Italian Stuffed Mushrooms - The One Holiday Appetizer With Zero Leftovers Every Single Year

Thanks to Flexispot for sponsoring this video! Click on my link: bit.ly/3V0ZXnv to get an extra $30 off your first order at Flexispot and be sure to check out their Black Friday deals! For my desk, the E7 there will be a Flash Sale on November 25th, $160 OFF. This is the best standing desk for WFH rated by TechRadar!
Today we're making Italian stuffed mushrooms! These are great for Thanksgiving or any holiday as an easy appetizer than can be made ahead of time. I hope you enjoy this stuffed mushroom recipe!
SUPPORT ON PATREON:
/ sipandfeast
MY AMAZON STORE (This is an affiliate link)
www.amazon.com/shop/sipandfeast
***PRINT RECIPE WITH INSTRUCTIONS AND PROCESS SHOTS***
ITALIAN STUFFED MUSHROOMS PRINT RECIPE:
www.sipandfeast.com/italian-s...
INGREDIENTS WITH GRAM AMOUNTS
-24 ounces (680 grams) white or cremini mushrooms see notes below
-½ cup parsley minced
-6 cloves garlic minced
-1 cup (120 grams) plain breadcrumbs
-⅝ cup (60 grams) Parmigiano Reggiano divided. ½ cup for stuffing and 2 extra tablespoons for topping
-½ cup (120 grams) olive oil
-1 ½ (6 grams) teaspoons kosher salt
-¼ teaspoon crushed red pepper
-½ (120 grams) cup dry white wine
-2 cups (480 grams)low sodium chicken stock divided
-3 tablespoons fresh lemon juice
-1 large lemon cut into wedges
FOLLOW ME ON INSTAGRAM:
/ sipandfeast
Disclosure:
I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

[@SipandFeast]

I’ve definitely noticed an increase in my energy and creativity since I’ve been using the standing desk so I wasn’t surprised when I read that a study run by a Harvard professor found that 87% of people who used a standing desk reported increased energy throughout the day. For my desk, the E7 there will be a Flash Sale on November 25th, $160 OFF bit.ly/3Op8Y81. This is the best standing desk for WFH rated by TechRadar!

[@AA-ws3vd]

Great advice!

[@jandasalovich6469]

I walk about 8 miles a day at my job. I sit when I’m at my desk. 😂

[@barbiec4312]

My physical therapist/ergonomic professional said that you should stand for half an hour, then sit for half and hour or more. Don’t stand and work for more than half an hour at a time.

[@MistyMasha]

Same!

[@charlesstockford5913]

I stood on my job for 8 to 12 hours every day. I didn't feel all that energized. Just tired with sore legs and feet.

[@sharonw9229]

James…I’m a chef and I have to tell you that there are only few select people I will follow that do cooking videos, you’re my number one. Precise and easy to understand, great technique, easy going, fun and great recipes! I always look forward to a KZbin chime 🔔 when you’ve posted something! Great job! Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family!

[@SipandFeast]

Really appreciate that, thank you so much! And Happy Thanksgiving to you!

[@kathleenengler6667]

Stuffed mushrooms were one of my mom’s FAVORITE things to make for a holiday dinner and so, as a favorite memory for me, I also love to make them! Your recipe is almost identical to hers! We LOVE garlic, but I don’t believe she ever made that many to call for 6 cloves, but if she ever did, we would eat them all! 😊 I know she always used Progresso Italian Seasoned Breadcrumbs. I love all of your videos and recipes. They always demonstrate that delicious recipes do not have to be difficult. videoing is in your home is also very relaxing to watch!

[@dee_dee_place]

I adore mushrooms, especially with butter & garlic. I have never been able to find the perfect balance for stuffed mushrooms, my breading has always come out too dry & dense. I can't wait to try your recipe, Jim. Thanks. I can't believe how much your son has grown throughout the years. Wow. My best regards to you & your family, now & during the holidays, Cent'Anni.

[@SimonPEdwards63]

@Sip and Feast and Brian Largerstrom are by far the best.

[@SuzanneBaruch]

I agree! I'm a senior sous chef and I *LOVE* everything about this channel.

