Comparing Animated Beauty and the Beasts (Vol.5)

[@Giuseppecoretti]

I have a suggestion for you.... different versions of Alice in wonderland( there is the son of Alice in Ever after high), different versions of the frog prince

[@rapidswelsa3306]

Ik he doesn't cover video games, but how about "Alice:madness returns/American McGee's Alice"

[@aravindrenmahenthiran6827]

Yeah but imo they did a horrible job writing Alice's son Alistair in ever after high

[@Giuseppecoretti]

@@aravindrenmahenthiran6827 why

[@aravindrenmahenthiran6827]

@@Giuseppecoretti cause he exhibits none of Alice's traits that would make him intresting he has no personality and is so boring

[@anastasiia1259]

Omg, yes! If I can help, there's a USSR Alice in wonderland and you can find it on KZbin with English subs, as well as part two Alice through the looking glass. The second one especially was my favorite cartoon growing up

[@thesadisticskitty]

You have to remember that Grimm's Fairy Tale Classics is an anime. Maria is a much easier Western name for a Japanese child to wrap their head around than Beru or Byuti would be, especially with the immediate cultural context that French and English speakers have that the name means "beautiful" being lost.

[@aceaceron1026]

I can explain the Grimms Fairy Tale Classics version. It's technically based on the Grimm Brothers' "The Summer and Winter Garden," which is where the idea of the father dying comes from. It just became "Beauty and the Beast" in foreign dubs.

[@0deadx21]

Their adaptation of _Cinderella_ was so bizarre.

[@aceaceron1026]

@@0deadx21 They literally had Cinderella's army of birds fly her to the prince. The word you're looking for is "awesome."

[@0deadx21]

@@aceaceron1026 Still bizarre. The dialogue, the story structure. It's like I was watching a Cinderella parody.

[@brandonlyon730]

Fun fact: Don Bluth originally had plans on making his own version of Beauty and the Beast, but the idea got scrapped when word got out Disney was planning on making there own version of the story and didn’t want to compete with them. It didn’t to far into production but there is some concept art on the idea.

[@meganconnell6853]

But the GoodTimes Entertainment like to create the version same as the original story.

[@kinberlykim3847]

hello kitty also had her own version of beauty and the beast in one of her cartoon shows, i don't remember much but younger me really liked it

[@2doot]

Furrytale theater

[@LucElementix]

There is also a Russian animated movie (or long episode) of Beauty and the beast made by the Russian studio Soiouzmoultfilm in 1952.

[@anastasiia1259]

I had no clue that Crimson flower was a Beauty and the beast adaptation!

[@annieandelsieofarendelle3294]

I'm surpised that Mamoru Hosoda's Belle wasn't included since that movie was incredible.

[@joaquinvaleri7022]

Hey i was going to say that!

[@tristanthompson8374]

There was a Beauty and the Beast episode in the HBO Family Classic: HAPPILY EVER AFTER: FAERY TALES FOR EVERY CHILD 👧 👦, and Jean Cocteau’s La Belle Et La Bete ✨

[@hypepixel5683]

The Beyoncé comment killed me😭

[@kingdomorange2]

I have to thank Beyoncé or who knows what will happen to my KZbin Channel!

[@iM_aSiYa]

OMG LOL

[@iM_aSiYa]

I just saw this 😂

[@KHTimeProtecter]

Beauty and the Beast is also an adaptation of the Greek story of Psyche and Eros.

[@liliecoffey8846]

Or so that's why it seemed so familiar

[@alexisdowers2030]

That's very true

[@brandonlyon730]

Not one to one but of a similar structure.

[@madisonyomans9004]

yeah, that makes a lot of sense because Eros does pretend to be well a monster that she was gonna marry because his mother is a cracky crazy waka doodle. Aphrodite can’t stand like he was pretty than her.

[@Superlad9494]

​@@madisonyomans9004 also it was noted that Eros was not only respected by some, but feared by others....since Love can make one act monsterous. Also I don't think Eros was pretending to be a monster in that story...that was something Psyche's suspicious sisters came up with.

[@PrincessLioness]

Could you include Happily Ever After the 90s HBO cartoon in your rankings or even make a separate video about it. Theirs renditions are so good.

