Interstellar Pitch Meeting Reaction

[@CosmicCyberYT]

#JusticeForTom. Cooper didn't even ask about his son when he was rescued at the end. And he was the only one sending messages to Cooper diligently and actively over the years. His son also wanted his dad back, especially after his own son died :(.

[@faisalmemon285]

His aptitude test showed that he would become a hick when he grew up. So I think he killed himself in some estupido way.

[@TheJerbol]

Great point!

[@havok6280]

To be fair, they wouldn’t have wasted so much time on the water planet if Brand hadn’t been so insistent on getting the data.

[@StopReadingMyNameOrElse]

Cooper's whole point after that situation, and he even says it too is Brandt and Doyle had "the survival skills of a boy scout troop". They were overeager scientists who's only thoughts were on "get data" and literally nothing else. Brandt got him killed and almost destroyed their ship by forcing Cooper to be in that situation.

[@Alvaro89Rus]

GIANT WAVE IS DATA

[@TheJerbol]

Yeah, bad writing. She knew the data was worthless anyway. I genuinely like this movie but the second half is a mess

[@tomaszpiotrowski4569]

reacting to a movie and then reacting to a pitch meeting a couple of days later is TIGHT!

[@marvinsarracino116]

Luv the pitch meeting on interstellar! The alright alright alright bit was Funny! 😂😂

[@8tonystark8]

Yes yes yes This should be mandated by law! After every reaction there should be the obligatory Pitch Meeting reaction

[@kilroy987]

NASA not reaching out to Cooper to fly, check. No good reason to land on the water planet, check. Movie hoping you'll forget the important logic after seeing the awesome visuals, check.

[@poopiecon1489]

They landed on water planet to retrieve the blackbox(which has all the information) from previous failed mission

[@landonhollis1415]

Yess!!!! Jax reacts to Pitch Meetings again!! More more more

[@sithlordkaeyl21]

Nice to see you back to reacting to Pitch Meetings again. Ryan George kills it in this video, and is always so entertaining to watch. I’ve commented this before, but I hope you keep reacting to them. Have a great rest of your day, and weekend, Jax.

[@darkwyve]

Yeah, it would actually be a cool follow-up when she watches a movie, if she did the pitch meeting afterwards (assuming there is one).

[@Timmycoo]

A LOT of people missed the "alright alright alright" joke so don't worry lol. Ryan has a lot of subtle jokes in his humor that sometimes you only get either after watching it again or thinking about it later. Love your reactions though. And I love this movie. It's one of the movies that whenever it was on TV, I'd end up watching it again lol.

[@cmac3530]

They did discuss the fact that Miller had only been on the planet for a short time. The problem was they only realized it AFTER they had landed and the wave had already took out Doyle. Brand says, with the time dilation, she probably just landed hours ago, and probably died just a few minutes ago. CASE confirms it when he tells them the status signal they had received from Miller had just been her initial status, echoing endlessly.

[@JakkFrost1]

10:06 he went "tharn", as it's called in Watership Down, or as it's more commonly referred to, "deer in the headlights". 😉

[@m_chupon5131]

I see Ryan subscribes to the Bill & Ted theory of time travel, where he needn't have bothered sending the "Stay" message even though he already did it in his past future.

[@wilgarcia1]

I think Dr. Miller ascertained the survivability the moment she saw that first wave. =P

[@joeybossolo7]

Your reactions are adorable, Jax. You’re awesome.

[@kevinwilson140]

If you can create an artificial environment on earth free of the blight, then launch them into space. Why not just do that... you know just without launching them out into space.

[@johnpittsii7524]

Hi Jax hope you are having an great and awesome day ❤

[@paulalexandredumasseauvan2357]

after your "all dogs..." reaction, i NEEDED to see something that made you laugh! this was fun watching your brain go 100 mph "...laughin' all the way! ha! ha! ha!" 👍☺

[@nelbongellor412]

Happy Jaxday

[@iamhawkeye3162]

I think NASA did reach out to him. Cooper finds the message thanks to Murph, effectively time travels, ends up in the tesseract, and sends the same message back to himself. So which came first? The message or the mission? I think in the original timeline, NASA came looking for him after he stole their drone that was seen in the beginning.

