It's that whistle! Vocal ANALYSIS of Rammstein's "Engel" live performance at Madison Square Garden!

[@314159BC]

Please, if you do another Rammstein song, let it be “Sonne”. The chorus melody is so beautiful, one of the most moving songs from them for me personally.

[@zzwwnikki6129]

Or buckstabu.

[@keldaris8625]

Ohne Dich is probably the most emotional for me personally, but I absolutely love Sonne.

[@314159BC]

@@keldaris8625 I feel that, it’s definitely pretty and somber. They honestly have so many songs that make me feel something deep.

[@scarymsmary]

YES YES YES!

[@maartenvanr9478]

+1 on Sonne. And I would also like you to react to Benzin. Not just for the vocals but for the pyrotechnics too😁

[@mournwood]

"His wings are on fire." It *is* Rammstein after all. If it CAN spew fire, it probably will at some point.

[@HannahRainbow88]

Flame throwers, glitter and foam - Sonisphere... 2010 maybe? 🤔 (I've been to a few festivals so the years have all blurred, but their set will always be engraved on my mind).

[@blued_moon4020]

It‘s Rammstein; they don’t have a show with pyrotechnics in it, they have pyrotechnics with a show in it.

[@kakikutya7912]

i heard an interview about a hungarian pyrotechnic who has done the pyro stuff for really high production movies and has won tons of awards, and she said that the top of her job is being able to do rammsteins live pyrotechnics, she said that everyones dream in that field is to work with those guys because they take on anything and they can get as creative and crazy as they want

[@EddieDean999]

Up to and including Till himself. Back in the day, he sang the first song of the evening engulfed in flames. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i5WsmIt5hpKigqs

[@hajotge12]

@@kakikutya7912 Wow! Here 3 little snippets from my "knowledge": 1. According to Flake they just stumbled into that pyrotechnics thingy because they wanted to get some real attention in a kind of rehearsal. (And I cannot easily find that interview :/) 2. Till has a license as pyrotechnician. Would not be allowed to do such things on stage otherwise. 3. In 2012 Rammstein bought 1/3 of the annual production of China of Lycopodium powder for their shows. (These are just spores of the plant genus "lycopodium" - oh, called "clubmoss" in English - and produce a great effect)

[@hansderuiter1699]

Don't forget: Till is a professional pyrotechnician!!! For real. He knows what he is doing. This why Rammstein uses so much fire and effects. That's why their performance's are so cool. If you listen too the lyrics; it is a complaint to God. It's a dark song.

[@petittrainguernsey3297]

All of Rammstein are qualified.

[@3twelveworkshop312]

Kiss rocks, Rammstein burns!!!

[@capcompass9298]

Cool pyrotechnics.

[@Hair8Metal8Karen]

Didn't he get his certifications after something went wrong with a performance, and he wanted to make sure it didn'thappen again? Then, the rest of the band followed suit.

[@Jinxness]

@@Hair8Metal8Karen Yes that is the story. Part of their staging that was on fire fell into the crowd during an early show. You can find videos of it and of Till going into the crowd to assist while the rest of the band played to keep people from panicking. Allegedly after learning that fans were more seriously injured because the people who responded didn't know how to stop the fire/safely move the fallen element the band decided they wanted control over their special effects going forward.

[@dmen89]

One interesting tidbit of Till Lindeman's accent or pronunciation is that it isn't a local dialect, but an old fashioned theatre dialect designed to be carried across distances in theatres and still be clearly understood. The fact that Till makes it work so wel with his Bass/Bariton vocal range is a very central component to Rammstein's sound and trademark. And this is just a very small part of what Rammstein has to offer in terms of style and range.

[@NavaSDMB]

And he uses it in every language. When I read a review of Rammstein's work where the critic complains about that pronunciation, I know the critic is about as familiar with Rammstein as I am with 16th-century embroidering techniques.

[@TroublesomeOwl]

@@NavaSDMB Maybe that is something you should look into improving about yourself. A deep knowledge of 16th century embroidery can do nothing but improve your life and all around value as a contributor to society

[@nuanil]

@@TroublesomeOwl 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@juhamakela8744]

I’ve always wondered myself how come so strong and far from hoch deutsch but that explains lot. Thanks Btw… I think it was 2001 I found them and Mutter war die alle erste Lied… einfach so unglaublich

[@HeavyMetalGamingHD]

@@NavaSDMB yes his english lindemann stuff goes also in that direction. the 1st album was in english the 2nd was german

[@Phyrrax]

Him being able to sing with those heavy wings at all is so impressive. Til is such a unit of a man.

[@iamaduckquack]

Not to take away from their shows but they do use tracks when performing at times, it isnt a secret. It doesnt matter though as Rammstein is more than just the vocals, its an entire performance.

[@NHR_Music]

@@iamaduckquack Yeah but for Rammstein it is usually only for specific parts live. In this song the only tracks you hear from the vocals are the female vocals and the whistle. So it is still very impressive.

[@iamaduckquack]

@@NHR_Music Very true, I should have been more specific. Thanks

[@jamiefookes1579]

@@iamaduckquack the backing tracks don't have lead vocals

[@jamiefookes1579]

@@NHR_Music the whistle is live, not on backing track

[@scott917]

The keyborad player has a treadmill under him and "walks" 90% of the show. Lots of energy!

[@karkajouautomaton4882]

Because he'd pace and wander into other bandmates otherwise. Not something you want to happen when intricate pyrotechnics are involved.

[@davidvilchez2209]

I think in a recent interview it was said he walks about 25 miles in one show

[@joethesheep4675]

@@karkajouautomaton4882 yeah. Ask James Hetfield about that.

[@rubenandersen1773]

@@davidvilchez2209 Maybe 2.5 miles? Normal walking speed is about 5km/h

[@IgnavumFortuna]

@@rubenandersen1773 Yes. But one show is more than one hour. And the way he is pacing: that's not normal walking speed.

[@Lordoftartaros]

Their concerts are like going to the Metal-Opera. From the vocals, pyrotechnics, to the staging, everything makes up a meaning. I will never forget the first time I saw them live, it was just amazing.