[@kingdomorange2]

I notice a lot of people ask me for this cartoon! I would LOVE too, the problem is I can't find a way to transfer to get the video footage of the cartoon onto my computer so I always have to skip that one.

[@joaquinvaleri7022]

​@@kingdomorange2i love Belle Mamoru Hosoda version ❤ and is my favorite Belle versions

[@Goosebumps657-qe3hq]

they did make show on HBO called happily ever after fairy tales for every child and they did make episodes of beauty and the beast, Cinderella, the little mermaid, Snow White, rapunzel & sleeping beauty

[@Thee_Anime_Gyrl]

Thank you so much for doing Belle

[@sharonjancovic4144]

7:16 a bamboo princess vibe

[@cacaumassipanoficial6203]

When I read the original story as a child I thought that since the Beast has a magic mirror and also knew Beauty's name, there was a chance he purposely did that to her father because he wanted to test him and also to take Beauty out of her difficult life(her sisters are very rude and Beauty has to do everything because they are spoiled and don't want to, and the Beast gives money to Beauty's father before he leaves, to me this seemed like a test and maybe an act of mercy since the man lost a lot of possessions).

[@joaquinvaleri7022]

The name Andreas means man

[@cassedwrds]

HBO family had a series called Happily Ever After that I really enjoyed as a kid. Each episode retold a classic fairy tale but would incorporate different cultures and modernize aspects. I liked comparing them to the Disney counterparts growing up and they could be fun to analyze for this series!

[@Galistarwater]

Disney's Beauty and the Beast remains my most favorite animated film from their lineup. Another great video. Can you do one for Hans Christian Anderson's The Snow Queen in the future? If love to hear your intake on that old Russian animated movie.😊

[@ivanacurna6577]

😢Awww you forgot add Studio Chizu's Belle. That's a shame. I highly recommend it, it has elements of Disney Beauty and the Beast but futuristic high tech VR take on. Trust me it's amazing.

[@rapidswelsa3306]

Belle,the beast and the freckled princess!! I was about to comment this! ❤

[@jamiesdolliverse]

I love this series so much! Can't wait to hear about every single disney princess! The Frog Prince would be interesting cuz you can talk about Tiana and Fiona's mum queen Lilian

[@Superlad9494]

About the one version of Belle having a proper name. In the original story it's mentioned Belle is a nickname...she has a different one, it only became Belle officially overtime because she prefers going by her nickname, but the first actual proper name usage is in 1991...if that rings anything for you.

[@Giuseppecoretti]

Or also comparing different versions of Swan Lake... there is Duchess swan in ever after high which the daughter of the Swan queen, which i don t know if is odile or odette because she pretends to steal other happily ever afters to other people because her story ends tragically

[@kingdomorange2]

She’s gonna be next week!

[@Giuseppecoretti]

@@kingdomorange2 wow! Great!

[@alexisdowers2030]

I got to agree with you on the Grimm's classic fairy tales, they are not my favorite but they are not half bad. They also have two versions of Snow White, the classic one and then a second one known as Snow White and Rose Red. I have no idea why though

[@eleonorepb4565]

Snow White and Snow White and Rose Red are actually unrelated, in German the two Snow White actually have different names

[@0deadx21]

@@eleonorepb4565 One of them is Snow White and the other Snow-White. In my language they have different names. Snow White's name for example comes from the adjective "snowy", and not "snow" or "white".

[@joshuafortune4420]

You have to do Alice, Tinker Bell, and The Frog Prince next

[@Bird-q7o]

10:27 Beauty has another grandson. His name’s Shawn Beast and I think he is taking the place as Beauty and Travis is the Beast

[@SapphireBlaze-i2h]

I think He is Going to Make a video about Jasmine because He did Snow white Cinderella Aurora IDK Why he did Rapunzel So early Since she's After Tiana Ariel and Belle So I think He is going to do Jasmine and after that Pocahontas But Pocahontas is So Underrated So it's Going to be Hard Finding Animated Versions Of her

[@Lyokogirl789]

I am disappointed we don’t see much footage of Travis, Coach Beast and even Shawn from Regal Academy. Travis didn’t even appear on the video thumbnail like Hawk for the Snow White video. 😔

[@pietracallins9416]