[@SipandFeast]

We make these every year and they're always gone within minutes! The written recipe is always linked in the description (it's the little "arrow" on mobile and a "show more" on desktop). In the description, you will also find my shop and other links with cookware/ingredients and all the other things you guys frequently ask about. Thanks as always for liking my videos!

[@droppingbombs1645]

Gotta say, as a father who also loves cooking for his family, it always brings a smile to my face when you bring your son in to taste test. I can tell it brings you a tonne of joy to make something he enjoys, and it really makes your videos incredibly relatable.

[@jlmu2583]

Can these be prepared a day ahead, and then baked off the next day, just before the guests arrive?

[@SipandFeast]

Yes, you can prep the day before.

[@Bender1138]

My favorite part of this video: "How do I know it's one and half teaspoons? I just do." When you cook enough, you just know these things.

[@SharifEwees]

Ha, I caught that too. Years ago, when I was actively trying to progress from a recipe-only cook to a 'by feel' cook, I kept a measuring spoon set spread out on the edge of the counter. I would manually pour those sm ingredients while looking at the set for reference. Same with a big measuring cup and liquid measurements. Over a year or so, I got rid of both and can now eyeball most things. Makes recipes so much easier.

[@VLind-uk6mb]

Yup.

[@Malkumecks]

Unless you’re baking pies, cakes, cookies, being exact isn’t always necessary. You can always ballpark stuff like this and add stuff later if it needs it.

[@BridgeportIPA]

This is my Grandmother's stuffed shrooms recipe minus two small ingredients: she squeezes out a small amount of anchovy paste and adds a slight squirt of Worcestershire - both provide a nice umami smoothness and small amount of bite. The same mixture is fantastic for stuffed artichokes. It's heavenly, a sense memory from my youth!

[@gbaygoogle]

James, yes, we love it when you go over the ingredients! Don’t change, and don’t apologize for it. 😂

[@andrwdnnlly]

What I love about this channel is how easy you make it feel with your nonchalant attitude towards ingredients….“You don’t like X, don’t use X”….that makes cooking feel very accessible, which is a big reason why I’ve been subscribed for a while now. I’m a cooking nerd and this is by far my favorite channel ❤

[@alicelee5045]

Itt is funny to see James so enthusiastic about mushrooms. I love mushrooms too. I've never seen him take seconds of what you have made. I like seeing your wife being a taste tester too. It is nice to see you interacting with your family and seeing the love and warmth. 😍🥰💞💞

[@jlafunk]

Going over the ingredients is essential, and I like that you talk about them. Sure, it's "formulaic" but not in a bad way. It's just a good way to structure your videos and cover everything first.

[@SipandFeast]

Appreciate the feedback, thank you!

[@Mark723]

Mis en place - it's why the French are the best chefs on the planet. Following their lead is a big step in the right direction of becoming a better home cook...

[@KeithSansevere]

Like others have said, I like the fact you list the ingredients but also showing how you prep them. For someone like me who isn't a great cook, showing the prep is just as important as showing the cooking in my opinion. I also love that you bring in your son and wife as taste testers. You can tell when someone is saying something is good just to say it's good, but with a child, there is no faking their reaction. The way he gobbled those up, practically inhaling them, it was obvious he liked them. I was surprised his rating was on 9 out of 10 though. I thought he would have said more than 10 because of how he devoured them. Keep up the great work.

[@phronsiekeys]

I love your face when your kid says "It tastes so good" -- he's so lucky to have your cooking and you're lucky to have his tasting!

[@Avarn388]

I've started to get back into cooking and your procedure to go over the ingredients first should never change. It helps folks like me get a sense of what makes up the recipe and understand why you picked what you picked. Keep up the great work; your videos are really helpful.

[@heyitsmort7744]

I feel the exact same way. It’s completely changed how I cook!

[@pomptonqueen]

It took me years to figure out, but once I did, cooking became so much easier. No more burning the garlic while I hunted down the wine - it was already measured out and at my fingertips.

[@TheGV50]

I'm Italian and my mother made these every year during the holidays. Thanks Jim for bringing back the memories!

[@vizzini2510]

The first time I met my father-in-law, I cooked a complete Thanksgiving meal, with stuffed mushrooms as the appetizer, and he was blown away. 37 years later, he still mentions the mushrooms every time the family gets together.

