Smith & Wesson Shield 2.0 vs Glock 43X - If I Could Only Have One...

Thanks for watching! Be sure to leave a comment and a thumbs up if you like the video. If you like what you see, consider subscribing and there’s more content on the way.
Music by Onlap.

[@2Atreehugger]

KS. Awesome video. Very informative and professional, your production is tops!. . Thanks for sticking with guns and no ranting. Again I am going to snivel a bit. I’m in california and can’t have the glock. I do have the non 2.0 shield and love it. I did some trigger clean up by minor polishing some rough surfaces..... keep up the good work

[@KSGunGuy01]

Thank you Jesse! Much appreciated brother. It’s tough to beat the Shield and I bet the polishing really dials it in. Cheers as always!

[@elitecorsair]

Why can’t you have the Glock in CA? I thought they allowed up to a 10 rd magazine.

[@dickgherkinstien2016]

@@elitecorsair California has a pistol roster and if the pistol doesn't meet the safety requirements or your not willing to pay to even have it submitted then you can't sell them in California. Gen 3 Glocks are on the roster but not gen 4 or 5. Glock said they will keep making gen 3 Glocks for California residents though

[@jeremiahmendoza387]

California is stupid.

[@nandoGdog]

I would build the SS80 then!

[@fireguy_75]

LOVING my 43X right now. Yeah I wish the grip was a little shorter but I'll tell ya, being able to get that 3rd finger on the grip makes a big difference to me.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Right on Ian! I 100% agree about getting a full grip on the 43X. Makes a huge difference. Thank you and cheers!

[@JoannaJedrzejczyksForehead]

The 43 has a shorter grip...

[@mikethomas4628]

Bought my 43x today and a bad ass spider concealment holster and magazine holder all in 1 👍

[@williamlackey123]

Ian Moniz I also love my 43x

[@Stormingsmoke]

antidzomtribute Have you handled the 43x? After doing so, my shield stays in the safe more days than not. Either way these guns are top tier for what they’re designed to do.

[@davidrpriest]

The best thing about this comparison is there is no bad choice.

[@CptWhit3y]

One company has the reputation of hardly ever malfunctioning....one does not.

[@daboyzay__]

@@CptWhit3y which one

[@CptWhit3y]

@@daboyzay__ Most people consider Glock to be the one of most reliable pistols on the market. If not the most reliable.

[@Domepeezy]

@@CptWhit3y s&w is just as reliable what are u talking about

[@CptWhit3y]

@@Domepeezy exactly what I said. Ask around and do your research.

[@jmunyard]

You are so lucky in The US to be able to CCW. Happy New Year all the best from Australia 🇦🇺

[@ChrisB10]

No luck involved. Bunch of badass mother fuckers chose to be free 225 years ago and were willing to fight and die for it. Cheers

[@zachmarshall236]

G43X is on top. Bought it first week it came out, love it.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Right on! Thank you and cheers!

[@ataz0th218]

I've owned the Shield 2.0 and currently own the 43X. Sold the Shield only because the Glock won me over with the capacity.

[@fdj4901]

The Shield plus has 10 + 1..13 + 1 and 15 + 1 capacity without compromising the grip...more capacity than the 43x

[@jayl8415]

The 43x has aftermarket 15 round flush fit mags out

[@julioa8321]

I have 3 of them along with the Shield Arms mag release. These mags are a game changer.

[@rick2112rkrk]

It's a good idea to switch to an aftermarket aluminum mag catch to avoid wear

[@Bill-vr3rm]

@E Flo use a layer or two of painters tape and a heat gun and it will fix that. There are vids on youtube to show you.

[@julioa8321]

I went with the 43x and the new Shield Arms S15 (15 rounds flush fit) for the glock. These mags are a game changer.

[@JahsonnM313]

I saw online an 19 round mag for the 43x. Not suitable for concealed carry but with the Extended mag there goes the Glock 19😁

[@jonmiller6320]

I was torn on the 19 but with that mag like u said...totally changes everything

[@coollibra3644]

@@JahsonnM313 you can add extensions. This will give you 20 rounds

[@julioa8321]

@@josemary2106 I shot my coworkers m&p shield this last Monday. It's definitely a better shooter than the glock. The grip angle, the trigger, the sights, and the grip texture are all better than the glock 43x/48. But I realized I will most likely never need a CCW gun for shooting at 35 yard steel targets (which we were that day). I will be needing my CCW for 3-7 yards which the glock does great at. I will take the 15+1 capacity of the glock over the better shootablility of the m&p.

[@QueenOfTopicsTv]

Me too I love it

[@Pandamonium626]

The Shield is significantly cheaper, comes with good metal sights, has flexible capacity for deep concealment up to 10+1 with aftermarket extensions, better grip texture, better ergonomics, great aftermarket support, and great reliability. To me this isn't even really a competition. Shield all the way.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Well said! It’s a great gun indeed. Thank you and cheers!

[@thaddonalson6792]

I just picked up the 43x for $439. It feels really good. I’ve only had it to the range once. I’m still preferring my M&P Shield, but I hope with more range time, the Glock will be my go to gun. Especially with the availability of the Shield Arms S15 magazines.

[@KeanonGilliamSlang369]

Nice comparison, thought I'm partial to the Glock, I've heard nothing but good things about the M&P Shield

[@KSGunGuy01]

Thank you Keanon! Both are indeed excellent brother. Cheers!

[@harusha9020]

KSGunGuy both are incredible firearms

[@midwest1228]

Another great video. The Shield has been my edc for quite a while now and I tend to prefer the ergo's of the m&p series over the Glocks. However, the 43x does interest me for it's slightly larger capacity. The original 43 just felt like a afterthought from Glock to me. Think this firearm, along with the 48 fit a nice "between" size for capacity and comfort.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Thank you very much! I agree that the 43X and 48 are great options from Glock. That said, it’s tough to beat the Shield. Cheers!

[@michaelpersaud4587]

Shield arms makes a 15 round mag for the 43x and 48. Makes the Decision a bit more easy for me. I will take the 43x. Nothing wrong with the smith and Wesson.

