Has The Game Changed? Iron Remover Comparison (Stoner Car Care vs DIY vs P&S)

In this one we compare iron removers and decide which one is the superior choice for my decontamination needs! In this battle we have the revolutionary no stink Stoner Iron Remover vs DIY Detail’s Modern Iron Remover vs P&S Crystal Wash which is an old school iron remover!
Imjoshv vid- • STONER CAR CARE'S NEW ...
Stoner Car Care Promo: JAMIE15- stonercarcare.com/products/st...
DIY Detail Promo: JAMIE10- diydetail.com/?ref=UKH78ur5
P&S Promo: JAMIE10- psdetailproducts.com/?ref=48e...
IK Sprayers:
IK Multi Pro 12 (No Battery)- amzn.to/41Tt1Cc
IK Multi Pro 2- amzn.to/41LRjxU
IK Multi Sprayer- amzn.to/48M3Jbn
IK Multi Mini 360- amzn.to/3S7pkp5
Wheel Bucket:
Detail Factory Tire Brush- amzn.to/3OeAEh1
Detail Factory Fender Well Brush- amzn.to/3S5HRC5
Wheel Mitt- amzn.to/4aJoAO6
Detail Brush- amzn.to/47ndM5E
Drill Brush- amzn.to/3S7Zt0r
Blue Ultra Brush- amzn.to/48ninWK
Wash Bucket:
Wash Mitt-amzn.to/47pUjBf
Emblem Brush-amzn.to/41Plq7v
Clay Towel-amzn.to/41RNxmv
Clay Scrubber-amzn.to/4aDs0C2s

[@StonerCarCare]

Nice review Jamie! Excited for the podcast tomorrow 🙌

[@diydetailofficial]

Thanks for using DIY Detail

[@TheBreakfastLover]

"Stainer's" 😂

[@IamDetailedAF]

I don't recall the last time a Stoner did anything good for me. 👀 They do clean my windows like a champ! Need to test more stuff.

[@JhawkerZ]

Great demo Jamie. I'd like to see a more in depth video of Mud Buster and Crystal Wash

[@JamieTheCleaner]

You got it 💪🧼

[@jcrepus]

What is the famous mud buster? Another mixup?

[@JamieTheCleaner]

@@jcrepus it’s a P&S product in the Off Road Line and very powerful pretreatment

[@imjoshv]

Great approach to the test! Mud buster looking good man!!

[@ryanmulhearn8843]

Looking forward to upcoming Cleaner Cast! Should be your most watched one yet!

[@SoCleenDetailing]

Can't wait for the vid on mud buster...that was awesome to see it in action 👏🏽

[@erikmarschang2245]

Yes please do a video on mudbuster. It looks like it's eats through bugs no problem!

[@TheBizcuit0426]

Jamie, can we get a video on the P&S Crystal wash and how you use it? There is limited to nothing online or on KZbin about it. It's almost a hidden jewel if it does what I think it should.

[@mikeeonfiya]

Yes please! I ordered some and waiting for shipment. P&S Hayward is a 30 min drive from me - so I’m going to try and reserve a position for the detail class on Dec. 4th. I’ll meet you then hopefully!

[@Ecdetails]

Dope test Jamie

[@dannysandoval5195]

Another great video from Jamie The Cleaner. Did you use P&S Mud Buster at full strength?

[@JamieTheCleaner]

4-1 dilution 👍

[@SR.Exclusive.Auto.Detail]

Yessir a new video 🔥

[@annalongfield]

I mostly get heavy contaminated vehicles. In my area, we have tons of manufacturing, a sea port, and several large rail yards all creating lots of various contamination. The claying process is taking up a ton of time and probably costing me money in my details. If I use crystal wash as my pre wash and iron buster as my decon, what's your recommended p&s soap for foaming and bucket use? I currently use pearl and it's not enough. This is for my clients initial wash or uncoated client's cars. Once coated, I am having no issues.

[@MyGuyKirby]

That rear hatch would have likely showed up more iron from that zone. I know the hood is so much easier to video but taller vehicles get more on the sides and rear. But you know that already but do appreciate your testing it out!

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Very true! Should have done a quick test on the back!

[@soynobody2741]

after watching JOSHV video, Stoner Iron Remover aint for me.. but im here to check out the how the Crystal Wash compares to traditional Iron Removers.. i had the crystal wash in a few checkout carts during the black friday and cyber monday specials and didnt buy yet.. does it make sense to stack the crystal wash with iron remover, since it only removes organinc contaminents??thanks for the video

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Yeah it could make sense to still do an iron remover at the end as normal 👍

[@I5ZQ8]

Wish u weren't so far from me, my white truck sits 4-6 days a week in a chemical refinery 200 yards from a flare stack and a railroad that gets used daily 😅

[@chrisbradley3224]

Does Crystal Wash unclog coatings like water spot remover? Seemed to do a bit here. Could be a gentler substitute for that function. The oxalic acid in Crystal Wash is less nasty than some of the water spot removers.