[@Uatu-the-Watcher]

Please keep up with the Pitch Meetings. They’re awesome and fun. :-)

[@ThomasAnomolus]

The data was important as they may need to seed miller's planet if the other two are also bad planets. Which the next planet was uninhabitable. So it's more about how much plan b get priority in the worst case scenario which earth is already facing!!

[@michaelstepa8748]

There's so many things to talk about in this film but I don't know if I've ever seen a discussion about the temporal paradox and how it requires these events to play out in this exact fashion for infinity. Future humans made the wormhole and put Cooper in the tesseract instead of dying in the black hole, but for them to exist Cooper had to do those things to begin with. Which further messes with the nature of time, and a whole lot else. And once elements like a paradox are part of the plot writing decisions that feel dumb and arbitrary are just that, but also exactly the sort of weirdness that would happen in such a situation. We demand stories make logical sense and omit coincidence but once you have higher-level science like this involved the absence of coincidence looks exactly like coincidence and vice-versa.

[@ZR-lj9xv]

Go watch the scene where they enter the atmosphere of Miller's planet and look off to the left side, you see Miller's ship breaking up.

[@ozcanison]

The thing that always got me, is they've had these space stations sitting next to the wormhole for 60years or so, and have those spaceships that Cooper stole, and yet they never once went through the wormhole again to look for them! Brand should have gotten to the last planet and found people already there!

[@bumblesquidsmurfgod8304]

If you enjoyed thinking about problems that could arise from travelling back and forth between areas where time passes at different rates, then you totally should watch Time Trap (2017). It is aimed at a younger audience, but I am in my 50s and I enjoyed it a lot. I shouldn't say too much about it, so I don't wreck it. But... just watch it, if you liked Interstellar, you will love it!

[@denisd3639]

You are so precious! Please keep up the excellent work!

[@LufianCloud]

saying "it was really really sad"... then smiling afterwards is scary. lol

[@kenibnanak5554]

The math required to create a temporal distortion field is daunting.

[@Sajwinder_singh]

Your reactions to pitch meetings are tight! Keep em coming!

[@Fritz0id]

Stop it

[@Sajwinder_singh]

@@Fritz0id why bub

[@coreyrobinson8209]

Miller's planet was closer to the black hole than anticipated. Romilly does some quick math and they make a plan to save time. I don't think they fully thought out what that meant for Miller until Brand says it in the lander.

[@CassandrashadowcassMorrison]

Koop Kooper is the host of the Cocktail Nation podcast

[@danielenglish235]

I didn't notice that reference 😂😂😂

[@dansgaming2064]

You should check out the theory where people think that Matthew's character was dead the whole time.

[@Lusciouslysorry]

Loved the combination of two channels I enjoy, Reacts With Jax and Pitch Meeting, and it got me wondering if it would be hard to compliment one channel with the catchphrases of the other so that it's nice but could be misinterpreted (as intended)?? Actually it would be super easy, barely an inconvenience: Reacts With Jax is tight.

[@sebswede9005]

"Each time i enter a black hole, people get older, i stay the same age".

[@pingidjit]

NASA didn't reach out to Cooper because he had attachments, family. They specified with Mann that they were sending only people who didn't have anyone they were leaving behind because it was a one way trip. In that context, its more weird that they sent Edmunds rather than them not reaching out to Cooper. Although, maybe they weren't aware that Brand and Edmunds were a couple. They might have hid it.

[@pingidjit]

Also, because it was secret NASA. If they had sent someone who left behind people, those people would be wondering and questioning what happened to their missing person. A problem for NASA wanting to remain secret.

[@faisalmemon285]

They sent Coop because he was getting all these messages like the coordinates of New NASA, etc. so they figured he’s important to the mission.