[@cstice5]

Got mine with night sights brand new with three 10 round mags and speed loader black on black for $350 $395 out the door could not be happier!!!!! Location Glenburnie Maryland. 06-07-2020

[@Wrecked01]

I was doing this exact comparison at the gun shop today. Both are great guns. I went with the G43x just because it felt better in my hand. No other reason.

[@positivereactions4044]

Just got the 43x with the black slide from factory, that’s how they make them now, have the shield also , I like the feel and shoot ability of the Glock , the 15 round mag is a no brained for the ultimate appendix edc

[@kmsharley75]

CZ P10c 😎 Out of these two I'd take the Shield all day...good stuff as always!

[@KSGunGuy01]

Right on! Thank you and cheers!

[@leaddispenser9]

I put my hands on the glock 48 a few days ago. And I gotta say I want that for summer.. that slim grip feels sooo much better than even my 19

[@KSGunGuy01]

Right on! Thank you and cheers!

[@goodegreg5]

What's up buddy I agree with everything you said but at the end of the day I can't pick the M&P the Glock just feels and shoots better crazy thing is I'm definitely not a Glock fanboy I'm a Ruger fanboy but the 43 x want me over

[@rickgarcia8481]

I felt exactly the same way... I don't even own a glock... But a family member brought a 43x over, and it felt perfect in my larger hands... Got to get one now

[@goodegreg5]

@Anton Chigurh no I don't own a p series but I will one day I love the way they look and shoot I just love Ruger

[@goodegreg5]

@Anton Chigurh yeah I feel you bro right now I'm stuck on the SR series I love that series such a soft shooter the SR9 is a tack driver

[@goodegreg5]

@Anton Chigurh Do you like it?

[@goodegreg5]

@Anton Chigurh yeah that's cool I also love my 43x I heard a lot of people say that about the print but honestly I really don't care about the print I have no idea why I just don't

[@markkosa1]

Shield comes in 40 and I have thousands of rounds for that...

[@klintheadlee9587]

Mark Kerns must be a pa

[@johnpierce4778]

Comes in 9mm, .40s&w, .45acp

[@JayB-bq7hh]

Why does everybody change the trigger ?? Train more and you don't need a 2.5 lb trigger, plus they are very unsafe in the end !! Sure they are cool looking and smooth but really not needed....................just saying !! If your a sports shooter fine, but a everyday person , doesn't need it !!!

[@rocdaneweracap]

Thank you. I've been telling people this

[@82luft49]

I fully agree, and also one very important point to think about. In a defense shooting, A jury will most likely be inclined to consider an enhanced trigger (aka race trigger) putting you in a disagreeable position as a "cowboy" looking for a human target.

[@rocdaneweracap]

The only thing I would change on my guns is the sites or recoil spring and a grip if needed.

[@JayB-bq7hh]

@@rocdaneweracap Yeah sights & grips if needed but I never do !! Overcome and adapt to what you got !!! Buy more mags and ammo is my idea !!! LOL

[@rocdaneweracap]

@@JayB-bq7hh I know I end up buying more mags and ammo anyway lol

[@arrow_head24]

Life’s good when your only problems are choosing the right concealed gun and Chick-fil-A or Popeyes spicy chicken sandwich.

[@MikeM4729]

I love Glock and own many but I can’t get past that ugly slide.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Totally understood! Thank you and cheers!

[@sweetcostarica]

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I love the color as it is non-tactical looking and to me, seems more fitting for a civilian CCW weapon.

[@rickyhogan2749]

I just don't care for the hideous slide, just my opinion.

[@sweetcostarica]

@@rickyhogan2749 Being concerned about the color of a firearm or how the trigger pull *"feels"* for example, is what beta males do. Color trigger feel press checking serrations grip texture etc.These are all beta wants & needs. Since almost ALL modern firearms are more accurate than the shooter...*Alpha males* care about one major thing: *is this gun reliable,* period. Alpha males don't think about or even care about what color a firearm is unless it is a real tactical issue. Stay frosty.

[@sweetcostarica]

@@brothermathisgoon You care about the color of a pistol & I'm the Soy Boy, *Marcell?!?* Thank you for proving my point. You're funny, I like you. Happy Flay Day (today) & upcoming Alpha Male Day aka, *Father's Day.* Note: *Military Service Records matters not* - I knew a couple of beta males in the service so I can verify they are everywhere. *Nice try* but everyone knows this and the above is true about betas.

[@funkyfresh2404]

Good review but too many mods to these guns for a true comparison for me.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Personally, I think it was a spot on comparison and the mods are acknowledged in the vid. Thank you and cheers Fresh!

[@TheMattTrakker]

I agree. If you are gonna put mods on a gun, do a break down of cost before, cost after.

[@JimmyLeeJr]

I don't think you can compare guns if there are mods. Stock vs Stock

[@shotgunscott]

I'm glad that you compared them with the same modifications that owners are likely to do. With the Shield starting off about $100 less, even after the mods, it will still be less to the modified Glock. I hate the looks and feel of Glocks, but I'll admit that they shoot very well. I shot my friend's at the range, and I was impressed how accurate it was. Usually it takes me a few more rounds to get a new firearm dialed in. That said, I prefer the M&P overall.

[@JahsonnM313]

Good point!

[@reecebain7904]

I agree with you. I had a Glock 43 (not X) and did not like it at all. I sold it and got the Shield 2.0 and I absolutely LOVE it! it's my EDC. I won't go back to Glock.

[@rickyhogan2749]

Both are Great Firearms, I would like to have both, but couldn't do that. I chose the one with the Great Lifetime Warranty and The Great Customer Service, The Shield. Thank you for the good and very helpful uploads, they are always appreciated.

[@KSGunGuy01]

The Shield is a great gun for sure! Thank you and cheers!

[@keithgregory7937]

I really do not like the S&W 2,0 grip i always find my self getting a Talon Grip for mine because when you carry it concealed it rubs up against your skin not to comfortable and can cause a rash the Glock 43X grip is just right if i had to choose one it would be The 43X.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Very fair points Keith! I agree that the grip on the Shield can be a bit abussive. Thank you and cheers brother!

