LIVE: Boyfriend Cop Murder Trial - MA v. Karen Read - Day 6

[@tactup23]

I like how the judge asks the prosecutor if he wants to object and then sustains it for him too. That’s truly a class act!

[@lauren5956]

How is there no probable cause when a body was found on the lawn?

[@BellaNY00]

Karen admitted she hit him with her vehicle! Many heard her say it and she said it on TV! She is guilty imo.

[@DMiller912]

I don't know if she's guilty or not, but seeing the way law enforcement handled this case so poorly...there's a ton of readable doubt. Everyone in the house, where a man lay on the lawn, should have been questioned, separately.

[@DMiller912]

Also, I agree with you Lauren.

[@sandtats]

Just because an injured or even a dead body is found on your property, just 8 ft from the road no less, doesn't give probable cause to obtain a warrant to search the home of the property owner; no reason to seize their personal property; search their phones. At the time it wasn't even determined what the cause or manner of death was. Zero evidence anyone in the home had anything to do with injuring him at the point. LE questioned the ppl in the home, all of whom said John never came into the house that night.

[@DMiller912]

There is probable cause when the body in question was said by the home owner, was supposed to be coming to that house to party. It wasn't just a random person laying outside. John Okeffe was purposely coming to the Albert's house.

[@Imsorrymami]

I cannot believe the judge told the lawyers don’t waste the jurors time with all of your questioning, a persons life is in the hands of this jury - ask away! Unbelievable

[@Shazvana]

I agree. I also feel this comment was directed towards the defense team more so. They are legally bound to do & ask whatever is needed to save Karen from this corrupt mess. There is not a day as yet, where this judge hasn't done something that doesn't pass the sniff test. I see a judge who is bias but thinks no one is noticing and this has been happening in every court session for this case. Even her swiveling on her chair during testimony tells me she's not interested in the truth of what happened, let alone the sighs.

[@michaelcalland801]

Incredible isn’t it !?

[@lisalopez8639]

She has said so many times too

[@rainaeasley7863]

Because he is all smoke and mirrors

[@rainaeasley7863]

Judges say that often because no one hade time for showboating and theatrics

[@amandameekhael]

The judge has the audacity to tell them they’re wasting the juror’s time when SHES the one who’s constantly doing side bar and delaying the entire case, plus doing short days.

[@Stefunny99]

I watch court cases almost daily. Have been for years and this judge is the worst I’ve ever seen.

[@celestehutchison709]

You couldn't have said it better!!!

[@rocsti5402]

Just saying objection is a time saver. Shes done numerous things to speed things up including not making decisions now and wasting time. Thats exactly what the defense wants. you really cant win with people.

[@SuperBlahhh94]

@@Stefunny99 have you seen the judge for the YSL trial? He makes her look great

[@mazie7952]

​@@Stefunny99exactly. She's awful

[@MGHArizona]

Not guilty!! The police should be investigated for their misconduct and the judge for her biases. Horrible!

[@cholewess4137]

Ok so it's not just me!

[@Shazvana]

We all know that if any of us "non-cop" folk had a beat up, near death, man on our front lawn, our homes would be locked down with in minutes and all our butts would be standing out in that cold snow because the PC is having the victim on our front lawn!!!!! These corrupt cops want us all to believe the BS they are saying about why they did not lock this home down. We all know why it was not locked down!!! This case makes my blood boil.

[@Jess023]

Right not even questioned or anything. Yeah that would never happen if it happened to us. NEVER

[@MissCherryBomb69]

They found a drunk guy passed out on my friends lawn, in Massachusetts mind you, and they knocked on her door and looked all around her house!

[@missychelle33]

Honestly perfectly said. Spot on.

[@rainaeasley7863]

Well if the guys girl friend says she hit him then I bout they would need to

[@missychelle33]

@@rainaeasley7863 she never said that.

[@beckyz5694]

This is so obvious to me this is a big time cover up by the police. Not saying they are all in on it, but come on... These cops saying they had no reason or probable cause to go into the house??! Give me a break! If any of us lay people were in this situation, the cops would have demanded and got a search warrant for the whole frickin house, and would have demanded to interview everyone there on record. This is ludacris. And these cops look ridiculous in their testimony of this.

[@marthawilliamson9929]

Police officer for 24 years & you didn't interview the people who lived at the crime scene, didn't fact check a witness, didn't take legit blood samples, didn't even seal the blood evidence, didn't close off the crime scene, didn't check the house for foul play, WHAT DID YOU DO? Because you definitely DIDN'T DO YOUR JOB!

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

If someone is at the scene saying they did it what would all that be necessary for? It wasn’t until Karen recanted and started all this mess that the investigation is such a problem..Karen is guilty and she knows it.,all this is crazy and she should be ashamed..

