Irfan Habib: Hoodwinking History | Manogna Sastry |

[@Nadanachandran]

Well done sister Manogna SASTRY. India is indebted to you and (regrettably only a handful) to the young and old who are bravely fighting entrenched lies and distortions of our glorious past.

[@PKarri]

Irfan Habib tried his level best to distort/ undermine non muslim personalities of great India.

[@ammanagrawal762]

What can u except from Mughal inspired Buslims

[@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg]

@@ammanagrawal762 Hindi also is a Mughal inspired language. !

[@RAMESH-js9lc]

@@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg Thats foolish.... Hindi came from sanskrit.

[@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg]

@@RAMESH-js9lc It is also foolish to believe that hindi and sanskrit are one and the same . If original language, there is no need for sanskrit or other languages help . Tamil is such an original language . It is a known fact that hindi/ hindustani was mere spoken language until 19th century when Deva nagari was adopted . Sanskrit also remained scritless until adopting brahmi , devanagari etc.

[@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg]

@@RAMESH-js9lc Then how can it's name be farsee pronounced as HINDI ?

[@cocophonix]

Excellent research and narration Manogna Sastry. My compliments and best wishes to the entire team.

[@sateshwarkukreti1383]

❤it

[@Spiralinteriors]

Irfaan habib is a villain of Indian history !!

[@0706suchi]

Great work. Rajiv ji did what he aspired for...and his kindness will benefit so many of us open our brains and think critically of the ones who ruined us as much as they could. And value our nation, our people and be cautious of the snakes around...all over the world. Dhanywaad Rajiv ji and team.

[@srpandya1]

I wish Irfan Habib (and Romila Thapar) a very very long life. So they can see their veneer of academic scholarship fully exposed and they also live to see that India has finally recognized them for who they really are

[@parameahwarbt4920]

They have already humiliated themselves by their false and fake history by self inflicted crimes!?? 😮if they have any shame left, they should leave india at least to save poor indians tax payers money if they are getting it in any form incl pension!??! That way they can purify themselves of the sins of feeding untruths to indians 😮

[@dilkash1831]

JIllat DEKHNE KO LAMBI UMER MILE DONO KO PURANA QILA MAE MAHABHARAT PERIOD HISTORY FOUND. ALONG WITH BAGPAT , AND DELHI BELT?

[@lajwantishahani1225]

First, Huge error in Irfan Habib's dating the IVC to 1500 BCE! Prof. Gregory Possehl has NOT given this date and having known Greg personally I can tell you that he would have ripped into Habib for this. Second, both IVC and Sumerian & Akkadian periods of Mesopotamian civilization were over long before 1500 BCE. Around 1900/1800 BCE to be precise. In 1500 BCE the Harappan region had no contact with the Babylonians who had taken over Mesopotamia.

[@annshumaansadhangi]

❤❤❤🙏🙏🙏☑️

[@ss-ib8gm]

please contact her

[@tusharcentaur]

Wonderful discourse mam, thanks for unmasking these mlechcha-descendants who have so far been so successful in distorting Indic civilizational heritage

[@fayazsultan6745]

Speaks a lot about your actual roots--- boarish!

[@vinayakgemini]

@fayaz sultan, Many Muslims crib that they have been subjected to hatred by country's majority Hindus..... The reason is people like you !!! Some years back when Akbaruddin Owaisi of AIMIM said that 15 minutes of police's silence is sufficient for the Muslims to "teach" Hindus a "lesson", more worrying was not his words, but 100s of youths who cheered him for this statement !! There ia absolutely " incapable leadership" of Muslims, who are preparing a highly "radicalised" Muslims for a streetfight in coming years !! What you sow, you will reap !!

[@sameehasamad]

@Tushar Still living in that caste based wonderland that favours the uppermost tier

[@viswambharannair5476]

👍👍👍

[@santa4091]

@@sameehasamad so you are a sheikh, a sunni, isn't it.

[@bhaijaan9319]

Excellent presentation Manogna Sastry Bharat desperatly need scholars like you and Vikram Sampat ---- Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳

[@sovonsanyal2240]

Thanks & thanks for exposing these enemies within...

[@AshishBagade-hv4el]

When Irfan did all that…I would be very interested to know if he had some ISLAMIC feelings inside of him and maybe he was laughing with glee inside to see the plight he will subject the stu*id Hindus to

[@biswabose8577]

no doubt about that, he was paying his role of academic Jihad.