[@Lordoftartaros]

Guys look at the upper msg, this is not the Official The Charismatic Voice, its just a scam. Please report it, lets stop that scam/spam on KZbin.

[@gregorhellmundt9559]

@@Lordoftartaros already gone

[@Lordoftartaros]

@@gregorhellmundt9559 Yep, probably saw my warning and he erase the comment. Thx

[@JCGver]

I wish opera had as many pyro technics as an average Rammstein concert

[@brain8484]

Obviously you have never been to an Opera to make such a silly comment

[@monikabaumann6050]

God I'd love to see Till Lindemann sing opera, because that dude has such an operatic presence on stage. Dude would make such a fantastic operatic villain.

[@TheDerMiku]

Closest thing to it might be from his solo stuff, Lubimiy Gorod: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qZvNnXZ4oLCGjc0 (Just if you didnt know about it) Or "Alle Tage ist kein Sonntag": kzbin.info/www/bejne/mJnamWdqocpmfrs His booming voice paired with more classical instruments is just wonderful.

[@jasonep2]

I'd love to see him as Mephistopheles in Gounod's Faust, or just hear him sing "Le veau d'or."

[@TheDerMiku]

@@jasonep2 Would be awesome.

[@LifeisFoo]

Here is a clip from a musical he was in "Hansel and Gretel." It's my favorite song from Till and it really shows off his skills: wer weiß das schon kzbin.info/www/bejne/iZewg4qkbL51Y9E

[@HanMoP]

" Alle Tage ist kein Sonntag" is classical singing. kzbin.info/www/bejne/nnbZZn6Eap2Voqs

[@Mephiston]

The fun fact about this song is the album it's from, Sensucht. The keyboardist, Flake, often jokes in interviews that it is his favourite album, because its when Till started singing, rather than just speaking the lyrics.

[@jasjfl]

Lol Herzeleid has entered the chat

[@MysteriousFigure]

@@jasjfl Agreed, I would strongly disagree considering Seemann is on herzeleid

[@jasjfl]

@@MysteriousFigure lol I mean Herzeleid the song more than anything

[@Outside85]

I wonder if Till is somehow taking revenge for that, because Flake is also the one they usually set on fire at some point during the show? (I was a show during 2023 and at one point two of them basically got out what looked to be flame throwers and pointed it at one of the three stations Flake was moving between during the concert.)

[@bacardi20]

They have only done one album before Sehnsucht and that’s Herzeleid.

[@brandontankersley8107]

The fact that a number of their official music videos are actually legitimate live performances and not just live footage with the studio recording over it is a testament for just how great these guys are.

[@bennoakes2477]

we aren't discussing top 40 artists who mime

[@SirFooplesTheThird]

I hate to correct you but this isn't an actual "official music video". Just a official live recording put out by the band. There's an a actual music video for Engel on KZbin as well

[@bigsmoke6805]

Erm, their official music videos all have studio versions over them

[@VanillaLibrarian]

Then again, their live performances are largely pre-recorded... I love Rammstein and given all the show elements it makes sense, but they're just about the last band I'd use to make this point, lol.

[@bigsmoke6805]

@@VanillaLibrarian true

[@moviemaniac916]

I remember hearing Engel in high school and was immediately drawn by the whistle. Still one of their best songs.

[@guidingrock7051]

same!

[@Haplo-san]

same.

[@neriah1981]

Same here. Jeez feels so long ago.. Anyway this and Seemann their bests imho.

[@vhaarr]

Same here. However, I don't like that they fake the whistle live.

[@Summon256]

@@vhaarr Because it's not the whistle itself, it's the keyboard sound to emitate the whistle! LOL They were never "singing" it to begin with as it was never intended, the whole "whistling" thing is nothing but an act to go along with it to make it look like they are whistling! If people weren't bunch of idiots and knew a thing or two about keyoboards they would have realized this long time ago!...

[@Pelasomma]

Elizabeth's little giggle of "His wings are on fire!" brilliant

[@joelc6460]

I finally got to see them live this year, probably the coolest/wildest live show ive been to! Their keyboard guy walking on the treadmill the entire show while playing was honestly impressive lmao.

[@VixenIcaza]

Seen them 3 times now and would always choose to see them again if I can afford to. This particular tour is probably my number 2 concert I have ever seen. Number 1 was a video game concert (Distant Worlds) with the composer.

[@phalaszczyk]

Same here. Saw them twice. It is a proper SPECTACLE.

[@sneaky_tiki]

It's been quite a few years since I was able to see them, and it is still probably the best 'performance' I have ever been to. I would say the stage setup was better for us than what is here, they had a large secondary stage in the middle of the pit with a bridge between the two, and they made full use of both. On top of that, it was like a 3 hour performance, with just a brief 10 minute intermission half way through. The stamina required for doing shows like that is incredible and very few modern acts take live performance so seriously. It's extremely impressive.

[@bobobo2224]

When I first saw the treadmill I thought it fit perfectly

[@iananelson8256]

@@sneaky_tiki When I saw them they had that same bridge!

[@Serenity_Dee]

The fiery wings are even more impressive in person. Rammstein is ALL about the pyrotechnics and yeah, the heat is intense.

[@swanky2202]

Absolutely. Felt the heat from 30 meters away!

[@joshuapilger8430]

The first iteration of the wings actually dug into tills back and went so deep, that they almost severed his spine. But he didn't stop the song.

[@argantyr5154]

@@joshuapilger8430 I've read somewhere that the Wings weights around 40kg (around 88 pounds).

[@joshuapilger8430]

I thought it was a bit closer to 100 lbs. Not sure the exact amount. But they are full metal. I believe the wings are aluminum and the structure is steel. But still, the size is massive.

