John Mearsheimer and Jeffrey Sachs - India Is Not Our Ally

[@ramasubramanianh9682]

Jeffrey's views are real and well articulated.

[@ProgressPost]

"Being America's enemy is dangerous; being America's friend is fatal" - Late Henry Kissinger, US Secretary of State

[@harveyspecter1855]

Henry kissinger was a shit person. It's best not to quote him on anything

[@HappyGamerz946]

Being an American is dangerous and fatal to oneself. - An American who understands world

[@avinashpandey7319]

@@wild_ravenX he siad it u are a fool or a us bot

[@bhuttonawazgandu9107]

As a pakistani I can assure you it's 100% true, it's Soo true it leaves you wishing you never shook hands in the first place and no amounts of baths will ever be enough.

[@ytforro]

and he got a Nobel Peace Prize !!

[@premprasad3511]

US policies are strange. It saw Indian as enemy during the cold war just because we chose not to ally with either of the two blocks. The Russians embraced us whole heartedly and signed a friendship treaty with India althogh India was not their ally. They never had any problem with India conducting its own policies independently. The US equation with China is even stranger. They hated them, but were nevertheless fascinated by the Chinese and wanted them as a partner. So the US stripped its own ally Taiwan of its nationhood and transferred it to mainland China as the real China, but also kept the the ally they just stabbed in the back as its protectrate, while also recognizing the one-China policy ! They then funded China's economic rise even as they feared it's military rise. On the eastern from of India, the US aided Pakistanis for deacdes arming them to teeth against India, knowing verey well that tehy would only these weapons and funds against India. Pakistan used the funds to build its nukes, and funded its vast terror network which has now become autonomous. The US looked the other way even as the Pakistanis unleashed decades of terror on India even as the US stopped funding them after Afghanistan. Suddenly they realized at the beginning of this century that India can be an ally because it would be a counterweight against China, but continued ouring huge investments into China which depleted teh US of its manufacturing sector and made China the factory of the world. Now they want India against Russia and China.

[@MrChandanc9]

US could not deny a large nation as China legitimacy anyway even without Soviet Union being Iron brothers with China

[@MrChandanc9]

And they are most delusional thinking India will go against Russia with all critical weapons being sourced from there

[@hunainkhan1648]

Now Russia supplies more weapon to Pakistan than us and is pakistan second largest defense supplier usse problem nahi hai tujhe hypocrite sala

[@premprasad3511]

@@LSD87-l2p I think the US would be better off not to see itself an beacon of values for others to emulate for the simple reason that it pursues its own national interests ruthlessly at the very expense of those very values it says it cherishes. This is not demonize the US as a villain, but its friends like India will certainly find breathe easy when US climbs down from its high moral pedestal and behaves like a mortal ! Because if the US doesnt do that, its friends also will start doing the same. India actually suffers a lot due to US actions. Just look at the US support to the fundamentalist regime in Bangladesh which siezed power from a democratically elected government. There is nothing morally righteous about what they did, stll they want India to consume the nonsense it's various agencies randomly preach. When similar things come from China, Pakistan, Canada, Turkey,we ask them to fuck off. With US we dont say that because of decency ,courtesy, and understanding that friends should have for eaxh other. But its moral policing is becoming intolerable now and public goodwill is the last thing you should be offendinge specially you have one in plenty in a friendly country who have no enmity OR animosity with the US. Treating friends with disdain is the worse than making a million enemies .You lose respect

[@lijackson-x6r]

Times are different now, the US is weak now and wants to ally with India to balance the power of Russia or China. This clearly shows that a multipolar world has arrived, especially when India does not want to ally with the US, and the EU also looks like an ally of the US, but in fact, the EU wants to be independent of the US. Moreover, the new Japanese Prime Minister came to power and he proposed that Japan station troops in the US, which expressed Japan's need for independence.

[@new_contents_all_day]

Even if India is not your Ally , don't worry, they don't start wars, they are very peaceful to other countries

[@AryanPandey-x9m]

Well said

[@robin-kq7un]

LOL! Yeah, India has always been VERY peaceful towards Pakistan, hasn't it?🤣🤣

[@new_contents_all_day]

@@robin-kq7un I don't want to fight .

