How Hitler Used Subhas Chandra Bose For a Propaganda

[@CloudyGamingCG]

He tried every way possible to help india gain independance, we should not feel bad about it but proud that a person we had who was couragoes and brave enough.

[@Anton-tf9iw]

Subhas Chandra Bose had the courage and bravery but not the occult vision to see that Hitler was worse than the Brits or the Imperial Japanese Army. Another Bengali did see that and his name is Aurobindo Ghose: history proved him right.

[@NadiaDham]

​@@Anton-tf9iw Like British and Americans did not see Russia and Germany jointly invaded Poland but They only waged war against Germany only

[@Bobby_kavitha]

@@CloudyGamingCG a sentence must be in under the description

[@arjunsandhu7431]

Hitler would have never let india be free, we would forever be under his debt as puppet country. Moreover you should read hitler's view on Indians and its fight on independence

[@debojitsen6250]

@@Anton-tf9iw Yes, Hitlar was worse, but that doesn't matter. Bose wanted him as an ally, not as the replacement of British imperialism. And this video is full of misinformations about Bose.

[@PANDA_0783]

This proves Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose was the most nationalist person at that time. We will never let your legacy down by any Political party, political leaders or any individual.

[@anonymous_guy-t7k]

Wtf is this term 'Most nationalist'? Everybody who was fighting for independence was nationalist only, nobody was anti national

[@PANDA_0783]

@KumarRohit_1206 There were some

[@plainermine9297]

@@PANDA_0783 Like who??? Can u pls tell?

[@SteveOmnipotent]

​@@PANDA_0783 Do you think that allying with H*tler was a good idea? Allying with USSR is okay(despite what Western propaganda talks about Stalin) but allying with Hitler and letting Hitler exterminate all slavs and all jews is the most selfish idea of all time. N*zis exterminated more people in 5 years than the British did in 2 decades of their rule in India(despite what those overblown out of proportion figures may tell, and I'm no imperialist, in fact, I'm a communist in support of USSR). And if H*tler won, India won't be independent despite what you think. India would be a German puppet state with little to no power

[@SteveOmnipotent]

​​@@PANDA_0783 If he had allied with USSR after WW2, then maybe I could have called him great, but the German part has tarnished his legacy for me

[@JustScroll.v]

OUR BRO IS BACK WITH A NETFLIX BEATING DOCUMENTRY 😍😍

[@Saswata_97]

Subhash Bose didn’t found Azad Hind Fauj in Germany. It was Free India Legion. Both are different.

[@nabarudranandi2005]

Azad hind fauj was founded by Captain Mohun Singh

[@user-nq5hy7vn9k]

A lot of the facts are wrong/distorted in this video

[@Juandinggong]

@@user-nq5hy7vn9kof course what is religion again? Do I have to say anymore

[@creativemortals7316]

​@@user-nq5hy7vn9k same thing, i was constantly thinking why is he somehow always criticizing bose but never gandhi, and all his info were almost pro Gandhi. And here people are thinking what a honest guy he is

[@sayanstrlrn834]

He said the same in video 🙄

[@OmPoonia-v9t]

Subhash Chandra BOSE is a hero of our nation 😊

[@phalgunibanerjee620]

❤

[@aureliano_37]

Unfortunately Hitler's bigotry and arrogance caused him the war.

[@NotRajdeep45]

GOD for us,the people of West Bengal 🙏🙏🛐🛐

[@idkwhattodo7170]

a war head clown who got trolled by germans.

[@AlHindh313]

But as per today’s definition who struggle for their independence are called Tourists* 😂😂😂😂😂

[@shivambhatt7066]

How hard it was for Subhash Chandra Bose we can't imagine. That's why he is the Goat.

[@aparupduke]

Subhash Chandra Bose - was the greatest Indian that ever lived - we are proud that we can associate with him in some manner!

[@dis_appointed8626]

Hmm not sure man. He was strategist for sure.

[@RRP859]

​@@dis_appointed8626who is greatest then according to you?

[@imjai345]

We got Kamdev video before GTA 6 💀

[@AbhayKarman]

That's wild😭🙏

[@Delian-dt4il]

Dum gen Alpha

[@Rudrakxh]

we got another comment that compares something with gta 6 before the realising of gta 6.

[@pranavvedpathak-pf4oo]

Ha ban gaye cool dude 😒

[@mohitkoker7441]

Bass kar bhai GTA khelga hai kabhi?

[@subhasishsingh7860]

"This man is interested more in propaganda victory rather than strategic victory"- Netaji about Hitler,1942

[@NikhilThakur-k8b]

Did you born in world war 2

[@subhasishsingh7860]

@NikhilThakur-k8b please take look at some special things called "Books" 😂😂

[@subhasishsingh7860]

@@NikhilThakur-k8bbro, try a device called "books" 😂😂

[@yolk6942]

​@@NikhilThakur-k8bbhai Google karke bhi kuch hota h

[@CaesarsGhos.]