[@juanmejiagomez5514]

Yeah man, fire is weird. I once drove like 10 meters away from a burning car and it felt like there was a campfire right next to me

[@BallisticAero]

Till Lindeman and the group of Rammstein are the truest definition of "musical artists". Not only talented musicians, they are capable of stringing together and painting wonderous stories with the lyrical choices but also the visual performances of the group are second to none. They deserve the red carpet wherever they tour

[@jimmynaylor1759]

When they played the UK, Kerrang magazine rated the show as 6 out of 5 Kerrangs and stated that every gig following this was destroyed. Rammstein are a true force of nature in scope and vision musically and storytelling. Every video is a masterpiece of cinematic glory, every show is mind-blowing. There is no other band like them.

[@notmozart1]

seen them 3 times in the U.K. - Fantastic concerts!!

[@Joliie]

Why I have tickets for both show this year in Denmark, they are so awesome live.

[@thefourthwritedjentleman3643]

Honestly, your genuine passion and enthusiasm is contagious And what a song and performance, simply blown away

[@KingArthas]

"When the clouds go to sleep, you can see us in the sky. We are afraid and alone. God knows I don't want to be an angel!" Such a dark song with such a beautiful melody! Rammstein are timeless!

[@emptyemptiness8372]

I had to stop for a minute after reading your posted lyrics, the existential angst those lyrics made arise were almost overwhelming, what a terrifying existence of angel they describe. Fantastic. Thank you.

[@sonea9444]

​@@emptyemptiness8372 broken english but: they live behind the sunshine separated from us - infinetly far they have to cling to stars (very tight) so they do not fall from the sky gives the chorus extra sadness

[@shannenredman9191]

Yes, the whistle was what got me hooked on this song. This is one of those songs I can play on repeat and never get tired of it.

[@sjoormen1]

true, this one, spring and spieluhr, for me.

[@unnamellie]

@@sjoormen1 yes!! I love Spring. Yes, it's kinda gruesome but I love chorus and the musical theme

[@SamielAC]

I'm pretty sure the whistle is pre-recorder for the live shows, too clean and perfect.

[@sonea9444]

​@@SamielACactually no. He whistles live

[@SamielAC]

@@sonea9444 nop prerecorded

[@scotthughes2687]

My god, I’ve never watched this live performance before. 16 years ago I was going through a divorce and listened to the studio version of this song over and over. The line “Wir haben angst und sind allein” really resonated with how lonely and depressed I felt. Watching Till’s face fall and then the angel turning and slowly walking away just brought back for a moment the sensation of being in the darkness of mid to late 2006 of my life. What an unbelievable performance. I loved it, but I don’t know if I can ever handle watching that again.

[@4t0m5k]

Ride the wave of the guitars, good man. You're not rocking this alone.

[@AmandaMcCarterWrites]

Till studied with an opera singer in Berlin to prepare for this tour. He had to hold a chair over his head and sing to develop the core strength to wear the wings and sing. He also said he hated it because it was such a long drive into the city every week.

[@sentatyn5207]

Thanks for this very interesting info!!!

[@mattdreizehn]

The reason why Rammstein is my favorite band is simple: they are unique. It's not only about their music, all their productions, in all aspects, are masterpieces. Their concerts are a whole experience and the last one in Mexico City, from the Stadium World Tour, just blew my mind. 🤘🖤🔥

[@tylerhaunted]

On top of how good these guys are, they have been all together since the beginning. No new or replaced band mates.

[@sapperlex]

and they formed only 4 years after the wall came down.

[@annegretkasten6277]

@@sapperlex But they knew each other very well before.

[@sapperlex]

@@annegretkasten6277 yes but after 30+ years...most bands cant make it 3-4 after becoming popular.

[@vitaemecha]

Hands down the best band I have ever seen live. I saw them 17 years ago at the Volkerball tour in Newcastle England and I was lucky enough to be photographed with my pregnant partner at the time which ended up on the DVD. Yes my now 17 year old Daughter's first gig was Rammstein ;)

[@dws84]

Me too, I’ve seen and been to more concerts I can count, and Rammstein are EASILY, the best band I’ve seen live.

[@TCookk]

that's so sick to hear!! Best parents!

[@MichelleBln]

I’m going to see them in July in Berlin. Also 4 months pregnant right now.

[@Kay_The_Coffee_Weirdo]

I think something you're missing is that those wings are super heavy because they're made of steel; which would account for a lot of the distrotion in his voice. I'm honestly surprised that he can keep a consistent sound with all that tension he needs to keep in his core. There's a video somewhere of him backstage before he comes out onstage with these wings, and he's yelling at the band to hurry up and start because the wings are so heavy.

[@ECopas]

Lindeman is beyond committed to the theatrics of his video performances.. like drilling a hole in his cheek to get the mouth light effect in “Ich tu der Weh”

[@happydude2163]

And his posture too :-)

[@goodstorylover]

Interesting point

[@Jelle1880]

I think they once said the suit alone weighs like 50k, which is mental.

[@i_can_c_u_2295]

@@ECopas and „ Rammlied“

[@MrGrimsmith]

I think this is the best representation of the "Angel" concept I've ever heard or seen. They have no free will, they are simply the tools of a greater being. Mechanical isn't far off. Obviously, it's Till so it's dialed up to 11. The guitar parts make so much of the music but Flake is *always* there, making sure there aren't any gaps. It's not a common thing for him to step forward that much but it's always wonderful to see and hear :)

[@ardithwagley6257]

Till is also moving like Frankenstein's monster in the 1931 movie starring Boris Karloff. They used weighted boots for that effect. The boots also allowed him to lean forward as Till does in this video. Super cool and so referential

[@Strampunch]

I didn't know that! I have to wonder if that also helps him not fall backwards with the weight of the wings, but the Frankenstein creature effect when he walks is an added bonus. Thank you for sharing this bit of information!

[@Rabgiliszta]

Flake has a major part in creating the ambience of the songs with his electronic effects and instruments. He creates an entire tapestry of sounds that you just realize how masterful is, after the 10th listening.

[@AndreasMarr-ix4ig]

He is a real goat in the background

[@lazyidiotofthemonth]

The Keyboardist for Rammstein was originally a classically trained Pianist, whose career path basically disappeared when East Germany ceased to exist. So he became the Keyboardist for Rammstein, which is why Rammstein has always had a very classical sound in their synth.

