Jalal's Take: “Assad or We Burn the Country”: Syria’s Struggle For Liberation

[@TheThinkingMuslim]

Please remember to subscribe - 70% of our viewers have not. This helps our channel grow organically.

[@antichamcha6544]

will believe you the day you say the same things about ruthless dictators ruling KSA, UAE, Bahrain, Qatar etc.

[@AmeyBarkaylow]

The arrival of Al-Mahdi must be real/authentic, he come alone and continue to claim and play his role as the beginning of the world's universal brotherhood towards the eternal afterlife. World history and the Malay language with him. The same long time will turn around the resurrection life until the ancient man before Adam. if say emerges Al-Mahdi 2025/24/23/22 - 2021 - 2020 - 2019 until 1 after century (AC) then directly to before century (BC) At the same time, explore outer space to other planets according to the capabilities and technology allow by the eternal ruler of nature, which has no beginning and no end. Everyone will witness in every event happened, there is an outbreak of self-incrimination, there are no lies, everyone witnesses together, there are no great nations... the only great thing is the creator of the world. 🙋‍♂️

[@BRICKERFORGE]

This is the most well-put-together summary of Syria I have seen. Jazak Allahu khair

[@elbrouse1]

Support Syrian people rebuild their country!

[@VanmanhBui-p2e]

Suria is no more buddy. Ruined by those so called "grass roots uprisers". What a joke.

[@ALLAHSHAHAADA]

@elbrouse ❤❤❤❤

[@larrydickman5936]

​@@VanmanhBui-p2eKeep telling yourself that

[@aurorafulnowandforever]

20:39 ❤ I'm a Muslim Arab and since the "Arab Spring" to this day I've seen it all, I lived it all, and I remember it all like it was yesterday. I'm genuinely amazed by this video. Very authentic and factual. I hope every foreign Muslim who cares about their brothers and sisters in Syria watch this video to learn the truth. May God guide us all. Thank you for this video and all of your efforts.

[@MrFarooqMAbbas]

Excellent, eloquently put the Syrian issue in perspective! Thank you, my wishes for the growth of your platform. JazakAllah Khair

[@nafdikyaaqsa]

Thank you. You've been brave and a breath of fresh air with your stance on Syria, in alignment with the Syrian people, amidst the flood of disappointment from those who positioned themselves as pro-Palestine but failed to humanise the Syrian people.

[@zaidtanim4163]

Very well-researched analysis, covering all aspects. Well done, and thank you for staying on the right path instead of following the herd like so many others.💝

[@ppetal1]

This perspective makes complete sense of a complicated situation.

[@alib7489]

A sincere request from a TM fan who watched/listened to almost every episode: Jalal bhai, please make these Jalal takes a weekly feature. Jazakallah Khair

[@ummshams8954]

JazakAllāh khayr Jalal for this excellent summary. With all the powers that be acting like diners at a feast, we ask Allāh to keep our brothers & sisters in His safekeeping. We truly do not have any other patron but He. And the only way we have to earn His mercy & compassion is to uphold justice for all, and put in practice the way of our Beloved, sallaAllāhu alaihi wasallam, who is a mercy to the worlds. May Allāh keep us all steadfast on the straight Path. Allāhumma āmīn.

[@angelajohnson3871]

Thank you for this. Some of what you stated caused a hard to swallow bitter pill reaction in me. However, as is meant to happen, when we place too much idealization on a country, government, regime, etc. and then expect it to live up to such an ideal, it will fail. This is a hard lesson but an important one. Mashallah ✨

[@Illudiumqsm]

As-salamu alaykum brother !! Thank you for all you do 😌 May Allah continue to protect you

[@ServantOfGodAllMighty]

I love this summarization brother Jalal! Jazzakallahu khayran 🙏

[@qutuz9495]

Very good take. Barak Allah feek, Jalal

[@nahumhabte6210]

«La ilaha illa Bashar». I will never forget that. Tells me everything i need to know about Him

[@cavaliercal594]

This is an excellent summary of the conflict in Syria, offering a clear explanation of the true motives behind the Marxist and Zionist/capitalist political forces in the region. The Assad family managed to maintain a delicate balance between leftist and right-wing Zionist political influences in the West, while simultaneously upholding a dictatorship and maintaining an alliance with Iran. However, juggling these four complex challenges proved to be too much for the Assad regime, ultimately leading to its sudden collapse.

[@muallaemine]

Throughout history almost all conquests of AlKuds starts with AlSham.. let that sink in. İt is the path that leads to the freedom of muslims insh'Allah. But nobody said it will be an easy or a straight forward path..

[@faatihbehardien2447]

Your videos are not difficult to think about whether you should press the like button in fact for me now it happens almost automatically. Excellently researched based on facts analysis presented simply and eloquently.

[@aann2084]

Thank Allah for liberating them from this tyrant. May Allah free the Palestinian people.

[@nawazishkhan2080]

INSHALLAH AMEEN SUMMA AMEEN

[@middleclassinvesting]

Great summary video brother jak !

