J vs Ben: ULTIMATE Marauder's Quotes Harry Potter TRIVIA Quiz

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Get your tickets for our LIVE TRIVIA event in Roanoke :: www.eventbrite.com/e/super-carlin-brothers-go-fest-trivia-night-tickets-694221734897

[@danielsantiagourtado3430]

Nice!😊😊😊

[@stevefontaine1335]

SuperCarlinBrothers Lord Of The Rings Film Theory Video.?🙏🙏🙏🎥

[@lordvanilla8075]

Harry Potter and the worst spectator sport.

[@PhilBagels]

Harry Potter and the Hungarian Horntail Harry Potter and the Weird, Creepy Eye Harry Potter and the Yule Ball Harry Potter and the Tri-Wizard Champions Harry Potter and the Ferret in Goyle's Pants

[@scottchadwick1247]

Well, whenever they shape shifted as anamagi to hangout with Lupin, they were, technically streaking.

[@PalmelaHanderson]

The whole thing Ben said about how Peter went back to Voldemort of all people because he was scared of Remus and Sirius should also give a big clue into how powerful those 2 were in their own right. And how powerful James would have been. And the fact that all of them, potentially, had a killer streak in them.

[@praharmitra]

The fact that they became animagi AND created the map should really be enough proof that they were already insanely strong wizards as children. In the year or two before the fall of Voldemort, it is entirely possible that they were in the top 10 most powerful wizards of that time period.

[@kqyrtic]

@@praharmitra if hagrid didnt get kicked out i think hed be somewhere in top 10

[@xyreniaofcthrayn1195]

@@kqyrtic true but hagrid would likely be charlie weasley's mentor in romania if he hadn't been chucked out.

[@peppapig-4665]

There are many examples one could use to prove their power (created marauder’s map, became animagi, etc.). One thing I’d like to say, though, is that all of them DEFINITELY had a killer streak in them. They fought in a war for years, for goodness sake 😂

[@klaudiagrob]

I always thought that Peter liked sorrounding himself with people who seemed strong to him.

[@lex9313]

mauraders content is top tier i’m so happy

[@mauraaa2988]

the reality of being a marauders stan is not knowing what’s canon anymore…

[@evab0beva]

SO REAL like i had no idea The Prank wasnt canon until someone called me out for it on pinterest 😭

[@Idekjustwhatever]

​@@evab0bevaYou mean when Sirius tricked Snape into going to the Shrieking Shack? That's canon

[@chelseafedy9046]

@mauraa2988 ikr

[@ella.r]

@@evab0bevaIsn’t that canon?

[@MissAlexisBlack]

@@evab0bevathat is canon…

[@gingerkays7362]

I always found it really heartwarming that when James, Sirius, and Peter found out about Remus’ “furry little problem” (that was their nickname for it) they didn’t abandon him like he feared and instead went through the difficult process of becoming animagi to make his time as a Werewolf a lot easier and more comfortable

[@maryann4451]

I think Sirius's treatment of Kreacher was because he was a reminder of Sirius's childhood trauma, not because he was a house elf (still doesn't make it okay that he treated him like that but that was my interpretation).

[@thedragonwarrior5861]

Yeah, Dumbledore says that Sirius was kind to house elves in general, but Kreacher was a reminder of the home and people he hated

[@peppapig-4665]

Sirius has a very valid reason to be upset with Kreacher, but I still don’t think he should have been so scolding and harsh. I don’t blame him, though, because Kreacher didn’t exactly make it easy for Sirius to be nice.

[@JennifuhhGilardi]

Kreacher spouted off old family ignorance that Sirius never stood for and he was pretty nasty and rude so 🤷🏼‍♀️ you can not be prejudiced against a group and still not like a member of that group

[@peppapig-4665]

@@JennifuhhGilardi yes, he was nasty and rude, but he also had the capability of being extremely caring and nice, as we see when the trio finally get on his good side. And, as Hermione pointed out, Kreacher was only repeating what he had heard his entire life. But still, even after centuries of listening to nonsense from pure bloods and even believing it himself, he found a way to be kind to the ones who were kind to him, even if they were ‘filthy’.