[@salusasec]

Flake ist ein spannender Typ, aber ein klassischer Pianist war er nicht

[@annegretkasten6277]

Flake played in Feeling B. The classical element comes from the Dresden Symphony Orchestra

[@redringaming3017]

Till is a beast, those wings weigh 50 kilograms. Edit: The reason he looks so focussed is because Till has terrible stage fright. He copes with this by playing the character we see on stage.

[@jurcooijmans9844]

I heard that was also a big reason why they have so many pyro and effects. He said he felt 'awkward' on stage, especially during the parts where he's not singing. So he just wanted to 'have something to do' instead of standing around.

[@chuckmawson7273]

He's a hell of a showman for someone with stage fright! wow

[@danilutka]

​@chuckmawson7273 it makes sense in a way. So many great actors and musicians are really introverted in real life. Think of it like the great comedians who are really depressed behind the scenes.

[@jakeetschannel2031]

The whistle has always been there!😎 Not just apart of the show 🔥

[@VioletPhoenixDude]

The pyrotechnics are Till's design. He is a qualified pyrotechnic technician (not sure of the term.) Just another thing to be in awe about Till's abilities. He always reaches out of his comfort zone to these performances. He's the bee's knees. I f*ckin adore his voice.

[@benjaminjohnson6453]

All six members of the band are certified pyrotechnicians now. But at the time of this concert, I am not sure if that was the case. Their US tour this year was phenomenal!

[@TheTorgator]

And probably the only reason they are legally allowed to do those crazy things on Stage. 😂

[@TheTorgator]

And probably the only reason they get insurance for their shows 😂

[@Nr4747]

I think it's just called pyrotechnician. And it isn't just Till anymore, all band members had to get some pyrotechnician qualifications over the years, although you are correct that it started with Till because he used to handle most of the pyrotechnics in the early years.

[@Deadmonson]

Yes! Till became a pyro tech due to an incident at one of their shows early on, where a support beam holding a pyro effect fell and caused a few injuries. Most notable, however, was how he handled the incident - the band kept playing and he personally moved the fallen piece, regardless of the risk to himself. That’s not acting, that’s being an awesome human. After this incident he was inspired to ensure nothing like that would ever happen again, and took it upon himself to become licensed in pyro. From the looks of their current stage… that effort has more than paid off. You can find the video I’m referring to on KZbin, and also some interviews about the incident around the web. Fascinating stuff.

[@MrMetrostroy]

OMG, your emotional reactions are so beautiful! So sincere and immersed in music, you just lovely!❤‍🔥

[@SoiledWig]

Not only was Christian Lorenz (keyboards) dancing a bit during the instrumental break, but he's walking on a treadmill the entire show.

[@TheLawnStripes]

And walks to the beat. If that isn't hard-core flexing your talent I don't know what is

[@ironmuzz]

The treadmill is linked to a generator and he's powering the whole arena with it 😜

[@TheLawnStripes]

@@ironmuzz 🤣

[@HeavyMetalGamingHD]

He talks in his biography (have no clue if there is a english translation for that book out there), that he simply loves walking. he has loved it throughout his whole live. he was even walking around a lot throughout his whole childhood. He explored the GDR (german democratic republic) on foot. he even got into trouble for it once. And now with rammstein he goes for long walks at every city they travel to. completely alone. sometimes for hours. He just loves to do that. this is his life. If you are able to speak german you should listen to his two audio books, because he is reading it by himself with his berlin dialect. He's such a likeable guy. Even his name Flake is cool. This comes from a German children book/animated TV show about a little viking boy, called wickie und die starken männer. Flake is the name of the village they live in.

[@BlueBerry-BerryBlue]

He never skips leglife.

[@issahime]

Being in the audience when those wings go off is beyond amazing. If you ever get the chance to see Rammstein in concert, do it! I got to see them in Tacoma with my husband, and it was the best concert I have ever been to.

[@bennoakes2477]

also, being there for the music isn't bad either. The gimmicks are only part of the show.

[@rexrogers1859]

@@bennoakes2477 Oh really???? Wow! Thanks, or we'd have never figured that one out!!!

[@paulwalsh2344]

@ 27:50 Till doesn't look alone... he looks dead inside... like an angel in heaven... for ETERNITY... as cold and full of sorrow as a stone statue of an angel.

[@Done9to5]

Well sad

[@Pirustae]

That's what Christians imagine angels

[@matthewschweitzer1690]

Whistle by itself is the start of the song, not just added in for this performance - it's amazing!

[@johan6983]

I think she meant the "Ameica" whisper/singing underneath. If I hear correct it is a sample from another Rammstein song. They often use outro/intro's during liveshows

[@antediluvianer]

I can proudly say I was in that audience in NYC and I kid you not those flames when they go you can feel the scorching heat dozens of metres away. I can only wonder how Richard and Paul have felt throughout the song and rest of the concert. Given MSG is indoor, the heat stays and it did despite ventilation throughout the entire concert

[@TwiggyHetfield27]

I went to the IZOD show a few months after the MSG one. The person we got the tickets from double booked them & got us seats a whole section closer to the stage. I could see Richard's face without my glasses. The heat from those flames thoughout that show was insane! It's like Richard & Paul were without a care in the world. The smiles plastered on their faces for that show said it all. It's like they ignored the heat & focused solely on the music & their fans. It was perfection.

[@bigh1708]

I saw them in 2001, big day out. The heat from the flame throwers was insane

[@ItsLimitable]

I went to the one in San Antonio this year and since it was closed off let me tell you the heat was felt. You sweat instantly and your body just feels warm off the first flame they release. Ventilation does its job but they use it so often it can't keep up for a while but you feel safe enough.

[@edwardmunoz7853]

Fkn Awesome 🤘

[@edwardmunoz7853]

@@ItsLimitable I bought Tix when they went on sale the 1st time then COVID-19 hit and fucked everything up and I wanted to go to that show 🤬😭

[@robertmccutchan5450]

I've been to a few of their concerts.....you can feel the heat from the fire balls across the stadium. They are truly great performers!!