[@agnasser]

If Syria is free, then Libya is also free.

[@nawazishkhan2080]

INSHALLAH AMEEN SUMMA AMEEN

[@poshvibes4021]

Jazakallah for this fantastic overview. As someone who naturally leans to the left, it has been a frustrating time arguing with those on the left who are determined to see this victory as something negative.

[@AzDaz-q1g]

It serves the west

[@3manification]

May Allah keep Syria united and liberating Palestine...🙏🙏🙏

[@farahrizvi6634]

Won’t happen, no Sunni country has the guts to stand up for Gaza like Iran.

[@homtanks7259]

JazakAllah'u khairan

[@rehenabegum3197]

This video was much needed in these uncertain times. Jazakallah

[@fatimah9202]

Aameen thumma Aameen. Jazaa kAllahu khairah fid daarain. May Allah bless and protect you from all sides

[@williamdavis9562]

What a breath of fresh air this channel is. No nonsense, no false narratives.

[@andrewpienaar4522]

Question: Why was action taken against the Assad regime and not Jordan and Saudi Arabia, considering that they are treating their people worse?

[@sheralikhan4164]

Great summary of the facts on ground, Jalal. Keep it up. Great analysis. Long live free Syria.

[@Ha15679]

I’m so glad you’ve done this video, there are too many ignorant people out there, almost blaming the Syrian people for the fall of Assad like they are to blame for wanting a better quality of life. There is no space for PKk/YPG terrorists in Syria who are stealing the Syrian oil. Syria is for Syrian people. I am so glad Syria has Turkey, they have the Syrians back. Turkey is the only country wants stability in Syria. Turkey shares the longest border. A stable Syria means a stable and terrorist free Syria and Turkey.

[@farahrizvi6634]

What a bloody stupid comment

[@faisalniazi1899]

Thank you

[@lvi25]

All Alawite in Syria should be educated about true Islam

[@el-Cu9432]

I have never considered Alawites Muslim. Syria was a Muslim country ruled by a kaffir tyrant.

[@nawazishkhan2080]

MASHALLAH JAZAKALLAH KHAIR Excellent summary of 13 years of Syrian revolution

[@waqashussain9264]

Finally a good overview of Syrias revolution

[@roubanashabe3490]

I'm so glad the Syrians are free 💚 they are the sweetest people who have been through the unimaginable! 💔 We in Lebanon 🇱🇧 have witnessed and heard of unspeakable atrocities, and I'm not exaggerating The Assad even kidnapped Lebanese people who opposed his brutal rule, many Lebanese Muslims/Christians have been missing, and just a few were released a week ago

[@collinshardyproust]

Are you dumb?! This is the worst thing that could have happened to Syria.

[@Raks78]

Jazakallah khair . Ameen for a strong Syria and free Palestine

[@ge12mma345ge12]

Listen to what Vanessa Bealey, who lived happily in Syria and was planning to live there permanently. She was fine with Assad, mainly because it was a country that was the freest in West Europe. She loved the people and thought quite highly of Assad, who she felt did an excellent job in spite of all the trouble the West and the "head choppers" were causing. They were poor because America took over the oilfields and Israel stole the Golan Heights and there were massive sanctions on Syria by America. He will be vindicated one day.

[@BornJune1984]

Brilliant

[@CocoLov2023]

THX again for this important Information about Syria🙏🏻🌹Only one comment by me👉🏽what Assad made in Syria was a WAR‼️Not a Civil War👌🏻💚

[@adnans8778]

The frustrating thing about these perspectives on Syria is that they do not engage with the substance of the arguments of those critical of the overthrow of Assad. Simply repeating how tyrannical Assad was, while true, is irrelevant to opposing arguments and dismissing them as "Leftist Anti-Imperialist" agenda is a cop out. I have listened to both sides, and I still do not see convincing arguments against the following: 1. HTS is rooted in ISIS and AQ philosophy and have not explained their current philosophy. The only thing HTS seems clear about is that it has become a nationalistic movement - isn't this a cause of concern to Muslims? A proper Islamic movement can be pragmatic but still clear about its vision. 2. Jolani's flip flopping between various groups from extremist to now partnering with the US and Israel (the other extreme), is not inspiring. Few extremist leaders make it back to balanced, moderate ground - lower level group members can, but leaders generally do not because they are driven not by belief but by narcissism. 3. Syria's territorial integrity is smashed. It seems unlikely it will ever recover unless major concessions are made to self-interested powers. 4. While it is good evil tyrant Assad has gone, Syria is likely to fall into the hands of other tyrants. The Egyptians and Libyans have trodden the same path and many now regret events. Numerous political analysts who are not on the left, are saying the immediate winner from Assad's downfall is Israel and the losers are Iran and Palestine - that seems fair. 5. Why hasn't HTS said anything against Israel's theft of its land? While HTS may not be able to do anything material about it, shouldn't it at least address it in some way? Indeed, there are reports of HTS seeking partnerships with Israel. It's positive that Assad has gone, but I see little to be positive about for the outlook for Syria. HTS and Jolani have shown little to base a positive outlook on and they have little agency - even they admit it. This is not the foundation of a strong Islamic movement.

