Palestine Population & Jewish Immigration

[@steins2496]

How is it that the British had more rights on the Palestinian land than the Palestinian people themselves.

[@mohammadmayer9135]

British won the war and they had full control on lebanon and Palestine and another country i forgot

[@khairulhelmihashim2510]

@@mohammadmayer9135 , most ex-ottoman territories were divided between french and british after WW1. french got lebanon and syria. british got iraq, palestine, jordan.

[@fouadmas5413]

Also many Germans felt betrayed with some of their citizens due to the Balfour Declaration during WW1

[@laszlok53]

2 reasons: 1. There was no "Palestinian people", they were arabs living there just the same arabs as all over the vicinity. Nothing special "palestinian" about them. Technically even the jews are "palestinians" ""Palestinian" was used to refer to the nationalist concept of a Palestinian people by Palestinian Arabs from the late 19th century, albeit in a limited way until World War I." en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinians 2. The British had no "rights" about land but "territory" by removing the previous rulers, the Ottoman administration. They did not OWN the territory but RULED it. Not so difficult to understand, if you TRY. If you don't, then anything might be difficult for you. About false history/narrative: palwatch.org/database/97

[@ghanay.2044]

@@mohammadmayer9135 Britain lied to the Arabs in WW1 that if they revolted against the Ottomans empire they will support a United Arab nation. Not even after the war ended they were conspiring with the French to devide up the land. At the same time they continued promising arabs an independent arab state.

[@salman-lf3ly]

That is why I support Palestine and stand with it, and anyone who has a human conscience must do the same

[@CivilThinking]

This is the world's craziest occupation. How come some foreigners come to a specific country and make a separate country?? And even the hilarious part is the UNO supported the formation of a new country within a country?! Crazy.

[@super_nova9202]

UN is the source of major crisis in our world today

[@laszlok53]

"formation of a new country within a country" Within what country?

[@guledfarah8610]

UN is the most useless thing in the world.

[@ShaikhaInk]

And today there are refugees in their own land ... how can you a refugee in your own country🙄.. Satanic policy

[@tboss6689]

how can Jews be foreigners their own land ? when did Judea become their land ?? israel is over 3500 years old while the name Palestine was invented by the Romans after they colonized Judea . its basic history .

[@XCyberAttackX]

He forgets to state that this 1/3 of Jewish, originally they are immigrants from Europe!! How you give them the right over the origin ppl (the pelastanian)?? Palestinean means the (Arab Muslim, Arab Christian and Arab Jewish) not the settler, immigrants.

[@justanotherman1639]

Original people are the Jews , who were forced to leave their homes during the Roman times, and now they are back

[@englishexpert1989]

@@justanotherman1639 - 𝑌𝑜𝑢𝑟 ℎ𝑜𝑢𝑠𝑒 𝑢𝑠𝑒𝑑 𝑡𝑜 𝑏𝑒 𝑚𝑦 ℎ𝑜𝑚𝑒 2000 𝑦𝑒𝑎𝑟𝑠 𝑏𝑎𝑐𝑘 .𝑌𝑜𝑢 𝑚𝑢𝑠𝑡 𝑙𝑒𝑎𝑣𝑒 𝑛𝑜𝑤

[@englishexpert1989]

@@justanotherman1639 - 𝑁𝑜 𝑜𝑛𝑒 𝑏𝑒𝑙𝑖𝑣𝑒𝑠 𝑖𝑛 𝑗𝑒𝑤𝑖𝑠ℎ 𝑓𝑎𝑖𝑟𝑦 𝑡𝑎𝑙𝑒𝑠

[@justanotherman1639]

@@englishexpert1989 you *stole my house 2000 years ago. You must leave now

[@justanotherman1639]

@@englishexpert1989 there is ample evidence. You simple don't want to agree

[@dorianel-khoury557]

This is not a point of view. This is the true history

[@almightyunicron]

@Justyna Stefania I. nice video man

[@rachelsamuel3328]

No, most of this is revisionist history.

[@brave-i9l]

Yes, history tells us that the Jews developed through legal means such as legal immigration and purchase of land. It was not until the Arabs launched a large-scale invasion that the Palestinian region fell into a cycle of violence.

[@saabajoe]

Minors corrections but overall accurate. One being, the British did not "promise Palestine" to Palestinians, they are indigenous, it was their land.

[@SketchyOnReviews]

Why British get to decide?

[@omarabddaim4877]

because they defeated the ottomons in WW1 and ruled over the land for themselves .. its a fundamental rule. The winner always gets to decide what he wants

[@dinajallad2164]

just like America is deciding everything now. they were the strong empire at the time.. and they are colonizers themselves

[@josephfreeman3816]