If he said that he was wrong We all know how it went

[@zain-pirzada]

This channel has shattered my perspective and everything I believed about KZbin algorithms and life

[@curious_one1156]

True. Totally true. Plus, there are those who believe India would not be independent without him, and that the Mahtma contributed nothing. Both of these extremes are false. The truth is, following the GoI Act of 1935, Independence of India was practically on the horizon, but the Brithish were simply delaying it. They made their 1st dominion status offer in August 1940 in return for India's cooperation during the war. This was rejected by INC. They then made another offer after Cripps Mission in 1942, which was also rejected and caused Quit India Movement. Finally British decided they had no choice due to the kind of effective anti British unity which had been created by: 1. Quit India Movement 2. Netaji's INA 3. Navy mutiny of 1946. 4. Rise of Socialism in Europe (Labour Party won overwhelming majority in 1945 election of Britain) 5. Collapse of British Economy (so they had little to gain by spending money on keeping India) 6. Fear that a Soviet style anti imperialist movement would occur and succeed in India. This fear was valid, since this happened later in China in 1949 against US backed emperor Chiang Kai-shek. Even Netaji finally knew that post WW2 Soviet Union would help.

[@vikramgogoi3621]

@@curious_one1156 Finally a rational person who knows history

[@confuse-e-asitis]

@@curious_one1156 Gandhi and Nehru's intentions were tainted by greed and power-hungry behavior. They never wanted an Independent India without them in power, and they prolonged the freedom struggle for more than twenty years.

[@BHARATHA-SAMPRAJYA]

@@curious_one1156 gandhi and his so-called ahimsa was a total failure and this was infact told by the british pm himself after the indipendance. Any sensible person can easily understand that it was because of the world war 2 loses along with the netajis resistance which ultimatly caused the revolting mindset inside the royal Indian army itself that caused them to leave . cause you cannot control a place without hardpower

[@Rudrakxh]

watching netflix's documentaries ❌ watching kamdev's documentaries ✅

[@confuse-e-asitis]

Don't make ur mind watching documentaries. These are propaganda videos funded by different parties. In the video, he intentionally forgot to mention why Gandhi Nehru started the Quit India movement in the first place. They were afraid of Bose. They thought with the help of Hitler Bose would launch an attack on British India and they would lose the power.

[@confuse-e-asitis]

Just see timelines and the course of action taken by Individuals. It will tell u the full story.

[@mesunandan]

He was the hero that our country needed at that time but may be did not deserve. He was not an extremist but he believed it to be the only way to free India then, because other strategies were failing. He could change his strategies as many time as he had to with the only thing constant in his heart, and that is his love and hope for his free motherland.

[@0xExcalibar752]

Yes totally agree with you...

[@makelifeeasy6006]

British were no different from the N@zi Germany. They also committed genоc¡de in India, Iran, and Africa. But the history always written by victors.

[@ShyamMeeraSingh1]

Always a Fan of You my brother.

[@kamdevofficial]

@@ShyamMeeraSingh1 Thanks Bhai ❤

[@NobleDorito8698]

Neo Buddhist shill😂

[@Rudrakxh]

i wish i could say that to you.

[@NobleDorito8698]

@@Rudrakxh Yup, he's a Neo Buddhist shill

[@Naran433]

Only spreading propaganda or hate towards the Modi government can't make u a neutral youtuber my brother the only suggestion I can give u.❤

[@sumansaha295]

Finally an essay video from Indian creator with actual content. Great research and editing. Appreciate the intellectual style very much. Keep it up, Cheers!

[@annoyedbrox4851]

This is top notch, kamdev you have topped even the western docu-entertainment history channels with that editing and I always love indian history topics, the efforts you and your team put in, I subscribed right after watching the east india company video, amazing work, please keep doing it the hardwork will definitely pay off, you are taking indian youtube to another level. Bravo Brother. I am passionate about history btw, thanks for this channel eh lad.

[@Aakxsh7]

He is and will always be my superhero😍

[@IntellectCorner]

0:03 - Introduction: Hitler's Exploitation of Subhas Chandra Bose During World War II 1:13 - Bose's Escape to Germany and Alliance with Hitler 1:41 - Hitler's Contempt for Indians and Propaganda Strategy 2:15 - Bose's Nationalist Ideals and Pursuit of Independence 2:44 - Bose's Background and Early Political Career 3:24 - Bose's Fascination with Authoritarian Regimes 4:15 - Hitler's Racist Views and Disregard for Indian Independence 6:25 - Bose's Split with Congress and Alignment with Extremism 8:23 - Bose's Plan for Indian Independence with Axis Powers' Support 10:38 - Hitler's Use of Bose for Anti-British Propaganda 11:55 - Establishment of Free India Centre and Azad Hind Radio 13:03 - Formation of the Indian Legion and Its Purpose 14:22 - Exposure of Bose's Presence in Germany and British Response 17:28 - Hitler's Rejection of Japanese Proposal and Meeting with Bose 18:43 - The Reality of the Hitler-Bose Meeting and Its Aftermath 20:32 - Bose's Journey to Japan and the Deteriorating War Situation 21:30 - Formation of the Indian National Army (INA) and Its Challenges 22:30 - The Disastrous Imphal-Kohima Campaign 23:19 - Bose's Determination Despite Setbacks 25:20 - Speculations Surrounding Bose's Death 25:56 - Conclusion: Bose's Legacy and His Fight for Indian Independence