[@mikegriego3671]

There are holsters you can get that covers your body from the gun with a piece of plastic while inside the waistband. Or just wear an undershirt.

[@brendaandersen4241]

I'm a new gun owner and I really enjoy your videos. Very informative. A bit difficult for me to follow everything because I'm just learning. But I was impressed, for sure! Keep up the good work.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Thank you very much! Welcome to the world of guns and cheers!

[@sandymitchell8182]

I definitely agree!,hard to beat any 2.0 out of the box especially the prices

[@jalan6473]

Talon Grips and Shield S15 15-shot magazines....the Glock jumps ahead IMO....

[@gilbertoesquivel9668]

If the be all win all is all about capacity then let us all edc G19's everyday...but EDC , practically speaking, is a lot more than that... There IS such a thing as diminishing returns on this topic...If you carry too bulky of a gun or too many rounds, then your rig becomes heavy, chunky, and uncomfortable. If you lengthen the grip too much then, it becomes less concealable...Then there is COST....Here is where the Shield 9 truly shines in that it always has served as a MADE IN THE USA ...ALWAYS CARRY GUN that answers the frequent asked question "which is the best gun to carry?" Clearly. S&W Shields' answer: "The one you can afford, take with you, and can hit with reliably..." More folks have trusted the Old EDC workhorse Shield to get this done than any other sub compact out there...

[@kauboy9816]

I have the 1st gen Shield. It's a great gun in it's own right, and you did the 2.0 justice in this vid. The thing that made me look at the 43x was the wider and slightly more boxy grip, as well as capacity. I finally made the call to buy a 43x and took the chance to upgrade to the night sights. You're right, the stock ones are junk. Holding this gun, it has the feel I've always wanted. My pinky stays on, it fills the palm but not too much, and Shield Arms is releasing a flush fit 15 round magazine in the next month or two. A gun that feels better in my hand and DOUBLES the capacity of my Shield? Yeah, I'll keep the ol' S&W as a bug or deep conceal, but the 43x is my new EDC. Still a good vid, even and balanced comparison. Thanks!

[@KSGunGuy01]

Very well put and I feel the same way! Interested to see the 15 round mags. Thank you and cheers!

[@cwsmith17]

2.0-->Grip. Handling. Sights. American company. Steel sear housing and chassis. Less felt recoil. Great customer service and Lifetime Warranty. Magguts Zee spring make it a 10 or 11 round gun. If desired, the after market Apex trigger is superior and stock trigger is better than stock 43X.

[@KSGunGuy01]

They do make great guns for sure! Thank you and cheers!

[@Sanctified_Leather]

Nice Review and Video KS . There both Great guns , can't go wrong with either one ... Have a Great and Blessed Weekend KS. 👍👋

[@KSGunGuy01]

Thank you Steven! Well said brother. Both are excellent. Cheers and have a great weekend as well!

[@bdm1000]

The Shield that guards the realms of men.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Indeed! Thank you and cheers!

[@gryphonz3]

Nice review. I really believe that the S&W 2.0 line of pistols are true "Glock Killers", not the CZ P-10 series. I have been doing a lot of soul searching and side-by-side shooting of the P-10C, G19/23/32 and 2.0 9mm/.40/.357 and am really fond of the 2.0 feel and shootability. The only exception to that, for me, is the G21.4. I think the Glock 21 out performs the 2.0 in .45 due to the dual recoil spring and 3 more rounds. In the end, for me, my EDC is the 2.0 in 9mm and my HD guns are the G21.4 and the 2.0 in .40 S&W. My Summer EDC will most likely be the Walther PPS M2 with the 8-rd mag due to the thinner profile.

[@KSGunGuy01]

I agree that the 2.0 line is fantastic. They are durable, reliable, and frankly look good. The PPS M2 is also very worthy. Thank you and cheers!

[@chuckdriver7741]

gryphonz3 - there is no such thing as a “Glock killer”. There is no such thing as Bigfoot either. Reality trumps fantasy. 🇺🇸🗽🦅🇦🇹

[@roweshowboxing]

Nothing is a Glock killer. Stop

[@bobbykelly2333]

I found the 43X for $380 a few months back and jumped on that It became my EDC over the 1st gen and performance center Shield... I absolutely love it. Never tried the 2.0 so I don't know... I did however trade in my 1st gen on a Shield plus and have been switching out between the Glock and Shield plus and think the Shield plus is vastly superior to the original and performance center...

[@Mike-gi1dk]

That's a great price. Was it used?

[@JacksonWalter735]

Between the Shield Plus and the Glock 43X, which one do you like better? I can't decide between the 43X MOS with the SA mags or the Shield Plus (the upgraded sights model). Currently the 43X MOS is slightly cheaper than the standard Shield Plus in my area, but once you factor in the SA mags and button release it comes out to the same price as the Shield Plus with the high vis sights.

[@nickypeeps93]

@@JacksonWalter735 even with just the 10 round mags I’d go 43x mos. I just picked one up and it’s great to have the option for the red dot straight from the factory.

[@kevinfitzsimmons1258]

I got a m2.0 with night sights and 3 mags for 400 and as much as I absolutely love my roommates 43x that he just picked up, the Shield is a better carry package FOR ME. 400 w/ metal ns vs 450 w/ square plastic sights lol. I've seen 250 for 1.0 and 330 for 2.0

[@marclarrea7330]

I just got Cabela's to price-match a 2.0 for $297 OTD. Great deal. I then promptly spent that savings on the Apex haha

[@RightFootForward11]

I just picked up a 43x, it was used for a week by a guy who buys from the gun store and returns it for a huge loss almost immediately (the store tries to talk him out of it each time, lol). The slide was really clean, and it has AmeriGlo night sights already installed. 450 OTD

[@RightFootForward11]

I just picked up a 43x, it was used for a week by a guy who buys from the gun store and returns it for a huge loss almost immediately (the store tries to talk him out of it each time, lol). The slide was really clean, and it has AmeriGlo night sights already installed. 450 OTD

[@keptitreal1007]

@@RightFootForward11 where's this gun shop at?