[@Patrickjohnphotography]

I Love the fact that YOU smile every time your family likes what they are trying, It is a smile of pride and of sheer happiness. Great video. I'm off to cook!

[@malloryg4251]

Not gonna lie- your videos actually bring a tear to my eye. Seeing you share your passion for cooking with your lovely son is so special. I truly hope that if I my husband and I have a son, he's a lot like yours. Great parenting to you and your wife! Also- I absolutely love your recipes!

[@Sungirl88]

They’re a beautiful family

[@suiciderunner100]

I love that you go over the ingredients at the start, makes it so easy when I try the recipe myself.

[@tinytelephones]

Yep, so much easier than going back and forth through the video to see if I forgot to prep something 😋

[@jlmu2583]

Can this be prepared the day ahead and then baked off the next day?

[@SipandFeast]

Yes, you can definitely prep the day before.

[@emily76m]

I love that you don’t care about the haters!! they only have power if you give it to them. Can’t wait to try these!

[@pomptonqueen]

I make almost the exact same stuffed mushrooms and I can attest to the fact that you will have no leftovers. They are delicious. I was happy to see you didn't waste the mushroom stems. I see so many recipes that have you remove them and never mention them again. My daughter and I made them with Stove Top stuffing (without the seasoning bag) when we found ourselves without breadcrumbs. Looking forward to more recipes for Thanksgiving and Christmas.

[@jackiewinters5792]

That's a really good substitution! Thanks for sharing the tip. 👍

[@bkafers]

I made these for friends on Thanksgiving Eve. I put the plate down and they were gone in 2 mins; I didn’t even get to taste one. Great job. Love the channel, all that success because you’re a genuine human being. 😊

[@debneg23]

“How do i know it is 1 1/2 teaspoons (salt), I just do!” Lol. I was raised in Queens NY with a lot of Italian American friends. You remind me so much of them! Awesome!

[@ewaa4152]

James, I've been cooking Italian for decades now, and I always learn something new from you. Thanks & keep posting.

[@deebee4850]

I make these all the time. I use some cooked, crumbled Italian sausage in the stuffing. Try it. It’s really a game changer. I also put a little mozzarella on top, too ❤️❤️ love stuffed mushrooms and these look wonderful!!

[@valzin2012]

I love the proud father!! Such a sweet son! Sweet husband to wife. Sweet wife to husband and son!!😊❤😊

[@alaskangypsy]

My mom used to make these when I was a kid, and she lost the recipe 30+ years ago! They were called "Happy Hour Mushrooms" back then. They are absolutely fabulous! Be careful serving as an appetizer because your guests may just fill up on these incredible mushrooms and skip the main dish! So glad to have this recipe!

[@VincentXbox360]

I’ve been cooking for a while, but your process just makes it so simple because I lay out all the ingredients before I even start so they’re ready to roll. Made your chicken cutlet recipe last night and they turned out delicious, I’m definitely no professional but the only way to get better is to keep doing it. Keep it up!

[@josephwinn902]

Hey James, love this recipe! I was raised in a very Sicilian / souther Italian neighborhood - stuffed mushrooms were one of my favorites! In my neighborhood this recipe was also made with spicy Italian sausage and the exact ingredients that you used in this version! It's so good to see the food I was raised with featured on your show! You rock! Have a great holiday man!

[@lisachauvin]

I’ve been invited to someone’s house for Thanksgiving and was asked to bring an appetizer. I had no idea what to make, and then this video pops up! Thank you so much! I can’t wait to make it!

[@paulscionti7235]

Don't let the complainers and criticizing people get you down, just ignore them and enjoy your work. Keep up the amazing job, Bravo

[@carlstevenson4232]

Linda here (Carl and I share an account). I’ve been loving your videos. Great humor, family involvement and delicious recipes! We’re on a sailboat in the Caribbean and I haven’t used the oven in 3 years to help keep the heat off the boat, but you’ve inspired me enough to buy a new oven and get back to it. (I wanted to make one of your other oven recipes but couldn’t get the old oven to light). I’m considered a very good cook and don’t often use recipes, but this stuffed mushroom recipe is at the top of my list. I’ll be substituting crushed pork rinds for the breadcrumbs, though. We’ll be pairing this with a salad to make it into a main course. Can’t wait for the oven to arrive. Thanks again!