Sketchy on zreviews. I hope this reaches you my friend. In answer to your question the British got to decide because st the end of World War I the British pretty much ran the world and hence they along with the French dictated the Treaty of Versailles which 1 formally ended the 1st World War 2. Beggars zgermsny and set the stage for World War 2 and had the League of Nations which the English and French also pretty much ran award them the Mandate over Palestine. But why you may ask was a Mandate by the British over Palestine a good or even a desirable thing? The short answer is 1. The THEORY was that certain areas had been ruled by the corrupt Ottoman Empire so long and so badly that these areas had no experience in self government or setting up functioning administrations for health education. Roads sanitation all the things that government does. So much like a big brother or father looks after and trains a young one so would the benevolent British train and develop the Palestinians in the art of governance until they could at some indeterminate time in the future do it for themselves. If this sounds like a not very believable proposition you d be correct. 2 but how about the Americans you ask? After all haven't they always been about a people s right to self determination and freedom? Well yes in the sense that at the beginning of the 20th century Americans were NOT a world power in the scale of the Germans zFrrnch Russians and especially Britons. They had only begun to assemble an empire with the defeat of Spain and the acquisition of the Philippines. Moreover the majority of AMERICANS SAW NO DESIRABILITY OR NECESSITY for such activities having a very rich Homeland of their own isolated bt two large oceans and with weak non threatening neighbors in the western hemisphere. In short they were isolationist by and large who had been more or less dragged into World War 1 by their government helped defeat the Germans and now wanted to return to their fsrms.theyvdidnt want anything to do with the Kearse of Nations either. So they didn't join. 3. In any event the British very much DID want a Mandate over Palestine. But why? To understand why you'd have to return to 1927 .in 2927 the 1st World War was not going well for Britain or for that matter France. In fact Germany was winning the Russians were exiting the war and Britain was near bankruptcy. So like many nations previously they went to the international Jewish banking community for a loan to finance their continuation of the war. This cartel of bankers had been in existence for centuries. Usually a loan was extended with interest tacked on. HOWEVER..this time the Zionist bankers had an additional requirement. Britain must make a declaration that it would support a Jewish state or Homeland. WHERE? IN PALESTINE where the Jewish state had existed more or less continuously for a couple of thousand years prior to its destruction by the Romsn Empire around 30 to 40 A D. 4. Now this condition was somewhat awkward for the British inasmuch as they had promised the Palestinian people self determination and an independent state of their own if they assisted the British in SW1 against the Turks. Wbich the Palestinians did to the best of their abilities. Nevertheless the British needed the loan. So they issued the Balfour Declarstion which more or less ststedvthatvthey would support the creation of a Jewish or Xionist state in.... Palestine. Since thec w 850s the zionists had foreseen the need for a Jewish safe haven. The Jrws had never been popular in European Christian countries and although dhimmi in Muslim countries had generally been treated far better. MOST European Jees wanted to go to the Us. However they were at that time believe it or not Not welcome. The second choice was Palestine a far poorer country. Neverthe less to have a state you've got to h a ve 3 things at a minimum land water and population. The Zionists began buying up land from Palestinian farmers along with watering they began a program of financing package and farm equipment for Jews to go to Palestine and settle on the land purchased. This program had been in existence for aroundv70 years prior to the Balfour Declaration. After the Balfour Declarstion it rspidlycac c elevated due tovrixing anti Semitismnin Europe most particularly in Germany Poland Hungary Lithuania Russia and Ukraine. By 1940 the more farsighted Jews had left Europe. The remainder went up in smoke at places like Dachsu and Auschwitz. Thexzionist program of resettlement really went into high gear at the end of Ww2. It was of course obvious that no country including the US wanted a large population of Jess. The remaining Jews well understood that there was no safe haven anywhere on earth for them other than Palestine which had been in the process of being prepared for them by the zionists for almost 100 years. The result was a tidal wave of Jewish immigration into Palestine. Aided and abetted by the British who held the Mandate . Friction and fighting between the zpalestinians and the zjess had been common since at least the 1920s but now became the norm with oara military units such as Iran rage Stern gang and Haganah on the zjeeish side and similar units on the Palestinian side. And BOTH sides attacked the British and killed them. Not surprisingly since Palestinians had been betrayed and lied to ever since the zbalfour Declaration and the Zinionists felt the zbritishvwere dragging their feet in allowing the establishment of the Jeeishvstste promised since the zbalfour Declaration. And indeed the British WERE responsible in the main for the sorry state of affairs. Enter the UN. IT Proposed and proceeded to implement an entirely arbitrary and grossly inequitable division of Palestine into a Jewish portion and a Palestinian portion.. one of many problems was that the proposed partition sllocsredc54 prevent ofvyhe land to the Jewscwho at thst time comprised about 33 percent of the population and who actually OWNED as a rexultnofnprevious purchases 7 per cent of the land. Not surprisingly the zoakestinians objected. The zbtitish tired of getting shot and bombed by both Jewish and Palestinian paramilitaries abandoned the Mandate. Ben zgutuan declared the state of Israel. The Hagsnsh a former terrorist irradiation became the zisraeli army. The Palestinians joined by 6 surrounding zmuslim countries set out to eliminate the new Jewish state .They failed. The Palestinians largely became refugees and their oars militariesremained terrorist organizations. Or at least labeled as such by the new state of Israel. While simplified this is an explanation if his one side became a state and the other side became stress terrorists. The winners get to put the labels on. Its as simple as that. A great injustice was done to t h e Palestinian people. This injustice began in 1850 and continues to this day.

[@odaenathus7825]

@@omarabddaim4877 like a bully, a thief....what a stupid answer

[@jeffreyfearn5662]

Simple the League of Nations decided that the British were to have a mandate, interesting how you don't mention the French Mandate!!

