J vs Ben: HARDEST Hogwarts Grounds Harry Potter TRIVIA Quiz

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Think you can stump us?! Become a Quiz Master :: www.patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers

[@Powerbomb323]

I am one now. We had a lovely conversation on Patreon xD. About the lootcrate stuff 😂😂 wonderful video, I'm almost done, I'm at question 11 rn.

[@stevefontaine1335]

🧹🪄⚡@SuperCarlinBrothers⚡🪄🧹Lord Of The Rings Film Theory Video.?🙏🙏🙏

[@Soph1aF]

Can you do a is Hermione an actual muggleborn? I think it would be a really interesting video!

[@shanekoch1990]

You guys should include a segment with each of these J vs. Ben were you guys guess what question you will see.

[@Galer_777]

You guys should do a hogwarts legacy quiz

[@Albhed_Rikku]

Ethan pitching in with a quick “David” during the Goliath movie rant was hilarious and I want him to know it did not go unnoticed.

[@suntanironman]

“David” is the name of the main antagonist (and much later on an ally) in Gargoyles. Not sure if Ethan knew that when he made the comment, but naming the two main opposing characters David and Goliath was quite intentional.

[@SnowyLynx90]

I love the sidetrack of being named a Sr. or a Jr. and they completely left out Jonathan's awesome solution of naming one of his son Nathan John.

[@Hamilfan31]

Also, and correct me if I’m wrong, isnt J also a Jr? Their dad is called John (source: the James and Lily Potter Quiz) so he could have done that so that Nate wasn’t John III

[@Xeyxey0]

​@Hamilfan31 he must not be a Jr since he said "no one in our family has done this". He could have a slightly different name, like maybe his dad's first name is just "John" or has a different middle name.

[@Xeyxey0]

​@@Hamilfan31it just randomly came up in one of the vids I was rewatching where Ben says about their dad's initals on the ball they shared, and he says "well your name is Jonathan and his name's John" so I guess his dad's first name is just "John".

[@Hamilfan31]

@@Xeyxey0oh ok thanks for clearing that up 😃

[@jamessmithson-br7rm]

Ben’s easily missed comment - “foast… primarily potatoes” just got me… more of this please 😂😂😂

[@nielstielemans7913]

Ah yes, the Marauders and their enemy: James 'Prongs' Potter, Sirius 'Padfoot' Black, Remus 'Moony' Lupin, Peter 'Wormtail' Pettigrew and Severus 'Seriously Lacking in Smolder' Snape

[@MNM150-HJ]

Lol

[@imaginepageant]

I can FEEL Ben’s pain at the end. BenFam stands with you, brother.

[@avaglennon9873]

“The fruit of the Fwomping Fwillow is Foast” is my new favorite quote

[@dmidkif]

Request for a “Hardest Harry Potter Bathrooms Quiz.” I’ve seen this idea before, as there are several significant scenes throughout the books that take place in bathrooms.

[@Necromancer4267]

Hogwarts Grounds should be a coffee flavor.

[@MarkHogan994]

I absolutely cannot express how much I love these quizzes. Harry Potter trivia absolutely never bores me and you guys are always so much fun to watch. It's just an awesome, cozy vibe, and I'm always in the mood for it, especially around the end of the year. I hope you keep making these for a long time!

[@imaginepageant]

+1. J vs. Ben is my go-to comfort watch.

[@killerfudgetastic]

Fun fact, the Marauders map ignores the Jr for Barty Crouch, so it’s not part of the bane enough to be recognized by magic.

[@YatarGhr-qd6ul]

It's also not required on passports or US government IDs (though if you have it on there, your boarding pass must match).

[@maizymusix]

The map was created by Remus, and I'm pretty sure when he was in school he didn't call Barty "Barty Crouch Jr." since Barty Sr. was a ministry official

[@Jah_LEASE_yah]

Ben still has the honor of being the first one to get a perfect score.

