Interview | Gyanvapi Row: Temples, Mosques Have Buddhist Stones Too': Historian Irfan Habib

Commenting on a string of controversies such as Varanasi's #GyanvapiMosque and Mathura's Krishna Janmabhoomi-#ShahiIdgah, eminent historian Professor #IrfanHabib said that whenever a mosque or temple was built in the olden times, the stones of Buddhist viharas were also found.
Video: The Quint
Music: BMG

[@rp19488]

Tum saala agar historian ho toh mere ghar ka mistri bhi civil engineer hai..😂😂

[@pranjalol1287]

Best comment! Jai Shri Ram❤

[@rp19488]

@@pranjalol1287 jai shree ram

[@BengaliManfromWB]

Leftist Muslims atleast don't become terrorists. They are never hardcore Muslims. They are anti Hindu but not one of those who study in madrassahs.

[@gravity.inescapable]

😂❤

[@pbkvijaykulkarni6404]

😂😂

[@NagappanSivanandam]

As a Muslim you can't think beyond your book

[@Pikkinmink7]

Not true at all, we go whoever the truth takes u

[@RijanKhanal-jh6t]

​@@Pikkinmink7let's be honest as a minority Muslim never proved themselves good for India. Compare to Muslim see the contribution of micro minority community of Jain's Parsis Sikhs Christian as well. Many can hate until and unless the Muslim Don't ride in growing India mission of startup they will be always questioned. We expect muslim community to produce world class economist scientist businessman and ceos. But I guess expecting it is impossible

[@_Moraceae]

​@@Pikkinmink7 the truth is A true muslim should consider Jesus, Ram, Shiv, Vishnu all other God's as God's. As Quran says god's words can't be corrupted. And Bible say it God's came down to save people, Gita Says Krishna is God, Vedas says All are Avatar of Supreme Brahman (God), Both prophet and God is true. Also according to quran who ever follow God is a muslim and Hindes were following Gods from way before the Qur'an came. Now this what I understand everyone has own versions of thoughts. Most muslim says Allah doesn't have a form or nothingness but Allah said he have a form, Hadith says he have a Shin, Hands, Face etc.

[@ansaaralimohammed7060]

In my book the entire world exists. Don't read it as religious book but read it as just book you will understand.

[@Pikkinmink7]

@RijanKhanal-jh6t that's not true, look at AP abdul kalam just to give u ONE example

[@RajeshMishra_1974]

*He is Historian second but a Muslim first*

[@SDFNI3894YR]

yes.

[@ilyasMugal-fp4iw]

बनारस से है कोई

[@Krushna_13]

lol he is an atheist

[@SumitSky608]

When it comes to good muslim There r always 1st teacher,1st scientist then 2nd or nothing like Khan Sir,APJ Abdul kalam But when it goes against your approach then 2nd anything first Muslim WHAT A HYPOCRITE WE R We should think like students rather than biasedy fall in trap.

[@ilyasMugal-fp4iw]

@@SumitSky608 कहां से हो.

[@shadestorm3995]

I urge people to watch K.K Muhammad's interview on Habib he is just a historian wo has lied before

[@f5rwall]

He is a historian, what is his role in deciding which stones are used? Thats for the archeological survey. His job is to use the reports

[@IndiHeads-mn4kq]

His job is nothing more then shutting the fuck up

[@nand3576]

How can u call this zaleel haivaan Historian. He can not read farsi and arabic not even aleef bay😢

[@rdutt945]

Any source of your comment!​@@nand3576

[@Critic224]

Are you a historian ? You are not even that! Then how can you question him ?

[@f5rwall]

@@Critic224 when a doctor cant dispute a pathology report how can a historian dispute archeological findings?? He will have to take what ia found and make his case. He cant refute it, like a doctor with a pathology report

[@supersuper3493]

Muslims will fight for islam, But we hindus have to fight for secularism, we should, we will. But not for this appeasing secularism, but true secularism.

[@usamashraf1866]

What..... You fight for true secularisum............ 😁😁😁😁😁

[@ishaanrohmetra3447]

@@usamashraf1866 atleat more than islamic people and republics whose allah is so insecure that they dont allow other faiths to exist and tried to convert more and mmore.

[@Aditya-zq7cs]

Nope we Hindus will fight for hindutva

[@usamashraf1866]

@@Aditya-zq7cs kkk you fight for hinduta..... 🗡️🗡️🗡️🗡️🗡️🗡️🗡️🍖🍖🍖🍖🍖🍖🍖🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐂🐃🐃🐂💩🐂🐃🐂🐃💩🐂🐃🐃🐃🐃🐂🐃🐂💩🐂💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩

[@supersuper3493]

@@usamashraf1866 yes true secularism, in which one will not be given rights to have multiple wives just because his prophet had dozen wives and some sex slaves.

[@vinay6552]

India ideally needs more and More Dr. APJ Abdul Kalams, but in reality we get more and more Irfan Habib's, Owaisi's, faruq Abdulla, mahbooba mufts...

