Lawyer Reacts: AMBER TAKES THE STAND Depp v Heard Trial Day 15 Part 1 Recap

Amber Heard is back on the stand giving her side of the story.
The divorced movie stars' trial began April 11 in Fairfax County, Virginia, and is broadcasting live.
As always, I will recap in the beginning and then take questions for the remainder of the time.
#AmberHeard #DeppVHeard #JohnnyDepp
Amber Heard's witness list: www.fairfaxcou....
Johnny Depp's witness list: www.fairfaxcou....
🔴 Do you or someone you know need to speak to a real lawyer about a case? Or do you find yourself needing legal advice? Please reach out to our firm and we will make sure to answer your questions or find someone who can. Our consultations are always free and confidential. You can call our firm at [phone] or email us at [e-mail].
✅ For business inquiries contact me at [e-mail]
✅ Let's connect: www.tragoslaw....
Twitter - @tragoslaw
Instagram - /tragoslaw
Facebook - /tragoslaw
TikTok - /tragoslaw
✅ Join our email list here - bit.ly/33lV3Mb
Get your Lawyer You Know merch here - bit.ly/LYKMerch
🔴 NOT LEGAL ADVICE

[@soldiergirl4603]

Did you notice that when Johnny testified, Amber stared at him the whole time and when Amber is testifying Johnny avoids eye contact? I’m not a psychologist, but as a victim of violence, I’ve learned that the victim tends to avoid eye contact with abuser to avoid rehashing the experiences or feelings associated with them. The abuser, however, will stare at the victim as a sign of their continued dominance over them.

[@ElReyMrz1]

watch ben chew flip her off for johnny while staring at her 48:07 kzbin.info/www/bejne/gXbVZmqug55_hrM

[@martistlouis]

thats what the body / language expert said ..... EXACTLY

[@irenebradshaw9613]

The only way I could have looked at my abuser was by a cosmic telescope or a psychic medium !! Believe me you are terrified of them you do NOT make eye contact not ever you want to be a zillion miles away from them. She is lying through her back teeth.

[@theresabrown5395]

This is very heartless.

[@carolinecoy3164]

Johnny couldn't win either way. If he had looked at her, people would have said he was trying to intimidate her, because he didn't look at her,it meant he was guilty. But no-one cared that she glared at him non stop. She was 100% trying to intimidate him. I loved the bit where she said... He won't look at me cos he's guilty,there's a clip of Johnny saying to Ben chew, I don't want to.. and a clip of her seeing him say that and she looks fuming 😂😂 she stared him down so much,cage was trying everything to get his attention. What victim would want their "abuser's" attention. Truth is, if she was that scared of him, she would have requested that she wasn't testifying directly opposite him. And they would have swapped positions of where they sat. But she clearly didn't care.

[@juliesmith1402]

At one point she stated that blood sprayed across a SMEG fridge, not the wall. That detail disappeared when a receipt showed that they hadn't bought it yet.

[@sidda7085]

Pretty much every detail of her story has been disproven by pictures, testimony, recorded conversations, & receipts 🤦🏼‍♀️ She was far too confident in her abilities as a liar & didn’t make sure her lies added up.

[@willygonutz9687]

They have GOT TO get all these inconsistencies together and present them to the court

[@gulfgal98]

I do not think Johnny really cares about the money but he wants the win. Johnny wants to clear his name and be rid of this horrible toxic woman forever. BTW, Camille did a great job today.

[@Romne]

Oh he cares about the money. The man has a very expensive lifestyle with very expensive taste, etc.

[@lindadee6603]

Hello Nancy. i think your right.

[@Laura_Seicean]

@@Romne she has a fortune of 2,5 milions dollars, he has 100 millions dollars. She doesn t have the money to pay him, also if he has so expensive lifestyle and taste, why isn t he already broke? He didn t have work in the last years. It is not about the money, the only thing he will accomplish is letting the world know what really happened and exposing her lies.

[@willygonutz9687]

Same

[@dianemilligan7370]

I think he is winning just by the exposure of her behavior - whether he wins or loses this trial, anyone who has heard the tapes and seen her on the stand knows she was the abuser. Though I do still hope he wins the verdict for ultimate vindication for all men who have been silently abused.

