Jacobite Rebellions | 3 Minute History

[@hi24times]

had to watch this to understand outlander lol

[@hi24times]

RBX HBMGeorgeHannoverIII same

[@malinmadsen8527]

Same, I'm reading the first book rn

[@msrainbowbrite]

haha ... me too

[@asaubgar7]

Lol me too I became interested in Scotland history & the highlands

[@aloktaishika893]

Same here

[@colinveacock5408]

Had the privilege to walk the Culloden Battlefield a few days ago. An eerie, quiet, place.

[@aga3714]

seems like almost everyone's here because of outlander... I feel u guys

[@R2BattleSquadron]

The hell is outlander?

[@mel4776]

@@R2BattleSquadron A tv show

[@markme4]

I'm more confused than when I got here

[@toErehWon]

Jacobite, were of the nation of Israel. Israel were 12 lost tribes. The Caucasian Eskenazi stole their identity, and are known as Jewish. The true Israelites today, are the so called Black, Hispanic, and NATIVE American. I think.

[@toErehWon]

@@igloo2962 I'm fine thank you, why? Do you have supporting facts to a claim?

[@toErehWon]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/j2jccqCjqJitn8U Lies

[@ocearbhaill3894]

ReCogNation - Na bro lol.

[@asafcohen8796]

@@toErehWon nah you're wrong Ashkenazi are also Jews but all of the Jews today are descendants of 2 of the 12 lost tribes. The other 10 tribes either married people from different religions or became the Samaritans it depends who you ask.

[@morgant.dulaman8733]

I did a paper on this last semester. Nice job summarizing what was a really convoluted (and in my opinion, a very underdiscussed) area of history.

[@Thumbsupurbum]

4:10 and they burned all the pies too? That's just evil.

[@bonniejonstarkiedakinginda3005]

The jacobites burned them so that fat Cumberland could not eat them!

[@rachdarastrix5251]

I'd have to agree that Jacobite pies must not fall into the evil hands of the English.

[@itsaguinness]

The Dishonored Coward Just turn them into mincemeat

[@pickeljarsforhillary102]

Aye! Now ya dunn it you Anglish bastards!!!!!!

[@jonathanredacted3245]

anyway, the spencers, princess di's family, were descended from both charles II and his brother james, so when william or his children ascend to the throne barring any horrific accidents, a descendent of the last two stuart kings will rule.

[@patricialmt5272]

Jonathan Simms Oh wow !!! Good to know!!!

[@pinkroseperson256]

3:13 MaRk mE, jAmEs

[@bonniejonstarkiedakinginda3005]

4:14 At least we burned the pies after culloden so that fat Cumberland could not eat them! A call this a victory!

[@wazza33racer]

Many jacobite scots were recruited by Tsar Peter the Great, and made an important contribution to the modern, Tsarist russian military, that enabled key victories in naval and land battles.

[@tillerman7272]

The Russian navy flag is an inverted Scottish flag to pay homage to them

[@cesarchavez5235]

Do a Video of : -Great Turkish War -Greek War of Independence -4th Crusade -Franco German War (1870) -Mexican American War -American Civil War -Vietnam War -Soviet Afghan War -Mongol invasion of Europe -First Roman Jewish War BTW: I´m really glad i found your channel ,so keep up the good work :)

[@HsienKoMeiLingFormerYANG]

First Indochina War & French Involved in Mexico too.

[@priamopastor6691]

season 3 of outlander is coming soon

[@klausj1544]

Priamo Pastor September my dude

[@dinger167]

3:12 for the 3rd jackobite uprising

[@liamgleeson3957]

There was an other war in Ireland were what was left of the Jacobite link in with Irish rebels

[@klausj1544]

Outlander is the best

[@nosferatuoddz7974]

Isn't it a romantic story?

[@thedumbdog1964]

First episode was pure shit. The book was nice though

[@kevinhendryx665]

No mention of the battle of Falkirk (Jan. 1746), an important Jacobite victory; the last uprising seems overly rushed and simplistic. And invoking "the divine right of kings" as a basis for Jacobitism seems a bit of a stretch. Probably suffers from attempting to throw too much into a mere 3 minutes.