[@Pabloghghgh]

Rammstein live is just unmatched. By far the greatest show I have ever attended to on the metal spectrum.

[@Gaius__]

Yes, they are in a league of their own when it comes to a spectacle during a live show. Even people who are not into that genre of music usually love the show.

[@lululu6102]

Rammstein are such legendary and talented guys

[@lululu6102]

maybe check out "Zeit", lyrical masterpiece.

[@SuneTheMairn]

I love that he almost looks like Atlas, carrying the world on his back like a burdon, but its an angel who does want to carry his wings... Brilliant

[@RustyDust101]

First off: thank you for the vocal analysis of the song and their techniques. This goes so far beyond my minimal understanding and it broadens my acknowldgement of their skills and talents even more. Thank you so much for that. The intro to the Maddison Square Garden videos always includes the whistle as part of the "Amerika Tour" intro. The whistle is part of the song "Engel". It is also one of their iconic trademarks most easily recognizable as a Rammstein song. I am not certain if the whistle is actually performed live on stage, or if it is playback. As whistling on tone on demand is such an incredibly difficult feat. Often whistles start off-key by a tiny bit until the exact pitch is hit by the whistler. Whistles change pitch quite a lot with so many different sets of affecting factors, such as air humidity, air pressure, humidity of the lips of the whistler, exhaustion, smoke, etc. But that doesn't detract from the performance in either case for me. Should they actually whistle live on stage then even more respect for them. That would be awesome beyond all belief, especially if Richard Z Kruspe and Paul Landers whistle in duet. The wings Till carries for that performance weigh around 50 kgs, so roughly 110 lbs, showing off what a beast Till is, even at his current age of 59 (in 2022). Now imagine carrying that, belted to your chest and belly with a harness cutting off full, deep breathing, and having to try to sing with it while remaining upright after nearly two hours of show. Hehe, that you picked up on the posture as a characterization of the angel is funny. It probably has less to do with Till's characterization of the angel, but rather the insane weight dragging his whole body backwards from the shoulders. He probably has to lean forward quite a bit to retain his equilibrium vs the insane leverage those wings apply to his whole body. So looking down, and pulling the microphone to him was probably a necessity and not really intentional as depicting the angel. 😁😁 But then again, this is Rammstein we are talking about. It could have been completely intentional, and I am spouting total bollocks here. We'll probably never know for certain. When it comes to the Rammstein lyrics nearly all their songs that aren't predominantly fun contain very deep, problematic, philosophical aspects. Their tendency to twist them into multiple meanings by using the German language is exemplary. Homophones and double meanings are stacked in such a way that neither interpretation is off the table, often until the very end of a stanza. Even then the potential double meanings (not necessarily double entendres as is meant in the English language) still allow for multiple interpretations. That's what is so amazing about Rammstein. You can most often discuss their songs and interpretations for hours without coming to a final true result. None, a few, or even all interpretations could be true at the same time. Fascinating talent there. Even Rammstein themself rarely if ever comment on the meaning of their songs. They smile and remain mute about it, increasing the mystery even more. The front line band members are often covered in a flame- and heat-retardant fluid or gel so they can survive all the flaming shenanigans on stage without major burns. If you haven't seen it yet, you might want to check out "Asche zu Asche" or "Feuer Frei!" for some of their insane pyrotechnical effects they themselves perform. All of the band members are registered owners of a minor pyrotechnics license, Till even has a major pyrotechnics license under the German law. "Engel", in comparison, is still fairly tame when it comes to their pyro effects. Not that those angel wings aren't spectacular, not in the least, but they pale in comparison to the sea of flames that is the stage for some songs.

[@ravenlockhart0925]

The whistle is indeed done live. You can see it done by the guitarist after the first chorus. If you listen closely, you can even hear him almost overblow once or twice as he puts out a little too much air, but immediately catches it

[@Voltage93]

It´s impressive how calm Till is. Carrying 50kgs on the back. Such a beast...Till and the wings:)

[@johnbranham9941]

I've always admired the German language, it's grit and gruffness Rammstein's mixture of the language and metal is brilliant. I've no ideal what the singing is about but it's awesome!

[@geraldinelafayette1838]

I know What you mean. It makes Hitler’s speeches sound so profound despite him being a total maniacal nut job.

[@sw1ck]

Saw them earlier this year in LA and it was easily one of best shows I’ve ever seen. The sheer spectacle was awe inspiring and the performance was masterful

[@EMPER0RC0W]

I highly recommend trying their song "Ohne Dich " it really shows Till's range well.

[@StephenChepp]

I was going to suggest this too.

[@monotonebooster3229]

Yes! Do this song :) \m/

[@andremarco2413]

My favorite song. I don't understand the lyrics, but it's as if it hits me different emotionally. I get emotional as if I catch some message and it really touches me

[@Adidas_der_schwanger_war]

@@andremarco2413 I think when you watch the music video you don't really have to understand the lyrics

[@andremarco2413]

@@Adidas_der_schwanger_war yes, it's self explanatory. But even when I had only heard the song

[@morrisonneale2169]

Seen Rammstein live 3 times they are definitely one of the best live acts you’ll ever see. I hope you get to go sometime. I love how much joy you get from these videos.

[@LucidGamer727]

He is a certified pyrotechnic. I saw them live in Philly this year. So many flames! I was in the pit. Hands down best concert I’ve been to.

[@DjuraCurcic]

It is sooo charming when you try to imagine how it feels being in audience on their concert. The thing is: you're not even close 😄 There is nothing from your experience that you can compare to this. The heat from the pyro is so intense, that you can feel it burning your skin 10 or 20 meters away from stage. And that smell of burning kerosine is something that you can't have on video. Love your reaction videos, btw. Keep them coming 🥰

[@JMan9191991]

If you ever get the chance, definitely see them live. I saw them this past September in San Antonio and it was absolutely incredible. My brother and I brought my 57 year old dad with us to see them and he said it was the best concert he's ever seen. This is after he's seen Black Sabbath, Dio, Guns N Roses, Metallica, Motley Crüe and many others.