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

And if you have no reasonable cause you can’t just bust into someone’s house..smh..they have never been suspects..they knew who did this and it’s a shame she couldn’t just plead..guilty people do two things..it’s a conspiracy or frame and the investigation was bad..Karen is two for two and she drug everyone thru the mud..she’s evil,

[@lisagrubb792]

@pebblez21 assuming arguendo that she did confess at the scene (debatable), how do you justify not performing a proper investigation - their JOB - based on that?? Recanting happens all the time. Even when it doesn’t - trials happen all the time - even when there are confessions. You still need to support even bringing the charges. Those supports are comprised of evidentiary proofs properly gathered at the crime scene and accumulated during the investigation. A “confession” means absolutely nothing at this stage in the investigation.

[@ecalose6785]

@@SAMMYBAMBAM24 what trial are you watching?

[@ecalose6785]

@@SAMMYBAMBAM24 she said DID I kill him. Jenn lied and made up the rest. Are you even serious!

[@LittleMissStamper]

This judge is very bias against the defence. This whole trial should be thrown out.

[@kimgale262]

I agree 150%. Judge is soòoo bais it's absolutely plain to see!!!

[@brandiassaker4825]

Someone said the judges brother represented one of the Albert Brothers in a case before.

[@wls1020]

Yes she is

[@hectorsantiago5992]

Judge looks like queen in Alice in wonderland.

[@kingduran007]

You can’t throw it out what about the Okeefe family they lost a son and need to know what happened to him

[@cuttie240]

The judge talks about not wasting the jury's time or something along those lines. But she's the one cutting these trial days short with half days. Maybe she should go a full business day and not waste anyone's time. Get it over with.

[@vanessalumbra9409]

Plus, every 5 minutes, when the defense is cross examining, she calls a side bar. Rarely with the state. Which also prolongs the trial. Let the defense do his job! His whole case is about shoddy and biased police work. Judge is biased.

[@lauren5956]

​@vanessalumbra9409 also she asks if Lally had an objection of she feels he should. Seems like she is coaching the prosecution. Someone noticed she coughs just before Lally objects also. Shady stuff.

[@karoleegregerson7600]

I noticed that yesterday. S he is very biased. I think she is mad at defense for making motion to remove her.

[@WotSheSaid]

⁠Also I thought they were supposed to provide the reason for objections, at least for the record.

[@Btflmama]

She is also the reason for delays with evidence. Everything was labeled and she decided to change it but wants to make it seem the lawyers are the problem. The cops also stared straight at Lally with smirks waiting for him to object. I bet Lally knows this is a ridiculous trial and that's why he is struggling and needs prompting to object.

[@erickab8533]

If she is found guilty she will get an appeal. Objection. Sustained. Why?? What grounds? This is the most ridiculous trial I’ve ever seen and it is very shady.

[@IAmALawyerToo]

Agree! Multiple grounds for appeal - forcing counsel to continually rephrase without guidance! It’s like a Pin the Tail on the Donkey court procedure.

[@DMiller912]

Agree!

[@leahbia82]

My fave is her asking the prosecutor if he wants to object, he says yes, then she sustains it. Like, umm... There was no objection until you said that!

[@Deborah-k7v]

So true shaddy

[@user-nj9db2tg9w]

@@leahbia82or multiple witnesses waiting and hesitating to answer something… staring at the common wealth, prompting them to object , to which they all then know the judge will sustain, so the witness doesn’t have to answer

[@jantoles7637]

The incompetency of Officer Lank is beyond the pale! 24 years as a police officer and does not know how to affix evidence tape to a bag containing evidence. What was he taught in the school to become a police officer? Are police officers required continuing education after receiving their certificate after graduating from cop school? I would be scared to to live in Canton because of the ineptness of every police officer I have seen give testimony in this case. I would like to know how the O'Keefe family feels about the "investigations" done by the police in this case.

[@pamelamckernan9236]

barber school is 1500 to 2000 hours training. police academy 6-8 weeks and have power

[@tinsloney]

Judge says get me the reports by tomorrow morning. Gets her the report by the night before. Then doesn’t bother to look or ask for them before court. Then says they can’t use them because she hasn’t seen them???? WOWOWOWOW

[@SounderMom31]

This judge was incredibly unprofessional and she ran that trial so unorganized. There were constant issues with making exhibits, SHE called for a sidebar every 5 minutes, her constant sighing into the mic and the most outrageous thing was, when she told the attorneys not to waist the jurors time with so many questions. SERIOUSLY?! The defendant is facing serious prison time and she tells the defense (the comment was mostly towards the defense) not to ask so many questions in order to defend their client? Unbelievable. If Karen Read would’ve been convicted, the judge would’ve handed her an appeal on a silver platter with that behavior.