[@chessproos]

​@@robin-kq7unno wars started by India although every won by India

[@RAVajayEN]

​@@robin-kq7unwe have defend ourselves bro

[@adedapoosanyinbi93]

Or put more realistically, America has never been India'a ally! America has sided with England to support Pakistan so where is this self righteous claim that "India is not our ally" come from? America and England supported Pakistan in the face ff against India in the Indiaan Ocean and the Russians had to send their fleet to back India up! America has itself to blame for this situation. You cant have your cake and eat it! India is also not an ally of America by America's policy choices and will never ally with America from past behaviour of American policy makers!

[@peanut0brain]

So why is Endia in quad?

[@SandiegoRockstar]

England always sided with India against Pakistan. Just look at the partition of Bengal and Punjab. Both were Indian land grabs organized by Britain. Or look at the disarming of Hyderabad Nizam or the abandonment of Kashmir to India. If the British Raj supported Pakistan, it would not have allowed either.

[@eastpaknomore]

@@peanut0brain Because the rednecks can finally make themselves useful by supporting a democratic nation

[@JustGotALife]

@@SandiegoRockstar if british raj supported pakistan? bro british raj created pakistan and now called west bengal in 10 freaking days.

[@bennett9072]

​@@SandiegoRockstarBritish education is this shit?

[@abelabrahom207]

India is and will never be an American Ally cuz India is an independent country.

[@taiwanstillisntacountry]

That doesn't use an indigenous language to talk with fellow citizens😂😂😂😂.

[@Sinister1008]

​@@taiwanstillisntacountry what

[@ShrekJo-we2st]

​@@taiwanstillisntacountry Are you really that stupid..?? HINDI is an indigenous Lang of India and Indians speak in Hindi with each other... BTW, TAIWAN is An INDEPENDENT COUNTRY And 90% Taiwanese DESPISE China 100% Tibetans despise China..

[@dexterroy]

​@@taiwanstillisntacountrywhen he said, some people need to get a passport and see the world, he meant people like you.

[@maigepresents5840]

​@@taiwanstillisntacountryumm... they have 2 dozen languages...

[@blindtorpedo]

India is not an American ally (well put Mr. Sachs) , Indians will not die for American causes , which is ultimately what being an ally boils down to , in this context.

[@bennett9072]

Why should India or any country die for other countries cause or wish? Are you an ally or slave??? I really don't understand these people's brains.

[@SaketKumar-xz5eu]

USA always supported a military ruler country Pakistan over India. When there was a war between India and Pakistan for the freedom of Bangladesh, USA sent their aircraft carrier to attract India, Russia was the only country in the world who stopped USA's aggression towards India. USA has been selling their weapons to the lunatic islamic country (Pakistan) from the past 70 years. USA helped Pakistan to develop the nuclear technology while opposing India in getting one. USA funded terrorism has destabilized the south asia region. Even now the USA is changing regime in Pakistan and Bangladesh, and establishing an anti hindu anti India government in Indian neighbours. Now please tell me why will Indians die for the "American" causes?

[@rajendran30]

Will you die for a stupid friend? If you dont why aren't you called an ally?

[@ashyouknow7420]

More like America has always been an ally of Pakistan than India. Actions speak louder than words. Where does this self righteous comment "India is not an American Ally" coming from?

[@PK-se2jh]

More like west has tried to break and harm India siding with Pakistan and promoting seperatist movement in India now they all get shocked when India has a negative opinion. Good part is west is going down to multipolar world so hopefully west bully will stop

[@quarryboats9285]

I admire Prof Sachs' self control having to listen to ostriches with their head still stuck in sand.

[@abh1yan]

😂

[@nastybadger-tn4kl]

Jeffery sachs is CCP clown

[@georgeng9252]

Jeffrey Sachs is 1000% right and John has to study more about how the world actually works.

[@impCaesarAug]

Jeffrey said John is right about the way the world actually works. Jeffrey wishes it would work differently.

[@Satyam1010-N]

You guys are not idea delusional not great low info of these people

[@well_said7846]

​@@impCaesarAug don't worry these people do not understand what they listen to. Personally I think there's less than zero percent chance that the events play out like Mr Sachs wants them to.

[@Nnomadd]

looks like you were not listening.

[@peterl545]

Sachs only makes ivory tower arguments against policies. But, his recommendations in the face of aggression and uncooperativeness is just nuts. We don't give up hard won peace and rules-based order to governments that would take us back to a darker age.

[@Jai-Bharat111]

Just let Jeffery speak. Don't interrupt.

[@bennett9072]

Why should any independent country can only be an ally or enemy? Why can't countries just mind thier own business. Land of freedom right? Hypocrits. Just always forcing others.