[@Risteard156]

The S&W are great gun's but parts are hard to find Glock is much better all the parts you need on the internet 👍

[@a.d.c7941]

I have to go with the 43X with no thought process to it at all. Longer grip for big hands and better control over recoil because of the grip. I have heard that changing the trigger can mess with the guns function. Is this true?

[@OmarGonzalez-gx1ks]

43x baby

[@RIPPER334]

I was glad Glock didn't ruff up the grip on the 43x and 48. The last thing I want is 80 grit sand paper rubbing against the inside of my waist all day. For the same reason, I kept my shield 1.0 instead of replacing it with the newer frame design. Also hated the "silver" slide Glock brought to market on the X and 48... And as soon as I saw the traditional finish, I traded. It basically cost me 100 bucks to upgrade to a new gun, without the millennial finish.

[@IamGroot786]

Same. I didn't many differences worth the upgrade to the 2.0 so I kept my 1st Gen too. It's one of those pistols I might never let go of, just like the PPS M2. Love them and they come back to my EDC rotation.

[@emansfvera]

Both great guns but the g43x is amazing, easily the best CCW pistol.

[@Rauzwel]

A well-tempered and seemingly unbiased approach and presentation is definitely welcome in the gun community. Subbed, keep it up man. I can't stand all these political youtube tough guys that think they're right because they're loud and obnoxious. Anyway, just bought a 43x and I'm very happy with it. I may have chosen something like P365 if I wasn't already trained with a glock and had to carry one at work every day, but the 43X is certainly a comfortable and quality firearm.

[@killacoiler1707]

I guess it depends on your body size hand size and budget really as to which direction you go. For someone of a significant body mass hiding the 10 round grip length of the G43X might not pose as difficult as it would for someone that is petite in stature. The M&P Shield 2.0 in my opinion is a one size fits all kind of pistol sure it doesn't have the round capacity but in all honesty I really find that to be a negligible arguement when considering a concealed carry weapon. The 100+ year old 1911 has only carried 7/8 rounds in stock configuration since it was designed and so few argued its sufficiency. If you need more than 7 or 8 rounds you are probably in an area you had no business being in to start with. I carried a Model 60 .357 5 shot J-Frame revolver for years and felt more than safe in doing so. Now I'm no Jerry Miculek but I did carry 2 speed loaders incase I needed to do a relatively tactical reload. I think the M&P Shield is the number 1 selling singlestack/subcompact for a reason it carries an acceptable amount of rounds and is the perfect balance of small enough to conceal with excellent shootability. There are much smaller lighter pistols out there that would conceal even better but they are very flippy and uncomfortable to shoot and if something isn't pleasurable to shoot you don't generally spend any real time training with it at the range. That means that in a life or death situation when adrenaline is pumping you are defending yourself with an unfamiliar firearm that you aren't fully competent with and that can be very dangerous in my opinion. I'm not knocking the new Glock offerings but I do find them to be bizarrely configured pistols with questionable appeal. It is kind of in a segment all its own not a full size but not a subcompact either. It is like a G19 on a diet. It will be interesting to see how it is received by the masses over time and what segment they feel it falls in. I think this was a fairly well thought out comparison sir. Thanks for the insight.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Very good points Coiler! I do agree that the Shield is a great balance between concealable and shootable, which is what attracts me most to it. I find it natural to grip and easy to get sights on target. I seen to have to adjust more on the 43X, though I need to give it more time and may end up really digging it as well. The looks don’t bother me as I’ve been a Glock fan for many years. With either way, it’s great that we have so many choices out there. Thank you and cheers!

[@bigscout1584]

Found my 43x for $379. Couldn't pass it up

[@southerndad68]

I carry the G43X with shieldarms S15 (15+1) mag, shieldarms S15 +5rd extension (20rd) backup mag. it has ameriglo tritium I-dot sights, recovery tactical rail adapter and Olight baldr mini RL laser/light combo, Sandstorm Precision Precision magwell adapter, rubberized talon grips. Eventually Im going to put an apex trigger w/3.5lb connector and the holosun 507k red dot optics to finish it off.

[@steveb6103]

2.0 all the way. But the Sig P-365 is in the rotation now also.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Right on Steve! Thank you and cheers brother!

[@24roughing76]

@Chair Force 1000 rounds in my p365 with zero issues. I own 2 Glocks and guess what? They break too!

[@joquin4618]

Smith&wesson M&P 1.0 for me bro!!! $250 out the door! Don’t feel the need to get rid of it and get a new one.... Although i like the Glock single stacks as well, smith&wesson is just more bang for the buck!!

[@KSGunGuy01]

Right on Jo! Very well said. Thank you and cheers!

[@CLL-1]

Jo Quin , We have a 1.0 Shield in our collection too and it’s a great gun. Everybody thought they wanted more grip texture until they actually got it with the 2.0. Now almost everyone complains about how badly it rubs their skin while carrying. I like the 1.0 texture, it’s just more practical.

[@joquin4618]

CLL1 don’t get me wrong, I like the 2.0 trigger better.... it’s just that the 1.0 still has it going !

[@joelsolsrud2378]

Where did you get it for $250 out the door???

[@joquin4618]

Joel Solsrud $250 from palmetto state armory, add tax and FFL so about $280-$300... still pretty good bang for your buck!

[@ericachenbach2617]

Forgot to mention, the Talon rubberized grip tape helps a lot on the 43x.

[@KSGunGuy01]

I need to look into them! Thank you and cheers Eric!

[@Stormingsmoke]

Guys do yourself a favor and go ahead and subsribe , the reviews on this channel are very in depth, well thought out and detailed, you’re not gonna get any better.

[@maxmuller1585]

As always, good video brother. I love both of these pistols, but the 43x is the first Glock I have left the trigger alone on. I really like it. I added talons and hackathorn grips to it though. The 10+1 capacity beats my shield, even with mag guts on it. They are both good pistols and you cant go wrong with either. I have to select the 43x though.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Right on Kevin! I bet the Talon Grips really helps quite a bit. Having 10 rounds in the mag is also a great thing. Thank you and cheers!