[@kcflygirl29]

Thank you for bringing this to light. Most people post political memes supporting “ the chosen people.” Chosen by who, the UN. Just as in the Punjab( Kashmir) Europeans meddle in affairs that aren’t theirs, then deny the blood on their hands.

[@Nudnik1]

So you return all the wealth and lands your European forefathers stole exploited occupied from naitive peoples after centuries of colonialism imperialism globally. Return to UK or Europe. Then tell Us we cannot return to our homeland.. נודנק

[@philipkozely3768]

They are chosen by themselves .... they selfrighteously gave to themselves the right to be chosen, superior to all non jews and claim delusionally that God chose them

[@DK-os8of]

Thank you so true ..

[@reformer4545]

Britain was afraid that the Germans would take control of Palestine and this would be tolerated. They agreed to let the European Jews obtain land for themselves in Palestine.

[@FrankskinOrweed-ep4ij]

When u realise who their God is, it makes more sense!

[@brusselssprout1]

Why does this historical summary falsely oppose "Jews" and "Palestinians" up to 1947? The issue was played between Jews of Palestine (including a large number of recent Jewish immigrants from Europe) and Arabs of Palestine (themselves composed of Muslims and a sizeable minority of Christians). It is MUCH later, way after the creation of the State of Israël and the 1948 war, that the term "Palestinians" started to become synonymous with the Arab population that lived in the parts of Palestine allocated to Arabs by the UN, as well as the Arab refugees that fled or were expelled from Israeli land during that war. And even after that war, none of the Arab territories that were meant to compose Arab Palestine had any statehood status: Gaza was governed by Egypt and the West Bank got integrated into Jordan. The construct of "Palestine" as an Arab/Muslim nation and state is recent and only gained traction after 1967.

[@MaximillianPushker]

Exactly, people conveniently forget all this. Yasser Arafat essentially invented the term “Palestinian” around the time of the Six Day War, which was almost 20 years after Israel was founded.

[@davidb7258]

Exactly what i was thinking. The narrative is there. There were no Jews, Muslims and Palestinians. It was Jews and Muslims living in Palestine which is a rename of the historical Kingdom of Israel and Judea.

[@reformer4545]

The Great British government committed a major mistake, a mistake that would be a shame for it. It gave the land to those who did not deserve it, and it became disturbed and fought against everyone who fought for their land and to defend their land.

[@brave-i9l]

Why don't they deserve it? Look at the difference between Israel and the West Bank, Gaza, and Israel. Are Arab citizens willing to move to the West Bank? They are not even willing to marry West Bankers.

[@fahmiizzuddinhalim5273]

“Palestinian” is a geographical entity that can be comprised of all different ethnicities. The UN proposal was to create two states both for Jews and Arabs not Jews and Palestinians. Cause, Palestinian can be Jews and Arabs. But also thank you for addressing the existence of Yishuv (Palestinian Jews community before the mass Aliyah in recorded modern Zionism history). Most people, think that Jews as whole only migrated from European countries and Russian empire but there are numbers of Jews migrated by foot from the neighbouring Arab world such as Yemen and Iraq. Note that, Jordan was initially part of the Palestine mandate and future Arab state solution for Palestinians Arabs. And none of this matter addressed to dispossess anyone from anywhere. Expulsions and land dispossession followed later resulted from Arab-Israel war 1948-1949 to reject the establishment of Israeli State. Both Jews and local Palestinians Arabs were severely affected by this horrible war. Jordan expelled Jews in Judea-Samaria and East Jerusalem provinces.

[@tboss6689]

Palestinians dont exist ,they are Just Arabs ,its why the UN specifically said Arab and Jews .

[@laszlok53]

Some accurate words. Thank you for them.

[@marshalljulie3676]

Arab is a race jew is a religion European Jews and Arab Jews some arabs are even Christians. I know I work with them

[@92GreyBlue]

Typical Jewish wordplay...... THE WORLD IS FINALLY WAKING UP TO YOUR WAYS.

[@KHAT-m8u]

Judaism aren’t race or ethnicity ! So don’t talking about something you don’t know. Palestinians are mixed descendants of Israel and his brother Ishmael (Father of the Arabs), which a European Jew of unknown parentage like them has absolutely nothing to do with.

[@Biblical_DNA]

1:31 The real reason why WWII started. Motivate Jews to leave their well established lives for Palestine.

[@Biblical_DNA]

2:19 Doubted me?

[@Biblical_DNA]

3:44 Because of the rise of who? Hitler. The Zionist Jesuit puppet.

[@Biblical_DNA]

3:57 What was the dilemma? That both the Jews and Palestinians have their own land in Palestinem

[@mthimkhulu30]

Europeans moved to middle east dont justify anything just say it straight

[@brave-i9l]

Like Muslims immigrating to the West?

[@nancymcmonarch]

The transcripts of the U.N. debates in the mid-40s are frustrating and heartbreaking to read. Representatives of so many Arab countries imploring, "Please don't do this! It defies all logic, and will end in bloodshed for years to come." And of course they were absolutely right. The UK and U.S. should have absorbed all the refugees.

