Karen Read Trial / Trooper Joe Paul Witness Part 2 / Expert Key Cycles

[@johnharris452]

This is what the jury needs when things seem complicated by stats and actions. Great job.

[@hkr667]

This is exactly what Jackson argued in court and I understood him just fine. It's just that trooper Paul is either stupid or malicious and I'd argue both.

[@katharineshade9550]

@@hkr667a lot of people need to see it visually to understand it properly. This made so much more sense to me!

[@RaoulThomas007]

The question is whether Bev would have allowed it into evidence. These Illustrations are amazing and provide a quick rendering of what may have happened based on testimony.

[@PhoebeMc]

Why not? She allowed in all the CWs evidence with no chain of custody. That's NEVER allowed!! Ajax contested that, but Bev wouldn't back down. They could've appealed for a different judge, but that would've put off the car at least another yr & Karen didn't want that. She's probably second guessing that decision now. Auntie Bev refused, no matter how many things she did that were unscrupulous & disgusting, too recuse herself from this case. As we watch & all say, "Jeez she's SO biased!" We all know she is! She's deliberately skewed this case to help the prosecution. Whether or not Karen tries to go after her when all is done, of course depending on the finding of the jury, is justified & significant. So, "Something funny, Ms. Read?" "Yes ma'am, you. " I doubt it's comical as much as exasperating!! Most people I know couldn't withstand the horrors she's still living thru.

[@lseh]

​@@RaoulThomas007I doubt it, she didn't seem to want anything useful entered. She didn't even like the zoomed in video of the tire.

[@katiehettinger7857]

Hope lawyers have noticed your work and you get lots of calls to help juries visualize technical data. Not everyone is good at creating pictures in their mind's eye from verbal descriptions. Good luck. 😉👍❤️🎉

[@joshn1678]

They didn't need your beautiful work to win this one, but they should have hired you. Your work is incredible, I remember seeing I during the Murdaugh trial. Hope you get more attention!

[@K-ls2kd]

You explained that better in 2:57 mins than the long drawn out testimony of the “expert” in court.

[@MeganSpruce90]

That is exactly it! I never could wrap my mind around the whole 24mph 62ft in 5 seconds thing... Being from an area with snow, we know when you're trying to get through snow, your tires spin... there was clearly a foot of snow minumum in this video.. so the vehicle is registering the tires spinning! This literally proves it.. and the visuals help so much! And i also notice in the tow truck video it shows the left and right steering wheel movement too..wow

[@tiffanimcmillian3058]

​@@Look_What_You_Didyou are not very bright

[@gwp4eva]

not sure exactly how the data recorder logs things, but the way they had to floor the SUV in reverse to get it through the snow and onto the tow truck sure looks like the triggering event Trooper Paul used to create his whole theory

[@chantallennox1201]

I thought that too and then checked the time…sped up 🙂

[@MeganSpruce90]

If the video is sped up, regardless, that seems like the triggering event that Paul based all of this off. 24mph, 62ft.. likely the tires spinning to gain traction.

[@blipco5]

Trooper Paul didn’t create any theory. He is an imbecile. TP was told what to write down by the people who planted the evidence in the same way you get a toddler to do what you want by "suggesting" a course of action when they haven’t a clue.

[@LARENLM]

Wish Jackson pushed this harder on cross. Showed the video of tow truck loading so it sunk in with jurors.

[@samanthasmile7746]

Exactly!

[@brandonwestfall3241]

Dear Trooper Paul, Get bent, lol Love, Me

[@islesofshoals3551]

😄😄😄😄

[@Penny_Laine]

Amen 🙏

[@samanthasmile7746]

Seriously!

[@5thdimension954]

Your work is impeccable. I wish you all the best in meeting your goals

[@40dougherty]

I finally understand key cycles

[@missycohen26]

Great visual. You are so talented!

[@tiffanyb4979]

What a great video! This makes it so much clearer. Thank you!

[@chhansen9813]

It was elemental!

[@malachy9400]

Such a clear and concise presentation, you would be a great asset to any investigation.

[@frankdeak2397]

Your absolute to detail is refreshing to see in someone else. Thank you.

[@Mommin_Aint_Eazy]

You've nailed this every time. Thank you!!!

[@terribeingessner8636]

Your are absolutely brilliant and very talented. Your video are incredible. Thank you for your incredible work.

