The Best Cheesecake In NYC | Best In Town

Herrine Ro and Erin Kommor search New York City to find the best New York-style cheesecake. They visit Veniero’s, a classic Italian bakery that’s been operating for over 120 years; Eileen’s Special Cheesecake, an award-laden spot with dozens of specialty flavors; and Mah-Ze-Dahr, a newcomer with a gourmet twist on a classic recipe. They try the most popular cheesecake at each spot and declare which is the best in town.
Editor’s note: This episode was filmed in December 2019 and January 2020. All New York restaurants remained closed to dine-in service, but check out the bakeries’ websites for current takeout, delivery, and shipping options.
VENIERO’S:
venierospastry.com/
/ venierospastry
EILEEN’S:
/ eileenscheesecake
www.eileenscheesecake.com/
MAH ZE DAHR:
mahzedahrbakery.com/announcem... / mahzedahrbakery
MORE BEST IN TOWN:
The Best Pepperoni Pizza In NYC
• The Best Pepperoni Piz...
The Best Hot Chocolate In London
• The Best Hot Chocolate...
The Best Barbecue In Austin
• The Best Barbecue In A...
------------------------------------------------------
#NYC #Cheesecake #FoodInsider
Insider is great journalism about what passionate people actually want to know. That’s everything from news to food, celebrity to science, politics to sports and all the rest. It’s smart. It’s fearless. It’s fun. We push the boundaries of digital storytelling. Our mission is to inform and inspire.
Subscribe to our channel and visit us at: www.insider.com
Food Insider on Facebook: / foodinsider
Food Insider on Instagram: / thisisinsiderfood
Food Insider on Twitter: / insiderfood
Insider on Snapchat: / 4020934530
Insider on Amazon Prime: www.amazon.com/v/thisisinsider
Insider on TikTok: / insider
Food Insider on Dailymotion: www.dailymotion.com/foodinsider
The Best Cheesecake In NYC | Best In Town

[@InsiderFood]

Want more Best in Town? Herrine and Erin visit Chicago to find the best Chicago-style hot dogs in the city: kzbin.info/www/bejne/j6fCn4OZq7useqM

[@zenogloria2919]

No

[@pinchasfeinstein9999]

Yummy

[@maetamonxg7718]

@Food Insider, turn off comments on this video. Too much trolling

[@whatever45892]

why would u bring someone who doesnt like cheesecake to taste it

[@innominadojustis2224]

Haha the BEST ONE IS JUNIORS period

[@anthonycools8400]

Why would you guys choose someone who doesn’t like cheesecake to go and taste them ! Smh

[@irvp3541]

anthony cools it’s a damn shame

[@shermagustave837]

The disrespect!!!

[@juicenot2481]

You cant trust the taste buds of someone who does not like cheesecake, she doesn't know food at all!

[@ayan-jk1177]

Idk it reminds me of when I annoy my friends with my likes and their dislikes lol.

[@ceecee5098]

Right

[@ashashh1260]

This girl literally ate Strawberry with a Pinch of Cheesecake

[@la.melaninqueentina]

I peeped that too 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jl1741]

No she ate TWO strawberries with a pinch on cheesecake.

[@sathviksaravan6409]

I am still thinking about it

[@core_gen]

I dont like the fact it was TWO DAMN STRAWBERRIES- and barely any of the freaking cheesecake- LIKE- BEHEAD THE WOMAN

[@Cjackson6672]

Fam ate all the strawberries and a crumb😂😂😂😂

[@nirlusebastiansia3272]

Next time, don't invite some critic that doesn't like the food at all.

[@koutaono9973]

yikes

[@leannejayyy]

I made ur likes 200😂💔

[@piecesofme8531]

LMAO

[@CainP]

She aint even a critic.

[@gimmekromer1151]

@@CainP everyone is a critic

[@boatonhana]

First they sent a vegetarian to review a BBQ joint and now they sent someone who doesn’t like cheesecake to review cheesecake.

[@margarethmichelina5146]

It's like sending your kid to hospital when they're not sick!

