Israel - Palestine, 60 years of conflicts

In 1948 the creation of the State of Israel was proclaimed. Three years after Nazism, Jews can settle in the land of their ancestors. But for the Arab populations living there, it is a disaster.

[@peixotogrp]

Este video para ter fundamento historico vc. Precisa ser mais imparcial. Vc começa o video falando da independencia de israel, mas nao fala que os arabes nao aceitaram o terriotio a eles determinado pela onu, e que foram a guerra contra israel. Que foi vencida por israel. A saida de 700.000 foi ordem dada pelos proprios arabes. A partir dai tudo que ocorre e culpa de israel. Mas, israel lutou e venceu 1948, 1967, 1973 e ainda assim todos questionam o estado e suas conquistas. Nao e mais uma questao de palestina e israel era uma questao do nacionalismo e expanssionismo arabe. Motivado pelas disputas da aguerra fria. Hoje nada mudou, os palestinos continuam nao sendo eles, mas simplesmente são massa de manobra, criadoros de terroristas.

[@fernandomiller884]

hahaha, caramba, imagina se você NÃO FOSSE imparcial...🤦‍♂😂

[@thunderstreet78]

This documentary left out the Egypt border, saying Gazans were stuck due to Israel borders on all sides. Egypt has an equally solid border because despite being Muslim they don’t like Palestinians. They allowed them to live in Egypt for a time but the Palestinians decided to attempt to overthrow the Egyptian government. Not a smart move.

[@peaked_aussie]

You equate the Egyptian government with Egyptians. If you remember a few years back there was a revolt in Egypt by the population who also don't like their government.

[@RuthAlvesReis]

VERY TRUE 🇮🇱🙏🏽❤️💙

[@morgannickels2019]

Everyone hates nazi Isreal

[@liashufflepuffs3584]

You ( if you were an Israeli) stole thier homes and killed them then you blame Egypt for that? I'm not a big fan for Egypt government but how can you be that guilty and have the irony?

[@hamzahaidarr6294]

I am a Palestinian and this person is lying to you. The Palestinians were not expelled from Egypt and the Egyptian people love us. This is a lying Israeli. He lies to you without shame.

[@melissawydola7614]

This documentary leaves out the Balfour declaration and the Haavara agreement.

[@jehdmahdi5959]

And the Goldstein's massacre in Hebron

[@want2learn296]

Well yeah because the documentary says 60 yrs of conflict. 1948 was after the declaration

[@prophet1782]

Doc calls them Palestinian Nothing such ss Palestinian race.They are Arabs.Palestine was a Fake name planted on zjews land Judea..​@@jehdmahdi5959

[@arnfridureinarsdottir4022]

And so much møre.

[@aubraehersel7720]

All I needed to know to skip watching this. They didn't include the entire foundation of the colonial project

[@lion0yury]

Narrow view to this problem. Not mentioned about all the Jewish refugees from Muslim countries who fled pogroms in the same time. Thousands

[@user-nm8my2et7c]

Utter rubbish. If you are kicked out of countries over 1000 times it defies credibility that you are an innocent party, or 'victim', which is the narrative the Jewish Zionists prefer.

[@gonzalesfrederic6213]

Notice that the Muslims (l do not like them much, but let us be honest) only hurt the Jews in Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Marocco, etc after Jews (meaning not all, only the Sionists) hurt Muslims. Before lsrael the Jews and the Muslims lived rather in harmony.

[@pavilionman64]

pogromos of jews in Muslim Land where really rare and isolated. But after Israel all muslim lands dislike hugely israeli jews but we can call it anti-semite. Whats important is that muslim dont have in they beliefs or policy to hatred or extermination to jews, but Europa had it. Reaching extreme cases in Germany and Russia. Unfortunately jews had to cope with the very first reaction of the extreamly retarded racist old Europa to immigration. And today we see the light version of the same in Europe called Xenophobia. And the extreme version of the same in Israel and Natzi Germany.

[@marialuciadeoliveiraabreu4189]

Quem fez esse documentário precisa urgentemente de aulas de história de quem realmente conhece e sabe do que está falando. O prof. e arqueólogo Rodrigo Silva, dá um banho de conhecimento, fica a dica 😉

[@watchandenjoy9916]

I am from Iraq, and what you say is very true. We have entire neighborhoods in Baghdad (the capital) that were full of Jews, and many of them were merchants. ​@@gonzalesfrederic6213

[@taisirghazi2963]

Please educate yourselves on "THE BELFOUR PROMISE"

[@user-jt4kk7cn1i]

Yes you're right

[@chantalameslon517]

Oui tout à fait . Mais paraît-il que cet accord était de 100 ans .

[@cal4207]

The Balfour Declaration not a promise

[@atatterson6992]

Balfour

[@stevejaubert2892]

Go home tonight and tell yourself you're lucky you don't have to worry about random rockets raining down.

[@KajunSpice902]

If they simply go home they won’t have to worry about rockets. 😉

[@krayxeez]

Who? Where? @@KajunSpice902

[@vickythefist7062]

FREE PALESTINE😊

[@TheHedgehogsDelimma]

Home is where the heart is? To claim the land belongs to you and was divinely mandated by God so you have the right to take it by force and subjugate the native peoples is one of the most oppressively psychopathic ideologies the world has known. It is in fact an abomination and a complete inversion of anything Godly and good. How many millions have died for this country to exist since it's inception in 1948? So don't talk about rockets raining down you hypocrite. This geographical location is quite relevant in the biblical sense however, if you believe in the new testament and you haven't been spoon feed distortions of mistruths over the years about key text and meanings, that being, as the location where the false christ is to set up his throne of rule and deceive a large majority of the world. Given recent events and the attitude towards indiscriminately killing Palestinians, the manifestation of this evil working through this county seems likely and more compelling to be true.

[@boazbell38]

@@KajunSpice902 how's that working out for you? it's simple... sooner or later they will piss off Israel enough to make them all go to "allah".. sooner than later...

[@EliTecapture-ru3vw]

Some things the documentary leaves out that is somewhat important. It was the Arabs that started the first war and asked the 700,000 Palestinians to leave their homes and return after "they kill all the jews". Another fact, all the neighboring Arab countries expelled all their Jews to Israel during the same period yet nobody ever talks about them. It's important to point out who started the war, it would dispel a lot of sentiment of entitlement towards Palestinians to the land lost.

[@gcb4763]

Your "facts"seem fictional and of no real revelance.

[@caiolima5016]

No

[@caiolima5016]

​@@San6.7902you

[@alessandramaffilippi3080]

I'm sorry, but it is now proven by myriads of documents that the Palestinians were forcibly forced by the Israelis to leave their homes, their land, to leave everything behind them. Also proven are the death marches in the desert, which some group of Palestinians were forced to cross without water, without food, under a 40 degree sun. History cannot be manipulated. There are mistakes and horrors on both sides. Everyone must take responsibility for their own.

[@catherinejudd7993]

Yes exactly true-since this documentary doesn’t mention the initial reason for 700,000 displaced than this documentary borders on disinformation.

[@lifeandbeyond7279]

Lots of new things I had never known on the conflict…great documentary, thanks you!

[@user-bq6yw1hw8u]

No!

[@user-zy6cg1cx1s]

تحيا الحقيقه تحيا العداله يا رب سلام العالم❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@csillakali2255]

Lots of lies

[@kellyoubrejr.5108]

Too many blood is wasted in this no ending war between this two War torn country. Only time would tell when this war stops! God bless Israel/Palestine, a brothers/sisters of the same blood.. From Philippines 🇵🇭 💖

[@hinahaider3588]

This documentary does not mention Lawrence of Arabia and not tells about the conspiracy of the fall of ottoman empire

[@marialuciadeoliveiraabreu4189]

Quem fez esse documentário, precisa urgentemente de aulas de história de quem realmente conhece e sabe do que está falando!! O prof. Rodrigo Silva dá um banho de conhecimento. Fica a dica 😉

[@Miriamt0789]

I lived in Israel (student visa) 07-08 as an American Jewish teen and let me tell you, those walls were NECESSARY. There were so many stabbings, it was incredible to see how little Palestinians valued even their own lives. Every one of these people celebrated 9/11, I was already disturbed by these hateful people. My sympathy is only for the children who are being brainwashed to hate since the day they’re born. Sorry Pals, FAFO 🇮🇱

[@elenorriley4324]

I had my eyes and mind opened more watching this documentary Thank you

[@user-bq6yw1hw8u]

NO!