[@rabarimehul8608]

​@@anonynousanon5008 🤣🤣🤣🤣 listen kk mohammed on irfan habib dictatorial mindset He had recently interview on Lallantop youtube channel

[@anonynousanon5008]

@@rabarimehul8608 Oh any one takes side to your chindu hatred it becomes word of God 😂😂😂 Logic of insecure virat chindu lolu

[@Goofyderclown]

@@anonynousanon5008 and the words of anyone who opposes Hindu becomes "based on facts" 😂 😂 Hypocrisy ki limit hoti hai bhai!

[@Lmaothesehindutvafolksdumbasf]

@@rabarimehul8608how tf is it a dictatorial mindset?? Are you mentally challenged? Habib is outlining the government’s blatantly hindu nationalist agenda in destroying monuments that were built ages ago just because they don’t adhere to the Hindu majority narrative.

[@rohitbhushan8855]

​@@anonynousanon5008 The guy is an archeologist who went through the evidences first hand unlike this politically motivated "historian" who had no expertise in the field of archeology and yet, somehow, thought that he was qualified enough to make a statement on the archeological findings of the sight. You're the one who's looking to blindly adore the person who's speaking what you want to hear.

[@ysmalik8690]

Habib Sb Agar 9000 BC may banay mandir ko todkar uspe 1670 may Masjid bna di gyi toh 2022 may Masjid todkar mandir bhi taamir kiya ja sakta hy.

[@payelbrahma2008]

Right.

[@lioness1249]

Keep changing for gerations to come, like illeterates, don't live in peace and just think of making pieces.....Animals r better than u guys.

[@ysmalik8690]

@@lioness1249 Forceful convertees of barbaric invaders now justifying their animal acts 🤨. Everything that was done to destroy our heritage, culture and civilization will be reversed. Jai Sri Ram 🚩

[@oalu]

​@@lioness1249 Are😂😂 bkc wo acha bol rha hai😂 hame. Sabko gali mat dena😅

[@v-rex3206]

​@@lioness1249peaceful community saying about peace

[@tarapadasarkar3108]

He just compared writing Allah at the top of Kumbh Pilar and a mosque built on the site of the demolished Hindu temple. The logic is Kumbh Pilar can not be a mosque and Gyanbapi mosque can not be a temple. Who are these people?

[@maycodes]

But the history will always remember professor lal who first discovered the temple remains ❤

[@ashoks5317]

That's why we say Jinnaha was a brilliant PM of Pakistan and Nehru a Joker who never paid any attention to the advice of Dr.Ambedkar.

[@bmniac]

Both were disasters. jinnah was worse than Nehru

[@ashoks5317]

@@bmniac Atleast Jinnah got what he wanted and became great leader in the eyes of Muslims unlike Nehru who became PM by arm twisting M.K.Gandhi

[@snehadipbhunia5881]

This is the man who cooked Indian history 😀, what a delicious dish he made! But that dish will gonna be rotten with time where fresh uncooked history will come out.

[@abhijeetkushwaha424]

'cooked indian history', and how many published researches have you got on indian history?

[@Goofyderclown]

@@abhijeetkushwaha424 not everyone wanna pursue "arts" lmao. And, just to get it isnide your small brain, public researches doesn't make a person successful. Many researchers have publihed gender study papers, doesn't make them a scholar!

[@manishgowda3640]

​@@Goofyderclownwtf are you talking? You high on something

[@pritikajoyti2290]

Why is the media giving time to these people who tried to change the story of India's history. The media personals should be better educated and this men's opinion doesn't matter .

[@chandrashekarh.m.3576]

​@@abhijeetkushwaha424oh ..u still don't know about Mr.K K Muhammed who is also AMU alumnus who exposed these Marxist historians for their twisted history ..?

[@devanshsharma3966]

Most biased historian on the face of the earth..

[@SadiqueKhan449]

Tabhi Oxford wale usko bula rahe thay

[@saterdraj6768]

Why? Because you don't agree with him?

[@humanity580]

​@@saterdraj6768 no bcoz he is tremendously humiliated in case of ram mandir in supreme court for his and his team's research which is also inscribed in his own written book😂😂😂😂

[@harris2057]

@@SadiqueKhan449atleast he has accepted the fact that temple was demolished

[@vivek-420]

@@SadiqueKhan449 Oxford hee jagah hai jaha se wo aae thhe, Macaulay putra

[@manoharchandrashekar2085]

This guy cook secular history 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@raahinyapratapsingh1629]

He didn't cook a secular story He just supported the agenda of jihadi and the hinduphobes who destroyed the Hindu temples

[@TheKakarot_itachi]

Do you even know what secular history means?