[@amanda-zg5ho]

They also sent someone who doesn't like pbj to review a pbj flavored cookie.

[@MultiCklee]

@@amanda-zg5ho yup. bj for a gal who doesn't like it.

[@safe-keeper1042]

Best way to review things. When the people who don't like it actually enjoy it, you know it's good ^^,

[@feverpitchcourtside]

Awful

[@la1495]

The blonde girl wasn't bringing anything to this. She's like that person in college in a group power point that just reads off the slides the rest of you made.

[@elleeleanor1764]

HOLY THAT'S RELATEABLE TO MEE

[@jeffhur4066]

Hahaha so true to my experiences

[@maureengrimes8582]

Erin ruined this. I don’t want to hear the opinion of the best cheesecake in New York from someone who doesn’t like cheesecake.

[@carylcabigao7268]

LOL SAME

[@emradford5173]

Agree

[@xmackdab658]

it’s a no biased opinion then

[@hehekeke8413]

@@xmackdab658 actually. It is biased since she doesn't like cheesecake, they're both biased. If she didn't mind it and didn't love but didn't hate it then it wouldn't be that biased

[@brenda_mart]

When I read your comment, I thought you meant the Erin (the vegan that would keep saying "that's not vegan") 😂

[@Top10Tibbz]

I low-key hate the insider for letting someone that hates cheesecake judge the best cheesecake in NY

[@i_am_a_sky_walkerzoom354]

Exactly wtf whyyyyy?

[@nextgenfootball69420]

they wanted it too seem like the cheesecakes were so good that it can convert a person who doesn't like it to like it

[@diamondgoldenblackmore408]

Cheese Cake.... This Too Shall Pass Away...., 😎🎈🥗🥤🍔🍔🍔🌈😀😄💌

[@safe-keeper1042]

Nah, that's the best part of this whole video.

[@nocturnalsimulacrum6385]

I unsubscribed...

[@Willy4206.]

The whole comment section is just ROASTING Erin and I love it

[@seulgisjoy7439]

She seems quite personable but why is she even in this video? She shouldn't be judging cheesecake.

[@ThoreauMyLifeAway]

She’s the worst.

[@eved.2173]

i literally love her what

[@Willy4206.]

They just put her in for her personality. Honestly can see why it’s not like anyone really uses the guide

[@k._.24]

@@ThoreauMyLifeAway yupp

[@akanshasubil6894]

I don't get why hosts who seem like they don't particularly like cheesecake, set out to find the best one and have also been judging on the basis of which cheesecake tastes the least like cheesecake 😑

[@fola3932]

Right, especially the part where they judge by how least it taste like cheesecake, like yall are cheesecake taste-testing why are we talking about which taste LEAST like cheesecake at all

[@mara0633]

Ok, but why would y'all bring her if she doesn't like cheesecake??

[@CBrown-zu6jf]

They're trying to turn a cheesecake hater into a cheesecake lover.

[@Erik_Emer]

@@CBrown-zu6jf I agree. If you can make a cheesecaker hater into a cheesecaker lover, even if with a specific location, that's a job supremely well done.

[@helin7926]

She's the host of the show, it's literally her job??? Also that's the whole point, to make her love it

[@NikkiLee2023]

She was rubbing her belly like she's lactose intolerant lol (something bad is going to happen)

[@Presca1]

My thoughts...

[@dillonmichaels6037]

Erin: "This is so good, I would totally try this again!" Also Erin: *eating just the fruits and crust*

[@BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB]

Erin shouldn’t even be here since she’s not a good judge of cheesecake.

[@nurhayatinurhayati3081]

Ikr

[@pussydweller1015]

It's just her opinion, this isn't some food critique show or something lmao

[@helin7926]

she's one of the hosts of the show like chill dude she didn't even complain or said she is professionaly qualified to judge it it's just a show :)

[@zir456]

@@pussydweller1015 But They still comparing which one better, so Its definitely considered Food Critique...🤔🤔🤔🤔

[@pussydweller1015]

@@zir456 aren't food critique shows supposed to be done by professional food critiques? And don't you earn starts or something if it's food critiques?