[@hunainkhan1648]

So why are you an ally of Russia hypocrite

[@bennett9072]

@@hunainkhan1648 when did India said russia and India are allies? Thats western termonology. We are partners yes but not allies. Having good relation doesnt mean you are allies. We have good relations with US too does that mean we are allies with US?

[@oliversmith2129]

​@@hunainkhan1648 Not an ally of Russia. Cite the alliance declaration would you?

[@BHARATWANKHEDE]

Historic friendship

[@sevenstars4817]

Then why india makes bhutan an ally although it is tilting towards china too?? And possesive about bhutan as if its their colony??

[@sujitdash6119]

As per Indian government: India is not believe in alliance. India believe in partnership. There is a significant difference in both. If you allie of a big country, you bound to agree with the stance of that big country, by retracing your own interest. But in partnership you have every right to raise your opinion and you can give suggestions to your counter part.

[@PomegranateChocolate]

India does not believe in partnership. India believes in hegemony and think of itself as an imperial power.

[@kaushikchakraborty6017]

​@@PomegranateChocolateIf your words are true, what is the harm? At least not Hippocrates😂

[@timothychung4811]

Is that what QUAD is?

[@ZuhaBuba]

@@timothychung4811 Timepass

[@Darknesstride]

@ ​India has never been an expanding or colonists nation, they were just living peacefully till the time, the arabs arrived to attack persia.

[@blackartist7]

John is right about how this world works now, and Jeffery is right about if we don't change how the world works or at least how American foreign policy works, we are all doomed eventually.

[@morninghope1]

I disagree. John is wrong about china intent which is different from western or johns view. Jeff is right.

[@ahnafahmed9545]

"These are my failed students in washington right now, because they didn't listen to their professor." 😂😂😂

[@petergreen5337]

❤😂Hahaha brilliant. " They SHOULD get a passport and travel the world " these are MY failed students.

[@colorguppies]

It’s because America was never India’s ally….not to mention Nixon and his racist views towards India. How did trusting Pakistan work? Where was bin Laden? America itself isn’t very friendly towards Indian. They like our work ethic, our brain power and the money Indian Americans make. I remember that it took us over 30 years to be able to build a temple. As an Indian American, my own country doesn’t like me. There is a lot more to it.

[@FreePalestine11]

You know he is right when "moderators" keep interrupting.

[@donkeykong516]

Well said Mr Sachs

[@bittoochatterjee2661]

India is not an ally of the USA, NATO, or the Western world. We Indians hold a deep skepticism toward the USA, Largely because of its actions during the 1971 Indo-Pak War. At that time, the USA, in collaboration with the UK’s Royal Navy, attempted to threaten India by deploying its 7th Fleet, including the USS Enterprise, to the Bay of Bengal, signaling a hostile stance in support of Pakistan. However, the situation changed dramatically when the USSR (now Russia) dispatched its nuclear missile-armed flotilla to the Indian Ocean, joining forces with the Indian Navy to patrol the Bay of Bengal, the Arabian Sea, and the Indian Ocean. Faced with this formidable alliance, the American and British naval forces withdrew, avoiding confrontation. 👌👌👍👍👏👏😁😁😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Had it not been for the USSR's 👌👌👍👍👏👏❤❤❤❤💕💕😘😘😍😍🤩🤩😊😊✌✌decisive support, India might have faced severe challenges at that critical moment. It’s also well-documented that during this period, US President of those year S.....I.....S F / M........ F President Nixon reportedly made offensive remarks about our then Honorable and respected Lady Prime Minister.Mrs Indira Gandhi ..….. A " B..... I.....T.....C.......H." This is American Culture. This is the kind of culture American People / Citizens have in them This is how American People / Citizens overcome any unruly passions These are the kind of Virtues American People / Citizens Have in Themselves This is how American People / Citizens show Obedience This is how American People / Citizens show how much peace Loving people they are in real Life 🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 👍👏👏👌👌😁😁😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 We India & Indians are strategic and far-sighted people. 👌👌👍👍✌✌👏👏😊😊😊😊😊😊 Not Like Brainless, Empty Top Floor, Greedy Selfish , Uncultured , Zero Morality Zero Values Zero Family Upbringing Present In Politician Ordinary People Of USA and So Called Wester World. 😁😁😁😁😂😂🤣🤣👎👎👎👎🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 we have a clear vision for our future. We believe that, with the blessings of our Hindu Gods and Goddesses, A day 101% will come, likely by the mid-21st century, When India and China 101% will resolve all their disputes Peacefully And After That We Indians / India , China, and Russia will form a strong alliance, challenging the influence 👍👍✌✌👏👏 of USA, NATO, and the Western world in this world. As for the Quad alliance, it should be understood that India will not directly involve itself in conflicts between the USA and China. For our national interests, we Indians / India may choose to quietly align ourselves with Russia, China, and even North Korea, 😁😁✌✌👍👍👌👌❤❤😍😍😁😁😁😁😂😂🤣🤣 Rather than openly supporting nations like Australia, Japan, South Korea, the Philippines, or Taiwan. India is not to be underestimated; our nation is guided by intelligence. Majority Educated Indians have something called brains in our Top Floor / Head Not Like Americans ZERO BRAIN and strategic insight in its approach to global affairs. From a True Hardcore & Staunch Hindu Brahmin Bengali Indian Who Hates the Western World Countries and its People from New Delhi India..