[@WhatTheHeckIsGoingOnHere]

I keep wondering if I am the only one who dislikes this judges rulings and asking for sidebar discussions! But apperantly I am not the only one.

[@ginafabiani5629]

No you’re not the only one she’s the worst

[@debbielang822]

Ha ! I think everyone watching this trial, on all sites, sees the corruption of the police and THE BIAS OF THIS RIDICULOUS THING THEY CALL A " JUDGE" ! You are not the only one!

[@hazelnut7131]

Major C. O. R. R. U. P. T. I. O. N at every level!! Unbelievable!

[@carolinagirl740]

Yes!!!!

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

OMG. Spanning over two agencies, the judge, the prosecutor and all those people? You don’t think someone woulda cracked. Give it a rest..she’s guilty. This is what guilty people do.. it’s a consistently and I’ve been fended plus the investigation was shoddy..she inserted herself right into that guilty role.

[@KTD1988]

💯 percent

[@johndevlin]

That ceiling fan is the real star of the show.

[@Stefunny99]

💯 😂

[@missychelle33]

Allllll of this is like watching paint dry. Literally all I care about is hearing the defense. At least it’s interesting. However I’ve listened to it all. It’s basically life right now 😂😂😂

[@mazie7952]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@MyMagpie]

We should name it! 😂

[@glo3139]

@@MyMagpieFanny

[@fluteplayervictoria4100]

Why is the judge so sassy to the defense? 👀

[@DMiller912]

Yes, and it's so obvious.

[@notsorryyouretriggered]

Bias

[@rocsti5402]

The defense are a bunch of weasels, thats why. Their entire "tipster" which formed this phony defense and allowed it into trial was a scam from the start. Karen's second biggest mistake after that night was going along with this BS and not pleading guilty. She might have doubts about whether she did it but deep down knows its extremely likely she is a killer. was she so blacked out she can't remember or not that drunk so her driving and Actions should have been fine. They are trying to have it both ways.

[@teachertone1]

​@@rocsti5402touche`

[@IronEaglet-ru8zb]

@@rocsti5402. The real weasels in this case are the collection of corrupt a-holes trying to frame an innocent woman. The real weasels are the cops sneaking a picture with a piece of taillight into Sean Goode’s report. That could only have been Proctor or Berkowitz. The defense attorneys are actually heroes.

[@Gambrellgirl]

What kind of judge asks the prosecutor “is there an objection?” Yes your honor. Ok the objection is sustained. What a kangaroo court.

[@rsera42O]

Ludicrous at best, seriously, 🙄

[@Amanda3280h]

So the judge is more worried about the time of the jurors that have this civil duty to complete than the life of someone hanging in the balance.

[@dianesweat6015]

Canton Police are dirty and so guilty

[@stephs17]

Exactly, if she's confessing at the scene why wasn't she taken in for questioning. They knew it wasn't an auto accident. One of the dirty cops said he assumed it was an assault by the injuries.

[@my2cents581]

Not a single citizen is safe under the watch of The Canton Police and Emergency Services!

[@stacyhenry5578]

I only having court 4 hours a day.And she's yelling that the attorneys are wasting time

[@IronEaglet-ru8zb]

The only attorney wasting time with irrelevant pointless questions is Lunchbox Lally.

[@mariecpa2000]

I've never seen a courtroom set up so that the victims family is so close to the defendant.

[@linahill7341]

It's actually very dangerous!

[@my2cents581]

It’s all by design!

[@madcityjesse00]

It's a tiny courtroom. Looks like enough seats for the families and a few journalists.

[@beckyz5694]

I also don't agree that the judge is sustaining 99% of all of the great questions by defense, the questions we need answers to!! And constantly asking for sidebars... come on judge

[@tanyaconley7375]

This judge is horrible!!! SHE is the one wasting time with all her side “bahs”. She is micromanaging everything to an extent that it is very bias. She is so scared defense will show something she can’t walk back to protect her friends.

[@MyMagpie]

Really???? Between the sidebars and the breaks, this trial will last months.

[@amandameekhael]

Judge is stalling on purpose when the lies are being exposed.

[@TinaMarie212]

"let's move this case along?" she is an inappropriate, biased judge and needs to be disbarred

[@glo3139]

You’re all taking too much of the juror’s precious time!!! Let’s whip into shape, BUT after this 5 minute break!!!!😂😂😂😂

[@Elizabeth.C.Holmes]

Is that u Karen?

[@KhenoronhkhwaJesusIs]

The only squandering going on here seems to be the taxpayers honest, hardworking money for this “judge”.

[@IronEaglet-ru8zb]

How ironic is it that Auntie Bev says this and repeatedly lets Lunchbox Lally ask hours of endless pointless questions that have nothing to do with this case? I don’t need the entire resume and family background of every witness, no one gives a F. Get to the point, Lunchbox.