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Correct it’s certainly not as strong but definitely helps unclog the coatings 👍🧼

[@big-redsdetailingcliffords2379]

Checking in brother

[@jayz313]

Jamie, do you have any experience with Turtle Wax Hybrid Soluntions Rapud Decon?

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Yeah good iron remover 👍

[@matthewneil6119]

I used the stoner and it stained my driveway as well. I was able to use my pressure washer to wash it off

[@parksnrecsdetailing]

Can Crystal Wash be used instead of an iron remover for paint decon before polishing and ceramic coating?

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Correct 👍 🧼

[@realdopewater]

Thanks! After I spray on the crystal wash, and let it dwell…can I foam the entire car with slightly alkaline foam? (KC Active Foam). This way I don’t have to rinse twice

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Yep 👍 once crystallized it has done it job just carry on as normal

[@realdopewater]

@@JamieTheCleaner my man 👌🏾

[@robpeluso2852]

Could you foam mud buster over crystal wash and then do the 1st rinse?

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Yes 👍

[@robpeluso2852]

Thanks Jamie! I’ll try that this winter as I live in the Northeast and they use 10x more road salt than needed 😂….

[@joerodriguez8546]

Where can I buy Mud Buster? Or is it a mix or concoction you formulated 😂

[@JamieTheCleaner]

O it’s an official product 🤣 psdetailproducts.com/products/mud-buster-general-purpose-cleaner promo: JAMIE10 to save some change

[@DetailingMadeSimple]

Great review my brother. Damnnnn 2 years not been detailed and no contamination? That’s crazy. Great to know it didn’t stain your driveways

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Ain’t nothing staining this driveway

[@DetailingMadeSimple]

@@JamieTheCleaner it’s in the swamp. Ain’t nothing getting to it

[@thesamsquatch5224]

Excellent video! Careful cause it'll stain your concrete, trim, your face and your credit score Just for Eddie shoutout to stained cheeks

[@edornelas7248]

U should of hit that hood with some water spot remover to see if we could see some bead action since u did coat it two years ago..

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Yeah I did off camera after the wash still pretty dead 🧼👍

[@edornelas7248]

@@JamieTheCleaner damn, ok. Thx for the reply!!

[@orthodox1717]

I'm torn betwwen buying a gallon of TW Iron Decon or P&S Iron Buster???

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Both are good 👍

[@orthodox1717]

@@JamieTheCleaner how did I know you would say that?! 🤣 Not that I disagree.

[@daltinos1011]

Should have just sprayed all three at the same time so it would been more equal result instead of wiping the last 2 down with a wash mitt before the last 2 iron removers

[@RCdetails203]

Crystal Wash is a pre treat contamination remover…the other 2 were traditional iron removers which usually recommend washing the vehicle first for maximum effectiveness so he was just using the products as the directions call for

[@MikesAutoDetailing]

Great video

[@the1whoshallremainnameless]

I just opened a gallon of Stoners about 5 minutes before i watched the video 😮

[@TheBreakfastLover]

You can still try to return it. It's a defective product that I'm sure Stainer's will recall.

[@shojus]

👌🏻

[@DJCHURKLE]

Is crystal wash safe for coatings and PPF?

[@aldaley3537]

The SUV in the video is ceramic coated.

[@DJCHURKLE]

@@aldaley3537 understood but coatings generally have an safe acidity/alkalinity working range. I don’t see anything listed for that

[@TheBreakfastLover]

the pH of Crystal Wash is 2.4, so its a fairly strong acid. Most coatings will start degrade at around pH 3 to 2. Most PPF can typically tolerate down to pH 4 to 3. So I wouldn't use on PPF nor coatings, perhaps on coating if diluted 10:1 and PPF diluted 100:1.

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Works very well on good ceramic coatings 👍🧼

[@DJCHURKLE]

@@TheBreakfastLover thanks so much!

[@PolishedMobileDetailing503]

Slow reaction time, no stinky smell. Easy to see that stoners product is for the dogs.

[@JamieTheCleaner]

In this one it had a similar reaction time but yeah others reviews it’s way slower so not sure 🤔

[@tristengarrett4198]

Try out detail studio iron out don’t have that stinky smell

[@khailerlopez8816]

typo @jamie

[@JamieTheCleaner]

Where?

[@khailerlopez8816]

@@JamieTheCleaner stainers vs diy vs pands

[@khailerlopez8816]

you said stainers not stoners no one perf just thought i’d let ya know brotha love your content

[@jbalinski]

😂@@JamieTheCleaner

[@JamieTheCleaner]

@@jbalinski 🤣🤣👍