality, we just don't know all the rules.

[@Scorch428]

If nothing escapes a blackhole, than how do the particles it emits escape??

[@Hydrocarbonateable]

I asked a physicist a couple months ago if anyone had calculated what it would take for a black hole to blow up, and he said nobody had ever tried. And here you guys are, with all your research. Nerds really are the best. ❤ Keep on asking the right questions!

[@bullymaguire3867]

There are no wrong questions

[@derpyderp2048]

@@bullymaguire3867 But some are more useful and more fun than others

[@ShadeAKAhayate]

Small enough mass would cause it to evaporate rapidly, which would be an equivalent of explosion.

[@kovy689]

This is all theoretical tho…

[@anujmchitale]

The video didn't calculate anything either. Just mentioned what others hypothesize. It's all a fantasy, in the end. That physicist gave you a real answer instead of a fantasy.

[@larvasupershow]

the idea of black holes as superprisons keeping reality breakers imprisoned is actually really cool

[@michaelbuckers]

For a rotating black hole, its singularity is shaped like a ring. When you spin it too fast, its singularity grows out of its own event horizon - which is why it's deemed impossible (there's also a lot of complicated math about it). These black holes also have 2 different event horizons, one time-like and one space-like. All natural black holes are thought to be rotating, with the "standard" non-rotating black holes being purely theoretical. The inverse is true for charged black holes, those are only thought to exist in theory since natural black holes neutralize their own charge by attracting more of opposite charge matter.

[@baraapudding]

a ringshaped singularity actually makes me wonder: what happens if you are in the exact centre of that "ringularity"? Because, like Kurzgesagt also explained, the singularity would be your future. But if you are in the exact centre of this ring, every direction points toward the future.

[@gordontaylor2815]

I'm curious why charged black holes are thought to only exist in theory - surely there are regions of space where, by chance, the amounts of particles with one charge vastly outnumber those of another charge?

[@blazewarking]

@@baraapuddingtime travel

[@namantherockstar]

Nutshell inspires me.. My parents said if i get 40K followers They'd buy me a professional camera for recording..begging u guys , literally Begging...

[@WEARETHEWARIORS]

yes the space event horizon is the ergo sphere, talked about in some other videos

[@JoltFlyer]

I really want to thank kurzgesagt for their incredible impact on our understanding of the universe, basically everything I know about it comes from your videos!

[@Tearen0]

The line that really got me in the gut was "...the singularity is not in front of you; it's in your future." If that ain't cosmic horror at its finest.

[@Opt1cILu5i0n]

Ikr. And if time is flowing backwards... Wouldnt that future to us be perceived as being in the past to an observer inside the black hole? Hense the singularity that gave birth to the big bang. Then lets continue to assume that to expand is just a property of space in and of itself, then the part of space that was originally contained withen the newly formed singularity, a single planc length of space is all you need to seed an ever expanding universe. It would just continue expanding forever in all directions outwards from an event in the "past" like we observe space to do. WOAH. Hold up. I now get why the big bang isnt at the centre of the universe. Its a point in time not a point in space. Holy fuck I cant believe I never fully wrapped my head around that. Classical thinking seems to feel as though space "should" emenate "outwards" from the big bang, but from our perspective as we look into space its like space comes rushing in from all directions following an event in the past that we cant see because of the cosmic event horizon. We would have to go faster then light and therefore back in time. We cant see the singularity here either because its just like the black hole. It exists as a moment before space and time. If you can even call that a "moment." That makes the brain spin to try and imagine haha. You get what Im laying down here? I never even noticed the incompletness in the brains ability to grasp Space-time. And what it has to do with our cosmic event horizon being like a bubble around us despite the fact space has no centre to it. Should place us at the center as we observe outwards no? That right there is a hint that were not picturing space correctly. Like does that mean the big bang happened EVERYWHERE?!? No. EVERYWHEN! Wait.... See what I mean!? WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING ON HERE AND WHY CAN MY BRIAN KIND OF CONTEMPLATE THAT. DOES PART OF WHATEVER "I" AM EXIST OUTSIDE OF SPACETIME? WE HAVE TOO MANNNN. AND THAT WOULD THEN GIVE RISE TO CONCIOUSNESS FOLLOWING MY ACID THEORY OF LIFE 😂 Its all connected hahaha. There was no time before the big bang, there was also no space!! The big bang THAT MADE SPACETIME, HOLD UP. took place OUTSIDE OF SPACETIME. IT HAD TO OF. IT HAPPENED RIGHT AT THE INSTANCE BEFORE SPACE AND TIME CAUSE IT CREATED SPACE AND TIME THATS WHY WE CAN NEVER SEE IT NO MATTER HOW FAR BACK WE LOOK. In order for time to exist the fastest speed at which information can travel is light speed. But light speed is actually defined as the distance at which light travels in a vacuum. "Distance" implies space. You cant have distance between things without space between them. Therefore you cant have time and causality without space. Hense. Space-time. Lol. So without there being a spacetime for the big bang to occur in. It can not occur in any specific location. Theres no location to have housed it in 😂 Time is a property of space. its literally just space. Its ALL space. Space is a mind bending concept. Spacetime is where the universe happens. Its all fuckn Space-time bro, I. I cant even right now 🤯😂💀