[@haledhajdari1154]

Why you didn't publicly wonder what Assad did ( or rather did not) to protect his territory of I$raeli occupation ? But now you want a new caretaker government of a country burned by Assad to do something. Just the leftist usual positions.

[@ubeydruff]

Well articulated, especially how the prisons and stories of torture are being emphasized in order to overlook governance shortcomings and sovereignty issues. The host here lazily uses a metaphor to avoid analyzing a serious issue, specifically that the Assad regime 'melted away'.There is no place in geopolitics for metaphors or analogies, as such are inaccurate, incomplete, overly simple. Really, the regime simply melted at the end, like ice cream? The host referred to some CIA programs that subsequently became public before defunded by Trump (although US troops have remained). What about the earlier US programs to destabilize the entire region as part of Israel's policy of 'controlled chaos'? Not everything in geopolitics is consistent or rational, so the host's attempt to summarize this into a chronological narrative is absurd--and grossly inaccurate during the Obama presidency. I highly encourage viewers to not rely on such channels for geopolitical knowledge. Making a Livestream or a weekly show isn't sufficient in this domain.

[@adnans8778]

@@ubeydruff Thanks for your additions. Yes exactly, in geopolitics multiple conflicting information can be true simultaneously. It is shallow to think that the enemy of Assad is automatically desirable. From what I can see, the arguments presented in support of HTS seem to be: 1. Anything is preferable to Assad 2. The Syrian people support them 3. Give them a chance None of these arguments are particularly thoughtful or convincing. People originally said anything was preferable to Mubarak and Gaddafi, and its foolish to think events cannot get worse now that Assad is gone. And while some Syrians may support HTS, people have a habit being overly optimistic - just ask the Palestinians in 1993 following the Oslo Accords. As for giving HTS the benefit of the doubt, we can do, but there are an awful lot of doubts. I also think the extent of hate towards Iran is unjustified. While Iran may be supporting Palestine for its own interests, it is still the only regime in the ME that is supporting them - no sunni state has lifted even a fist in solidarity with Palestine for decades. Remember Iran has been targeted by the US and its Gulf allies since 1979. Iran didn't start the war with Iraq. Iran originally wanted friendly relations with the US. Iran is trying to secure itself and its used underhand tactics to do so, but it can reasonably argue it has been forced into this. The real facilitators of the genocide of the Palestinians are Egypt, Jordan, and Saudi - the sunni states. As for the leftists, again I think the attack on them is unjustified. They have done a huge amount to bring attention to Palestine and in many cases made sacrifices to do so. Personal attacks against them are unwarranted - address their arguments directly instead.

[@ZohaibAli-z9r]

​@@adnans8778 Bro stop advocating for Iran for god's sake . Iran is the most blood thirsty Muslim nation in the world right now . Sending it's militias to neighboring sunni countries and committing mass murders . I am not saying that sunni leaders are saints but Iran is also the same and in some cases worst than sunni countries.

[@monahaque1660]

Excellent commentary.

[@Raidar29]

an excellent summary nice

[@toryal100]

You guys did such a wonderful job about adding text to the screen. Thank you.

[@nizal9388]

Please do not travel to these countries after having called out these rulers, for the sake if your safety

[@ercaner_buzbey]

When I started my legal licence degree in Ankara University I wanted to participate for classroom elections. There was however an already established student political organization leaning to the left and because of their overly tyrannical approach to the student relations the university administration was forced to reestablish classroom represention. Those guys blabbered about that the new act was directed against them and to topple their statues. But when the election time came they (with all their economic backing and organizational power) they printed mass propaganda posters and distributed them everywhere on the campus. They were asking votes with their previous actions. Guess what one of those is "we brought the class representation from the dead"😂😂 West is doing the same about revolution. Things are unfolding against them but they are trying to use it to keep crowds from accepting reality as it is and keep them following their narrative. They plan and Allah plans, Allah is the best of planners.

[@caylia9989]

It was not state of Terorr!! Disgusting ! That is for the Saudi! Spectacular??

[@Mariama_B]

Allah bless the Ummah❤️

[@johndoe-fs7ib]

RE: This sounds a lot like the propaganda of Lybia...or Afganistan...or Iraq...I am sure Assad inherited a corrupt political situation...he had no real control over the deep stare that existed there ...Syria has been a multi ethnic state...so lets see how free and democratic this new Syria will be..because the examples we have as mentioned up above beg to differ..

[@nas603]

Iran and Hezbollah were “drunk on sectarian hate”. Sounds like the brother has been brainwashed. It really pains me to see the Muslims being fooled a second time. Will the Syrian people only be happy when their state is dismembered and ISIS and alQaeda like groups rule again. You’re right time will tell but I think Iraq and Lebanon should now tighten their border security and never again should they lay down their lives for their traitorous Syrian brothers.

