Is Pet Sitter Responsible for Dog’s Death? | Part 2

[@matthewdyck2603]

I’m surprised JJ didn’t hit the defendant with her usual “Do you take any psychotropic medication” or “have you been psychiatrically hospitalized in the last six months” 😭💀

[@KakashiandRay]

proably because it is pretty sure that she does😂

[@Nina-05]

Ahhh yes, the good ole psychotropic medication questions; and don’t forget JJ yelling “ they don’t look like a NUT to me!” 😂

[@jimmiller2237]

She twice asked her if she's on anything.

[@nilaja-itsmylife]

“Are you on something that I’m not aware of?!?”-JJ She asked that much 2x 😵‍💫

[@ishahcanah7351]

She did ask several times… and at the end said to her “If you weren’t so high on something…”

[@bja808]

Can we just award the Plaintiff the $5k and end this case? The defendant is annoying AF

[@apoliticallevi]

I got 5 on it.

[@r.r911]

Judge Judy is pretty cheap. She won't award full amount.

[@meganmoon6197]

@@r.r911Not when it comes to dogs. She’s very generous then

[@kennyhayesmusic7499]

That's what I was thinking most of this case. 😵‍💫

[@acenastra]

Hahahah

[@sarahsmiles4607]

I wouldn’t even trust that woman to watch a pet rock for me based on the way she’s acting. Such a tragic scenario and my heart breaks for the plaintiff.

[@karondalittlejohn]

😂😂 omg but seriously

[@chreazuremeyelove]

I wouldn't let her watch a piece of lint!

[@PositivitySpeaks101]

The rock would be endangered he she watched it!! Wouldn’t let her watch a paper clip!!

[@elvickRULES]

It would turn into a bunch of broke rocks or be tossed into the ocean

[@NanaPapa123]

Sadly, per her Facebook page, she has a baby. :-(

[@tinasung3814]

Defendant just can't answer a question without adding extra words to excuse herself fr any responsibility. I am glad she is in JJ's courtroom so the whole nation can see what an awful human being she presented herself to be

[@nicoleparreira1024]

Right? If I worked with her I’d accidentally start the beginning of this case instead of my presentation one day. ‘Whoops. That’s who she is.’

[@thefaithfulgarden8186]

Amber heard vibes

[@cls3201]

Meth Head

[@TheCourtsOfLove]

This is possibly the most unhinged defendant ever on Judge Judy.

[@bo2720]

"Thanksgiving dog attack" was even worse. Its on this Channel a few vids down, genuinely disturbing

[@drewoke5046]

Not even close . There has been way worse .

[@justinm6582]

On the new judge Judy called Judy justice’ a defendant claimed the plaintiff stabbed their own dog!! That lady was indeed nuts!

[@bubbaXzone]

i don't buy she had a little too much to drink the night before... she probably had a little too much to drink just a few hours before the court + i bet their were some drugs involved

[@kemzyacco5629]

I was thinking the same

[@carlairving]

So her whole argument is "I was super negligent but at my own place so it's all A-Ok!" 🤯

[@iykeharrison9161]

No, her argument is that it is the dog's fault for digging up the hole

[@nessabp14]

and then "her dogs like to dig holes, they do it all the time in her backyard"

[@kellymurphy6667]

"... Which I obviously knew about but didn't think it would be a problem at MY place..???"

[@-az-1236]

It's so frustrating to see a defendant lie constantly, but it is more frustrating to see a plaintiff who's constantly interrupting when you were clearly winning. 😤

[@jdsiv3]

i think the plaintiff is just bewildered and responding emotionally, but she is not really interrupting. She has kept herself from speaking several times.

[@alex1vid]

Part of it is ego but another part is human nature & controlling impulse. It's difficult for some people to read the room or situation, and believe it or not, it's difficult for some people to truly get that the Judge is intelligent.

[@trekgirl65]

Excuse me, whining. Her dog was killed by the defendant. And you expect a grieving pet owner to be quiet? How unsympathic you are.

[@dorothymcguire2105]

​​@@trekgirl65her dog was killed by a car. Awful but an accident nontheless. JJ did not give the pet sitter any chance to tell her side about why, at the last minute, the owner decided not to let her stay at her house or more to the point why the relative who stayed there while she was away could not have looked after the dogs in their own surroundings?