[@midsouthexplorers7702]

It isn't nearly the same comparison, but I currently have the original Shield and the G48. At one time I had the G43 and gave it up in favor of the Shield. I think whether you're talking about the G43, G43x, or G48, I'd still take the Shield over the any of them in terms of a carry gun. It's a bit more flexible, and you get more for paying less. I've seen Shields online going for $225 - $300 NEW. I still love Glocks, but S&W really knocked it out the park with the Shield.

[@Tom_Sawyer_]

Looking at your size comparison, looks like all S&W needs to do is produce a 10 round magazine for the shield(love it) & they are going to be very close in size. Are they making single stacks too big? Look at the M&P 2.0 compact with 3.6 inch barrel & you get 15+1/17+1 & you only gain .3 of an inch in overall length & it’s the same height for a few ounces more then the Glock 43X & it’s a NAIL driver. Have a great day!

[@KSGunGuy01]

Very good points indeed! I do think single stacks are getting a bit bigger, which is both good and not good depending on how you look at it. Thank you and cheers!

[@themightycrixus1131]

They make polymer 12rd magazines that go for like 25 bucks. They work well.

[@themightycrixus1131]

They make polymer 12rd magazines that go for like 25 bucks. They work well.

[@plw81sg]

2.0 for the win. Glock is over priced.

[@KSGunGuy01]

The Shield is tough to bear for sure! Thank you and cheers!

[@plw81sg]

KSGunGuy you’re welcome sir.

[@dbenson002]

Agree with your assement that the Shield is better for concealment and shootability....plus the fact that my Shield holds 10 and 11 rounds thanks to the Magguts +2 spring system..so with 10 and 11 in the Shield....the Glock 43x or the 48 is another almost made it but not quite product.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Well said and I’ve heard great things about Magguts. Thank you and cheers!

[@larrylucas5731]

Yeah, I have to agree. My S/W is easy to shoot and was $150 cheaper. I want a Glock but the price of it plus having to add all the upgrades gust don't fit the budget. Thanks for the video!

[@KSGunGuy01]

Right on! The price on the Shield makes it hard to pass up. Thank you and cheers!

[@davidb8397]

I own a shield and I love it but wouldn't mind having a g 43x, have checked it out in academy and really liked it .by the way I do own glocks and you do not have to do any upgrades, they are great right out of the box dont listen to all the bs you're missing out on awesome guns

[@Beetmagnet]

I have both. The Shield is a much better shooter; better felt recoil, much better trigger. The Glock has more rounds, will eventually have better aftermarket availability, and has Glock reputation for reliability. Its a wash. I don't think you could go wrong either way. Buy one of each. Wait...buy 2 of each because some stupid politician tells you you don't need one. They're right...you need 2 or more.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Very well said! Thank you and cheers!

[@raymarchetta7551]

Plus another AR 15

[@rickyhogan2749]

I like your thinking.

[@thesprinkler7893]

Shield is just as reliable. Love my shield. But I think the 43x would be a great gun too. Just more expensive and especially with adding sights

[@BumpyJohnson9219]

I am looking to purchase my first firearm. I owned a revolver when I was 17, but didn’t really use it. I just kept it for a couple years and got rid of it. This is my first personal purchase. I had few people recommend the p365, Glock 43x, or the s&w m&p shield. What is the best for carrying and for shooting. Mind you this will be for me and my fiancée, and she has no experience with guns whatsoever. I want a gun the is economical, but also consistent and reliable. Also one that she can learn discipline, aim, and form fairly easily with. I am open to suggestions if anyone has any. Thanks in advance!

[@suicune1939]

I love my s&w shield 2.0 9mm would not change anything about it

[@mfirstchoice]

Glock 43X love at first grip

[@copierguy1961A]

I love my 43x. The 10 round magazine is great for CWP. It fits in my hand well and I personally love the slide color. I think the Glock looks better than the Smith but of course that is a personal choice. I respect your opinion and love these “if I could only have one “ videos. Keep them coming.

[@KSGunGuy01]

That’s awesome! I do agree that it fits well in the hand. Definitely my favorite feature. Thank you and cheers Gregory!

[@dcamnc1]

You have sweaty hands too. They are my curse. If I could change one thing about myself it would be my sweaty-ass hands.

[@slickdaddy12]

I'm just a big fan of the Walther PPS m2. But I like the Shield. Either choice would he a good one. That trigger on the Shield takes it up another level.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Well said Stephen! Thank you and cheers brother!

[@MCAS2177]

Glock is a good gun but the shield seems to take the lead right now and it’s a great concealed carry. I bought the pinky extender base plate for my 7 round magazine on eBay for 5 bucks. So it’s all good. Thanks for the info

[@108pel]

Shield Arms makes a 15 rounds flush mag for the 43X (black 43X rail coming out soon too) But I’ll stick to my S&W M&P 2.0 3.6

[@roberttosa2560]

Thanks KS , you just helped me break the tie on on my next CCW. I am looking at both of these pistols and have decided on the Shield. Really enjoy your videos. Keep ‘‘em coming.

[@sweetcostarica8714]

I think since the *grip texture* on the 43X is less aggressive than guns like the G19 (G23) or G17 (G22) for a simple & obvious reason. Glock designed a less *"aggressive"* grip texture on the G42, G43, G43X, & G48 on purpose. Why!?! These a CCW handguns designed to be wore everyday, 24/7. Do you want sand paper ruining your clothes &/or rubbing you skin off? *Note:* To say that this grip is "not very good" is to miss the point entirely on what these guns were design for. They are not range guns for paper warriors and they are not full combat guns for the military.

[@KSGunGuy01]

I believe there is a better balance for grip texture and the 43X/48 didn’t get there. I find the Shield to be comfortable all day with a few adjustments here and there, so more aggressive is doable. It’s all personal opinion of course. Thank you and cheers!