[@csillakali2255]

Itse not true

[@Kwame-yw9kz]

"Your oppressor's victory is not your defeat; your defeat is your submission to oppression." Ghassan Kanafani

[@atatterson6992]

Does that mean that after you start wars, lose and suffer the consequences... just keep doing terroristic attacks amd it will make you feel better? Seems to be the muslim mindset...

[@valkry007]

although this is an old documentary (2008) it does a good job at trying to be impartial and balanced, unlike anything made now, which is either pro this side or pro that side.

[@amaroszapatacolina5226]

Me gustaría mirar el documental detenidamente.

[@BOZ_11]

and even absent any bias it's clear who the invaders are

[@HistoricalAnalysis12]

thanks you so much !

[@user-ce1zb9vb9b]

if your not pro of a side your not honest

[@sanitene6039]

A smart man said . Uncertainty is an un comfortable situation to be in , Certainty is a ridiculous situation to be in , Now tell me again you personally know the jews today are not the jews of 2000 years ago ?!? Brilliant!!

[@garyhill2740]

To both of these peoples, this is their home. How can either be expected so simply give it up? Even if there is no simple solution, one could hope there is a solution both could live with, that would put an end to their conflicts and misery.

[@anastasiasurvivante6320]

Mais c'est inimaginable que soit passé sous silence le fait que c'est l'ONU, après vote de tous ses Etats membres, qui a partagé la Palestine entre les arabes et les Juifs le 29 novembre 1947, car la Palestine était devenue BRITANNIQUE depuis 1920 après la chute de l'empire ottoman au Moyen-Orient ! Ce ne sont pas deux peuples qui se battent pour un même territoire car les Alliés se sont battus contre la Turquie pendant la première guerre mondiale et ont conquis l'empire ottoman ! La Palestine n'appartenait plus aux musulmans, et encore moins aux arabes installés SANS DROIT NI TITRE sous l'empire ottoman puis britannique. C'étaient des descendants de tribus arabes NOMADES venues d'Irak, d'Arabie saoudite, du Yémen, de Syrie, du Liban, d'Egypte et de Jordanie et ils ont été déplacés par l'ONU dans la partie réservée aux arabes et grassement indemnisés ! C'est l'acharnement arabe qui a créé ce monstrueux conflit israélopalestinien.

[@iowa4088]

Nonsense, Jews do not come from the region, Jewish religion was normal in Europe until Hitler came. every 2nd was Jewish

[@user-wm7ve2yn5n]

لا أستطيع أن أصدق أن التحول من لاجئ إلى مستعمر أمر غريب إلى هذا الحد

[@HistoricalAnalysis12]

You are talking about Palestinians?

[@jeannedarc7533]

​@@HistoricalAnalysis12 No, he is talking about Israelis.

[@vladimirioffe4237]

@@jeannedarc7533No, he is just talking…

[@hhhaa111]

👍👍

[@hhhaa111]

مع الأسف جاءوا من أوربا واحتلوا فلسطين

[@renubhagat8396]

I was not aware of the history of Palestine but since Oct 7 watching as many documentaries to know about it.This is one of them👍👍

[@suzimonkey345]

I’ve been trying to inform myself to. It’s the most difficult subject I’ve ever researched! The 2 sides contradict each other on EVERYTHING…it’s as if there are no facts. It’s important not to judge history by today’s principles. At the end of the 2nd World War, one side won & one side lost, empires crumbled etc. It was a time of great change. Countless millions were displaced. The Palestinians were a tiny number of people when compared to many other peoples. ONLY the Palestinians are still considered refugees generations later. It’s tragic! The poor people have been used as political pawns & kept being fed, “the right of return” so the Arab world could reject the existence of Israel. It’s heartbreaking! Anyway, I think that it’s important to go back before the technical “creation of Israel” to when the conflicts really started over 100 years ago. The British mandate was in response to all the violence & terrorism, NOT the cause of it! It’s fascinating that Jewish people were responsible for terrorism against the British! It’s a huge tragic mess & I’ve got carried away typing a huge, messy comment! 😊

[@chantalameslon517]

Autrefois je regardais de émissions sur radio Iran qui a été censurée ce que vous entendez n’ est rien à côté de ce que les juifs disaient sur les crimes commis par Israël . Un exemple : ils vidaient le corps des organes et les redonnait aux familles palestiniennes avec des pierres dedans . Ce que je vous dis là n’ est rien .

[@a1j886]

As an American I now see this conflict clearly. What would we do if it wasn’t for KZbin? Real history lessons. Thanks!!

[@jenniferh8148]

Can you really base your entire understanding of a multi decade conflict on an 80 minute KZbin video? There's tons missing.

[@ullahinayat-og6hr]

Nothing is missing its clear now for smart people ​@@jenniferh8148

[@paulamarsh1]

Please educate yourself more - this video is biased and leaves out the other side.

[@a1j886]

lol I’ve watched hundred of videos from each side of this history. I’m thanking KZbin based off of it helping me see both sides clearly!

[@Hezekiah1]

@@paulamarsh1other side? This wasn’t about sides, it is explaining what happened.

[@thoughtpolice9847]

Is there a version of this for adults that doesn't have things blurred out?

[@jamesalexander3530]

Crazy isn't it? Hell, they even blur kids faces in some videos. Way too much censorship if you think about it

[@thoughtpolice9847]

@@jamesalexander3530 yea it's nuts.. recently I watched a WW2 doc where they were talking about Nazis and what they did with "low IQ"/mentally ill people.. they blurred out those people.. and it wasn't in a situation where anything bad was happening to them .. they were in an asylum or whatever.. So they literally invalidated their existence like Hitler would have by blurring them out. Like.. really think about that. Yikes.

[@krayxeez]

I think it's safe to say this is the most complex conflict there exists. It's not black and white like many people try to portrait. We cannot say that there is a clear "good" and "bad" side in this conflict. May there be peace one day, although I think we won't see that in our lifetime.

[@TheHedgehogsDelimma]

While I try not to view most things in absolutes, or black and white, after reading and listening to this topic's subject matter from many different angles and perspectives for the better part of the last 25 years or so, I have to say I've reached no other conclusion then it being completely one-sided and fundamentally the fault falls to one group almost exclusively. To claim the land belongs to you and was divinely mandated by God so you have the right to take it by force and subjugate the native peoples is one of the most oppressively psychopathic ideologies in modern times. Frankly it shouldn't exist the way it does, but I think theology and supposed prophecy's play a part.

[@farsalami8605]

@@TheHedgehogsDelimma your research... is not research my friend. If you wanna go into religious stuff... quran says this land is for the jews. if someone calls themselves muslim, then this case should be closed. I copy paste some comment i left for someone else, maybe it is of some benefit to you.: questions to ask yourself. **6- what early incidents can you name,, of violent incidents between jewish settlers and the people already living there? what was the background of these conflicts ? who killed whom 1- where did the jews settle, who lived there? 2- new " palestinians" ( jews from mostly eu/usa. what were they doing there/? who did they see as their enemies? who did they fight with at the beginning? 3- what was the initial response of the arabic speaking population of the region? Who were the " arab zionists" ? what did they think about a jewish state? 4- who en when did people start calling themselves palestinians? what did this word mean? when did it become common to use this name? who used it and when? How did the people of palestine identify themselves? south-syrian-egyptian-jordanian-arab-muslim/christian/jew- etc. when why what did it mean? 5 what does palestinian identity encompass? Which distinctive features does it have? language-cuisine-historical figures- founding fathers-epic stories etc etc. It isn't too much i hope, if you want to have an opinion you at least need to know the basics... not just a few video's. A timeline with superficial knowledge of the what happened is the least you need . right?