[@michaelcalland801]

@@Elizabeth.C.Holmes Could be anyone… Everyone deserves a fair trial

[@jessicawhite7204]

There wouldn’t be so many side bars if the lawyers were able to say why they’re objecting. They’re being told they’re wrong by a sustained objection but having to guess why. It’s a ridiculous waste of time.

[@jantoles7637]

I cannot believe the judge asks the prosecuting attorney if he objects to things. Is not that the attorney's responsibility?

[@joannt2298]

If you’re talking about when the defense is entering new evidence, she has to ask for the record.

[@Physics072]

If you object the Judge will sustain as long as its the prosecution.

[@leahbia82]

And if they don't object.... she will hint to them by asking if they want to object and then sustain it.

[@MyMagpie]

It’s just nutty!!

[@Girlmom4]

It’s just insane!!! I’ve never watched a trial where it’s SOOO OBVIOUS!! It’s truly appalling the amount of objections from the prosecution that she’s sustaining!!! I just can’t believe it!!

[@Physics072]

@@leahbia82 Heheh yea I did see that a few times. Wink Wink you might want to object to that.

[@dianesweat6015]

She's biased for sure.

[@beverlymills5018]

My question is, why didn’t anyone wake the homeowners to find out if John fell asleep inside? Also why did the homeowners not up and involved with this????

[@Patricia-wu9yj]

That’s what I want to know. All this going on out front of your house and Karen screaming and nobody came out to see what was going on.

[@tracyg5290]

It was 6am!! They just partied at a bar and at their home..I wouldn't be fully aware of what was happening outside of my home either

[@kathymccarthy5264]

It was a blizzard--what would they hear if they were sleeping off a hangover??

[@karoleegregerson7600]

Perhaps because the beat him very badly took him outside to cover up what they had done inside.

[@sandtats]

@@kathymccarthy5264 Plus none of the cruisers, the engine or ambulance utilized their sirens that night, only flashing blue lights.

[@michaelfaraday7388]

Regardless of the outcome this judge should be reprimanded . Her obvious bias is disgusting .

[@rsera42O]

Yes, she needs to step down to traffic court for the balance of her career… clearly she is in bed with the Alberts 😳🎯

[@Jina_G]

So who's responsible for sacking that police department and replacing all of them?

[@MissCherryBomb69]

I believe the DA, not positive

[@karoleegregerson7600]

So much reasonable doubt. Not guilty. Should not take jury very long.

[@bethlouden3333]

I'm playing catch up so I'm behind. If she's found guilty our jury system has failed. It's a failure anyway...jurors vote with their emotions not the facts. But this case screams reasonable doubt...

[@IngaLeo4]

If she gets convicted based on this trial, someone must be paying someone.... There is no way she is guilty here, I don't think

[@TammyMacMac]

The thing is...part of an accused due process rights is that a thorough investigation be completed. Clearly this wasn't done in any way, shape, or fashion...by anyone. These officers' versions of a thorough investigation are unique to say the least...lol

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

No need for one until she started with her conspiracy crap…truly.

[@katrinasilliman5913]

It’s amazing how forgetful all of these first responders are. “I don’t recall”…none of them remember anything!

[@madcityjesse00]

They only lose their memory when the defense asks questions.

[@melissa74066]

If that had been just a regular civilian house the police would have been all over that house with a fine tooth comb

[@BurlyJ]

The best part of this case is hearing the bailiff say, "Hear ye hear ye hear" at the beginning every time lol

[@rsera42O]

Right… 😂😅😂

[@satraramek9760]

The judge is ensuring a dismissal of all charges when the defendant appeals. With surveillance cameras everywhere, why is the actual crime never filmed? As much as Big Brother is detested, we need more surveillance in certain places!

[@Floridarobins]

If John O'Keefe was seen on video holding a cocktail glass exiting the bar, then entered the house, a violent fight ensued in the basement , he was then dragged outside and put on the front lawn, why would he still be holding the cocktail glass???

[@tracyg5290]

Great question!!!!

[@juanacastillo7154]

facts are facts.⚖️

[@josephinedimercurio5012]

Because he never entered the house . She’s left him in there to die because she was mad . Why she came back in the morning? I wonder

[@bjohnjackson1083]

Well said

[@AttorneyDeborah]

No track marks on the yard .. plus the plow driver seeing a ford edge at the scene. An investigator would be too smart at lead it to leave footprints in the snow. I think they waited for the plow to go by, so they didn't get caught.. and loaded him up in the car in the garage or driveway and driven on the street and dumped.

[@WILLPILL31]

"Move the case along" the judge ASK THE PROSECUTION if the object, when the prosecution havent even objected yet! TFFFFF Shes clearly for the prosecutions and covering up valuable evidence for the defense!