[@pingidjit]

@@faisalmemon285 They sent Coop after he found out about secret NASA. Otherwise they never would have contacted him. Also I think the dad wanted Cooper to pilot his daughter to safety. He hoped for Brand to make plan 'B' a success and needed the best pilot, who just happened to stumble through their doors.

[@faisalmemon285]

@@pingidjit Yeah, that’s what I’m saying. Coop got the secret coordinates etc.

[@rolandhdz17]

did you get to see this movie in IMAX 70mm? I just did last week and going again. words can't describe this experience 😲

[@AlexSwanson-rw7cv]

It was CASE who went down to the water planet, supposedly because TARS talked too much given the urgency at 7 Earth-years per hour.

[@chriscarpenter1920]

Jax: *gives an extensive explanation on why traveling to the water planet first is a bad idea* Screenwriter Guy: Hey shut up

[@Steve_Blackwood]

If there’s a plot hole, logical fallacy, or silly character action, Ryan will find it and ridicule it for our amusement. 😂

[@LibrarianMichael]

I agree with you on all this. Some good visuals but so many plot holes and silly stuff. The robot was pretty cool though.

[@ianp1986]

More Pitch Meeting reactions, please ❤😊

[@fsociety7494]

Rest of the twilight movie pitch meetings please.

[@danielenglish235]

5:18 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@deepermind4884]

What I didn't understand about the first mission to the "water" planet is why would anyone land in a vast amount of water? Was it a dry vast plain a few minutes before? If you landed in the middle of the Pacific Ocean, would you conclude that Earth is totally covered in water? Wouldn't you do at least one orbit of the planet & look for habitable, life sustaining areas? It made no sense to me.

[@Kasino80]

Tom gets a truck, and his sister tries to kidnap his family and destroys his livelihood.

[@reakajohanson996]

Wow, she is pretty ❤

[@iyayiezomo5796]

1:34

[@dansgaming2064]

There is a KZbin channel called How it should have ended. It's really good and I would recommend checking it out. If you do, most of their videos have post credit scenes.

[@jonasfermefors]

The thing I get most annoyed about in the plot is Cooper claiming it's humans from the future who created the tesseract & wormhole.. because there would be no humans in the future without the wormhole so that is impossible unless we are somehow talking about branching futures where the future humans try to create a better branch of time for humans? A bit convoluted perhaps? (I still love the movie)

[@ultmotive]

You're treading into paradox territory and alternate realities and that's why it doesn't make sense. It's like if you knocked a glass of water off the table and could go back in time to stop it from hitting the floor. You would be destined to fail because if you were successful the glass wouldn't have spilled on the floor and your past self never would have wanted to go back in time to try in the fist place. The whole logic of that falls apart. So you are correct, the only way out of the loop is through an alternate reality.

[@Nick-kb2jc]

I want someone to write an Interstellar prequel novel about the 12 explorers SO BADLY. It was an obsession of mine for such a long time after I saw this movie ten years ago in 2014. I even started writing a fan fiction myself at one point 🤣. But I want a professional writer to do it so bad.

[@aarond2136]

I second that motion . is Nolan available?

[@Nick-kb2jc]

@@aarond2136there are a few writers I’ve bothered on twitter about it 😅. Greg Keyes wrote the official Interstellar novelization and would be great I think.

[@QuantumS1ngularity]

About Miller's planet, a lot of people wonder why they went there first, but that shows that A LOT of people missed the conversation before them chosing the planet. The initial data gathering was done automatically by the beacons of the ships sent there. The information they had for all 3 planets was cached by a relay on the other side of the wormhole. Doyle's consideration was the rescources, including time, needed by the crew to go to the other 2 planets, the closer one of which required months to get there, the further one probably over a year to reach. And that is just one way. If their planets weren't all that perfect, like we find with Mann's planet, that meant at least another year of travel on the way back plus 2 more people. Miller's planet was the closest one, they basically spawned right next to it and despite the little data they had of it, it was still looking the best of all 3. That's why reluctantly they decided to go there. In the heat of the moment could've they forgotten that she was there only for about 90 minutes - completely possible.