[@lemonade93678]

Secular history (school level history) where all the atrocities done by the muslim invaders are hidden and dedicate whole chapter on almost each of their kings to overglorify them and all the credibilities of important hindu and sikh dynasties like ahoms, marathas and singhs are not discussed or discussed in minimum. ​@@TheKakarot_itachi

[@nand3576]

Look at this man the way he smiles very sarcastic which is the result of his upbringing reading Hadees. It is an eye sore to shraddhaalu visiting Kaashi. Thi eye sore should go-away either peacefully or Baabri way!

[@bindasguy3666]

video title is wrong, when irfan habib talk about buddhist stones?

[@sanjair-music4372]

So the ancient monument act is valid to the one that was build in 1670 and not the older and previous one, so what kind of historian is he?

[@lalaland122]

" He said Kya okhadna hai okhadle"in very educated manner.

[@aashishsharma9106]

Ukhadenge. Ayodhya mai Ramdarshan karneke baad, Kashi aur Mathura keliye ladenge

[@rohitbhushan8855]

His credibility is all lost..

[@12allrounder]

Not siding with both sides of the argument, rebuilding a temple or promoting a mosque, what do Muslims think of praying in a mosque that stands above a temple, and a Nandi gazing in front, overlooking the fact millions of Hindu's sentimental value, isn't this an act of shirk? comment below (keep it civilised).

[@vivek-420]

I think it is part of their religion. It is religiously sanctioned to them to hate the non-Muslim. I am saying after reading the Quran. It is a violent text and hateful of polytheists and idol worshippers.

[@hotfun07]

Let the Buddhists Claim Temple and Mosque Lands. I'm all for it. Indians must know the Historical Identity of every religious place.

[@amols8836]

Abhi jo buddha gaya ka vihar hai vo bhi puri tarah se Buddhist ko nahi diya hai... Baki ki jagha ka claim kar k koan sunega

[@hotfun07]

@@amols8836 Halla Bol. Pata chalna chahiye kaun kitna kroor tha itihaas mein.

[@logicalthinker483]

In tha case most of the temples especially in the madhya Hindustan would be Buddhist monastries since India was once a Buddhist majority country before being forcefully converting the masses to hinduism

[@avibcci1297]

I hope they do. Hindus will be very happy if dharmic religion again enrich this sacred place of Bharat, but they should have proof like the darbari of the guy who created qutum minar written clearly, how his great king vandalised 27 temples of bunch of God and godess to mark a this huge pillar.

[@hotfun07]

@@logicalthinker483 Ambedkarite are you? Shudras existed amongst Buddhists too. All the best with your quest.

[@mitrar123]

He is right , Hindus must fight for their rights. 💪💪

[@suvo5041]

Chacha rest le lo! Rest in peace ho ne ka time a gya hai

[@shrazi516]

very sick minded ur..will u tell the same to ur old parents too or one shud say the same to you when u get old

[@vinayedke614]

Aurangjeb destroyed many pilgrimage across the country. It's our duty to rebuild them again 🚩🔱💫🙏

[@payelbrahma2008]

Right you are.Beware of MACU SECUs like Irfan Habibs and its sponsor Quint.

[@saterdraj6768]

If he did, why were the rajput hindu kings his servants?

[@broadcastwithatg5195]

​@@saterdraj6768 Aurangzeb ko bhaga dete lekin phir Aurangzeb turkey sae army leker aa jata jaise humayun persia sae laaya tha babar bhi Persian Empire sae hi army leker india aaya tha

[@swamiganesh2875]

@@saterdraj6768 Typical Hidu-phobic apologist for Aurangazeb. Must be a rice bag convert!

[@TheKakarot_itachi]

And Hindus destroyed Buddhism. Time to revive Buddhism.

[@akcj875]

Very nice to have muslims accept hold shivling as sacred...soon indian muslims will become idol worshippers.... Its only a matter of time that that every mosque will get idols

[@bmniac]

Bitter rubbish. But Islam will die in most parts of the world.

[@ustinov10]

Hagia sophia main kya hua? Turkey ne kya kiya church ko?

[@SattickDas2001]

What must be done is to disallow worship at such controversial places and put them up for display to the general public , so everyone becomes aware of whatever sort of religious atrocities have been commited over time, so such things are never allowed to happen again. Also, scientific exploration and research must not be impeded for political reasons.

[@chanukyanuthalapati6553]

Taj Mahal is a tourist site yet they used to allow Friday prayer without any tickets for muslims. What you say may be right despite that people won't allow that be it Hindus or be it muslims.

[@mangopudding5979]

Why should worship be not allowed ik such places when in reality it's a Hindu temple, are you an anti Hindu?

[@mangopudding5979]

@@anonynousanon5008 only people in power discriminated against others. Are you anti So called upper caste?

[@hamdensore929]

@@anonynousanon5008 pynctureputra try everything 3600+ more bullah house would be demolished 🤣🤣🇵🇰🤮porkistani🇵🇰 🐷🤮🤮

[@anonynousanon5008]

@@hamdensore929 Lol gau mutra drunk virat chindu found my religion by reading some gupt veda written by himself 😂😂😂.