[@zap6878]

No he was incharge He murderered his people He is nothing but a killer

[@WorldPeace-AdamNeira]

This is quite a good albeit brief explanation and summary of the past thirteen years in Syria, but to really understand this period you need to go back to the early 1960's to look at how and why the Assad Regime arose in the first place. Also... Many analysts overlook a key aspect of the Syria chronology, i.e. the visit of Malcolm Hoenlein to Damascus in late Dec. 2010. It is true that Syria is a key piece of the Middle East Jigsaw Puzzle but unless you understand all the squares on the Cube you will not have a full picture and will not know how to solve it. I have analysed and deconstructed Jalal's talk here in full. FYI, I have been auditing and analysing Syria in great depth since 21/8/2013, which was a truly pivotal day in human history. I don't think there is anyone alive who knows more about the origins and trajectory of the conflict and what the solutions are. I have put in at least 5,000 hours of work over a decade. e.g. From late 2013 to 2019 I composed in excess of 12000 tweets about Syria plus a multitude of comments and counsel to various media, agencies and leaders. (Data Mining all my past public counsel on Syria to condense my wisdom about the country is a worthy endeavour.) A very small but important part chronology of my past counsel about Syria: 28/5/2015 Replying to Petra Stienen and Bente Scheller: " He, Bashar al Assad, can be Alawite Rep. for Tartus/Latakia. If not, Putin can give him and Asma a dacha in Vladivostok. Keys ready." 29/6/2017 "Syria must not be balkanised. Existing borders to remain. 14 governates. Damascus as the capital. Moderate - Monotheist - Pluralist" 9/7/2017 SYRIA The Vision - By 2030 it becomes possible to drive in peace and security from Jerusalem to Tehran, via The Golan Heights > Damascus, Jobar, Madaya, Beirut, Tripoli, Ain Dara, Aleppo, Raqqa, Palmyra, Deir Ez Zour, Mosul and Baghdad ! Over say 8 weeks. (A/C car in summer of course. 😎) What a road trip that would be! A Grand Middle East Tour ! Visualise - Verbalise - Actualise. 16/11/2018 I counselled to the US State Dept, POTUS, Erdogan, The Elysee and Netanyahu: "If Ahmad Shah Massoud had been given the right support, and not been killed of course, Afghanistan would be completely different since 2001. The closest and most hopeful approximation to Massoud in Syria now is Jolani." 23/1/2019 Replying to Charles Lister on Twitter: As I have explained, a professional, paid 42 person "Int'ernational Transitional Oversight Committee for Syria" is required. (To work with the 50 Syrian guests at the IPC + the MDMEMP + the 24/7 Ceasefire Monitors) Charles L. gets one of the seats on ITOCS2024. 👍 12/5/2023 Replying to Wassim Nasr at France 24: "Well done Wassim and your editors at France 24 who organised this trip with help from official channels. Blessings to the good people of Idlib Governate. There is a certain set of moves of the Rubik's Cube that can and must be made now to redeem Syria. I have been following the Syrian Civil War very closely since 21/8/2013, which was a key date in human history. i.e. The Sarin Attack on East Ghouta. P.S. Jolani is a viable leader of Syria in the coming years... These recent comments by two other Syria watchers are relevant. 6/12/2024 @ Armin Rosen There is a case to be made-and I've made it here before-that the Syrian civil war is the most important event of the 21st century. Possible deadliest war, generated a host of other conflicts, produced ISIS and massive European refugee crisis... @ Nick Gorges I make this argument all the time in my personal life to explain why people need to care about Syria. Have a good day. Prayers for the peace, prosperity and security of Syria. ٱلسَّلَامُ عَلَيْكُمْ 😎 Adam Neira Founder of World Peace 2050 Founded in April 2000 Paris - Jerusalem - Melbourne

[@JackJohnson-pi5nh]

We have to admit that he did keep his word he did burn the country

[@Free_Falastin2024]

No Kurd would fight with israel. What humiliation to inflict on oneself.

[@Ha15679]

pkk/ypg want to be the 2nd Israel. Not all Kurd will support terrorists, but I’m afraid there is a very high number who does.

[@nas603]

I think he stopped thinking completely

[@homeboy144]

hahahhaha 💀

[@mohamedali2858]

After the victory in Syria, some express their feelings in the language of the Quran (How can he have kingship over us when we are more deserving of it?)

