J vs Ben: ULTIMATE Harry Potter Halloween Quiz

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

How well did you do??? Post your score here!

[@minnesotagirlslife7733]

SuperCarlinBrothers hi! When I clicked on the video notification, it was so new, it said the video was private. I clicked again, and I was the second person here. Love you guys!

[@iikaedenii]

23/25

[@augustasblinstrubas4195]

I got no point but I didn’t play the game

[@micahelali5138]

Im early brother

[@SHURIKENRCN]

SuperCarlinBrothers 25/25

[@annabeth1500]

Ben should've won. J missing Madame Maxine and specifying the age line shouldn't have counted. Especially since singing skeletons didn't count for dancing skeletons for being close when J got age line granted to him by being close. That was close enough rather than the Weird Sisters. Ben should've won. #BenWon

[@RedEveTillDawn]

Percy Jackson Fan he should’ve at least gotten a half point for the skeleton one

[@LordofFullmetal]

No, two entirely different situations. J wasn't WRONG. He was talking about the right thing, he just didn't use the very specific words the question was looking for. Ben literally got part of it WRONG. Dancing and singing are two different things.

[@celinabinkley6978]

Percy Jackson Fan EXACTLY THANK YOU. that was total bs. J shouldn’t have gotten the Madame Maxine point because he added it after OR the age line one because he didn’t say age line OR the why was Halloween an important date because Ben was more specific and J said because Harry survived but it was because of the ‘defeat’ of Voldemort. Also Ben should’ve gotten the point for dancing skeletons because that was way closer than the ones J got points for and shouldn’t have and he should’ve gotten the Ginny question right too for the same reason J was ‘close enough’ on later questions. Glad I’m not the only one who noticed. I really don’t like how J acted in this because it’s like he’s so obsessed with being right, but not with being fair, and gets so upset when he gets them wrong & like he shouldn’t have, but Ben just accepts it when he gets things wrong. I wouldn’t want to play with J. Ben definitely won this quiz.

[@Imrano_Rex]

Gosh how many times did Derek let J off here? Lol. Ben should have been way ahead, he was more specific.

[@rachel-js9xe]

right 😭

[@EileenJustMe]

I feel like Jon adding Madame Maxime late to his answer should not have counted. Reminds me of when Ben misunderstood the Question with the house Ghosts in a different quiz and they didn't let him change it... ;)

[@ameliaparis3222]

This is exactly what came to my mind too

[@TorrinCruddas]

LOL thats not right he didn't cheat

[@geethau4676]

@@TorrinCruddas J cheated

[@cindydeakin8234]

Somebody is used to getting their own way, and some others are used to enabling him...noticed it before, but not as much as this time.

[@nerdstorm596]

It’s definitely the older/ younger brother dynamic. It’s funny how that follows you. I don’t see my brother often, but when I do, it will easily fall to the same thing. I often have to tell myself, “no. I’m not a kid anymore. I’m 30. With a wife and kid. I don’t just have to follow what he says.” Ben needs to do the same. The problem is, his growing was with his brother with the exception of a few years at college. He never moved away or anything. Never had time to separate from that dynamic. But yeah. Jon often reminds me of my older brother.

[@madethistocomment727]

Here from the future. Younger brother Tyler hosts a lot now and he does NOT let J get away with anything.

[@Lucky008aau]

18:59 J gives himself an unearned point!

[@kaitlynand7070]

Chris Reno yo I had to rewind to the time stamp and omg I’m surprised I missed that! What the heck! Ben deserved the win

[@googlegiggler2706]

No someone else is counting on the screen too

[@theneekofficial8829]

Chris Reno Yeah but it wasn’t added to the counter on the screen. Just follow that one.

[@lilyawoodburn]

Omg I caught that! I hope they address that mistake in the next J vs. Ben video, wow

[@kerenchoi6967]

ok ik everyone kinda already commented about this but cmon J, give ben credit where credit is due and take the loss when you mess up. the maxime thing was pretty low. but, i will say bens attitude about everything makes it all better. you see hes totally having fun and i love that. i think thats why im team ben

[@someonedifferent198]

Ben in my heart you totally won this one!!!

[@GMdrivingMOPARguy]

I really feel like Ben probably should have won this one.

[@mariama615]

GMdrivingMOPARguy exactly!