[@TymetheInfamous]

What happened to the black girl :( she was fun

[@ANG3LiiToVU3LA]

She was an amazing food reviewer

[@catstealer3454]

yeah:(

[@jennifercalandra2074]

I agree. I really don't care for these two at all.

[@jomama617]

@@K4yla23 How?

[@oneshotclan1456]

No she garbage

[@injesusname3732]

"a crust detracts from the cheesecake" ...adds 10 lbs of strawberries

[@icantthinkofaname15]

Lol

[@jennifercalandra2074]

Lmao

[@nocturnal371]

Lol

[@jesusisthetruth4497]

RIGHT LOL

[@reverlyevans-higgins5357]

Cheesecake should never be bland and it shouldn't have toppings to be complete, it should be able to stand alone but enhanced by a topping. The topping is usually there to hide the flaws in the top crust, but a ban marie would eliminate the need for that.

[@Eliv537]

Hard when you don’t have a crust lol

[@nobody-fo9px]

Exactly

[@nguyendang6178]

Yup I never eat cheesecake with topping and can easily finish the whole slide. A good cheesecake is already a perfection by itself.

[@pariahincognito3914]

The blonde girl you guys called Erin looked like she was faking her reactions and from the start it was clear that she didn't like cheesecake so it kinda ruined the mood. Seriously this ain't valid.

[@LoveVanita]

She literally made the whole episode about her

[@core_gen]

@@LoveVanita omgg- she did,she kept nagging about how she wont like it,probably fakes her reaction Like focus on the damn food rather than yourself I get criticizing is major part of food reviews but get someone who probably doesnt even like it ruins it (I wanted to just say your correct but i ended up rambling- sorry-)

[@gemsparkles7977]

Yes, she wants to be a celebrity.... Lol

[@soluna_22]

Bring someone who really loves cheesecake next time. So annoying

[@harryvanrooyen8430]

2 girls 1 cup.....

[@icantthinkofaname15]

@@harryvanrooyen8430 shtf weirdo

[@fliesinthesugarbowlshooflyshoo]

@@icantthinkofaname15 no u

[@vitaminjisoo1439]

This made me remember the time they send off a vegetarian to taste a Filipino pork dish but she just ended up eating the fish version 👎

[@theluffy99]

Link for that vid? Can't find it

[@zoyaali1396]

how is she a vegetarian if she eats fish that’s so funny

[@vitaminjisoo1439]

i think fish isn't technically a meat as i remember. idk maybe im wrong but as i remember vegetarians can eat fish 🐠

[@nicknicknicks8079]

Lmaooo that is so stupid. Vegetarians ugh

[@zoyaali1396]

vitamin jisoo I mean it’s animal flesh 😶 ppl just don’t wanna admit it bc they use it as an excuse to eat a form of meat

[@TymetheInfamous]

It's not as fun when they don't dig in and devour it

[@swetasaxena6830]

Omfg it's you here I mean I kinda watch your videos

[@nabihanasir2326]

Can we just talk about Mah-Ze-Dahr, please? I'm so proud of Ms. Ahmad for excelling in her field and showing other young Pakistani-North Americans (I'm Canadian lol, hence the generalization) that we can do it too!

[@smartskater11]

I don't know why you would choose someone to review something they don't even like eating?

[@jadespidey]

Right? Its just mind boggling that they picked that blond girl for this..

[@laurenmires5741]

Yeah i don't really get it. Maybe they were hoping she would be more critical

[@tressa442121]

@@southernindigo1973 I started off thinking the same, why pick someone who doesn't like cheesecake but it was nice to see that she wasn't so easily sold and gave a more real opinion. 2 and 3 look amazing!

[@1Skorpia]

Tgats what annoys me. Fire that girl!

[@idiopathic_x]

2:40 tasty strawberry 7:22 tasty strawberry jam with tart crust 10:02 crust crust crust Oh god please dont send someone who dislike cheese to make a review of it. She fakes her reaction and that just ruined everything!

[@ChumboFumbo]

The fact that they brought a cheesecake hater on a cheesecake review tour reminds me of when they brought a vegan to a barbecue restaurant.