[@Subhashish69]

Why did he ignore / suppress the findings of Prof. BB Lal's Ayodhya findings in 1976-77?

[@madhusudhan-yw9xg]

He is not a historian

[@aryanpandit4750]

धर्म का नशा उतरते ही श्रीलंका की जनता को एहसास हुआ की वे बर्बाद हो चुके हैं 😊😊😊 अगला नंबर तुम्हारा है अंडभक्तों 😁

[@alibilal1863]

I'm happy to see there are still people who are strong enough to deflect the political propaganda of dividing our attention from main issues like employment healthcare and education.

[@5minutecalms]

Exactly my thoughts

[@sumimase2762]

Sadly only on comment section

[@supersuper3493]

Humare sath aapka bhi number aayega pandit ji😂

[@IM_Nothing00]

Are pandu hamare sath tera bhi ayega number😘😘 dont worey

[@punarbasunath7730]

We love bhuddha 🤣so it part of dharma

[@debaduttasahoo5001]

Parshwa Devi Devta har Hindu Sanatani Mandir mein hote hain, isliye Shiv Mandir mein bhi Ganesh Ji, Maa Shakti (Durga/Parvati) aur Hanuman ji bhi milenge. Andhe ko rasta dikhaya ja sakta hai par andhe hone ki naatak karne wale ko rasta kaise dikhayein... Aise hi insaan hain yeh Irfan Habib sahab. Dr. K.K. Muhammed ne inki AMU mein swabhaav ke baare bahut ache se vivaran diya hai Lallantop interview mein.

[@abhishekdivecha3435]

Okay but it is clear that he agrees to the fact that Mathura is Lord Krishna's janmabhoomi, he agreed to that fact

[@vip129870]

Does anyone ask him for attribution and evidence to prove what he says??

[@NishitShukla]

Rana Kumbha ke minar par agar All likha hua hai to wo unke baad kisi muslim shasak ne kiya hoga, usko hatao wahan se.

[@TheSahil1498]

Historian or Distorian??

[@nishupandey3430]

WHEN HISTORIAN WANTED TO BECOME ARCHEOLOGIST

[@thedarthlord7724]

Even if we remove all the Muslims from India people are still gonna fight on the basis of caste. Imagine if we are able to remove all the minorities, people will still find a way to fight based on race, color and height. People are gonna find a way to segregate each other based on looks and beliefs. There is no end to this unless we try to understand each other and coexist together regardless of anything. And I think social media and technology is to blame here we are becoming more segregated because of it.

[@thedarthlord7724]

@UC1Pck6q_jd0zbG2Nl1OPfMA hmmmm.... your opinions are very cerebral , intellectual and thoughtful.

[@supersuper3493]

Both can not live together on their own, we need pure secularism and a robust law order system.

[@supersuper3493]

And we don't have problem with any other minorities except islam and missionaries.

[@usamashraf1866]

Yes....you are correct.....

[@israshalim9111]

@@supersuper3493 By 'we' you mentioned means hinduvta.Good educated hindus have no problems with islam,same goes for good educated Muslims

[@CrazzzyGhost]

Chori kiya manta hu , lekin wapis nahi denge !

[@hulkman4351]

Kishi Majid me koi murti dekhi hai khabhi......temple me ho sakta hai....Allah .....par murti Majid me nahi ho sakti ......

[@rahulrajhans3121]

Buddism never claimed such sites and they aren't in a majority. Simple

[@amols8836]

Claim kar k bhi kya milne wala hai... Yaha to Buddhist statue ko bhagwa rang aur kapda laga kar devi devta ban diya hai... Kahi par teliyabhadar keha k pujte hai kahi eakvira devi... Vo to chaodo aaj tak bihar ka buddha gaya ka buddha vihar bhi Buddhist ko nahi diya hai... Hai kya koai sune wala

[@sm4063]

@@amols8836 it's a copy of jainism. It's not even original.hsm is superior to any faith or cult

[@Diecastlover777]

​@@amols8836Absolutely right😢

[@arenmishra]

​@@amols8836Baudh Gaya mein Bhagwan Buddha ki hi Puja hoti hai.

[@hiteshgoswami1429]

Wah what a damn logic these guys have.. you can destroy temple (of course u r not sure it was Hindu gods temple), then u have the audacity to ask a question stupidly that can u destroy thing done in 1670!!! It was before 1670 is not even in equation of these so called literate people

[@sharmaji6835]

Adha such to kubula par pure ke waqt khel gaye sir ji😄

[@sarcasm_underestimated7020]

Hey mate, do you know difference between historian and archeologist!!

[@tuxnoel]

But those mosques at Kashi and Mathura built by Aurangzeb can be shifted for relocation without any speck of damage .