[@sweetcostarica8714]

​@@KSGunGuy01 I guess you could say any review of any thing is personal opinion. The thing is... is that opinion an uninformed one or a *well informed one.* What I am saying is *information* is the key to forming correct opinions that lead to the right personal opinion. For example: It is the Army's personal opinion that the SIG 320 is the best gun for them. How did they come to that conclusion? - They asked gun makers to submit samples of sidearms - Testing, testing, & more testing of the samples - The guns that completed ALL the test satisfactory in the testers opinion were two: Glock & SIG - The Army's *personal opinion* now weights in and SIG was picked from the two finishers Lately (past 15 to 20 years) many folks in the gun industry & reviewers of firearms (most are also in the gun industry) have started to focus on grips & triggers on handguns. I never thought this was an issue since most modern guns have fine grips & triggers. So I am sure this focus has to do with making more money for aftermarket companies that keeps the money flowing to everyone. *Not saying it is wrong,* just saying. GRIP - to be or not to be You said KSGunGuy, "I believe there is a better balance for grip texture and the 43X/48 didn’t get there." Grip texture (how aggressive) & trigger (spongy seems to be bad in the industry) is all NOT REALLY IMPORTANT to CCW & Self-defense. Maybe for a long distance snipper, competition shooter, or John Wick but not for the average guy. WHY A handgun for self-defense or CCW can have no grip texture & even a bad trigger and win the fight easily. I say this to buck the recent gun industry promotion on grip texture because it is obvious that looking at all the guns used for self-defense grip texture was closer the mild like the Glocks, G42, G43, G43X, & G48 than the main line Glocks. Examples: - The *guns cowboys & gunslingers* used in the Wild West had mostly smooth wood handles as it was the shape of the handle that kept the weapon in the hand & steady. - Many *1911s* have smooth handles ALL the way around the handle & frame. - *Walter PP & PPK* pistol have smooth handle with little checkering. And that checkering was not aggressive. - *Russian Makarov* pistols had/have smooth fore & aft handles and a not very aggressive side panels/some side panels were smooth. - *Dirty Harry's 44 Magnum* had a mostly smooth handle and that gun could... "blow your head clean off". Most of the guns above were use for a long time and many are known for accurate fire over many other firearms. And all with no or very little grip texture. Yet the guns worked well & hit their target(s). SUMMARY The *grip texture* on a gun is not important at all if you learned to shoot correctly. Also, a good or bad trigger is not so important due to the dynamics of a gun fight. Plus all modern triggers are designed to work well in a self-defense situation.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Thanks for the thoughts. The military chose the Sig due to money. Considering the amount of issues both civilian and non-civilian shooters have had with the P320, Sig clearly didn’t win because of quality. Not saying they should have chosen Glock, just saying that their choice has proven to be problematic. As for the great list of old guns, you’re implying that advancements in technology and technique stopped with those guns. You and I both know it didn’t. So while those guns were great in those days, they would not stand up to modern standards considering the choices we have now. I do agree that you need to know how to shoot correctly, but having the right tool designed for the right application is important and the 43X and 48 should have been thought out more thoroughly. I’ll say again, it’s personal opinion. That said, look through the comments on videos of those guns and see how many people agree. It’s the same with other reviewers/industry folks... I’ve talked to many. The other Glocks have more texture and they are designed for carry, so why make these two anemic?

[@sweetcostarica8714]

@@KSGunGuy01 You said, "The military chose the Sig due to money..." and "Not saying they should have chosen Glock, just saying that their choice has proven to be problematic." The U.S. Army’s coveted Modular Handgun System competition was very hard and I heard there was some controversy involving them not completing the tests after the only two gun that passed it were discovered. Anyway the SIG's issue(s) was serious (see link below): August 12, 2017 on nationalinterest.org *The U.S. Army’s New Handgun Is in Big Trouble* The pistol apparently fires when dropped. by Task and Purpose nationalinterest.org/blog/the-us-armys-new-handgun-hot-water-after-multiple-reports-21883 But when 65% of U.S. Police effectively carry Glocks I WILL say the U.S. Army like many other police/militaries *should have chosen Glock.* You say, "...advancements in technology and technique stopped with those guns. You and I both know it didn’t." KSGunGuy, we are taking about *"grip texture"* that has been around since the British Brown Bess. There is nothing advanced about it. Checkering & raised diamonds for a solid grip are pretty simple concepts to understand. *Besides,* Glock, Inc. knows all about the need for grip texture is on their guns. How much is the question. Do you really think Glock, Inc. made a mistake and accidentally on the G42, G43, G43X, & G48 made the grip texture too low & weak? Really? As I already mentioned, Glock, Inc. for the sake of *ease of carry,* made their CCW guns less aggressive in grip texture *so not to destroy clothing or irritate the users skin.* *Note:* You can accurately shoot guns without checkering on their handles or even an aggressive grip texture as the powerful guns listed has shown. *Reference* see my previous list of famous smooth handled (for the most part) firearms above. Again Grip texture - NOT REALLY IMPORTANT to CCW & Self-defense. You said, "but having the right tool designed for the right application is important..." Here, in this sentence I think you "jump the shark". There are many tools in the US gun industry to choose from that will be the right tool. Even if it were not for our CCW/self-defense discussion. With modern guns that almost all work well any handgun can be the right tool. As the right application (CCW or basic self-defense in this case) covers a lot of ground where many gun systems can & will work. It is really easy. USING A GUN FOR PROTECTION This task is a serious one but the tool can be many and hard thinking it is a waste of time and energy. There is no one right gun. There are many correct choices and it is very hard to fail in picking a gun for protection. I mean you got to be pretty... well you get the idea. Also, think about this - if you buy a gun and it doesn't quite work for you, you can sell it easily since guns generally hold their value or you can improvise, adapt, & overcome the issue(s) and use the weapon well for life. ITS ALL ABOUT THE MAN You said, "...and the 43X and 48 should have been thought out more thoroughly." ALWAYS remember it is the shooter not the tool that makes the successful shot or end of the incident. The focus is: - 90% the man/woman (practice, study, awareness of your surroundings, staying away from questionable/dangerous areas, etc.) - 10% tool, i.e. what self-defense tool you use. If it is a gun that is the easiest choice to make. As I said earlier there are many right choices in the USA for CCW or a self-defense handgun. The word *personal opinion* is a good one. But *"informed"* personal opinion* is the best word. Stay salty.