[@spinba11]

When did that happen

[@Jah_LEASE_yah]

@@spinba11 kzbin.info/www/bejne/eXbbc4eLd5mlmdksi=urtexSYqmznP4w8x

[@novasmith2604]

@@spinba11it was during the magical misters quiz. It was a collab with with someone

[@ShirleyLestrade]

I love how they flawlessly did the potter puppet pals thing 😂

[@Purrsephone19]

Could we get a Justice for Ginny episode? She was ICONIC in the books, and the movies did her so dirty, and people don't talk about it enough imo.

[@howveyouben]

People talk about this a LOT, to the point where I’m sick of it

[@annabanana9863]

I'm pretty sure they talked about this long ago sonewhere. I'm talking atleast 2 years ago 😅 Sorry I'm not going to searc but also good luck finding it lol

[@dmidkif]

A “Hardest Ginny Weasley Quiz” would be a lot of fun.

[@marshallpeters7174]

@@dmidkif With questions that can only be answered with book knowledge.

[@suntanironman]

5:47 The Gargoyles plot involving the spell isn’t ridiculous. A castle raising above the clouds was (seemingly) an impossibility. Therefore it was (seemingly) impossible for the spell to ever be broken. That was the intent of the spell (to never be broken). It was only through modern-day (1990s) intervention and magic-loopholes that the impossible-to-break spell was broken.

[@suntanironman]

And when Goliath willingly allows the spell to be cast upon him, he is doing so with the intention of never waking up again. He is fully aware of the conditions for the spell and 100% expects to remain as stone forever (forever or until he is shattered in his stone sleep).

[@DavidRay_40]

When will you two collab with Morgan Ross from MovieFlame? He's the ultimate Harry Potter expert. I want to see you do a HP quiz with him in the future.

[@Synthesyn342]

I’d actually really like to see this! I feel like he’s really good with story stuff, but less with the obscure knowledge 😂

[@S-Mania]

Yes, I'd love for this to happen! Get on it, guys! Please! ❤😊 All the leading experts in one room doing quizzes!

[@captscallywag]

I’d say Morgan Ross is #2 behind Jay

[@jdartistry90]

This and the harry potter folklore channel would be so cool!! 🎉

[@SilkBuckets]

and morgan just reacted to dumbledores big plan

[@Flaming_Pulsar]

Hey Ben, just so you know Violet Evergarden is the name of a light novel and anime (and the titular character)

[@ryutak777]

I was looking for this comment

[@emilyskala5452]

​@ryutak777 me too😂

[@hufflepom]

I love these! Thank you so much. Still waiting for a bathroom themed quizmaster quiz. Lol.

[@CatchingPieces]

There actually is a lot of bathroom trivia in the books! Moaning Myrtle’s bathroom, the entrance to the chamber of secrets, the bathroom where Harry uses sectumsepra, and the entrance to the ministry of magic… I’m sure we could get 15 questions out of it! (I started to mention a bathroom in Grimmauld Place and then remembered I made that one up for fanfiction 😅)

[@hufflepom]

@@CatchingPieces there are bathroom things in Grimmauld Place. Harry goes there after having VoldyVisions.

[@CatchingPieces]

@@hufflepom you’re right; I forgot!

[@laser8389]

All this talk about the Whomping Willow got me thinking about something I've never considered before: how did Dumbledore expect first-year baby Lupin to get to the knot before transforming? I mean, he's right up there with Hermione for resourcefulness in spellcasting, but for him to have to sneak out every month with no one noticing would be hard enough, how was he supposed to surreptitiously hit the correct knot on the trunk? Did he have Wingardium Leviosa down so well by the time he got there that he could float a stick to it? Just run and hope for the best? The fandom wiki says Madam Pomfrey escorted him to the shack, but if that's the case, why have the tunnel and WW at all? Or was she the one to poke the knot? Having him escorted either directly to the shack or via the tunnel seems like something that someone should have noticed. Also, does every Whomping Willow have a freezy knot?

[@carmeltabby]

All good questions and worthy of expounding on. I hope they do a video on it.

[@yavuzsensei6458]

24:14 I like that the lake is both the sewers of Hogwarts and the home of Merpeople. They swim in wizards' feces all day.