[@iykeharrison9161]

This defendant is the clear definition of lack of accountability. Wtf! 😅😅😅

[@prettyricky6135]

JJ: 👩🏻‍⚖️ “I wanna know what you’re on” Defendant- “I drank too much on the plane ✈️ yesterday” 😂😂😂💀

[@Wayniesgirl]

She actually said "I wish" at one point. Pretty good indicator that she was probably intoxicated one way or another while watching the dog.

[@jenem9618]

@@WayniesgirlSome people are under the influence on such a regular basis that they act erratically even when sober. The defendant is reminding me of that type

[@Frosty0762]

That doesn't mean that she does so regularly. I often hear people use those words for similar questions that. One that has never had a drink or used a drug. He's 36. Certain phrases or words don't always mean everyone should jump the gun and assume what they said has a deeper meaning other than sarcasm. Crazy. She's grown regardless, she's allowed to drink on the plane lol I'm sure the vet wouldn't have suggested her and she wouldn't have continuous clientele if she was a drunk.​@@Wayniesgirl

[@ec-kj4yp]

wow. this defendant is a real piece of work. disgusting.

[@bo2720]

"Thanksgiving dog attack" was even worse. Its on this Channel a few vids down, genuinely disturbing

[@shendisackett]

​@@bo2720that was really bad.

[@Christine-iw4ke]

Yes, that's exactly the word for her. Absolutely disgusting.

[@MrQ12elve]

this lady holds the world record for saying the most 'Mm-hmm ' without JJ telling her off

[@emilyp5176]

This defendant is abhorrent! Her last statement of “it was an accident, nothing more”…. Maybe so, but it was negligent and her lack of accountability is indefensible 🤬

[@amandadonaldson8748]

It was technically an accident, but if that kind of accident happened while I was supposed to be the one watching the dog, I would feel absolutely horrible! I certainly wouldn't be on TV trying to claim it was the owner's fault!

[@michaela7100]

At least she didn't put it in the microwave

[@rogerroo]

You’re so eloquent

[@annneylan50]

Shes 💯 a bunny boiler! 😢

[@ishahcanah7351]

The lesson to be learned: Never leave your dogs (pets) with someone you don’t know for three weeks…

[@janjr165]

🎯

[@candysays100]

I mean, her vet recommended her. If anything, the vet’s office steered her in the direction of hiring her. Why would you doubt someone verified by your vet?

[@CalHut]

The woman behind the defendant @ 1:10 is like, “oh my god.” Lol

[@themirrorsofmymind]

I saw that too! I wonder if she was thinking *_"Judith is about to BLOW!"_*

[@kay44422]

at the end too lol I can't stand ppl all because of ones like her and ppl wanna judge me because I'm real and honest lol at least I'm not delusional ill take it 😂😂

[@jayro792]

I was looking for this comment. I felt that same sentiment from that woman….. ugh, just answer the question 🤦🏾

[@PorchElla]

This defendant has no empathy or decency!! Can't believe there are people like this. She must have pretended a lot before getting the pet sitting job from the plaintiff!

[@YolanderWilliams-y9k]

She don't think it's her fault unbelievable

[@kurtyoung6769]

My thoughts too!!!!

[@YolanderWilliams-y9k]

@@kurtyoung6769 exactly 💯

[@J-W.-]

I always ask myself how anyone makes it through life that silly.

[@sandlotkrew8778]

Imagine dropping your baby off at a daycare and something happens during the time your baby is playing & he/she ends up dead... And all the employees can say is "Babies play all the time. It was an accident. If you're gonna turn it into anything more than that, that's insanity."

[@valynteena]

I wish Judge Judy had asked her that. What if this was a baby , maybe someone's only child after years of trying

[@firstlast8258]

​@valynteena it wasn't a baby though it was an animal

[@Daydream_N]

​@@firstlast8258yeah that's what the WHAT IF part is for

[@samanthaw.861]

The plaintiff’s name may be Budwiser but the defendant is the one who had too much to drink.

[@JJPrizeDistributionComittee]

"It digs out of her yard all the time!" Don't you just love it when they wrestle the shovel away from JJ and dig their own hole deeper! 1st, interrupting JJ is a terrible idea no matter what you are going to say, 2nd if she had dogs that were known to dig out of her yard all the time... that means you should have been *extra* vigilant! Not a great defense when you're accused of neglect!