[@queenbeecanadas]

Girl you make the nonsense of "stuff" make actual sense! 🐝 appreciate your work

[@cmp-vegan5136]

your videos are really impressive… simple and on point!! thank you! ❤

[@LawNerdAmber]

Holy moly you just helped me understand so much! Thank you

[@mrssabre2946]

This is an amazing visual! Thank you. I wish they were able to use this during trial

[@charlie15627]

Thank you It was fairly obvious to me, when I heard the trooper being questioned. He seemed to recognize his mistake, when questioned but was being intentionally obtuse, in order to avoid admitting his error. I know there's plenty of people out there who wouldn't pick up on the problem and I'm really glad you made a clear simple video, with visuals, explaining it in a way that everyone can understand. The prosecutor and all the other lying frauds should be criminally prosecuted for trying to pin this on Ms. Reed. She just lost her loved one and they immediately try blaming her for the death, when it was clear from the beginning that she didn't do it. They're doing it for the sole purpose of protecting the person who did do it. Despicable.

[@milart12]

I'm sure that you are aware of the state's new theory that the testing which Paul performed were actually done exclusively during key cycle 1167 and not 1164-1167- It makes a lot of sense Trooper Paul was wrong about when his testing showed up in the Techstream data. The starting point for his theory is to assume that Trooper Paul's testing actually began at key cycle 1167. This means all the triggers that are shown on key cycles 1164 and 1165 are not from Trooper Paul's testing. From this you can count backwards and make the triggers on 1162 match up with Karen Read's drive to/from Fairview on 1/29/22. Counting backwards, we get the following: 1167: Trooper Paul's testing -- triggers showing antilock braking, sudden braking, etc. These triggers make sense in terms of what Trooper Paul described doing in his tests. 1166: Car taken off the flatbed and driven into the sallyport -- no triggers 1165: Car loaded onto flatbed in Dighton -- 1 traction control trigger 1164: Car driven by Bill Read from 1 Meadows in Canton to Dighton. Near the end of the drive, the car gets stuck in the snow for about 6 minutes, thus recording the triggers we see on key cycle 1164. Those triggers are all of the "accelerator pedal is medium or higher immediately after shifting" variety. The odometer is at 12665 for this trigger, and also on the next trigger (1165). 1163: Car driven by Karen Read at 5am from 1 Meadows to various locations in Canton, then back to 1 Meadows. -- no triggers 1162: Car driven by Karen Read from the Waterfall to 34 Fairview, then to 1 Meadows. -- Two triggers, including the one that, according to the CW, allegedly shows the moment John O'Keefe was hit. Reply

[@richardbetts816]

Nicely done! Hope Troopah Paul is watching

[@hkr667]

The only thing Paul should be watching is the inside of the unemployment office

[@kimrosenow609]

You've explained this so simply - fantastic. Why can't (or wont) the experts be as clear and concise as this?

[@LibbyCee17]

You are really good at making videos that allow people watching to visualize the information. Great job.

[@josephbrantley3953]

Thank you for all your hard work

[@jasmina_dee]

Thanks very much 🤗

[@JetPackDino]

feels like you care about this case more than that cop did. thank you for this video

[@tla1616]

It’s John O’Keefe. You wrote Brian on your data sheet. Great video

[@emilycruz2021]

I really love your videos. It's so much easier to understand some of this testimony with your awesome animations. I really appreciate this video because I zoned out listening to the key cycle portion.

[@ediesaffron3593]

Wow! Fantastic job!! This was SO incredibly helpful! I hope lawyers will see your work and hire you for future cases. You’re amazing! Keep up the good work! 💖☺️

[@cheaglelover734]

Thank you!

[@rebeccaaustralia6448]

Thank you! Your videos make it easy to understand the key cycles

[@yvettevalencia8651]

Great work! Just found your channel. Keep it up!

[@matt1074]

Did anyone notice the car had no snow on it in the port. But there was a perfect snow outline on the floor. This could account for another key cycle. Plus the police tape fit perfectly. That car was in that port before tgat video

[@Set-it-to-11]

"Exactly!"

[@marissagentles3032]

I have been saying this...the car outside the sally port had snow even on the windows and when they play the video of it inside the sallyport...all that snow was gone... so they did tamper with the video n the car for sure

[@luisadiniz9559]

As an architect and modeling instructor your videos are really impressive. Thank you

[@MrBroccoliGuy]

Do you think you would consider doing a video visualizing Dr. Wolfe's testimony?

[@rex88moser]

You mean the one with the air canon, right 🤣

[@MrBroccoliGuy]

@@rex88moser Not just that experiment, but yes, that's the guy. Did you see his face light up about the glass cannon? He loves his job!

[@michele36618]

Thank you ! Holy cow that key cycle stuff totally went over my head. Now I get it ! Thank you so much !!