[@Lethallencosplay]

I don’t know when they started doing it, but now live during the last chorus Till gets lifted into the air by his wings… fire and all 😌 if you ever have the opportunity to see them live, they are worth every. Single. Penny. It’s more than just seeing an amazing band live. It’s an entire experience that you never forget. Edit: sounds like they're not doing this anymore, this was back in 2017. I should have clarified!

[@bl_2410]

Saw them in Chicago this year. That was 3 months ago, and I’m still in the afterglow. It was a bucket list event for me, and it blew every expectation I had out of the water. If you’re remotely interested in them, it’s worth it.

[@crayx48]

I think that might be new. At the concert I visited in July, they did the acoustic version of Engel. Looking forward to the 2023 shows in Munich :)

[@Lethallencosplay]

@@crayx48 this was back in 2017, I think, when I saw them and they lifted Till during Engel, but it makes sense that they would switch things up with tours!

[@ylianasynnvesandvoldmeland5203]

Wait... He's doing the wings again!?

[@Tati3543]

I agree wholeheartedly

[@goodstorylover]

50+ lady here, approached Rammstein with caution on suggestion from my daughters to listen to them, after hearing Engel here I am, having already enjoyed their concert live.

[@Andy_from_de]

never too late to join the "Armee der Tristen". 🙂

[@goodstorylover]

@@Andy_from_de I had problem with their lyrics tho, at first, there was too much violence etc., but then I have seen a documentary about them and see it in a different way now.

[@charleswayne7221]

Your so in tune with not only the musical event but with yourself and the expression of what your seeing and hearing.. It's fascinating. And so raw. Just amazing!

[@TheSilentScreamX]

Rammstein & Nightwish are the two best live shows I've been to. They're the two bands I go out of my way to see every time they're playing within driving distance.

[@De-M-oN]

Manowar is incredible live too (but you really need to be live there. On video its not the same, especially with manowar)

[@nightmusic8]

Now that’s a costume for parties. A great song, fantastic decor, awesome performance.

[@d0nnerknispel64]

but not indoors :D

[@arnepietruszewski9255]

Yeah but will have huge problems to get through any doors.😁

[@LJHacki]

And not for so long. Its about 50 kiligramms or round about 110 pounds. :D

[@nightmusic8]

@@LJHacki even 1 minute at a party with this costume will make a lasting impression on anyone present. It’s near unimaginable this is only a song on their playlist, they play so many songs each concert each with the same intensity and dedication. Applaud them is all I can do .

[@zuxiloman1638]

I'm so amazed to hear that you loved "mein hertz brennt" it's one of my favourites and you should definetly do more from rammstein.They're musical geniuses and should be treated as such

[@maleboglia1775]

Many people dont like Rammstein because they are shocked by the first looks and sounds, but everybody who digs only a little bit deeper into this dark rabbit hole just loves 'em!

[@jiM.I.O]

the deeper i dive in i realize i never gonna spend money for this. but thats the great thing about music tastes😋

[@De-M-oN]

@@jiM.I.O your music taste is weird then hehe. Maybe you would like the studio versions more

[@jiM.I.O]

@@De-M-oN First i already saw them at Highfield festival and the sound was total shit and you know i just couldnt care less for the show I love a good concert and there are so many other artists who create better music in my opinion and they only want half of the price 🤷‍♂

[@De-M-oN]

@@jiM.I.O I can imagine that they sound better on their own shows. Festival is not always the best choice tbh. I never saw Rammstein live though, because getting a ticket for them is as difficult as playing lotto xD

[@jiM.I.O]

@@De-M-oN Thats the thing as a good band you should always be able to sound good in my opinion and i dont take the risk pay for their own shows especially when the music isnt giving me as much as other Bands do For you as a fan thats sad of course. i hope you can manage to attend a show in the future

[@jdETH1989]

“God knows I don’t want to be an angel.” Those words have always spoken to me, and this might be the Rammstein song that resonates with me the most. Been a huge fan since I was 14, and this, Mein Hertz Brennt, Adios, and Spieluhr were probably the tracks I was most obsessed with.

[@keldaris8625]

Spieluhr is legit one of my favorite songs of all time.

[@fabioqueiros9322]

@@keldaris8625 mine too! It’s so underrated… I saw an article on Metal Hammer that had it as the worse song in “Mutter” (to be fair, they framed it as not being as good as the others, not the song was bad itself), can you believe that??

[@fabioqueiros9322]

@@keldaris8625 mine too! It’s so underrated… I saw an article on Metal Hammer that had it as the worse song in “Mutter” (to be fair, they framed it as not being as good as the others, not the song was bad itself), can you believe that??

[@climber950]

Hey Jerry, how do you like their newest album? Zeit really hits me hard, especially the music video. As a paramedic I’ve seen a lot of death. Like a ton. The video hit me like a ton of bricks when I watched with the English subtitles.

[@johnnywalker472]

...es wird verscharrt im Nassen Sand, mit einer Spieluhr in der Hand.

[@Zeevina]

Engel always gives me goosebumps. LOVE LOVE LOVE this song

[@SebastianBohn]

Rammstein is really one of the best matches for you. Till's voice offers so much for your deep professional analysis, their stage acting pleases your roleplay soul and the little 13 year Elizabeth loves fireworks and giggles. So much fun to view. 😊

[@jovana_r]

I think you would really be amazed and also have even much more to talk about if you watch "Ich tu dir weh" from the same show. Rammstein is unique band, for their performances, music, lyrics... I guess, they are unique in every aspect. And I really think that Till will surprise you more and more, if you continue to explore their music. Love your reactions and can't wait for more Rammstein. 🖤

[@ileana8360]

I know that the live performance is very effectiv, but if reacting to "Ich tu dir weh", I would recommend the music video for better understanding due to the fact that Rammstein allways plays with the lyrics and often a word or phrase has double or even tripple meanning.