[@flynspaceball6445]

As soon as you hear the word “activist” in description about one person, then there should be an immediate question in one’s mind about this person. Stay the h… away from these nuts.

[@Callidus7SSM]

Underrated comment. Especially in this day and age.

[@zekemedia1310]

Spot on

[@psoteriou3884]

Totally agree 👍

[@monicaisaacsart]

“I drank too much on the plane yesterday” is a wild defence argument in a court of law 🤣💀

[@MrAcook1985]

😹😹 right

[@wintercame]

Question is what drug(s)?

[@MarkT1700]

​@@wintercameseriously. she seems really off.

[@intothemindshaft]

Prob why JJ said in part 1 “it’s not that hot in here” cos she a sweaty hungover miserable lady 😂

[@joecrawford172]

"Oh, she's slandered me all over town." Ummmm, it's not slander if they are FACTS. (Can't believe there's a part 3 to this ...)

[@bubbaXzone]

right you kill a dog and you dare say its slander. What you should say i am so sorry! How can i make it right?

[@QAZ-OMEN]

Sometimes i wish JJ could force the defendant to actually pay the verdict instead of the show.

[@MichaelJones-yx4zv]

If they don't abide by her judgement she can not pay them

[@Eros4tw]

Its an "accident" based on negligence. Replace this dog with a child...and say while this woman was charged with babysitting, the child opened the front door, walked out into the street and was hit by a car. By this womans thought process - she would bare ZERO responsibility because "it was just an accident". The Defendant should not be allowed to babysit a Cabbage Patch Doll, let alone a living thing.

[@pollak1989]

Couldn’t have said it better myself

[@andrewsercer9538]

The word is "bear", Eros4tw ..... "bear" responsibility.

[@Eros4tw]

@@andrewsercer9538 🙄

[@andrewsercer9538]

@@Eros4tw sorry, I know nobody likes that guy .... but it really annoys me and it makes me wonder if you really know what you're saying, you know?

[@TheFakeyCakeMaker]

Plaintiff called JJ "Honey" hahahaha! Brilliant 2:51

[@lexismith3670]

LMAO THE LADY BEHIND THE DEFENDENT IS DOING TOO MUCH 😂😂😂

[@STÜDD_Music]

“I drank too much on the plane yesterday” oh lord 😂

[@frenchgirl75000]

She's high or what?

[@ivannovotny4552]

@french Too many Budweisers?

[@balkb8297]

That defendant, some piece of work.

[@vetmom79]

At 1:13 the lady in the back of the defendant cracks me up😂 she couldn't even get over how dumb the defendant is 2:36 same lady can't believe it 😂

[@justinowen9526]

Did she just tell JJ she drank too much on the plane yesterday? 😂😂

[@QuietlySoulful359]

It seems the defendant is under the influence.

[@kellymurphy6667]

In withdrawls I think, and anxiously hoping to get herself outta there to self medicate but only after giving herself the best chance to wipe her hands clean of any culpability

[@QuietlySoulful359]

@@kellymurphy6667 Good point

[@MVPallday58]

Hurry up with part 3 please! My break is almost over!

[@ImThePr3s]

Drank too much the day before a court case? Yep shows her level of ignorance

[@k.robertrichardson6779]

The plaintiff is about one "Ohhhhhh!" away from getting her case thrown out. And Judge Judy is on her side.

[@ericatalk4441]

I wanna know what you’re ON! “I drank too much on the plane yesterday so maybe that’s what it is”. That lady was in the airport giving hell 😂😂😂

[@SimiLandGaming]

I love that Judge Judy pronounced Budapest like a Hungarian 😊

[@MarkT1700]

She's well traveled. She says it properly.

[@simpleman3009]

If she knew the dog was a digger then she should have been watching the dogs

[@lornesbored]

Absolutely DESPERATE for part 3 on this

[@usausa3234]

Sounds like an accident. My goodness

[@kurtyoung6769]

My thoughts too

[@mariejenkins-stephens6176]

That isn’t no accident I let my dogs out to play all the time supervised they are small dogs people like to steal in no way shape or form the dog should be left unsupervised

[@janjr165]

The only way the defendant will learn accountability is when something horrific happens to her, and the only explanation she receives from the person responsible is, “Well, it was an accident so everything is okay.” Then, and ONLY then will she realize the stupidity and lack of empathy in her own perspective.