[@almudd]

Yeah I think Sirius' character is very interesting because he "knows" a lot of things he should live by, but he can't live to it that easily 😅

[@darthmagnum2007]

Huge missed opportunity during question 12 as they are joking about Voldy knocking on the Potter's door, since they have been making Jimmy Potts Nascar jokes. "Hi, I'm Tommy Riddles, and I've been trying to reach out about your car's extended warranty."

[@Beeba10]

Maybe the scene's different in the books, I can't remember, but in the movies the "The world isn't split into good people and Death Eaters" line was when Harry was confiding in Sirius in OOTP that he thought he was becoming bad, because of his dreams/visions.

[@peppapig-4665]

Yes, this is what came to my mind as well.

[@Moony385]

In the book it was about umbridge because harry felt his scar hurt when umbridge touched him

[@keyblademasterclark]

There's one quote I was waiting to see on this quiz. "I DID MY WAITING! 12 YEARS OF IT! IN AZKABAN PRISON!" Plot twist: It was Teddy Lupin

[@Caffeinated_Firefly]

"The world isn't split into good people and death eaters, We've all got both light and dark inside us. What matters is the part we choose to act on" is my favorite Sirius quote and basically why he was my favorite character for a while, I would have NOT struggled with that one 😂

[@thedragonwarrior5861]

You got to admit, Goblet of Fire does sound way more mystical/intriguing than Tri-wizard Tournament

[@agustinfranco0]

you guys should do a movie vs book quiz. all about things different from each other and having to answer what happens in a particular one like "in the movie, what happens to the elder wand?" "in the books..:"

[@wannabeellewoods8570]

it's always a good day when supercarlinbrothers posts a J vs Ben🥳

[@erikamohrmann7986]

I never used to watch them cause they looked so long, but this past summer i got all caught up and now i watch them whenever they come out

[@aderoninone3244]

On a quiz like this, there should be bonus points for when it was said. Helps to add more since the pool if answers is so limited here

[@mrborgeusborg1541]

Book 4 should really be named: "Harry Potter and the 3rd time Voldemort tries to kill me and fails".

[@jamesgardner4738]

Technically it would be the 4th time.

[@nathaniel6324]

​@jamesgardner4738 no. in prisoner, voldemort is not in the book.

[@Devlinator61116]

@@nathaniel6324 1 when Harry was one year old, 2 at the end of Philospher's Stone, 3 at the end of Chamber of Secrets, 4 at the end of Goblet of Fire.

[@mrborgeusborg1541]

@@Devlinator61116 correct. when typing and not factchecking in my head, I didn't count the 1 year old incident. My mistake.

[@JennifuhhGilardi]

Pretty sure prisoner is the one story where there isn’t a plan for Voldemort to kill Harry but sure

[@desmondgentle1474]

The funny thing is, when they're talking about Voldemort not going up to peoples' doors and knocking on them, he does that exact thing in Deathly Hallows. Harry has a vision of him abroad while he's still looking for Gregorovich and he knocks on the front door of a house and waits for someone to open it.

[@peppapig-4665]

What, really?! Now I can’t stop imagining how hilarious it would have been for a passerby to see! 🤣🤣

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

SO TRUE 😂

[@Lovesmusic0218]

“Welcome to another evening of evenings……. This week we will discuss this evening's news” 😂 I'm going to use that 0:07

[@carlrood4457]

The thing to keep in mind is we only have Snapes' memories to go on. Memory isn't like a video recording. Our own prejudices and biases taint them. They even change over time. Just look at studies on eye witness accounts. Multiple people can witness the exact same events and have wildly diverging stories.

[@BitterBrit]

Ordinarily I would agree with you on this, because you're right for a person's memories and how we play them back in our heads. But most of the memories are shown through a Pensieve and they don't work like that. It allows you to play back the memory as if you were there. During the Snape's Worst Memory chapter Harry is capable of seeing a lot more than I would think a person would be consciously capable of remembering. And if they were tampered with, like Slughorn's memories in book 6, there would be signs of distortion. As far as we're told, that's not the case.