Another amazing video! I really enjoy seeing your opinion on the various versions of the characters. I was just a little sad that I didn't see your opinion of Travis, he's my favorite character from Regal Academy. Sorry for any grammar mistakes, English is not my first language and I had to use the translator

[@surtoinutildecriatividade909]

Hello! As a person who is almost hyperfixated in this fairytale, I was really excited expecting the Beauty and The Beast video. Despite liking the Disney version I would say the bests adaptations of BATB I've ever see are the Happily Ever After series where the story takes place in what it seems to be somewhere in Africa. The main couple is adorable. Beauty has a nice caring family despite the situation, no envious siblings, the beast is amazing and sarcastic and really show a worthy inner personality which is the purpose of the story right? Its one of the best versions I highly recomend it.

[@afrolens9532]

You should watch Happily Ever After: Fairy Tales for Every Chile Made by the same animators that made Proud Family and BeBe’s Kids. They center around the classic fairy tales with people of color as the focus. The Beauty and the Beast one is my favorite one

[@meganconnell6853]

7:50: I prefer the nice 1992 GoodTimes Entertainment Version of "Beauty and the Beast", it's better than the horrible 1991 Disney Version of "Beauty and the Beast", I'm sorry, it's my preference and my opinion anyway and I'll really mean it.

[@TshepiSehurutsi-hm8hf]

I honestly love how much work and effort is put into these videos and for that I say THANK YOU!!!!!!!!🥰😘😘😘

[@angelagokool9514]

Phelous and the Movies had also reviewed some of the straight-to-video movies on this list, such as the Burbank Animation version of the story, and Good Times Animation. His reviews of straight-to video movies are pretty negative, but also hilarious!

[@natt_tenshi2707]

One version I was hoping to see on here was A Tale of the Crimson Flower. It’s a really beautiful Russian animation that funnily enough has Tim Curry playing the Beast in the English dub. It’s one of my favourite versions and I’d like to think their version of Beauty, Anastasia is a little more interesting then some of the Beauties on this list, but that could just be me being biased. Glad to see all these other versions in the video tho. I had a bit of an obsession with different animated versions of Beauty and the Beast as a kid and you not only mentioned most of them but also some ones I never knew about.

[@firerose4495]

I remember watching the dub version back in 2018.

[@ThePipofDespair]

I'm in a college production of Beauty and the Beast rn! Great timing!

[@DirtHutCaver]

@7:57 I had some of those on DVD when I was a kid, but I didn't keep them when I moved. I think my favorite was their version of The Little Princess because instead of her dad dying, like in the og story, he lives. :) I also had their version of Pocahontas, The Little Mermaid, Snow White, and... Hm, that might've been all in that dvd set. They were cute movies, I thought. I liked their version of Pocahontas better than Disney's. Cinderella might have been in the dvd set, but I don't remember entirely. It's been over a decade (ack!) so my memory is kinda foggy. But, yeah... Idk, I liked most of their adaptations, the ones I saw anyhow, better than Disney's. 😅

[@bea2323]

12:05 OmGG I completly forgot that show existed, Im on such a nostalgia trip rn

[@1appletree]

Honestly Ever After High is the best written story, maybe not because of Rosabella, though she would be at least number 2 for me, but their version of the Beast is number 1 the most likeable.

[@kokoro7996]

Other Beauties I would like to mention are Blake from RWBY and Suzu from the anime film Belle.

[@Giuseppecoretti]

there is another Japanese version of beauty and the beast in the animated series called Sekai Meisaku dowa shirizu which ran between 1984 and 1987

[@artewerty]

Beauty and the beast ❤

[@darladimple8437]

can you compare all teh Cinderellas next

[@tianajones909]

Next you should do the different versions of the nutcracker or swan lake

[@VoyinThePanda]

Balle by Disney i grow with her shes my favourite sense Balle reminds of my sister sense my sister word a gold dress on her sweet eighthing 18

[@Magicalgirl982]

Can you please do Aladdin? It’s my favorite movie and it has an interesting story. ❤ Also I love this fairytale series because it gives me new fairytale movie/series’s for me to watch. Thank you 😊

[@joaquinvaleri7022]

You forgot Belle by Mamoru Hosoda

[@DefneBaggio]

The fourth time Disney won in one of these, first Cinderella, then Rapunzel, then Ariel and now Belle

[@lenastorm6280]

Could you please do different versions of Little Red Riding Hood? That's my favourite fairy tale!