[@Patriarchy_69]

No one deserves shit ~ America

[@rahmioruc581]

Such a flawed take: *Kurds did the "dirty job" against whom? (Did you forget the so called Islamic State has enslaved Yezidi kids? Fighting against these people suddenly now became a dirty job? ) *How do you know SDF does not represent Kurds? (I am not saying %100 Kurds support SDF. But do you follow the discussions between two main factions. The one in the orbit of Turkey basically request SDF to become an entirely Kurdish organization, leaving behind other nations around the area. This position is fundementally wrong, just look at the Ottoman regulations of 1850's, these places were called Kurdistan, and they have been Arabized. I don't believe in any historical claim of right to a land, it is a different version of fascism. So, even for Turkey backed Kurdish groups ,the problem is not of a representation) *All of a sudden you connect Kurds with Israel . (You well know that the loss of Syria has diminished any chances for Hamas and Palestanian resistance. You guys have decided that as long as our Sharia-aligned guys rule over Syria who cares if Israel wins or gets more territory. So when it comes to you guys it is good to be "strategic", but Kurdish people who have been stateless since hundred years, if they start acting strategicly they become enemies of umma. *Your next argument could be Kurds are just there protecting the oil (The oil revenues of which had never been shared with Kurds before. And yet, I believe after an election process the revenus should be shared will all Syrians. And check who is providing Israil with oil?) These kinds of flawed takes, which has no intention to understand Kurdish position and just repeats Turkish official position is the reason why Kurds feeel threatened, and that's why many call for cooperating with Israel, because you guys have no intention to help Kurdish people have the right to govern themselves wassalam. May Allah give guidance to you and people like you

[@adnkir1234]

The word for a doctor who is an eye specialist is ophthalmologist, not optometrist. Optometrists usually check visual acuity, prescribe glasses, have some training to spot common eye conditions, and usually refer the patient to an eye doctor known as ophthalmologist if they find something unusual. The main job of an optometrist is to take the workload off ophthalmologists by prescribing glasses and contact lenses and hence dealing with refractory errors. A high standard site like Thinking Muslim should be very careful in selecting words.

[@AnwarKaleemullah]

Pray for sovereign Syria with well educated members of govt. not by illiterate people, inclusions of all minorities without atrocities and revenge. I am a sunny American Muslim

[@بسمهعلي-ب5س]

سِالُتتكِ بّالُلُُه 💔الُجْلُيَلُ الُجْبّارَ انَ تْنَقًذَنَا قًبّلُ انَ نَمٌوَتْ مٌنَ شِدِتْ الُجْوَع انَتٌْخيَكِ انَيَ دٌِخلُةِ ْعلُى الُلُُه تْمٌ ْعلُيَكِ انَيَ فَيَ وَجُْهك انَـيَ اخـتْكِ انَـيَ اتْرَجْـاكِ اتْـوَسِـلُ الُـيَـكِ انَـقًـذَنَا لُـوَجُْـه الُـلُُـه. يَــشِــُهدِ الُــلُــُه يَاٌخـيَ انَ مٌنَ الُــصّــبّاحُ حُـتْا الُـانَ يَــحُــرَمٌ ْعـــلُيَـنَـا الاكل غير الماء والله اني ما كتبت هذا الكلام الا من الضيق وقسوت الضروف اني طالبه من الله ثم منك لاتردني خايبه يا اخي ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' اخي اول كلامي انا اقسم بالله على كتاب الله اني لااكذب عليك ولا انصب ولا احتال اني بنت يمنيه نازحين من انا واسرتي بيننا ایت الشهرب 15 الف يمني والان علينا 45 الف حق 3 شهور وصاحب البيت من الناس الي ماترحم والله يا اخي انه يجي كل يوم يبهدلنا ويتكلم علينا ويريد من البيت للشارع لانناماقدرنا ندفعله الأجار شافونا الجيران نبكي ورجعو تكلمو الجيران ومهلنالاخره الأسبوع معادفعنا له حلف يمين بالله هذا بيخرجنا إلى الشارع رحمه واحنا. بلادنا بسبب هذا الحرب ولانجد قوت يومنا وعايشين اناوامي واخوتي سفار والدنا متوفي الله يرحمه ومامعنا أحد في هذا الدنيا جاانبنا في هذه الظروف القاسيه اخوتي الصغار خرجو للشارع وشافو الجيران ياكلو واوقفو عند بابهم لجل يعطوهم ولو كسره خبز والله الذي له ملك السموات والارض انهم غلفو الباب وطردوهم ورجعو یبکو ایموتو من الجوع ما احد رحمهم وعطلة ردها لقمت عیش والان لوما احدنا ساعدنا في إيكيلو دقيق اقسم بالله انموت من الجوع فيا اخي انا دخيله على الله ثم عليك واريد منك المساعده لوجه الله انشدك بالله تحب الخير واتساعدني بقدر ماتستطيع مع تراسلي واتساب على هذا الرقم 00967717591071 وتطلب اسم بطاقتي وترسلي ولاتتاخر وايعوضك الله بكل خير اخواني سغار شوف كيف حالتهم وساعدنا وأنقذنا قبل أن يطردونا في الشارع تتبهدل أو نموت من الجوع وانا واسرتي نسالك بالله لولك مقدره على مساعد لاتتاخر علينا وجزاك الله خيرا.:،،،،،.،.؛؛؛٪٪٪٪٪،،،،،،،،،،،… .ا™°°°😢😢😢😢.، ❤😮

[@abmerkeju8093]

Let's also talk about what also happened in Egypt after Mubarak fell

[@liamcohrs9495]

Do you have any evidence of SDF collaboration with Israel?