[@moralambush]

Well said.

[@sadhanabhagour7308]

Dude your prediction about brics gets real.china and india has now solved their border disputes successfully

[@joelaugustus5812]

Build a toilet first and stop pooping on railway tracks . Then give your intellect

[@smileplease5567]

India loves all hates non, and 1000 years of our history teach us to be alert and powerful, at the same time work with all.

[@Malice-Towards-One-and-All]

US is like a person who spurned you for years and wants to take him into your life just because he is being rejected by others

[@trekpac2]

The guy on the left was pretty ignorant and rude, interjecting like this was a debate between Biden and Trump.

[@rubylaser8601]

Depending on who you are. If you're China, India is not your ally. If you're Japan or Philippines, India is your ally.

[@Sabundy]

Remind me again who invaded who? Because last time I checked Japan invaded China and the Philippines. And the US invaded the Philippines. India is not an ally to any of these countries. India has only strategic partners. It's funny how those guys in the video don't even mention that India is a member of BRICS and the Shanghai Co-operation Organisation. India knows very well it cannot and will not ever be treated as an equal by the US. The US has vassal states. Submissive and subservient vassals. It does not have allies. Ally implies equality. Japan and the Philippines are NOT America's equals by any stretch. They are vassals that largely do as they are told.

[@leecheong4986]

Don't be stupid. India will not die for Japan and especially the Philippines. What can the Philippines offer to India. More cheap labour??? 😂😂😂

[@keyboardmanyoutube3189]

India is not an ally to no one….. As a superpower, India will have conflict with Japan and Philippine too …. Imagine India vs. USA, which side Japan and Philippine would be on? Indians know it

[@peanut0brain]

On paper only

[@Karthagast]

@@peanut0brain Not even that. The Quad is NOT a military alliance. In fact, India has not a single official ally, and that is as such on purpose since India wants to keep its options open. On the other hand, USA is so desperate to get India as an ally so India can play the role of useful idiot (the one being in the front line of a prospected war, thus receiving the full blow from the enemy, while USA "helps" from the other side of the Pacific Ocean) that USA will accept anything coming from India, even its membership to the BRICS and the Sanghai Cooperation Organization, without realising that it is being played by India.

[@fredliu1701]

John is good for the USA, Jeff is great for all mankind!

[@tigading2177]

John is good for USA? LOL John is good for Lockheed and Raytheon!!

[@ellekewilms6891]

Thank you, Jeffrey Sachs! How do you maintain your integrity and keep vowing for Peace, amongst the endless paranoid warmongers.

[@merlinraja2863]

India is at a stalemate on the border with China. Both understand that war is a lose-lose situation - only US wins by weakening both India and China.

[@texx1985]

India has never been a yank ally.. Yanks keeps supporting Pakistan. Russia saved India in one of the wars. Easy choices

[@alokchandra2028]

Amazing clarity from Jeffery world must listen to this sane voice

[@harishkotian83]

Americas and Europe's problem is not world's problem.

[@treeberry4]

Perfect example of either you are with us or against us. Not a country simply minding its own business 😐

[@Marine-x3r]

It's not marriage.. it's geopolitics.. which works on all reasoning based on every nation's nature and history and much more

[@nimittchauhan9652]

India is an ally in the sense of partnership. We believe in cooperation rather than dictating what others should do. We’re looking for mutual benifits and global peace.

[@moriumakhter2424]

Not really! You treat your neighbor countries like America treated other countries around the world. Just check Adani's project with Srilanka and Bangladesh closely and you will understand.