[@jarrettbarnett7656]

J pulling some BS in this quiz

[@umbrella0110]

Also, J shouldn't have gotten a point because he included Madam Maxine's name. 🤨

[@mady8705]

It’s just like the other quiz where Ben didn’t hear Hogwarts HOUSE ghost, and so he put moaning Myrtle so he didn’t get the point. it’s the same thing, but J just gave himself a point anyways

[@bentheredonethat1350]

Ben probably should have gotten the point for Singing Skeletons, and J probably should have missed the one when he didn't write down Maxime.

[@Ottawa3453]

I feel like if Jay was allowed to add Madame Maxime to his list after he had already submitted his answer, then Singing Skeletons is close enough to Dancing Skeletons.

[@graemeappleyard]

I cry foul. J should not have gotten points for a few of those questions. And adding Madam Maxime after the flip is full out "Cheater cheater, pumpkin eater". Ben deserves the win. #Jcheats

[@TorrinCruddas]

I agree

[@cosmoniums5990]

I agree

[@catwoman7142]

Ben shoulda won that by 3 or 4 points

[@MrHackSatireVideos]

#Jcheats a lot. I understand arguing your case, but h's straight up greedy for those points.

[@avaleet5498]

I agree that Ben should have won, but you don't have to get so mad it's just a game

[@zactacon]

Umm real score J: 17 Ben: 22 Ben should’ve won definitely!!

[@erindavies211]

That's what I thought.

[@jamiecopland6317]

Feels like Ben should have won that. J stole a few points!

[@MD-xc3js]

I totally agree: "ooh I didn't hear you say Madame Maxime" yeah right. That point should only have gone to Ben! :P

[@cassandramuller7337]

Well Ben had it wrong, but J didn't deserve it either. I mean even if it was true, I've never won an argument for more points on a test bescause I 'misunderstood' the question.

[@kassard1]

It SHOULD be a tie! J insisted in taking a point earlier for being “close enough” so “singing skeletons” is way closer to dancing skeletons than the weird sisters. Boom. Point. Tie.

[@LordofFullmetal]

Uh no, because the answer J got for being "close enough" was way closer to the actual answer than Ben's was. J literally just used the wrong words to describe the exact right situation. That's WHY it was deemed "Close enough". It was the exact same answer at heart, it literally just used different words. Ben on the other hand was literally wrong. He was incorrect. He said singing skeletons and the answer was dancing skeletons. Singing and dancing weren't interchangeable terms last I checked, they were two very different things. And skeletons are a pretty easy guess given we're talking about Halloween; we don't know he didn't get that out of sheer luck, whereas it's really obvious that J ACTUALLY knew the answer.

[@almightykue3914]

But why was Ben not given a point for the Ginny question? She was worried because she had no memory, but she was worried because she was being possessed and thus had no memory. Its the exact right answer, in fact even more right than the answer provided.

[@Mary_Studios]

Or J shouldn't have gotten a point because he didn't put down Madame Maxiene at first.

[@DocStewie77]

Ben, looks like fans agree you at LEAST tied on this one.

[@katrinasims7547]

This one was kinda a load of B.S. If J could get a point adding to the answer after the fact then Ben should have at least gotten a point with his singing skeleton answer. It's no ones fault but J's if he didn't hear all the answer options, he should have been paying attention. I usually enjoy these types of videos , but this one definitely didn't sit right with me. Sometimes J can be annoyingly competitive and boastful to the point of it being unwatchable. I still enjoy a majority of the content , but I honestly feel bad for Ben for getting the short end of the stick.

[@LordofFullmetal]

To be fair, it's not always as easy as "paying more attention". Not everyone has perfect hearing, and some people's brains take longer to register what's said. I know I miss a lot of stuff people say to me purely because it takes my brain so long to register some of it that I end up totally missing other stuff. You also don't know what his hearing's like. That's not necessarily within his control, and it's close minded to suggest it is.

[@katrinasims7547]

True, but based on how he acts and boasts in previous videos I doubt he has any of those problems and he could actually help it if his hearing is a bit poor. I'm sure they make enough to afford a hearing aid if needed.

[@Diddd4444]

Katrina Sims so right. When Ben gets things wrong, he’s such a good sport about it. I feel so bad for him..