[@MSW613]

​@@TheHedgehogsDelimmaThe aggressors were clearly arabs/Palestinians

[@krayxeez]

@@TheHedgehogsDelimma Still I don’t think it’s that onesided. Why do Muslims have so many countries and Jews have (had) none? Doesn’t really seem fair to me.

[@olafclausing7843]

@@TheHedgehogsDelimma You seem to have not learned much in 25 years..

[@letstalk458]

The narrator said Jews finally got thier country in their ancestor's land. But what how can you validate the claim of ancestry? Jews call it their ancestor's land acording to their religious books right? So if someone can claim a big piece of land becoz their religious books say it belongs to them then there are so many religions around the world and everybody will start to claim lands here and there acording to their religious books.

[@incikjaykee1569]

Exactly!

[@Funkywallot]

Its a problem when Islam (invented 1500 years AFTER) Judaism claims Jerusalem as the third most holy place for Islam. Now, how did that come about ? Of course they made some adjustments in the war instruction manual : The holy Q´ran. Do you follow ?

[@jeannedarc7533]

​@@Funkywallot And it's a problem when modern-day Palestinians share a strong genetic link with the ancient Canaanites who were there before the Jews.

[@Funkywallot]

@@jeannedarc7533 ??? Caanans are from the same semitic famlily as jews and arabs. How does that change anything ? The so called "palestinians" are not linked to only to the caanans, that would be balony. Of course they would have been mixed with dozens of different empire rulers societys throughout a 4000 year old history. So, Its not a problem. Its a problem to those who thinks that Palestinians are pure blood tribes . Echoing H...itler

[@drugoviic]

read history, jews are natively from the land of israel

[@alessandramaffilippi3080]

A precious documentary that helps us understand, even if difficult to accept, how we arrived at the horror and atrocities of these last months. An impartial look, as history reports should always be. Thanks for sharing and reposting it. Dated yet always contemporary.

[@PrinceOfMixes]

And so the circle goes round and round. I wonder when humanity is ready to break these cycles.

[@shalomex-muslims2991]

A Very good well-made documentary. Thank you for sharing.

[@Hap_Shaughessy]

History just keeps repeating itself over there.

[@malenedietl3369]

Because the zionists never intended on peace or sharing the land with any palestinian. @Hap_Shaughessy

[@jerrybauer1767]

As long as religion dominates the minds of otherwise sensible people and segragates us from our fellow human beings there will never be peace in the middle east and other parts of the world. Christopher Hitchens said it best " religion poisons everything "

[@Hezekiah1]

Except now is the first time we can all research past history.. and the first time in history that we can research everything while it’s happening. So hopefully this means it’s not gonna repeat itself again.

[@Adam-xd8df]

@@Hezekiah1 it always will

[@Hezekiah1]

@@Adam-xd8df that’s why your spirit doesn’t see it, it does go into the new kingdom. You would have to have the spirit of.. well peace forever to go to that place. Don’t take consciousness for granted., it is actually shared, as one. Hence the reason you’re hearing what I’m saying in your head right now as you’re reading it. Never underestimate our creator.

[@Spiritofaconure]

42:38 wow, I could never see something like that happening again, and this was the first time I heard Sadats voice for the first time, golda Meir said you always call me an old lady 😂 and him laughing like that 😂

[@prophet1782]

Laila Khaled cant be 64. How old was she in 1970 ? 12 yrs ?

[@daveprask1323]

This documentary is from 2008 she’s 79 now

[@paulamarsh1]

It's incredible, after all these years, to see the eternal hatred in her face... she has not changed, not one bit, and epitomises the Arab Palestinian at their worst : pure and simple Jew hatred. No wonder they are a lost cause! Look at their track record in Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt and Kuwait. Ask yourself why none of the Arab countries want anything to do with them. Surely after all these years, some Palestinian would actually begin to self reflect ?@@daveprask1323

[@michaelw2288]

Why didnt Palestinians declare a State of Palestine in 1948 with Jerusalem as their capital city?. In their 1964 National Charter article 24 states: "This Organization does not exercise any territorial sovereignty over the West Bank in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, on the Gaza Strip or in the Himmah Area."

[@GARINHAZOREA1]

I am asking myself this as well lately. Why didnt they also declare a state... i think its because they were unorganized and not really a people. every arab here understood there was no ambition to be a state and it was obvious they would merge into the other arab territories after Israel was destroyed.

[@drake3116]

​@@GARINHAZOREA1nah. They didnt declare it, because they thought they'll win next war, get jews out, take israel and use its status just renaming it.

[@bsahmed1]

Thanks to social media and spread of information, with a couple of clicks and with courage and human decency, the truth shines for every seeker to recognize. Plan Dalet is a good way to start your search. It details the ethnic cleansing of Palestinian villages and towns from their inhabitants. Search Dier Yassin, Tantura, Ramla, Lidd or Lydda and hundreds of other massacres committed by Zionist Hagana, Irgun and Stern gangs in 1947-1948 under the eyes of the British authorities. Plan Dalet, the blueprint of the ethnic cleansing of Palestinian villages and towns started in December 1947 and was FINALIZED by the High Command of the Zionist leadership on March 10, 1947. Not a SINGLE Arab army soldier had entered the Palestine/Israel before the Zionists declared the birth of their state on May 15, 1948. By then, more than 300000 defenseless civilians had already been massacred, expelled, raped, and mutilated and more than 300 villages and towns emptied, destroyed, torched, and imploded with dynamite under the watchful eyes of and with the support of the British soldiers and police, who left the country on the fateful day. The Zionists even ran out of dynamite because of the extent of their barbarity. By the end of that year, 20000 civilians had been butchered and 750000-900000 defenseless civilians, 85% of the population who had lived in the land that became Israel, had been rendered refugees. 530 villages were destroyed and sepopulated. Zionists criminals even murdered the Swedish diplomat Count Folke Bernadotte, the UN peace envoy in Sept 1948 because he was a witness to their crimes. He objected to the Zionist plan of ethnically cleansing Palestine of its native inhabitants. He, by the way, as the head of the Swedish Red Cross, had helped in the release of about 20000-30000 inmates from the Nazi concentration camps in Germany during WW2. Videos and resources you might find educational: Warning, they may be difficult to get because of censorship. Hundreds of books were written on the subject too. It is VERY easy to get informed. 1. 1948 Creation & Catastrophe (2017) 2. Gaza by Garry Keane & Andrew McConnell (2019) 3. Tantura (2022) 4. Gaza Fights for Freedom, a film by Abby Martin (2019) 5. The Iron Wall, a film by Mohammed Alatar (2006) 6. 5 Broken Cameras (2011) 7. Jenin Jenin (2002) 8. Born in Gaza (2014) 9. The Law in These Parts by Ra’anan Alexandrowicz & Liran Atzmor (2011) 10. Naila and the Uprising (2017) 11. To Shoot an Elephant by Alberto Arce and Mohammad Rujailahk (2009) 12. Mayor by David Osit (2022) 13. Slingshots Hip Hop (2008) 14. Occupation 101: Voices of the Silenced Majority (2006) 15. With God on Our Side (2010) 16. How the Palestinians Were Displaced in 1948 17.The Village Under the Forest (2013) 18. Roadmap to Apartheid (2012) 19. The sons of Eilaboun. 20. The massacre of Safsaf And how many years can some people exist Before they're allowed to be free? Yes, and how many times can a man turn his head And pretend that he just doesn't see? The answer, my friend, is blowin' in the wind The answer is blowin' in the wind Yes, and how many times must a man look up Before he can see the sky? And how many ears must one man have Before he can hear people cry? Yes, and how many deaths will it take 'til he knows That too many people have died? The answer, my friend, is blowin' in the wind The answer is blowin' in the wind

[@RuthAlvesReis]

​@@GARINHAZOREA1 the so-called palestinians only have in mind the destruction of Jewish People as Iran, Lebanon, etc. They teach their children to HATE not to LOVE. There are good Arabs, for sure; but the majority of commun people don't have the intelligence nor the knowledge nir the discernment to fully know the Islamic mentality. They don't know what they are expressing, stupid and ignorant people. The evil 😈 minds and hearts of the Occidental countries are abnormal! And they call themselves educated and civilized! B.S. .. the UN incapable to pronounce HAMAS terrorists. When this abusers monsters terrorists start once again their attacks in the rest of the world, it will be too late. Those who are in favor of TERRORISTS would be the FIRST to experience the torture and abuses so they shut their mouth ONCE AND FOR ALL! GOD WILL HAVE NO MERCI ON THEM. THE WRATH IF THE ALMIGHTY SHALL BE UPON ALL NATIONS and those who speak UNTRUTHFULY. 🇮🇱🩵❤️🇦🇪

[@Westgirl277]

Same question

[@incikjaykee1569]

Bravo all of you make this documentary! Brilliant!