[@jovana_r]

@@ileana8360 Elizabeth always has the lyrics in front of her, no matter if the video has them. So I still suggest the live version, because, seeing how much she liked "Engel" performance, I am sure that she would like this one even more. Music video is not that much entertaning.

[@ileana8360]

@@jovana_r I am aware that she always checks the lyrics and that the live performace is more entertaining. I was reffering to the moment in the music video where he is looking in the mirror. You will not get this twist easily by just reading the words. Or what do you think?

[@LeeKennison]

Hi ​Jovana, once I saw that Elizabeth was doing Rammstein I though of you and hoped you would see it. 😀

[@jovana_r]

@@ileana8360 I agree, but I think that the whole experience will be much more effective if she reacts to the live version. She is aware of twists and double meanings of Rammstein songs. And even if she misses it on first listening, people will tell her. But that's just my opinion.

[@sarahclement4279]

This is my favorite Rammstein song. Possibly my favorite song by any band. It was a joy to watch you analyze and appreciate it.

[@the1khronohs40]

Rammstein = Powerful Art ❤️ If you get a chance to see them live, DO IT!!! You’ll never, ever regret it! 😱🥰

[@usmc249]

Agreed. I have always known who they were, recently saw them in San Antonio and now I’m hooked.

[@justineglickman]

I saw them back in '99. I was not ready 😂 I was front and center and got thoroughly soaked during buck dich. But I've been to every tour since!!

[@AnthonyRidley2011]

Now that you’ve dived into Rammstein live, I cannot recommend highly enough Ohne Dich from Live In Paris - Till’s performance is deeply moving, and the song itself is a beautiful love song about being away from the ones you love. On top of that, there’s no pyro so you can really see how much the band play off each other

[@The_Seal77]

Ohne Dich the video is such a tear jerker, just thinking about it brings me to tears

[@asbjorgkjerstin742]

Ochne Dich was the first Rammstein song I ever heard and I was an instant fan. I've seen them live twice and they are incredible.

[@Modlendingen]

Ohne Dich is just a beutyful masterpiece :)

[@peterdixon7734]

I prefer Ohne Dich at Nimes for the audience meltdown.

[@Drexos17]

Live in Paris and MSG are some of the best live performances captured. only thing better is seeing it live

[@charleswayne7221]

I know it been a year since this review. But everytime I see you I'm overwhelmed by your passion for all musical things!! I absolutely love your take on this and all of your musical reviews.. You just get it on such a deeper level.. It's why I keep coming back!!

[@Gregc63]

Been listening to Rammstein ever since Sehnsucht was released, still one of my favorite albums! That whole album is amazing, and I have been a huge fan ever since! Engel is still on many of my playlists! I've seen several live performances of this song and the MSG performance is hands down, one of the best. If you get a chance, watch that entire concert, nothing short of amazing! We were going to try and see them, but they never came close enough to us to be able to make it happen. Glad you were finally introduced to and started analyzing their music! Love the channel!

[@jameskerr1154]

Till is amazing, guys almost 60 now, and still killing it. I first saw them over 20 years ago, one of the craziest and most memorable shows I've ever seen, and looks like they've pushed it even higher. Hopefully they tour in my part of the world again and I can catch another show.

[@Patrick-857]

I saw them several years ago at Big Day Out in Auckland New Zealand headlining with Tool. I've seen Tool times and am a huge fan, but these guys stole the show, hands down best thing I've ever seen.

[@1959Edsel]

It's fun seeing someone get super excited about the music like you do here.

[@angc214]

I saw Rammstein live in Chicago back in September. It was truly a life altering experience for me. When they did Engel, they took a break for a few minutes to go to the B stage in the middle of the audience. They did a piano version of Engel. After they finished singing, they boarded inflatable boats and had the crowd move the boats to the main stage.

[@AbbyBane.]

We were there too, and agree it was life altering

[@benjaminjohnson6453]

Saw them in Foxborough and I agree. Absolutely incredible and life-altering.

[@m1k8g3]

We were at that show and by far the best live performance I’ve been to.

[@oldcarguy9827]

I was there too. AWESOME show.

[@cyrillavoie3689]

Did the same thing in Minneapolis.

[@shaneross9240]

It's so amazing to see how at 20:27 how far he's leaning forward, and knowing with the wings expanded any leaning left or right will throw him immediately off in that direction, with the line of the wings above his head, to maintain normal balance and then singing on top of that core pressure.

[@Bob5mith]

Not to mention that he'll barbecue his guitarists if he leans too far to one side.

[@zanthejansenvanrensburg3359]

Love this song and the incredible performance by Rammstein. The angel/burning wings can also be found in the ‘Deutschland’ MV

[@bassmasta9117]

I just saw Rammstein live at the Philadelphia Eagles stadium and it was the most epic show I've ever seen😭😭giant crowd, pyromancy, and Rammstein music blasting. It was hypnotizing.

[@neonviking2229]

I was there too! Such a great show!

[@terrymartin5839]

I was at the Met-Life show on the same tour back in September. Easily in my top 3 favorite shows, if not at the very top. Weather was shit so crowd was kind of thin but holy hell they played their asses off.

[@ChrisCanada-Smith]

I was there as well! Absolutely amazing show!!!

[@the_zugaroth]

The feuerzone in Philadelphia was the best! I was even underneath two of three of the boats! Having one of the fire spouts directly in front of you sucks the air right out of your lungs

[@ChrisCanada-Smith]

@@the_zugaroth We were a little further back, about 50' from the stage in the center, just a bit in front of the towers. Got a great view of Engel, though! It was crazy when those towers went off, I damn near got a sunburn!

[@tomfiend86]

Really looking forward to this! Have been hoping to see you analyse Zeit but this will definitely tide me over 😁

[@Andy_from_de]

yes, the songs from Zeit also should be done at some time, but it was really high time that Elizabeth got to see a live performance. Will take a while before we see official recent live performances.

[@Youtubite15]

Zeit, Adieu, or Angst would be EPIC!!!

[@carlkolthoff5402]

Zeit would be great pick, as it shows a bit of a different side of Rammstein and Tills vocals. Definitely prefer the music video version over live performance on that particular song.