[@zenriou305]

Could not agree more with you. That was some bs

[@christiancasaverdepertica1802]

3:07 Unpopular opinion: Nearly headless nick is a bad character. He was just poorly executed

[@prof.evilpictures8696]

I see what you did there...

[@wyldegi]

Lol

[@lilygarmodon2135]

... Why Must You People Make Bad Puns?

[@Maker0824]

if I didn’t read that reply I would be very disappointed in you

[@scarlettf6925]

You..I like you

[@Diispaceyone]

J take the L dude 😂. you definitely didn’t deserve the point for that madame maxime last minute inclusion. if you didn’t hear it that’s on you.

[@MrChemicalDisaster]

I realize that it’s all in good fun, but J seems a bit like a sore loser(even when winning) with the Imprecise answers/missed madame Maxime...

[@alessandraalmanza9052]

Especially today tho 🤔 he hasn't been like this in other quizzes...

[@cassandramuller7337]

He hasn't been as much like this on other quizes, but I get what you're getting at.

[@zlayne357]

I noticed that too. In the beginning when Ben was ahead he got curt and like pushed on like he was annoyed.

[@Leiake2604]

I've seen this fanatical side to him before. Ben's is just more easy going in general... makes him slightly more likeable.

[@annafuller5310]

MrChemicalDisaster he do be a Slytherin. If he matches with that personality type he’s likely to be a sore loser LOL

[@pcplayer9613]

I got 21/25. Also, J, you added a point to your score at 18:50 even though you didn't get the point.

[@youwillneverknow7165]

Okay sorry, but this was so unfair. Ben had a total of three very specific answers that at least accumulated would constitute a point (the skeletons on their own even should be worth a point) and J got to add an answer later on? They should have at least tied.

[@gutentag2235]

Bot

[@roniblack9213]

I understand now why J wins so much more often than Ben. If you're cheating and counting wrong answers and changing your answers after Ben tells you the correct answer, but don't count Ben's answers that are much closer than yours, than of course you'll win. Seriously J, play fair or don't play at all. Watching cheaters isn't fun.

[@idunrudemo]

Might be bc I'm on #TEAMBEN but it kind of felt like J cheated a little

[@williamaiken3814]

Totally. They wouldn't give Ben singing skeletons but J can add things after the reveal? Something is a little fishy here! #TEAMBEN

[@laurent5593]

Idun Rudemo ben definitely deserved some of the “kinda there” points when J didn’t (like voldemort’s disappearance)

[@summerthoughts7681]

#TEAMBEN #JUSTICEFORBEN

[@YiseleRose]

Yeah, when Ben gets an answer kinda wrong he immediately accepts defeat but J argues that his answers right for the point. I know this is not serious at all but it bothered me 😂 #TEAMBEN

[@sandracaraballo9830]

Honestly, these used to be my favorite types of videos they did but Jay makes them so annoying, like you're a grown man, enough with the faces and arguing with Derek.

[@dr.kasturijadhav795]

Ben's age line answer was more specific. J still gave himself a point. How Slytherin of you! Not a sporty loser are we? J, you scored 19 not 20. Ben is the winner in this one, although I am #TeamJ

[@bigz2669]

I dont count J winning this one cause of the add in answer. Either they tied or Ben won.

[@TorrinCruddas]

Ben won cause he cheated

[@OCD.Reader]

I am glad to see the entire comment section agreeing in unison that ben won this one. yayiii. Also, ben is such a chilled guy. he doesn't whine at all. Just deals with it.

[@batmoney1348]

HOW DID J WIN THIS ONE?? ben obviously won

[@xAbbieCx13]

I agree!

[@AuliaSekar]

agree he answered few questions more specific

[@JOHNDOE-bn3lx]

He did not receive the last poibt, which would have offically put him in a draw, and jay shouldn't have received a point for an answer he has modified

[@batmoney1348]

i know, he is such a sore loser. but i love watching their vids anyways so it doesnt really matter

[@5LikeThat]

It's more than ridiculous than J was allowed to add Madame Maxime's name to his board after the fact. And that Ben didn't get the point for the Age Line question (Chamber of Secets? Cant remember anymore, smh). Ben got robbed. 🙄

[@Libellulaire]

Ben did get the point for the age line question (goblet of fire...), but J also gave himself a point for this one. Even though the others wouldn't give him the point, he gave it to himself... bs.