[@adityajoshi6422]

Intellectual jihad, the worst of all

[@NikSha-dc2if]

Mythology written by such historians from western world and Marxist. The Indian Nobel man Rishi, Muni, Sadhu, Saant, Acharya and Mahatma lived their life in search of truth, they died for truth, even for sake of life they never lied and they lived the life of truth, and they documented the jeewan darshan for centuries with credibility and credence. Jai Mother bharti 🇮🇳

[@sateshwarkukreti1383]

True👌

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

Irfan Habib is a propagandist for Pakistanis.

[@ravindersingh3701]

He was Marxist historians not an archiologist who prove by facts

[@arunmisra5963]

इस वार्तालाप को आप लोग हिन्दी भाषा में करेंगे तो🤘😜🤘 जन साधारण अधिक जानकारी प्राप्त होती❤ धन्यवाद सर !

[@arunjetli7909]

@@ravindersingh3701 not a Marxist he is JSMill follower

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

@@ravindersingh3701 He is not a Marxist as a staunch Muslim cannot be a Marxist. His opinions are totally against the Soviet historians who criticized Aurangzeb and other Muslim rulers, who are adored by Habib and Thaper. Russian historians support Tilak's theory and the books of Tilak are now translated into Russians.

[@ravindersingh3701]

@@DipakBose-bq1vv His view point is being corrected by new research

[@sadashivarao1140]

Great feeling to listen to you Sir.

[@greatrpc1123]

Great explanation Mam, Habib did his best to malign our great culture. Habib the same as usual jihadi.

[@ravindersingh3701]

Wonderful to correct history

[@carvakasatyasrutah9249]

David Horowitz has a marvellous book on the lefty professors in US universities called The Professors: The 101 Most Dangerous Academics In America & published in 2006. It badly needs an update.

[@mukundshamlalshamlal5959]

Brilliant research work. Ifran must sit at your feet and learn. Also suggest he go to Achrya Aginvrat to get some light on the Ved

[@dr.strange4947]

Just one thing to say...THANK YOU!

[@pramod6898]

Very enlightening discussion !!

[@rajendratiwari1904]

Thank you sir for telling the truth about these biased historians like Irfan habib ,romilla thapar and jha type people.

[@pal3amrit]

Please provide it's translation to hindi language audience. ताकि हिंदी पट्टी के नवीन शोधार्थी भी इससे लाभान्वित हो सकें।

[@biswabose8577]

Wonderful presentation Madam !

[@kpdwivedi1672]

Excellent work

[@bittertruth8374]

Irfan is running JINNAH’s agenda

[@sateshwarkukreti1383]

Jaisht -shresth 🙏 What you and your team are being delivering to society is valuable. Jayatu sanatanam, jayatu Bharatam 🚩🔱🙏

[@grkmurthy1157]

Great research work. Hats off to you and to your team members. I salute you!

[@rajeshmohapatra565]

I need more depth analysis of his historiography, it's very high level

[@sanjayvaidya4925]

Buy the books watch his videos.

[@anilbiz8921]

The first script was invented almost five and a half thousand years ago. The name of that ancient script was Saendhavii. It was first invented in Mahenjodaro. Many ancient scripts have still not yet been deciphered. The next two scripts that we know of are the Bráhmii and Kharośt́ii scripts. Bráhmii script was written from right to left, like Urdu, while Kharośt́ii was written from left to right, like modern Indian scripts. However, during the reign of the emperor Ashok, the use of Bráhmii script was prevalent in all of north India. Kharośt́ii was little used by comparison. For this reason Ashok used Bráhmii script on his stone inscriptions. In Laoria and other areas one sees the exclusive use of Bráhmii script. Shri P R Sarkar Published in: Ánanda Vacanámrtam Part 9

[@Vssk7]

Eye opening observations and facts stated in this above video..!! Absolutely incredible work and gives the youth a fighting spirit to go after the truth.

[@kishanrai4720]

People like habib/thapar etc tried very hard to distort indian with the help of congis and leftists .

[@123sudeepshiram]

How can he act on behalf of wakf board when he is icmr and other institutions is it not conflict of interest

[@kailashagrawal1220]

Those who have misled people by wrongfully presenting the past/fact should be prosecuted for their wrongs.

[@puneetthakur4951]

You all are doing very noble work standing tall against these Ravanas

[@SAFFRONSTRATEGY]

I have purchased the book 10 Heads of Ravan and have begun with the supreme liar Romila Thapar!

[@rohitsinghrtr]

People should listen to KK Mohamed . He showed Irfan Habib right place.

[@Captain_Sosuke_Aizen]

where can I see the 10 heads of Ravana animation? Searched KZbin its not there.

