James White is still stuck in the 90s in 2024

[@shamelesspopery]

"How much you wanna make a bet I can throw a football over them mountains?... Yeah... Coach woulda put me in fourth quarter, we would've been state champions."

[@Deuterocomical]

@@shamelesspopery Excellent reference!

[@stefanielozinski]

💀

[@acekoala457]

Maybe it isn't the Roman Catholics that live rent free in his head. Maybe the 90s live rent free in his head.

[@mousakandah5188]

Nice try Catholic, but this argument didn't exist in the 90s so its invalid.

[@josephross1900]

This comment made me burst out laughing

[@DenverDias]

James White: "Only 90s kids will remember this..."

[@deadalivemaniac]

As a former fan of White and ex-Calvinist, I’m so sorry we encouraged James White to be like this. Our bad.

[@Onlyafool172]

What matters is that you are here now hahah, maybe you were predestined to hype that man up

[@KnightFel]

Sad seeing someone leave Christ for smells and bells.

[@Onlyafool172]

@@KnightFel so sad someone looking for a interpretation the agree with, dw he was predistined to do it

[@somewhatreallycoolguy7439]

i forgive you

[@josephross1900]

Yeah, but did you watch any of his debates from the 90s?

[@ComiCross]

If you liked this, I’d recommend checking out James White’s debate with Jerry back in the 90’s.

[@eucharistenjoyer]

I don't know why, but I think James White should debate Fr. Mitch Pacwa. I think it would be a nice way of moving the ball forward.

[@IanVinh]

James W: Let's move the ball forward Also James W: Back in the 90s 😅

[@sbanach]

I wonder if he's aware this is a running gag.

[@paxcoder]

When I watched the debated with Voice of Reason, I was wondering if he's doing it on purpose.

[@deadalivemaniac]

I used to follow James, he has no self awareness. The proof is in the fact he released a video after his debate with Horn on of a Christian can lose their salvation telling people not to believe reviews of the debate which overwhelmingly favored Trent.

[@KnightFel]

He prob doesn’t care at all lol. It’s just papist coping.

[@IsaiahINRI]

​@@KnightFelso true. For more information see James White's debate with Gerry Matatics.

[@PhilipBlair-by7ic]

You know I debated Catholic answers back in the 90s

[@DivineComedyandStuff]

James White got really into the 90s and nobody ever saw him again.

[@oldmovieman7550]

I understood that reference. Probably because I grew up in the 90s

[@DivineComedyandStuff]

@@oldmovieman7550 The Sandlot lol

[@Peter-qb8gf]

LOL

[@FreddyMontana69]

Everyone get your James White bingo card!

[@RCC.1962]

😅😂

[@EruIluvatar5]

"Satispassio"

[@jess96154]

James White's 90s references get so tiring.

[@CorneliusCorndogJr]

did you know that James White debated Gerry Matatics in 1990 about “Was Peter the pope”?

[@guesswho22peekaboo]

Wow was not expecting Pokémon Stadium music. You just unlocked a hidden memory in my brain lmao

[@OpenOceanOnly]

The year isn’t over yet. How many 90’s references do you reckon he’ll make before the year is out?

[@tonyl3762]

Notice he hardly ever brings up his debate with Gary Michuta on the canon and never by name. Gary smoked him and tough topic too.

[@Deuterocomical]

@@tonyl3762 He also never brings up his debate with Sungenis on the Mass

[@thenazarenecatholic]

I was thinking that too! When I saw that debate, I was confused at first. I thought, “is this the same James White? Because he never brings up Michuta in his daily flashbacks.”

[@KnightFel]

He smoked Michuta, what are you talking about? Sungenis wasn’t convincing either.

[@tonyl3762]

@@KnightFel Did we watch the same debate? lol. Michuta has dismantled the Josephus and "laid up in the Temple" argument, esp recently on his AA channel.

[@michaelpsellos770]

I can't believe James White defeated Gerry Maddox in the 90s. The man who was declared sacred tradition by the pope ex cathedral in 1989, and is one of three men permitted to have "nihil obstat" printed on their left butt cheek. I am shook and will be attending the local Second Baptist Church this sunday.

[@eucharistenjoyer]

" 'Nihil obstat' printed on their left butt cheek." My sides went out of orbit, this is gold.

[@halleylujah247]

You know what would be even more fun if he started saying he "debated in the late 1900s"

[@sw3aty_forte]

lol

[@zeektm1762]

James Whimsical when he refers to Gerry Matatics' 1990 debate for the 500th time instead of responding to the argument:

[@ghostapostle7225]

Total Fr. Brown Jesuit W

[@marteld2108]

Santa Claus the Calvinist really believes that he has never lost a debate.