[@yashrawat1856]

Jali jali jali jali😁😁

[@unsung.2770]

Chacha Rest lelo Bohot Gyan pele ho hume ithne din... Abh hum sunayenge tum Intellectual Marxist ko

[@sakshamchauhan2502]

Rise, Reclaim, Reconquer.

[@shaikziyad9866]

world renowned historian has commented on the issue, and we have people who do not know the H of history countering him

[@Gauravkumar-om9oy]

What he said, clearly stated aurangzeb destroyed mandir in Kashi and mathura. It's written even in aurangzeb biography written by shaqi Persian writer

[@varshavora9935]

Even though he may be a renowned historian... He is not more powerful that judicial system of india... We follow the court

[@sumimase2762]

@@varshavora9935 but the investigators appointed from SC come to historians for reference

[@5minutecalms]

@@Gauravkumar-om9oy that everyone knows. But that doesn't mean we take revenge on today's Muslims for what one king did in middle ages. India was formed around 1947, we can't just go around taking over other's land based on historical events using our modern religious identity.

[@Gauravkumar-om9oy]

@@5minutecalms so replacing one mosque with temple means revenge from muslims, how comes that, is any govt schemes denied to them, is any benefit denied,is voting right denied,is fundamental rights denied. How could u say it's revenge. Revenge would be to ask them jaziya tax, which Hindus used to give. Temples which are talked about are not any random temples, these have been mentioned in Vedas, somewhere 1000 to 2000 BC, very much important to Hindus Kashi one is one of 12 jyotirling, mathura is birthplace of lord Krishna. Hoe do u expect Hindus to not be able to worship there.

[@mehmano9045]

Atleast he admits these were demolished

[@badarpurschool9618]

Most polarizing figure

[@karthikvskp]

I know the quint wil come up with such videos aftr the ayodhya and gnavapi asi survery...... If govt has to demolish somethng built in 1600 .... it will to provide justice..... all that is asked by hindus is to leave the mathura, ayodhya, kasi temples as those are the birth places of krishna, ram and kasi where siva lived.... its utmost important places for hindus... hindus dnt hav any othr place to go.... expect india.... but for the peaceful community the worlds 2nd most followed religion they hav many countries ..... so plz support hindus

[@srinivasulumekala8308]

Well, you are one hell of a MC.

[@Naruto-kc8vz]

I all the major pilgrimage sites related to life of Buddha are still intact in India and Buddhists can go to visit it, but the same is not true for gyancapi.

[@Abdullah-mn6sw]

Since when did Gyanwapi become a pilgrimage site. Can visit their site, huh, I wonder why did they leave? Yeah right, driven off by Indians because of their religion.

[@logicalthinker483]

Lier. Almost all the ancient temples in madhya Hindustan were Buddhist monasteries before forcefully converting the people into hinduism

[@Abdullah-mn6sw]

@@logicalthinker483 Almost all? Link to that?

[@Naruto-kc8vz]

@@logicalthinker483 Change your name to Madarsa thinker.

[@logicalthinker483]

@@Abdullah-mn6sw u can ask them for re survey.

[@VikramShetty1502]

Can’t speak a word of Sanskrit or Farsi, so which history was he studying ?

[@KrypticKruiser]

He's right! There was buddhist monastery

[@ss6966]

Heard that Mr. Adani has bought 49% stakes in your channel. I think I may unsubscribe from your channel soon. Not that I have anything against Mr. Adani, but I am against the idea of corporatisation of news media. You all people do this for money. But, this is your weakness. You bow down infront of money. You are weak people.

[@5minutecalms]

Ambani owns BJP shares

[@IndianSumaira]

Seriously??? They sold this channel???

[@SattickDas2001]

Hinduism and Buddhism both arose in India and is more or less indigenous to this land. The Buddha himself was born as hindu.

[@Dani-lk3ed]

Budhha was ex-hindu ...he left this casteist religion and made his own philosophy...so he was ex-hindu...

[@payelbrahma2008]

@@Dani-lk3ed Have some brain to understand that in our Constitution HINDUISM INCLUDES BUDHISM,JAINISM,SIKHISM.

[@payelbrahma2008]

Right.

[@avibcci1297]

@@Dani-lk3ed he was a ksatriya too. Now caste is not exclusive to Hinduism. You will find dalit buddist, sikh, Christian and muslims too cause it's a social identity not a religion one. Despite converting from Hinduism you will still carry the social identity.

[@ilyasMugal-fp4iw]

बनारस से है कोई

[@rahulistwal4735]

See the entire Europeans & Americans who’ve lectured us in remaining secular but what they truly endorse & support is appeasement politics . They themselves have wiped native Red Indians as well as demolished Muslim mosques and structures in entire Europe once they regained power .Bigger question is if a historian establishes that the temple structure was demolished irrespective of when in the past , should that not be the will of the larger community to accept of the past wrong & give way to reconstruction on the original structure.

[@darshshinde]

Irfan Habibs are 'Eminent Historians' , and Meenakshi Jains are to be ignored inspite of all the evidence!