[@durgeshsss]

​@@moriumakhter2424mulla spotted opinion rejected 😂 Noobs speaks with zero facts

[@chessproos]

​@@moriumakhter2424brother that's capitalism it creates jobs for THEM not for Indians AND DO CHECK THE YEARKY AID GIVEN TO SRILANKA AND MALDIVES OR BANGLADESH OR EVEN THERE DAILY NECESSITIES LOAN

[@Dsmfu-p2v]

@@moriumakhter2424What about Adani’s projects? Were they coerced? Did India topple or throttle any government to get them? When Sri Lanka was down and out because of their own policies, which country helped them? And what about Bangladesh? Did Adani get any preferential treatment from BD? If yes, why would you think millions of dollars are overdue for payment to Adani?

[@Sabundy]

That one guy is the definition of American exceptionalism 😂😂. He truly believes that when the US conducts economic warfare against other countries it somehow magically means "self inflicted". I guess what he menas is that every country that doesnt obey the US and do as its told is "self inflicting" harm on themselve by nit obeying. That guy woukd have made a great mob boss or slave owner with that logic.

[@keyboardmanyoutube3189]

He’s brainwashed well that believes Xi not welcome foreign investment….. Can Xi be worse than Trump or Biden?

[@pefsgk5092]

Isn't the founding father of USA, G. Washington, a slaves owner??!!

[@aryanshukla7305]

Even friendship of America is viewed with a healthy suspicion in all places

[@RahulPatil-yg7vy]

When U.S uses the word ‘Ally’ for any nation it actually means ‘Colony’.

[@DivijShrivastava]

One thing that the world needs to understand is that India never leaves its friends. If you had ever helped us, we will never leave you, that’s our culture. We go more by heart.

[@curious_one1156]

examples ? Would be good if same heart was applied to low castes in India itself.

[@sathyanarayana887]

​@@curious_one1156low caste ruling In India...go any government depts ...these sub human race responsible for our backwardness & we prompt to go abroad....

[@smileplease5567]

​@@curious_one1156In Their is no low caste in our constitution we all are equal.

[@chessproos]

​@@curious_one1156what you tryna prove smarty pants

[@BISHAL-l3g]

​​@@curious_one1156There are many. I will give you one.. During 2004 Tsunami North Korea had nothing much but as a good will helped India with some 30000$, in return India helped N. Korea with food and grains on 2007 when they needed help and also during COVID pandemic. You see. All countries are good in its own way. North Korea is no different.. it's only the US who are warmongers.

[@vetiarvind]

Indian here, yes we are not going to be American allies but we're no one's allies. We're not Russian allies we're not North Korean allies we don't aid other countries war effort. India even muted ties with our former friend the USSR when they invaded Afghanistan. India is not an imperialist country and the US has nothing to fear from us except that we may overtake you as the world's largest English speaking population (right now we're #2)

[@krishnendukundu6446]

We Indian don't use "ally" word. "Ally" is a dependency word. India is a sovereign country, have our a own interest and independent policies.

[@rajeshmenon75]

I believe that more than being a Super Power, we (India) should be rhe best friend for all countries and help the countries who need help in development. All countries should come together to bring up small and poor countries to the front. They should also work towards stopping wars around the world and bring happiness and peace to all the people around the world.

[@aham-mumukshu-asmi]

India has always been friendly and contributing to America. But in return America has been supporting pakistan to fuel issues in India. So its the other way. Americans dont want to be allies of India. India always welcomes all allies if they are trustworthy

[@TheVaibhav500]

Rest aside J sachs is the brilliant speaker with the extraordinary enunciation skills. Can listen to him all day👍🏻

[@a.r.2006]

Glad that there are some American who speak sense and not dictate terms to other countries. Except for "India can be ally"(No we won't. We're the ones who started NAM), I agree with most of the parts.

[@thelungilife6057]

Sachs has a very limited definition of "ally". His definition is "you hop to it if America says so". America is not used to dealing with rising democracies that exercise their own sovereignty, like India does. That's why they misguidedly spent 40 years supporting Pakistan.

[@AcikaB]

J Sachs is smart....brlliant. A true thinker

[@SwaminathanSingh-fg5cz]

India is a POWER HOUSE just now a SUPER POWER. INDIA does not need anyone . India's TWO MOST TRUSTED FRIENDS ARE THE RUSSIANS AND ISREALIS both would help anytime . Both have RESPECT FOR INDIA 🙏🙏🙏

[@AmlinDavid]

Historically America has never been an ally of 🇮🇳 instead Pakistan has benifitted from United States.