[@klee4d]

Funny how Scamber takes pics of Johnny asleep in a chair and on a sofa but has no pictures of all her beatings!

[@scottkain8977]

I was literally thinking the same exact thing to the letter. She has multiple pictures of Johnny passed out on various locations...but she does not have a single picture of her injuries or a medical report or anything that resembles her alleged "beatings". It really does smell like horse sh*t,

[@webexpertcharlie]

If Depp loses this, I think we need to take a serious look at the jury system in this country

[@jakeand9020]

Well, I think the general consensus is he's currently winning. The mainstream has already started the narrative. Depp - a "white, straight, wealthy male" - has a better chance of winning. And that, "has nothing to do with the case, and everything to do with society."

[@willygonutz9687]

Yeah. But even when he wins, 'Justice' shouldn't cost you your dignity, your privacy and the privacy of your friends and family. Not to mention the $$$$$. This is not something the 'average guy' would have been able to do. The justice system is f#¢ked. .... this is coming from Australia, but I think it's the same all over

[@lb8781]

... but we are supposed to 'always believe the woman' ... "Me Too" ... what a joke

[@scarletcourt9026]

It was weird how she didn’t bring up any negative issues about herself. That’s not realistic at all.

[@rodneylee4026]

Not even once that I can recall.

[@snayezulu7251]

That put me off too. Johnny never hid his demons which made him more believable. Nope, not Amber. She’s a perfect princess.

[@nGUNNARp]

unable to admit to even the most minor of faults (or not even faults, but things that could be considered faults by others)...just like Dr. Curry said, self righteous and holds everyone else to this high moral standard that she herself doesn't follow but thinks she does

[@RS-or8sh]

Like she never really took drugs...in her nurses notes she admits she used to use coke and take shrooms and mdma and is on a load of prescription ones.....but she makes out she doesn't really do them

[@MAINECOONLADY]

AH tried to show humility by admitting JD "has much more money, bigger name star & more impressive career."

[@amandaslade9072]

Yet 14 years with Vanessa who had a very active and successful modelling, acting and music career hmmm. Also his daughter now modelling and acting and he's very supportive. 4 years with Wynona who was building a successful acting career, he was very proud of her!

[@RS-or8sh]

I thought that...doesn't fit with JD being controlling over what she wears etc etc

[@voiboi]

Dont forget Kate Moss.. she supported him as well

[@carolinecoy3164]

​@@RS-or8shI think he would say things about some things she was wearing. If you look at the photo while she was at Coachella, she was sat with the shortest shorts on, a vest top that barely covered her tits,and had her legs wrapped around some guy. I'm sure most men would question that. Bit she'd just been attacked by JD according to her testimony. That's not how you'd be acting after such an horrifying ordeal if you ask me. Then take so many drugs that anything could happen to you. She's so full of shite it's ridiculous.

[@footyball66]

One thing I noticed was that on several occasions she started her 'crying' episodes when talking about the relationship breaking down, but at times didn't 'cry' when talking about the abuse. Especially at the beginning of her testimony. Not sure you'd be crying about the relationship breaking down 6 years after the fact, especially when that person 'abused' you.

[@SA-Bean-Bean]

Exactly! And notice how she can literally snap back immediately from the fake FAKE EXTREMELY FAKE forlorn and suddenly magically be able to act like nothing is wrong! Ive been through every trauma there is my entire life repeatedly and whenever im talking about it i NEVER STARE INTO PEOPLES EYES LIKE THAT AND CERTAINLY DONT STARE DIRECTLY AT MY ABUSERS WHEN CONFRONTING THEM LIKE SHE HAS! And tbh, im not going to sit and cry all dramatically like she pretended to after so many years later- when recalling abuse i dont cry like that at all bc you learn to cope and to hide the pain and allowing it to surface again takes so much therapy- not being on a witness stand! She is so full of sht

[@sidda7085]

Plus the only times she smiled was recounting her relationship with Depp.