[@kingdomorange2]

She’s coming soon! I’m working on her right now!

[@lenastorm6280]

@@kingdomorange2 Awesome! Thanks.

[@ivanacurna6577]

@@kingdomorange2 Have you also thinking making one about Goldilocks and three Bears? I mean there's a lot of version of Goldilocks to analyze like Simsala Grimm, Burbank, Unstable Fables, the antagonistic Goldilocks from Disney XD 7D, Goldie from Disney Junior Goldie and Bear, Blondie Lockes from Ever After High and Goldie from Puss in Boots the Last Wish. That's all Goldilocks' I could think of but what do you think?

[@pyw3823]

I think the reason that in Ever after High sleeping beauty and Beauty and the beast are sisters is the same reason as to why raven and apple aren't step mother step daughter, it's because there has been so many generations so aspects of the story has been lost. So it makes sense that eventually the position as the next sleeping beauty and Beauty and the beast through royal marriages would end up in one royal family thus making briar and rosabella cousins.

[@viviennemorgan7217]

apple and raven aren't step daughter and stepmother, they're more like they don't know anything about what their mothers did.

[@pyw3823]

@@viviennemorgan7217 I literally never said they were. Like my comment was saying that Apple and raven as step family because that aspect of the story has been lost over the generations..

[@viviennemorgan7217]

@@pyw3823 oh i didn't notice that and i don't ever know that apple and raven are a part of a stepfamily

[@pyw3823]

@@viviennemorgan7217 no there not, my mistake I worded it weird, basically in the og story, they are step family as we all know. However in the EAH they aren't and that's due to generations of the story taking place and eventually them being step family would be basically impossible

[@viviennemorgan7217]

@@pyw3823 it's ok and it's kinda weird that the kids of both sleeping beauty and beauty and the beast are cousins due to the fathers being brothers.

[@TheBatIsRad6435]

What happened to your Snowwhite and sleeping beauty videos

[@kingdomorange2]

Being redone. Snow White will be up on Monday!

[@EduPuffs]

Different versions of Mulan?

[@OpticalSorcerer]

I feel like Disney's Belle definitely set the standard for other versions of the character afterwards. And it's wild to me that so many people forget that she's a nerd just because she's beautiful.

[@meganconnell6853]

Well, I prefer the name Beauty not Belle, so I prefer GoodTimes Entertainment's Beauty and I like it.

[@0deadx21]

@@meganconnell6853 GoodTimes Entertainment's Beauty is quite pleasant to watch. Golden Films's on the other hand, I don't even know anything about her.

[@meganconnell6853]

That's what I prefer the name Beauty not Belle, I do really have know, but you know it what I said that is my preference and my opinion, I prefer the GoodTimes Entertainment Version of "Beauty and the Beast" with the name Beauty in it, I like it this time and I mean it.

[@nightdragon5quest87]

A suggestion, Hello Kitty Furrytail Theater. They do many fairytales

[@viviennemorgan7217]

he doesn't do plays.

[@zitavarga9575]

Why did some of your videos got deleted?? 😢 I wanted to watch the comparing Sleeping Beauty one but I can’t find it anywhere and I don’t know what happened.

[@thegayghost872]

Disney is unfortunately probably going to top a lot of these lists

[@0deadx21]

My favorite animated Cinderella is the one from Jetlag. The Disney animated movie suffers from the lack of backstory, lack of character development, and that half the film is focused on the animals. If they were suppose to be used for whatever the moral is, the execution was quite poor.

[@eleonorepb4565]

@@0deadx21 But Disney! Cinderella character was devlopped in the second sequel

[@0deadx21]

@@eleonorepb4565 Those don't count. And the Cinderella from the sequels feels like a different character than the one from the first film. All of a sudden her dialogue isn't bland, and her personality increased significantly. The first film and the second sequel don't go very well together.

[@magicshop4002]

posted 9 minutes ago in my time! early once again I'm gonna edit this with my thoughts edit: okay, after seeing all of them.. my favorite remains Rosabella from EAH. 2nd is disney, although that movie was kinda boring to me as a child i fear..