[@aulakh2]

War is inevitable!!! Only fools can shy away from

[@MuhammadKeepsRidingOnMyDick]

So you're the first victim?

[@SahilG23]

America Russia India China explained in 5 mins. And deep down everyone in the room knows he is right.

[@devashisnanda3477]

India is NOT a developing country it's a recovering country.

[@TheSsharma11]

Rightly said…India is like a ‘sand’ ..you try to grab it with your fist…the more you tighten your grip, the faster it will slip out of your hand…

[@chengsweelim2765]

Thanks Jeffery Sachs

[@nastybadger-tn4kl]

Jeffery sachs is CCP clown

[@mirrorflame1988]

Well said!!

[@bhagatsingh5019]

Very sensible discussion

[@merlinraja2863]

India has to always act in its own best interest. "India First" - just like Trump's "America First."

[@Dihorse371]

Mearsheimer comes from "America First" while Sach speaks as "all people are equal".

[@moraramu3340]

#IncredibleIndia

[@WorldWiz22]

We had a PM who thought like Mr. Jeffrey Sachs. He was one of the best and loved his country more than him. But he made two crucial mistakes. 1) He started empathizing with China, even when he got repeated warning he ignored and chose to trust China. 2) He was not strong enough to see his country going to war he chose to leave the extreme cases and focused on the economy more with war preparedness at very low. and the result was 1962. But don't forget 1967 and 1971 as his daughter was different. India is not your friend if you consider us as Ukraine, sad to say but they are a scapegoat, that is the truth. India is your friend if you have equal commitment in bringing down an expansionist like China. By now even Russia knows China's true intention.

[@gameaddict3884]

Jeffery spoke bitter truths.

[@sushanthadusumilli1067]

Americans need to get this to their mind. ' USA is not the sole superpower that can control every geopolitical and economic sectors of the world'. Asia has risen up. South America has moved away, Africa is rising up now. They need to keep their control urges in check or the whole world will be united against USA no matter how many conflicts they have within themselves

[@rkox88]

John doesn't even understand iphone production. FOXCONN (A Taiwanese company) manufactures iPhone mostly China, didn't sound like the India factory was going well at all. To imply its all gone to India is off the rails propaganda

[@callingyououtallday5499]

Here's a funny one, what is both sides are actually talking to each other and are say "let's just ratchet the hell out of these situations into leading people to think we will have nuclear armegedon and just monetise of their fears! Take them to the brink!"

[@aham-mumukshu-asmi]

This is why as an Indian I will keep voting for BJP and Modiji as our PM. We went from being US/UK slaves under Congress to Self reliance in decision making under BJP. The decision to buy Oil from Russia is a Geopolicitical masterstorke from India which clearly helped reclaim our power as an Independent nation

[@robin-kq7un]

Yes - and now you're just underlings to Putin! 😂😂

[@aham-mumukshu-asmi]

@@robin-kq7un Lol Is that why Modiji visiting Zelensky and Putin kept quiet? Cry baby cry 🤣🤣

[@leena4989]

​@@robin-kq7unplease grow up n study 😂😂😂

[@AnujSingh-cc4wk]

He really said, nuclear war , that can ruin our day😐.....there will be no days to ruin.😐

[@aceankit2009]

India and US can’t be all weather allies because our interests are different but we can align in certain common concerns. For example China

[@suhaasbhat8736]

In simple words, we are our own friends. We dont care if people in America suffer nor would people in America care if we suffer. We would pity but the feeling is mutual. Geopolitics boils down to trade and quid pro quo mostly. No sane nation would be part of win lose situation.

[@esphilee]

I am glad that there are people who clapped after professor Sachs's speech.

[@trekpac2]

The US is aspiring to become the next India and it is doing a good job.

[@s-qc9ns]

Doesn't make sense? India is a civilizational country. Americans are all immigrants including the whites.

[@EejuVava]

One of the main focus of the state department and American intelligence/military has been to cause chaos and confusion and present itself as the firefighters 😺 this only makes sense to the people who are pulling the strings way inside the military industrial complex.

[@nimeshAttendance-kv1yp]

Prof.sachs is the best.. Love from sri lanka 🇱🇰🙏

[@shegde4456]

The group was formed without United States. US was added later on the insistence of Australia to that group. India and Japan dint want US since the perception of it being an anti-China group, which to this day since US joined has been a constant question Journalists keep asking if itis.