[@MuzuTalks]

leaving a comment for reach, great video brother ❤

[@VicasArav]

Amazing documentary Kamdev brother. Hats off to you for your great efforts in making this documentary. 👏👏👏🎉🎉

[@pm.nothome]

your Documentry was something I needed at the end of this year

[@Mayank-eu8yx]

what inspires me more than this story and netaji is, you and your work. its exceptional. Inspires me to keep learning new things and keep doing things i love. great content really love it

[@debapratimbhattacharjee1569]

Kuch zyada ni ho gaya bhai?

[@iArpanMishra]

Awesome work! Really appreciate it!

[@AmriteshSingh-d9o]

Amazing documentary brother

[@JustScroll.v]

DEKH TOH LETA BHAI 1 MINUTE HI HUA HAI UPLOAD KRKE HYPOCRITE

[@wantPEACEforEveryone]

Bro complete first .

[@wantPEACEforEveryone]

Bro complete watching it first..

[@AmriteshSingh-d9o]

Well it is going to be amazing no doubt in that

[@AmriteshSingh-d9o]

Well it is going to be amazing no doubt in that

[@xyzabc-li2ty]

Subash mind was in the right place but the method and Allies he chosen to get the freedom,backfired on himself

[@subhadippaul4494]

which allies he should have chosen?

[@ঔৣSHIV-TANDAVঔৣ]

😂 khudse ghar me jhadu nhi lagta hoga padhayi likhai hoti nhi hogi chle hain gyan dene 🤣 vo netaji subhash chandra bose ko tu hota to kya karta uss time koi option nhi tha

[@anoop61284]

​@@subhadippaul4494none. He should have stayed in india. India would have got freedom even without him leaving india

[@xyzabc-li2ty]

No one , should have been supporting Gandhi or used his influence to revolutionize Indian people like bhagat singh

[@xyzabc-li2ty]

Ye option kam kiya kya??? Option bohut the look at Gandhi and bhagat singh and other freedom fighters

[@reflectotanjiro582]

4:45 kamdev you should understand that book is not original and it is translated and some changes are made... Winner will write history not losers

[@jhaG_]

Really, are you sure? I want to know how can you say this so surely. Please elaborate.

[@reflectotanjiro582]

@@jhaG_ how do you think.. It is exactly what hitler is written..

[@aureliano_37]

True, but I don't think Hitler would have had a high opinion of modern Indians (the Indians of that era) though he might have had high opinions for the "Aryans" who once lived in India.

[@OfficialOffsideBall]

​@@aureliano_37 Aryans of Natzees and the Aryans as a race aren't the same.

[@whodoesntcare]

​@@aureliano_37 i think its highly probable that he would consider indians as a mixed race of aryans and indeginous ( knowing his views of complexion and ethnicity)

[@abhinavav7770]

*Reads the title* Finally someone pointed this out

[@muktirajpandey]

What a great video to watch. thanks brother for these amzing documentary type videos. You are truly making youtube a OTT platform like Netflix,Amazon Prime.

[@rajveersinghania239]

Clement Attlee, the former British Prime Minister, stated that the British had to leave India because of doubts about the loyalty and allegiance of British Indian forces, specifically the Indian National Army (INA) led by Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose. This is mentioned in the article “Netaji was the reason why the British left India”

[@timelord2024]

the same INA "veterans" that mostly sided with Pakistan in 1947 war

[@rajveersinghania239]

@ what are you talking about bro I never heard of it

[@sreenathgopinathan4002]

Yes. Many of INA members like Major General Mohammed Zaman Kiani and Lt Col Habib Ur Rahman (who escaped in the aeroplane crash which took the life of Netaji) participated in India Pakistan war of 1947 in favour of Pakistan In September 1947, the Pakistani prime minister Liaquat Ali Khan and the Punjabi minister Shaukat Hayat Khan put Major Gen M Z Kiani as the in charge of the southern wing of the Pakistan's effort to overthrow the Maharaja of Jammu and Kashmir. General Kiani established a General Headquarters, GHQ Azad, based in Gujrat City. From here, Kiani's forces organised raiding operations on Kashmir border and directed the Kashmiri rebels in Poonch, eventually leading to the formation of Azad Kashmir. Brigadier Raja Habib ur Rahman Khan served as his chief of staff and was responsible for the capture of strategic towns and cities such as Bhimber and Mirpur.