[@9bang88]

​@@Opt1cILu5i0ni aint reading allat

[@grimsladeleviathan3958]

@@Opt1cILu5i0n Just to let you know, I did read all of that. Don't stop thinking, my friend. Because this is fascinating to say the least.

[@peregrine4214]

@@Opt1cILu5i0n wait is this not a normal thing to think about? i think about it all the time.

[@thebossbrothers123]

​@@Opt1cILu5i0nThese sorts of realizations is why i personally believe in a consious Creator. If a 'naked singularity' is a construct of 'maximum absurdity with infinite range', that basically translates to being with unlimited information and ability to release said information. Yet space-time was actively construed to hold information in a recognizable form by the beings that would inhabit said 'information'. WHY???. Why not just release truly unstable things all the time/all the space, why have a universal/axiomatic censor on the truly absurd and unstable? My only answer i can understand is that constraints were not necessary but curated, intended. Anecdotally nothing in the universe typically wishes to be alone so I would like to persume God inconcievable and infinitely full of 'information' wanted to share it and the universe as observed is how he shares his space(time) with everyone. Angels, animals, solar constructs, humans, everyone and everything that 'lives' is his, Jehovah's, passion project.

[@williamantonio9743]

So basically falling into a black hole and seeing the singularity is like the reverse of Golden Experience Requiem.

[@thatsaysalotabout-man9547]

They're very very different, but surely they have core similarities

[@gladoseon4117]

“You will never reach the truth” vs “You will always reach the singularity”. Also, GER’s ability is called “return to zero”, which reminds me a bit of how Black Holes delete information.

[@Voc_spooksauce]

Not only was the animation, narration and information for this amazing as always, but the music was so on point. Specially when talking about the end of reality itself with the chorus and all

[@mix3k818]

It's so funny and fascinating watching a science channel actively make physics-breaking hypothesies like this.

[@Litkeen]

Infinite density does not make sense, if it really was infinite then the gravitational pull it exerts on the universe would be infinite, and so the whole universe would be going at the speed of light towards the singularity Plus, how a single point with 0 volume even make sense? The pauli exclusion principle forbids fermions (e.g. electrons) from occupying the same state. That means no 2 electrons can be in the same place, therefore 0 volume is impossible as that would mean 2 particles occupying the same space.

[@jiminslostjams249]

@@LitkeenWhy are you ranting to a random comment that has nothing to do with what you’re talking about?

[@Webi]

@@Litkeen The existence of the universe itself is a paradox, after all how can something come from nothing.

[@quickmythril2398]

it's so funny to call a Gates Foundation funded propaganda dispenser as a "science channel" :D

[@laratheplanespotter]

I’ve been eager to see a new video from you!! I love your channel and content very much! Thank you for making science accessible for everyone!

[@naailkhokhar]

🤖

[@Comment27560]

You really be thinking this is science💀 These are theories

[@eristheslayer]

@avidanbhujbal27 these are theories based on... say it with me...

[@martinmarkov9707]

​@@eristheslayer bananas and birbs.. and bombs.

[@laratheplanespotter]

@@naailkhokhar uhh no. I’m a human. Well, 4% Neanderthal but I’m definitely human. To everyone else: I meant the channel as a whole

[@Hazel-of-the-Basil]

This seems like an insanely good premise for a cosmic horror scify movie about scientists trying to break an event horizon

[@BladeLigerV]

Is a black hole an infinite prison of a singularity, or is a black hole a protective shell that's just holding the singularity in place?

[@zepaduse97]

Both; actually. It’s a singularity in which all protons and electrons are basically forcefully merged together making it purely neutrons. In the event that the singularity is disrupted it’d be one hell of nuclear explosion forcing the extra neutrons to violently unfuse back into electrons and protons which at this point is my theory will recreate a sun.(the sun part is my speculation because a sun is essentially a continuous nuclear explosion. Don’t take what I said in that last part as fact.)

[@Kokodesuyoooo]

"Is black hole infinite because of it's singularity? Or is black hole singular because of it's infinity?" "Nah i'd win."