[@carina-jaipaul1342]

Here in Australia, if you get caught lying on the stand you will do jail time no ifs or buts.. Judges here do not tolerate it at all…

[@eternaljewelleryuk]

It’s a shame the US isn’t like that because she deserves to be locked up 😏

[@Dynomite132010]

Then AH should be jailed... correct me if I am wrong but I thought AH was guilty of lying about bringing her dogs into the country and having others lie about it. If it's true will she face charges?

[@eternaljewelleryuk]

@@Dynomite132010 I’m pretty sure she can’t return to Australia because she will be arrested but I’m not sure what it’s over.

[@sara_387]

@@eternaljewelleryuk I also read that she couldn't return to Australia...it caused problems for Aquaman 2, because she couldn't use a special set on the Gold Coast. It was reported that the FBI investigated (on Australia's behalf) the claims that came out of the UK trial that she coerced one of JD's staff into perjuring themselves during the court case in Australia over the dog smuggling. It was reported that they were considering perjury charges for AH (and possibly others involved) if she ever returned, but possibly they just refused entry to Australia. She was charged with making a false declaration on a customs form, which can result in the person's visa being cancelled.

[@patricknez7258]

I feel like in America, lying on the stand is almost like a given. Or at least lying in court or in legal matters. I see so many shows and vids about diff people lying in court, suspects witnesses even cops and investigators in some of them 😔 maybe I'm cynical or I have confirmation bias.. to be fair, there probably aren't as many shows and vids about straightforward, seemingly honest cases lol. That just occurred to me 😅

[@lilypina9073]

She would not have been able to walk well the next day if he was being that forceful with the bottle.

[@martistlouis]

she could walk down the next AM, find her rapist AND MAKE HIM A CUP OF COFFEE ?

[@lareinedubois]

My thoughts exactly.

[@lb8781]

... when she describes being raked with the bottle she says she felt pain in her "pubic bone"... wrong anatomy, wrong words, wrong, wrong ... this is pure confabulation ...

[@samanthamelesenka4785]

I was beaten to the point of a concussion in a domestic violence instance, my mom was almost murdered by my father... THIS WOMAN is FULL OF SHIT. I'm literally sick to my stomach watching someone lie about domestic violence. Her testimony is a slap in the face of every man or woman who has dealt with this trauma. (Pun intended!) I hope he is awarded every penny and she NEVER works again.

[@eefgilbert9468]

And she goes into treatment.

[@TricommStrategies]

I'm sorry you had to experience that. I have luckily never been in that situation so I can't imagine how horrific it must be for someone who has to watch this farce.

[@sl8605]

I never wish bad on anyone, but she deserves it.

[@cazh3768]

Love to you, my skin is crawling also x

[@Masi1900]

I'm sorry you had such a terrifying experience. Much love to you ❤️

[@jennxreads]

The biggest red flag for me is how she makes herself out to be perfect. We have HEARD the tapes and she wasn’t perfect. This makes me doubt everything she says.

[@nancyyyy1001]

That’s literally what I noticed, no accountability, it’s everyone else’s fault smh

[@kathychallender7579]

She could have said that yes she yelled and was loud and crying while she was trying to get through to JD!

[@DubaiShortsChannel]

This is how people tell stories, come on

[@lotusthemermaid]

The *soup kitchen* lmao

[@mariaorourke5866]

Very true. None of us is perfect and it is impressive that Johnny Depp seems willing to stand up and be counted

[@amairanifox1332]

How is crying without any tears!!

[@ParodyWhitney]

She’s crazy.. kzbin.info/www/bejne/bJvWoqCiaKZjbLM

[@austindreher2791]

I know right. When I cry I have tears running down my face.

[@krishnamahabir3333]

You are the only JD trial You-tuber I subscribed to. You are balanced, educational and tries to avoid gossiping. Great job.

[@ElReyMrz1]

That what is any after every objection was crazy. Amber just answers the original question. Also telling amber things she forgot was very troubling! She was testifying along with her!

[@patriciachianelli7507]

Thought her testimony today was worse then then yesterday. Too off the wall.

[@rolo4945]

True, same as Dawn Hughes

[@deborahmcgee7970]

How can they get away with that

[@ElReyMrz1]

at least Ben Chew got to casually flip Amber off on the stand watch at 48:07 kzbin.info/www/bejne/gXbVZmqug55_hrM

[@amandaslade9072]

People seem to forget that whether a private or commercial Jet, the Captain is governed by the same aviation rules and responsibilities. There is no way everyone on that plane just stood by and did nothing! Many of Security are ex Police too.