[@silverghost5752]

He was the same person who resisted the ASI findings on Ram Janmabhoomi. His own student Mr Mohammed, the former ASI director proved him wrong and exposed his motives. Sad that people Ike him, Bipin Chandra and Romila Thapar have been dominating the historical studies in India up until recently. They have poisoned tge minds of generations of students with their poison and lies.

[@parmeshdwivedi2781]

Thanks!

[@jayaprakashprakash4147]

Best lecture! Putting the points one by one Manojna exposes the vicious intentions of Irfan - the fanatic in red robes.

[@RAMESH-js9lc]

These Islamists are exclusivist and insular to the core but insist everyone else should be inclusive. How audacious of him to relegate 5000 year old Indian civilization to some foot notes and half pages while according maximum and positive coverage to the mughals? I think the Hindu was sleeping all along....even the constititution seems to be favourable to the muslim😮

[@phalgunimaiti3646]

Thousands of historical resources are there in Indian subcontinent. Still historians would go foreign references to make Indian history. Why ?

[@notrat5678]

Awesome presentation Ms. Sastry. Thanks for sharing.

[@hsingh38]

Thanks

[@SangamTalks]

Thank you For Your Support!

[@LuCipher321]

It feels disgusting to realize our 7 decade-long incompetence and mute spectator-ship in placing the restoration of our past into the very hands of the children of the offspring of the invaders and vandals who physically destroyed our past and our Vedic ancestors.

[@shishirtamotia3992]

Actually Marxists and Muslims have both been invaders. Muslims ndid succeed but fortunately Marxist’s didn’t hence India could preserve her civilisation. Both British historians and Irfan Habib types did work against Hindus. Both these people reflect the barbarous nature of the victor. It is well known that history is written by the victor. In case of India after 1947, Nehru Ji left it to Muslims too hoping that these people would do justice to the history at least. But Muslims, quite often indulge into deception and lies are mostly not loyal to the country they belong to but to the so called religion. Actually such people must have gone to Pakistan along with Aligarh Muslim University. Govt of India must work on the project of transferring to Pakistan.

[@ps5606]

The biggest misery of India is not its poverty, but it is the low self esteem in this Indian generation. Talk to the children, you will often find the children saying why we have always lost all the times to mughal or british. This lack of pride in Indians is the biggest reason that India has not been able to develop like many other countries. People like Irfan Habib, Romila Thappar have poisoned the whole generation of Indians with their concocted, fabricated history.

[@rahara7]

Great finishing touch by Kapil Kumar sir.....

[@subbiahsivakumar]

Superb clarity! God bless!

[@mahavirsingh8469]

You are eye opener for hindu society 👏

[@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg]

An excellent supporter of brahmin domination !

[@mayajagannathan130]

This young speaker Mangona has done a wonderful job in demolishing the falsehood perpetrated by Habib

[@saubhagyasrivastava6050]

Well done sangam talk you are the best

[@vaibhawc]

Now this is called Intellectual Kshatra

[@anilbiz8921]