[@adamesd3699]

To be fair, while the father really was a dictator, the son, when he came in, tried at first to be Mr Nice Guy (at least for a Middle Eastern dictator). This led to what was known as the “Damascus Spring”. But then people started criticizing the regime, Assad and the people around him got worried, and they brought back the Mukhabarat snatch you in the middle of the night types. So he ended up killing even more people than his father, though deep down, he was probably a much less brutal man by nature. That was his tragedy.

[@hasnainy]

We make dua for a blessed healing Syria- where all sects and religions can live in harmony- however when you read history- it has had a difficult past post- WW1. Too much division between the groups who live in that region. Too much interference by the super powers eg UK, France, USA, Israel, Russia etc Eventually it ends up like a lot of other pan- Arab nationalist states ie dictatorship! Hope the Syrians will show maturity and foresight and wisdom to improve their condition. We will wait and review in a years time what path is taken by new government

[@XA-fi9bp]

Absolutely rubbish. You know nothing

[@nas603]

Yes, it’s a surprisingly disguised as an intellectual discussion

[@fairuzshahimi6930]

What about the assassination of Shaikh Ramadhan al-Bouti in the House of Allah 😢

[@bae4198]

Why hts al joulani are not defending siria against israel intervention?????????????????????????????????????????????????

[@Karakulak1071]

Patience, Muslims need to use patience, let's remind ourselves that Israel is suicidal.

[@JacintaPalerm]

Skipping over usa sanctions and control Syrian oil. Skipping over western intervention.

[@TheThinkingMuslim]

Did you watch the video?

[@AzDaz-q1g]

Yes it was propaganda and double speak ,the fact is the west courted Assad vs n he refused them he supported hezbollah in defeating Israel after that the cia made it the mission to destroy assassins

[@JamesJanuary-2001]

Respect Akhi,

[@tempusfugit7662]

The 2011 civil waa as r was far from organic, just as the Arab spring was also fomented, triggered and managed by the CIA.

[@Nifalh]

Yeah people keep talking about the arab spring, but the reality is that the revolution, even when successful, didn't gain the ummah substantial things. Just look at Egypt.

[@nas603]

Agreed

[@shamsali9903]

In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious and Most Merciful ‎وَالَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا بَعْضُهُمْ أَوْلِيَاءُ بَعْضٍ ۚ إِلَّا تَفْعَلُوهُ تَكُن فِتْنَةٌ فِي الْأَرْضِ وَفَسَادٌ كَبِيرٌ And those who disbelieve are allies of one another, (and) if you (Muslims of the whole world collectively) do not do so [i.e. become allies, as one united block under one Khalifah (a chief Muslim ruler for the whole Muslim world) to make victorious Allah's religion of Islamic Monotheism], there will be Fitnah (wars, battles, polytheism) and oppression on the earth, and a great mischief and corruption (appearance of polytheism). 8: 73 Why are we Muslims not talking about reestablishing the power and control Allah SWT give us from the beginning? The command is to unite under one Khalifah. The number one concern on the minds of the Muslims is the tragedy in Gazza. The destruction in Gazza is worse than that of Hiroshima and Nagasaki combined. The Zionist Israelis are the modern day Amelak as they were a tribe from nation of the Israelites and their brutality in Gazza and West Bank is the evidence. We have to listen to what Allah SWT is saying to us in the above verse and from the beginning. "And Remember when your Lord said to the Angels, I am going place Khalifah on earth".... 2: 30 You see the UN which controlled by USA, is dead body in the muddy water as every resolution passed by majority, is vetoed by USA. Which means we have to create a balance of power in the world by creating United League of Muslim Nations. Which is to reestablish the Caliphate because we are children of Adam, peace be upon him . "United League of Muslim Nations" under one Khalifah will be a strictly defensive Force with a quick response to any threat to the Ummah of Islam. And it is easy to do it. It will be the Council of Muftis, from which they will choose the Khalifah. Under the Khalifah will be a seat for a Mufti from every country in world with 100,000 plus Muslim population as Islam is for entire World. From every municipality we will choose a representative till we have the Council of Muftis for that country with a Grand Mufti of that country to sit in the Council of Muftis under the Khalifah. All communication can be done remotely with everyone working from home. Most effective and real democratic way of governing where all decisions are made by the Council of Muftis but the Khalifah having the final say. Under the Khalifah, the "ULMN" will have its own army, navy and Air Force under one commander for defending the entire ummah. We already have the hardware from major Muslim countries. They just have to be relabeled "ULMN" when they out to defend any part of the Ummah like removing the Mediterranean Sea blockade by Israelis.The four letters "ULMN" will be enough to deter anyone from doing what is happening in Gazza today. But we have to be the Nation of Al Muttaqun for Allah SWT is saying now: "You are the Best of People ever raised up for Mankind, enjoining what is Good, forbidding what is evil and believing in Allah SWT" .... Quran 3: 110 Then how can we go wrong when the fear of "ULMN" will overwhelm the hearts of our enemies? That is what Islam is and we are Muslims to resolve every matter in a Peaceful manner, Insha Allah. Alhamdu Lillah. If no one is willing to act as the acting Khalifah, I will be the acting Khalifah till one is chosen and sincerely invite all Muslims to join me in this effort, for if we fail but we will never fail, we will still get one Hashanah for our intentions, Insha Allah Jazak Allah Khair Your brother Abu Saad Acting Khalifah (as Son of Adam, AS.