[@carina-jaipaul1342]

Don’t forget that Elaine said in her opening that AH will show us how she applied the Malani Colour Correcting Compact for the different days of apparent bruises… Let’s see if this really happens…

[@jessisamess8]

I’ve been waiting on this !!

[@javieratoledo9262]

She didn’t specify brand…

[@carina-jaipaul1342]

@@javieratoledo9262 in the video it clears shows when the camera gets a close up that says Malani written on the front in gold.. So much so that Malani has seen it and commented on it…

[@fionarangel9486]

They haven't finished with AH yet

[@javieratoledo9262]

@@carina-jaipaul1342 she showed a corrector palette and didn’t specify brand. Elaine clearly was meaning she carried make up to cover bruises. Of course she doesn’t wear a supermarket brand…

[@vickimills3915]

Great coverage , what got my attention today was she stated he bashed her dragged her threw blood, raped her and she was scared he was going to kill her but when it was over she then took 2 sleeping pills and went to sleep for a few hours and then woke up and went down stairs to make him a cup of coffee -REALLY I DONT THINK SO

[@simonew.3651]

And what's really irritating me about that: when he was passed out during/after the Bosten flight she was too scared to go home with him!

[@vall2633]

Yeah, that one! 🤔 how could she even walk after all that?

[@charmainegalloway7863]

This is exactly my issue. And Elaine focused on 3 days. So per Amber she went through all that trauma but didn't tell anyone or try get to a hospital or get someone to be with her. No. Just sleep and wake up the nxt day late morning and want to make him coffee (after being assaulted, raped and slapped). Then she said she saw the finger then only, so saying she wasn't present she doesn't know what happened to his finger). The he was peeing messages so she was confused and they put her in a theater and wanted to drug her. After that she went upstairs and took a third of what they wanted to give her. OK. So then she slept again (this is day 2). Then Elaine tells Amber to tell the jury what she noticed on the 3rd day.. Esp wrt food.. Which is where the mashed potatoes smeared all over comes in). This is also when Amber tries to pack clothes without paint on it and discovers steak rolled up in her bath robe. Then somewhere after she flies back to LA with Ben King. But also says she continued to find meat rolled up in pieces of her robe for the next few days? How... She just took a flight... And then per the other witnesseses they looked for Johnny's fingertip and when they eventually found it out it on ice and took him to hospital.. This was all the same day.. According to them. Here is an audio which then corroborates the testimony from Dr Kipper and Ben King. I am unsure how Amber spaced one event over 3 days.. If someone can figure it out. kzbin.info/www/bejne/jHWzaoGMhtKcjtk

[@lifehealingmagic]

#EXACTLY

[@amithorpe]

and weren't the sleeping pills Ambien?

[@vivienleigh4640]

I forgot two, JD couldn't help saying "Wow" when she claimed to want to protect his children. She was obviously jealous of them, that they got any of his attention (narciss...).

[@RS-or8sh]

@@user-bv1ss5nj9b I thought that. What a strange way to describe them

[@merissaesposito8485]

Whats funny is she said he brutally assulted her in numerous ways BUT YET she was granted a restraining order and she begged for him to break it and talk to her ! Thats not a victim thats a manipulator !

[@willygonutz9687]

Yep. ....... and that restraining order, ... she took it out the day before (or the day after) he left to go on a world tour with his band The Hollywood Vampires. 🤔

[@carolinecoy3164]

​@@willygonutz9687exactly. Why would you need a restraining order for someone no where near you for months. It was utter stupidity that she claimed she didn't know his schedule at that time.😒

[@sallymoore7415]

She was surrounded by all her friends who lived in johnnys penthouses rent free 💁🏼‍♀️ how could she say she had no one!

[@deborahmcgee7970]

Sally Moore people who didn’t follow it all along might believe her I don’t. He gave her everything

[@yianhinsaechao7898]

amber also said.. " johnny never let me see my friends......." MEANWHILE HER FRIENDS LIVES WITH THEM RENT FREE 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂!!