[@truthseeker-nv6ny]

I think the US or UK or Germany should've given up some of their land for the Jewish state to be established

[@nancymcmonarch]

@@truthseeker-nv6ny "Jewish state" = backward theocracy, and the last place those concentration camp survivors wanted to stay was in Germany. BUT they'd have been relatively safe and sound as eventual U.S. citizens. And our country had HELLA more room for them than Palestine did.

[@nancymcmonarch]

@@botungkiggung Most of them didn't arrive in Palestine until the UN created Israel in the late 40s. The migrants from Europe would have been far less a problem in, say, Montana.

[@nancymcmonarch]

@@botungkiggung I agree, but what's done is done. Israel isn't going anywhere.

[@nancymcmonarch]

@@botungkiggung Won't even try to guess what that means. I DO think the only hope for peace there is for the UN or NATO to send troops in, as the Allies did in Germany and Japan, to teach the damn locals how to live in peace for a change. 75 years of waiting for them to play nice amongst themselves is WAY too long a grace period.

[@jeremyhodge6216]

The British and Americans are to blame for this mess we're in 😒

[@FrankskinOrweed-ep4ij]

Nah they had a part to play in enabling all of this but blame the Jew supremacists ultimately. Even letter to Rothschild’s from Royal family stated that existing Palestinians were not to be harmed, yet Zionists broke this term on Day 1!!!

[@shahrahil1298]

Save gaza ❤

[@celinesleiman6001]

Save the whole of Palestine from the river to the sea.

[@hsm8321]

@@celinesleiman6001 palestine will be free

[@pandacat8249]

💪✊

[@theunknownguy265]

🇸🇦❤🇵🇸

[@celinesleiman6001]

@@hsm8321 insha Allah. It's Allah's promise.

[@HussainAlrebeh]

Who's watching this after Oct 7th? Welcome to the history class.

[@Sundancer09]

Fortunately, I already know the history of the mythological 'land without a people.' 🤭

[@SCUT_Z0NE]

You mean propaganda? Islam is the biggest coloniser in human history 😂😂 you must really love self loathing ignorant indoctrinated western people

[@khairulhelmihashim2510]

to shift the demographic balance to build a Jewish majority, the Israel govt allows any Jews to migrate and settle there, creating further tensions.

[@tboss6689]

so your fine with 52 Islamic states but your problem is one Jewish state ?

[@odaenathus7825]

@@tboss6689 yes

[@syhuhjk]

@@odaenathus7825 that's shows too much amount of intolerance

[@rachelsamuel3328]

There is no further tensions. It is an Israeli Jewish state. They can make anyone they want as citizens.

[@rachelsamuel3328]

@علي ياسر I thought Moses was a perfect Muslim prophet?

[@dunaibrahim5574]

There’s many investors who buy property in different countries does that give them the right to actually own the had and set up their own state? It wouldn’t happen anywhere else

[@forestfighter6891]

Usa pls bring ths israel jews to your country. Dnt make chaos in our land

[@Qwertz772]

usa isnt making chaos its the yahoodi strong united people unlike arabia

[@cindyrolle6476]

This is the best explanation of the concise history of Palestine and Israel.

[@tboss6689]

but its wrong, why is there no mention of Judea ??

[@marshalljulie3676]

@@tboss6689 probably made up to support the lie

[@tboss6689]

@@marshalljulie3676 i like the word probably , when people cant disprove the truth they resort to words like probably ! Just say anything to make you feel better

[@KHAT-m8u]

@@tboss6689 Which still a name of the religion Judaism WHICH ISN’T A RACE.

[@tboss6689]

its an ethno religion , look it up @@KHAT-m8u

[@guyeshel9316]

1936-1938 You're calling it the "Palestinian revolt" while we here call it the "Arab revolt". And calling the Arabs "Palestinians" while they themselves did not call themselves "Palestinians" is heavily misleading. Provide some sources for Arabs referring to themselves as Palestinians before 1947 and I will rethink about this.

[@tarek903]

Go back to Europe and end this, instead you question that there were people there. Golda meir her self said once she is Palestinian. Shimon perrz has a Palestinian passport. Go spread your lies somewhere else please. 800,000 Palestinian expelled from their home in 1948 and he says there were no Palestinians. What an asshole zionist

[@GrayWolf-i2n]

World problem created by West

[@truthmatters1950]

Critical point, stated and visible in print, but glossed over @1:19 : With the Jewish population of Palestine at around `14%, the 1917 Balfour Declaration promised a Jewish "national home" - NOT a "state", and that there was to be no prejudice to existing "non-Jewish" communities. This, at a time when Jews were 14% of the population. And lived harmoniously amongst their fellow Arab citizens.

[@shainazion4073]

Except other British documents and the Mandate documents all explain that the Jewish Agency was the future government of the area of Palestine. There was no other people discussed in the Mandate Charter documents except the non-Jewish communities in Palestine who were given religious and civil rights, Not political rights! Read the Mandate Charter!!

[@truthmatters1950]

@@shainazion4073 ​​⁠Thank you for your response Shaina. The British, having reneged on their promised reward for Arab support of the Allied WW1 effort, in fact promised the Jews fleeing global persecution a “homeland” - to your point, NOT a state - in the area already occupied by Arabs.

[@shainazion4073]

@@truthmatters1950 That is not what was understood, or talked about, or in correspondence. To reconstitute their homeland. Their homeland was a kingdom, a self-governing kingdom, a state.