[@firstlast8258]

Stupid is as stupid does

[@Wayniesgirl]

The defendant is a complete narcissist. Doing everything she can to deflect the blame. She blamed the plaintiff and the dog. What was next, the dirt and the fence?

[@nancyharabedian7293]

This "dogwalker" gives good dogwalkers like myself a bad name! If this dogwalker knew that the dog tended to dig under the fence, why did she not watch the dog more closely? She is incompetant, and needs to find another line of work!

[@missyrose2154]

No it was not an accident ! This was pure negligence on the defendants part . She did what so many people do … she shoved the dogs outside alone for however long assuming it would be fine in the yard and not thinking about what could go wrong . If she knew the dog was a digger then it should not have been left alone to be able to dig . I am willing to bet that dog was out there alone for a long time . People assume a fenced yard is all the protection you need but you still have to use common sense especially dogs who dig because they will find the weak spot and go after it . I know I have a beagle and hes a digger. You learn fast not to leave him alone in the yard. This was not an accident . She can’t take any responsibility for her own actions it’s oh but they did this and they did that every time Judy points out mistakes made by the defendant. This woman is a narcissist and I would not hire her to babysit a goldfish!

[@rongyos]

0:40 It is admirable that he pronounced the name of Hungary's capital city correctly.

[@jennifer_mertens]

"An accident, nothing more"? Still doesn't absolve her from being guilty AF of allowing the Plaintiff's dog TO DIE. The Defendant's demeanor and attitude make the situation 1000% worse. She won't shut up with the excuses. No remorse, just like a psychopath...or a toddler.

[@missthang4982]

Defendant is high af!... ... Awkward! 😳

[@apllu17]

"I drank too much on the airplane, maybe that's it." OMG, what an excuse.

[@rox7558]

is there a part 3? they didnt dismiss and such

[@YolanderWilliams-y9k]

She delusional

[@thatssjess9533]

JJ: There's something not right with you 😂😂😂😂😂

[@WarGrowlmon18]

She's either on something or she NEEDS to be on something!!!

[@abigbagofchips]

WHERE'S PART 3?

[@bionicRod]

Are you on something? I wish! 😂😂😂

[@thesb2836]

there is something wrong with the defendant

[@jennakennedy3403]

I think judge Judy is getting a power trip over not letting the other lady talk, I feel she took the older ladies side right away because they are closer in age. Then proceeded to not even listen to any of the discrepancies the defendant was trying to explain. She didn’t even want to see the photos of the actual scene of the events that she is supposed to be ruling on….

[@jennakennedy3403]

And trying to discredit the younger ladies story by claiming she is mentally or physically disordered in some way is such an unnecessary comparison to make. If there were text messages proving her claims then what would JJ say then?? Seems definitely staged beyond just the normal filming of this show

[@cls3201]

Methamphetamines are a terrible drug 😮. The defendant was HIGH AS A KITE. 🙄

[@breeze8756]

She keeps changing her story! JJ's right. The chic is crazy!😂

[@fingolfin897]

I hope she never STOPS getting death threats.

[@Misssugarpink-st2lh]

I know this is not relevant to the case, but as a Hungarian it was a pleasent surprise that Judge Judy pronounced our capital city, Budapest, perfectly. Like how we pronounce it in Hungarian!😃

[@DonGrigorianFishing]

The Defendant is on Uppers AKA Amphetamines and she can't control herself or her mouth! She was also definitely high at the time of watching over the dogs and left them outside to run amok 💯

[@kurtyoung6769]

Judge Judy is the only one acting out of control

[@themermaidstale5008]

Knowing how much I loved my pets, my heart breaks for the lady.

[@DawnRoache-y9n]

She made Judge Judy tear up!!!

[@jj5469]

Where is part 3 at

[@alyssiawatson4496]

At the end of the day, the dog was unsupervised. She never denied it so she’s in the wrong regardless of her answer.