[@ryanc6851]

Honestly you're one of my favorite people to watch on KZbin for recipes. Hope you and your family have a happy Thanksgiving! I'm in charge of dessert this year (if you have any dessert recipes feel free to share lol). But I'll definitely be making this one soon though.

[@SipandFeast]

Thanks so much. I have a bunch of desserts on my website (amaretto pumpkin pie, apple crostata are the most thanksgiving-y types) and will have a tiramisu video up soon. The full length 37 minute version of the tiramisu video plus a cocktail is already up on Patreon but the much shorter version will be up on KZbin probably 2nd week of December.

[@jackieblue787]

These shrooms look amazing. 😋

[@Samurai78420]

I seriously can't believe I just found this channel last week in my feed. Im a Chef and subscribe to a lot of really awesome cooks. So I don't know why the algorithm held out on me here, lol. Definitely a new favorite for sure. He's awesome.

[@24dmiller]

Sharon, thank you for your compliment. It’s refreshing to see one chef being gracious towards another. James, I love your videos. I think you and Chef John are my favorites. Happiest of Thanksgivings to you both.

[@katiesinger9134]

I am definitely going to try these for the holidays !! Love the way your family is involved in rating the mushrooms. Thank you !!

[@whiteconch1356]

James, your show and your recipes rock...love what you are bringing to the art of cooking! Many thanks for sharing your culinary gifts with us all!

[@Stacey.B]

Thanks for how you structure your videos. I really appreciate the fact that you layout everything in the beginning so I can follow along and pause while I cook with you. Thanks again and Happy Thanksgiving!

[@orvillealdrich7601]

Great video! Love the "taste tester" and his quick assessment of the dish! Says a lot when he reaches for more! Will be adding this recipe to our upcoming weekend menu - can't wait!

[@Natalie_K_4991]

I recently discovered your channel via your quick and easy fall soup video, and I absolutely love your relaxed and honest style of cooking and presenting. You make everything seem doable and approachable, and most importantly, enjoyable! I also really appreciate the fact that you explain why you do things a certain way, because it helps me understand and remember it even when I'm working with a different recipe or making up my own dishes. Thank you so much!!

[@279steven]

What a great channel. Having your family involved is just wonderful. 👍🇮🇹

[@paulineanderson3985]

James is amazing and he wolfed those mushrooms down, these look really good. Good job dad!

[@pamelacarnemolla-dihmes4084]

I love this recipe and I like how you explain each ingredient! I just love your recipes, everyone so far😊😋

[@joannkelly7994]

Thank you. The recipe looked good and simple. Thank you for sharing. Enjoy your Thanksgiving. Stay blessed.

[@cherylludwig9955]

I LOVE LOVE LOVE your cooking channel! And love James as your taste tester! He is sooo sweet, cute, funny and has great manners! 🥰

[@Roundbrow]

This one's a winner. Going to make this for my mother this Thanksgiving, thanks for sharing Jim!

[@TheStudio_70]

I’m going to make these for our Christmas dinner. Can’t wait to try these out. Thank you for all your recipes, and happy holidays to you and your family.

[@Elizabeth-qf9hb]

Really enjoy the ingredients at the beginning because it lets you see what all you'll need at once. A lot of times with other food channels they show you as they make the dish and its harder to see everything. Nice job, i'll be trying these out soon!

[@davi3070]

Your videos are extremely informative in a practical everyday kind of way and super entertaining and wholesome when your family is involved. Without the family you are in the top 10 for cooking videos in my book. With the family interactions you are fighting for that top spot. Keep it up man, love your stuff. Just getting better and better.

[@mrob75]

Awesome recipe! The little “taste tester” always puts a smile on my face!

[@japhyryder66]

These look so good! I’m definitely planning on making this for New Year’s Eve! Love your videos, James!

[@pameladucker9056]

I love mushrooms and I'm definitely going to try these! My favorite part of your videos is watching your interaction with your son. Your face lights up when he comes in! Thank you for another yummy looking recipe!

[@LivetolearnMama]

I have loved every single one of your recipes that I've tried. I'm definitely adding this one to the holiday menu! I love mushrooms, and I can tell this will be a winner!