[@Mo-vb7hy]

People are dying with inflation and poverty, but that’s not important! Fighting over religion is…Where is humanity after all?

[@AbhinayJain90]

why don't you ask your majjids to use your zakat funds towards welfare of non-muslims, then? no? so then we know who your humanity is for, don't we?

[@ericarora8268]

That's what the government want

[@chanukyanuthalapati6553]

Don't get me wrong but I believe proper conclusion to this stupidity is really important for unity and integrity of our country. It's high time we get our shit in order be it temple or no temple. Solving inflation and poverty is not an exclusive option. Things can happen in parallel.

[@Mo-vb7hy]

@@chanukyanuthalapati6553 I understand your point. But this is just one of the many religious issues that will keep rearing its ugly head as long as the country exists. Development is happening great! But it should reach the ones who are really downtrodden na. This country can handle only 1 issue at a time, and in all this, the common man suffers. 😊 Honestly right now what I sense is the policy of divide and rule. I guess all politics works like this, but it is only these past few years that I see the religious rift widening. 🥹

[@avibcci1297]

People were always dying. Poverty in india in 10 years has decreased from 22.5 to 12.5 %. I don't think the present government was busy making toilets and roads if 4 decades of socialism has given some good inputs

[@suneetagawde7593]

Smart sir Nandi is normally found in shiva temples And yes,govt can demolish something built in 1640 as it wes built by indias enemies

[@swagatochatterjee7104]

Ok, so when are we demolishing RSS headquarters in Nagpur? Savarkar was ratting out INA suporters and volunteers while the INA was fighting the British.

[@vr6402]

@@swagatochatterjee7104 👌👍👍👍👍✊️

[@spartan187]

We have a constitutional law act of worship which prohibits demolition of any religious worship place Bcoz of dispute , only ayoda was excluded because despite started before independence . No wonder for vote they can change law as well

[@5minutecalms]

India's enemies?? They themselves were Indians lol. Just like the many Brahmins who oppr3ssed lower castes and the many Hindu kings who k1lled Jains and Buddhists. Savarkar and RSS should be indefinitely b@nned. Savarkar literally praised Hitler and his treatment of J3ws, and then went to lick british boots

[@supersuper3493]

@@spartan187 we can remove that act again

[@123lenu]

Time is over for Irfan habib and romila thapar!! RAM has come to his origin where they stopped and opposed with balant, concoted lies. Now they are feared in the last leg of their life thier lies exposed and giving monument act as a clarification!!!

[@ajitkhanna4669]

Irfan ,is it permissible to offer namaz in a mosque over a temple?

[@Anonymous-tm7jp]

Mulla spotted, opinion rejected. As simple as that. Kashi, Mathura sab humara hi hai, hum jo chahe woh kare😁

[@anarchy_373]

Tabhi toh Anonymous ho be, naam bataane wali harkate hee hai tumhari 😂😂😂

[@Mozambique2407]

​@@anarchy_373 tere name se kya pta chlta librandu ya muslim?

[@supersuper3493]

1:30 allah ki carving hatana chahiye, kyuki allah ko dusre bhagwano ke sath nhi rakh skate, allah gussa ho jayega nhi toh

[@Syedshohaib]

Yes

[@supersuper3493]

@MARCOS 🇮🇳 usne haan toh bola, fir har baat pr kya dikkat hai tujhe. Vaise bhi aisa bolne se koi fark pada nhi uske man me

[@supersuper3493]

@Atheist 😂😂humari hypocrisy ki koi seema nhi hoti😂

[@supersuper3493]

@Atheist pura bharat pela gaya tha, tu bhi bhartiya hi hai dulle

[@supersuper3493]

@Atheist tu atheist hain na, atheist ko Bharat mein hi rakhna padega. Atheist ko paxtan bhej diya to gand maar ke vapas bhaga denge

[@WBSchoolOfMaths]

Everything clear from the image of the structure

[@kim-nw7cg]

Ok, what are those buddhist stones

[@kk-vx5ty]

Haha, talking of Buddhists, Whole of Buddhism and buddhsit philosophy has hinduism. Aur baudho ko kaise pareshan kiya videshoyo ne vo sab jante hai.

[@Sage.ji.]

Hinduism is shit

[@MM-ue4ol]

You need serious study, leave the serious study rather basic studies of history of religion. buddhism is all Hinduism ! WhatsApp ?

[@ajk4400]

Haha. Hinduism didn't exist as an organised religion when Buddha was born. If Hindu philosophy is in Buddhism, why did they both fight?

[@ajk4400]

@MARCOS 🇮🇳 Buddhists and Hindus fought for patronage. Look at bhakti tradition and how Buddhist amd Jaina institutions were destroyed by Hindu Kings. Buddha opposed the Hindu philosophy of Brahmana varna and said Brahmana is the one who attains knowledge. Hindus were into killing cattle but Buddhism preached non-violence. You don't have an understanding of history.