[@truthmatters1950]

@@shainazion4073 Apologies but I’m not clear on what you mean by “their homeland “ - do you mean “Jewish homeland” and, by inference when you say “state, homeland “ you mean a Jewish state (was promised to the Jewish people)?

[@shainazion4073]

@@truthmatters1950 There were meetings between the early Zionists leaders, there was letters, there was correspondence. In the wording, "reconstitute the Jewish homeland", the Jewish homeland was kingdoms and then a ruling court, "the SanHedrin" for 1000 years.

[@Dahit-ji6lf]

Talk about genocide on Armenian Assyrian and Greek perpetrated by Turkey,in your next video.

[@Theouterrim77]

Most of what was assigned to Jews out of that 54% was the Negev desert! And the rest that was assigned were areas where Jews had purchased land.

[@Theouterrim77]

@علي ياسر Genetic studies prove Jews have predominantly Semitic DNA.

[@Theouterrim77]

@علي ياسر Half of Israelis are from Middle Eastern and North Africa lands. I'll repeat, genetic studies by the most respected scientists all record that Jews have predominantly Semitic genetics. I never lie, it's one that has been told lies from the beginning of one's life.

[@Theouterrim77]

@علي ياسر Genetic studies are "consistent with a historical formulation of the Jewish people as descending from ancient Hebrew and Israelites of the Levant" and "the dispersion of the people of ancient Israel throughout the Old World". Source: Behar DM, et al (July 2010). "The genome-wide structure of the Jewish people". Nature. 466 (7303): 238-42. This is also confirmed by the work by Ostrer H, Skorecki K (February 2013). "The population genetics of the Jewish people". Human Genetics. 132 (2): 119-27 also back up Behar's work. The above are the two most respected scientists in the field. ------------------------- In August 2012, Dr. Harry Ostrer in his book Legacy: A Genetic History of the Jewish People, summarized his and other work in genetics of the last 20 years, and concluded that all major Jewish groups share a common Middle Eastern origin. Harry, Ostrer (2012). Legacy a Genetic History of the Jewish People. Oxford University Press ----------------------- Citing autosomal DNA studies, Nicholas Wade estimates that "Ashkenazic and Sephardic Jews have roughly 30 percent European ancestry, with most of the rest from the Middle East." He further noticed that "The two communities seem very similar to each other genetically, which is unexpected because they have been separated for so long." Concerning this relationship he points to Atzmon's conclusions that "the shared genetic elements suggest that members of any Jewish community are related to one another as closely as are fourth or fifth cousins in a large population, which is about 10 times higher than the relationship between two people chosen at random off the streets of New York City Wade, Nicholas (2010-06-09). "Studies Show Jews' Genetic Similarity". The New York Times. ------------------------------- The genetic composition of Ashkenazi, Sephardi, and Mizrahi Jewish populations show significant amounts of shared Middle Eastern ancestry. Sources: Blazer, Dan G.; Hernandez, Lyla M., eds. (2006). "The Importance of Ancestral Origin". Genes, Behavior, and the Social Environment: Moving Beyond the Nature/Nurture Debate. p. 100. Katsnelson, Alla (3 June 2010). "Jews worldwide share genetic ties". Nature. Frudakis, Tony (2010). "Ashkenazi Jews". Molecular Photofitting: Predicting Ancestry and Phenotype Using DNA. Elsevier. p. 383 ‐----------------------------------------- In a study of Israeli Jews and Palestinian Muslim Arabs, more than 70% of the Jewish men and 82% of the Arab men whose DNA was studied, had inherited their Y chromosomes from the same paternal ancestors, who lived in the region within the last few thousand years. "Our recent study of high-resolution microsatellite haplotypes demonstrated that a substantial portion of Y chromosomes of Jews (70%) and of Palestinian Muslim Arabs (82%) belonged to the same chromosome pool." Source: Nebel A, Filon D, Weiss DA, Weale M, Faerman M, Oppenheim A, Thomas MG (December 2000). "High-resolution Y chromosome haplotypes of Israeli and Palestinian Arabs reveal geographic substructure and substantial overlap with haplotypes of Jews". Human Genetics. 107 (6): 630-41.

[@Theouterrim77]

@علي ياسر Type "Khazar theory debunked" to learn how brainwashed one is.

[@Theouterrim77]

@علي ياسر So you think using your eyes is a scientific way to tell the DNA of people ? What's your IQ? Is it high enough for such a subject?

[@emchichecasa5830]

Emir Fayçal, 1919: "We, Arabs, who have been friends of the Jews and who have treated them as brethren, not only in recent years, but centuries ago, I believe that Palestine belongs to the Jews just as England belongs to the English and France to the French."

[@Human-bf7kz]

He was promised the Levant ,he was double crossed , Sykes-Picot Agreement , driven out by the French , removed by the British and sent to Iraq. His father was a traitor and so was he.

[@KHAT-m8u]

No, it is the land of the descendants of Israel and his brother Ishmael (Father of the Arabs), which a European Jew of unknown parentage like you and them has absolutely nothing to do with. JUDAISM IS A RELIGION NOT A RACE. Lastly emir Faisal didn’t say this so stop your fabrication you even wrote his name wrong.