[@Getluvgiveluv]

Amazing wow ❤, you need to send your work to attorneys nationwide , I’m sure your talents won’t ever go unnoticed! Is the same thing that Allen Jackson said when cross, but to actually watch and understand it properly is even more amazing thanks

[@triciamuir]

You're amazing! Much easier to understand the key cycles with your video 😊 wish you much success!

[@francescaetc]

@azgetindustries- you should update the Fallen Police Officer's name to John O'Keefe near the end of the video.

[@LiLHarOak]

2:33

[@silikon2]

Either nearly all the cops that testified in this case are dishonest or incompetent. I would be terrified to live in Massachusetts. The Massachusetts police association announced how horrified they were with Trooper Proctor's misogynistic texts, while in the same press release saying "The Association is proud of the work our members do each day, as well as the fact that our Massachusetts homicide solve rate is the envy of the country," Considering Proctor has been accused of framing Karen and there's significant evidence supporting this... did they really not see the implication of that statement?

[@Tommy-pe8ct]

You're absolutely right 👍🏻💯💯

[@Phenomaton]

"it doesnt have to..." trooper Paul makes my day every time i head him speak 🤣🤣 Your videos rock! and you are wicked cute!!

[@ClariceStarling45]

Oh man I tuned out of all of that “expert testimony” and was clueless about any of it state or def. This is so simple .. and you explained it in 9 days 2 hours 2 min and 3 seconds less than lally !

[@ZeldaKelly]

This is brilliant! You have a wonderful career ahead of you!

[@chocol8milk]

I will be impressed if you could do a visualization of the crime scene telling Trooper Paul 'stuff'. 😂

[@sharonsekhon9475]

This helps explain so much. Thank you!

[@AntiEmpire]

Thank you so much!!!!

[@lillyshaw9439]

Yes! You have an excellent visuals and this is so true. The only thing that worries me is “I hope the Jury remember it!”. I have forgotten do much from the earlier trial, and whrn I retwarch snippets - my mouth drops at the total inadequacy of the Police investigation.

[@HulaHula667]

Thank you for explaining this information clearly and proving (as if we didn’t already know) that either TP doesn’t have a clue about what he’s talking about or he’s lying - or both!

[@veraspresser5503]

I just subbed and thank you for sharing.

[@YES214]

So many of us are giving you shout outs 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🫡 thank you for your excellent work!

[@dianaduguay6190]

Your coverage is incredible.

[@kellygb4370]

I love how pristine your work is. You did a concise, clean, easy to understand video with Karen Read case, so I just subscribe for more.

[@johnkelly2169]

This is brilliant work. As are all your videos. Elegant and informative.

[@Vichtyr09]

Great job with the explanation. Easy to follow!

[@adriannegrant766]

Defence needed you, thank you

[@Lanny-io9bi]

I have no doubt that you are going to go far and be very successful with your work and You are very good at what you do!

[@BlameJason]