[@jenniferbaucom9769]

I really appreciate you showing the ingredients up front. Very sensible, along with your great advice on the various items. Thank you so very much from North Carolina!

[@arlenethibodeaux5298]

James is sooo polite! Great job explaining everything. I donot usually like mushrooms but definitely want to try this. Would make a great Thanksgiving appetizer!🍂🍁Thank you!🤎👍

[@beeveedee9355]

I made this recipe yesterday and it turned out wonderfully. Everybody loved them. I will be using this recipe again! Thanks for all your great videos and recipes. I'm learning so much.

[@maurice6542]

Looks great love how detailed you are I will definitely be trying this soon. THANKS ALOT

[@thespankdmonkey]

Love all of the ingredients you used for the stuffing. Yet when I give it a go I think I will be adding one and maybe two minced habanero peppers to just kick it up a notch. Love your channel for all the great mellow cooking with a nice family finish at the end. Cheers and Happy Holidays to you and yours!

[@davidcoatsworth7030]

I love watching your videos and am reminded of the meals I cooked for your two young sons...who are now grown men....and the nightly ritual of taste-testing Dad's cooking. Thank you for sharing your recipes and for reminding me of the magic of being a parent. My wife and I will be making this recipe on Thanksgiving! Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family.

[@carmelabologna9051]

Your videos are so perfectly presented! You have your ingredients ready and measured out and you always give an alternative to leaving out items if they are not to our taste. It is so great to watch you cook in a very relaxing atmosphere. I sometimes think James will not like your dishes because not many lads his age have such a developed palate! But he most often gets it right and what a lucky lad he is to have a parent that cooks like you do. I prepare these mushrooms in exactly the way that you do except now I am going to add a lot more garlic! You are really, really great at this!!

[@montanascookies]

I can't wait to try this ! I love your videos and you make me want to cook more so thank you! Happy Thanksgiving to you, your better half and James!

[@averagemamil4523]

I remember making something similar in the 1980s - just goes to show great taste and flavour traverses the decades and never goes out of fashion - fantastic vid as always 👏

[@mrjaxthecat]

I love how proud you are of (yourself) and your son when he eats the mushrooms! Great recipe, as always.

[@annechetty3490]

I can't wait to try this recipe - it looks so delicious! Your son is growing up before our eyes on your videos - it's been so great to have his honest opinions on your dishes!! Happy Thanksgiving to your lovely family :)

[@barrelrollio]

Perfect. The format, recipe, and everything - perfect. I love the immediate reaction with these mushrooms haha

[@DianaF74]

Definitely adding these to my Christmas Eve appetizers. They look amazing!

[@anthonypagano7167]

James... You're my favorite cooking channel on KZbin! Thanks for all the great recipes. I love the "Most underrated pasta ever", the pasta e faggioli, the shrimp alfredo, and the stuffed mushrooms to name a few. I've made them all and my wife loves them, too. We moved to Florida from Long Island five years ago, so I'm very comfortable listening to you, and I enjoy the way you interact with your family! Thanks so much.

[@GrammarPD]

Making these for New Year’s Eve. Thanks for making recipes that are accessible.

[@jennifermays8550]

We made these for Thanksgiving this year and yes, there were no leftovers! I have been watching your videos for a little while, made a few of them too. You are easy to follow and break down the recipes so well! Keep it up! Thank you

[@LauraPeregrine]

This sounds great. I look forward to trying it. My go-to stuffed mushroom recipe is seasoned with ground savory which I think goes very well with mushrooms.

[@danielgoulding4623]

Jim, I just made these for Thanksgiving. I used the chef's advantage to sample them before they are served .OMG . They took a little extra work for the prep but so worth it. And the juice is like gold ! Glad I made a double batch. Happy Thanksgiving to all of you.

[@jackiewinters5792]

With Thanksgiving approaching us I will definitely make these! I haven't had them in like, ten years. Way too long! I can't wait to try these. Thank you for sharing! I hope you & your family have a wonderful Thanksgiving. 💜🍄

[@2Wheels_NYC]

I love the interaction with your family! Happy Thanksgiving to you all!

[@janettemasiello5560]

OMG I love absolutely love stuffed mushrooms ! Your recipe looks like the best one I've ever seen and I am definitely trying this ! Yum 😋

[@sylviegauthier2145]

I love the look on your face when your young(er) taste tester is obviously enjoying what you made. It's so sweet.