[@sreenathgopinathan4002]

Habib ur Rahman (1913-1978) was an army officer in the Indian National Army (INA) who was charged with "waging war against His Majesty the King Emperor". He served as Subhas Chandra Bose's chief of staff in Singapore, and accompanied Bose on his fatal last flight from Taipei to Tokyo, sharing the last moments of his life. Rahman also played an important role in the First Kashmir War. Convinced that Maharaja Hari Singh was out to exterminate the Muslims of Jammu and Kashmir, he joined Major General Zaman Kiani, in launching a rebellion against the Maharaja from Gujrat in Pakistani Punjab.

[@rajveersinghania239]

@@sreenathgopinathan4002 so it was the Muslims who sided with Pakistan right you and I both know who they are loyal to I don’t think I need to say more on this topic

[@Tanmoy-so4bh]

His love and compassion was genuine for the country...but at the end it was all failure...we could learn only patriotism and not giving up attitude from him...but Gandhi and all the non violence leaders...they kept the foundation...the construction of identity 'India'...and its constitution...all of them were legends...its only modern perspect that keeps us blind and fuels hatred for some of them.

[@dineshyadav-cx7sb]

Yes 100% right, and gandhiji's non violence idea was also very good decision from bloody and violence fights. But even now many andhbhakt community not want to accept. No doubt bose was great but without gandhiji it was impossible for indian to achieved independent.

[@koushikdas1992]

​@@dineshyadav-cx7sb Without America it is. America wanted new era of domination and forced British to free its colonized region one by one. British chose American way in order to get backed by America.

[@gurs-123]

Bose was also against Jews refugees in India. The only reason the British leave India is because they did not want to play Colonial Game any more and nor did they have money.

[@NehaVerma-q5c]

Just listen BR Ambedkar interview to BBC in 1955. He clearly mentioned that India became free because of BOSE.

[@gurs-123]

@NehaVerma-q5c He was wrong.

[@singh-hj5bv]

Then what was royal India navy revolt 1946 which inspired by ina which unfortunately led you Britishers 1947 to feared and make you pack your bags and leave out as possible in hurry😂

[@gurs-123]

@@singh-hj5bv You can live in your delusion but there is nothing like this you saying. In Actual fact, he had a lack of understanding of ideologies, and the world.

[@hunterrrking6297]

Gandhi expose please he was british agent

[@GloomyGlue]

Who said? An old man with white hairs who claims to be an astrophysicist, historian, political and geopolitics expert?

[@ঔৣSHIV-TANDAVঔৣ]

British agent to nhi tha shayad but vo kuch jayada hi pyar karta tha Britishers se agar gandhi nhi hota to hame azadi milne me itni der nhi lagti ye bhi ek had tak sahi hain

[@AveragepoliticsEnjoyer]

​@@ঔৣSHIV-TANDAVঔৣ Ghanta Kaise milti azadi konse weapons the Indians ke pass tab ?? Kuch bhi Kisi bhi Ka Sonke ajate ho

[@prasoonjha6314]

Stop watching conspiracy theorists

[@hunterrrking6297]

@@ঔৣSHIV-TANDAVঔৣ Bhai uski history padho british uske sath jada he soft the pehlese and usse political support bhi kiya hai .. tho 100 💯 british agent tha perfect plant kiya gaya tha taki britisher ko koi mare na

[@kanishk5962]

There's a book by Gurcharan Das named "Another Sort of Freedom", the beginning of which shows how WWII polarised Indians. Das was a kid when India became independent (and also during the latter half of WWII), and recounts that the old were conservative enough to hope the British sustained themselves (and their empire), while the young were more radical, some favouring Gandhi and some even Bose. One of his relations was considered an oddball because of being supportive of communism. Fascinating stuff

[@hrideepkrborahshorts]

Netaji, India will always remember you as the real Hero... Haame Azadi dilane ne keliye, aapko koti-koti pranaam 🙏🙏🙏

[@atoz2739]

So glad to found Your Channel wayy before dhruv recommended it ! Exceptional contents ❤

[@lokeshmeenarajindia]

Great Subhash Chandra bosji❤❤अखंड भारत🇮🇳👳🇮🇳👳 India🇮🇳🇮🇳❤ , 1945

[@MdSawkat-zi6vn]

Carry-on! Keep making Neutral videos like this....❤❤❤❤

[@Utkal-bandhopadhyay]

What a eye opening vdo , tx man make more such vdos , m feeling too bad for subhash he is always alive in our heart 💗

[@HarshVermaJhs]

20:04 Lol 😂🤣 "Quit india movement nearly won the war against British"😂🤣😭

[@rashidrazakhan9153]

Bhai historian ne jo khaa wo likha h, quit india movement bhale disaster hi rha ho atleast log aye to the. Ye sala apne logo mae dhoni vs gambhir, kholi vs rohit, gandhi vs bose, Nehru vs sardar ki obsession kyu nhi nikalta. Jbki ye sb ek dusre ki izzat krte the

[@buzztube1738]

Lotpot

[@shabbiransari9731]

Next video on Gaza the same people doing genocide on Palestinians

[@StudyingReligions]

6:34 Extremism.??? Seriously bro Seriously. Deshbhakti Ko Extremism Bol Rha Hai! Bose wanted to use Hitler to gain Independence of India! He knew they were Extremists but wanted to use them for our Motherland's freedom!