So one thing that I think people are getting confused about is assuming that Key Cycle 01164 was actually the FIRST time that Trooper Paul began his crash reconstruction tests in the Lexus and then working back from there based on the known Key Cycles. One thing to consider is the possibility that when Key Cycle 01164 occurred, it could've been after there had been several more Key Cycles that we don't know about. What if Key Cycle 01162 was actually the first time they did a "crash reconstruction test" in the Canton PD parking lot, causing that triggering event that they're trying to say was Karen Read reversing into John? Then they drove the 36 miles to make it look like it matched up with when Karen would've hit John? So it's true to say that when Karen dropped off John at 34 Fair View a little after midnight on January 29th, 2022 that would've been Key Cycle 01159 OR UNDER (meaning it could NOT have been at Key Cycle 01162 as alleged by the Common Wealth and Mass State Police). For all we know it could've been at Key Cycle 01155 when Karen dropped John off at 34 Fair View and then once the Lexus was in police custody, there could've been other Key Cycles that we don't know about and Key Cycle 01162 could've been when the Lexus had already been at Canton PD for a few days and they could've caused that triggering event (which they're accusing Karen of doing when she supposedly hit John) and then they could've driven the Lexus 36 miles following that Key Cycle in an attempt to make it appear that it was when Karen drove it to her parents to make the Lexus Tech Stream data match on the report but they accidentally screwed up the Key Cycle count and exposed themselves. In other words, Key Cycle 01162 wasn't necessarily when the Lexus was driven onto the tow truck in Dighton, it could've been (and likely was) at a later point in time, after it had already arrived at the Canton PD Sally Port. They didn't necessarily have to actually drive the Lexus 36 miles out on the street but could've used a dynanometer or 'Dyno' which is typically used to test horsepower and goes under the tires and allows them to rotate freely without the car actually traveling anywhere (kinda like a hamster wheel for cars). So they could have added those 36 miles in the Sally Port by putting it on a Dyno and pushing the accelerator in Drive until it recorded 36 miles. Or it could've been done after they picked up the car from Dighton but before it actually arrived at the Sally Port because it did take a suspiciously long time to tow it from Dighton to Canton PD, even in the bad weather conditions. Shouldn't have take an hour and 15 minutes to go 36 miles yet somehow they towed the car at 4:12 and it didn't arrive at the Canton PD Sally Port until 5:30 (1:18 minutes) which would mean the average speed of the tow truck was approximately 28 mph as it drove (mostly on the highway) from Dighton to Canton. That's extremely slow, even for blizzard conditions (but if there was heavy traffic or some other detours, that could also explain the unusually long transportation time). But either way, all we know for certain based on the Key Cycles is that Karen Read could not have caused those triggering events in which they claim she accelerated in reverse at 24.2 mph, and hit John O'Keefe because she couldn't have had the car when that triggering event occurred, based on the Key Cycles which don't lie. But we know who does lie, Trooper Proctor and Trooper Bukhenik and probably everyone else they work with. Great video and thank you for making it easier for people to understand the Key Cycles because that was something I was screaming about since it came up during Lally's Direct Examination and I realized they don't match up to when Karen dropped John off but most people seemed to have a hard time understanding what it meant because it can sound more confusing than it actually is, especially with Trooper Paul mucking it up during Alan Jackson's cross examination. I thought Jackson would bring up the Key Cycles again later with one of their own experts to make it crystal clear for the jury and was a little surprised that he didn't but I'm sure at least one or two of the jurors understood what Jackson was saying when he crossed Trooper Paul on it. I still thought they should've pounded that fact harder because initially, the triggering event which they claimed occurred when Karen dropped off John, was very hard for me to get over or rationalize in my mind and I thought it was one of the first pieces of evidence that really suggested that Karen Read may have actually hit John, and that she had likely done so intentionally, until I realized that the Key Cycles don't match up, which then caused me to become 100% sure that Karen Read was innocent and that they were framing her. Maybe at the next trial they'll go deeper into the Key Cycles and make it crystal clear that Karen Read could not have caused that triggering event at Key Cycle 01162 (if there actually ends up being another trial). God bless.

[@milart12]

I'm sure that you are aware of the state's new theory that the testing which Paul performed were actually done exclusively during key cycle 1167 and not 1164-1167- It makes a lot of sense Trooper Paul was wrong about when his testing showed up in the Techstream data. The starting point for his theory is to assume that Trooper Paul's testing actually began at key cycle 1167. This means all the triggers that are shown on key cycles 1164 and 1165 are not from Trooper Paul's testing. From this you can count backwards and make the triggers on 1162 match up with Karen Read's drive to/from Fairview on 1/29/22. Counting backwards, we get the following: 1167: Trooper Paul's testing -- triggers showing antilock braking, sudden braking, etc. These triggers make sense in terms of what Trooper Paul described doing in his tests. 1166: Car taken off the flatbed and driven into the sallyport -- no triggers 1165: Car loaded onto flatbed in Dighton -- 1 traction control trigger 1164: Car driven by Bill Read from 1 Meadows in Canton to Dighton. Near the end of the drive, the car gets stuck in the snow for about 6 minutes, thus recording the triggers we see on key cycle 1164. Those triggers are all of the "accelerator pedal is medium or higher immediately after shifting" variety. The odometer is at 12665 for this trigger, and also on the next trigger (1165). 1163: Car driven by Karen Read at 5am from 1 Meadows to various locations in Canton, then back to 1 Meadows. -- no triggers 1162: Car driven by Karen Read from the Waterfall to 34 Fairview, then to 1 Meadows. -- Two triggers, including the one that, according to the CW, allegedly shows the moment John O'Keefe was hit.

[@ndan3746]

You really needed to be on the stand with this ... this is so much more understandable than what the jury listened too

[@OutpostMJ]

Great work, as always. Your videos help slow down and visualize movement, dynamics, and small details that in real life happened chaotically and lightning fast (including various hypotheses).

[@go5582]

hi. Great channel,topic and video.

[@dan7549]

I like your analysis and how you explain, saw the Trump 3d video too. Good job! Subscribed.