[@flyingcoathang86]

Oh and great documentary. More and more I cherish balanced reporting looking to provide information only for the people.

[@helennuttle1680]

Great documentary,thank you for sharing it with us ❤…

[@mordehai2736]

few remarks: 1)"War started" - means 7 arab armies attacked newborn State of Israel, enemies from inside also started a revolt, that caused an exile 2)"Others call it Palestine" - Romans called it Palestine when destroyed a Judea kingdom, Palestinians can not pronounce 'p' so they call it Falestin 3) 700,000 exiled Palestinians - Arabs in Palestine did not recognize themself as Palestinians back in 1948, they became a nation much later in exile.

[@gaugengotm2307]

FO

[@user-cc6gi4zy1z]

Check your research

[@Anas_Sherif]

1) Interesting how you called it the "newborn state of Israel" 2) The word came from the 12 century BC, and it was "Philistines", it originally was pronounced like an "F" not a "P" 3) As if you existed before 1948? If you lived here since the Israelites Palestinians lived there since the Canaanites.

[@PanzerKampfWagun]

@@Anas_Sherif Philistines were a Greek group that invaded Israel around Ashqelon and Gaza, they are the historical enemies of Israel and the name was a act of humiliation. Calling Palestinians Canaanites is so stupid, that is purely ancestry, from this me as a Greek is also a Mycaenean. Mizrahi Jews also hold a lot of Canaanite ancestry because they lived there and spoke the same language and followed the same religion as 2,000 years ago (your "palestinians" did not). Does that mean Palestinians are mizrahi or Mizrahi are Palestinians? No

[@Anas_Sherif]

@@PanzerKampfWagun Hmmmm humiliation hmmmm... the only thing missing is the moustache... Saying the Palestinians are the Canaanites is stupid, and that's the point, those European and African and Arab and Latin Jews share nothing with the Israelites in common except for the religion, and just a little amount of them are semite, not mentioning the Ethiopian Jews who faced gen. .ocide by Israel so Israel doesn't have that much black people... And finally, if you even had the historical rights to the land, still doesn't justify t. .error. .ism and r. .ap. .ing children...

[@sirevanskoech5540]

The problem is an innocent generation born into conflict and bitterness you belong to a party you don't choose at birth

[@tamaramousley8597]

This is not the “best” documentary because it leaves out important content historically and archalogically also.

[@tuyyo1946]

Those two sons of Abraham, half brothers, have caused so much problems to the whole world since centuries ago. One gets fed up with their problems.

[@krshhbadi9877]

درود ممنون از توجه شما و اضافه کردن زبان فارسی در قسمت ترجمه خودکار .

[@jamesb.9155]

No 'Persian' Farsi, found?

[@LionRex9250]

He said thank you for providing Farsi/Persian as one of the languages. ​@@jamesb.9155

[@SlavaSG84]

Народы всех стран-участниц конфликта заинтересованы в скорейшем его разрешении. Именно народы, а не правители. Потому что война - это всегда голод, разруха, разрушения, слёзы и боль для всех участников конфликта. И всё, что нужно для разрешения этого конфликта на долгие века - это собрание всех религиозных и политических лидеров всех стран, включая авторитетных представителей арабов и Израиля, а также крупных государств Земли, которые будут посредниками. На этом собрании будет решён вопрос не о земле, которая уже является израильской, а о тех людях, которые подвешены в воздухе. Их не принимает ни Израиль, ни аравийские страны, они уже многие поколения находятся в правовом вакууме. Эта ситуация сложилась из-за не дальновидного решения всех участников этого конфликта, проведённого ранее. Сейчас справедливое решение способно обеспечить решение этого конфликта. А справедливым может быть только распределение этих жителей по всем странам, но на это должна быть готовность правительства Израиля, правительств аравийских стран, других помощников, кто готов помочь, предоставить им какую-либо территорию бесплатно. Ведь у них нет денег, они беженцы, и не могут ничего купить. Просто помочь за свой счёт, естественно не за счёт людей, которые живут уже на этой территории, а за государственный. Первая цель - разрешение конфликта, а вторая цель - создание образа справедливого религиозного благочестивого государства, где ценится каждая Душа. Нужно просто собрать, посчитать тех людей, которые остались на территории Израиля, но вне правового поля, и просто распределить их не только в Израиле, конечно же, обязательно учитывая и их желания. Всё это должно быть гармонично, в этом должны участвовать все стороны, и предложить свою помощь. Только тогда постепенно снизится взаимное озлобление людей друг на друга, потому что взаимная агрессия первоначально произошла из-за вопроса о территориях, только потом уже возник вопрос разных религий. Вначале нужно решить именно территориальный вопрос и помочь тем людям и их детям обрести своё жилье, возможность работать, обеспечивать себя, предоставить медицинскую помощь и так далее.

[@jamesb.9155]

Well, look up Isl_am and the doctrine clearly states no tolerance for the Jews because of an ancient hatred by the doctrine against the jews . . . Shalom Aleichem.

[@levteplitsky1385]

Ваш план решения проблемы идеален, но неосуществим, к сожалению, т.к. человек -существо иррациональное, движимое собственными фантазиями, которые для него важнее реальности. Только фантазируя человечество достигло многого, ну а недостатки-это продолжение наших достоинств. Наивная мечта о еврейском государстве осуществилась благодаря энергичности мечтателей и стечению обстоятельств в их пользу. У палестинцев этого не получилось, т.к. это было и остаётся население, скорее племя а не народ, и этим племенем легко манипулировать, создав из идеи своей земли своего рода религию и фанатиков--самоубийц, жертвующих собой ради иллюзии. И никакими обещаниями хорошей жизни где либо их не сооблазнить, они борются за своё место в Истории. Даже эмигрировав в нормальные страны они не становятся на сторону народов, давших им приют, а продолжают "борьбу за освобождение Палестины". От евреев, естественно. Для них это справедливо и остановить их можно только железной рукой. Только беспощадной силой. Другие варианты, как показала история, пока не работают. Но у Бога дней много, в конце концов гимн Государства Израиль называется "Надежда".

[@SlavaSG84]

@@levteplitsky1385 физическое устранение, не сделает народ счастливым. Жизнь времена, дух вечен.

[@levteplitsky1385]

@@SlavaSG84 Тут разговор не о счастье, тем более что это точно и , в особенности что можно считать счастьем народа вопрос сложный и споры идут о нём неутихая. Речь идёт о выживании еврейского народа в кольце врагов.Подчёркиваю: врагов а не противников, с противниками можно договариваться. А на врагов то прекрасно действует физическое устранение, опыт Второй Мировой прекрасно это продемонстрировал. Люди только внешне одинаковы, внутри же могут чудовищами, тут всё сильно зависит от среды и воспитания. Атака 7--го октября это ещё раз показала. Люди навязавшие войну Израилю и всему цивилизованному миру, ведут её не по дуэльному кодексу и не по рыцарским правилам, а по принципу --в любви и на войне все приёмы хороши, так что и "ответка" им должна быть симметричная. Хочу быть правильно понятым--меня лично эта ситуация не радует, но другого решения тут быть не может. А вот когда пушки замолчат, тогда и о духе можно будет порассуждать без лишних эмоций.