[@sweetcostarica8714]

@@KSGunGuy01 You're not replying anymore signals the end of our conversation/friendly debate. As you can see I like to debate & play the "Angels" advocate. I am not in the gun community, not a gun collector, and don't run a gun store. So I have no stake in weapons, after markets parts, custom parts, promotion of other's products, etc. If you thought I was trolling you, *I was not.* I am for truth (telling it like it is) & consumer protection. I had many, many guns in the past after leaving the US Navy and now own just three (3) - listed from most useful 1st to least useful last: - a Shotgun (filled with slugs - bear country) - a "black" rifle (empty - more of a safe queen) & lastly - a CCW handgun (has Critical Defence polymer tips in it) I say the CCW handgun is least useful since I use better self-defense techniques: *1st* and avoidance, *2nd* awareness, *3rd* pepper gel/spray, *4th* Judo, etc. *5th* As a last resort... then use a firearm. Since less than 1% of the US public gets into a CCW incident where someone or two are shot I am pretty confident of my "least useful" statement. This is one major reason I was trying to water down your (IMO) too serious take on the grip of the Glock or any gun really. There are very few modern bad grips out there that are not "thought out" and GLOCK Inc. is not that sloppy. I could disagree from a CCW stand point on a lot of things you said & have done to the gun in the video above from a CCW/self-defense perspective but I know why you *say and do* the things you say & do anyway so why get into it? Long story short, I enjoyed this friendly disagreement. Stay happy & safe *KSGunGuy.*

[@jpilot12]

Has someone who has both there both good guns. I carry the Glock and my dad carry’s the M&P. personally I could go with both. For my dad the Glock trigger pinches his finger, and the smith and Wesson is a better feeling gun. I and agree so in the end it’s more of one feels better then the other but both good guns. Glock also holds 10 rounds but most people buy the double stack mag from shield arms, which is not available for the M&P. Other than that it’s more of what feels better for you.

[@ultima913]

Bought the Glock 43x earlier today to replace my old carry, my .45 S&W M&P which was too big for summer in my area. Found this video afterwards. Great choice on both!

[@ES44AC-2]

Great video. I'm glad Glock doesn't have the cheese grater grips to take off skin during CCW.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Thank you very much! I prefer mor grip but understand exactly where you are coming from. Cheers!

[@EGKID]

I’ve got both and for the money the shield cannot be beat! I got my shield new for $279 with tritium night sights vs $429 for the 43x and the Glock still needs sights. I’ve only got 80 rounds through the 43x and a little over 500 through the shield. But so far both are great and I grab which ever one happens to be closest on the way out the door.

[@slundgr]

Have you ever noticed the Glock shooting to the left a little bit?

[@mk45gunnr25]

Glock 43x all day. S&W Shield is a great gun. But I carry a Glock every day on duty so that's the deciding factor for me

[@KSGunGuy01]

Right on and that makes sense. Thank you and cheers!

[@Deathrend8481]

I ended up setting the P365 aside due to it just being too small. I couldn't shoot it like I wanted.

[@KSGunGuy01]

I hear you there! Thank you and cheers!

[@williamwallace9427]

I’ve got both ... the shield feels like perfection in the hand.. but I don’t like the takedown lever ... The glock doesn’t feel as good In Hand... but.. glock reliability

[@brandonUwanawich954]

Isn’t the width on the shield .89 and weight 18.2 oz unloaded? And The Shield has a Spring from magguts you can get a 10+1 with same length

[@Bulldog75stp]

I just purchased a black slide G43x. I heard Shield Arms makes a 15-round mag for the 43x/48. Game over...

[@sandymitchell8182]

ya but the 43 has 6 rounds

[@Bulldog75stp]

@@sandymitchell8182 Yeah, but I got the 43X. Comes with 10 + 1.

[@sandymitchell8182]

@@Bulldog75stp yes 43X much better

[@davidarizonaunited7578]

I own a s&w 9c. I shot the Glock 43x a couple days ago. And fell in love with the glock. So far its been the only glock that I enjoyed shooting. Shield I have not shot. I would like to shoot the shield 2.0 vs 43x.

[@kirkland0074]

I love glocks had them since 1995 but purchased a Shield 6yrs ago and never had an issue 100% reliable so far. It’s my daily carry gun and I trust my life to it but you can’t go wrong with either.

[@nessas.9647]

5th review and now I know that I want the Shield. Thanks

[@Rattpac]

Great job on the reviews. Bought the shield 9mm for my wife and she absolutely loves it. Although my choice for carry is my Smith M&P 9c with double stack mag, but I do enjoy shooting her shield as well.

[@KSGunGuy01]

That’s awesome! Both the Shield and 9c are fantastic guns. Hopefully they will do another 9c in a 2.0 at some point. Thank you and cheers!

[@themoderndaygamer637]

My buddy owns a 2.0 and I own the 43x he actually likes mine more

[@fitop.7468]

Great review I would go with the M&P Shield too. "Magguts" makes a +2 for the Shield that makes it 9 rounds same size as the 8 round magazine. 9+1.😎👍

[@KSGunGuy01]

Thank you very much! I hear those magguts are pretty cool as well. Cheers Fito!

[@fitop.7468]

@@KSGunGuy01 Yeah Harley no KZbin reviews on Magguts.

[@donhoinohio9477]

If the Shield had 10+1 like the Glock 43x, I would get one. Same grip length for concealment purposes, so advantage (for me) goes to the Glock due to more rounds capacity.

[@mengdynasty6034]

I had a shield and switched to a G26, now running the 43X. All are exceptional.

[@steven3379]

Late to this video, but just as well, choice between two customized guns is rather pointless. Now if they were stock I get it, but as was shown, it was a waste of time.

[@KSGunGuy01]

I do it my way

[@steven3379]

@@KSGunGuy01 yep, 2 times a day in your bathroom.... 😂😂😂 Either way... The video is still useless.

[@KSGunGuy01]

Make more sense next time chief.

