Ipsy Glam Bag Vs. Macy's Beauty Box September 2023 | WHICH BEAUTY BOX IS BETTER?

[@vickiebonbeauty1395]

Macy's is a clear winner. The full sized item in the IPSY bag is an inexpensive drug store eye pencil. I don't find that exciting. Lol!

[@burkeangel07]

I vote for Macy’s this month! I love this competition video every month! ❤

[@christinalaska]

Tarte… ABH… Fekkai shampoo/conditioner…Lancôme? Fragrance samples? Come on girl… Macy’s killed it

[@tonjamcgovern7474]

I liked my Macy's bag and I was surprised with the hair clip and did held my hair really well. Thanks for sharing.

[@dianak.8209]

Omg I was queen of the Lancome juicy tubes back in the day. Getting very nostalgic! Aand! Angel was my perfume lol Both boxes were great! Maybe Macy's? I'm really shocked that the FAB cream was that big!

[@dianeoc2973]

I love Ipsy this month!

[@PWatts-ff2fd]

I got the Macy's Box because of you. I have both now. Thank you, Girl!

[@ritafoster8625]

I think maceys because I love that brand of shampoo

[@angelwings7866]

I love my Macy's boxes. I LOVE LOVE LOVE getting the fragrances. The perfect way to try new scents and the Mugler Angel scent I have purchased a couple of times. Found the scent when I took a trip years ago to England.

[@WillSing4TP]

That mascara brush is YUGE!😂 Don't know about Pacifica's makeup, but I love love love their vitamin C skincare. Made in the US, vegan, & cruelty-free. Good for Ipsy.😎

[@jennifermarchand7035]

Both were good boxes this month but I think Macys was the winner as well! TFS!

[@crescentmoon374]

picked Ipsy !!!!

[@MellaYellow]

Macy's because I buy that mascara and wear claw clips! I don't use small makeup bags. Fun video!

[@gemineyesmeow]

I prefer the Macys box. I really enjoy the bonus they give subscribers each month. It's always something different, and i have received items I've ended up loving! I do prefer something different than a bag every month

[@leonnahofer9138]

Macys all the way this time!

[@fateemajohnson825]

I agree with you on they are really close but I like the perfumes in Macy's.

[@user-dz1ds1cr2p]

That was fun.

[@cazzi6927]

Macys. There were actually a couple things I would like to try…Ipsy, I didn’t see anything I would even want. I like Pacifica, their packaging is cute but I wouldn’t get Ipsy for packaging of 1 product lol and the eye liner is basically only full size by default. Ya they have smaller eye liners, but this as a full size item, isn’t much of a ‘wow, a full size product’ 😂

[@jeannie2532]

Wow great boxes on both. I just signed up for Macy’s. I wanted the fragrance samples and the coupon as I’m always shopping in their cosmetics dept. Thank you for sharing 🍁🍁🍁

[@janeentroy]

I agree Macy's wins. For fragrance sub I do Luxury Scent Box, you get 9 ml with them, everyone else gives you 8 ml. They have a lot of niche fragrances, and some designer.

[@SHERRILOWE-wz4lg]

Macys I love it

[@gilbertrivera2057]

Macy's has my vote. ❤

[@Divinediamonddexterity]

I love watching your videos i wish I had found it sooner

[@joball-porter9481]

❤MACY BOX❤

[@HeavenlyZenDesigns]

New sub here!! Love your channel!! I only got the eye liner in my September bag, not the rest you showed. Everything else I got in my bag was different and all samples. So weird 😕

[@northernbeautygal]

Ohhhh this is really hard! I don’t think I can choose either. They both have great items. I also just got my glam bag and I’m in Canada 🇨🇦! Lots of people got their glam bags late this month. Enjoy all the products though they are fantastic ♥️

[@karinathegamer7899]

Hi,for me Macy's is better this month,but I also saw products in Ipsy that I would like to try. Unfortunately I live in the UK and I am subscribed to Birchbox,hoping sooner or later to see such brands in their boxes too.Greetings from the UK.❤

[@janetplancey9712]

I think Macy for sure

[@vickimyers4022]

Both are great!!