[@deborahmcgee7970]

👍🇮🇪 justice for Johnny call go Jonny go go go ☘️🇮🇪🇮🇪🙏☘️🇮🇪🇮🇪

[@martistlouis]

they all USED Johnny ! pathetic

[@jdr9419]

Amber is making a mockery out of DV victims as well as victims of SA past and presence, in my opinion. While DV and SA victims are often not believed as it is, this pathetic performance will ensure victims of SA and DV will be looked upon with even more skepticism and disdain due to her performances.

[@Sneakystealz]

100% agree. I've been seeing people coming out today, who have been victims of DV and expressing how much hate they have for Amber for this kind of mockery.

[@cococgb5389]

I hope that’s not the case 🙏🏻 AH is the New Face / Poster Girl for Abuser !!!

[@BeautifulBeastie]

I said the same thing.....a mockery of victims trauma.

[@missdaisysunshine8633]

Agreed and infuriating

[@ChristinaLIbbotson]

In her opening answer Amber stated that she’s in court because her ex-husband is suing her for an op-ed she wrote.

[@missdaisysunshine8633]

Yup

[@amydraughon7632]

Which contradicts what was said originally

[@rchambers1993]

Her lack of ability to show emotion, especially when not speaking and looking around the room for approval.. also turning off the display of emotion instantly rings of sociopathy..they actually do not have feelings but display the appearance of emotions as others expect them to..

[@luv2cre84]

Yes!!!!💯💯💯

[@CocoAzoitei]

💯

[@martistlouis]

BUT will the JURY see

[@rchambers1993]

@@martistlouis honestly, I’m praying to God that they do..

[@lb8781]

... they are witnessing a hysterical actress' bad performance!

[@kardiojunkee]

She stated she was not only punched in the arm and then with all his rings on wrestled her to the floor and continuously punched her in the face. She takes a photo of her arm of this abuse - her face is in the pic. No marks on her face!! The bruise itself seemed to be in a later stage of healing . She seems to recover quickly from being traumatized and “crying “ to a normal tone of voice back to her own narrative story telling. Bad acting - not believable!!!!

[@MB-bh9ic]

And she mentions him grabbing her by the neck there wasn’t one mark on her neck in those photos and remember she has inflicted injuries to herself in the past

[@cherilauterio2658]

I saw another video from someone who lives at the condominiums where Johnny and Amber lived and she said that the door to the pool is very heavy and she has gotten the same bruises on her arm from that door

[@martistlouis]

all those beatings and a few pics of a FEW mild scuffs - THE WAY SHE SAYS IT , HE BEAT THE LIVING CRAP out of her . and he's threatening to kill her ? she takes pills and goes to bed?

[@kardiojunkee]

@@martistlouis Yes!!! You’re a victim of SA, where your assailant states they are going to f*kn kill you….. after the assault , you fearing for your life and safety stay vigilant to protect yourself from further abuse and possible impending death by taking sleeping pills- WTF!!! Doesn’t make sense whatsoever . All pics in evidence from AH side with respect to the Australia incident are all photos of the house, not the beaten marks of a SA, DV survivor…. How the hell is this even remotely a credible defence??!!! She is making it harder for both men and women who suffer DV, SA to come forward, all to boost her ego and further her career. We all know she pushed her op-ed piece through during her movie promotion. Absolutely SHAMEFUL!!! I hope JD is able to recover from the continuous manipulation, verbal, emotional and physical abuse at the hands of a BPD assailant. If justice prevails (which it hardly does lately) he will win back his reputation and his career. She should get everything coming to her- karma’s a bitch!!!!

[@cranberrycobbler]

I believe on at least two times today Amber contradicted her own testimony.

[@amydraughon7632]

Exactly right. I can't remember the instances but I caught that too

[@stephanypasnin1474]

I love how her memory is scattered when the finger is severed. All this abuse and she still goes back. I live in Australia and all i remember is the dogs, what happened to them. She went to hospital after finger incident and she says nothing to hospital about hands, arms , feet , pubic bone , face being cut. She doesnt remember phone call at airport just them crying on the phone. And the security guy says she was yelling abuse at them when he left to go to hospital, she says she was so worried about him. And again she goes back.