[@noblegas8485]

​@@BitterBritthere's tampering and there's actually misremembering and misinterpreting stuff

[@BitterBrit]

@@noblegas8485 Sure. But that's what I already addressed in reference to the Pensieve. You're not remembering anything, you're just there. It's written almost as a form of pseudo time travel considering Harry was able to just wander about and pay attention to the surroundings around him whilst Snape had his head in his DADA test paper. And it's Snape's memory. I don't know about you, but if I was so thoroughly absorbed in a piece of paper (or likely parchment) I'd have close to zero recollection of my surroundings. But Harry was able to wander about. My point is, there's no way for the memory to be misinterpreted in the form of a Pensieve. That's why Dumbledore uses it in the Goblet of Fire when it's introduced - for clarity.

[@scarlett.23]

@@BitterBritI agree with your point. That’s why Dumbledore uses Pensieve in the first place- in his head, the memories are vague, distorted and biased, with time all little details forgotten. But in the Pensieve, he can see clearly what was happening during the trial like on video tape. Pensieve is a powerful magical artifact so it makes sense

[@silverrsea]

@@BitterBrit But it still doesn't change the fact that what we saw was of Snape's memories of the Marauders, no? Sure the Pensieve shows you memories in a third person's POV, but it still just ultimately shows how the boys interacted with him and not how they interacted with other people.

[@m-edesharnais5409]

3:06 Hearing you guys talking about the endlessly charming Gentleman-Burglar that is Arsène Lupin just made me smile ear to ear!! 😁😁😁 For the people who don't know, Arsène Lupin is an older french book series, where Arsène Lupin would as easily break in an unbreakable place and take all the valuables just for kicks, or as easily climb mountains (so to speak) to help or save the life of a woman just because he was charmed by her smile or touched by her tears! I'm a terrible salesperson, but they are REALLY DELICIOUSLY GOOD!! And YES, he did had not one but two battles of wits with Sherlock Holmes in one book!! (Although for copyright reasons, he was hilariously named Herlock Sholmes!! Not even joking!!!)

[@TatsuChi]

There was also a Japanese Manga/Anime spin-off based around his grandson called Lupin The Third

[@ella.r]

such a good show!!!

[@m-edesharnais5409]

@@TatsuChi Oh, that's nice!! I'd love to read it!! 😊

[@Mary_Studios]

So that's where Herlock Sholmes came from in the Great Ace Attorney Cronicles

[@thirteenthandy]

Speaking of "ze grindylows," I'm re-reading Goblet right now and that part came up last night. I started cracking up when I realized that it's a direct reference to what Fleur says herself. Now I wonder if Emma Watson improvised it just because it was a Fleur line given to Hermione.

[@neilfan1016]

i believe it was improvised

[@emmerya5515]

The bit about Voldemort knocking on doors makes me rhink of that one knock knock joke x,D - Knock Knock - who's there? - You know... - You know who? - Exactly. Avada Kedavra!

[@CrazyMuggleGirl]

“Martin Miggs:The Mad Muggle” is the comic book found in Ron’s bedroom when Harry first visits the Burrow in Chamber of Secrets lol, I feel like Jimmy Potts and Weary Siri are definitely in that comic as guest characters 😂 they are mad Muggles for sure. James and Sirius race each other with their car and motorcycle (respectively) as the bikini-clad Muggle women (as seen on the poster in Sirius’ bedroom) cheer them on, haha

[@superpotterfan7435]

I love that they used the “Until the very end” quote!!! That’s the quote I chose for my Harry Potter tattoo! I liked it way more than “Always”

[@novasmith2604]

I like that a lot. Always, typically feels creepy to me cause really snape is just super obsessive

[@Cflea797]

I always found it interesting that the 3 friends went by different parts of their names. Sirius by his first name, Lupin by his last, and Wormtail by his nickname.

[@stecky87]

Sirius makes sense - he hates (justifiably) his family. He'd probably avoid using the family name as much as possible

[@novasmith2604]

I think that’s probably for the readers benefit in prt. One Sirius would be sirius because there are multiple blacks (also hates his family). Remus would be referred to as lupin more often because when Harry (and us the readers) are introduced to him he is a professor and so for most of the book he is referred to as Professor Lupin and then they just drop the title (sorta like Hagrid, plenty of times I forget that that isn’t his first name). Wormtail is a bit more difficult to figure out but I thinks it’s because he was originally scabbers and so calling him a more human name is weird

[@eranshachar9954]

I love the Ben vs. J episodes so fun. I hope to compete with the brothers one day on Potter knowledge because I love the books and the movies. I restart reading every time for like I don't know how long and this is still fun to do and never boring.