[@djpyroteknikz135]

Still patiently waiting for Pottermore to release a hard quiz on Luna Lovegood so that I can then wait for the "J vs Ben: HARDEST Luna Lovegood Quiz" video.

[@zermeenkhan249]

DJ Pyro Teknikz same

[@kittykatycupcake318]

I’m gonna be her for Halloween 😄

[@mia-hr1rr]

:D

[@hallaloth3112]

Given their comment about Neville being in random obscure places. . . a Hardest Neville Longbottom quiz is in order as well.

[@Cat-sl6bo]

kittykatycupcake I wanted to be her, but I couldn’t find the correct Ravenclaw robes and I refuse to wear Ravenclaw stuff with a raven. IT IS AN EAGLE!

[@ploxxybb]

18:56, J gives himself a point on his white board, though he lost the round. I saw that ;)

[@cj_obrien]

J shouldn’t have gotten that point when he added it after Ben said it.

[@cj_obrien]

Dear the person that liked my comment, Thank you for liking my comment. You are the first person to like any of the comments I have posted ever. Thanks You

[@TheXenogias]

You guys should try and do a quiz together as a team. It would be interesting than the 1V1, you guys always do.

[@r1nc0re37]

Thank you for not being mean about the point thing And i agree that would be interesting

[@0Quiwi0]

I have to call rules lawyer here! The goblet didn't mind the age. It was just the age line that caused Fred and George to be hit back

[@LordofFullmetal]

Yes but WHY was the age line there at all? WHY did Fred and George cross it? You cannot separate the situation from the Goblet, because it's the literal reason all of it happens. The Goblet's as much the cause as the line itself is, because had the Goblet not been there the line wouldn't have been.

[@LuckyRare]

Age line was there because of them (Organizers) wanting it to be "of age" wizards only. Goblet itself doesn't care.

[@0Quiwi0]

Dumbledore made the age line so underaged wizards couldn't put their name in the goblet. Anyone who could figure out how to go past it could put their name in. Barty jr. just figured out how to add someone else's name and make it choose Harry's name as an extra. Sadly it was never explained how the heck he did it. I mean Dumbledore doesn't know how to change the goblet's choice and this guy went through Dumbledores spell and tampered with the highly magical relic

[@malaikaaa96]

This was definitely the most unfair round. J, play by the rules bud. If Ben has a more specific answer, even if you’re right, he gets the point. And you don’t get to add on answers after. Once you turn your board that’s your final answer. PLAY FAIR 👎🏾👎🏾

[@Annajohnson14]

If he's right he's right even if Ben has a more right answer he's still right

[@designateddriveranddragons8845]

Did you seriously let J count Maxim after Ben reminded him she was a choice after the reveal?

[@CindyEnigma]

I honestly screamed "that's not fair"

[@cassandramuller7337]

Me too. And then they wouldn't even allow Ben's singing skeletons. It was close enough.

[@richardkeane895]

J's more competitive. Ben definitely should have won.

[@cassandramuller7337]

J's also not a very good loser. He's an even worse winner.

[@CindyEnigma]

@@cassandramuller7337 i know, right?. He gets mad when he loses a point, but oh man if he wins he'll let you know. No offence tho, i love them and this channel.

[@tygermbg]

Sorry Jay, but Ben totally won this!

[@be555]

No J, the twins didn't go to the hospital because they tried to put their names in the goblet, but directly because they crossed the age line!

[@ForeverDegenerate]

Except they crossed the age line because they tried to put their names in the Goblet of Fire. If anything, J's answer was more specific then Ben's because J's answer actually tells you WHICH Age Line they crossed. ;)

[@connormontanya3547]

ForeverDegenerate but his answer didn’t say anything about the age line so therefore Ben had the right answer the age line

[@J3009]

@@ForeverDegenerate That's like telling that they got beards, because they wanted to be in a Triwizard Tournament

[@sonnykennison3249]

There was one age line. I can go further, they grew beards because they went to hogwarts, see they only tried putting their names in because they wanted to win, and they only wanted to win the triwizard tournament because they knew about it at all so really I'm right.