[@DanielJohnson-ot8wj]

I’ve done the best thing you can do and bought both. Really all 3 of the best EDC guns imo. G43X, P365X, and the shield plus PC ported. Now I just carry which one I’ve got the itch for any given day. They all 3 serve a purpose daily in my rotation. They just swap spots lol. My H&K USP will always be my home defense weapon of choice tho. I love that gun! A beast to carry in your britches or shorts tho. Especially when you got a case of the gone ass disease.

[@Spudsmachenzie1]

If you have long finger/hands like me (6’1 and slim), Glock 43 is just too slim from back of grip to trigger. Shield is just right. Plus with the shield and +2 taran tactical base plate this dude has you can make your 8 round mag and 10 round mag with the FACTORY mag spring. Full-size/compact guns...Glock all day long... but single stacks (and $) shield wins big IMO.

[@KSGunGuy01]

I agree! Thank you and cheers!

[@cah630]

@@KSGunGuy01 k

[@ezekielmajor5511]

The topic of your video should have been: Why I chose the S & W Shield 2.0 over the Glock 43X. My question is - why are all new handguns compared to Glocks? What does that tell you? Right now, no SD handgun is better than the G43X MOS.

[@ashsherman]

Very Old posts here but i must say for those who stumble on that as i have. The shield 9mm 2.0 in 2021 still has absolutely the very best most crisp trigger of any alternative, even in newer models. The 2.0 isn't THAT old. STILL MUCH better than the GLOCK non match-grade stock trigger, even the old 1st gen triggers. Everyone is moving from external hammers to strikers. There must be a reason. I didn't think much until Walther PPQ became their new flagship pieces like The XD for Springfield is now., With PPQ dethroning the PPK, a hammer fired. JUST SAYO G FOR THISE CWHO WANT A BUDGET PIECE THAT'S ACTUALLY EXCEPTIONAL EXCEPT FOR CAPACITY BUT IT'S MICRO COMPACT,FOR A 9MM THAT IS, NOT A 380. IT'S NO HELLCAT

[@masterxiong7368]

Love both but 43x and the 15 mag is the sell point for me. Price is reasonable

[@GrayGhostDog1]

Excellent review... Shield 2.0 is good-2-go, but I have to give the nod to 43X. 43X can be had with two choices of night sights from the factory, more rounds in flush mags, better stock trigger, and mag release can be swapped to other side for us southpaws...

[@KSGunGuy01]

Thank you! Definitely great points. I think the 43X will be a great competitor going forward. Cheers!

[@gravy1471]

M&p all day

[@Kornholeeoo]

The 2.0s are fantastic guns. I’ve had a couple of the M&P 9s. But I have shied away from guns that require a mag extension for my pinky. No one wanted to love the Sig P365 more than me. Or the G26. Also the Kimber Solo. Not to mention the G43. But I had to get rid of all of them. Well my daughter got the G43. But I picked up the new Sig P365XL and the new G43X the other day. Love both of them and they are so similar yet so different. They’ll both be in my rotation after I get at least 500 rounds through them.

[@cedrics7802]

Oh yes , The S & W SHIELD Rules . Pluse its made in 40 S&W and 45 ACP . Also , made w/ported bbl. & sld. Finally, made in the USA .

[@KSGunGuy01]

Right on! Thank you and cheers!

[@terryteague1236]

I love my G43X. The G43X gives you the option of a black upper, which I prefer. Shield makes a metal Shield 15 round "S15" flush mag for the G43X and reviews have been good, recommending a metal mag release, because the metal mag will possibly wear on the plastic mag release over time. Alien Gear already has the shell for the G43X. I just ordered mine. I like the Alien Gear Modular Holster System, giving so many carry options. S&W Shield is a fine handgun, but I just prefer Glock.

[@terryteague1236]

I ordered and received 3 Shield Arms S15 magazines and changed out the magazine release for a metal extended release. The new ones are a little tighter in the grip but after a little use, they are fine. I like them. The only thing I didn't expect, is that the new mags are not for left handed shooters, which I happen to be. I can live with that fact though, and if they ever do make them for both, I'll order them and give these to my right handed son who also has a G43X. I've ordered 4 more.

[@chrissourp6807]

I do know this : My stupid S/W Shield has been back for various failures 4 TIMES ! And it still sucks. 8 Glocks and NEVER 1 failure. Of any kind. Just got the new G43X and it goes to the range for the first round tomorrow. I am expecting to have a freekin blast. S/W is in my sock drawer, where it belongs. A waste of good money. I do not care what anybody thinks, Glocks have NEVER failed me. Ever.

[@jrG070605]

I will say the shield is no slouch...if it held 10 rds like the 365 it would be a very difficult decision...maybe that will be the Shield 3.0

[@KSGunGuy01]

It will be interesting to see what they do with a 3.0. Thank you and cheers!

[@rdblankenship]

I know this video was almost a year ago, but I don't see the Shield 2.0 in the same price range as the original Shield M&P, would there be a good reason to pay more for the 2.0?

[@kwmulligan]

I was deciding between the two also, Went for the 1.0. A month ago, they were going for $250. Could not justify spending the extra an $80 for a little better stipling and serrated cut outs in front of slide. Hope this helps.

[@andrewc735]

Got a original M&P Shield at academy price matched and an additional 10% off when palmetto armory ran a Christmas sale awhile back. $280 out the door

[@KSGunGuy01]

That's awesome! Thank you and cheers!

[@fumasterchu12]

Both look like quality ccw's, but both could use something from the other. If you put the grip texture of the 2.0 on the 43X you have a great ccw. Put a longer grip/mag capacity on the 2.0 and it's a homerun. I agree they both could use a better trigger which you've already addressed. I love the flat-faced triggers, and especially the one you have in the Glock. Great review as usual brother, Cheers!

[@KSGunGuy01]

Very well said Fu! I think taking the best of both would make an outstanding gun. Thank you and cheers brother!

[@LAYDAWOOD6]

Shield is the better gun, glock has more capacity. Neither compare to a glock 26 or even close to a Glock 19. Premium slim line guns just don't compare to premium double stacks in shootability. If you have to have a slim line gun, get a P365XL, I just don't trust it with my life.