Josh Lucas Hates Kevin Costner…Here’s Why!

[@thenextfilm]

Do you think Josh Lucas should continue playing John Dutton? Let me know what you think in the comments below.

[@dianeallen6295]

Yes

[@MsMC-qc6ms]

Seems like the natural solution.

[@dianeallen6295]

Absolutely yes!!!

[@md.saunders6625]

100% absolutely yes!!!! I'd love it if they do this.

[@cotyreed047360]

Absolutely not! No actor should have a lissssp! He needs to learn how to talk like a normal person before he can be an actor!

[@marygoad9103]

I would love to see Josh Lucas take up the current John Dutton role!😮

[@alexanderklarskov5002]

I would love a spinoff with mr. Lucas playing Dutton. Picking up stories from the flashbacks or other stories from around that time

[@janmorton6729]

Yes, if it means Yellowstone can continue, please let Josh Lucas take over as John Dutton.

[@dianeallen6295]

He can return as a cousin to take over the ranch. I think Sheridan wants to end the series and it’s a shame.

[@dianeallen6295]

I would love to see Josh Lucas return.

[@impeace46]

Yes! I agree. Josh Lucas should be allowed to continue playing the role of John Dutton

[@lorrainepeters217]

He was wonderful in Red Dog

[@vanessapitt9886]

Watching it now! Great movie

[@lilstrick7]

Funny how Taylor Sheridan says " he doesn't want to use the same ppl from one of his shows to the next" is bull§hit. The chic that's screwing Jamie on Yellowstone is the same chic that plays Claire on 1883. The livestock sheriff short guy with the mustache plays the cook "Cookie" on 1883, and a few other people I can't think of at the moment. Plus, Sheridan himself plays on Yellowstone and 1883, he was Charlie. I'm not hating I'm just stating facts, he lies.

[@cherylstaton2937]

I definitely would love to see Josh Lucas take over as the present John Dutton, he’s a great actor!

[@sandrafuller3850]

I love Josh Lucas and he is the perfect John Dutton.

[@timedwards2662]

I think Josh could play the same John Dutton he plays now as well as convincingly playing the present one. Sure some would be pissed at first. But Josh is talented and I believe he could pull it off. I say all this having met Kevin in the past as he was close friends with a dear friend of mine. I know enough about Kevin to know he has very personal reasons not to choose to continue in a role I know he loved. It was inevitable that he and Sheridan would clash because they are both so creative. Kevin has serious shit going on in his life right now. He is trying to prioritize what is really important. Y’all can guess what that might be based on the media. All I can tell you is Kevin is and has always been family first. So whatever is going on has more to do with his personal life than his professional. And guess what? He doesn’t give a shit what anyone else thinks and never has.

[@colleen6804]

I absolutely would love to see Josh Lucas continue his role. 🙏🙏🙏

[@kathyrhode6252]

Yes josh should continue playing John Dutton. They can age him and he’ll fit the roll with perfection

[@wandaparker8789]

Josh deserves to play John Dutton ,no matter how Tyler feels about actors playing the same role This is a once in a lifetime exception to your rule Tyler ! With all respect Josh is the only actor to play the part ! He has earned the privilege ! It's a no Brainer! Why should an excellent actor like Josh be penalized for Kevin's decisions? We are rooting for you Josh 👍You are the man ! 👏👏🕺🌟✨️📸😎

[@judianderson3379]

He would make a great now John Dutton

[@brred3946]

Yes Josh Lucas would be perfect for the role

[@Jim-zt1hl]

He can do it!!!!!

[@debgraham]

Yes, he should! Absolutely!

[@GeriBurt-kv5cn]

I don’t know what we think makes but I would love Lucas to play JD!!

[@loririchards9444]

I would like to see Josh Lucas should continue as John Dutton or maybe a long lost son.

[@brendarosell501]

Spot on for Josh Lucas❤a dead ringer for Kevin Costner. At first I thought it was...

[@brendarosell501]

Taylor could have continued Yellowstone with multiple stories when they were younger. Still, I love Yellowstone regardless❤

[@dot0045]

Yes on Lucas. On using same people 1883 Claire Dutton played by Dawn Olivieri also played in 2018 Yellowstone (7 episodes) as Sarah Atwood

[@johndevenney7144]

Of course he should Josh is a wonderful actor

[@ericarichards7261]

It would be okay. They would just have to make him up to look a little bit older. But yes it makes sense especially to keep the show going. I like Kevin Costner and everything he does, but I would have to say, he threw a wrench 🔧 in the mix, and that is disappointing!

[@carleithaearls7302]

Yellowstone hasn't ran the storyline out and into the ground yet. It needs to continue, just like 1923 needs to get back for completion.