[@josephj.prioli1823]

@26:49: The Captioner DID, in fact, write "Biologicially Accurate Suction Noise" on the caption! Too cool!

[@carolynbrubaker1619]

I watched the Gargoyles with my son when he was a kid. He had to record them because the show came on after his bed time. We watched it every night just before he reset record and went to bed. I fell in love with it. Great story! Especially loved Goliath's voice

[@danceninja21]

Ooohhh Man! Ben was doing so good the whole time!!!! I totally thought he was gonna tie this game and win by a brownie point!! Better luck next time Ben!!! 😆

[@fidelianerina]

If you think about it, with the brownie point, they did tie!

[@danceninja21]

@@fidelianerina very true! Brownie points are valuable

[@kuroneko5390]

Gargoyles is a great series! I loved it as a child, rewatched it on disney plus as an adult and still loved it. It just suffered from being invented when there was only regular tv and loosing funding at the end. That's a show that should be remade and expanded on.

[@suntanironman]

I agree. It should be expanded on… and is being expanded on! It’s been green-lit for a new live-action Disney+ series. Was officially announced last month. What I REALLY want is a continuation of animated series with the original creator and original voice cast, but I’ll certainly take a live-action series as well. Whatever gets the franchise going again, I’m all for it.

[@LylaNox]

​@@suntanironmanNot a live Action!!! 😭😭😭😱😱😱 Thats practicaly the WORST they could do!!!

[@marshallpeters7174]

Nice bit at 16:55. The second option given is by the "Forbidden Foast". Also noticed the "Qudich pitch".

[@clynn1995ny]

I definitely kept thinking Faust not foast... And I was cracking up at how weirdly dark that thought is. Like the squid holding a bloody piece of Faust

[@DenDave_]

Would give Ben another brownie point for including the danger signs in the question about what Muggles see at Hogwart's location.

[@melodyfussell829]

To answer the Jr/Sr question (because I asked my dad like 2 weeks ago--my brother is named after him): The Jr. and Sr. Suffixes are not mandatory. You can choose to include Jr. In the child's legal name at birth, and if the dad wants to be able to legally sign stuff with Sr., he has to do the paperwork to legally add it to his name

[@samwiseplaysyt485]

Y'all should do a HP quiz with the phelp twins (the actors of feorge and gred) it would be amazing!

[@Layforce88]

I love it when anime I've seen gets referenced like Violet Evergarden, definitely worth watching.

[@ianmurrah8651]

Great fun, the editing in the slugs question definitely had me cackling, yalls team are amazing

[@r.mar.673]

You can see the joy Jay is holding back when Ben is sad at the end.

[@elmogalante7688]

To be precise it can be called Gargoyle only if it conducts rain water away from the roof of the building (hence the onomatopoeic name), if it has merely decorative form is a Grotesque, like in this case the winged boars!

[@lyrarose8178]

I don't know how but somehow, even when I'm sobbing and crying from heartbreak..... just listening to them helps me feel better. They make me laugh and smile.....

[@mptness4389]

Funnily enough, in the book after Harry surfaces from the lake, Fleur does in fact say "ze grindylows" so I wonder if Emma or the writers were simply pulling from that!

[@allisonperry4247]

I loved your J V Ben when you did all questions you got wrong in the past, you guys should do questions you asked for multiple choice! Keep up the great content❤

[@Devilish98]

Hilariously im rewatching that series this week. Gargoyles: Goliath, Hudson, Brooklyn, Broadway, Lexington, Bronx. Demona and angela as well

[@favouriteghost]

Fun fact! Gargoyle is actually their name when they're also fountains (generally they spit water - comes from 'gargle'). A gargoyle that has nothing to do with water is called a "Grotesque".

[@Starrylyra47]

I knew a friend of mine who was a junior. We called him little Jon in elementary school and his father was big John. He has since had a kid who is technically John the third, but we all call him trip for short because he’s a triplet.

[@iankelley8230]

I think the real questions is not who flushed Myrtle. It's why the heck does the piping lead to the lake?