[@kevinhendryx665]

PS: Outlander has a much to do with Jacobite history as The Sound of Music has to do with the Second World War.

[@JabzyJoe]

+Kevin Hendryx I only mention battles that had an impact on the course of the war, so decisive victories, change the tide etc. So, why do you think Falkirk Muir was that important? And you dont think they believed in the divine rights of Kings?

[@Alan_Mac]

"the divine right of kings" was the essence of the Jacobites' case. An utterly absurd position to take and thank God we Scots rounded on the empty-headed idiots. Shame we can't do the same to today's ScotNuts.

[@aaronaustin225]

@@Alan_Mac Nonsense, that was NOT the essence on Jacobitism. It was a war because of the British Monarchy being Catholic, and whether the Monarchy would rule AND reign and not submit to oligarchy parliamentarian rule.

[@Alan_Mac]

@@aaronaustin225 Of course it was. The whole point of the Revolution of 1688 was to assert the sovereignty of parliament. Various Jacobite fuckwits then tried to turn the clock back so they could have a divine monarchy again but, thankfully, failed.

[@thegreatwalrus6574]

Do "Anglo-Zanzibar war I 41 minute history".

[@agungpriambodo1674]

Not 41 minutes but 36

[@redneckhapa]

What a tough decision. I'm half Scottish and raised Protestant in America. I'm not sure if I would have supported the Catholic King or "divine right of kings", which is what the Jacobites wanted, but then I would have wanted to have a sovereign Scotland. I would have been a Scottish Protestant nationalist.

[@JuanKuzov]

the jacobites were not nationalists

[@nutyyyy]

A lot of the support came from opposition to the act of union. The Scottish Jacobites wanted to end the union and return to the three kingdom monarchy that existed from 1603-1707. During both the 1715 and 1745 risings James and Charles both officially dissolved the union after being declared king and regent of Scotland respectively. It's not quite as simple as calling it a war of independence because it was more complicated than that, however a Jacobite victory would result in a break up of the union (and a return to the previous arrangement of three Kingdoms with separate parliaments ruled by one king. This was popular with Scots and the Irish as well as some Anglicans in England because the British state had been increasingly centralised from 1688 onwards. The Irish obviously favoured a Catholic king but also saw the Stuart's as having rightful claim to the High Kingship of Ireland due to lineage. Scots generally opposed the Union, especially in the early years and 1715 was by far the largest rising and was declared with the express goal of ending the union. There were many other factors that motivated Jacobites and they often overlapped. There were very few Catholics in Scotland by the 1700s but there was a big divide between Presbyterians and Episcopalians though the split was not always clear cut. Episcopalians generally supported the Jacobite cause not only because of anti-union sentiments but also to reverse the establishment of the Presbyterian Kirk as the official church of Scotland. Conversely this is why most opponents of the Jacobites in Scotland were Presbyterians however there were also many presbyterians who per the Jacobites for other reasons. These reasons included an unease about the union, as many feared that just as in the 1640s there would be an attempt by the English to restore episcopalianism as the state religion of Scotland. Others were uneasy particularly in 1715 about having a Lutheran German King - important to remember that the hanoverians for much of their reign were also of a different religion to their subjects. The focus on Hanover also caused resentment among the English which is why there was more Jacobite activity in England in 1715 than in 45. The other thing to remember is that it was harder to stage a rising in England than in Scotland. The British troops were more abundant and government control was more established so many suspected Jacobites could be captured or subdued before organised resistance was established. Plus England since the end of the civil war was a much less martial society in the civilian sphere than in Scotland. So in other words it was harder to mobilise the Jacobites in England than it was in Scotland. Also by the end of the rising Lowlanders and scots speaking Eastern Highlanders were a majority in the army, not Gaels.