[@shabazpathan2501]

Watch till end

[@Lmao-truth-5670]

deshbhakti emotion hai uske liye kaam karne ka tarika extremism hai jo bohat baar back fire karta hai itihaas gawah hai iska why Bose wont have choosen it in a normal condition he choose it because other things were failing

[@Bobby_kavitha]

Anandbhakt=deshbakt=> leads to extremism at desperate situation

[@arjunsandhu7431]

Haha nobody could really use hitler out dude, not even his own people 😂 were super afraid of his unpredictable behavior. You should read mein kampf hitler biography and his views on india😂

[@anmolmohanty7537]

An extrimist only can choose help from hitler because the other idea and hopes had failed 😔, no doubt about his patriotism but he was choosing a wrong helping hand indeed

[@VidyaBelchade]

U are a true artist my friend...Keep posting

[@aranibhattacharya9635]

You have reached a kernel of truth -- that Hitler was neither pro-Indian nor a supporter of Bose. But you extrapolate to say that all the Axis Powers were opportunistic, with absolutely no evidence. Japanese leaders like Tojo, Koiso and Terauchi actually supported Netaji. Even among the Germans, they could have denied the submarine if they wanted to, which was a risky undertaking. Also, its laughable to say that the Quit India Movement was a success, when it was easily suppressed within 2-3 months and the British Indian Army continued to function.

[@prasoonjha6314]

The same Japan promised Phizo that they would get Nagaland independence from India. So much for non-opportunistic, selfless, India-loving Imperial Japan.

[@singh-hj5bv]

@@prasoonjha6314same Japan gave azad hind fauz to establish on andaman Nicobar free from British and establish and continue their freedom fight from there

[@alonegameryt5608]

worth watching full video one more need on part 2 ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@0xExcalibar752]

Netaji was a mad patriot...❤️

[@Mohitpooniaoffical]

Your intro and outro is fantastic.

[@sashareef]

I watched numerous videos about independence, and while most depicted leaders as almost heroic figures reminiscent of Rajamouli's films, this particular video stood out for its factual accuracy. It reinforced the idea that no human is a hero and shouldn't be idolized. We can admire their contributions, but we should not resort to worship.

[@harshshah2775]

The singporian prime minister is a good example for what you said. He made sure that there would be no status or roads named after him to make sure that any future political parties would not be able to hide behind his image and mess everything that he stood for.

[@goutambaidya5087]

Even Bose was not extremist. Instead he was influenced by the russiun revolution. Only he knew that the axis are biggest oppositers of allies, who are villain for India. You know? Because of him all world got independent from western colonization for that man. He was a god human

[@Politicalbeing47]

On one side , Sangis are saying India got Independence because of British got broken after WW2. On Another side , Sangis are Saying Bose is the reason of Independence 🤧🤧🤧🤧🤧🤧🤧🤧🤧🤧

[@AbhinavSingh-ce3wk]

Wake up baby Kam dev uploaded another banger after long time

[@dibyendugoswami-l7r]

I feel like there isn't enough documentaries available on Subhash Chandra Bose. He was one of those handful visionaries who wanted to free india not by slaps by rather by force and rebellion. We should collectively help reach out his stories to the world

[@creativemortals7316]

Dude i started your video positively after seeing the first few comments, but half the way through the video, i could literally smell the bias you have for gandhi and nehru, and not for bose. Azad hind fauj was never founded by subash bose, it was founded by captain mohan singh and rashbehari bose, later bose took command of it, same way half of the facts were moulded by you in showing bose in a bad light. Ajit doval, literally a great man in intelligence dept, he has said if bose was there no partition would have occured, even jinnah said they will be one country if the pm was bose, hell even clement atlee, the pm of Britain said it was bose, who led the british to go away. Everyone has biases, bose wasn't certainly a perfect being, but the way you portrayed him in this video, and how you showed gandhi was the main guy in freedom, its no wonder why our country is still so under developed, always believing war isnt the only way freedom is achieved.

[@Prince-np7yu]

Your documentary is best on KZbin

[@VSM101]

nope

[@theresponsibleuser90]

Even if he was wrong,he was still better than Gandhi, Nehru & Britishers ✅

[@ShyamS-sx7xt]

also than modi amit shah yogi rss bjp

[@yolk6942]

​@@ShyamS-sx7xtyes

[@devil1000ish]

Laughable considering the fact that Bose named two brigades of INA after Gandhi and Nehru.

[@vaibhavaher4244]

Gandhi is way taller than what even most liberals assume, let alone WhatsApp Sanghis.

[@Argdut1106]

​@@vaibhavaher4244Taller in what respect exactly? 😂

[@bodhisattwaghosh2673]

One of the first subscribers of this channel. Made the right decision. Keep it on. Kamdev is a true commentator. Bose was a true patriot.

[@thekunalpahuja]

KZbin algorithm needs to promote your videos again. The documentary before this video and this one both deserve atleast 1 million views.