[@mighty0974]

That piece of taillight looks like it was just tossed on the ground.

[@DennisD-mv8lg]

judge is linked to people in case . she is bias

[@mazie7952]

Exactly

[@ilovetati91]

that's a ridiculous conspiracy. she literally allowed evidence today on the SOLE basis of relevance to the defense's argument of bias in the police dept

[@MissCherryBomb69]

​@@ilovetati91 chris albert calls her auntie bev so you're completely wrong!!! She knows the family

[@jeanwinders9556]

​@@ilovetati91 judge Bev's brother was the lawyer for Chris Alberts's DUI/Manslaughter case. He was guilty.

[@professorvoluck9311]

It’s absolutely ridiculous that the victim’s brother and sister in law are seated right in Karen’s face. It’s intimidating and she’s innocent until proven guilty. They should be seated on the prosecution side or somewhere behind, where they can’t stare her down.

[@Jina_G]

I thought the same.

[@glo3139]

I thought the same thing, but THEIR TESTIMONY was favorable to Karen: I think the feds have spoken to the family of OFFICER John O’Keefe. No one seems to want to call him by his official name. They seem to forget that he is a brother in blue. His name is Officer John O’Keefe, and I’m speculating about the family, because their testimony wasn’t favorable to the prosecution on the first day. At least I didn’t seem to think so.

[@user-nj9db2tg9w]

Maybe they support Karen

[@jessikat36]

IMO, they believe she is innocent.

[@Anna-cx4tg]

Paul's message exchange with a blogger who injected himself into the case are out there, he believes Karen killed his brother ​@@jessikat36

[@DMiller912]

So much reasonable doubt thus far. At this point, I would vote not guilty.

[@iamtomkills]

Just as well there’s a full trial yet to finish and you’re not on a jury lol.

[@DMiller912]

That's why I said thus far, and at this point . Read much? Never said I was a juror.

[@iamtomkills]

@@DMiller912 you’re not supposed to formulate at this point. Only at the end of the trial there is no thus far. Chill out. I wasn’t trying to offend you.

[@Stefunny99]

@@iamtomkillsKeywords.. “thus far.” Pay attention to details.

[@DMiller912]

No offense taken. Just my opinion at this particular point.

[@angeez82]

HOW does his Family believe this BS case??? He clearly was beat n left outside 🤦‍♀️

[@ellimpiador6559]

Canton people, they stick tagethah. If you wernt bawn theah, not wurth ya time tryin' ta figgah it out.

[@JulieRushworth]

​@ellimpiador6559 I'm in the uk, it's obvious they've set Karen up

[@CatConsten]

I think the altercation was inside AND somewhat outside. Also, the dog reacted to an ensuing fight, attacking John O'Keefe's arm. They left this poor man outside to die in the cold, NOT Karen Read!

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

Clearly huh?? Let’s see..Karen last to see him and found him in a snow back, her broken glass nearby, taillight busted..if my BF didn’t come home I’d be calling people not screaming in front yards..her behavior was not sorrow it was guilt.. two police agencies, all those people and lil ole Karen was framed? My behind.

[@ginafabiani5629]

I agree. I don’t get it but sometimes I wonder if the brother and sister are now starting to see it.

[@Physics072]

Start calling here "Side Bar Sally" So much time wasted on side bars never seen a judge waste that much of the juries time.

[@FakeNewsNJ]

Most trials I watch have headphones instead of sidebars.

[@MissCherryBomb69]

Shes the one wasting the juries time not the defense

[@Physics072]

@@FakeNewsNJ They are old school. I was in a 6 week trial not nearly this many side bars.

[@ThisIsBabyRuth]

Though Judge YSL-Ural Glanville😂

[@ballchain4410]

Glad I don’t live there and have her as a judge! Move the case alone…! Ya let’s rush the fate of someone’s life!!! Wtf!!! How is she even on the bench! And why isn’t the defense going against her as an unfair judge, it’s very clear she is!

[@MissCherryBomb69]

I dont know. I live about a half hr away and this blows my mind. The judge knows the family of the crooked Albert Family

[@es4796]

I’m honestly surprised that they couldn’t get it moved to a completely different jurisdiction knowing how well connected the Albert family is within the police and justice system

[@heidibetweenjewelryandjob7811]

Is it too late (if they haven’t already) to subpoena the phone records of Detective Lank to see who he was talking to that night?

[@MyMagpie]

Right? I hope they have that when the defense has their chance.

[@heidibetweenjewelryandjob7811]

@mymagpie that was a fairly long conversation to not remember who you were talking to on a night like that. Maybe it’s nothing, but worth knowing.