[@mommaramirez780]

Macy's always win for me. 😆 I'm still mad at IPSY, I'll get over it when I run low on skincare. 😂

[@terriepriest4789]

Love Pallets

[@surpriseitsus9622]

I think I need the Macy's box. 😊

[@angiegreen7225]

I love these videos 😊

[@lmsfas4263]

I actually found both not too bad however I’ve had a bad experience with Macys so I’m leaning more toward Ipsy. I have shorter hair so the clip in the Macys box would do me no good. Not everyone has long hair. I’ve had several Lancôme Juicy Tubes and find you have to really knead them to get the color and the gloss to mix otherwise when you squeeze it out it’s just clear gloss. Sorry, just being honest

[@MsRandom24]

This one got me! Signed up for Macys

[@alisharoberts2178]

Macy's won. Ipsy was good but I'd use everything in the Macy's box

[@annamendoza3479]

It's Macy's for me this month. I'm pissed with Ipsy's courier because they lost my glam bag shipment! I was really looking forward to the Natasha Denona bundle I got for Add Ons and it's now out of stock 🤬

[@cathycasuccio-ec4sw]

that happened to me for the August bag add-ons. First time with them since joining in Dec. 2022. Contacted Ipsy Care and they resolved it within an hour or so, credited my card - but I really would have loved the ELF sunscreen. My other add-ons were shipped but I was most excited to receive the sunscreen - so a bit of a letdown.

[@annamendoza3479]

@cathycasuccio-ec4sw Sorry it happened to you. Glad your issue got resolved. I'm starting to think it might be time to move to a different subscription box. This is probably the 3rd time it's happened to me.

[@breezyvibe]

Great video!! Both were great!!

[@Gigigrandma0309]

My Ipsy was late also. Signed up for Macy’s but there is a waiting list apparently. I have serious FOMO now, am loving both! ❤

[@alikc25]

Macy's won this one.

[@daphnegarzarelli-lawson324]

I don’t like the Ipsy one. Not brands or products I like. Just a personal preference.

[@nancy5831]

This are fun videos! I like the Macys product, but I am a sucker for Ipsy’s bags❤ what do you do with all your bags?

[@MellaYellow]

Sydney do you ever sell anything? I want to buy P.Louise World Full of Wonder palette.💜

[@Chrissy1966]

Not keep 2xs i mean give away. Lol😂

[@valeriesjourney17]

Hi there, I'm new to your channel. The coupon that is in the Macy's box; does it have any exclusions? I'm thinking of how Ulta's coupons usually have exclusions on their coupons. Thanks!

[@nancyhetzke3885]

Ipsy will win over Macy’s just because I don’t want any fragrance. I. Used to throw them away until I found someone who waned them

[@flowersaremyfavorite]

♥✨♥✨

[@catmansma]

I got both of these bags and haven't even opened them yet. Actually..., I haven't sat down since JUNE with any of my boxes. June..... was I was sick, husband in hospital, set aside, July had more sttuff August...you get the picture And i just canceled both boxes, Ipsy I was going to anyway, but I love the Macy's box. But-hospital bills now. Life realities are always taking away my fun!! Ipsy I was going to cancel because, of the way they conduct business. I would lose track..did I get it? Was that last months? And they have that window, if you want to choose , you have to do on certain dates. If you want to add-on, also on certain dates. I don't recall if I got a shipping notice, but their little calender thing that it will be shipped between , and they gave dates...I got dizzy. If i missed a bag and I paid for it- I would have no ide. You HAVE to be on the phone with ipsy alot..Macy's they bill on certain days, ship out and certain days and ..yes as you mentioned you usually get by 15th. Allure is the best on shipping I think-but another video. BUT I do want to get myself some of that lavender pillow spray. That just makes me feel all girlie just hearing about it...I'm all for feeling girlie these days. I do enjoy my sub. boxes..and I will miss the ones i cancelled, but I'LL BE BACK!! Have great night and thank you...oh i noticed your subsciber numbers are up! Way to go Sydney. This is the best channel for not just seeing sub boxes but checking out other, expensive, products before buying,

[@sinsitysinderella790]

I totally get the being sick and hospital bills, I'm so sorry, it really sucks. With an average of at least one major operation a year for me ... the $ goes fast. I hope you have a fun Christmasy feeling when you get to open all of your collected boxes! 🎁🎁🎁

[@lauriederderian4173]

Macy’s is much better

[@Chrissy1966]

🎉 im so happy i can finally able to tell u i love ur channel. I want to know if u would show us ur beauty room. What do u keep and what do u keep. Do u do give aways? Love chrissy from whitehall pa.

[@WillSing4TP]

FYI, it's pronounced fuh-KYE. (Did you see I rhymed?🤓)

[@sharonharris9782]

Im not a fan of Ipsy at all. I feel like most of the time you get name brands ive never heard of. Yes, occasionally, you'll get one but most of rhe stuff strikes me as being really cheap. Now Macy s i like. They may also give samples but they' re brands i know and trust. I LOVED the Juicy Tubes back in the day, so i think you will also like it. Macys for the win!!!