[@nyahtonks3914]

the BRB is funnier when they literally just talked abt how there’s a wall right there and ben would be trapped if he went that way. nice

[@belzebuthdesign]

I always thought that James looked like such a bad person in his time at Hogwarts because we see him from Snape perspective. And Snape HATES him...

[@quinnowens5621]

Maybe he was just a bad person, that’s okay too.

[@robfab5204]

​@@quinnowens5621no it's not

[@Rooster33Rooster]

Well we always say that Harry would never do anything like that to anyone but we seem to forget that Harry and friends jinxes Malfoy Crab and Goyal so bad that they looked like oozing slugs on the train back from Hogwarts

[@WHYARENOHANDLESAVAILABLE1]

@@Rooster33Roosterthat was self-defence

[@donb7519]

​@@quinnowens5621thatd be fine if everyone didnt love the guy and we didnt know harrys angel of a mom falls for him

[@gabrielellis3334]

7:00 its in order of the phoenix when harry is first starting to deal with the Voldemort connection and starts to wonder if something is going wrong with him

[@mauraaa2988]

YES omg im glad a show like Lupin is getting recognition internationally, bc Omar Sy (the main actor, he’s really famous in france) is so good !!

[@sawanna508]

Yes, I am thankfull for recomenting this show. I didn't know about it and it sounds interessting. I know the charackter Arsene Lupin and Omar Sy of course.

[@klaudiagrob]

Quote 5 is one that I always found weird in terms of phrasing. I like this quiz. James wasnt a bad person. He was spoiled definitely. But he was a best friend for his friends. He just had to grow up.

[@JennifuhhGilardi]

HIGHLY RECOMMEND READING OR LISTENING TO ‘ALL THE YOUNG DUDES’ which is a fanfic about the marauders time at hogwarts and it’s literal magic. I’ve never read fan fiction before but I think I love it more than HP in general.

[@savinizm]

Ethan is the best host ever!!! He doesn’t give unnecessary hints and can actually be silent during discussion

[@BroCo87]

Throwing shade at kangaroo Kat??? 😂

[@CharlesOffdensen]

9:22 When Luke leaves Dagoba: "Luke, you are truly your father's son." 12:26 funniest quote in all of the books. A bit cruel to Snape though.

[@BadJaMon]

You guys should end with a wager question like Jeopardy. So whichever brother happens to be behind has a chance to come back with a huge gamble of all his points especially if J plays it safe

[@siriusorionblack_59]

MARAUDERS FOR THE WIN

[@arthurxavier3515]

You could also say J and Ben are playing ALL questions with multiple choice

[@Caranig]

Anybody else mildly shaken to learn that the space he appears to walk into for the beginning of the BRB/Scenic Route bits is just a wall? I kinda figured it was an open space or out a doorway or something ... 😂

[@enbyrennn]

THE MARAUDERS LETS GOOOO THIS IS MY TIME TO SHINE

[@autumn1284]

This episode was so fun. Lupin is such a great show. Highly recommend. Also royal candle club poison apple smells amazing. I’m burning it now.

[@goodsamaritangaming1997]

Harry Potter and a series of unfortunate events. 😂😂 Harry Potter and the Goblet of Mysteries. Not much different, but there are more mysteries in the year than there is fire.

[@calebfeener9508]

Awesome quiz! It was my first time getting 100% of the questions correct on your quizzes!

[@toribellmar7623]

ohhh this is right for my marauders era heart ♥️ brothers treating us with marauders videos yay! (passionately waiting for more ‘what ifs’ in which sirius lives)

[@eltanin.amelia]

I can't believe the guys didn't know the third one straight away. that is one of my favourite scenes in the whole series.

[@ravenjoybower]

*knocks on door* "Hello, we're just here recruiting for your friendly neighbourhood Death Eaters. Lots of fun, plenty of power, bit of Muggle torturing, it's really quite lovely."