[@sebastiano_Meli]

The feds will handle all the when she’s beats this case

[@Nancyg531]

Judge wouldn’t allow that , she’s in on this whole thing

[@heidibetweenjewelryandjob7811]

@@Nancyg531 But legally I mean…they would still be able to subpoena since case is still going on right?

[@MissX905]

What is the prosecution contending that Ms. Read's vehicle hit the victim on the road or on the lawn? If on the road how would there be so many pieces of the rear taillight be scattered so far onto the lawn and deep under the snow? If he was hit while standing on the lawn where are any marks of a car backing over the curb?

[@JazzyScat]

Not to mention that being more than 6 feet tall 240lbs first thing that a car at 26mph makes impact with are his legs and would be very bruised if not broken. He had none of theses.

[@deborahdeller3110]

Solo cups in a shopping bag, no markings, no evidence tape, I'm going to apply for a police officer position in Canton

[@KhenoronhkhwaJesusIs]

I do believe that skunks smell better than any of these p.o.’s involved in this case.

[@my2cents581]

As long as you are dishonest, slimy, and corrupt, you will definitely be hired and fit right in!

[@scarletbegonias2359]

So a dead guy on my front lawn isn't probably cause for a search?

[@Deborah-k7v]

They are faming Karen something is off here

[@Stefunny99]

Where or who do we go to voice our opinion that this clown judge needs to be removed from this trial? This is RIDICULOUS. She’s so bias it’s sickening.

[@susanwhalls6230]

Is she elected? Probably, all these people complaining prob don’t know their local elected officials

[@Stefunny99]

@@susanwhalls6230 I’m googling trying to find where to file a complaint. Everyone needs to do the same. This judge is a clown. A very bias clown.

[@susanwhalls6230]

@@Stefunny99 I just looked , that community elected her in 2023 & prob most of higher police officials

[@rocsti5402]

Lmao every youtube trial people complain about the judges non stop, most of whom don't even bother to pay attention to local judges or cases. Go figure.

[@mazie7952]

Judge Newman was the best. I've watched a lot of trials. This judge is absolutely annoying.

[@Rae_777]

Dang. Is there a prosecution objection she WON’T sustain? 😮

[@ginafabiani5629]

Nope but she will overrule the defense objections. It’s insane

[@my2cents581]

Im convinced the judge has no idea what “sustained” and “overruled” means! She is an abomination to the justice system! 100% DEI hire.

[@amandameekhael]

Prosecutor is asking the most bare minimum questions. He shows zero emotion for John Okeef, who’s he’s supposed to defend. Look at the difference between him and the team who defended Jennifer Dulous. Huge difference.

[@josephsisson]

What if anything, did the prosecutor, sort of try, if anything, to sort of, do to educate himself, if anyone, to sort of know how he, if anything, could sort of, attempted to ask, if anything, a question that is sort of comprehensible? Do you sort of know what I mean, if anything?

[@jacquelinefriedhof242]

World’s best comment.

[@KhenoronhkhwaJesusIs]

🤭!!

[@MissCherryBomb69]

😂😂

[@CatConsten]

It's amazing how this judge admonished attorney's regarding the presentation of evidence. This woman is fighting for her life. However much time it takes to present evidence, let it be. FREE Karen Read! JUSTICE for John O'Keefe!!🙏🏻

[@marandarose8012]

How does someone not know if they've ever used evidence tape before????

[@michele6873]

The judge seems SO biased to me and I've truly had an open mind.

[@catdad33]

How so? Bc she’s been super fair in everything I’ve seen.

[@michele6873]

@@catdad33 There have been a number of instances where she seems exasperated by the defense. It's in her tone and language. Even when she admonishes 'both sides' she looks directly at the defense. As an observer, I should not get the feeling that she favors the Commonwealth.

[@_kc20]

@@michele6873yes 👏🏻💯

[@notsorryyouretriggered]

@@catdad33🤣 You cant be serious

[@Stefunny99]

@@notsorryyouretriggered seriously. Must be an Albert in the comment section. It’s SO apparent and appalling how bias this judge is.

[@kristyb4466]

I thought we weren’t going to keep having repetitive testimony? How many times do we need to hear testimony about the weather conditions?

[@Whatareyagonnado777]

Case stinks so bad it’s not even funny , framework at its finest , free this poor girl .

[@kingduran007]

She is not totally innocent either Driving while highly intoxicated And who knows what else really went on that night with her

[@loveandhappiness304]

2:39:35 That officer on the stand is ready for a couple of dirty martinis or old Cuban after being on the stand today. Lesson here is. DON'T BE A DIRTY LAW ENFORCEMENT.

[@KhenoronhkhwaJesusIs]

Lank lunkhead is what passes as a p.o. there in Canton?

[@LostInBoston617]

3:01:07 She seems to cough to signal Lally to object, which she naturally sustains. Anyone else catching that?