[@fionarangel9486]

It's not just the security guy that said she was shouting at them when he was trying to get Johnny out of the house in Australia - it's on a tape recording ffs! It's not like she's not been privvy to all these recordings and witness statements is it - she's been sitting there the whole time! Surely she's deluded??? I say all that but I really hope to god we are right and Johnny didn't do those things, because I would be mortified. I guess that's part of the problem isn't it - she's gone so far that it's making people feel even worse for not believing her

[@martistlouis]

@@fionarangel9486 she's created DOUBT in that JURY - all she needed to do

[@Ms007ilovejesus]

Surely there’ll be one or more jurors that’d be tempted to look online. People aren’t as honest as we’d like to think. Without admitting it how could that influence sway the others?

[@amydraughon7632]

If they don't already see what we see then johnny is fkd. God I hope they do

[@annikajohansson9171]

As long as they look online and not at TV like Fox News, Johnny will be okay.

[@howareyou857]

Yeah but they wont be able to use it as 'evidence' in summation

[@nataliegriffin7727]

At the very least, I'm sure they have friends and family watching who can give them the run down over phone lol

[@VoyagetoLove]

When I was juror on a similar type of case jurors did a tiny bit outside research because when there are alot of obvious holes in the case, it's human nature to want to fill those holes in. Also I couldn't stop my family members for ranting about the case.

[@baseballnan55]

70% of chat not subscribers? Come on guys--this guy does a great review!

[@christiturner1275]

She acted like she was Johnny’s savior.

[@martistlouis]

and his daughter hates her but. SHE LOVES THOSE CHILDREN ! BS

[@carljohnson8017]

It's a real pleasure to listen to a gentleman who does not need to use bad language to make his point. Thanks!

[@themothership1981]

A lot of people were saying that the bruising around her eyes and stuff was from Botox.

[@TM-wk4qu]

I thought the same!! Camille was on her game, but why did it take until today for her to show up? The best they got the book of evidence out for Amber's attorney

[@sl8605]

Almost had to turn the tv off when Amber was talking about being SA with wine bottle and Elaine kept saying "I'm sorry, I am so sorry" it was quite sickening!

[@martistlouis]

but it didn't hurt and she could walk after AND MAKE HIM A CUP OF COFFEE ......

[@penelopecort6852]

Brilliant observation from Janee about the iphone being 3 years old on the arm bruise photo - could this be the phone always used when she's messing with metadata so we can't tell the date a photo was taken . Ummmm .............

[@helenaweeks4628]

Couple of times I picked up on Elaine asking something along the lines of “are you sure?” And then Amber would give a more ambiguous answer because she had obviously answered wrong the first time. The instance I recall was a date AH was asked for and answered pretty confidently “March 3” which must have been wrong because like I say, Elaine gave her another chance to answer.

[@deborahmcgee7970]

That’s a disgrace you won’t need to do that if you were telling the truth. I can still remember from Decades ago they would want to stop that shenanigans so they would. Justice for Jonny love from Ireland 🇮🇪 ☘️❤️💐🙏🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪

[@freebirddee2620]

She gives a lot on leading questions too.... ambers clearly forgetting her lines x

[@candigaler1845]

Her lawyer was so leading with her yesterday and I think trying to rain her in but they couldn’t cos she thought she was on a movie set I can’t with her she is insane and dr curry i applaude you 👏👏

[@alquimiaazul]

Depp team was happy when she mention Kate Moss

[@wildheartarabians7099]

I so agree! I have been asking why his attorneys were being so under-active all along! Given their fees, the job they are doing so far is quite lacking!

[@valg.3270]

It is like Johnny’s is trying to NOT be annoying. I didn’t watch much today, but it seems like Amber’s team doesn’t have their act together.

[@vall2633]

I think it is tactics, they are allowing her to gang herself with her over speaking and contradicting herself and acting.

[@abird1539]

There's that old saying: "Give a man enough rope and he'll hang himself". They're letting her stack up her 'stories' and they can later- like a bowling ball-- STRIKE! Letting her do herself in.