[@MAYONNAISEMOOSE]

there ARE atheist/secular jews your braindead@@KHAT-m8u

[@bigpoppapump430]

That’s not even his name lmfao

[@bigpoppapump430]

Also where’s your source where did he say this, what a ridiculous statement

[@AmmitzbollJeppe]

5:10 "Most of the land was owned by Palestineans". This is supposed to be about the situation in 1947. But the term "Palestineans" was only invented during the 1960's.

[@luisvivanco6897]

Quite lucid and well informed. In a topic that defies fairness and impartiality. Well done. One observation: About the UN 1947 partition plan (and map). If you observe well, in that 54% adjudicated to the jews, a quite big percentage is desert land (not the Sinai, as it is stated in 7:26, but the Negev desert). Which puts in perspective a more fair share for the jews as the third of Palestine's population. Also, just seconds before that quoted part, it says that the only city with majority of jews was Tel Aviv. That is true for Tel Aviv, but there were many other small cities or towns or villages, of jewish majority, made up of virtually up to 100 percent jewish people, like Petach Tikva, Netanya, and many kibbutz... in 1939 about 25.000 jews were living in kibbutzim, and they constituted the absolute majority there. More important and significant: between 1922 and 1948 approximately two thirds of Jerusalem population of 165,000 were jews (ca. 60/65%). Apart from those details and maybe anothers, the information is very good, serious and as just as it can be.

[@bensilverstern4156]

The Sinai desert?? The qualifications of this worthy gentleman are thrown into question. Does he not know where the Sinai is located?

[@AbuBakar-rk5fq]

Desert and Sinai. Well, isn’t it very from Egypt? He means the Negev Desert, very close to the Sinai Desert

[@ryaddenni5969]

palestinians were totally right there was only 7007 of them and they let 113k jews in , and only after that they started rioting ,it was their land they didnt have to accept a jewish invasion , since we all know what happens to certain ethnicities when they become a minority

[@MakeLoveNotWar865]

Theank you for the video.

[@synergyttm9255]

There is alot of information missing from this video. It's incomplete. I hope that there would be a more detailed video covering the complete history of Israel. Unfortunately there isn't.

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

Britain: The Rothschild family is bad

[@g.iskandar90]

Interesting point of view of the history of Palestine and the UN '47 partition plan.

[@marioprovi6048]

Why is there a problem between Palestinians and Israelis, about 23% of the Palestinian region, but not between Jordanians and Palestinians, about 77% of the Palestinian region.

[@Mo-oy5gs]

its not region. its a country. jordan is different country

[@marioprovi6048]

@@Mo-oy5gs Palestine has never been a nation state, apparently you are completely unaware of that.

[@Mo-oy5gs]

@@marioprovi6048 go tell that to some other fool okay. what a joke u are

[@marioprovi6048]

@@Mo-oy5gs The farther you drift from the truth the more you will hate those who speak the truth.

[@Mo-oy5gs]

@@marioprovi6048 except you are lying which doesnt apply then

[@Nudnik1]

65% of Israeli Jews are not from Europe or Russia they are mitzrahi sabra from this region.. It is not "Palestine" today.. This PhD is not accurate. Zionism began in 1740 there were pogroms in Europe against us since Rhineland pogroms and we were always living in Israel. Maybe all Americans and Canadians give all the you stole and occupied back to native Americans .. Go back to Europe then tell us Jews we cant return back to our ancient homeland.. This Oklahoma prof is funny.. נודנק👎

[@Έλλην-ο7ι]

Your "ancient homeland" has already been debunked.

[@rachelsamuel3328]

Zionism began with Moses and the Children of Israel walking about to get to go to the land promised them.

[@rachelsamuel3328]

That is why He is not working at a Good college.

[@Nudnik1]

@@rachelsamuel3328 To many of these people spread misinformation.

[@rachelsamuel3328]

@@Nudnik1 Totally agree! I spend a lot of time trying to put correct information out there. But many of these people believe their prejudices.

[@mw32411]

Just stop with the clickbait we want to see the videos.

[@ארקדיה1267]

You cannot be sure about the numbers unless it's official

[@Mnbvv531]

The thing is people of Palestine welcome with wide arms to all Jews ..when no one in world was willing to accept Jews now see what they did

[@rollinghippo2940]

​@Mnbvv531 this is surely a lesson to be learned.

[@reformer4545]

The facts may disturb the Israelis. How Israel was founded as a state. Only three things. The money. The song of the Jews in Europe in the nineteenth century. The Balfour Declaration. The government. And also the most important thing is the British.

[@homecinema1484]

UK MADE A MESS IN NEAR EAST

[@rachelsamuel3328]

It was not so much the UK, the League of Nations all 50 countries voted on the Jews to have their own country It was unanimously approved. This was in,1922.