[@Jina_G]

Yep.

[@angeez82]

Judge clearly bias towards defense and why aren’t they ever there a full day ??? With everything thus far especially injuries, cocktail glass, missing items, and dog bite he was clearly beat up n placed outside.

[@buntybaggins536]

This judge cant wait to sustain the prosecutors objections! Ive seen her elicit objection herself!

[@KTD1988]

Oh my gosh , so Officer Goode just testified that in 2009 Timothy Albert (brother of Brian Albert) was involved in a moter vehicle accident , fled the scene and drove to 34 Fairview and was arrested! Judge only lets the Defense “very briefly” question on it. Canton PD Lank and Goode got him off with only a misdemeanor! Chris Albert also involved in MVA but led to the death of someone! In this case the Judge’s brother got the case to only 6 months in jail! Chris Albert also involved in a bar fight and case was dismissed. When the defense attorney asked about Tim Albert case getting dismissed, the judge immediately striked and asked for a side bar. 😳 Judge then concludes by saying “the Alberts aren’t one entity”. 😮. Sure seem to be one corrupt and gross family and this judge is BIASED

[@hotpinkthread]

Is the teeth/tongue smacking sound before speaking a Massachusetts thing, or a cop thing. It seems like every single witness so far is doing it. It is soooo frustrating to listen to.

[@AmyPigula]

His face says it all. It says “I did a really bad job of investigating.” Face of regret.

[@davidmack3806]

Question. Hopefully the difference asks, was the rest of the broken glass in the bag, if not, where is the rest of it?

[@cholewess4137]

This judge seems so irritated every time she is asked permission to approach, chill out.

[@aynrandcansuckit4016]

WHERE THE ACTUAL F is the other shoe ? Missing along with the dog?

[@JenniferCrompton-ux7ud]

Since when does the objecting attorney NOT have to say what grounds their objecting on? I’ve never seen a judge just say “sustained” before even asking for the objection grounds, such as hearsay, 403B, council testifying, etc. and then she doesn’t let the other side argue their objection to the objection.!

[@joditurrisi6004]

FFS, so many sidebars, we should start a poole on the total ending sidebar count ...

[@kstern214]

the judge’s impatience with the defense - whether it be questioning a witness, making an argument, or locating documents - and her loud sighs are inappropriate. her favoritism towards the prosecution is evident, and her behavior is infringing on the defense and likely impacting the jury’s view of the defendant.

[@dianesweat6015]

Judge is somewhat biased and way too many side bars

[@missychelle33]

Somewhat? No. She’s totally and completely biased

[@missychelle33]

Somewhat? No. She’s totally and completely biased

[@ilovetati91]

@@missychelle33 delusional karen fan

[@my2cents581]

“SOMEWHAT”?

[@ballchain4410]

I’ve never seen a case where the judge is calling side bar so many times….

[@Physics072]

Was there a police Memo given out that said "If you are a Boston or Canton Police officer and are in the area of the court house during the Defense cross examination. Please blast your sirens to intimidate the witnesses or show support, either way please blast away." ?

[@IronEaglet-ru8zb]

How many McAlberts are in these comment threads? Straight Outta Canton

[@jacquelinefriedhof242]

😂

[@Anna-cx4tg]

Meanwhile, Karen has a PR team she pays 3k per month but I'm sure her people are not commenting here, oh no.

[@IronEaglet-ru8zb]

@@Anna-cx4tg. Do you have proof of this? I think i know more than 99.9% of the public, I’ve probably put 1000 hours into studying this case, and I’ve never heard that.

[@IronEaglet-ru8zb]

@@Anna-cx4tg I seriously doubt this is accurate. Karen Read doesn’t need a PR team, they have all the facts on their side and the public knows it. The worst case of law enforcement corruption I’ve ever seen. Despicable.

[@amandakayanderson5532]

30 minutes into their 4 hour trial and she already wants a break. Yet she tells the defense attorney HE is wasting the juries time? 😆 she is a joke on top corrupt. No, she just wants him to stop giving them evidence that proves how corrupt her friends are. I will not be shocked if she refuses anymore evidence and blames it on time.