[@SlavaSG84]

@@levteplitsky1385 пушки замолчат, когда начнут думать о духе. Для кого то счастье заключается в возможности не умереть сегодня.

[@marklumley619]

When talking about the 1967 six day war, at 8:12 you said the Israelis attacked first. This is a blatant lie as it was the Egyptians who attacked first from the Sinai Peninsula. Already at this point I’m seeing a Palestinian bias as your map of Israel didn’t show the changes to territory. You showed the present map for 1948 rather than the true map of the time. Also you casually mentioned that the Jordanians had annexed the West Bank but didn’t really expound on that. It’s crazy how the Palestinians didn’t care when Jordan annexed so called Palestinian land but certainly upset when after a war Israel took land as a spoil of war.

[@incikjaykee1569]

Not one believe you anymore.. keep try

[@user-wn6lj5re6o]

You live in some kind of imaginary world. Egypt attacked???? Are you out of your mind? And what do you care about Jordan? How does this relate to the military occupation of the West Bank by Israel, an apartheid state?

[@DAPS-bl7ez]

Absolutely correct.

[@DAPS-bl7ez]

@@user-wn6lj5re6o No, it has never been an 'apartheid' state. Perhaps you should learn what the word means.

[@jeannedarc7533]

​@@DAPS-bl7ez Human rights organisations would like to disagree with you. And don't tell me Arabs had equal rights because I can make a similar argument for Nazi Germany. Stop relying on logical fallacies.

[@iliastiberiu]

So, anybody knows exactly the solution to end this epic war?

[@henrysantos7160]

Amazing documentary very well done.

[@anthonybernstein9698]

Who incited the war in Hebron in 1929? Who started the war in 1948, and which countries were involved? What part did The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Sheik ali Hussani play in the arabs leaving their homes? In 1967 Israel did not attack first. The very first aggressive move was the blockade of Eilat, the Egyptian navy moved in Israeli territorial waters and this is considered a declaration of war, according to the United Nations. Why was Hurwitz labelled a Zionist, he was a Russian Jew fleeing persecution and death from the Russians? The biggest questions are: What did the killing achieve? Did the result of so many dead justify the killing? Are the arabs any better off today than they were in 1948? Can the murderers sleep peacefully, knowing that thousands died because of their actions of choosing death before life? Are the arabs any nearer to achieving their goal of destroying Israel? After every war people move on, when will the arabs learn to move on, start a new way of living, not the old way of dying? They were not conquering new territories, the IDF were chasing an invading army that came to conquer. This is normal combat practice when a country is invaded. The constant use of the word "invade" is very misleading. Jordan attacked Israel on the encouragement of Egypt. The IDF fought a defensive war chasing the Jordanian out of Israel, and moving into land thar Jordan illegally occupied in 1948. If Israel had lost the war in 1967 how many POWs would not have been killed, and how many civilians would have been killed? It is doubtful if any soldier or civilian would have lived after an arab victory. Why did the arabs need to fight after 1967, in every country after a war the defeated country accepts defeat and start a new life, a new beginning, we have seen this throughout the worlds wars. The ideology, radicalization and brainwashing will never succeed in giving the arabs what they want. Generations of kids growing up with the hatred, burning desire to kill. They are fed a history of lies, the arabs will never conquer Israel, its a dream, something that has been instilled into them from birth. Even successful arabs living in many countries across the world talk about home in Israel. They lead good lives in western countries, only speak about returning, but never do. How did an Egyptian named Yasser Arafat become the leader of the arabs? How many offers of statehood did the arabs reject? Why did the arabs reject all offers of statehood? Why were the arabs thrown out of all the countries where they were living, the last country was Egypt? Why did the United Nations in 1948 form a separate organisation called UNRWA to care for 700,000 refugees and another organisation to care for 114 million refugees world wide? As long as arabs are fed a diet of lies that give them hope, an impossible dream to kill every Jew they will never be more than self inflicted "refugees" for many more generations. If the arabs give up the desire to kill and be martyred they have a future. They must choose life over death, love over hate. How can an arab mother say she is happy her son is dead, and she has more sons that will make her happier when they get killed fighting Jews. This is unheard of in the civilised world, our children are our lives, our future, they will give joy to us when we get old. We will dance at our grandchildrens weddings, hold their babies in our arms. The arab mothers don't want their children to marry and bring joy and happiness into their homes, they want photographs of dead sons above the bed which is a shrine. The narrative was "With each attack, Israel was responding with violence". It should read. It shoud be "With each violent attack Israel responded in a similar way". Today is 23rd March 2024, the war started on 7th October 2023. Hamas is losing the war and is hoping the world will force a ceasefire. There are only 4 battalions remaining in Rafah, 4,000 hamas terrorists hiding in tunels waiting for the IDF. If hamas can just hang on long enough Israel accepting a ceasefire give hamas the victory of the war. Hamas will declare victory, because Israel lost. Only one winner in war. Many more people will die before the war ends. Hamas will not surrender, it cannot accept defeat, they have survived every war they started because of world pressure on Israel. No arab country in the world wants the palastinians, why dont arab countries want them. Israel is no different. Where are they to go.

[@djzeederbyshire2932]

Very well said. 100%

[@bobbymckail2874]

This absolute propaganda from an Israeli Zionist Genocide apologist.

[@nenitaespinosa1808]

The strongest emotion that can end war is love for peace. Love for the future of family, quest for survival of the family amidst pangs of hunger and fear . It is miserable to note that hunger for domination and power are overpowering this thing we call. May God in his Mercy open the hearts and minds of people.

[@user-ve6wu7gp6c]

I give you a very short answer: Because the Jews captured the land, the Palestinians had to fight back.

[@sekenzyslayer3096]

No

[@bodomeijer772]

i dont Understand in the Situation as it is now, that why are not the Palestinian People saying Demonstrating againts the Radical Group of Hamas. This tells me that they are not against the Hamas and are not against what happend with the kidnapping of the Jews. This is my Personal Opinion

[@Frost-uy9me]

The people of Gaza were complicit in the October 7th atrocities. The building of the vast and complex tunnel systems and prolific rocket manufacture COULD NOT have happened without their assistance and/or tacit approval. They have, on that basis alone, forfeited the privilege of living anywhere near innocent Israeli women and children. What remains to be seen is whether a majority of the Israeli people have come to this realisation.

[@Wabaro1146]

This is very true. All of them support Hamas terrorists

[@RuthAlvesReis]

​​@@Frost-uy9me What nobody says is that , the so-called Palestinians chosen Hamas as their leaders. That Israelians left Gaza in 2005, they left behind a PROSPEROUS LAND, DESTROYD BY THE PALESTINIANS OUT OF HATE AND JELOUSY; and the responsability of Gaza passed to the hands of Egypt. And Palestinians don't EXIST!! What EXISTS are Arabs in Gaza and the name Palestine doesn't even exist in Arabic language ..! They don't have the letter "P" , It was the Roman Empire that called the land " Siria Palestina ", to humiliate the Jews People. ISAREL IS A SOVERIGN NATION. The so-called Palestinians have had YEARS in a row to build their nation but instead they buit under-ground tunnels, below private houses, schools, mosques, hospitals, to blame the Israel Nation. They have HATE and DESPISE Israel. They teach their children to hate not to LOVE. Arabs in Israel are free to work and study. In which Arab Country is there FREE Jews to work and study ? ( Not even in the UAE the most MODERATE Arab Country, God Bless), People are so IGNORANT and STUPID !! God is with ISRAEL. GOD BLESS ISRAEL 🇮🇱 🙏🏽 ❤

[@paulmcallister8948]

Mine too!

[@majedtaleb3944]

Because you ignorants lack any empathy and are selfish as F. You see in this documentary how the Palestinians have been treated and you still question why Hamas did what it did?? 🤦🏻

[@paulmugi3431]

Absolutely brilliant work.