[@rachelsamuel3328]

@علي ياسر Try again in English,

[@sheep.herder]

the story of a persecuted people who were mass migrated into palestine as asylum seeking refugees who later inundated their host nation, like rats 🐀

[@robhuhges]

This guy keeps referring to Palestinians and Jews like they're two distinct groups and so continue a verbal lue that began in the 1960s. Both arabs and indigenous Jews were Palestinians. The Arabs were called simply arabs or Palestinian arabs not Palestinians. They never called for a Palestinian state and if they ever did get arab independence they would have probably been Jordanian subjects. The westernised jews turned a dingy forsaken piece of the earth that looked the same in 1920 as it did in biblical times into a productive land. Arabs poured into the area to share in the economic benefits that were unthinkable under ottoman rule. At the end of the day you've got to pick sides. What would you rather see there? A modern Liberal Democracy or a backward theocratic state ruled over by a succession of tribal despots.

[@kynotamurray7105]

Interesting points!

[@bensilverstern4156]

You glide over the fact that the “54per cent” was mainly the Negev desert .

[@Theouterrim77]

Exactly

[@sparrowjack7031]

But they would get the most fertile parts in the north like Jaffa. Also didn't israel make "the desert bloom"? 😂

[@JNChannel95]

​@@sparrowjack7031 sure they did, I don't think the Arabs would make the land bloom if they got it though.

[@sparrowjack7031]

​​@@JNChannel95​@JNChannel95 You are a f##ing racist. And I hope someone will treat you accordingly. The rest of Palestine was blooming long before the Zi0nists came and stole a blooming land. How are the Zi0nists making the desert bloom? By ethnic cleansing.

[@sparrowjack7031]

​​@@JNChannel95“The story of the Zi0nists is not that they came to a Palestine and made it bloom - it's that they came to a blooming country and they stole it,” says Miko Peled, son of a former Israeli military general.

[@hanselben]

You’re conflating the terms for Palestine the place and Palestinians the people. There was no state of Palestine before 48. It was a territory held by a series of conquering empires. The last independent nation living there were the Jews 2000 years ago before the Romans destroyed their civilization and exiled the Jews from their land.

[@sabaadaileh2227]

Source: supermarket

[@AbuBakar-rk5fq]

No Israel 🇮🇱 in 1917 why you cry

[@hanselben]

@@AbuBakar-rk5fq me no cry. Why you cry?

[@hanselben]

@@sabaadaileh2227 Palestine is a region. Not a state. Never was.

[@AbuBakar-rk5fq]

Palestine was not a land without a people. There was a free people who loved life and loved their land. Palestine is related to the tribes of the Palestinians who were mentioned in the Holy Bible. In the end, this is their land. The Philistines are the owners of the land. It is illogical for the return of a people who lost the land that God gave them more than 2000 years ago, according to this argument. Their return is illogical, and no one can accept this ridiculous pretext. A people comes from a faraway place in Europe as refugees, and then they replace the people with the original people. Who is participating in this satanic thing?

[@joshuacondell1686]

And by the way anti Israeli propaganda keeps saying jews only owned 7% of the land thinking that the rest belongs to the Arabs. Most of the land or nearly all of it was state owned land by the British mandatory government.

[@MakeLoveNotWar865]

Joshua Condell NO british never owoned Palestine, it was owned by Palestinian People who lived there for centuries and thousands of years.

[@missthunderstormable]

but turks did and then they left.

[@rowdyyates4273]

@@marwanabuhasan8979 yes so that america would come into the war!

[@cura2435]

That's called an occupation. Known as british occupation. Never owned. And is it in any way right to say that the brits owned the land?

[@joshuacondell1686]

@@cura2435 fair enough. After all the Jews has fight a guerilla war against the British and drove them out of eretz Yisrael. But don't act as though it's 7% and the rest was privately owned. It was government controlled land. Crown land in other words.

[@arten1692]

Amazing and thats the true 100% my grandfather told me everything

[@farestimani9204]

You’re European grandfather?

[@guyeshel9316]

Not 100%, using terms that did not apply to the dates makes it inaccurate.

[@farestimani9204]

@@guyeshel9316 lmao

[@farestimani9204]

@@guyeshel9316 should we refer to the Bible then

[@MrRony721]

Thanks for your video 👍🏻

[@shainazion4073]

This is the most bullshit I've seen and heard since I left my Aunts farm upstate. The British did a Land Survey in 1945, and the Palestinian farmers owned 3.3% of the land, the Jews owned 8.6% of the land, the wealthy Arab landowners (absentee) owned 16.5% of the land. State Land was 70%, this land was transferred from the Ottomans, to the British, and then to Israel. Israel was created by almost 80% of non-Arab owned land. So, just with this one fact, most of this video is incorrect.

[@thetruejuanalto]

this is relevant again. this also means they are the sam epeople just those that left and those that stayed.? no?

[@AhamedKabeer-wn1jb]

Thank you so much ..well explanied..

[@dfab6572]

Britain to be blamed.

[@jesseandjan]

OIL and religion is what it is all about

[@buffdadio1]

Jerusalem also had a Jewish majority as did many cities. You completely neglected to mention Jewish biblical connection to the land. In those days Arabs were seen as one entity and received huge swaths of the Middle East. That’s why the Jews were granted the majority of the mandate of palastine

[@rachelsamuel3328]

Jerusalem, Safed.,Gaza, Tel Aviv, Tiberias. All had Jewish majority.

[@tarek903]

Majority? Jews before 1947 and after mass migration from Europe didn’t pass 1/3 of the population. Go spread lies somewhere else

[@rachelsamuel3328]

@@tarek903 Your reading comprehension is off. Yes, Jerusalem had a Jewish majority, as well as the cities I mentioned. Jerusalem has always been a holy city to the Jews.it is mentioned again and again in Torah, unlike never mentioned in the Qur'an.