[@CamiLouWoo]

😂 all the little magical wizard turds floating in the lake water

[@marshallpeters7174]

That castle is ancient. They probably didn't have septic systems when it was built.

[@iankelley8230]

@@marshallpeters7174 They didn't, they just vanished their loads when they went. Truth.

[@sirhenry9313]

Oh, I know this was a while ago, but that captioner was having so much fun 😂

[@leannep2688]

The smolder was my fave part but i kept expecting a frying pan gif from tangled to pop up on screen!

[@hufflepom]

Does anyone else feel a sense of pride when you get one that they miss/ get one without the multiple choice that they used the multiple choice? Lol

[@CatchingPieces]

I remembered the reindeer statue!

[@riluna3695]

I distinctly remember that for an old quiz when they were asked how Muggle-born students are given their Hogwarts letters. Not only did I get it when they didn't, my answer was even more specific than the quiz's answer, and I had it off the top of my head. I'd done specific research on it to help out with a story of my own in that universe, so that was definitely a huge point of authorial pride. Especially because I'm usually atrocious at these quizzes :P

[@hufflepom]

@@riluna3695 that’s awesome!

[@hufflepom]

@@CatchingPieces I forgot the word for reindeer and called it a “Santa horse”. I got it once we got the multiple choice. Lol

[@dorian9339]

I had that with Davey Gudgeon this time! That's mainly because I am a huge Marauders fan (specifically the super-long fanfic "All the Young Dudes", where the Davey Gudgeon accident is expanded upon) Oh, and the irl wizard rock band The Whomping Willows also has a song called "In Which I Whomp Davey Gudgeon"

[@SpizzyRich]

Ben acknowledged zero prep. Good on you for getting a nearly perfect score for a quiz that could have been on any ol' topic.

[@LyndZMSFits]

They got it!!! 🙌😂😎 18:14

[@shade7033]

they did indeed 🤣 they failed on phavorite and squiphd tho

[@tammybarnett1290]

It completes my day when I see one of your J vs Ben videos recently posted!! Thank you!! 🪄🧙‍♀️🦅

[@FPL_Gaines]

The fact you wrote 'foast' in the mpc of question 9(b), appreciate those details

[@adamrabe3105]

The talk of moldering old ruins reminds me of the discussions in Spiderman Across the SpiderVerse : "Why do people say ATM machine; machine is already in the name" or "Why say chai tea; you are already saying tea."

[@VirakNgauv]

Aw, Ben needs to watch more anime! Great episode! 'Twas a fun watch.

[@chadjenkins4876]

Hogwarts grounds sounds like a decent coffee house

[@ridiculousedtollett6120]

I had a similar thought.

[@CatchingPieces]

But… that’s NOT why the whomping Willow was planted. The shack and the tunnel were for Remus. The tree was for *everyone else*, to keep them away from him while he was transformed.

[@mrborgeusborg1541]

You jinxed it!!! I am not dissapointed in you missing the last question, Ben. I am dissapointed you jinxed it.

[@mecahhannah]

Awesome as always thanks guys gargoyles is one of my favorite shows ever and the one you're missing was Lexington.

[@KatrinaM1234]

Anyone else thinking of Flynn Ryder for the smolder?

[@PS-DLMA]

3 cheers for Ethan! How you managed shenanigans of the brothers is amazing :) foast for you 🎉

[@Kahtilik]

Ben: Ethan is behind the camera, we can see him but you can't Me: crying (because i can't see him)

[@JillInTheBox]

Welcome back to another video of Ben, J, and Ethan losing their minds. Featuring: foast.

[@Beeba10]

This has been my best one yet! 10/10, and then 5/5 Quizmaster Questions! Granted, I guessed one or two of them and had to look at the answer options for one or two others, but woohoo! lol

[@kevinfox500]

Okay Carlin Bros, here's the skinny on the JrtSr question. It is not required to add the Senior Suffix, if you gove a son thw Junior Suffix. You being the Senior is implied, but not legally required. Now, when the father passes, if the son can alsp opt the change jis Suffix to Senior, if they wish to. My bonus brother and bonus nephew are both still Juniors, as he decided to keep his as it was given, due to needing to update a lot of things. Myself, dad and I have different middle names, so one would think that would be a non issue. We both use our middle names, because people assume. Figure it would be what they'd do. Now, on the I, II, III version of it, the number doesn't change, and the 1st is also never mentioned. My inlaws use that option, as some families see Junior as an insult. Essentially it's seen as Implying that the son will never reach, nor exceed the success of the father. Hooe this answers any questions you had on the subject. My way of saying thanks for the content.