[@Megabeat30]

You might want to read the records on the Jacobites my dude ..as per 'Jacobites Gleanings from State Manuscripts: Short Sketches of Jacobites' by J. macbeth Forbes , all of the Jacobites taken prisoner after the Wars and taken to the American plantations were described as "black"persons (with few exceptions)

[@og-greenmachine8623]

Let them be fools. 👉🏽Nice from this side😎 -Little Chief🦅 Arawak Choctaw Blackfoot Cherokee

[@David-lu4gq]

Well, it wasn't really a "glorious revolution". And the Jacobites were not crushed in Ireland at the Battle of the Boyne. James left for France to gain more support after completing a successful reargaurd action to get his forces away. With James gone, the Irish Jacobites fell back to the West, and fought for another year. They were crushed that Aughrim, where their commander was decapitated by a Williamite cannonball. As he was the only one who knew the plan of battle, the Irish Jacobites were slaughtered. About 7000 of them. Then the seige of Limerick occured, which led to the flight of the Wild geese, and the Brits breaking the Treaty of Limerick. Wait, that would be 20 minutes.

[@SuperZadie]

Outlander brought me here. lol

[@rocknrollkid90]

Could you review, “The Troubles?”

[@antoniodebouff820]

Did you use Microsoft paint for these drawings: they're SPECTACULAR!!!

[@buchan448]

lol true masterpieces

[@AlfonsLC]

Ye Jacobites by name. Lend an ear lend an ear

[@iainhowe4561]

Ye Jacobites by name, your faults I shall proclaim and your doctrines I shall blame, ye will hear, ye will hear.

[@drdst27]

@@iainhowe4561 It all was for our rightful King.

[@nicklester8977]

Do you like CGP Grey?

[@Megabeat30]

The nick-name of Chevalier de St. George, the hero of the Jacobites, was the Black Bird due to his "black" complexion [Ref. The Scottish Songs: Collected and Illustrated, Vol 2. By Robert Chambers]

[@vestty5802]

You forgot the Irish who fought on both sides

[@Al3oxnfri]

1:24 - The battle of Killy Kranky. I had to rewind this video, like I do Outlander, to understand lol.

[@joshuamccoy2803]

*Killiecrankie

[@shellyb1237]

I'm doing a history writing thing that has to be like ten pages I'm just starting It's 2:02am I need to go to school and hand it in tommorow I need to wake up at 7 to catch my bus And there is no info about the jacobites because it got deleted YAY

[@tomashize]

Clear and concise, a good intro to the topic.Thank ye kind

[@edwardhogan1877]

Thanks for posting-very enlightening and concise account of Jacobite movement in Scotland. First time I have grasped the historical timeline.

[@rzabala8943]

When you're reading an article of history or current events. Does anyone else picture Jabzy reading it for you?

[@yaboyed5779]

Y’all gonna make me watch Outlander now

[@alaskaball188]

My Clan, Clan MacMillan, was divided during the rebellion, some Joined the Jacobites and others stayed Neutral , I dont know of any who joined the Unionists, likley none considering they were highlanders

[@Emperor_of_all_Badgers]

We'll be back

[@robertjarman3703]

It's worth remembering how closely linked all these timelines were. I mean, the Salem Witch Trials were held at the same time as the original Glorious revolution, Quebec City was captured by the British Armies about 15 years after the last Jacobite revolt and George Washington was born before the second rebellion. Centralization like we see with modern nation states is actually much newer than many think.

[@buchan448]

im from galashiels Scotland just found yer chanel randomly, have subscribed and pressed the bell :D

[@HubertSylwester]

Wha'll be king but Cherlie?

[@lizzy1124]

Did you draw these pictures?? Btw htx for the video. it really helped me with my homework:)

[@LordFoppingtonIII]

What was the mistake?

[@JabzyJoe]

+LordFoppingtonIII I said Clan Campbells were killed at Glencoe, but they did the killing. So it was pretty bad.

[@og-greenmachine8623]

👉🏽Colors

[@hawamypower2428]

In Benjamin Franklins book he described all these guys as dark in skin color.

[@xtopia9758]

this was my first ever video on KZbin I watched it on the 21 March 2017. it’s weird to think that this was the only channel I watched back then. why did I not subscribe?