[@Onlyafool172]

He was predestined with the gift of echo chamber

[@not.an.organist]

He’s not stuck in the 90s he’s just stuck in a Protestant ‘church’. Which is virtually the same thing.

[@IsaiahINRI]

The 90s is more advanced than Protestant theology. They're still arguing over stuff we had solved before Nicaea I

[@bareit98]

Like, surely he must know he does this. Give it up dude!

[@sassafrassanid5718]

This guy is Sunk Cost Fallacy personified. Pray for bro

[@wesleycorway]

"Back in the 90s, I was in a very famous TV show...."

[@bman5257]

Society of Jesus has to be one of the most remarkable phenomena in world history. The amount of powerhouse saints and geniuses is off the charts.

[@thecatechumen]

Shout out to Fr. John, haha!

[@nerdanalog1707]

I do have a tender spot for the elderly who try to relive their romanticised « glory » days. This is a temptation we shall all face at one point, the « back in my days… »

[@peterhenryzepeda3484]

James White played Nintendo 64 with Gerry Matitixs, and Mitch Pachwa.

[@TheBurningWarrior]

Nah, it was still NES for Matatics (SNES, was available but only in Japan). Because of this, when Fr Pacwa wanted to play N64, Mr White informed him that in all the tine he debated Jerry Matatix, he never played N64, so they couldn't play N64 then in '99.

[@harley6659]

Don't know what's more annoying, the constant call backs to previous debates or the way he pronounces Greek. Excellent video.

[@martin-458]

Isn't this the guy that did numerous debates with Roman Catholics?

[@crushtheserpent]

Still does

[@910iva]

Got cooked by voice of reason

[@sw3aty_forte]

maybe idk not sure

[@josephross1900]

Yeah, I don't think he has debated any especially not in the 90s

[@crushtheserpent]

@@josephross1900 He's done plenty of debates with Catholics since the 90's. He did one recently with Voice Of Reason.

[@RCC.1962]

OMG ! Here we go again! He really can't help himself. 😂😅😂😅

[@aaronwinter447]

I get a feeling James White still has copies of these debates on VHS in a box somewhere.

[@TCM1231]

Ain’t no way he brings up the 90s in his OPENING STATEMENT

[@pedrogutierrez1547]

Interesting how James White never gives his debate with Patrick Madrid a mention… and Yes! Also from the 90’s.

[@nunuvyerbizniz6803]

Does anyone know if James White has ever debated Gerry Matatics? I'm struggling to find any information on whether or not he and Gerry ever talked.

[@cactoidjim1477]

Gerry Matatics! Mitch Pacwa! Uncle Rico!

[@VivatChristus]

Oh, 1990s. I thought you meant stuck in the 90s of the 1st century and thought, "Great! He converted!" Oh well. Also, great way to end. I would also add Fr. Robert McTeigue SJ as a based Jesuit.

[@victoria9381]

That goutee 😂 oh vey 🤦

[@Cklert]

Bro peaked in the 90s and never moved on.

[@mikeyangel1067]

What peaked in the 90’s for James was his last hair before he went downhill in other categories. 😢😅

[@chasejohnson1775]

Can anyone tell me why he insists on saying "Roman Catholicism" and "Roman Catholics"?

[@Deuterocomical]

Probably because "Catholic" means universal and he wants to distinguish it from that

[@abortion_worst_genocide_ever]

Roman Catholic is Catholic and is Universal. Period. If you are a Protestant you will protest against the truth, it doesn't change it anyways.@@Deuterocomical

[@abortion_worst_genocide_ever]

@@Heinrich.Denzinger our Religion is Catholicism, and we are the actual Christians, the others are Protestant, so, disobedient herethic people.

[@josephross1900]

Roman catholic is an American derogatory saying our loyalty is Rome not the US.

[@abortion_worst_genocide_ever]

@@Deuterocomical there are many other Catholic groups who are in communion with Rom and aren't Roman. So, people Just Show ignorance believing it's Just something about Rom. To be a real Catholic, a real Christian, you must accept Peter as the authority and it doesn't mean it's Just something about Rom. All of you should inverstigate and learn about the Church, you are ignorants and that's the reason because you are protestants, If you would study, all of you would know, that the only christianism is Catholic and obeys the Pope.

[@Hmmmmmm487]

Correction:Jamal Black is stuck in the 90’s

[@HonorableMembah]

The Catholic Church - founded 1990 by Gerry Matatics, Long Beach

[@marklauber8653]

The fresh prince of predestination 😎 (More specifically, double predestination)

[@RealSeanithan]

These last few videos to come out have been enjoyable and I've liked them a great deal. I am curious, though: are there any more AI or YTP videos in the works? Those were some of the funniest videos I've seen in my life.

[@Deuterocomical]

@@RealSeanithan Yes! The AI and YTP videos will keep coming, don’t worry. Just trying out some other ideas. Thanks for being a loyal fan!