[@MAChapa-je7fj]

Absolutely --- Why hasn't Taylor Sheridan thought of having Josh Lucas play an older John Dutton?? Makeup works wonders and Josh would be wonderful in the part. Then we all could continue to enjoy Yellowstone. In case anyone hasn't noticed, people don't watch to see Kevin Costner, we all watch to see everyone else and what they will do next. That is why Yellowstone is so popular. So move on Kevin, we have Josh!!!!

[@bernardspeggy0]

Yes I think Josh could do a fine job replacing kevin..it would seem weird at first but hey we'd get over it

[@lavinadrewery1537]

I think Josh Lucas would definitely be a great John Dutton

[@AVal5856]

Taylor Sheraton is such a diva, Doesn't even understand how much people would Appreciate if he stood with Kevin Costner or Josh Lucas. It's the writing and the characters that made Yellowstone. The stars of the show.That's what made it you should keep that in mind!!! You should do whatever it takes to keep all the characters ❤️ ❤️

[@CindyMiller-l6v]

I love John Lucas and could see him being John Dutton. He is great in all his movies and just as sexy and good looking as Costner. 😊

[@MargieMorrison-q5t]

Don't get me wrong I like the now John Dutton but if he leaving the show Josh would be the perfect man to take his place I'm excited to see what happens

[@ellenstoever3808]

Josh Lucas should continue as Yellowstone should too!!

[@josannahowell2461]

Every movie I saw him and he was dashing and he was wonderful I love his acting and he's in the one movie with Katie Holmes a charming love story Secret I believe it was called. He played a great John Dutton.

[@billandmindywilliams2800]

Josh Lucas would be perfect

[@phyllisbasile8495]

Yes

[@ThunderJarvis]

He fits the role better than Costner

[@terryandrews7271]

That might be the only way I come back to watch The freaking show

[@tinacathey8241]

Those that are old enough maybe Yellowstone should be another "who shot JR" fans will not be happy with John dying which it appears the only way to end the show. My thought is what about the other characters. They are just important and fun to watch. Are you going to kill them all off?

[@cherylcastaneda6823]

Love Josh! He would be perfect to take the role

[@larrywiggin3489]

Yellowstone needs to clean up their language, some of that stuff might be ok but every other word good grief, don’t watch anymore!

[@cindydavis9455]

Keep him in You can do so much more

[@velmabello7553]

Josh should be john dutton

[@hiker4life4020]

First of all I take issue with your saying that Sheridan doesn't like to use the same actors. We saw several actors from Yellowstone in 1883. Secondly it's sad in a way that Josh does not recognize his own abilities. Even the best loved shows end sooner or later. They should simply use his experience in Yellowstone to springboard into something else rather than blaming others for a failure he apparently wants to head to. Very strange

[@dereksmith1113]

I didn't hear anything about Josh Lucas hating Kevin Costner. Are you making assumptions, or am I missing something?

[@chrislang7460]

Sheridan shafted the franchise. Let’s not try to blame Costner. Costner was outstanding.

[@shantishanti1949]

Josh Lucas was brilliant as was Kevin. You can believe what you like.

[@Knockyourselfout89]

Josh lucas is aging like a fine wine

[@thenextfilm]

absolutely

[@theshowupdadfoundation7632]

josh Lucas can't carry Kevins saddle bags

[@cotyreed047360]

At least kevin doesn’t have a lissssp and at least kevin doesn’t feel the need to show everyone his “preference” by the way he talks! Its a lisp, NOT a way to tell everyone you like men!

[@Grams-snu]

Taylor Sheridan ruined your career get his facts straight Taylor Sheridan And His EGO Costner is not replaceable watchers if this show and Costners fans won't except our watch it

[@donnachandler6720]

Josh Lucas great actor but Keven Costor he's not

[@kathyburks9994]

DOES ANYONE HAVE AN IDEA WHO WAS ON THE STAIRS AT THE GOVERNOR'S HOUSE HEARING JOHN TELL BETH ABOUT THE TRAIN STATION

[@Bellaclodya]

Not true!

[@nancypeters4384]

Perfect solution, but I believe Sheridan has already decided to move forward with his sequel and Matthew McConaughey. Don't get me wrong I love Matthew, but Josh Lucas would be a perfect John Dutton. Send John away for several episodes then return with Lucas playing him. What is happening to the rest of the cast? That seems to be an unanswered question. There have been series that had to change actors playing the lead and people adjusted. Handled correctly it could be done!

[@dianemanley5233]

Trash gossip

[@tonydeeugenio1489]

Yes no brainer

[@wyvettamccarley7664]

Yes