[@michaelyudovin3887]

If peace had been embraced in 1948, Palestinians would have achieved a state, peace, and cooperation. Instead, they chose otherwise, and 75 years later we continue with war and destruction. Salam and Shalom.

[@RuthAlvesReis]

SALAM & SHALOM Thank you, peace be upon you 🙏

[@richjacobs9736]

Great video🎉 thanks

[@PrabatiSango143]

Hii iam odisha kn kn kn odisha cement kora 0:10

[@zuboy4272]

not again

[@amirhidic165]

Why didn't you start from 1947 how did Palestine given by UK and America

[@tonysnow759]

This is one of the best documentaries I’ve seen on Palestine/Zionist conflict

[@familiaemquestao3663]

Israel/terrorismo

[@user-uk9ih1kc6y]

ALL SUPPORT TO THE STATE OF YISRAEL AND THE YEWISH PEOPLE ALL OVER THE WORLD !!! SHALOM FROM FINLAND !!!

[@JacintaPalerm]

Many Jews do not agree with the Israel state.

[@szimultan00]

It have to discuss on religion level too. Ecumenical conference required to talk about the understanding and forgiveness. Christian,muslim, jewish participants with. They can also be Buddhist, Taoist, and Shinto observers.

[@cordes6900]

? Why only 60 years, what about the about 120 years before that?

[@renubhagat8396]

The kids as army, power in wrong hands is dangerous

[@BigDaddyKai620]

I wish you would have explained a lot more of why those people moved from the land. Because I remember they was a part of another group that was losing the war and was told by their own people that they would handle it but end up losing to Israel anyways.

[@AsemSaleh]

No matter how you try to sugarcoat it... It is an outright land-theft.

[@lisaschuster686]

I never think about my elementary school. Those people never grew up. Adults. Or so you would think.

[@slimbelgaied7093]

This conflict will unfortunatelly never end

[@manueljose5644]

It will end when the US and some western countries stop financing and backing Israel.

[@Rx_VV]

The 2000-year inheritance fight between the Jewish grandchildren of Isaac and the grandchildren of his half-brother Ishmael the Arab 🥸☝

[@Funkywallot]

And they are semites ... Both of the tribes.

[@chrisperez3614]

It’s not a religious conflict it’s a settler colonial conflict. Religion plays a part but the Palestinian’s would have fought against any group that set up a settler colonial project in their homeland.

[@yaminoonna3218]

Palestinians are literally the descendants of the true inhabitants of that land. They were the same jews who converted to Christianity and later Islam. They are not Arabs. They even look nothing like Arabs.

[@Rx_VV]

@@chrisperez3614 Homeland of jews and arrabs ??? 🤔

[@zjeee]

@@chrisperez3614 Really? They did not make much of a fuss against the ottomans during the time the Ottomans controlled the area, just one major revolt in 400 years. They did not really make much Fuzz against the Mamluks that controlled the area before the Ottomans either. Many of them allied themselves with Nazi Germany during WW2, before the creation of the state of Israel. it's not hard to understand why, they shared a common goal with the Nazis, you know what I am talking about. They have been under control by others for more than a 1000 of years making very little fuss then suddenly the Jews come and it explodes. I think it's pretty obvious it's not only about religion but it's probably the biggest driving factor.

[@glane3962]

60 years? They have been at it for over 2,000 years

[@jamesb.9155]

No, only since the 7th century BCE.

[@glane3962]

@@jamesb.9155So over 2,000 years like I said.

[@Hamada932]

@@glane39622000 years were Middle Eastern people today it’s European colonialists

[@glane3962]

@@Hamada932 No, it’s not. And Jews are described as WHITE in the Old Testament description. Nice try though.

[@glane3962]

@@Hamada932 You should read the Old Testament description. Goes against what you just said.

[@lizmunoz4816]

Gracias, muy claro y objetivo el documental. Aprendí.

[@Larsbor]

In the time Israel had Sinai and Jerusalem… what was the status with the arabs in the conquered areas (palestinians that are not jews)?

[@Tracertme]

A great video which shows there never really was a Palestine nation more a Nomadic group of people without any government that even the Arab nations ignored and didn’t recognise. Unfortunately with the Hamas influence now there clearly is only one option left and that is to remove Hamas from Palestine as they are war mongering and not Palestinian.

[@user-db3td8xv3m]

Это вы исчезнете💯Фалестина будет свабодная☝🏻🇵🇸ваши тупые фильмы никто не верит!

[@user-db3td8xv3m]

Хамас лучшие воины и сопротивление против лжеизраильских терористов☝🏻🇵🇸

[@user-db3td8xv3m]

ООН конечно провозгласил терористической лжеизраиль, потому что ООН тоже терористы!

[@user-xd6gb6ss6s]

The Jews were given a small piece of land, they were happy about it. And the Arabs were allocated a large part, which was divided between Jordan and Egypt. They did not think about the Arabs of Palestine. The population of Jordan is 80% Palestinian. The Arabs don’t want Jews at all, they have the same position as Hitler

[@electronicpizzaparlor]

Ehhh yeah no. Eastern Europeans with some Semitic ancestry from thousands of years ago who were in Europe for thousands of years decided to travel over seas from eastern Europe and take away the houses and farms from Arabs living there killing many in the process. Netanyahu's real name: Mileikowsky Yair Lapids real name: Giladi Ariel Sharons real name: Arik Scheinerman Yitzhak Rabin: Isaac Rubitzov Yitzhak Shamirs real name: Icchak Jaziernicky Golda Meirs real name: Golda Mabovitch Yigal Allons real name: Peikowitz Shimon Peress real name: Szymon Perski Moshe Sharetts real name: Shertok David Ben-Gurion real name: Grün Zalman Shazars real name: Shneur Zalman Rubashov Jordan has nothing to do with anything, 800 BCE has nothing to do with anything, how small the land is (seems to be getting bigger by the day) has nothing to do with anything. Zionists gaslight themselves and others into thinking they somehow are not in the wrong by leaving out all the massacre's of Arabs and focusing on issues from three thousand years ago, complicating a simple issue with detail after detail of irrelevant facts and dates.

[@ginalombardi2507]

Wow! As genocide rains down on Gaza and the West Bank, you try to tell folks that it was and is the Arabs causing the issue. You still believe the DIsney version of Jews coming to Israel, and history points out that in 1897 the first Zionist conference was held and a basic tenant was go to Israel and get rid of all those Palestine people and take the land.

[@ONIS-RD]

Excelente material para poder entender que este problema no es de haora es antiguo.

[@ABB56.]

Dang those people steal literally everything. The entire world has committed a horrific betrayal to humanity. 😢

[@CrunchyDark]

Free humanity, from religions!

[@zjeee]

Or we could allow people to choose freely what they want to believe. Just a thought.

[@MichaelSharpBLACKDRUMMIKE]

Religion is ignorant.

[@jamesb.9155]

Ok but what about Israel and the people there who seek to live their life according to their religious principles and practices. Do they get a nod or need to get your permission or something? Shalom Aleichem.

[@glane3962]

@@MichaelSharpBLACKDRUMMIKEYou should Arheism. Phew 😮‍💨😅

[@SupriYati-tn5hc]

Israel palestinian conflic its not about religion bro. Wake up

[@tommythecat4961]

Thankfully in the end they talked it out, and today Israel and Palestine live together side by side!

[@Mavetlemehablim]

it is important to note that Palestine is the name of a geographical region, and not the name of a nation or people, the real name of this land is the land of Hnaan, on this land in ancient times there were two Jewish kingdoms, Israel and Judea, there was no Palestine when the Romans conquered this land, in order to punish the Jews, they called this land Palestine. so everyone who lives on this land, including Jews, can call themselves Palestinians, because this is not a nation, these are the names of the land, but those who call themselves Palestinians by nationality are in fact Arabs who migrated to this land from Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, Jordan , all this has been proven historically, and not only, in all the holy books, the Torah, the Koran, the Bible, it is written that the land of Khnaan belongs to the Jews by God’s call, there is not even a mention of the great Palestinians.