[@poisonedapples6327]

it would help if you looked at happily-ever-after versions of all the princesses (HBO max)

[@Loona9Wolf]

Can you do the ugly duckling next? ( Make sure to include the grandson of the ugly duckling from regal academy )

[@maytalacedo20]

the golden films version of beauty and the beast was my guilty pleasure mainly how overdramatic beast is about when he said he can't live without her it's corny but romantic in a way you wld see in a soap opera😂

[@SarahWestCrazyTaxiQueen]

I love all incarnations for redeeming values

[@Mooms]

Golden Films and Goodtimes Entertainment are separate companies, Goodtimes had the rights to distribute Golden Films’s library

[@nightinggale5881]

Try HBO's happily ever after. I actually used to watch this series because of how they changed the ethnicity of the characters and stories

[@0deadx21]

Ah, the fairy tale Phelous can't review enough. 7:52 Unlike _Snow White, Cinderella_ and Sleeping Beauty *Jetlag* did not make a _BatB_ movie, but they did make _Little Red Riding Hood_ and _Alice in Wonderland_ for example, oh and that _Hunchback of Notre Dame_ movie too. 11:17 Her name is *IRWINA* The previous sister's name is *ROWENA*

[@kingdomorange2]

OMFG IRWINA IS AN EVEN WORSE NAME

[@0deadx21]

​@@kingdomorange2 With the other sister named Jaqueline, it's a mystery why the other is named Irwina. They could have gone with the likes of Beatrice, Charlotte, Sophia, Andrea, Bernadette instead. At least Rowena sounds decent.

[@WCA_FanParody]

No 'Belle'? The Studio Chizu one from 2021?

[@NightoftheLivingcookies10]

Have you ever heard of the old animated TV show “Happily Ever After Fairy Tales For Every Child?” That also told different iterations of Fairy Tales but placed them in different cultures! (Spanish Cinderella, Thumbelina in the Amazon, Native American Snow White, Chinese Little Mermaid, Middle Eastern Beauty and the Beast) It was one of my favorites as a kid!

[@daisyswift6573]

Wait, I'm confused. Your title says ranking Beauty and the Beasts, but in the video you rank only Belle??? not the actual show and such

[@MagdaNowak0511]

I love the Beauty from the Simsala Grimm, she is the most lovely girl with her look

[@gyrosik8851]

10:12 from what I remember this story is meant to be an adaptation of different similar story

[@eleonorepb4565]

We also have Tale of the Crimson Flower

[@DanielAlfonzoVillalobosAlfonzo]

Have you thought about ranking up the Beast? It would be really cool if you do.

[@LusiaEyre]

Beauty and the Beast by Bevanfield . Seriously, a must see!

[@ElliottEntertainmentChannel]

What about Beauty and the Beet?

[@anikinlopena8920]

so in the eah realm sleeping beauty and beauty’s princes/husbands are the siblings not the two princesses. from the siblings after the one of them and “briar rose” the sleeping beauty story happens which births briar beauty, the brother is left wealthy but alone growing bitter and selfish leading him to be cursed into a beast by an enchanted fairy and that’s how beauty and beast happens which then births rosabella and makes them cousins.

[@MrSumme345]

10:20 i used to love that show

[@muppetsretrofan8873]

I've seen the Disney one but I've been wanting to watch the other adaptions. Could you do a video on the MANY animated adaptions of Treasure Island? The Golden Films version is the worst IMO. The Mel O Toons version has cute designs but goes by too quickly. I love Treasure Planet but I also want to see other animated adaptions of Treasure Island get their due.

[@ivanacurna6577]

Wait a minute. Doesn't Fiona technically count as beauty in Beauty and The Beast trope in Shrek franchise?🤨

[@eleonorepb4565]

@@ivanacurna6577 Wouldn't technically Shrek being the Beauty of the story. He is a commoner and is the one to enter her castle

[@ivanacurna6577]

@@eleonorepb4565 he's technically the beast, and Fiona is the beauty but in this case she cursed. You should check DF2364 Beauties and Beasts podcast episode about the movie, it better explains it than I😅

[@MichalaJohnson-zv5pp]

Let’s save Mario and Sonic at the Paris Olympic Games

[@WarriorMondenkind]

So Gaston and the stealing of the ring subplot was invented by Jean Cocteau in Le Belle et la Bete

[@eleonorepb4565]

Honestly it's my favorite adaptation

[@WarriorMondenkind]

@@eleonorepb4565 Shelly Duval's Fairtale Theater version is an homage to that version if you want a version in color and English

[@norskicola7097]

I don't know if you're aware of this and intentionally lefted it out, but there was a movie released around 2022 called belle. That is heavily inspired by beauty and the beast.