[@connormontanya3547]

Sonny Joon but the question was not why did they cross the age line. The question is why did they spend most of Halloween in the hospital wing which therefore means the answer is the age line

[@samos4924]

Ben when he gets a question wrong: "Dang it!" Jonathan when he gets a question wrong: "WHAT!? That never happened. The quiz is wrong!"

[@patrickadams1305]

Jay you usully good at these quizzes but I honestly think Ben won this one by the 2question you weren't 100% correct on or it should of been a tie by giving Ben the last Question

[@bernardberkner3399]

You guys should be giving half point for incomplete questions (the ones you need to argue with the teacher for) This way it gives a better representation of how well you guys did

[@thebox5001]

Ben should have won, jay was whining and weaseling his way with points the whole time

[@doreencloutier1066]

Agree . I would've gave him the skeletal question. .he was close enough.

[@live_evil4961]

weaseling, i see what you did there😏

[@celinabinkley6978]

Ajay Singh EXACTLY. Yeah, that was total bs. J shouldn’t have gotten the Madame Maxine point because he added it after OR the age line one because he didn’t say age line OR the why was Halloween an important date because Ben was more specific and J said because Harry survived but it was because of the ‘defeat’ of Voldemort. Also Ben should’ve gotten the point for dancing skeletons because that was way closer than the ones J got points for and shouldn’t have and he should’ve gotten the Ginny question right too for the same reason J was ‘close enough’ on later questions. Glad I’m not the only one who noticed. I really don’t like how J acted in this because it’s like he’s so obsessed with being right, but not with being fair, and gets so upset when he gets them wrong & like he shouldn’t have, but Ben just accepts it when he gets things wrong. I wouldn’t want to play with J. Ben definitely won this quiz.

[@geethau4676]

I agree

[@sofiavelez1311]

I love J and Ben but I feel like J really cheated on this one. He gave himself extra points, got points when he didn’t really get the answer, and added onto his answers after they said it. I still love them but this one didn’t seem very fair

[@geoffreysmart6801]

Sorry, but no. I'm giving the win to Ben.

[@mreevee7785]

Yeah same most of the time i was like "if ben has the more correct answer then he gets it right over J" They probably think were just like those teachers

[@malaikaaa96]

100%

[@indiansfan444444]

At worst it should of been a tie. If they give the point for putting the name in the goblet instead of crossing the age line then remembering it was skeletons should be just as acceptable.

[@stephaniebarney]

me too. it seems like the guy tends to favor J when he gets a tiny bit of the answer. The last one he should've gotten half a point

[@mariama615]

Geoffrey Smart J cannot handle defeat very well 🙃

[@rhiannonbrewer5365]

Hella late to the party but Ben was done so dirty in this quiz. J is adding a point when not told his answer counted and just moving merrily along when Ben obviously got it almost perfectly right? And J being allowed to alter his answer once showing it to the camera even though that wouldn’t be allowed to Ben on any other quiz or this one? The gall

[@theNightGoesOnx4]

I feel like J wins sometimes because he takes points when he didn't really get the question right 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@filthycade2399]

As far as i watched his wins are fair.

[@theNightGoesOnx4]

@@filthycade2399 I'm not saying he's straight up cheating. I just feel like there are questions he doesn't answer correctly but he takes the points anyway because he's pretty close (e.g- 16:30 & 20:55). Ben usually loses by only a few points and that wouldn't be the case if J didn't get those extra points just because the "audience knows" J knew what part of the book they're referring to.

[@andressanchez7629]

@@theNightGoesOnx4 he's right he just didn't word it correctly

[@nads4002]

Ben won. Period.

[@123genki]

Booooooooo, J DID NOT deserve this win!! Victory to Ben #teamben

[@Sandmantpp]

This game was biased in J's favor...Ben was more right about questions that were given to them both, and J was allowed to ANSWER QUESTIONS AFTER THE FACT, and after all those generous rulings in J's favor...you don't give Ben credit on "singing skeletons"? What a charade.

[@JellyBelz]

Should have been a tie. "Voldemort Defeat" from Ben was better than "Harry Survives" from J. Also, come on DK... you couldn't give Ben the skeletons? Ah, specifics...