[@RCC.1962]

This is comic Gold! Im only halfway through this... I owe you a present. Thank you for this, and please keep them coming.

[@RealSeanithan]

@@Deuterocomical if you kept this kind of stuff, I'd be fine too: it's all funny. I've been watching since you put Fr Pine and Trent Horn on your old channel.

[@becky-not-thomas]

I don't know who he is, but what is it about the beard? Or is it just compensation for the baldness? It looks like a fake beard . I just can't keep watching.... LOL!

[@frapaschal6594]

Surprisingly enjoyable stream of quotes. Who’s going to go watch these old debates?

[@thetorinado2697]

Bro really said “all my original thoughts came from August of 1990” and cited himself as his best source while setting himself up as the president of the Fr. Mitch Pacwa Fan Club

[@SingPsalms]

This was exhausting lol

[@stlouisix3]

After 3 decades, James White is still afraid of debating über-based MHFM because we are true Catholics! The debate challenge is still open, Jamie boy!😂😂😂😂😂😅😅😅

[@IsaiahINRI]

"The Doctrine of Papal Infalibility is so useless." Then why is it such a hang up for y'all?

[@NathanielStallings-nf6qi]

The first reference was fine but you’ve gotta stop after like 2 or 3😂

[@dynamic9016]

Really appreciate this video...James White is ridiculous..😅

[@mellieg.7543]

Does James realize that he is constantly referring back to debates that took place before many of his young adult viewers were born 😶?

[@IC-XC_NIKA]

😴🥱🛌💤

[@davemoore7808]

I love the 90's.

[@divinemercyapologetics]

Pax Christi❤

[@jamessheffield4173]

They are charging me with innovation, and base their charge on my confession of three hypostases, and blame me for asserting one Goodness, one Power, one Godhead. In this they are not wide of the truth, for I do so assert. Their complaint is that their custom does not accept this, and that Scripture does not agree. What is my reply? I do not consider it fair that the custom which obtains among them should be regarded as a law and rule of orthodoxy. If custom is to be taken in proof of what is right, then it is certainly competent for me to put forward on my side the custom which obtains here. If they reject this, we are clearly not bound to follow them. Therefore let God-inspired Scripture decide between us; and on whichever side be found doctrines in harmony with the Word of God, in favor of that side will be cast the vote of truth.[1] Basil the Great, The Letters, Letter 189 (To Eustathius the Physician).

[@CatholicSamurai]

yeah but did Basil debate Gerry Mattatix in 1990? James White debater him in 1990, you know.

[@DanielRevolt]

So he’s not allowed to reference one of the 200 debates he’s done because it was in the 90’s? I didn’t know theology had changed so much since then.

[@Deuterocomical]

It's funny because he only mentions the handful of them that he thinks he won, despite doing 200 of them

[@DanielRevolt]

@@Deuterocomical because he’s driving the same point? Challenge the position, this stuff is just…silly.

[@Deuterocomical]

@@DanielRevolt You think my channel is silly? Good! That was the goal 😃

[@DanielRevolt]

@@Deuterocomical I don’t know who you are or what you do on this channel. This video popped up on my recommended. My point remains.

[@HelloTygr]

I don’t think it’s a particularly effective debate tactic, but I don’t think that referring to past debates warrants making fun of like this. It just doesn’t make sense as a critique or joke.

[@Deuterocomical]

How many more times would he have to do it for it to become comical for you?

[@MothyEmms]

whats the problem/joke?

[@Deuterocomical]

@@MothyEmms Every time James White debates a Catholic, he takes some of his allotted time bring up the old debates he did in the 90

[@MothyEmms]

@@Deuterocomical yeah and?

[@vincenzorutigliano7239]

That's not the best way to "move the ball forward" like he intended

[@MothyEmms]

@@vincenzorutigliano7239 why? if it is useful to the points he is making it makes sense to refer to them instead of manually reiterating the same points, doesn't it?

[@Joker22593]

Except he lost all those debates too. By referring to them instead of actually explaining his point, he's pretending that he won them and the audience never hears a real argument. He's basically saying "I don't have to debate this because I already won." Arrogant and unhelpful.

[@rbnmnt3341]

JW is not stuck in the 90's. He's stuck in scripture. That is the issue for you that think tradition usurps God's word.

[@Fasolislithuan]

Good joke. This channel and the comments are good for share a lot of laughs

[@ghostapostle7225]

*stuck in his own interpretation of Scripture.

[@RCC.1962]

@@ghostapostle7225 LOL!!

[@Leocomander]

Wow thanks for giving me a front row seat to nonsense.

[@eucharistenjoyer]

All the 30000 different denominations that ascribe to Sola Scriptura think they're stuck in Scripture, and surprisingly they diverge in so many topics. Intriguing right?