[@rsera42O]

😂

[@Arkivious]

Did you check anywhere in the house for the possibility of a fight? “No I wouldn’t have probable cause to do so.” Aren’t you guys friends? 😂 3:07:14

[@kazmel024]

3:01:15 the judge coughs during the questioning and coincidentally has no more coughs when the prosecutor objects 😂 this trial is a joke

[@robertcomtois2074]

She told the defense not to much more in open court in front of the jury that sounds highly prejudicial to me

[@rsera42O]

Yes, that is correct… if guilty an appellate attorney would get her case overturned easy… this is just ridiculous at best! Hey judge 👩‍⚖️ this is not justice… she needs to be investigated.,. Seriously…. 😳

[@AliceNsWonderland]

If you blew away the snow, down to ground where John's body was found... WHY DIDN'T YOU FIND THE PLASTIC THEN?!? *BC IT WASN'T IN THE SNOW YET!!!*

[@michaelcalland801]

Anyone who’s ever had a broken taillight knows they don’t” Shatter”… Especially into 45 pieces…. She hit a person..” allegedly “ not a brick wall

[@IrishEyes333]

I have to admit, I'm not convinced of her guilt. It's just not time to render a decision. I will say, my heart aches for the O'Keefe family. Their grief is palpable. There will be no winners in this case.

[@wls1020]

Funny how nobody "recalls" the basement door even though it is right next to where they enter the house

[@carolinagirl740]

I swear this trial becomes more like Perry Mason everyday thanks to the brilliant defense team.

[@lisabuchan4075]

Karen is a PhD....so she is Dr. Read, correct? If so, they should refer to her, as such.

[@kayvee9094]

Yeah a doctor just like Dr. Jill. Lol

[@mazie7952]

Sloppy job by cops. Solo cops stop and shop bags. 🙄

[@jessicastotallyoverthetopb8418]

Also where is John's shoe

[@jennyharshbarger4388]

Every time that judge “coughs” the prosecution objects 🤔 anyone else notice that?

[@my2cents581]

The judge objects on behalf of the State!

[@jerinli3038]

Defense is brutal today...sneakily throwing in evidence that was brought in outside of jury presence. Wow!

[@lisabuchan4075]

That is their job!

[@wavylos9029]

@@lisabuchan4075😅😅😅😅😅 if I pay a lawyer over 50k and his strategy is to sneak exhibits , he will end up in the Charle’s River by the end of the day … they are high maintenance Bums 😂😂😂😂😂, I’ll give Jackson credit on his wordplay but not going to change my mind on him having a lil penis 😊😊

[@rocsti5402]

A fair trial is the job of both attorneys. Doing shady stuff like this doesn't serve true justice.

[@LeannaMurphy-mx7zy]

😂because we haven’t seen that prosecution and witnesses are shady? Priceless

[@michaelcalland801]

You have prosecution witnesses that testified at the grand jury a year ago saying one thing & then showing up at trial dropping brand new statements like…” I heard Karen Read say I hit him”. Very odd thing to come up with out of the blue at trial. You don’t think that was by design

[@_Jsin211]

Why does it look like everyone in Boston has resting b face

[@TammyMacMac]

Because they do...lol Born and raised there. Always told I had that 😂

[@rosemarygallagher3076]

Because Karen is fighting for her life.

[@BellaNY00]

😂😂🤦‍♀️🤷‍♀️

[@joshuahickman8239]

All of New England is like that. The cold weather freezes permanent RBF on everyone.

[@lisabuchan4075]

Hungover, as they are big drinkers!

[@Ashlee_Oak21]

Mr lally GAG on the prosecution side looks very red after that defense on officer lank hahahaha this is a disgrace of our police and justice system.

[@KhenoronhkhwaJesusIs]

Previous job title prior to the J.O. murder case as for Lank in Canton: Pooper Scooper. Talk about “dirty”.

[@melissa74066]

One thing was isn’t setting well with me is the fact that the victim was found right in the yard. Why would his killers dump him 20 feet from their front porch ?

[@gretchensims6657]

It could very well be that no one dumped him but that a fight occurred somewhere in it around the house and then he stumbled out of the house and fell where he was found. The sad truth is that we will never likely know the truth of his death due to the insanely sloppy job done by this department. I don’t entirely blame them as they don’t handle unattended death investigations and the state police refused to take it on initially leave this Barney Fife dept to “do their best” in the beginning.

[@DMiller912]

So many side bars!!!

[@lauraburke9188]

I loled when he said the crime scene tape wasn't doing its job cause SIR! Pot meet kettle.

[@lb2645]

Today its said hes 8 feet off the road. Its been said even further already. But no car tracks thru the yard?? No obvious demt in the pile of snow that usualy lines the side of a street in snow country as many know. No massive damage from this jumpung of a curb and lawn driving mid winter storm. Makes no sense if ypu know anything about living in the snow and how it packs when driven on acumulates in storms . Is plowed to the side.

[@Anna-cx4tg]

What car tracks, it snowed for hours afterwards

[@lb2645]

@@Anna-cx4tg there would still be a layer of packed snow under the soft snow that was blown away from the top.. common occurance when a vehicle drives over snow. Anyone who has ever backed out their driveway without shoveling first would understand what I'm describing.

[@AliceNsWonderland]

Wouldn't the taillight pieces be on the road, where the accident allegedly happened and not 12ft away?