[@doreencloutier1066]

Also I defeat was in quotes. Meaning supposed defeat

[@mashaparfenenko905]

So many of the times, J says “but you know that’s what I meant” and takes the point anyway. This is not how you do a quiz. If you know it - write it down. Otherwise it doesn’t count. It’s not about what you know, it’s about the answers you give

[@annaoffive]

Yeah this especially bothers me cuz similar/the same thing happens to Ben but he still doesn’t get the point and yet when J does it he does? I mean I love them and the vids but that’s not sportsmanlike!

[@ahdurinregion]

To be honest, I thought you guys were wearing cowboys hats in the first second or so... got me very confused about cowboys in Harry Potter lol Edit: Realized you mentioned that at the end of the video XD

[@nathanmond6508]

Anyone else realize that j gave himself an extra point on his board?

[@ericbeilmann3649]

I was wondering if anyone else noticed that. It was so subtle I barely caught it.

[@nathanmond6508]

@@ericbeilmann3649 I noticed immediately, but I have ocd so.

[@Novafan]

i remember seeing that in a few other quizzes too

[@lacyomsberg1235]

Wait time stamp?

[@marinegoeseels3891]

I have to agree with some of the comments here... Ben deserved this win, J got a couple of undeserved points there

[@yulbs]

18:58 J giving himself a point eventhough he got the question wrong. Good thing you keep track of the score! :D

[@andreen596]

I think Ben actually won this one because he actually got two answers more accurately than J that was actually what the quiz had and then J cheated on the feast question by adding Maxime otherwise another fun quiz. #teamBen

[@El_Man623]

18:50 You can see Jay scoring himself an extra point. Shame on you ;)

[@roberthughes1495]

Its just the letter j

[@Xjebin]

robert Hughes his name is Jon but they just call him J

[@wyldegi]

Honestly I don’t think he meant it. He normally gets the answers correct and went autopilot because he was listening to Ben

[@fballjake65]

I believe that the Deathday Party is also the way that the books establish what year the story takes place. By saying that it is Sir Nicholas' 500 death day party and then stating that he died October 31, 1492, we know that Harry's second year starts in 1992. If I'm not mistaken, I think this is the first time a year is established to the Harry Potter story.

[@matcine5413]

That sounds pretty possible

[@promise8075]

jabeaty89 well we also knew the year of Harry’s birthday...

[@Wltrwllyngaeiou]

@@promise8075 we know that because of the deathday party, iirc

[@JoelCromwell]

That is indeed the case, the entire Harry Potter timeline was originally built around the Deathday party.

[@mrerikpi4648]

Yes, it was the first time the timeline was established 👍🏼 JKR then confirmed it more directly through the date on the Potters' tombstone, i think.

[@raquelsuarezcordera1180]

Two facts we all noticed watching this video: 1. Ben won. 2. J, you cheated mate.

[@strawbbymilk]

At 26:37, J sounds EXACTLY like Kronk from The Emperor’s New Groove like aaaahhhhh

[@andrewwiener4557]

By all accounts it doesn't make sense!

[@CrimsonFox36]

Oi! J! I see you cheatin there, giving yourself a point when you lost

[@fullmetalninjadog]

J totally shouldn't won cause of Maxine

[@nathans9764]

The deathday feast serves two other purposes; it introduces Myrtle, AND it saves Mrs. Norris. Because Hermione offends Myrtle, she flees back to her bathroom, floods the hall, and Mrs. Norris isn't killed but just petrified.

[@bellasaperston1308]

*the tune of this is halloween* THIS IS HARRY POTTER THIS IS HARRY POTTER HARRY POTTER HARRY POTTER

[@susansparrow]

Something Bella this is Pottermore works too!

[@PhilBagels]

That doesn't scan. "Harry Potter" is too many syllables.

[@daynastokes5649]

@@PhilBagels we could short form "harry potter" to "harry p", but then we have a whole new set of problems

[@makardeku]

i cant do it to the tune of this is halloween, all i hear is harry yelling *HARRY POTTER HARRY POTTER HARRY POTTER* “i found the source of the ticking ! it’s a pipe bomb! * yaaaay * “meuahhaha voldemort voldemort oh voldy voldy voldemort! 😂

[@makardeku]

if J could add on maxine even after the answer was revealed ben should of gotten dancing skeletons.

[@filthycade2399]

I agree with J for taking a point for Weasley twins question. Trying to put their name means crossing the age line. But it was unfair when J wrote Maxim’s name down after revealing the answer, he shouldn’t have gotten the point. its his fault that he didnt hear the name.

