Is Christian McCaffrey A Hall Of Famer? | 12/19/24

[@jamiq7228]

So many more worthy guys to discuss if they should be in. Cmon man.

[@zeathstadium9203]

If Roger Craig's not in the hall of fame McCaffrey doesn't even belong within 100 miles of the hall of fame.

[@williamdillard5060]

Agreed 💯

[@rzrramon8310]

Argument over with this.

[@RobertBalto]

Really? There's THAT big of a gap between them? (even though McCaffrey has more touchdowns in about half the number of games) So what does that make Christian McCaffrey then? An average NFL running back?

[@carlbenson6412]

Hey Dan & staff, I put Christian in the category or the Freeman McNeil's, Curt Warner's & other vey good backs that had 4 or 5 excellent years that aren't in Canton. There's probably 6-10 of 'em.

[@samelmudir]

College career count?

[@uc95nu51]

If Mccaffrey goes in then put in Trent Dilfer. Dilfer led the Ravens to a Super Bowl. Dudeza winner

[@RobertBalto]

I HOPE this was a joke...

[@tylermeyer2163]

No too many years where he's been injured maybe if he has a few more dominant seasons of high level play but the guy is on the outside looking in to me.

[@TimPerdue-n8w]

Eddie George....ricky waters....fred taylor...herschel walker....not even close

[@xlargetophat]

Wtf, Walker?

[@stingrey1571]

dan's favorite topic.

[@danoops]

Dan seems to bring up hall of fame discussions a lot. More than most.

[@stingrey1571]

@@danoops dan's go to discussion topics -is he a hall of famer? -my source says THIS is definitely going to happen. -how awesome was jordan?

[@ryanblosser6081]

Terrell Davis is the comp here. I understand SBs but he also had Elway so I don't think either are HoFers

[@baadda7997]

Hell no.

[@Lodie]

Tiki barber 10449yrds 55 tds rush, 5183yrds 12tds rec. Matt forte 9796yrds 54tds, 4672yrds 21tds rec. Both played 10 years. I would vote for Forte before Mccaffery even with super bowl wins. Mcaffery has the tds and awards. Lots of yards yes. But idk if HOF. Interesting convo though.

[@DrPhill96]

Super Bowl wins?

[@Lodie]

@DrPhill96 may have not phrased it the best. Meant like if mccaffery had superbowl wins. My bad lol He doesn't have any yet.

[@markula_4040]

He doesn't have the stats. If he had some hardware like an MVP and Super Bowl MVP like Terrell Davis. Then maybe we can have a conversation. Until he has that or another 3-5 great seasons, there is nothing to talk about and quite honestly it's foolish to even bring it up right now which for Dan Patrick, is par for the course. I mean, he has identical numbers and hardware as Todd Gurley right now. Where was this conversation for Todd?

[@SnakeEaterGaming]

If he stayed healthy and was consistently available, then probably yeah. But he’s hurt all the time. Its Unfortunate.

[@xlargetophat]

Terry Allen Minnesota Vikings

[@ronherrera8327]

Kiki Barber is not even top 25 all-time rushing leaders. Why would you consider him a Hall of Famer?

[@duder9180]

Ffs. Can we at least let him finish his career before having this conversation. But I guess if he retired today the answer is no. 87th on the rushing yds list, and 132nd on the all purpose yeard list.

[@33TimberWolf]

No. He doesn’t have the #’s or the rings. Hall of Fame is supposed to be best of the best; not a participation gift.

[@bryantparker7390]

Only position where rings matter is QB and there are a handful of ringless HOF Qbs. I agree he's not HOF but not cuz of rings

[@ebransc09]

+ key role in Niner’s first title in ages = Maybe

[@shep68]

I’d take Emmitt Smith’s O-line over Emmitt Smith all day long.

[@KoolAidBuzz]

@shep68 That is one of the best statements I ever heard!

[@seanguinn]

Barry Sanders with Emmitt Smith O-line 🤯

[@drvannozzun]

Like the end of Gladiator- not yet, not yet

[@Marie-i4r5b]

Yes Dan i thought the same,,it feels like he is

[@c3920]

😂, no. Silly topic.

[@trolleyman98]

No injured too much

[@carterfong]

No. Next question?

[@braddillon4311]

No

[@Kyeuss]

Absolutely not

[@SEEKUP4EVER]

How can Dan be so incredibly ignorant about why McCaffrey went to Germany for stem cell treatments. The type of treatments he received are illegal here in the USA. The injury didn’t come back this season. He injured his knee when he came down directly on said knee on a frozen field. Dan shows ignorance almost everyone he talks 49ers. Marvin says he’s a fan yet never stands up to Dan’s’ ignorant hot takes.

[@DrPhill96]

Yawn

[@kitchen6036]

This is a ridiculous topic and shows that sports shows shouldn’t be in everyday

[@rcud1]

Certainly not yet anyway.

[@K-StateScottFL]

No.

[@williamdillard5060]

Nope. A very talented player. Can't even play a full season.

[@strawberryreacts9585]

He's played full seasons in 5 of 8

[@schultzywillpa26]

NO

[@jamesnikkel8704]

If Dan would just accept Jesus as his lord and savior, Dan might be more tolerable.

[@Marie-i4r5b]

I believe he should be in the hall of famer

[@JUICED408]

no fuckin way you make the gay guy that!!!

[@JohnRigby5011]

Yes

[@Yeomannn]

No

[@DrPhill96]

No.

[@dr.awkward9075]

No

[@chrisswanson8666]

no