[@dustdove]

Great work. It seems A Jackson was paying attention. 😊

[@ukenagi]

I fully understand now! Thanks and great explanation

[@teedeed5390]

I have been recommending this channel when I can very interesting and I know these are not easy just to throw together great stuff are you doing work on Arcca guys testimony and put together how it’s impossible for a car to have hit John can’t wait to see what you do next ❤

[@nothanksmate]

Wow, so talented. Thanks for your insight into this trial, have really appreciated it.

[@stevekelsey411]

Your videos and explanations are fantastic. Thanks.

[@tellanpairama9245]

Great presentation

[@Orangemochafrappucino]

Excellent video thank you. If I were a lawyer I’d be calling you yesterday.

[@SummerGlimmer237]

Didn’t Jen McCabe drive Karen’s SUV back to Johns. Then they got in Kerry’s car and went to 34 Fairview

[@Set-it-to-11]

Jen McCabe drove the car back to John's, but the ignition was not necessarily turned off at Jen's, so MAY NOT have added another cycle. Still, all earlier than the 1162 cycle.

[@nicoledangredo535]

My thoughts also however that theory also proves those triggers aren’t hers

[@kfrankism]

Good job. They need you for trial demonstratives. Alan Jackson would have loved these.

[@AmyB369]

I hope to see your work in trials in the future it’s excellent! Keep making these reenactments on popular trials covered on KZbin and you’re sure to get your hard work noticed and have a lot of success ❤

[@HenAnd-DK]

Nice work ❤ tropper Poul need to see this, on noe need his is an expert.😅😂

[@BookHermit_au]

Excellent visualisation thank you

[@virginiakelly3541]

This is awesome!! Love your work!!

[@RoxyGirl1958]

I wish you great success!

[@ronkoyonagi4907]

Trooper Paul...coming to a Mall to learn how to be a Mall Cop....soon

[@The_10th_Man]

Lol. He’s getting promoted more like.

[@crystalwhitten9107]

Great job! 😊

[@Fatedcauze]

Scary how invasive these system can be, but also as in this case, if they do have date/time of those cycles, and anyone on that jury can explain it as you did to the others she will probably be found not guilty. As a side note, most if not all cars in the US have 4 positions, off/lock - accessory - on - start. It’s possible that the ecm/bcm sees acc and on as the same. Great video! This happened about 20 miles from me and I have always thought something wasn’t right.

[@wonder5487]

Excellent work!

[@donnacorliss9368]

Great job and analysis!!

[@FarmGirl-s9c]

Red to get you to testify in the next trial!

[@REB4444]

Well done. About as clear as it can be for the lay person.

[@collierlandry]

Great video!

[@iBlueClovr]

This whole trial is unbelievable

[@The_10th_Man]

So I have to ask, how do we know 1164 was Paul’s tests? And if it is, how are we explaining the 36 odometer miles between what you attribute to getting the vehicle on the tow truck and Paul’s tests?

[@Peppermint-o4r]

There is no “Brian OKeefe” in this case. The text on this video at 2:32 mentions the wrong name.

[@robynm5250]

Amazing work

[@BiancaMMM]

GREAT JOB!

[@robinsmart4397]

Karen left 34 Fairview Rd 12:30 latest. This is also the latest for 2nd Trigger Event. The 1st Trigger Event (3 point turn on Cedarcrest Rd, between Fairview and Snowflake Ln ) was 8 minutes earlier @ 12:22, which is when they say John's phone was asending/descending 3 flights at 138 Dedham St.

[@danielledemayo6438]

Good job!!!

[@theresacoffman8133]

Great work - again!

[@Tinmann_77]

I love how the prosecutions own experts destory the prosecutions case so the prosecution tries to argue both sides which just proves reasonable doubt

[@chhansen9813]

Trooper was brilliant! LOL

[@mauragallagher9001]

Very helpful!

[@kgraham5820]

I hope the jury looks at the information as easily

[@Corrinalovespink]

You help me to understand so much

[@RoxyGirl1958]

This is excellent!!!

[@sandrabecht4489]

Vielen Dank. Großartig👍👍

[@sigmapifsc]

I like your work and your style! It would be good to see you create a graphical representation of 2 things. 1, the lexus backing out of the garage, hitting the travers, but from the other angle, if you can get the actual heights of the tail light, and recreate where it hit, like where it would have made contact with the travers. One commentator suggested the tail light may have hit the rear wiper? Also, if JO was standing in the way the prosecution suggests, with his exact hight, and the hight of the tail light, it would be great to see you do a graphic animation where do they match up in relation to the marks on his arm! Let us know if you make those videos!