[@lindasmart6450]

When you cry, some of the tears run down your face. But some of them drain from the lacrimal sac, up near your eyes, down the nasolacrimal duct to the inferior meatus. In the inferior meatus, the tears mix with the mucus that your sinuses produce, giving you a runny nose. This cannot be faked hence Heard struggles to moisten a single tissue!

[@ImagineINMontana]

Saves tissue!

[@gorey4more837]

Super interesting info! Thank you for it!👍

[@rchambers1993]

Interesting tidbit.. I watched an old interview of Johnny Depp in his earlier acting days he used the words “getting rid of the monster” he was referring to the media.. not about himself at all. She recorded him in a way to set him up to sound like he was talking about himself

[@cococgb5389]

Wow that’s so interesting!!

[@janethowgate3514]

From watching a few different body analysts , they Refer to to the monster as Johnnys outside persona. The monster is NOT part of Johnny. The monster, Johnny has brought up in interviews over many many years. This is NOT just secluded to Amber Heard. #justiceforjohnny

[@shelbyschnoor9369]

I like how straightforward you are, you help me challenge my biases in this case. Love your channel!

[@laracroce5814]

Peter, check out “The Behavior Panel”. They’re serious. We’re talking military instructiors, resistance to interrogation instructors, etc. They are analyzing JD and did AH on her old depo too. You should look them up. They’re great.

[@rosestewart1606]

I agree. they're the best out there given that there are 4 of them with different backgrounds. they do a lot of legal work and as to how they are used in a court case, they can evaluate a witness and figure out where they are or are not being truthful. this gives the lawyers a heads up as to where they can poke holes. but honestly the interrogations may be the most important part.

[@abird1539]

I've checked them out too. Varied backgrounds, quite 'expert', thorough and believable. I like their analyses.

[@rhondamalotte5073]

Thanks for noting the discrepancy between JD's controlling behavior and adamant refusal to consider a prenuptial.

[@shaylyc]

Did you see when Johnny got close and she “acted” so afraid?

[@lamamama2680]

I was waiting for anyone else to pick up on this! He clearly was trying to just leave same as he always does following the officer I'm waiting for her to manipulate that

[@nickgallagher8054]

I watched a video saying she quoted The Talented Mr. Ripley word for word.

[@shirleyg9225]

Yes, read and heard that, too!

[@therealdeal3672]

I never realized lawyer is a verb as well as a noun!

[@paulacothren3591]

Honestly, the Q&A is the best part of all these videos.

[@Onlyasking-b3s]

I think JD's lawyers are holding back and setting her up for a fall

[@Gigi-rk7dr]

Once the jury hears an answer- striking it is for formality only- you can’t strike it from their memory.

[@MC-zv6dc]

AH said the SA happened on the counter. Later the lawyer "clarified" that it happened on the ping pong table.

[@martistlouis]

no ping pong table would hold two people up

[@heftyhefty_]

Ping pong tables barely hold solo cups.

[@violimo]

Elaine's voice is harshing Amber's melodramatic buzz.

[@leeanne8702]

Camille was awesome today. She was ON her game, and while she objected, she was very respectful, unlike Elaine….

[@britvica]

How? Ah just hears the question and the other is already screaming objection? I'd go crazy. I'd tell her to go f herself, either let me speak or I can go. But that was rediculus: AH just opens the mouth and that one is objecting. No wonder AH forgets the question, who wouldn't 🤦‍♀️

[@nancyyyy1001]

Oh god that Elaine😂 even the judge is tired of her, i can’t even dislike her shes too hilarious 😆

[@Hunny3761]

Thanks!

[@scarletcourt9026]

I don’t doubt the nasty verbal and emotional abuse from both sides. I do, however, doubt the physical abuse on Johnny’s side due to his former behaviors. He has no history of that. She does.

[@BbGun-lw5vi]

I agree. Although Amber has shown herself to be so abusive that I think that when Johnny verbally attacked back, it was reactive.

[@javieratoledo9262]

You should check the UK decision. Her ex partner dismissed that and said it was for cops being homophobic

[@jgirl18515]

She said that she met with a lawyer to discuss creating a post nup (which doesn't make much sense since she says she's independent and never wanted anything from him) but that is when Johnny's fingertip was cut off, and she claims to have been physically and sa with a bottle. She took lots of photos and stayed. Why? Perhaps her lawyer told her that she needed to be married longer than 1 month to get a decent settlement.