[@azeez7034]

This is why the IDF is in Syria now.

[@inkipinki8468]

Unfortunately I respectfully disagree!

[@samimas4343]

Muslims feared to have longer beards in Syria. People who prayed Fajir regularly got persecuted. Religious men and covered women didn't get far in governmental positions. Praying is forbidden in government buildings for employees, in schools, and in the army where military service is obligatory on all Syrian males. Rifaat, Bashar's uncle at the time of Assad the father, was in favor of forbidding the hijab. Hafiz, the president then, thought it was too much since syrians were very conservative. He worked on the issue slowly in the media in showing hijabis again and again as backwards, poor, pushovers, naive, cheaters ... Rifaat then rebelled against his brother and started forcing women to remove hijabs. There was an uprising and Hafiz had to send Rifaat away after he stole tons of syrian gold reserves. That was before the war. And later on when the rebellion got real, prisoners who didn't prostrate for Bashar's images and didn't confess him as god were killed. That was the secular rule of Baath party in main muslim majority country.

[@AzDaz-q1g]

Spoke to a Syria who said it doesn’t matter he said there only bombing because of iran

[@plastic9990]

in-sha’Allah 🇵🇰❤️🇵🇰

[@GreenPartyAli]

disappointed at your monologue, you r exposing your Shia hatred. journalistic fairness demands that you invite Rania Khalek to your program and have an open discussion.

[@Karakulak1071]

During Hakan Fidan's press conference with the new Syrian leader el-Sharaa, he reiterated that the US has no place in Syria, he said that some unscrupulous people in the US government had lied to him, the PKK YPG will not have their own enclave in Syria. Yes, Türkiye is absolutely behind the rebuilding and sovereignty of Syria, Fidan warned foreign actors not to encroach on Syria's development but welcomed any help foreign countries could provide.

[@AzDaz-q1g]

Turks violated an destroyed syria

[@ge12mma345ge12]

Minorities in Syria are now being slaughtered and I don''t understand why you can't see this. She was advised to get out when it was clear that the terrorists were taking over. So she did. She was sad she could only take one of her beloved dogs. Please look for the whole story!

[@azeez7034]

Grassroots ? I would have to disagree because... The United States, with occasional interruptions, has been interfering in the important Middle East nation of Syria for over 70 years, and today there are hundreds of American soldiers still present on Syrian soil. These realities are not well known. US intrusion in Syrian affairs can be traced to the late 1940s, as outlined in 2016 by the American author Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

[@z-fb7cy]

🚨 Iranian bots alert in the chat as always

[@AzDaz-q1g]

Jewish bot alert

[@loneranger4469]

The Over Thinking Muslim...😂😂😂

[@Michael-h9d3x]

Israel was being defeated by Hezbollah. That's why Israel proposed the ceasefire with them. If it wasn't for the fall of Assad which was Netanyahu's plan since 2001, Israel would have not been able to destroy Syria's entire military and take its land. That is why they are celebrating the fall of Assad. With Syria becoming a state like Jordan and Egypt makes a Palestinian state impossible. The only force fighting and giving their lives for the Sunni Palestinians were the Shia Hezbollah while the Sunni's did nothing. The fall of Assad made Israel win and put them on the road to expanding the greater Israel. Iran could have made a deal with the US to stop supporting Hezbollah and the Palestinian in return for lifting of the sanctions which would have resulted in a great economy for Iran, but they chose to support the Palestinians instead and suffered a devastating economy. The Thinking Muslim channel is not thinking.

[@hamzamusa6793]

Haha Hamas sided with the rebels call them Zionist too your Shia Iranian Russian propaganda is cheap and old you were defeated take your L

[@collinshardyproust]

They are paid by Qatar.

[@Use_fediverse-7814]

I don't like Israel, I dislike Assad even more. Had Israel wanted Bashar gone, they would have done it, over 10 years ago.

[@collinshardyproust]

@Use_fediverse-7814 They couldn't because of Russia. Now Russia was tied up in Ukraine.

[@egay86292]

Damascus honeymoon. as long as the colonial cancer exists, "stability" is a dark joke.

[@UniteforAll]

Jalal must be disappointed that he gave matt kenard a platform

[@TasiaSaumier]

SOMEONE TAKE THE BASHAR ALIEN CHANNELER OFF THE GODDAM INTERNET TOO

[@arshmash5340]

More of these short 20 minutes segments pls , g00d analysis though. Sick of these resistards and lefties in twitter

[@ChristinaStone-ly8yg]

Assad Assad is like shoes of Abraham's sacrifice that need him to wear in love, like an Isaiah. Lift him up.