[@threemarksat210]

That was great, you should do more of these. And they probably don't require a lot of editing. Have you ever watched "The Fallen of World War II"? Or "History of the entire World, I guess"? If not, lets go! Edit: Also "The Somme then and now.. 1916 - 2016"

[@clairegoulet927]

Hi @ReactsWithJax Can I recommend giving "The Fifth Element" a look?

[@Allhavengames]

you know there is something actually called Time Dilation and speed or gravitational pull would make time tick differently for me then you, we do this GPS satellites because of how high up the GPS satellites are, they are farther away with less gravitational pull so they tick faster, so we have to auto correct the time on GPS for Einsteins general theory of relativity. and yes if we could move next to or in a black hole were there much more gravity. the time on earth would move faster kind of

[@faisalmemon285]

That’s the right word to use: Autocorrect.

[@m_chupon5131]

I think the movie played a bit fast and loose with the time dilation though, being in orbit around the planet, or anywhere near the planet really, would experience the same dilation. Basically, Romilly shouldn't have aged 23 years unless he was parked **ridiculously** far away. I'm also a bit skeptical about why that planet isn't already tidally locked to the black hole, or if there's any way to have dilation that extreme and still be outside the roche limit where the planet should have been torn apart already 🤔 (Though I don't know the math on those last 2 things so maaaaaybe it checks out, just seems unlikely at first glance)

[@Allhavengames]

@@m_chupon5131 depends on planetary mass and some outer accretion disks of a black hole are so dense that it could protect a planet from radiation but tidal lock just depends on distance, size, gravity. they definitely made up their own laws of physics.

[@m_chupon5131]

@@Allhavengames With how extreme the tidal forces apparently are on the water planet, I'd think the planet would need to be **very** young to have not tidally locked already.

[@faisalmemon285]

@@m_chupon5131 Dude, this is not real life. It’s a movie.

[@poopiecon1489]

4:20 they went there to retrieve the blackbox from previous failed mission. The box that anne Hathaway character tried to grab and almost got k!lled

[@faisalmemon285]

You should release your Pitch Meeting video on Tuesday and your movie reaction on Friday. I think you’ll make more money this way, and we won’t have to wait a whole week.

[@carlchiles1047]

Every woman should hear at least once a day that she’s pretty, so here’s your once a day….you ARE pretty…and like I told you ..check out BUCK ROGERS IN THE 25th CENTURY to see Erin Grey..whose smile and eyes are just like yours…and BTW, it’s a series ..for about 3 years..everyone loved the little robot..

[@MasterNinjaTeddyBear]

If you want to play on a water planet in a game, may i suggest Subnautica? Next channel idea for you would be let’s plays. I think you would enjoy it and even understand how someone could live on an alien water planet.

[@Trigg3rFing3r123]

Hello I love your mcu reactions I have a question Have you seen any of the movies because I have always thought you’d of seen the original avengers and the older x men

[@JayBizz.]

Can you watch guardians of the galaxy volume 3 please 🙏 it’s an amazing movie

[@pedrorocha9722]

And here's part of why I never watched this movie until the end: because it's so improbable.

[@RuleNo2NoNames]

This movie was not mind blowing, it was mind bending 😊

[@faisalmemon285]

And mind boring.

[@ThomasAnomolus]

I don't think Murphy ever new that her father was talking to her from the dimension just that he had found a way to communicate. Which she only figured out because she wanted the watch for sentimental reasons only to notice binary ticking which in her room where he and her father decoded a binary message so it's more a genius connecting the dots

[@havok6280]

How do you like dem apples, Matt Damon?

[@HouseofHobo]

I love Interstellar, but Doyle's death always felt silly visually. He is swept away by the wave laterally. Left to right. Then the next shot, the ship is hit by the wave rising vertically.

[@faisalmemon285]

Nolan does not believe in science but makes people think he does. He’s like a Jar Jar Abrams who has no idea what Star Wars is about.

[@zamhobby9662]

Please do more Pitch Meeting....

[@homelander9795]

Watch daredevil ....it's a must

[@ThomasAnomolus]

It wasn't about how much time she had to study the planet!!! They choose her planet because it had liquid water!!!! Something exceedingly rare in the universe!!!!