[@SoldierofGodAki]

Indian begging western countries for investment 🤣 begging for defense, 60% of population earn below $200 yet they call themselves superpower😂😂😂

[@arjuna03]

This uploader giving heart to every comment making fun of India reveals his intentions of putting up clickbait thumbnail-caption. Listen.. we don't need your certificates, you can't predict your own economies, what do you know about a complex universe called INDIA ?

[@billyesomann]

Who is the man, iPhone moved to India and IPhone moved to Vietnam and IPhone moved back to America

[@vlada]

Apple built a new lab in Shenzhen.

[@MrThekaladhar]

Brilliant by J Sachs on the point.

[@freenational]

Brilliant, Jeffrey is the only sane person in the room.

[@abcatos]

We are an Independent country. We are not ur ally. Get over it.

[@Charlie43348]

Then why does Modi beg European and American leaders to visit and invest. To receive all the investment going into China and direct it to India instead. Your GDP per capita is $2,000. You will never grow at the speed china did. Pipe down.

[@mohib024]

India will always be independent and not ally with anyone; My country my rule.

[@HappyGamerz946]

Jeffrey Sachs has my respect - the person who truly understands the world unlike those hypocrites who act like they are all the world is about. Not A Fun Fact: Americans conclude their speeches with "God Bless America". So it means God should not bless other nations.

[@AMIRSINGWAIBA]

..............................Why China is developed and India is already next Africa now ??? Why Chinese and Western companies will never invest in India in future ??? These are main reasons.. 1) Western slavery( Ghulam) corrupt parliament democracy in India now.. 2) No raw materials, no good infrastructure developments and no skilled workers in India now..... 3)43% Indian leaders( MP and MLA) are from criminal backgrounds ( Rapists, corrupt, gangsters) in India now so corruptions everywhere in India now... 4) Western ( American) propaganda media with fake news against (Communism) China and North Korea destroyed 19th century Indians minds forever now 5) One rape case in every 20 minutes in India according to Google now and everywhere loots in India now....

[@Ciksha]

India's Andaman and Nicobar islands laughing in the corner 😂. Indians do not need USA for China. India is capable of handling that issue.

[@disturbed0insane]

What they mean is that India doesnt allow them to treat India as American Vassal.

[@distinctga5811]

Sachs says that the USA started this policy from 2014 on, but it wasn't the USA that started this. It started in Ukraine. Putin blackmailed Yanukovic into not signing the EU association agreement. This led to widespread unrest in Kiev because Yanukovic ran on the idea that he would sign the EU association agreement. Yanukovic was ousted as president so Putin invaded Ukraine and annexed portions of the country. China supported the annexation while simultaneously building an anti-US alliance. China also removed the sovereign nature of Hong Kong which led to a drop in support for a similar deal in Taiwan. This lead to China taking a more aggressive stance on Taiwan, which is close allies with the USA. These two points of contention led to a series of protective steps which became more prominent as time went on.

[@kranthikiran73]

Hearing this Conversation after China released 'Deepseek'...you can say how relevant this is...

[@willwang3688]

Newton's third law: any force will meet an equal opposite force. Jeffrey Sachs is the only cool brain in that panel.

[@song7021]

As Sachs said they are FAILED students. Cause they don’t listen to their Prof Sachs they are busy forming opinions to counter the professors.

[@subhodeeprouth7753]

I mean why on Earth would India consider US its ally when time and time again US has sided with Pakistan in some of the most important issues in India's history??

[@jaspal8jan]

We(India) want to have a good relationship with all but we can't take SIDES. Our priority is the upliftment of our people..

[@krkkrk7262]

We have no eternal allies, and we have no perpetual enemies. Our interests are eternal and perpetual, and those interests it is our duty to follow. - Lord Palmerston, 19th century British PM

[@nijindavis3926]

Never would India, be an ally of the US! Let it sink in.

[@Sabundy]

Im always fascinated when i see guys talking about "decoupling". I know then for a fact they have never been to China. Nor have they been to India. Because they sure as hell dont understand how rich China is and how poor India still is. If they think the mostly very poor India can in any way, shaoe or form replace the consumer market of China then they nust be sniffing some good stuff. And given how many news stories you can easily read about new factories being opened in China by Gernany (Volkswagen is moving a large percentage of its production to China), The US and Japan (Panasonic recently started production on a new appliance factory in China)....it becones clear that decoupling is not what the western mainstream media claims. Sure....there will be some more diversification of production......but its literally impossible for companies to "decouple" from the country that makes most if the worlds priducts, and is most of the worlds main trading partner. Simple logic will tell you that.