[@tarek903]

@@rachelsamuel3328 Ashkenazi boy, spreading false news

[@buffdadio1]

@@tarek903 the only lie out there is that the “Palestinians” claim to be a indigenous to the land, when in fact there was NEVER a nation called Palestine, or a Arab country in that region for that matter. And what are you suggesting, that ashkenazi Jews aren’t really Jews? That’s just a straight up a stupid statement to make. You people are trying to rewrite history or alter it in hopes of gaining the world’s sympathy like a bunch of babies. Every generation tried to destroy us and did not succeed. I suggest you stop wasting your time as well.

[@shainazion4073]

There is a real problem using the term Palestinians throughout the video. There was no Palestinians, there was Arabs, Druze, Bahai, Samaritans, etc.

[@NadaTae]

Colonizer brain :

[@MoctarMohammat]

So it seems that Jewish people don't have their own country that represents?? Where are the Jews originally from in this world??

[@danamasad2439]

Where are the Christians originally from?

[@philipkozely3768]

Palestine was owned non jews before 1948

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

You mean the indigenous people, you failed immigrant

[@jellygood8552]

Difficult to find an unbiased presentation

[@jesusislord3592]

the title of your video makes it clear. you want to develop your political agenda, you lack a real understanding of this matter.

[@jesusislord3592]

@Justyna Stefania I. is this your answer? Seriously? You post me a video where a Korean guy is faking the support of the Palestinian case and shows the reaction of some immature respectless boys? Wow🙂I didn't expect that you dive soooo deeeep into the matter LOL🤣🤣

[@GodKiller97]

You’re insane. Maybe you disagree with the content of the video, but the title itself doesn’t lean in favor of any bias. Explain how if you really think it does

[@jesusislord3592]

@@GodKiller97 People with education and knowledge don't call anyone "insane" who has a better fact- based knowledge, especially if they themselves only have superficial knowledge. Or else you would have known that the term "Palestinians" is a political term that was used for the first time 1964 in the PLO Charter for all Arabs in the Disputed Areas and by Yasser Arafat in his speech to the General Assembly of the United Nations.The juxtaposition of the terms "Palestinians" and immigration of Jews to Israel is therefore historically incorrect, because the immigration of Jews from Europe already increased sharply at the end of the Second World War and took place from 1947 onwards due to pogroms and expulsions from the Arab countries. The term "immigration" belittles the circumstances of this forced immigration due to persecution .750,000 Arab refugees faced 1 million Jewish refugees who received no help from the UN. The Arab refugees, on the other hand, have already received billions of dollars in aid from a special UN refugee agency, called UNRWA, and their refugee status is extended to all subsequent generations. And that's not supposed to be biased in favor of the so called Palestineans?????

[@philipemalta670]

The truth or an adivice, why dont Share or putting them at a good places,when the desire to having good Technologies center and giving for Them, as a away not to help, because nobody like to stay on Thais position , if They having rights. So it'ss certanly that if thay could take some of places on the Earth as away to exploring Their capacities, being intelection or not or on a relation, to Keep your Faith.

[@shimonT16]

Read mark's Twain book about his visit on about 1850 to Israel land, describing how the land was almost empty / Most of the Arabs were later work immigrants!

[@barneygimble8984]

What other comedians do you think are historians?

[@zibrantaybie]

Really? The third most important place for muslims and 1st most important place for christians was empty?

[@abrorbobomurodov]

mark's Twain isnt neutral !!! dont read his books at all

[@AbdirahmanIdris-ku9xm]

And in 1945, the Arabs were the majority population

[@Ahmad-up9og]

Very fair explanation

[@sarthakghosh4690]

It's the british always !

[@reverse3590]

Well explain

[@123jac]

At the end of the day, the true God gave the land to the sons of Jacob.

[@Human-bf7kz]

That land has changed hands so many times Lets see how long the foreign entity lasts.

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

Since when did the Khazars become among the sons of Jacob, you fool?

[@123jac]

@@عليياسر-ذ5ب read history dumb ass, your momma should send you back to school.

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

​@@123jacThe false Khazar talks about the intelligent Obi history, saying that he is an indigenous person

[@benelhajdahmenwael5063]

and then he kicked them out of the Holy Land due to their sins and wrong deeds.

[@editor1208]

someone fucked up!

[@aubaisamara337]

what the hell are you ok

[@Hassan-rp2eh]

U

[@אזורינטפורטלחדשותאזורי]

One sided presentation. Read the Bible from time to time.

[@karfomachet7265]

I'll read harry potter when I want to read a made up story not the bible , which is based on myths stolen from others anyway . Israel paid for its birth in the blood of its people and not because of any myths in the bible .Love to Israel .

[@ahmedseelawi2948]

Why would I care what ur bible says lol like I even believe in it

[@zaraandshalya5648]

Bible made by a man Lol I don't even know why those Christan people believe in a man made book

[@zaraandshalya5648]

@Omar Elatrash I know bible doesn't make sense but I hope those people find the true religion.

[@zaraandshalya5648]

@Omar Elatrash sure!