[@huckleberi6540]

Erin: hates cheesecake Also Erin: does a cheesecake tasting video Also Erin: eats the strawberry on top Also Erin: i hate it

[@vatsacycle]

The hosts are what "rawrXD" girls evolved into after 2010

[@MrSammydude123]

Was watching this with your comment in the back of my mind, you're spot on haha

[@SA-nt9kl]

🤣

[@RockstarEater]

4:35 They be like, "um. Sorry. Nope." 😂

[@boneetasingh8036]

Erin clearly doesn’t like cheese came.. why sign up to do this? Annoying af

[@michaelermcgowaniv]

Bonnie N they both are

[@missshorty3894]

@@michaelermcgowaniv why even bother watching it then if you don't like either of them??

[@animemichealjackson9404]

Miss Shorty why are you watching this to begin with?

[@beeplebopple6203]

Anime Michael Jackson because she wants to? She never said that she didn’t want to watch this.

[@noobify5207]

Cake*

[@theruralwanderer]

Erin just ruins this video, she's like a picky toddler. Next time bring a cheesecake-lover, like me. I'd be stuffing my face more than hosting the video. lol

[@johnwick860]

assigning Erin for this episode is like hiring someone who hates their current job but still applies for the similar job

[@SofiaCRiv]

I love Eileen’s Special Cheesecake so fluffy and yet keeps that classical flavour and also the crust is really nice

[@TheNinnyfee]

How can you choose the best NY cheesecake when 2 out of 3 are non-traditional and one tester hates cheesecake?

[@stevo4844]

“Yes what makes a real New York cheese cake is the PHILADELPHIA cream cheese” 😂

[@kuddlecat]

That’s the name of the brand tho

[@karcas9390]

Philadelphia is a brand

[@stevo4844]

Kar Cas Issa joke my man

[@aleyshakluver8575]

Especially one created in NY.....both the cream cheese and the cheesecake. Mmmm

[@melanintingz6555]

Kuddle Cat he knows it was a joke 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@Xoiqa]

When the Pakistani lady popped up my heart felt so warm since I am Pakistani. Loved this video. ❤️

[@sleepiestbrain]

It's 11am and I'm craving for some cheesecake rn... oh gawd

[@whoisant1479]

Fr Its 11 where I live to

[@zonnm]

its 2 am ;-;

[@CBrown-zu6jf]

I've only been to Eileen's but Mah-Ze-Dahr looks like a winner to me. Not too thick, not too light. And their crust looks heavenly.

[@bubbleteakiddo2979]

WHY would you bring her? SHE OBVIOUSLY DOESN'T LIKE IT DAWG

[@icantthinkofaname15]

You sound so stupid 🤦‍♀️

[@bubbleteakiddo2979]

@@icantthinkofaname15 uh...you talkin' to me?

[@icantthinkofaname15]

@@bubbleteakiddo2979 obviously

[@bubbleteakiddo2979]

@@icantthinkofaname15 k but how do i sound stupid?? I don't think the 100+ people who liked my comment think i sound stupid

[@icantthinkofaname15]

@@bubbleteakiddo2979 when you put "DAWG" sounds stupid

[@RockstarEater]

I'm waiting for the day when the hosts have an argument over which one should be the winner, and refuse to budge on their position.

[@ethankarp4309]

Watch the burger episode, New York one

[@TryingtoFood]

entire world in lockdown waiting for rations from government food insider: Cheesecake

[@MichalKos9]

Pure matrix

[@francescarobinson7702]

It was filmed in 2019

[@randomly47]

WHY WOULD ANYONE CHOOSE SOMEONE THAT HATES CHEESECAKE EVEN THOUGH THIS IS LITERALLY JUDGING CHEESECAKE .

[@biancaluta5303]

This seems to be a sad, disappointing version of "Worth it" with Steven and Andrew. It kind of annoys me that it exists 😂

[@TVG-]

People: *Starving in their houses* Food Insider: *CHEESECAKE*

[@seph1109]

Well food is the main point of their channel 🤷‍♀

[@Kanal7Indonesia]

What ?