[@JabzyJoe]

Welcome back though!

[@xtopia9758]

Thanks jazby u r awesome

[@NaviRyan]

It's funny my mother loves outlander is married to a Fraser and we looked at old paintings my dad looks like simon the fox except without a wig should probably start watching the tv show now that I think about it

[@Daniel-ll2cl]

flare 156 what a incoherent rant

[@cathysmaha9934]

@@Daniel-ll2cl Considering that neither you or I are the grammer police, if you look at what flare 156 wrote, he was missing his punctuations, but was trying to share something with pride and excitement...he wrote... "It's funny. My mother loves outlander, is married to a Fraser, and we looked at old paintings. My dad looks like simon the fox, except without a wig. I should probably start watching the tv show now that I think about it." My apologies if I've offended anyone, but I just don't like to see people get bullied who were in no way rude or obnoxious to anyone. flare 156 was just sharing something of newfound importance with the rest of us here on the forum.

[@raphlvlogs271]

many of those Highlanders immigrated to America due to being pushed out.

[@GG-bw3uz]

jabzy whats the exact music track you use ????

[@2Muchpjp]

Talk about the Cromwell edict of 1653.

[@HiHi-ph9tn]

This helped a lot it's really good 😊 but the title said 3 minutes not 4:33😂😂😂 wow I wondered why it was long.

[@Marvinskanalify]

Hang on. Are the Blackfyre rebellions in ASOIF based on the Jacobite rebellions?

[@ArcticTemper]

Doubt it, the Jacobites were supporting House Stuart - who were displaced by William of Orange. The Blackfyres were the bastard-branch of House Targaryen. Smaller details may be based on this period of British history, but I doubt the overall concept it. Daenerys and her sons not being able to invade Westeros and being forced to find loyal supporters from within and win via revolt would be more like the Jacobite rebellions.

[@AustenKime]

The Blackfyre Rebellions could just as easily be based on Harold Godwinsons brother tostig and his alliance with Harold Hardradda in 1066

[@Catubrannos]

If you're going to shoehorn the clans into ASOIF, then Clan Campbell are the Lannisters and Clan MacDonald are the Starks

[@AustenKime]

Absolutely not. House stark is 100% supposed to be the Yorkists and the lannisters are 100% lancastrian, you'd have to be blind to try and force something else on that influence.

[@Catubrannos]

+Austen Kime Northern England is more catholic (old religion) and York was represented by the white rose. Jacobites were mostly catholic and represented by a white cockade. MacDonalds were catholic mostly and supported the Jacobites. Lannister colour is red, Lancastrian rose is red, they play the political game better and later joined the new religion of protestants. The protestant Campbells were loyal to the new religion over old cultural ties and consistently supported protestant causes staying closer to the centre of power than the more peripheral MacDonalds.

[@benstevinson764]

The Ghost's 👻 of Culloden 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 🎶

[@xrunnells7982]

What do you use for your drawing?

[@JabzyJoe]

Mainly photoshop nowadays.

[@Jhyy28]

Could you make a video about finnish civil war or video about Finlands wars in world war 2(winter war 1939-1940, continuation war 1941-1944 and lapland war 1944-1945)? :)

[@untitled06]

Can u do one on the downfall of the Douglas Clan

[@maxharkin1012]

Have you seen outlander?

[@agungpriambodo1674]

The Highlanders are better than the Lowlanders HERE I GO

[@trishflower7479]

My mother was mostly Scottish. Having watched Outlander twice, I realized I knew practically nothing of her genealogy. Here I am!

[@kingdomofprussia5846]

The Lowlands are be great and small With many lords and lairds Declare for Scotia’s king and law, Wha’ll spear ye war But Cherlie

[@re1v3r]

Made it to about the third minute before I was lost. We need a channel that does TWO MINUTE histories, or else I'll never lern n b st00pid 4evar

[@EddieHD_]

What music are you using?

[@JabzyJoe]

+White Heterosexual Cis Male Nevada City from the KZbin audio library.

[@EddieHD_]

Jabzy Thanks!