[@lunarbat6009]

💀 ​@@Kokodesuyoooo

[@omaki82036]

@@Kokodesuyoooo nice one

[@VECTOYETMOSTAPAH]

​@@KokodesuyooooINFINITY IS A FAKE NUMBER

[@saren874]

Love your videos. Most physicists doubt the existence of singularities and say they're caused by incomplete models, at least in my impression.

[@mrsamot4677]

Yep. Anytime we get an infinity in our math it normally means we don’t have strong enough tools to understand.

[@ceu160193]

@@mrsamot4677 Since universe began from point with infinite energy and infinite mass exploding, singularity can exist.

[@eclogite]

@@ceu160193 As I understand, it's thought more recently that the universe was very small but not infinitesimal

[@lukasrafajpps]

@@ceu160193 are you certain about that information?

[@lukasrafajpps]

That is the correct view. There is a singularity according to general relativity but gravity at that point is so strong that maybe the effects of quantum gravity overtake the effects of general relativity. And we know general relativity can't work at the center of a BH because it is based on the fact that you can locally replace every point of the curved spacetime by a flat minkowski spacetime and then use methods of calculus to transfer between these points. But this will not work if the curvature is infinite as you can't create a locally flat Minkowski spacetime at that point.

[@Cheeser409]

"Ferb I know what we are going to do today"

[@thund3rscores]

underrated

[@flaminggolem9539]

Candice be like:'MOOOOOM'

[@sebastianlovernumber10928]

BHAHAHAH

[@drabsnow2254]

singularity... white holes? they also eject mass as much as black holes eat it up.

[@Alex_192.]

@@flaminggolem9539 "PHINEAS AND FERB ARE BREAKING THE UNIVERSE AGAIN!"

[@thehavocmiranda]

The idea of black holes are superheroes, protecting the whole universe from the singularity is beautiful.

[@catpoke9557]

The comparison of a black hole to an elementary particle was really interesting. I almost wonder if some of the weird properties of black holes exist because it's basically a macro object running on quantum software lol After all, the quantum world often behaves in ways that make no sense outside of it.

[@cedriceric9730]

😂 thats exactly what it is

[@catpoke9557]

@@cedriceric9730 I would not be surprised

[@patrickchang9135]

Lucky that black holes don't randomly teleport like how quantum objects do then eh

[@qwertyqwert2818]

or it's a micro object if we just count the singularity, so maybe it's actually much closer to one?

[@catpoke9557]

@@qwertyqwert2818 Good point. It would make sense that it behaves similarly considering it's actually the smallest object in the universe, just surrounded by darkness.

[@jasperderonde5895]

Wow... black holes are so unfathomably fascinating*, I will never not be perplexed watching your videos on this topic. Educating, amusing, gorgeous to the eye. Outstanding work, Kurzgesagt team

[@SaraMorgan-ym6ue]

can enough nukes blow up the black hole?

[@Nwunchuck27]

Nope they're a bottomless pit

[@lyssiana]

Me: *calls joe biden* Joe Biden: *throws infinite nukes at every black hole*

[@Mannwhich]

That's why these videos keep getting made, because you'll just eat it up.

[@SquirrelGamez]

It's fascinating how much we know about black holes now compared to only a few decades ago.

[@MohdSaud-wd2mq]

Lol

[@avengersendgame9706]

And still don't know 1% of it

[@g76agi]

​@@avengersendgame9706whered you get that number from?

[@avengersendgame9706]

@@g76agi just from the past ,we will never know enough about space .there will always be new information related to space even after 1000 years.

[@zhamed9587]

@@avengersendgame9706 "... and you ˹O humanity˺ have been given but little knowledge.” -- Quran 17:85

[@JustSomePerson8]

Need a more in depth video like this on just back holes. Maybe can we get in a black hole alive video

[@jerseyse410]

This is probably my favorite video you guys have made to date, I love the thought of breaking physics

[@Victory-Otp]

This might be the most important channel on KZbin, because never before in human history has such complicated, complex topics been this readily available, and easy to understand. This channel allows so many people to research important topics that humanity benefits from solutions and knowledge on.

[@TechfulThinking]

Absolutely love whoever choreographed the music for this video! The “breaking physics” section was epic 😱

[@cupacoopa1790]

I FEEL LIKE WATCHING OPENHIMER THO!

[@davidumann6707]

@@cupacoopa1790 -We're saying there's a chance that when push that button, we destroy physics? -Chances are near zero. -Near zero? -What do you want from theory alone? -Zero would be nice.

[@tradd1763]

This was one of the most interesting videos I've seen