[@_pearl_]

It’s always such a good day when you guys post a J vs. Ben! Thanks for continuing to make them!!

[@TrensGemini]

One thousand years ago, superstition and the sword ruled. It was a time of darkness. It was a world of fear. It was an age of gargoyles. Stone by day, warriors by night. We were betrayed by the humans we had sworn to protect, frozen in stone by a magic spell for a thousand years. Now, here in Manhattan... the spell is broken. AND WE LIVE AGAIN! We are defenders of the night. We are Gargoyles! P.S. I must insist that Ben watches Violet Evergarden especially episode 10. So he cannot ever forget the name of this anime.

[@Berserk-vj8kz]

Never noticed that overlap before but the Family Logo of the Bei Fong Family (Toph) also is a flying boar/winged boar. Hogwarts is Bei Fong Manor from now on. 😂

[@snoproian]

Cant help but feel that Ben would have tied J if he only watched more anime! 🤣

[@musicman4782]

"Hogwarts Grounds" would be a great name for a new flavor of Carlin Brothers Coffee.

[@linekiller7]

Jay and Ben should absolutely do a Kids on Brooms DnD adventure! I really think they would enjoy that immensely!

[@saanvitammana271]

Foast facts of the day: Squids can eat foast Dumbledore was wrapped in foast Foast is harvested from the fhwomping fillow and is primarily made out of potatoes

[@nightfox6738]

28:30 Violet Evergarden is a character from a completely different story... She is the main character of an anime of the same name.

[@adammcgurk7950]

This episode was chaotic and I love it

[@cutpie9]

The captioner got the PHOAST! Give them a Phoaf of Phoast

[@NCThomas821]

Regarding the Jr Sr question - you technically didn't have to differentiate between the 2 since the question asked "Which Ministry official . . ." Jr was not a ministry official, so Barty Crouch is a perfectly acceptable answer.

[@liamwarner5749]

I don''t think the forbidden's forest is officially the forbidden forest. Everyone calls it that but I'm fairly sure it has an actual official name. Also to help the captioner "The phruit of the phwomphing phwillow is phoast to pheef the phiant squid."

[@SalKhayer]

Revisited this one 3 months later. The captioners NAILED it. Phoast. Phavorite. God-tier captioning tbh

[@laser8389]

The winged boars by the gates are not gargoyles. Gargoyles are decorative water spouts on a roof (think of the thing that Judge Frollo grabs at the end of Hunchback of Notre Dame), as compared to grotesques, which are statues on a roof that don't spout water (Quasimodo's stone buddies). The boars are just statues.

[@joannascillyotter6683]

Q 15 ....me literally shouting Davey Gudgeon!!! 🤣🤣

[@khodexus4963]

I knew it wasn't Violet Evergarden because that's the name of a completely different franchise.

[@kandipiatkowski8589]

J's sweater/jumper looks like a Mickey who has seen things....lol

[@cbjfan99]

You missed Broadway, voiced by Bill Fagerbakke. David was actually the bad guy, voiced by Jonathan Frames

[@BlastingKelvins]

For the Sr/Jr question, Sr is not a legal requirement, but Jr is, as long as the Sr is alive, once they pass away, the Jr can choose to drop it, but most don't to avoid confusion.

[@EmilyCheetham]

Is it legal though? Henry the 8th who became one of the most famous monarchs in British history wasn’t a jr.