We see that in the case of written script emanation also remains intact. The name of the first script invented by the people of India is Bráhmii or Kharośt́ii script. With the passage of time this Bráhmii-Kharośt́ii script evolved into three separate scripts. The name of the distorted script to the southwest of Allahabad is Náradá script. The distorted form to the northwest of Allahabad is Sáradá script. The script that arose in Allahabad and the lands east of there is known as Kut́ilá script. The area where Náradá script was used included the western areas of modern Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Sindhu, Gujarat and Maharashtra. The Nágar pandits of Gujarat wrote many Sanskrit compositions in Náradá script. Later the script was named Nágarii after them. When they wrote their local language in this script they used to call it Deshii Nágarii or Moŕi. When they wrote Sanskrit (devabháśá) they would write with conjuncts by joining the upper lines [mátrá]. Then they would call the script Devanágarii. Although the modern Gujarati script is Deshiinágarii and does not have mátrá, it does have conjuncts. Among the Moŕi scripts that were used to write the different languages of Rajasthan (Marwari, Mevárii, Haŕaoti, D́hund́háru, Meváti, etc.), western Madhya Pradesh (Málavii, Bundelii), and Maharashtra (Marathi, Varáŕi, Khándeshii, Koḿkanii), Maharashtraʼs Moŕi has conjuncts in certain circumstances. However the remaining Moŕi scripts did not and do not have conjuncts. Although modern Marathi books and so forth are printed in Devanágarii script, Devanágarii is not Maharashtraʼs script. The Moŕi scripts of Rajasthan (Curuwalii, Yodhpurii, Jhunjhunwalii, etc.) are still commonly used by the general public, especially by merchants. Sindhuʼs script is not used for printing modern-day books and so on. Books in Sindhi are now printed with Farsi script, however the old Sindhi script, or Láháńd́ei, is still prevalent among merchants. The northwestern Sáradá script evolved into several branches. The T́ekŕi, T́egŕi or T́eḿŕei (this script is a close relative of Tibetan script) scripts of the Himalayan mountain regions, Laddaki script (it is also a close relative of Tibetan script), Kashmiri Sáradá (the script in which the modern-day Kashmir pandits write Sanskrit), and Duggardeshii Sáradá (the script of Jammuʼs Dogri language), etc. are all distortions of the ancient Sáradá script. The script in which modern-day Panjabi is written is known as Guŕmukhii script. It is not a natural distortion of Sáradá. The Sikh guru, Arjanadeva, introduced this script (there is some difference of opinion regarding this). This script does not have full conjuncts either, however if some effort is made conjuncts can be introduced. This will eliminate the need to write words such as skul, st́ap, st́eshan, etc. as sakul, satap, sat́eshan. The pandits did not write down the Vedas for a long time, even after the invention of script. They used to believe that the Vedas should not be written down since their forefathers had not done so. Had they looked into it a little more deeply they would have realized that the Vedas were not written down in ancient times because written script did not exist. Later, when the Vedas could no longer be committed to memory, the Kashmir pandits were the first to write them down and they did so in this distorted Sáradá script.(3) Távat Kashmiiradeshasyád paiṋcáshatyojanátmakah Similarly, we have ajeyameru, that is, “invincible land”. From this comes Ajamiir, not Ájamiir or Ájamiiŕ. Both of these are incorrect. Although the scientific name of the script that arose in the lands east of Allahabad is Kut́ilá, it is better known as Shriiharśa in the annals of history. The gold coins of the emperor Harśavarddhan were inscribed with this script. It has been found in Kaoshámbi near Allahabad. Modern Bengali, Maethilii, Manipuri, Assamese and Oriya are written in this script. The scripts of Angika, Bhojpuri, Magahii, Chattisgarhi and Nagpuri are also Shriiharśa scripts, but since the people have forgotten their mother scripts and have not been able to create a developed literature of their own up until now, they do their writing and reading nowadays in Hindi. Since Hindi books are printed in Devanágarii script they are more familiar with Devanágarii script. Shrii P R Sarkar Source: Emanation (Discourse 20) Published in: Varńa Vijiṋána

[@ramakrishna6733]

Irfaan hanib, Father Mohamed Habib also a history student in foreign University was brainwashed and therefore his son is like this..

[@sunilcamin]

Thank you. Great work guys. I hope everybody views this.

[@nnbg8000]

Thank you!

[@bhaijaan9319]

Always honour to hear Malhotra and Kapil sir

[@justLife_review]

Al Jazeera channel pe phir se ulta pulta bol ke aaya hai ye distorian IRFAN HABIB .

[@vyompadhiyar2326]

Commendable work ✨

[@udaybhanu6125]

Excellent presentation,but the power point seems to be operated by an amateur. When the written matter is shown on the screen the operator is shifting the camera immediately to the speaker which is not required. In the process the reader is left disappointed as he is not able to read more than a line.

[@ashwaninagpal1647]

Thanks to put our valuable civilisation for information of Bhartiya people. One suggestion, if such valuable information is also put in Hindi as well, this would help reach masses who are nationalist

[@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg]

Only the hindi speakers are patriots ?

[@naren2k6]

Marxist speaks volumes, tells you the mindset, and a hypocrite.

[@KKJha-rq5nv]

The 'Nadi Sukta' of the Rig Veda and it's description of the mighty Saraswati River whose existence has been proved by the interdisciplinary scientific studies settles the issue.

[@tsMuthuraman-hm6wg]

Nadi sukta can be the poetic expression upon seeing the dry gaggar river bed ! Geological study has not given the name of the river !

[@Ramprasad85]

Wonderful. Before Irfan Habib dies there should be a live interview or sting operation with him asking these questions

[@vijay-1]

Important exposure

[@ramulakkarajul1143]

Rajiv Malhotra ji ko saadar pranaam

[@AshokGupta-oq6hs]

Madam,Prof Habib's perspective of indian medieval history is a muslim.perspective as this is the period during which muslim invaders ruled parts of india while being safely secured in strong forts and maintaining large armies which were continually engaged in battles. Prof.Habib's perspective has great traction among muslims of indian subcontinent and rightly so due to identity affinity.