[@Youtubite15]

@@carlkolthoff5402 The music video is exceptional.

[@tomfiend86]

@@carlkolthoff5402 oh absolutely. The song accompanied by the video guts me every time

[@mellamoelcaballo]

This is still hands down the greatest live show ever. I saw rammstein in san antonio in 2012, and this song was part of the encore and i still get chills when i think about it!!! Thanks for helping me relive this!

[@BeerElf66]

I saw them in the UK in the summer, they did an acoustic version of Engel, with the lyrics projected to sing. along. Total goosebumps

[@wubbazugg6327]

I flew down to LA from Seattle for their show back in September of this year, and I gotta say, they're legitimately the most intense performers I've ever seen. And there was even more fire than there was during this performance.

[@0waverunner0]

wish i could have made it down to TX for that show....

[@gracezecchel2123]

Ladies and Gentlemen, this is Rammstein. The most incredible live band of the world. ❤️ I have seen them last july, it was the best concert of my life. And seen them in june 2024 here in Europe! I can't wait!

[@johnfrank9060]

Their return to America and Madison Square Garden being the first venue was an incredible concert that I will never forget being there for.

[@gauchesymbiote1039]

Rammstein is simply the best live band ever. They put 1000% into every single performance. If you ever get the chance, see them live, do it. It's not just a concert, It's an experience. I can't wait to see you do more Rammstein.

[@christianokolski9701]

I love how much enthusiasm and enjoyment you bring to these videos! You clearly love music and performance.

[@jakersrule7267]

I saw them live in September. They were so amazing. The heat was intense and the show was incredible. I've been to plenty of concerts so far, but it has been hard to beat Rammstein. If you have the chance to see them live, please do! Also, check out the song Sonne

[@anthicorfu]

Some years ago I was part of an audience in the firezone as they call it and... It was AWESOME! We could feel the fire in our face! Great band, great songs, great performance. Getting better and better as years go by!

[@sinrenfield]

Rammstein is in the top of the many bands Ive seen live. They are worth every penny!

[@DavidHeinz-kq9ym]

if you ever get a chance to see them, do not hesitate. The best live performance I've ever seen.

[@HeavyMetalGamingHD]

you can't afford to hesitate for even a second, because it doesn't take much longer for them to even sell out big stadium shows. Rammstein are in their own way bigger than most of germany's music scene combined.

[@bjhellstream]

This performance of Till is quite breathy and I have always believed that it's because he really is out of breath because of the pressure from the wings. Works well anyway. When I saw this live for the first time it was just mindblowing. Such a good song and that show is just amazing.

[@bradtaylor1766]

Over the years I have been to well over 700 concerts from Alice Cooper to Jazz to Philharmonic Orchestras to ZZ Top to Zakk Wylde and this is one my top performances, arrangement-choreography-musical (+Vocal) talent. Gives me goosebumps ... 💪

[@boblethbridge6292]

After "Du Hast" in Paris, the wings are just cute... I REALLY enjoy your growing depth of analysis of Til's vocalisations; he's a bit of an enigma for most of us...

[@goth8012]

I got to see them years ago, managed to get on barricade for the show. The flames and heat were so intense my forehead was literally peeling the next day. I've been to hundreds of shows and Rammstein is top 3, hands down. However, if you are interested in seeing just how intense their pyro can get, I would recommend a live version of Feuer Frei. That song has, without a doubt, the most impressive pyro moment in the history of pyro. Plus the song itself is just good fun, Til's vocals are much more animated then in others.

[@juanramirez67846]

I remember seeing them in 1999 and the flames were so hot, you could feel them at the center of the GA floor. I can only imagine how hot it was in front.

[@infospy]

Live Aus Berlin's rendition of Klavier gives me chills. And yes, if it can have fire, it WILL have fire. Rammstein live performances are legendary!

[@capp00]

I love Engel! Top 2 Rammstein song. And this MSG concert is so fantastic. Which I could have seen it live. OH, and the Steel Angel Wings weigh in at around 110lbs (50kg). And yes, seeing all the pyrotechnics live is just amazing. Best live show I've ever seen.

[@joshhencik1849]

This was always one of my favorite songs by them. It was heavy but also haunting.

[@lesliemadariaga8207]

Every concert the do is a so good performance with fire, and special effects on it … my dream is going one day ! ❤

[@mavericktheace]

Their live show is amazing. I had the pleasure of hanging out with these gentlemen backstage in Edmonton a number of years ago. It was a great time :)

[@tsch23]

Till Lindemann has an incredible range of skills. I think he would be a good actor too. If you would like to hear how he sounds in French chanson, I would like to recommend the song "Le jardin des larmes" that he recorded in a duet with the French singer ZAZ. Greetings from Germany, der Badener

[@ileana8360]

Absolutely. This would be another incredible side of Tills ability to portray duality by acting and singing

[@djooennepen]

I thought I've read about Till playing 'the bad guy' in some German kids-movies.

[@Severy]

Reacting KZbinr: The wings are on fire! Till: They could be more on fire!

[@DierdreWolf]

I was at their Boston concert this past Sept -- and the live rendition of Engel was the most beautiful thing I have ever heard. I love the song but they turned it into like a audience-sing-along version and it was one of the best experiences I've ever had at a concert.

[@paranoidrodent]

I was at the Montreal show that opened the North American leg of their tour in late August and yeah, Engel live is just phenomenal.

[@Scortor]

I was at the Gillette show too!! In the Fueurzone! It was my first time seeing them live, and holy shit was it amazing!

[@danesorensen1775]

Yes! Engel is one my favourites, especially the one with Liv Kristine as guest vocalist. Her tones were truly angelic and brought the whole song to fruition ❤

[@Aellae0122]

This was looking if i was the only 1. Never see anyone react to the Berlin version from years ago

[@anneherrmann1478]

I love how you‘re looking on all the Details ❤️

[@merrick13]

When I saw them live in Texas performing this song, till was lifted and hanging in the air while the wings were burning, was a truly beautiful sight