Income from Shares - Capital Gain or Business Income?

[@aqilmunawar3524]

Sir, very informative and well explained. I have a query what if Amrita Talwar was investjng in Real Estate (instead of shares) for Investment. Do u think the judgment would have remain the same as given by High Court?

[@AbhishekMahajanER]

I liked your video, I have a doubt - I have a salary income, profit / loss from equity stocks(intraday & overnight), equity MF and Future & Options. I understand capital gain will be taxed less compare to business income for equity, but there can also be cases, where we can have profit from equity stock and loss in F&O or profit in F&O and loss in equity - for this case can put both in business income ? What you will suggest for long term (considering CBDT 6/2016 clarification)?

[@sirajudheench2445]

I normally sold shares within 1 month. Can I treat it as Business income????

[@sirajudheench2445]

Is this allowed to file ITR with Short term gains as Business income and LONG TERM GAIN as Capital gain.???

[@nishikantrai654]

Video is very informative, unique and to the point. I came across such a video by searching the topic. I have a query, if possible, please reply. I am a retired person. I have earned Rs 15 lacs from F&O and Rs 5 lacs as from Sale of Equity shares within 8 months for AY 2021-22. Is income from sale of shares within one years is STCG or Business Income? Please guide

[@bicaps1313]

Hello Mr Rai! Please check my video of this topic kzbin.info/www/bejne/eKnRm2ZoosyhodE

[@AbhishekMahajanER]

Hello Nishikantji, sale of equity can be in business income or STCG. If you only conside for AY2021-22 you will have lower tax in case of STCG. But also consider circular 6/2016, you will not able to change later AY.

[@subhamjain7477]

Hello I had 44AD business income and other sources income asprimary source of income . But this year I had capital gains. Will you please guide which ITR form is applicable? Plz reply

[@yuvrajsharma2832]

Same question

[@yuvrajsharma2832]

Can u guide me also

[@KTB4691]

Circular 6 is still valid For fy 20-21 ?

[@KTB4691]

Instead of not having more transactions can I show it in stock in trade ?