[@benstevinson764]

FREEDOM!!! 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@triconcert]

Would have appreciated some pauses to absorb the information deeper but the presentation seemed quite factual and less propagandistic than most histories on the Jacobites. Thanks for sharing.

[@JabzyJoe]

+mark andre augustus Cheers. I'm still trying to sort out the pacing of these videos.

[@mikewilliams7781]

So you haven't figured out how to pause KZbin videos?

[@cathysmaha9934]

actually @mark andre augustus, you can slow it down to about 75 and it's perfect

[@laurensklaassen6869]

would be cool to do a 3 min history on the khazar khanate, a jewish khanate, when you get back from your epic world travels :P

[@og-greenmachine8623]

Got my Bonnie Prince Charles plaid💪🏽 -Little Chief🦅 Arawak Choctaw Blackfoot Cherokee

[@vtx1321]

Could have been a good video had you taken out The religious aspect. There was an element in 1688/89 But it was Not a factor in The 45. You will notice.many of the Educated pro Jacobite readers will try help you in the right direction. There was far more Episcopal Jacobite's than Catholic in The 45 and there were many of The Jacobite officers Protestant and Episcopal too. I've no issue with most of your vid and it's a good simple info vid for outlander fans etc. The serious minded need to read Murray Pittoecks Culliden and go to a Jacobite group webpage. A circle of Gentleman or The Royal oak society of Scotland will always help. Good effort overall

[@johnvonshepard9373]

Why the Brit so Lucky?

[@callummcgregorenthusiast5545]

Proud to be from a Jacobite town. Alba gu brath

[@kolyayerg1118]

Do one about Kazakh revolution!!!!

[@JabzyJoe]

+kolya yerg Afraid it'll be a while before i get to that

[@kolyayerg1118]

Oh its okay its your time.

[@Boom12343]

because this video was so three minute long was it not

[@coconutman2586]

that doesnt make sense If I had to die tomorrow maybe just as cute... *drumroll* MORE FROM POSER WORLD TV! battleshits i like your jacket, where'd you get it

[@kevinwayne259]

here from mcqueen aw95

[@dmcd3895]

My ancestors fought for the Jacobites, fought for the fenian brotherhood and fought for IRA. God knows how I ended up being born in England lol.

[@priamopastor6691]

Scotland should have won the battle of culloden. Prince Edward Stuart should have been king everything would have been better. If only. I wonder what life would have been

[@iainhowe4561]

It sounds like the Scots did, indeed, win the battle of Culloden. They were locked, as always, in their eternal battle with the old enemy, the Scots.

[@Alan_Mac]

How could Scotland win a battle it wasn't fighting in?

[@HsienKoMeiLingFormerYANG]

Wednesday's Child The Stewart were originally Celtic (Breton) family that was nomanised in the past and who would been rallying behind William I army.

[@tarz96]

FREEDOM!!!!

[@nobilityjudah5303]

Jacobitters are color people!

[@JabzyJoe]

They're not. No.

[@nobilityjudah5303]

@@JabzyJoe Yes they are! They are decendants of the ancient Isrealites of the bible! The ancient Isrealites were people of color.

[@Goto-fv8cy]

I am a relative a James that’s why I am here

[@wabtm1]

I wouldn’t mind a 4 minute history if you slowed down your talking.

[@officerbanjo4916]

These characters look like they were drawn in 3 minutes

[@atriangle1865]

Uhh this is actually 4:33 I’m unsubscribing

[@seantheguy1391]

If only the Jacobites had succeeded perhaps the Ireland would be whole again

[@valianthaggis3655]

It's four minutes, mate

[@MrConan89]

Sorry, talk is too fast.

[@Marianapj76]

Yeah I’m struggling to understand. English is my second language ☹️

[@rosiehasson3236]

i have a test on this tomorrow and don’t know shit anyone wanna help me lol 🤠

[@scottishshiv]

did you pass

[@zuzan_805]

Came from outlander

[@zuzan_805]

Noah Does Christian Apologetics. Oh hey u again :)

[@zuzan_805]

Noah Does Christian Apologetics. Yea I guess we looked on the same topic

[@zuzan_805]

Noah Does Christian Apologetics. Do u have insta ?