[@TVG-]

@@seph1109 Yes

[@badnameC]

who is starving in their houses?

[@YourMajesty143]

Umm grocery stores are still open, my guy, why are y'all starving for no reason?

[@FingeringThings]

It is a mistake watching this while on a diet

[@zachary3557]

i remember your other comment from the terry jo disaster video

[@zachary3557]

hello

[@bignoonzz]

Fingering Things ✔️ or while fasting

[@veyyazel5042]

And while fasting.

[@patricksalish]

*good name*

[@eljayy91]

Yeah can Erin like not be in these videos again thank you. She’s like that friend in the group who doesn’t really contribute but she’s just there.

[@gemsparkles7977]

Omg. I thought I was the only one getting that Vibe!!!!

[@pixierainbow7]

4:40 "can you tell me how you guys make it step by step" proceeds to stare at each other... "ohhsdjgdkfjvkef" could've just said, "it's a secret"

[@nourake341]

the blond girl with the bad fake eyelashes is triggerin me so much!

[@swarnikasingh2647]

Who has bad eyelashes?

[@miheerthampi343]

im 4 minutes into the video and i hate her already

[@PopeyesisGood]

@@miheerthampi343 Hate is a strong word miheer

[@liviawong6928]

@@PopeyesisGood Well, she earned it in this situation

[@PopeyesisGood]

Livia Wong You hate her for doing her job? That’s stupid

[@foodielah535]

9:38 Her expression said it all 🤣

[@mathani]

i agree with the concept of the last one, the lemon definitely takes it to another level, when i make cheesecake at home now, i always add lemon to it.

[@FBotster]

They say the cracker detracts from the flavors of the cheese cake but puts strawberry and glaze...

[@jettgalindo]

Why the heck have someone who doesn't like cheesecake judge the best NY cheesecake??? Wasted opportunity 🤦‍♀️

[@agus1dee]

I literally LOVE cheesecake. Like it’s one of my favorite desserts.

[@Kaiser3141]

How could you not feature Junior’s. How. Dare. You.

[@getouttahere4389]

they already did like long ago

[@marneerinaldi7092]

Junior’s has gone downhill since moving closer to tourist trap central. I had it from their grand central location years ago and it was legit, the best cheesecake I’ve had EVER. I went last year and it was just... meh.

[@nataliebaas4479]

Thank you 👏👏👏 I thought the same thing!!!

[@kayg7438]

For real

[@indamix8221]

That's what I said!

[@ayaanahmad9071]

When your fasting and u need cheese cake

[@bignoonzz]

Ayaan Ahmad relatable

[@_sadgirl_8730]

samee

[@Permeation]

I’ve been going to Veniero’s ever since I was a kid and their cheesecake does not disappoint! Wish I could have some right now.

[@lucasbolt2441]

5:50 Why does Erin make such weird faces

[@addison7624]

Surprised they didn’t send someone lactose intolerant to review the ice cream lmao

[@papercutz2633]

Always loved cheesecake, but after eating eileens I have set the bar higher for cheesecakes. Every time I go in there I can easily spend $40+. Usually after I eat Robertas pizza or a chopped cheese from 110th and 1st

[@Il0vescarecrow]

Papercutz so you eat the cheesecake, then the pizza? 😂

[@YourMajesty143]

@@Il0vescarecrow - No, re-read it. They said they have dessert AFTER they've had pizza or a chopped cheese sandwich.

[@Il0vescarecrow]

YourMajesty143 lol ok

[@papercutz2633]

Yes cheesecake afterward:)

[@la.melaninqueentina]

I wanna try them but it's pricey 😩😩😩😩 just for a reg style cheese cake.

[@ballislife2351]

JUNIOR’S AND ONLY JUNIOR’S

[@Hgood1]

ballislife2351 like I can’t believe they didn’t go to Junior’s which is the standard when you go to other cities and ask but is it like a Junior’s cheesecake

[@rmknicks]

But its basic and only basic.

[@vincentvanderbilt5598]

Too sweet for my cup of tea, eileen's indeed!