[@ajk4400]

@MARCOS 🇮🇳 You seem not to understand and tenets of religions. Buddhism is non-thestic philosophy. It rejects God. It even rejects Brahma and Atman for the simple reason that according to Buddhism everything changes-the principle of anicca.

[@IndianSumaira]

So true, I second with Irfan Sir, yeh government bewaqufi ki baate Kar rahi hai just to keep people distracted from main issues. Divide and rule bas

[@chanukyanuthalapati6553]

It's not the government. Every gov does this shit in one way or the other. Having a weak opposition and click bait media is to be blamed.

[@manoharchandrashekar2085]

@Atheist don't cook secular history we fed up with ok

[@subhaloyola25]

Thik hai mandir Hume sop do uske baad employment, inflation pr baat krte hai. Agar itni hi buddhi hai tumhari kaum ko toh tumhe mandir sopne me prblm nhi honi chahiye.

[@ashwinidesai4051]

@Atheist Kitna bada wala bigot hai tu. Chee!! Neech insaan.

[@mangopudding5979]

Irfan is wrong. Government is not dividing anyone.

[@satyanarayandas1984]

Akhir at last girghit ne apna rang dikhaya 😂😂😂😂

[@loveislove9211]

Its rare to find a one single unbiased muslim man on planet .

[@theeagle4877]

See this difference between hindu and muslim ...A Muslim historian did not lie about the past aurangzeb demolition of temple..But he mention there is a temple where Allah is carved in one of the pillar ...does it become mosque by any mean...

[@supersuper3493]

Ohhhhh so muslim are more benevolent and plural. Thats why muslim majority pakista is secular and hindu majority Bharat is a hindu Rashtra. 💯💯💯

[@theeagle4877]

@@supersuper3493 Even Hindus,Sikh Christain they all live pakistan ....And for your kind information jitna hinduo ka nahi hai ye mulk usse zyada musalmano ka hai...Bohot khoon bhaya hai musalmano ne apne watan ke liye....Aj bhi khoon bha rahe hain Musalman..Ye mulk kisi ke baap ka nahi hai ....Kal Musalman tha,Aaj hai aur kal Insha Allah rahega...

[@theeagle4877]

@@supersuper3493 It is hindu rashtra ...Hindu is a geographical defination of people living in Hindustan...

[@supersuper3493]

@@theeagle4877 so you're a hindu? Say bharat mata ki jay Vande mataram

[@supersuper3493]

@@theeagle4877 and see how much hindus has been decreased from paxtan, just search hindu population of paxtan in 1951 and population now, you will get it. And you're muslim, so maybe you will not see anything bad about paxtan killing minority.

[@payelbrahma2008]

Quint is a Congressi Channel hence MACU SECU Irfan Habib is getting undue importance here.

[@a.k4394]

Just sold his book to kabari wala (medieval India)

[@Omia917]

He should apologize for his lies

[@robin2455]

Pehle thum hindhu the kya thum convert hoke musalman bangai

[@SadiqueKhan449]

Ha hum hindu thay lekin jab pata chala hindu naam Persian ne diya hai hinduwon ko toh ham convert hogye

[@hamentsingh6538]

​@@SadiqueKhan449 ni ni jb aurangjeb tumhari maa bhen k utha k le gya jb tumhe marne k liye fatve nikale mugllo n jb tumhse jasiya manga tb tumhe samj aaya muslamaan baane m fayda h.. And hence you converted 😂😂

[@amusingwordplay7298]

"If Hindu Raj does become a fact, it will, no doubt, be the greatest calamity for this country. No matter what the Hindus say. Hinduism is a menace to liberty, equality and fraternity. On that account it is incompatible with democracy. Hindu Raj must be prevented at any cost.” - Dr. BR Ambedkar, Architect of the Indian Constitution. He was critical of religion in general (Hinduism & Islam) but he had forewarned and predicted what would happen if you mix Hinduism with Majoritarian politics. And that's what is unfolding in India.

[@alpha0246]

Cope lol

[@heavenlyhighlands2594]

Yes as if islamic countries are pinnacles of human rights and liberty, no freedom to women at all. Look at Afghanistan, Iran, syria and various other countries.

[@punarbasunath7730]

@Atheist dream comes true

[@46_shivangipandey96]

Ambedkar was truly a visionary person 🙏👏👏💖💜

[@avibcci1297]

@Atheist well every institutions in india are from colonial era which are supposed to rule a colony not to serve people. There is nothing indian about this system. Terrible socialism for 4 decades finally india is having a cultural revival.

[@csnarayanan5688]

Religions and politics are interconnected in all countries controlled power and position in administration not only today but in earlier rulers also results in colonial rule in all parts of the world, history' made them as heros by their historians .