[@arndtlange9573]

Beautiful myth… 😂😂😂

[@Mavetlemehablim]

@@arndtlange9573 This is a great myth, the state of Palestine, and the people of Palestine. There is no source in the world and no history about the people of Palestine from before 1956, there is nothing ancient that can testify about the people of Palestine on the land of Canaan. They are Arabs who immigrated from Lebanon, Syria, Egypt, Jordan, Iraq, during the rule of the Ottoman Empire. It's very simple, if you find something about the term Palestinian people from before 1956, write to me about it, it's very interesting to see. 😂😂😂

[@clayton4552022]

And again the 2000 years old story blah blah blah 🤣🤣🤣

[@butterflyeffect4568]

Okay then by your logic nowadays Jews who came in 1948 arent really Jews. Because they also emmigrated before 1948 in Europe mixing with local people. So Palestinians arent native people nor are the nowaday Israelis post 1948. There I solved it for you boo. So you shouldnt be upset because neither of you is native to land. Real Jews from Israel at that time are either in (Tunisa,Algeria, Morocco,Yemen etc.)or countries you named above. And they are still there and they were black or mixed with black. I dont think pale skin can survive in such conditions. Speaking as pale person myself.

[@joskorogosic8188]

this is the answer to the hatred NOT THE COUNTRY BUT HATRED OF MUSLIMS TOWARDS THE JEWS WOVEN THROUGH ISLAM (QURAN)

[@rshs5942]

Actually not the Islam that hate Jews or Muslims do, but god showed in the Koran their features as they betrayed him many times and never obeied him or a Prophet.

[@nancyperezfonseca2371]

Excelente documental, muy bien logrado, comprendí mejor la compleja historia de esta región y sus habitantes. Deseo encuentren por fin La Paz..

[@sonachenab]

Very informative. Thanks.

[@enmn6001]

And full of atrocities

[@freluquetkick]

The Palestinians never wanted to share this territory. 2000 years of wandering for the Jews who finally found a place to live. If the Palestinians had been less selfish, we would not be here today. Les palestiniens n'ont jamais voulu partager ce territoire. 2000 ans d'érance pour les juifs qui retrouvent enfin un endroit pour vivre. Si les palestiniens avaient été moins égoiste, on n'en serait pas là aujourd'hui.

[@BeaconOfHope1948]

Am Israel Chai!

[@annknapp1767]

A jaundiced documentary, if ever there was one.

[@BADDUDE_CORNPOP]

You don't even got to watch this documentary it tells you everything you need to know in the first 2 minutes about whose land it is who took what from who and who pushed who out

[@farsalami8605]

hahaha you are allergic to knowledge my friend... it was... persian/egyptian/roman/ottoman/caliphate/ crusaders and lastly british land .... british divided it... one group became greedy and lost. they became greedy again and lost again.... and again... and again

[@Againstdhawa]

its more complicated than that jews have always lived there in large numbers before islamists conquered middle east that land was all christian and jewish

[@BJ-lg5jx]

In Jordan Palestine caused troubled and driven out, in Lebanon Palestine also bring chaos to Lebanon economy and peace..

[@manueljose5644]

You mean Israel caused ans causes trouble...

[@justiceriser8970]

Yet before isarel return the Palestinians were kind and hospitality people they took them in when most arab countries didn't want

[@richjacobs9736]

There's plenty of land just move somewhere else

[@arkameatys]

you mean "the man with the eye-patch? Not blind-fold?

[@ChagitMalichy-lg5cq]

Watch your tongue you don’t like it.

[@wendyfay16]

If you've already watched the video called 'Israel - Palestine, 60 years of violence' English version - then don't bother with this one as it's the same video.

[@richjacobs9736]

They don't understand it's not their land

[@rosmariegisin4475]

They dont understand not Palästinenst heir Land

[@meshackkirui4951]

I pray for peace in both Palestine and Israel. This is possibility Unfortunately both countries have decided to perish together as fools instead of living together peacefully

[@Eitner100]

Excellent documentary! Especially for those who do not know the history.

[@blackknight3496]

2024 nothings changed

[@levanabenghouzi4887]

Oui parce que l onu continu a appeler et a donner Des droits de refugier apres plusieurs generations de "palestiniens" alors que Les autres population dans le monde ne sont appeles refugies que la generation Des deplaces, et a tout pour que cette population reste dans Des camps et que leur descendants ne puissent s integrer nul part, ils Leur meme eduque la haine du juifs dans Les ecoles de l onu ce qui a declenche Les atrocites du 57 octobre et Les consequence a gaza, d ailleurs personne ne veut ouvrir ses frontieres aux gazaouis comme ils l ont fait aux syriens, aux ukrainiens, aux saoudiens, pourquoi a t on cree un peuple palestiniens qui a Des origine d egyptiens, de syriens de jordaniens et meme de tunisiens, de libiens et autre

[@harrismaher9888]

We never want lethal secular leader like Yasser Arafat...

[@hansolavrkkennordland9534]

Why not?

[@mattikarosenthal3298]

How did he die of aids?

[@tonysnow759]

* On 25 February 1994, which was also the 15th day of Ramadan, Baruch Goldstein, a Zionist extremist from the far-right Kach movement, carried out a massacre in al-Ibrahimi Mosque (the Cave of the Patriarchs) in Hebron. Goldstein entered the sanctuary and opened fire at praying Muslims with an automatic weapon, killing 29 of them and injuring about 150 others. I thought this event was important enough to mention in your documentary

[@Frost-uy9me]

There's no far right problem anywhere. The problem is with Islamists and Islamism.

[@HVS-gk7oo]

Not even fellow arabs and muslims of Jordan or Lebanon wanted the Palestinans? Or Egypt? Good work.

[@user-be2dd1nn5k]

You folks, you mean this battle didn't begin yesterday

[@MrMyfrankland]

*Zechariah 12:1-3(KJV)-The burden of the word of the Lord for Israel, saith the Lord, which stretcheth forth the heavens, and layeth the foundation of the earth, and formeth the spirit of man within him. 2 Behold, I will make Jerusalem a cup of trembling unto all the people round about, when they shall be in the siege both against Judah and against Jerusalem. 3 And in that day will I make Jerusalem(THE SEAT OF ISRAELI GOVERNMENT) a burdensome stone for all people: all that burden themselves with it shall be cut in pieces, though all the people of the earth be gathered together against it. *Jeremiah 16:15(NKJV)-15 but, ‘The Lord lives who brought up the children of Israel from the land of the north and from all the lands where He had driven them.’ For I will bring them back into their land which I gave to their fathers. *Ezekiel 39:28(NKJV)-28 then they shall know that I am the Lord their God, who sent them into captivity among the nations, but also brought them back to their land, and left none of them [a]captive any longer. *Isaiah 66:7-9(NLT)7 “Before the birth pains even begin, Jerusalem gives birth to a son. 8 Who has ever seen anything as strange as this? Who ever heard of such a thing? Has a nation ever been born in a single day Has a country ever come forth in a mere moment? But by the time Jerusalem’s birth pains begin, her children will be born. 9 Would I ever bring this nation to the point of birth and then not deliver it?” asks the Lord. “No! I would never keep this nation from being born,” says your God. *Ezekiel 36:9-11(NKJV)-9 For indeed I am for you, and I will turn to you, and you shall be tilled and sown. 10 I will multiply men upon you, all the house of Israel, all of it; and the cities shall be inhabited and the ruins rebuilt. 11 I will multiply upon you man and beast; and they shall increase and bear young; I will make you inhabited as in former times, and do better for you than at your beginnings. Then you shall know that I am the Lord. *Ezekiel 36:30-36(NKJV)-30 And I will multiply the fruit of your trees and the increase of your fields, so that you need never again bear the reproach of famine among the nations. 31 Then you will remember your evil ways and your deeds that were not good; and you will [a]loathe yourselves in your own sight, for your iniquities and your abominations. 32 Not for your sake do I do this,” says the Lord God, “let it be known to you. Be ashamed and confounded for your own ways, O house of Israel!” 33 ‘Thus says the Lord God: “On the day that I cleanse you from all your iniquities, I will also enable you to dwell in the cities, and the ruins shall be rebuilt. 34 The desolate land shall be tilled instead of lying desolate in the sight of all who pass by. 35 So they will say, ‘This land that was desolate has become like the garden of Eden; and the wasted, desolate, and ruined cities are now fortified and inhabited.’ 36 Then the nations which are left all around you shall know that I, the Lord, have rebuilt the ruined places and planted what was desolate. I, the Lord, have spoken it, and I will do it.”