[@TheTaxburden]

I was kind of shocked it didnt make the list. Not my favorite but it is hugely popular.

[@kreenabobeena]

Juniors is definitely the best!!

[@che6828]

Why are you making me crave my favorite dessert when I can’t go out and get it

[@janabroflovski2572]

I really wish I was there just to taste it, I'm a big fan of cheesecakes! 🥺

[@andrereed3761]

I was not there to try any of the cheesecake, however they all looked amazing. I am going to agree... Eileen's has to be the best! Love the videos, keep them coming.

[@ratducci7917]

I got some cheesecake in my fridge right now. Time for third dessert!

[@aurorarising1945]

Me watching this under quarantine in nyc, adding this into my list of 834858483848 places to go when shutdown is over

[@spearface8724]

Okay all these look great and all but can we just focus on how cute they are together for one second

[@lwhite1310]

Can't go wrong with those 3 places. Love Cheesecake ❤❤❤

[@heathergil1]

My favorite cheesecake in NYC is from Two Little Red Hens...haven’t had it from these other places mentioned but it’s my favorite to date.

[@mattbarnicoat]

I have never been to NYC but I was always been told Juniors is THE standard.

[@desmondmurphy9330]

Apparently one of the commenters said when it moved to a new location the quality of their cheesecake dropped dramatically.

[@mmoore5190]

@@desmondmurphy9330 the original location is in Brooklyn and has never moved.

[@desmondmurphy9330]

Mmm Kaylaa I heard that apparently when it “moved” the quality of food went down, and because I wanted to visit New York I wanted to know if it was still worth it.

[@mmoore5190]

@@desmondmurphy9330 but the original has never moved...

[@desmondmurphy9330]

Mmm Kaylaa well now I know that. Thank-you, your information on this topic has been most illuminating and helpful.

[@leannemayor5755]

Finally someone makes it without the crust. Thank you .pity I am in Sydney Australia but I may just make one this week lol

[@LilyLamll]

Thanks for sharing! 🤩 It takes gusto for businesses to learn, grow and do consistently well without leg-rooms for disappointment...

[@saroneaimah8854]

I would definitely love to try the first one. It looks so good. But the crust is my favorite part 😭 oh well I’m sure it’s still good.

[@gi11yb34n]

i know this sounds kind of weird but why is Veniero's cake so white?? is it bleached??

[@samianawaz6863]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@LeonardoAddingtonLeo]

Might have a touch of purple dye added in, helps color correct the yellow of the dairy out

[@char5285]

It claps when the plane lands

[@Il0vescarecrow]

Char lol

[@YourMajesty143]

@@char5285 - lmao 😆

[@shondrajohnson6136]

Herrine and a girl who doesn’t like cheesecake. Please do the great content of this series a favor with hosts who are more concerned with the food they eat rather than how they look eating. Video content 10/10 Hosts 3/10

[@KillerTacos54]

Love this series

[@haveagoodday7021]

Woah! Cheesecake with no brim!

[@venom5809]

When I saw the lemon I knew that was the winner for me 👍

[@rk6319]

Thanks a lot! now I'm craving cheesecake and I shall buy it tonight when I go to work.

[@alontosittiealyssaa.8866]

okayyyy this video sooooo satisfying!!!! ever!, like i never stop loving there moments with their cheesecake

[@vonnettemariadanjitalaba841]

9:37 the feeling you get after seeing boo after Quarantine 😉

[@krypticencoder]

That Maze-Dar lady owner looked like a cheese cake too..

[@mysisterisafoodie]

Kilo Juliet why she pretending she don’t like cheesecake. She be eating it, clearly.

[@mysisterisafoodie]

southerninddigo1973 lol. My grumpy ass couldn’t tell.