[@suryasaianil]

I dont know why they call it as gymn vapi masjid ? Its original viswanadh temple... the age and history of temple much older than the age of islam

[@Guru-ct8mi]

Ohh didn't know about the pillar. At the least we should remove the inscription of Allah from the pillar. May be put it at the bottom to secularize it.

[@Mohamed-vg8ly]

Senior government official making descions over monuments wahhh

[@donaldtrumpjunior2938]

Oh so u will change history??..it's ur father's property??

[@Guru-ct8mi]

@@Mohamed-vg8ly thats the thing...right?? They are unable to make any decisions to ab public ko hi kuch krna pdega na bhai.

[@Guru-ct8mi]

@@donaldtrumpjunior2938 No it's public property so let the public decide what should be done.

[@donaldtrumpjunior2938]

@@Guru-ct8mi history are history it is not meant to be changed,either u learn or u don't learn from it..it totally depend on the Individual....whether u like it or not...it shall remain as it was...India has become a joke today,there just no value for constitution,from changing cities to now changing monument??. seriously??..there are better problems within the country to take care of..not arguing on some random shit...

[@bakkinathan6801]

It's the divide and rule policy of the central government,the nation is burning with communal voilence The Pm and home ministry is silent Why 🙏

[@ansaaralimohammed7060]

I am very proud to be an Muslim And these are small issue cannot shake my faith. I see the iman of Palestinians many of them are loosing their loved one family members and property but they are not leaving thier Imaan. I love my religion and respect others and expect the same from every one.

[@abhijeetyadav7447]

If only you also stick to your religion in past then today there'll be no need to express shame on Israel and sympathy with Palestine

[@arenmishra]

It is Islam that wishes Hell to non-believers in Allah. Dharma philosophy of Bharat has a common law(Dharma) that applies to all Humans, irrespective of faith. Also, asking Hindus to not fight for the birthplaces of their revered Avatars of Bhagwan, while at the same time support Palestinians fight for their claimed land, is hypocritical.

[@abhimanyupratap1746]

As per quint he is an eminent historian

[@hitmanpp8828]

Adani buys quint.

[@hiteshpunjabi9413]

Why to dwell in the past? Move forward on the path of development & betterment of the country rather than trying to turn wheels of time back to the past. Covid taught us we don't need temples or mosques or anyother places of worship we need hospitals, schools to educate people

[@mangopudding5979]

Keep your nonsense with you. It's about cultural heritage and identity.

[@mountolympus1098]

Okay so we don't need mosques right tell that to your muslim masters

[@shrazi516]

There are enuf heritage and identity ​@@mangopudding5979

[@shrazi516]

exactly was my point in oen of the instagram post but ppl bombarded on me with so much hate..ppl just dont want to live and let live..who know what happened in those kings era y to dig it..noone is stopping them from building new temples but they stop us from building new mosques..but still these ppl r never satisfied very egoistic ppl ever

[@srikarthesketcher5566]

Temples se waha ki puri economy badalegi. Schools n hospitals apne aap.aa jayengi. Prosperity shuru hoga.

[@ishittrivedi5325]

This historian is either fool or trying to make others fools. Everyone knows Temples in Kashi belongs to lord Shiva and that of Jyotirling Kashi Vishwanath temple every Hindu residing even in antartica knows What is importance of Kashi Vishwanath Mahadev Temple and how Aurangzeb broke that. Why these people trying to mislead others?

[@abhijeetpathare1328]

If Rana Kumbha's pillar is still a non islamic monument dispite being 'Allah' written on it then how come gyanvyapi temple be considered as a mosque. No doubt its a temple

[@commentguy7]

SAB HMARA HAI.. KASHI, AYODHYA,MATHURA, तेजोमहालया,aur सूर्य स्तंभ ।।।

[@SkillMattersforall]

Sawal ye hain galti sudharne ke liye timeline hain kya kuch?

[@planetearth4990]

Very soon my dear 🙏🏻🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️❤️

[@parthapratimchoudhury3067]

Wish you had showed the same wisdom while commenting on Babri-Ramlala!

[@abhay_cs]

This rascal should be put behind bars for lying to the court in the Ayodhya case

[@sunilk8309]

Was it right for Aurangzeb to demolish temples?

[@othiyaness3516]

Agreed

[@just-for-fun-777]

Hamare mandir hum leke chorenge !!!

[@dratulkumarsingh4546]

Waise bhi quint ko bola jai ki poti par baithoge ya saaf jagah par the quint poti par baithna prefer karega

[@alisamsreenivasulu9772]

Truth, truth !... where are you ?

[@HemanthReddyBharatiya]

Learn from K.K. Muhammad sir ,who was the former Regional director of ASI, and part of Ayodhya ram mandir site excavation under the BB LAL guidence.....

[@parameahwarbt4920]

Sir, he is jihadi writer!? 😅

[@JohnnyRotten-uf6xw]

Nice to know Irfan Habib supports taking back of the Kabaa, which was built by pre-Islamic Arabians.