[@Dhonkesh_Bakshi]

Excellent content, much appreciated. Keep making these.

[@commander727]

What a goosebumps documentry 🚩🚩🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@aakashmitra1114]

"The man who never gave up on Indian Independence!" - What a great thing to feel as a bengali..

[@thebrotaku7156]

Hey bhai. Great video. Just a minor english grammar error in the title. "A propaganda" is incorrect. Propaganda is not a countable noun. Looking forward to the next one!

[@gamingwithkj5739]

In 1958 clement etly visited India who is prime minister of India at that time in a meeting at Kolkata some one asked him you won the secend world war then what make you to leave india and give indian people independence he said one word bose army because of bose indian registance to Britishers at higher level also indian British army soldiers are not in a mood of working under Britishers that's they have to leave india and they gave india independence

[@NizilShah]

One major missed thing: Japan had formed the puppet Free India state based on Andaman Nicobar and Bose was the head of that state. And Japan did a cruel massacre there. Bose did not know that. Japan wanted India as a puppet state, not as Free Nation.

[@NehaVerma-q5c]

Do you Bose had established Provisional government of free india. Area captured from British were under the control of government. Why Japanese give strategic island of Andaman and Nicobar to Bose, if they really wanted to colonise India. Remember the fact that India became free due to Subhash Chandra Bose and ina. Quit India was failed in 1942. And Bose was not died in plane crash in 1945. He escaped to Russia.

[@AveragepoliticsEnjoyer]

​@@NehaVerma-q5c That's a conspiracy and I am much more side with netaji but I think he left us in Crash 😢

[@Blspeek-ag]

We are still puppet of european race as a non white we will never be a super power they will never let us 😢,but we are little batter than africans they are doomed from the start😂

[@ARYAN_WARRIOR.]

​@@NehaVerma-q5c what happened after he went to Russia? I mean why did he just remained like neutral guy?

[@appy4401]

@@NehaVerma-q5c we have got a conspiracy theorist here. got any proof for what you're claiming? And why did you just ignore the atrocities committed by Japan on India?

[@dipakmajumdar1213]

Bose tried to enter Soviet, but could not. So, he had to go to Germany with the help of Itali. He was against Hitler's attack of Soviet. He was never a student of Cambridge University. He stood 4th in the ICS Exam in England. He never married. Emily was never his wife. Bose died in the year 1978 in Faizabad, India.

[@curious_one1156]

Eye opening. There are those who believe India would not be independent without Netaji, and that the Mahtma contributed nothing. Both of these extremes are false. The truth is, following the GoI Act of 1935, Independence of India was practically on the horizon, but the Brithish were simply delaying it. They made their 1st dominion status offer in August 1940 in return for India's cooperation during the war. This was rejected by INC. They then made another offer after Cripps Mission in 1942, which was also rejected and caused Quit India Movement. Finally British decided they had no choice due to the kind of effective anti British unity which had been created by: 1. Quit India Movement 2. Netaji's INA 3. Navy mutiny of 1946. 4. Rise of Socialism in Europe (Labour Party won overwhelming majority in 1945 election of Britain) 5. Collapse of British Economy (so they had little to gain by spending money on keeping India) 6. Fear that a Soviet style anti imperialist movement would occur and succeed in India. This fear was valid, since this happened later in China in 1949 against US backed emperor Chiang Kai-shek. Even Netaji finally knew that post WW2 Soviet Union would help.

[@OMA407]

Majority people will understand only what they want to listen.There is no one reason as you mentioned but multiple factors contributing to our Independence.M not Gandhi's fan due to his orthodox and hypocrite views on women, Caste, Religion, Race,etc, but no one can ignore his contributions that is for sure.

[@ArindamKumar_2002]

I liked point no. 6.

[@WhiteFang111]

Maybe under bose Pakistan won't have happened British jus divided u all.

[@prasoonjha1816]

Great points though there is a minor mistake. Chiang Kai-Shek was not the emperor of China, he was the leader of KMT which came into power by overthrowing the Chinese Emperor.

[@sourishpaul3117]

Salute to Mother India's Warrior Son Netaji Bose 🙏🪷🌺💐🔥🇮🇳

[@dhyeygandhi8738]

He's back boys!

[@partha1kundu]

He did not die in plane crash..it's proven truth

[@Politicalbeing47]

According to WhatsApp University of Sangis and Commis 🤮

[@shivanshgilhotra701]

wow that was really interesting i want to confirm 1 thing idk if you'll read this or not imphal and kohima battles that were japanese disaster were they actually mostly indian soldiers(azad hind fauz) or japanese and in movie of sam manekshaw (I've not exactly read materials to quote ) we saw heroism of sam and victory of indian(british india) was celebrated even by indian soldiers but didn't they realise that they were actually fighting azad hind fauz or am i wrong in analyzing this(and i wanna clarify its not like i wanted japanese rule or something over india)

[@shivanshgilhotra701]