[@pvuccino]

I always thought the Marauder's Map was sort of like Tom Riddle's diary, in the way that it preserved the image of their teenage selves.

[@bilboswaggings]

I think the fearing fear itself being wise isn't wise in itself, but it is wise in comparison to most other things you could fear

[@brandontodd1728]

0:40 "James doesn't have that many quotes", dark joke but so true

[@shaba2229]

I think Daniel should be in a painting for the fan service, it’s very very small but it’ll show up often and randomly

[@morganstiefvater2019]

I've always thought book four should be And The Tri Wizard Tournament, but J has convinced me otherwise with the throwaway line about the prevailing mystery of that book.

[@productofpixiedust]

I’ve rewatched this for like 3-4 hrs bc I’m at work and keep getting distracted… or it’s a really good video. More Marauders vids pls ☺️

[@brandibastian4193]

Not going to lie. When you guys were talking about Voldemort knocking on the door I was picturing something like in Terminator when the gun was in a box of flowers 😂

[@supervegito2277]

22:20 I remember the teaser text on the back of OOTP covering that line. And when the 5th book released my parents got all 5, and thats how i began reading them.

[@caraslaboszewski2275]

'Until the very end.' 'Always.' Boys, you need to have a talk.

[@izzysmith105]

I love that question 3 was in there, I remember them saying it wrong in a video ages ago and finally they're corrected on it!

[@danielsantiagourtado3430]

Love these trivias! Thanks for making them! Love to play with you!🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤

[@parthjha955]

Handwriting and marking each question number gives away who's the older brother here

[@UnfazedPhoenix]

I was having the worst day. You guys made me laugh so much. The intro was great 😂 thank you ❤

[@maxwell9211]

What’s funny is Daniel Radcliffe is the exact age, 34, that Lupin and Sirius would have been when they first met in the third book

[@leslienope]

On top of the goblet being the central mystery, it's also the portkey that takes Harry and Cedric to the graveyard, so it is literally central to the overall arc of the series. I think GoF is the right title for that reason.

[@jamesgardner4738]

The Tri-Wizard Cup is turned into the portkey. The Goblet of Fire is just a Magical impartial "Judge" that selects the 3 champions.

[@leslienope]

@@jamesgardner4738 OMG. Can you believe that I actually sat here for several minutes, thinking to myself "That is right, isn't it? Yeah it's the same cup.... right? Yeah" before posting my comment?? And yet still ended up being ridiculously wrong 😆

[@almudd]

This quiz is pure hilarious chaos! Very worthy of the marauders 🫡 I would pay to just watch Ben and J discuss the marauders generally

[@MegaMeg117]

I think if they would have called the book HP and the Triwizard Tournament, we all would have just assumed Harry was going to be participating from the get go.

[@TheRavensNest]

Hearing them say Sirius hits different for me now. We named our son Sirius (he's five weeks old so it's still pretty new) . 😂

[@philippzimmerer1280]

Only missed the "until the end" one. Loved this!

[@selonianth]

As a note regarding why James did that specific thing to Snape, the "wash out your mouth" as I recall it was immediately after Snape called her a mudblood when she tried to help him with the Marauders. James, being an anti-pureblood supremacist and... also having the hots for Lily, immediately punishes Snape for his slur. Meaning that while it is certainly not a nice thing to do, it's far from the cruel act it sounds like. Though... they're plenty mean to him anyway, but I'm pretty sure the implication is that Snape was just as bad if not worse (given he was trying to get in with Lucius and the Pureblood Supremacists in Slytherin)

[@nicholeginsberg8601]

The only place we see James as a character is in the memory of someone who hates him, and yet everyone agrees that this memory is 100% accurate. Im sure James wasn't as bad as Snape remembers him

[@metagross999]

4:00 I had exactly the same process as J: remembered the exact scene except for whether it was Sirius or James, thought it made sense to fill in the lack of James quotes but thought Sirius made more sense, got it wrong

[@henriettajsoneskelin7806]

Why did I know all of them before SCB had time to answer, I haven't revised the books or the movies in years but it was satisfying discovering my main interest through my teenage years and young adulthood is still part of me ❤ I lived and breathed The Marauders every day for 15 years! I'm 32 now and swamped with mom life. Also, laughed so many times, loved this!😂

[@aschultz09]

“Let’s get cozy” immediately into an ad for the next exorcist movie 👌

[@Caranig]

Wow! This is the first HP quiz where I've gotten 100%. I really didn't expect that.