[@emadledzoghyer3515]

Jesus is Palestinian + zionists changed the Quran to trick ppl. of course they gonna change the Bible and make u believe everything they say

[@peterchelule2405]

Wow!!!!!

[@julielemker2131]

Zechariah 12:9 "And it shall come to pass in that day, that I will seek to destroy all the nations that come against Jerusalem" Deuteronomy 7:6: "For you [Israel] are a people holy to the Lord your God. The Lord your God has chosen you out of all the peoples on the face of the earth to be His people, His treasured possession"

[@AhmetTugrulGUL]

we are all craeted by Allah GOD.

[@julielemker2131]

@@AhmetTugrulGUL John 8:58: "Jesus said to them, ‘Truly, truly, I say to you, before Abraham was, I am.’" John 18:6: "When Jesus said, ‘I am He,’ they drew back and fell to the ground." John 14:6: "Jesus told him, ‘I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one can come to the Father except through Me.’"

[@julielemker2131]

@@AhmetTugrulGULAllah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "The most awful name in Allah's sight on the Day of Resurrection, will be (that of) a man calling himself Malik Al-Amlak (the king of kings). The Resurrection Day, also known as Easter Sunday, is the day Christians celebrate Jesus rising from the dead. This event is seen as a confirmation of Jesus’ divinity and His victory over death. In the context of the Resurrection, Jesus is often referred to as the “firstborn from the dead” (Revelation 1:5), indicating His triumph over death and His role as the first of a new creation of those who, through faith in Him, can look forward to eternal life Why is Allah so scared of Jesus??

[@AhmetTugrulGUL]

@@julielemker2131 2:136] Say, [O believers], “We have believed in Allah and what has been revealed to us and what has been revealed to Abraham and Ishmael and Isaac and Jacob and the Descendants and what was given to Moses and Jesus and what was given to the prophets from their Lord. We make no distinction between any of them, and we are Muslims [in submission] to Him.

[@AhmetTugrulGUL]

@@julielemker2131 2:87] And We did certainly give Moses the Torah and followed up after him with messengers. And We gave Jesus, the son of Mary, clear proofs and supported him with the Pure Spirit. But is it [not] that every time a messenger came to you, [O Children of Israel], with what your souls did not desire, you were arrogant? And a party [of messengers] you denied and another party you killed

[@flyingcoathang86]

Sides is irrelevant now. Too much generational killing which will mean no end to the conflict ever. The problem with us all today is we have been brainwashed to pick a side. Especially us who have not experienced any of it first hand. The only discussion we should be having is intervention. If you pick a side you show your nerviness or ignorance around the reality of war and what it does to the people and most of all the beautiful children. Have you ever asked yourself why there has been no intervention for both peoples sake? Those kind of questions are what we should be asking.

[@lisaschuster686]

Please tell your computer how we all pronounced Rabin and Sharon and Fatah.

[@user-iw6et6gt2z]

You don't use the right terms, and facts. Arabs could have a state, but rejected it! They refused to. Accept Israere l! Many of the Arabs were immigrants from arab countries and not originally palestine. On the Nacba they were told by arab countries to live their homes until they will kill Israelis. But, the jewish didn't die. 800000 jewish were sent from their homes in arab countries. You didnt mention it. You didnt mention the attacks arab countries did. That Egypt controlled gaza, the gaza people are not palestinians. They are Egyptians. Jordan controlled the west bank they were jordanians. Not palestinians. Gaza was slams before, and better with Israrl.

[@johnhaupt1097]

Thank you

[@almabrisiarodriguez-xh2lo]

ISRAEL 🇮🇱 GIVING AID TO THE ENEMY IS NONSENSE PLEASE STOP

[@johnmayibeneme20]

They don't have to, but they are doing it! UAE are at war with Yemen, how much aid have they provided to the people they are fighting? Has famine not caught up with them? Who is speaking for them like you speak for hamas? Are Turks not fighting a section in Syria, has Turks provided aid to them? If Palestinians or Hamas were in Israel's position, would they provide aid to Israel? If Iran were Israeli, and Israel was at their mercy, would they provide aid to enemy Israel? They will not. But Israel is providing aid to the people of Palistian anyway and it is called going the extra mile. If not the way the Palestinians have been radicalised into believing that they will take over Israel someday and to never back out and they grow up with such lies and illussion, from the river to the sea, obviously killing all of jews(genicide) and declaring a state of Palestine, it would have been easier to resolve. But from what I see and what I know about Islamic ideology ( religious) there is no peace. Even if you like sign hundredred of peace accord with Palistian, they will gladly sign it, but that radical Islamic jihadi agenda against Israel must stand because they will break the agreement when the time comes and kill and destroy and the Jews I know will always defend themselves. The more the Palestinians prove to be a dangerous neighbour to be with, the more Israel will be protecting themselves by pushing them inside for their safety because they cannot make discomfort their way of life neither would they evacuate their ancestral land and drown in the sea for the sake of Palestinians. If all these were not attached to religion, myths and lies, we would have peace because there are many situations similar to that of Israel and Palestinians even worse, but because they are not linked to religion and lies, there are no wars. As a matter of fact they coexist together in peace.

[@hamzahaidarr6294]

The story in brief : My grandmother is 90 years old. She is older and older than the State of Israel. The State of Israel is an occupation state. They came to Palestine hungry and afraid, crying because of Hitler. And when we welcomed them with love, they stole our homes, killed our people, and built a state in the place of another people.

[@MrKurmann]

Sounds like the Palestinians into Lebanon.. Yes it is.

[@abctoxyz6293]

Now lela khalid lives in a burqa, has 20 children and cannot interview on camera

[@nhquyen_]

Never believe those muslims who say all religions will live equally in one country :))

[@NatureStatusAK]

This is not real documentary

[@Ack359]

It is a real documentary. It tries to be partial and give both sides, which is what documentaries are supposed to do

[@levteplitsky1385]

@@Ack359 The author forgot role of USSR. Bloody role.

[@Ack359]

@@levteplitsky1385 yes Stalin certainly helped Israel in their early days, and they have never forgotten him for it

[@levteplitsky1385]

@@Ack359 You are right, but honeymoon had ended in September 1948, and after , 40 years straight, USSR had been used every means to annihilate State of Israel.

[@Ack359]

@@levteplitsky1385 doesn’t matter, USA took over to help. There are Jews all over the world to support their homeland. If they are attacked, there is always someone to support them because they were so badly abused in the 1940s

[@dragonquest1991]

Documentaire expéditif. On ne sait pas comment les juifs ont obtenu Israel, en deux second ils se retrouve en pleine guerre avec des avions de chasse, des chars qui ont été créée comme par magie. bref pleins de zones d'ombre qui rendent le doc incompréhensible et ne permet pas de mieux comprendre le sujet.

[@MrMultiescriba]

Great French reporters. Thank you.

[@melianavictoriaperalta7098]

Paz para Palestina 🕊️☮️

[@user-iz2tq3dx5d]

*Israel

[@glane3962]

Tell them to stop supporting Terror then.

[@cantbeu]

Have you watched Avatar?@@glane3962

[@TNL_tez]

🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@Royalking009]

🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@bodomeijer772]

The Extra Land which the Jews did take happend in the War. This is what happens in War,the stronger will Win and take!!!!!!!!

[@Is_mail22]

Something a nazi would say