I also wanna ask whenever we hear about Bose's contribution we get that he had his army ready to attack british india so is it really true or it was part of german propaganda ? with this i dont mean to devalue Bose's contribution i consider him more prominent than nehru,gandhi

[@Lmao-truth-5670]

bhai India was a extremely divided place where a lot of Indian supported the british and sided with British isiliye itne saalon tak British rule kar paye its a complex topic tum jitna simple samajhte honutna hai nahi

[@socialdesk3570]

​​@@shivanshgilhotra701 why it feels like you are a subscriber of Abhijit Chavda or someone like him 😅 Idk, your last statement give that feeling 😅

[@socialdesk3570]

Yes bro, I have the same question way earlier. When I started my preparation for NDA. I doubt whether Sam got that medal by defeating INA

[@shivanshgilhotra701]

@@socialdesk3570 I actually am a subscriber of abhijit chavda 😂 don't know how last line gave that but yeah I'm not a student of history but I like to know about these topics so I have subscribed to similar channels as an interest

[@avijitjana1141]

Extraordinary explanation. 100....00 thanks to bring true history in front.

[@vilasvillu010]

I was expecting videos on current issues

[@hinduwarrior123]

Kamdev I really love your podcast ! Subscribed to you! Lots of love and good wishes from Uttarakhand ❤

[@sagarmane6883]

And Savarkar wrote to Britishers that I would help you to fight against Azad Hind Sena and Germany

[@SyndicalDream]

Savarkar support German invasion of Czechoslovia, Poland, France

[@Sougata-bio]

He did his best for India in his own way, being a brilliant person he could live a luxurious life, but he quit that... Salute❤

[@rishxb.mp4]

Last night i was checking my subscription list and i saw your channel and wondered there had been months you didn't uploaded any video and coincidentally today you came with a video....i love your work brother ...but please try to bring at least one video every month

[@pinakprasaddeb9656]

The last words made by him felt so hard...we should never forget what is the cost of our Independence... blessed to be born in India...

[@jhaG_]

Bhai ek video gandhi par. Kya gandhi waisa hai jaise right wing wale kahte hai. Waise mai left wing ka nahi hu.😅

[@black_pickle_]

no

[@jhaG_]

@black_pickle_ why??????

[@atintripathi5948]

​​​@@jhaG_he just center - left wing not right wing.....

[@dr.rangarajc9691]

Gandhiji warned that ends don't justify the means. ""If one takes care of the means, the end will take care of itself." "The means may be likened to a seed, the end to a tree; and there is just the same inviolable connection between the means and the end as there is between the seed and the tree"

[@black_pickle_]

one thing : netaji respected gandhi

[@pranavjoshi2920]

Netaji shook hands with Hitler as well. Two things: he was being diplomatic, and he stood by "samay pe gadhe ko bhi baap banana padta hai"!

[@NehaVerma-q5c]

​@@pranavjoshi2920agree. Actually Bose called him father of nation just to get political support and uniting Indians inside India.

[@sipun5911]

​@@pranavjoshi2920 “Give me blood. I will give you Freedom.” the Statement decipt that he went any extent for Freedom.

[@ImPotatoking]

@@pranavjoshi2920 but he never admired hitler like he did to gandhi

[@AtheistIndian2024]

Just think if Gandhi is gadha then what you are and what modi is simple and straight

[@Roy-jz2ok]

Pretty good analysis with facts.

[@sermon1984]

Bhai ek request hai tu Description mai resources daal diya kar

[@randomshorts_ty]

Resources hoga to dalega na!

[@ayankrdutta3671]

Subhas chandra bose was a very high level military tactician and visionary leader…

[@yolk6942]

No his military missions all failed

[@JjSs1204]

He was a visionary leader but he was not a good military commander and his ideology is not good

[@arthlogy]

1:57 nice animation you tried different.

[@YSubbarayudu-z2j]

JAI HIND NETAJI JAYAHO🙏

[@soumenadhikary3383]

Stop making videos with false facts..

[@rohanbansal2324]

Adhbut video. Good clean Hindi too, keep it up bro.

[@OmPoonia-v9t]

Dear kamdev, I have a question that what was the mejor Power that give us freedom. is that aajad hind faug

[@ঔৣSHIV-TANDAVঔৣ]

Yup it is....... It's pretty obvious

[@sachins5784]

We got freedom because British power weakened after the second world war. Infact you'll see this with all colonial powers around that time, many countries got freedom in the aftermath of world war 2 because all these global colonial powers were economically and otherwise weakened - they were struggling to hold their colonies and the subjugation finally ended. Ofc, we can't ignore the combined efforts of all the freedom fighters, but atleast in the case of India, it was probably this factor instead of one particular person or movement.

[@NehaVerma-q5c]

​@@sachins5784 It is one of the factor. But India became free because red fort trails of INA had created a feeling of revolt among the British Indian army soldiers. Just listen to Br Ambedkar interview to bbc in 1955. He clearly mentioned that India became free because of BOSE.

[@achyutsingh]

Excellent and unbiased analysis of our Freedom fighter. His relentless passion of never giving up makes him a national Hero.