[@0deadx21]

There's a difference between an inspiration and an adaptation. 2022's _Belle_ is not a _BatB_ adaptation.

[@eleonorepb4565]

@@0deadx21 Then at that point we could say that Tangle don't count as a Rapunzel adaptation, we could say that it's only inspired by the tale

[@0deadx21]

@@eleonorepb4565 No, _Tangled_ is a "Rapunzel" adaptation. It's not a parody, satire, or set in a different genre. It's not a similar case like _Ella Enchanted_ and _Ever After_ which truly are not "Cinderella" adaptations, but movies inspired the fairy tale or are based on something inspired by the fairy tale. _Ella Enchanted_ was from a series of books parodying fairy tales, and _Ever After_ is by no means a fairy tale movie.

[@kairahczareinesimbulan467]

Thank you

[@0deadx21]

8:48 14:15 If you see this animation style, it's *Golden Films* and not GoodTimes Entertainment. 8:00 15:36 Looking at this, you can immediately tell that's not Golden Films.

[@aliciahuang6329]

There is one thing I don't get about regal academy they call tacos, burritos. Question is the creator of the show food culture blind. Everybody knows the difference between a taco or burrito. Or they don't have a actual burrito model or just say taco instead of calling a taco a burrito.

[@cake_pop7853]

For me, the good times BaTB was difficult to watch because the Beast just screamed at Beauty for every little thing

[@cake_pop7853]

@@0deadx21 No? I'm specifically talking about the Good Times Beauty and the Beast

[@2doot]

I'm a simple man, I see Once Upon a Zombie (my beloved, gone too soon...) and I click Edit: my disappointment is immeasurable, gurl why include the OOAZ version of it on the thumbnail if you're not even gonna talk about tf? 😭

[@MayraHernandez-dp3tn]

Forgot HBO Happily Ever After-Beauty and Beast

[@NenadlPopovic]

Ruby Spears & Golden Films animations ARE WAAAAAAY more accurate to original fairytale than Disney!

[@meganconnell6853]

Well, GoodTimes Entertainment Version is better than the Disney one, it is replacing the horrible 1991 Disney Version of "Beauty and the Beast" to the nice 1992 GoodTimes Entertainment Version of "Beauty and the Beast" that I'm interesting of it, I prefer it, it's my best favourite Version anyway, I like it, it's my preference and my opinion anyway and I mean it.

[@Blossom44100]

I like Belle best

[@emnem1319]

What happened to the snow white and cinderella comparison videos?

[@alitaybi4251]

Where is snow white and cinderella's videos bro? 😢😢🎉

[@kingdomorange2]

I’ve redoing and reuploading them!

[@ccmastergad2892]

the scarlet flower 1952 by soyuzmultfilm

[@hassanhosney]

Would you reupload and update your video of Rapunzel, as well?

[@kingdomorange2]

Yes!

[@ZaireErnest]

Ever after high

[@brandonlyon730]

Is it wrong I know a good chunk of these from watching a lot of Phelous.

[@milesdeluna799]

Flash fact: Ever After High Rosabella is 100%, Disney Princess Belle is 95% Regal academy Travis Beast 70%

[@SummerHelton]

Beauty from the wolf amoung us

[@171QA]

Great video.

[@kingdomorange2]

Thanks!

[@ohw5306]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@Gothqueen29]

I love your channel

[@kingdomorange2]

Thank u!

[@loftyprempeh8863]

Proud to say 3rd

[@anastasiia1259]

Nooo where did the SnowWhite video go :((

[@kingdomorange2]

I'm working on a new and much better version!

[@KristenHaggerty-r5k]

Tell as old as time

[@iM_aSiYa]

Oh no! U didn’t thank Beyoncé 😮