[@zuzan_805]

Noah Does Christian Apologetics. Haha then u probably understood when they spoke in Gaelic

[@zuzan_805]

Noah Does Christian Apologetics. Then any other social ?

[@weirdscience8341]

the jacobites rebelled the end wayyy faster than 3 minutes

[@conscienceaginBlackadder]

"Glorious Revolution" was the last successful invasion of Britain. The Empire era's favoured myth of never being invaded wrote that fact out.

[@conscienceaginBlackadder]

@@keyvanff123 A military entry into a country against its government's resistance is an invasion, whatever balance of the body politic are on the invaders' side. Simon Schama vol 2: The critical event of 1688 is better described as the invasion it undoubtedly was, rather than as a "revolution". It had been contemplated by William in the Netherlands long before he had an official invitation. William was shrewd enough to know it would be a gamble. But by spring 1688 he had come to believe it would be worse not to embark on it. The controlling imperatives were all Dutch. It was 3 months before the enormous armada + its huge cargo of troops, many of them the creams of the Dutch army, were able to sail from Scheveningen. James now led what was left of his army into Wiltshire. But it was precisely the fact of the Prince of Wales, and the possibility that as time went on his legitimacy would seem more not less credible, that made William realise, with his peerless sense of timing, that if he failed to seize the moment, he would squander an advantage that might never return. So, with the Dutch Blues on the streets, he simply rejected every overture short of the crown itself.

[@conscienceaginBlackadder]

@Britannia Simon Schama. The army ag the tune was subject to Pritestanr0t mutinies against Catholic officers, undermining it. Despite which, James did lead an army to Wiltshire, failed to encounter William, retreated to London to watch out for his family's safety, + found that general John Churchill had defected.

[@shane8037]

NOT a rebellion.

[@vadoksam9235]

I felt a real anti-Jacobite and dismissive and disrespectful tone towards those men who fought and died for charlie. You utterly glossed over the horrendously horrific highland clearences and skipped it far too non caringly as if it was nothing ! This all lead to the eradication of an ancient richly cultured deep clan society that had fought and existed since before the roman ceasars tried to conquer them. The loss of an entire culture and lineage of people. Yet both your tone and selection of facts made it seem as if it was of no importance. In essence, you failed to mention any of what made the government forces horrific. Hangings, beheadings, loot. Many of the real reasons why the Jacobites fought were not mentioned and you made the government seems so unevil and basic with hee haw truly bad qualities. The attitude towards the men who fought and died for charlie seemed a little dissmisive as you failed to mention the countless years of hangings, beheadings, looting and forceful cultural takeover of poor Scotland. I cant help but feel a bias in favour of protestant British England.

[@arktiny9633]

mate. It was meant to fit into 3 minuets of course he glossed over stuff.

[@ThegrandtravelNerd]

Hiii

[@robinsonnuila4715]

132 comment

[@Megabeat30]

Dang you people never tire of obfuscating others history ... The Jacobites were "Black people"

[@jamiemcdonald1904]

😭

[@hauntedmoodylady]

why try to cram 15 minutes into 3,absurd..

[@melware1372]

I'm gonna say it out loud, people. Bonnie Prince Charlie wasn't that handsome.

[@thedumbdog1964]

Ms Freakshow bastard

[@markdoyle6414]

Alot of information but too fast to follow.

[@johnforjustice2350]

What the hell are you eating? Can hear you spitting on mike. And is this a speed reading class? I’m a descendent of lowlander

[@Cultrix]

Good idea ,but terrible nasal voice made it difficult to understand clearly.

[@CreatingChaos]

Religion 🙄 its time we stopped fighting over imaginary beings

[@hushai5154]

Talks way to fast, poor quality work.

[@realThomastheCat]

I think that's the point

[@jamesduncan4076]

Slow down please

[@BAIRN1876]

For King James and no union 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@collinchris]

sorry, accent threw me. so...blah blah blah