[@jenellegonzalez1140]

The defendant looks like she's on drugs lol what's wrong with her

[@AndrewCurtis57]

ACTIVE LISTENING… you should listen with a purpose to understand and NOT with a purpose to respond. The defendant didn’t listen to anything JJ asked or said.

[@emm7632]

Where animals are concerned, you are not going to win if you are in charge of an animal when it dies, despite animals being unpredictable JJ is always going to come down on the side of the owner. I find JJ sometimes can be a bit judgmental of how someone behaves and looks. This defendant was never going to win.

[@sharten5706]

She's a wicked person.

[@firstlast8258]

Takes one to know one

[@stratfordbaby]

Budapest and she said it correctly!!!! KOSZONOM SZEPEN JUDGE!!!!

[@UKProud]

The lady at 1:15 is a MOOD

[@fabmissb]

I would understand if it were just one dog, but she was with 4+ dogs out in the fenced yard, and had no reason to expect the dog to dig out. She gave back the deposit, which was the correct thing to do (I will say, that woman was getting away with a scandal of a deal; I’ve never received less than $100 for just one dog for one weekend, so the idea of $750 for four dogs for three weeks is bananas). The owner even said that she has a doggy door, meaning that she lets the dogs have as much outside time as they’d like without her supervision, so the idea that the sitter was expected to keep a close watch on the dog in a fenced yard is wild.

[@keoraanderson459]

I said in part 1 she was on drugs and JJ caught it in this one 👍🏽

[@Naji_Naughty_Pantry_Eggs]

Ms Budweiser 😂😂😂

[@debracaruso-catalli7941]

Thank you Judge Judy my friend Susan Budweiser was devestated

[@patriciagazey4693]

Why is she smirking

[@thomasw3285]

Bigger issue is, how does one take a river cruise from Budapest to Amsterdam? The Rhine and the Danube aren't the same thing...

[@MoneyHova]

Ppl like this NEVER take responsibility for anything.

[@shannonbugeja3746]

The defendant is a disgrace I get so angry every time I watch this case she’s in the category of the most despicable person ever.

[@GardenOfGethsemanie]

How many times do I have to refresh to get episode 3?!

[@JoeyTeam31]

Obviously she never got paid because the dog died.......so now she is getting sued to my understanding because she didn't take care of the dog as requested by the owner, and she probably left it unsupervised........ONE THING EVERY PET SITTER SHOULD KNOW IS THAT A POODLES 🐩 especially the french poodles, they escape often.

[@r.r911]

"They dig 🕳 " lol. So ignorant. 😮

[@rjr1284]

If it were a case of human children instead of dogs the defendant would be in prison.

[@firstlast8258]

You first

[@sabrinashelton1997]

Is there another part?

[@jaynicoleproductions9611]

She seems like she's on something...and what did JJ mean when she said "It's not that hot in here?" lol

[@shaneclark5022]

Defendant is right. It was an accident. It was a dog

[@lunacielo7680]

You must be on whatever she was on.

[@AntoniusReginaldus]

Wow. Impervious to sense.

[@MrMousley]

Question to the defendant .. If you had been baby sitting and the child wandered off and got hit by a car would that be ''an accident and nothing more'' that you weren't responsible for as well ?

[@crystalle8982]

Omg! The defendant's running big mouth is so annoying. Even if she's caught red handed, I bet you her mouth would still running wide & loud to make excuses. Avoid associating with these kind of "friends".

[@PrePre_]

I had the same reaction as the woman in the audience @1:13 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@muhfux]

she can afford another dog with that last name

[@savannahwren6734]

Part 3?

[@EUC-NYC-GUY]

She’s addicted to pain killers.

[@hankrhill324]

Did I hear the plaintiff call JJ hunny? 😂

[@pegasoltaeclair0611]

She most certainly didn't cruise on the Rhine in Budapest, it doesn't flow there lol Also, JJ pronounced "Budapest" right, that's heartwarming. ❤

[@EdwardKamaunbrows878]

JJs look at 4:02 says it all that this defendant is a nutter! haha

[@marie_FKH]

As a pet parent, I can assure you if something were to happen to any of my babies on someone else’s watch we would be in a different courtroom

[@missbradicah]

The defendant dug herself a hole every instance she opened her mouth. Least credible litigant EVER!

[@timmahoney7079]

The plaintiff called JJ "honey"? :)