[@filthycade2399]

Luna Alma its specific cause the actual quiz has answers to choose from. On the core they were both correct . I think.

[@Libellulaire]

Yes, and no. I mean, look at the question "What happened to the twins that meant they spent most of Halloween in the hospital wing ?", the question is clearly asking for the fact they aged. The question is "why were they at the hospital ?", it's not asking "why did they age and had to go to the hospital ?" We all know what J meant, but the thing is that Ben was indeed more specific. J gave what led to the reason of their aging (putting their names), while Ben gave the reason (they got aged by the age line). In such a case of one being really specific while the other isn't, the later gets no points. If it had been the first question like that, sure, give the point to both. But it was at least the 3rd question with a very detailed answer. You'd think that by that time J would be more careful and be specific, not beat around the bush.

[@jaitdas3582]

It's not the same thing actually. Plus his reason for his answer is "that's why the goblet did it" where as in fact the age line did it to them not the goblet (if you read the books).

[@Mertle_The_Turtle_5165]

J, Twisted Sister is an old school metal band!😄😄😄 In the Muggle world! 😄😄😄 In real life! Am I the only one that noticed it?

[@ainokankaanpaa9205]

27:33 Twisted Sister is an actual band, the harry potter version is Wierd Sisters

[@Stargazer_Ley]

I was looking to see if anyone else caught that. In fact, I think it's because of Twisted Sister that Weird Sisters could not be named in the film. I could be wrong about that though.

[@Jlransom79]

#TeamBen. Sorry, J, gloating was inappropriate.

[@charleslee8313]

Give Ben credit for that last one!

[@stephany_joaquin]

I think we can all agree that Ben was the true winner here. #TeamBen #BenWon

[@navyam6710]

Am I the only one who doesn’t take part but has fun watching jay and Ben struggling and pulling their hair out 😂😂 No?! Just me...

[@desireebarhorst-weller1767]

You're not the only one. I think it's just a lot of fun to watch!

[@bethbayless5652]

I just watch it they are enjoyable to watch

[@pilarwilkinson7004]

Ben was definitely a winner on this one- Nice try J Have to say though, Ben's reaction at about 15:00 is so me during some of these quizzes

[@apefrost]

Ben got robbed! J would've argued hardcore over technicalities but younger bro Ben just accepted it without question. J IS A CEATER, period. Go #TeamBen!

[@PhoebeHB]

Ben absolutely should've gotten the point for the final question, because he was way more right than J and none of the other answer choices had anything to do with skeletons so if he'd been given the multiple choice he obviously would've got it right.

[@dustinhovde9715]

You guys should open a coffee shop / burger bar thing! Carlin Brothers Coffee and Burgers!! You can sell your coffee of course, a selection of specialty burgers, and some of your merchandise. Small impromptu meet ups could also be held there! It would give a great reason for your huge fan base to travel to your local area and check out all the cool places featured on your other channel!

[@twistedlimitsjj1901]

Or coffee and BAGELS

[@katherinepoole8842]

Dustin Hovde they kind of already did. Not the burger part, but they did launch Carlin Brothers Coffee a few weeks ago.

[@angelsharp90]

Ben should have won J was put points he didn't earn

[@NA-ck6cz]

Typical Slytherin move there

[@morgangobin9985]

Nick Angelos We aren’t all cheaters! Just J is! ;)

[@SereniaSaissa]

Question 21 - the twins crossing the age line - the Goblet was only available for 24 hours for contenders to put their name in. Not for the week that J mentions!! Just thought you might want to know.

[@stephaniebarney]

Ben deserved more points

[@elidaacosta7216]

J if you "know that's the reason" you should say that... You stole this win 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@TheRubberDuck77]

Ben soooooooo should have win this one

[@scr00g3]

J is the biggest cheater of all time. Ben clearly deserves to win.

[@kaitlynand7070]

Lau rib @18:58 he gives himself an extra point

[@scr00g3]

Kaitlyn And But DK recounts the points when he edits the video. But apart from that, J took points several times when clearly Ben’s answer was more accurate. And the biggest scandal is when he adds Maxime after the answers were revealed, and he still gets the point on that one. He also always argues about the accuracy of his answers even when they are far to vague or don’t even mention the right answer. He may know the answer but he didn’t wright it.