[@lynnallen7325]

Definitely how delicious it seems to be, but also the ease of making them is very appealing. We will be having these Thanksgiving. Glad to see your video. Happy Holidays.

[@angel19093]

Looks amazing. Printed recipe to make soon. Following! Can't wait to watch more of your videos.

[@Shooshoobella7]

I love to cook and come from a long line of amazing family cooks, so I'm rather picky about YT cooking channels. Yours is one of the few I enjoy watching. Appreciate your no nonsense, straightforward, and easy to understand recipes and techniques. The stuffed mushroom recipe looks delicious and is very close to the one I've been using for several years, with the exception of the white wine, which I will now start incorporating as well. So thank you!

[@lisamessiana1032]

YES!!🍄🌟 Thanks Jim!👏 Happy Thanksgiving🦃 to you and your family😊 💞

[@jaduvalify]

Wow! The way your son enjoyed those stuffed mushrooms has convinced me to cook some up. And your wife giving it a 10 rating gives me confidence this will be a perfect choice to serve at our next holiday meal. Great video, Well explained. Looks super delicious!

[@AskMamaMOE]

Your son's reaction, and your reaction to his reaction was beautiful! Great recipe! Can't wait to try it out at home.

[@rosanapasquini8714]

Looks delish will definitely try thank you for the recipe.

[@haydehabdolahian7691]

Happy thanksgiving to you and your family , I do love your recipes and the way you tell it to us 👍

[@rushiaskinnerwallace6175]

I love how your son will test anything ya make and gives such great feedback. You guys seem to have a great relationship and it’s sweet to watch. Loved seeing your wife in this one and her feedback and her idea. Can’t wait to make these. 🙏🏼

[@kari97632]

Love James, so cute. Great recipe. I'll definitely be making these this year. Great for potlucks.

[@JB43186]

Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours. I’m grateful for your videos! They bring back wonderful memories of my Nonna’s kitchen.

[@SipandFeast]

Thanks so much and Happy Thanksgiving to you!

[@anitaseeram880]

excited to try this recipe...looks delicious! thanks!

[@princessoh2751]

Thank you for sharing!! Will be trying these for sure.

[@danielwerger5641]

Another great video James, thank you...! Cheers from Canada...!!!

[@monstersmomma8594]

This recipe is such a hit!! I’ve catered it 2 times and now it’s being requested regularly! I’ve even adjusted it to be vegan for some clients! Thank you!

[@gayghostprince]

i think your cooking videos are some of the best on KZbin. i appreciate how accessible you make learning new recipes for people

[@allaboutthesaucechannel]

Fantastic! I love mushrooms! I appreciate your work so much! Adding the stock and wine - I've never done that! - thank you! Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours!

[@beachblond1968]

This is going to be on my Christmas table, along with your baked artichoke hearts. Thank you!

[@patty6845]

I was looking for a stuffed mushroom recipe so I came to you. I will definitely be making this. It’s very similar to what my aunts used to make on the Holidays. Thanks!

[@jlb5175]

I made these for Thanksgiving and they were a huge hit. Will make again! Thanks for the fantastic recipe.

[@mikehillman8115]

Taste Delicious ....and A Big Smile from Dad.... The Joy of having James a part of it. Im going to spend the holidays with my 2 daughters im cooking every night and baking Pizzelles and Italian Wedding cookies...and so much MOre

[@nysavvy9241]

Love stuffed mushrooms.. They look fantastic Jim. Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family.

[@gmashands]

That desk is perfect for those of us who stand to sew for great length of times. Thanks so much Mr Jim👍👍👍

[@eddiewilson8119]

Thank you for sharing this recipe and I love stuff mushrooms!and they look so delicious 😋 I can just taste them!

[@jmarotta3]

I’m Italian and love your recipes. Made several of your dishes,so good

[@SusieKatpersonKoch]

This version looks great James! Thank you. I'm looking forward to making this! In the past I've always used ground Italian sausage and fresh spinach added to the mix!

[@SipandFeast]

Italian sausage is great in the mushrooms. There are so many ways to make them!

[@WilliamStout27]

Good and simple, perfect Jim.