[@Charbified]

@@EmilyCheetham That was a long time ago though, and he is referred to specifically as "Henry VIII" so not sure that was the best example hahaha That does raise the question though of what if they do it again... If the original Sr is still alive, does the child of the Jr have to be Jr Jr

[@EmilyCheetham]

@@Charbified looking online I cannot find any legal requirements (atleast in uk) to add junior/jr to your child’s name if you give them the same name as you. I also cannot found any legal requirement to add senior to your name.

[@EmilyCheetham]

@@Charbified he was Henry 8th after he became monarch. He was the 8th monarch in British history to be called Henry (like our current monarch is Charles 3rd but before him was hi mum Elizabeth 2nd) but he was NOT the 8th in a row if that is what you are thinking.

[@neozakk_]

My father is a junior. And he not only does not have junior is his legal name, he actively does not go by junior. This is definitely not a requirement, at least not in the United States. Edit: my grandfather is also very much alive. And also, does not choose to go by senior. I can't speak to it being a legal part of his name, but for sure my father is not legally known as a junior outside of our immediate family.

[@ButterScotch2.0]

I love that “D” was an Anime character and he guessed it. I bursted out laughing when I saw that! Such a good show

[@gryffindorgirl1009]

I love how there IS no captions being done. It's hilarious

[@AthenianOwl237]

You have to turn them on (if you do, you'll also see the captioner gave them their wish)

[@DerNiko]

Violet Evergarden had me rolling XD It does sound like a Harry Potter name tbh, so good on the quiz master But the fact that Ben fell for it, too? XD Btw, Violet Evergarden is the protagonist of a very emotional, beautiful, Netflix Anime series. Can only recommend you give it a watch, it truly is that good. However, keep tissues close at hand :D

[@lsg6864]

This was the most fun episode ever! 😆Love everything you do ♥

[@isaac_aren]

A gargoyle has to also be a water feature such as a drain or a spout. Otherwise, it is a grotesque

[@zackatk77]

Ya done well Ben. Wear that brownie point with pride.

[@mistyb1183]

OK I understand if you put any suffix after the name that means you become the other if you’re the first and then your child the second that’s automatically become the same was the junior some people just switch the middle names to make it easier

[@Kain1445]

Wow! So close, just for Ben to fall short at the finish line 😱

[@SnowtimeRL]

Yo how is it possible to still be doing this and you haven’t run out of ideas, it’s wild that the Harry Potter universe is so big

[@crazysasha1374]

"True facts about the giant squid" Loving your references, Ethan! Zefrank would be proud.

[@ElysWolf]

Love how Ben and Jay kept going on tangents this whole quiz, but Ethan would put them back on track! LOL!

[@wizardman8482]

Violet evergarden is a very slow, very sad anime that is about a manufactured girl that is meant only for war but ends up being a typest... for some reason.?. Definitely nothing to do with the wizarding world

[@mauraaa2988]

at the question "who would get the davey gudgeon question right? that’s completely mental", i bring you : US. THE MARAUDERS FANDOM. (yes we are crazy)

[@rhiannonludolph9113]

yeah honestly the amount of knowledge i have from the marauders fandom is terrifying

[@TheBeelzboss]

Technically a gargoyle is a drain pipe and the figure carved around it is a grotesque. Somewhere along the lines things got confused...

[@keyblademasterclark]

Actually J, the castle was rebuilt on top the Eerie Building, which was owned by David Xanatos. and the last gargoyle you couldn't remember was Broadway. THAT SHOW WAS THE BOMB

[@chefRyan38]

Editing was on fire this go

[@13vatra]

"Get down there and help Potter!" *Flush* 😂😂😂

[@anvithashriramanujam4746]

the funniest part abt the foast captioning discussion is that there are no captions right now 😭

[@HannahEvansOfficial]

Love your videos

[@makaylahaverluk667]

27:55 Violet Evergarden is actually an anime that I highly recommend! It's about a young girl raised as a weapon of war and how she copes with the end of the war and has to learn to become a regular citizen and understand emotions.

[@mistyb1183]

18:20 no, there’s no captions I think they just gave up lol

[@xyreniaofcthrayn1195]

Ben went for Violet Evergarden, the one person who is in no way associated to harry potter but is a great netflix series though.