[@walidb123]

It seems far too reductive to refer the “political left” like a boogeyman here. I think you’ve done well to condense a difficult topic though

[@AzDaz-q1g]

Syrias air defence were quiet good with out them iran in much more open

[@awb6544]

What about the Saudi regime and the baghraini regimes. You peddle nonsense.

[@hamzamusa6793]

Haha keep crying Hamas sided with rebels call them “Zionist too” your Shia Russian propaganda is old cheap and played out just accept your defeat

[@Fatima74]

Picture if Sisi at @20:27 😂

[@behrouzch29]

As an Iranian, I have always opposed my country’s support for Palestine. I believe it is a complete waste of resources. We have subjected ourselves to global sanctions for a delusional ideology, thinking that as part of the Muslim world and a powerful country, we must liberate Palestine. However, the reality is that sectarianism and the deep-seated hatred towards Shia Muslims among Sunnis are so strong that, no matter how much we sacrifice for them, they will never truly align with us. Our national interest, in my opinion, lies in forming alliances with Israel and the Kurds. Sunni Muslims whether religious or driven by Arab nationalism view us with disdain. Religious Sunnis label us as "Rafidis" while nationalist Arabs consider us "Majus" (fire worshipers) a derogatory racist term. After all sacrifice which they all were against Iran's national interest ,This lunatic came and says the axis of resistance has never been for Palestine!! i really hope one day my government will cease its support for Palestinians and their cause, focusing instead on building a strong coalition with Israel and the West. With the third-largest oil reserves and the second-largest natural gas reserves in the world, we could be the strongest country in West Asia if we weren’t burdened by sanctions.

[@hamzamusa6793]

Damn Sunnis kicked you so hard got you to give up on Islam and become Zionist 😂😂😂😂🎉

[@infoseputaronepiece]

As sunni, i agree with you 👍👍 sunni leaders are sellout. Its fact that shia majority country help palestine

[@AhmadFakih123]

As a Lebanese Shia from the South, having lost family members for the Palestinian cause and witnessed the destruction of my village, I can no longer prioritise Palestine over my own country. Despite our sacrifices, Palestinians often view our support with suspicion, fueled by sectarian biases embedded in their culture and rhetoric. The broader Muslim world, with its 1.5 billion people, should stand up for Palestine if they truly consider it part of their "Ummah." Until then, our involvement should focus on protecting our nations and people. Peace with Israel remains inconceivable given decades of bloodshed. Yet, after October 7th, Iran and the Axis of Resistance must reconsider their unreciprocated support for the Palestinian cause, especially after Hamas’s reckless, uncoordinated actions. Palestinians have undermined their own cause through actions like the Oslo Accords and internal divisions. Their history in Lebanon includes harm to both Shia and Christian communities. It’s time for us-whether Shia from Lebanon, Iran, Iraq, or Afghanistan-to focus on building our own strength and futures, leaving behind the illusions of a cause even many Sunnis have abandoned.

[@PIPI-s3o]

I think viewers should also the Activists Network ..interview with Laith Marouf dated 22nd Dec. Reality on the ground is very different in Syria. Why is there Ethnic Cleaning of People in the golan heights and others areas being occupied by the zionists. I pray for the people of Syria but i think it will like what Mahmood Abbas is doing in the west bank

[@sandytatham3592]

Huh? Ethnic cleansing on the Golan Heights? Several Druze villages on the Syrian side of the Golan Heights said they preferred to become part of Israel. Under the new *Islamist* regime their safety and civil rights are not guaranteed.

[@AdamBinDawood]

👍

[@oopsm3574]

Rubbish news propaganda

[@farmannamdar]

AT LIST ASAD WASENT AMERICAN AND ISREAL PUPPET

[@VivianKristiansen-n8s]

Talk to Syriana Analysis-/Kevork Almassian. You are wrong on several points!!

[@Karakulak1071]

Kevork is a western propagandist and what makes it worse is that he doesn't even know it. 😂

[@AGlimpseofTruth-D10]

Imagine having the audacity to suggest a well-known Assadist. Who even lied about 13 yr old Hamza Ali Al Khateeb. Tryin to defend the Assad Regime.

[@engrjalalzafar]

Incorrect & Superficial Analysis. Its Israel,s Victory & not Ummah,s.

[@AzDaz-q1g]

Al jewlani mossadi

[@TasiaSaumier]

[@Khalid-u7q1i]

Bullshit

[@hamzamusa6793]

Cry harder Ibn Mutah 🥺🤪

[@silenceisgolden3238]

I do believe that the Kurdish tribes deserve their own province under a sovereign Syria democratically administered under HTS. I do feel like they will only keep getting intimidated by the Turkish influence in the North, so the best option for them is to migrate South and finally settle near the Golan Heights where they will live peacefully ever after.