[@Nloveru]

Point stands that they should have realized she had only been on the planet for just over an hour and thus would not have collected any further data.

[@farhan-momin]

Now please react to dune

[@faisalmemon285]

React to Aliens.

[@benvandermerwe4934]

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🥂🚀🇿🇦

[@Audulf-of-Frisia]

I found that movie so bad that I still don't get why people think it's great. All the flaws mentioned I noticed while watching it. Which is uncommon for me though 😁

[@MeneGR]

Wow wow wow wow wow.

[@diobrando8890]

React to An American Tail!!

[@faisalmemon285]

Jax, how would you feel if your dad was watching you from behind a bookcase?

[@ultmotive]

I think the water planet's purpose was to introduce to the viewers the concept of gravitational time dilation and to raise the stakes of their mission because it's such a complex thing for people to wrap their heads around. We all live and die on the same planet and have never had to think or even fathom that time does not flow the same everywhere in the universe.

[@stiimuli]

You're oddly specific!

[@Shhtick]

dune next?

[@tfpp1]

Jax, if you ever want to have a second career, you could totally do soft-spoken ASMR and be fabulous at it. Just saying. 🤞🏼☺️

[@Kasino80]

I love Nolan movies when they're good, but this one just annoys the hell out of me, because nothing in it makes sense when you think about it too much.

[@spazbog123]

Yeah but if they didn't go to the water planet first most of the movie doesn't take place. It is probably (except for the 5th dimension stuff) the most unrealistic part of the movie - they know about relativity and they know its the worst planet of the 3 for wasting time back on Earth but they start there anyway.

[@jbwade5676]

😢😢😢

[@dandychiggins7240]

Well done, yoga lady, I love people reacting to pitch meetings, I would not recommend watching pitchs of movies you like tho 👍

[@carlchiles1047]

TARS stayed up..while CASE went down to the water planet because TARS talked too much and time was precious…

[@Mr59Kenzo]

NASA would have sent a probe first

[@kernowarty]

I don't remember any giant waves in Interstellar. I shall have to watch it again

[@faisalmemon285]

That literally was the only good scene in the movie.

[@kernowarty]

@@faisalmemon285 I must have been asleep

[@SummitSummit]

He kept pronouncing Barn's name wrong.

[@TheJerbol]

Pitch Meetings _RUIN_ movies for me and I couldn't be happier about it to be honest

[@jbwade5676]

Talk To me 😢

[@DevlinDomini]

Big, gaping plot-holes are tight!

[@TheJerbol]

It's a genuinely great movie with genuinely bad writing

[@geneparadiso6258]

Hey Jax! Tell us a little about yourself. You don’t have to be specific. Are you married, do you have kids? Do you work?

[@lookatthisjamoke]

whats great about Interstellar and this pitch meeting is that Ryan barely has many flaws to point out. Some of the things he says are just things that happen in the movie, no joke or punchline. Thats just how GOOD Interstellar is.

[@rantman4521]

Finally saw a "pitch meeting"......not really feelin it. Maybe it's just me. Is it always this guy talking the same way? Just askin.

[@jewelrana9910]

Why no mcu upload?

[@Audulf-of-Frisia]

I must be missing something but I found Interstellar a really bad movie. It made no sense to me.

[@joegreene7619]

I know a lot of people like it, but I just feel like Interstellar is a mediocre movie with a horrible ending.

[@otanarevalo]

ok sir

[@faisalmemon285]

Interstellar is just plain dumb. One hour on water planet will never equal to 7 years in space, no matter how much time dilates.

[@brandonhill2183]

​@@faisalmemon285go tell that to Kip Thorne

[@faisalmemon285]

@@brandonhill2183 He’s a THEORETICAL physicist. There’s no use in arguing with him. He’ll just mix fact with theory hoping to confuse you to win the argument.

[@brandonhill2183]

@faisalmemon285 so you know more about physics than Kip Thorne.....ok bud. Whatever you say