[@rajibchakroborthy4181]

Chineese bots 😂

[@Sabundy]

@@rajibchakroborthy4181 what a weak sauce, and pathetic response. You can offer zero rebuttal, or facts whatsoever. All you can say is "Chinese bots" in a lame attempt to gaslight me. Because that is literally all you have. You have neither facts nor an argument. I guess we know who has had their brain rotted with a non stop daily diet of sinophobia.....you.....

[@pefsgk5092]

@@rajibchakroborthy4181 NED bots...

[@xpsmango4146]

Indian birth rate 200% higher than the death rate. 60,000 babies are born every day. 20,000 people die every day.

[@yellowflash511]

Retarded take

[@adityak2791]

Where Can I watch the full video

[@manishyadav-gr3dj]

This Jeff guy really knows stuff

[@shivakumarv301]

Team work is all about understanding and maneuvering to our common goals. Scercy and element of surprise is the key.

[@newhistory9754]

Wow out of my level

[@sujitkumarbiswas2214]

Sirs, I'm Indian. But I don't believe that there's any conflict in between India and China.😂 Really so. Dalai Lama is a point of humanity, may be, but Indiashould be more careful about the person accused for neighbouring country's integration issue. Otherwise there's no point can sustain against Pakistan.😂. Truly. Further, nowadays it's implanted issue for internal politics,I.e., creating a delusion to keep people busy with foreign affairs forgetting internal crisis such as price hike, inflation, jobless, homeless, linguistic and cultural conflicts, religious conflicts and so on. Same happens in America in between USA and Mexico.😂 if there's really so severe problem then probably it would happen of crushing Mexico by USA. But it never happened. Only crisis remain unsolved to solve internal crisis. 😅😅

[@tonyramdial9651]

Luten, China is building her navy to secure her international interests and her natural resources needed to keep her economy and military going. She is also stock piling at home. The BRI will soon be her bases to resupply her navy as she projects power worldwide.

[@bharattanwar5047]

where can i watch it all

[@JemingMyang]

Whatsup with floating captions ??? Its annoying .

[@rabbithole8580]

O hated that too

[@chrisgardner4222]

I wonder if AI created that idea?

[@vatsalvora29]

6:26 My goodness, the panic reaction is too hilarious & eye opening. It is essential to understand the reality - USA is a consumerism market, not a manufacturing market. For the whole video, as an Indian, we are no bodies allies. We are Non-Aligned. Period. When we buy oil for cheap from Russia, and sell it at higher prices to countries that don’t want to purchase it from Russia, we are simply doing business. And, the truth is that if India doesn’t do it, then some other country would. So, our government & businesses are just looking out for ourselves and making some profit in between.

[@sameergautam6634]

Since when Indian Ocean choke points became American strategy? Also, as of current situation, Nobody can defeat India in Indian Ocean Including South China Sea!

[@anthonycardenas7863]

The professor doesn't understand foreign relations very well. Why did we start to decouple from China in the first place? When we opened the market to China, they flourished and made promises and agreements to help and align with our democratic ideals. The U.S kept their end of the deal by provided American companies to move over and manufacture in China. China did not keep their end of the deal and started breaking promises and commitments, stealing American intellectual property, inching over on Indias border, stole military blueprint information from the west, they lied and didn't want democracy, just the benefits of a capitalist market that democracies benefit from. It's pretty easy to understand why we left China, if we kept trade going with China, it is not smart to economically support another superpower that is increasingly becoming more hostile, stealing and lying from the country that let you in to the global market which gave them the economic prosperity it has had to be on the world stage.

[@garryb05]

Any company moving away from china and investing in other countries knows there business more than any economist in the world and they are not fool to take such a big step which will put them in loss..

[@wheeloftime2908]

Ah ,the sheer white bigotry on this panel. .India is a SUPERB nation who because of liberal policies became d 6th Largest economy and the MOST promising emerging market .SHE IS GORGEOUS ..HER ETHNIC ,LINGUISTIC DIVERSITY IS SUPERB .SHE PIONEERED NON VIOLENT PEOPLES MOVEMENTS ,AHIMSA.SHE HEAVILY CONTRIBUTED TO MATHEMATICS,STATECRAFT,ECONOMICS,ART ,CULTURE,AGRICULTURE,MUSIC,

[@bhumitrajyaguru]

they still stuck in nuclear era but they don't know today the world is much ahead than just nuclear arsenals.

[@francisogrady1832]

Wasn't that border drawn by an englishman who had never been there?