[@rawdaaljawhary4174]

Nice!

[@rupaloveadama8012]

i mean, if you were hearing harrys story from the perspective of draco.... im sure it would sound a lot like snape talking about james

[@prernanix4329]

It’s also called Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire because it is the Goblet that takes Harry to the Graveyard in the end. 31:49

[@jamesgardner4738]

No, it is the Tri-Wizard Cup that takes Harry and Cedric to the graveyard and back.

[@EmberFrayStories]

I love Fridays, you get PopCorn Culture and a Video! Thanks for the joy guys

[@Stan_Merrill]

I'm still waiting for a film or series about the Marauders and the Founders.

[@laureprivat2368]

Funny you're mentioning Ewan McGregor; I read back in the days that he was considered for the role of Lupin

[@t.j.armendariz354]

Ben “I’ll take a chance” Me: “like deciding to go to the streaming shack?”

[@stecky87]

I'm so use to Ben waffling, it's weird to see J do so. Remus is easily the best Marauder - he's the most level-headed

[@shdynasty94]

Whoo! A rare perfect score for me - lots of laughs throughout the episode too!

[@CarrotsKing]

i was waiting for "that Sirius Black grin" quote...

[@maia.papaya]

I got tickets for the live trivia im so pumpedddd

[@pizzadohpaz]

This is my favorite reader of questions 😂😂 he's great

[@kulygirl5966]

Instead of playing along me and my daughter pick a team for each quiz 😅

[@_pearl_]

Oo I would love a what’s so wise about fearing fear itself video!!

[@Filip-zt2yw]

Can we have a "Golden trio Quotes" next? Q: What did Ron say when they got back after meeting Fluffy for the first time? or Q: Who said " I'm a what?"

[@bellaknightR597]

Is it weird that I imagine James as a father (had he survived to do so) being a combination of Amos Diggory and Gilderoy Lockheart? 😂😂😂 **cool magic happens** Random witch or wizard: Who did that? James: it was prrrretty obvious it was my boy

[@billysmith5409]

These two are definitely the sons of a news caster.

[@Smooby_Dooperson]

15:33 Ben you’re talking about Coke 😂😂😂 drink it or take that rust off your car !

[@Reno52593]

I like the thumbnail on this one!! It doesn't give away the answer, because it really could have been either one lol

[@sounddragon5505]

Playing catch with a cannonball sound like Garp and Luffy playing catch! 🤣

[@topknotg5530]

When you started asking if he had seen the series Lupin my first thought was Lupin III, which is a long lived anime series (dating back to the '70s) whose titular character is the grandson of the Gentleman Thief Arsene Lupin from the old French stories

[@hollypepen4012]

Yay Marauders!! Also, Harry Potter and Everyone Needs a Haircut (at least the movie) 😅🤣😂

[@joly6598]

DARN IT, @SuperCarlinBrothers!~ xD

[@aishaazeemah4289]

The justification of bullying at the end there XD

[@whitewolf2875]

Love it!!! Also is their going to be a live action little mermaid review soon??

[@jakemustian99]

Absolutely throwing shade at helena. "Bit of a softball" "yea, i think so"

[@brandibastian4193]

I feel like people are going to be sending you art of Jimmy Potts comics now

[@Liam-pv7ti]

This was a roller coaster of an episode for me, J fan

[@mecahhannah]

Awesome as always thanks

[@EmilyCheetham]

Daniel Radcliffe has already categorically said he will NOT come back for future Wizarding world movies or tv shows. Not as Harry OR as any other character. He does NOT want fan service or to take the spot light away from any other characters of any age.

[@rubygracemoseley8144]

This was such a fun quiz! I got 12 of them right! I was very confident because I knew there’d mainly just be two people involved so it was mainly just me trying to decide between Sirius and Lupin but I’m still very proud of myself