[@muhammadtahir3327]

1:20 Please correct the pathway from which Neta ji went to Soviet Union, he went to Moscow via Afghanistan

[@Aryan_Harx]

Society union?😂

[@muhammadtahir3327]

@@Aryan_Harx Means?

[@Aryan_Harx]

@@muhammadtahir3327 you write society union instead of Soviet Union

[@muhammadtahir3327]

@@Aryan_Harx Hahaha thanks for correction Yar ... Ye sari masla auto correction ka hy, ye bechara apny ap ko bhot intelligent samjhta hy 😉

[@harshitakulsaini3944]

Prime example of quality over quantity

[@Priykant24]

This is the first time I don't agree with you. Hitlar didn't criticize us but our psuedo leaders who were doing not exactly what it takes to get freedom.

[@prasoonjha6314]

Hitler believed Indians to be an inferior race. Period. Non-Germans and even among them non-whites being inferior people was the core belief of the Nazis.

[@Srijanadhikari2928]

He viewed non Germans as inferiors 😂😂 If axis would’ve won ww2 You would be either speaking japanese or German

[@aloksheel9454]

Bose was and will remain great.....soo practical,courageous and true INDIAN

[@siddheshpatil509]

Bhaiii Etna na tadpaooo jaldi video dala kro bandi se jyada ab tum tadpane lage hoo😂😂😂

[@private_host]

😂🤣

[@Talestime0]

Love and respect from Turkey 🇹🇷 Your content is really amazing. Best wishes ♥️

[@grimreaperplayz5740]

How are you understanding it?

[@OfficialOffsideBall]

​@@grimreaperplayz5740 Turkish hain, par India mein Janam to leh sakte hain nah? 😂

[@subhradipgiri9723]

But the story didn’t end there... A new movement in India started around INA... Navy mutiny started... Communist, although initially suspicious about Netaji...corrected their views.

[@jayantakumardey3696]

Communists were among the main agitators of naval revolts. Like stalwart communist leader BT Ranadive was the main organiser of All india general strike in support of Naval mutiny.

[@not.the.beti.b]

Amazing vid! What books did you refer to in your research apart from Mein Kampf? Asking as i would like to read them.

[@kamdevofficial]

Sure! I read, Mein kampf, Netaji collected works, Lost Hero by Mihir Bose, Bose in Nazi Germany by romain Hayes, and I read some other books related to Bose (But didn't refer them in video)

[@Utkarsh-w2d]

There is one thing we indians never talk about. The british didn't escape from india, they left india and humiliated us, just like for a lot of nations in africa. In their minds, "they gave independence to indians, the inferior race". The chapter- The indo china war of class 10 NCERT inspired me a lot. If we had the got the independence in the manner of vietnam, it would have been so much better. in 1940 our population was 340 million. If just 2 million of our people united and fought a violent war, we would have won quite easily. Ofcourse i am aware of divide and rule strategy of britain. If gandhi tried to convince, people would have fought for him. But, ofcourse he chose humiliation over violence and death. Even though, Famines caused by british raj killed more people ( More of us were killed than Genocide of jews of in Europe).

[@hunterrrking6297]

Right

[@sachins5784]

That's because Gandhi was also an extremist in his views. He was a pacifist, but there's a important difference to make when you're entire population is subjugated by a colonial power - which Gandhi obviously failed to make. Obviously we can only guess, but I really wonder why other "violent" movements against the British didn't really take off, considering the population - surely someone else might have had the same ideas as Bose. It's just weird.

[@AndWeWillNeverBeAloneAgain]

Independence of vietnam was brutal followed by an ideological struggle later on

[@sreenathgopinathan4002]

Yes. Independence of Indo China from the French colonial rule was a bloody affair. Partition of India and decolonisation of British India was comparatively less violent compared to that

[@anubge]

Brilliantly done bro. Commenting for reach.

[@joc4970]

Jaldi se download delete/trim hone se pehle

[@Ledvegom]

No gandhiji and neheruji has given freedom to us.

[@JuniadAnsari-i3z]

only Goat Subhas ❤

[@Ledvegom]

@@JuniadAnsari-i3z sorry bro I am Pakistani. They gave us freedom from India. 😂😂😂

[@THEYSSD]

26:34 welcome back

[@AnirudhTammireddy]

Back se welcome hai tera timestamp Like a fart

[@NotRajdeep45]

Then why Clement Attlee Said in his Interview that British Would never left India if there was no Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and INA since they had almost Won the entire WW 2 by that time.Stop Spreading Propaganda in Indians don't play with the Emotions of Bengalis Netaji is our God🛐🛐🛐🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@ankanchoudhury8433]

Which interview? Any link to the source?

[@NotRajdeep45]

@ankanchoudhury8433 Read the book Bose:An Indian Samurai by General GD Bakshi then you will understand Netaji's Contribution.You can also check and article by India Today, search it on Google

[@plaguedoctor_]

You are the one spreading propaganda

[@ganesh_kamble]

One of the underrated channels on KZbin