[@saloni22815]

Lmao

[@YourMajesty143]

So here's a cake 6:58 And there's some pastries 7:01 Here's Herrine saying "There's so many things to eat" 7:04 Here's the Bakery Chef surrounded by pastries 7:16 Here she is surrounded by 60 pastries and only 1 cheesecake 7:21 Ok now children, a raise of hands, who here thinks she ignores these pastries and only eats the cheesecake, despite saying she doesn't like it? Anybody? Anybodyyy?? Ok how about this, if she DOES eat the cheesecake, how many believe it's bc she's actually a hypocrite liar? Ok how many believe she bakes it differently so that it's palatable enough for her to even eat it? Now wait, wait, before you raise your hands, make sure you're using common sense and deductive reasoning. I mean, of course you'd use common sense -- like who just jumps to conclusions and makes stupid assumptions about people, am I right? Yeaaaa I wonder 🤔

[@samrit9494]

May be the whole point of bringing Irin in the Picture is to Make her like Cheese Cake ... At the End she did liked the Cheese cake! So now we got one more Fan.

[@laylahernandez4382]

i watch these videos to manifest me moving to new york & then eating cool food

[@huil.6823]

Hands down Eileen's! My daughter was about 10 and she told Eileen on a scale of 1-10, she would rate the cheesecakes 💯

[@user-sk8zq3fj1x]

Hey. Try watching this whilst fasting 🥺😢🤤

[@guuskeizers8457]

Then dont watch

[@mihir702]

I’d rather not fast

[@bignoonzz]

I’m fasting too and watching food or just making food for my brother and sister makes me less hungry lol

[@fatdaddybruno2443]

Thought this said “try watch whilst fisting”

[@yeexiong9304]

I ❤️❤️❤️ Eileen’s Cheesecake. Every time I’m in NYC, I have to get some.

[@luuchoo93]

I’ve been to several countries but for me New York cheesecake is THE best dessert in the world. Addictive.

[@LIVID808]

Juniors is not only my favorite cheesecake in the city but it’s the best cheesecake I’ve ever had. It’s a shame you didn’t pay them a visit.

[@sofiarashid1835]

You forgot Juniors cheesecake they have the best one in NYC

[@rmknicks]

It's super basic, just okay cheesecake.

[@TheTaxburden]

Not my fav but its popular. Was shocked it wasnt on the list.

[@rubibeats]

They stuck to manhattan bakery’s in this video it seems. Juniors is right across the bridge in Brooklyn though and its standard cheesecake. Nothing super special or gourmet about it.

[@jasonrivera8902]

Eileen’s by a super mile best cheesecake in nyc

[@ThePhyze]

Wow...that 3rd & the 2nd cheesecakes really makes me so into it, especially the last one, oh my God.

[@hypnoticz9]

I’m surprised Junior’s didn’t make it.

[@rasclotify]

That's what I just commented as well. THEE most ICONIC cheesecake spot in NYC, and you didn't go there?! That's like the gold standard.

[@davidmun1601]

I get this feeling that these people do not know much about New York City cheesecakes. It's like having a basketball GOAT debate without mentioning Michael Jordan

[@mayaeleanor4479]

We love the CHEESECAKE CRUST

[@wewe745]

Smile of your co-host makes me happy , so sweet and generous I can sense it by just looking at her, please bring her in more videos 💓💓💓💓💓

[@rajnatta9917]

The way they said sauce made my day.

[@iwastheonewhocrashedyourwi9500]

The disadvantage of being early : *_There are no good comments to laugh at_* .____.

[@janabroflovski2572]

Comeback now and you'll see

[@muzamiljavid1552]

Yesss Pakistan 🇵🇰 ♥ 😍 I'm from Pakistan and that Lady has my Massive Respect because she named her Bakery from Urdu language. And I loved that reaction of the girl on the left. *Umber Ahmed* made us Proud ❤ Thank you Food Insider.

[@autumnes.]

I love Eileen's all time favorite :D

[@Kmn01923]

Nothing I love more than cheesecake when it comes to desserts..

[@edhern619]

"do you want to split this strawberry?" Corona intensifies

[@claricedejonge]

Where do I sign up for this job😂

[@bestboy897]

Tell me if you find anything

[@janabroflovski2572]

@@bestboy897 it was a joke 🤦‍♀️

[@melsyoutube]

I can’t wait to visit New York one day