[@philipeisenberg6984]

Snakes In The Ganga by Dr Rajiv Malhotra is explosive.

[@ss-ib8gm]

bose was killed by his muslim assistant, just like vijaynagar king was backstabbed by his muslim geberals

[@cp6947]

Final nail in the coffin would be when Indus-Sarswati Valley Civilization script gets deciphered...

[@punam7803]

Abbasi Modi has failed multiple Hindu schoolchildren by making sure that is Pashmanda/ Moghuls are held in high esteem

[@sampathkumar2277]

If it’s true All these guys must held accountable for distorting history. These very historians were given red carpet welcome, their books published by foreign publishers.

[@chaitanyakada1341]

Irfan Habib hoodwinked a CIVILISATION. This is because of Nehru.

[@PSVVinodKumar]

There is nothing more important than cremating the history of leftist mindset at this moment of resurgence 🙏🙏🙏

[@RakeshSharma-ws6wx]

I don't want to read or anything written by Mr Habib,Mrs Romilla Thappar.

[@JaiHindHinduRastra]

We want return back the money instead of the book with intrest and also about our civilization and history who give the such authority to remove our religion and civilization.

[@sumanachakraborty8135]

Hinduon ko thorhi si smjh aa jayen.Jaise sab kuchh ho rha hain humlog khtm ho jayenge bohot jald hi.

[@utubesanjay]

Or first education minister was born in mecca. Should we really be surprised about Irfan?

[@ramakrishna6733]

Irfan Habib has done PhD from foreign reputed university...i want to know his topic of research and the profile of the guide who signed research papers

[@sateshwarkukreti1383]

True historian Kapil Kumar ji and team you well exposed to so-called historian. Jayatu sanatanam, jayatu Bharatam 🚩🔱🙏

[@kirannaidu7405]

All of Irfan Habib's work should be questioned in court and the money he was granted by the Indian government. Should be recovered.

[@loke4321]

Great historian Irfan habib is not having Arabic language knowledge and he called himself a medieval historian is big joke !! Har Har Mahadeo !!

[@HackSparrrowakaSicario]

His name says it all..

[@sundareshanal1849]

We need immersive as well as extensive exposes on all the works of this academic imposter -a politician wearing the scholastic attire. We should get these videos translated into all Indian languages and repeatedly take them to the public fora.

[@PK-se2jh]

awesome thankyou

[@bhagwatshah]

Ofcourse Irfan Habib will look to Mesopotamia - it is Iraq and hence his ideological homeland! Such people keep looking towards Arabia and middle east because that's where they imagine all civilisation came from! Their religious and ideological roots are too deep for them to acknowledge India as an independent civilisation!

[@suryashaw3906]

We want all of you who are working for revival of indic civilization should come on a common platform to promote our civilization valour and pride, for that include abhi and niyu please

[@arunmisra5963]

I found one of snake🐍 in ganga & name it😂😊😎

[@venkataraghotham7586]

The recent critique of contemporary "historians" of India authored by sundry engineers,computer programmers etc is absolutely of poor quality. While there is ample scope for a professional critique of Thapar and Habib,the book itself is poor.

[@sudersanvarma4931]

Yah nehruvian historians are best for evaluation of real indian history such as romilla and Karen do the best

[@ananthan8951]

It is a start. Let professional historians break the stranglehold of the academic hegemony of ideological historians.

[@subratasinha955]

Great logical counter facts for habibs introspection for the remaining life great job mam

[@ss-ib8gm]

there books should be banned good it was not translated in anyother language we should make these new sceitic history scholars like dr shastry , sahana singh , sanjeev , sanyal, raj vedam, should be translated in all languages

[@Petercharlie303]

Whatever is their educational qualification, Madrassa mulla remains a Madrassa mulla

[@HarshSingh-zj2bf]

Sorry to say Mr Irfan Habib like the rest of his kind , showed his true colours

[@aprofromuk]

habib is a MC :)

[@venkataramanramakrishnan5302]

We all know the antecedents of Irfan Habib!

[@username92707]

Arya’ became ‘Sire’ became ‘Sir’. They all mean and stand for the same!

[@robertbrowning41]

Do not criticize others ,write afresh and win as many co-minded as Habib had done .

[@chandraprakashchourase8959]

Vedic civilization was present before indus valley civilization.

[@snvvishwanathamprasantm7867]

Bitterness truths disclosed by our eminent Historians...Indians must Aware & Read Real Histories...