[@simonreilly213]

J seems like the kind of guy you just don’t want to hang out with

[@scr00g3]

Simon Reilly I totally agree, Ben seems nicer. J seems king of arrogant, it must be a nightmare playing games with him.

[@DetailBearOn]

Well, he is a Slytherin where "cunning folk use any means to achieve their ends".

[@UnorthodoxSoundwave.]

Goblet of Fire being close enough for Age Line (for J): ✅ Singing Skeletons being close enough for Dancing Skeletons (for Ben): ❌ EXCUSE ME HOW DOES THAT MAKE SENSE!?!.

[@carrie637]

Singing and dancing are two completely different things. The Age Line was created to prevent underage students from being able to put their names in the Goblet of Fire, so they were in close relation to each other.

[@UnorthodoxSoundwave.]

Carrie Yes, but just like every time someone sings they don't always dance, every time someone makes an age line, they aren't protecting the Goblet of Fire.

[@wilsonfisk4501]

J cheated on this quiz

[@NA-ck6cz]

Slytherin... duh

[@luxx4]

I just realized something For all of the first years in Harrys 4th year, the TriWiz Tournament and Cedrics death would have been pretty weird for their start to school

[@dxredeviled6880]

So excited for every video!

[@carlrood4457]

Here's a question. Even though they couldn't understand parselmouth, shouldn't Ron and Hermione have heard the hissing?

[@jaitdas3582]

They probably dismissed it as wind noises imo

[@thebook-ishangle4041]

Yeah...

[@Potato-1423]

This is a bit off topic, but it’s somewhat a theory. I was listening to a Disney song from Princess and the Frog. “Friends on the Other Side”. Dr. Facilier who’s singing the song said he was royal in his mother’s side. I’d do it, but you guys are the professionals :P

[@bigc6818]

Dr. Facilier

[@Potato-1423]

A man of many talents Thanks!

[@xgardenofedenx]

What he meant by that is that his mother was probably a pretty esteemed voodoo practitioner, and hence considered like a royal in that community. Considering what he's able to do with black magic I'm sure he got most of his experience/power from her.

[@bigc6818]

You're welcome

[@nickdillhoff6794]

But what is the theory exactly....this isn't a theory just a comment

[@sydnickiB]

Their littlie pumpkin drawings at the beginning were so adorable!!!

[@CaptainRiterraSmith]

QUIZ! HALLOWEEN QUIZ ON SCB! Thought you ought to know. (faints)

[@LesliePaige]

This had the funniest interactions and responses! Love you guys

[@zermeenkhan249]

Finally I’ve done my waiting for a quiz like this 12 YEARS OF IT IN AZKABAN

[@wendyaftowicz7570]

J added an answer later...cheating! lol throwing the flag!

[@EARFQ]

Nice hats!

[@bibida4499]

Those quizzes might be the only videos on youtube that I can enjoy half an hour 😁I love your videos 😍

[@vermontvampyre]

Jay that point you took was cheatsy so Ben beat you on the age line questions >:(

[@eileentherien8285]

IVE BEEN BINGING YOUR HARRY POTTER VIDEOS! got so excited when i saw a brand new one! : )

[@idunrudemo]

THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT I NEED AND WANT RIGHT NOW!❤️❤️

[@summerthoughts7681]

Idun Rudemo same

[@rheachang593]

Every movie ever Harry: did you hear the voices? Hermione: there aren't any voices Harry: you said that last time and there WAS voices Hermione: So? Harry: fine

[@DeniseF]

Be careful doing a 12 hours stream.Make sure you move around regularly and take breaks from the screen.sorry I sound like a mother hen here lol

[@_carlioux1711]

I too feel worried.. 12 hours is a long time!

[@sophieosu]

Im pretty much sitting in my chair 12 hours a day so...

[@childhoodisthatyou9869]

It sounds like fun. Especially if you get paid for it.

[@dutchik5107]

@Rose Wheeler well after like 9 hours or so people usually aren't having fun anymore. But getting paid is good

[@DeniseF]

@Rose Wheeler I'm just more concerned with the constant sitting down.i hope they take turns in having breaks ya know. You always here of people doing long streams without drinking or moving around and they collapse and sometimes even die..I'm sure they'll be fine but still lol