[@ElementalDivinity]

She kept referring that attorney at her divorce attorney when referencing the post nup

[@amydraughon7632]

She took pics of all the house damage but not of her horrific injuries? My ass

[@lb8781]

... after 1 MONTH of marriage, she already has a DIVORCE ATTORNEY! ...

[@Julzartnerd]

Cheaters always use gaslighting and that’s what she’s doing about her promiscuous behavior. His recorded dialogue backs up his testimony about how she wouldn’t let him leave or drop a subject and one recording she sounds wasted?

[@charlottemartin683]

On the recording JD literally said that he leaves because he doesn’t want to get attacked so much that he ends up reacting and clocks the wife. If he hit her on a Regis basis he wouldn’t be saying he doesn’t want to be pushed to that and he wouldn’t be getting away from fights

[@Julie-kq7fq]

I've been saying this aswell. And when he said that to her if it had already happened then she would have said so there and then .it just didn't happen and she is a liar.

[@martistlouis]

and she personally COMPLAINS that he always WALKS AWAY !

[@fionarangel9486]

Yes, he would have said he doesn't want it to happen again

[@freebirddee2620]

Another interesting point that JDs lawyers definitely noticed... when speaking about when JD tried to push her sister down the stairs, she says "I thought of Kate moss". Well, a few years ago she tried to say that JD had once tried to push winona ryders sister down the stairs (obv quickly debunked) so, she clearly meant to say "I thought of winona".... Welp! X

[@cdonnelly5566]

with regaurds to the MetaData/ giving the court her phone... I am shocked by this fact. the only thing I can imagine is she or her legal team realised giving this over to the court would completely destroy her claims and so decided the jury being given instruction that they can take a negative inference over them actually seeing the data. I really hope the Jurry sees that as well

[@leyamatalas2706]

I read AH was in court previously on DV- with her former Female partner prior to JD!!- Think she dropped the charge, but they should bring that woman in.

[@amydraughon7632]

I think due to the fact that AH mentioned the kate moss rumor, the lawyers let it slide so they can bring in her former charge

[@javieratoledo9262]

Her ex partner made a statement for the UK trial denying violence

[@kandikane923]

and that Partner/ex-wife will do the same in this case.

[@alias2364-t9y]

Camille, up set the flow of the Directors cut, of Ambers acting scenes, it was a pleasure to witness.

[@carrierichards1343]

Yes yes! Your on. Popcorn spent the day not even being able to do anything but over run with DV/Sv victims it’s out. Everyone is on the same page I hope this supports victims. Popcorn was hard to listen to all failing DV, but I see it’s not just there or Emily today we all saw it. Victims are angry.

[@sidda7085]

What in the world are you trying to say?

[@tmb6490]

@@sidda7085 another channel had victims of DV/SV telling their stories or critique of Amber’s performance on the stand. Bottom line , many channels are all saying the same thing victims are angry.

[@sidda7085]

@@tmb6490 Are you talking about popcorn planet by any chance? I watched the live stream. As a victim myself, I completely agree with every thing those ladies said. All of it was accurate. Edit: Omg I’m dumb! I joke reread OP’s comment & realized he literally said “popcorn” 🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️ For the record… although I didn’t see him say popcorn until just now, it was after that reference that was confusing to me. Word salary lol

[@tazzieflats]

Hello from HOLLAND.Just letting know..love to watch this channel!!!!!!!!

[@montylitt8657]

I hope JD attorneys have an endgame that will sink her. Tbh I can't listen to her or watch the testimony, but from watching analysis and reading the comments, I'm pretty worried. It has to be an absolute 100% slam dunk for him to win. And so far I haven't heard anything that sounds remotely like that. Maybe the cross will expose her in an egregious enough lie it becomes untenable for anyone on the jury to believe her.

[@rodneylee4026]

I think they'll have something like that with the paint job in Australia. She claims she didn't do any of it and I think there is proof somewhere that she did. She claims to have been sleeping at the time he lost his finger and painted all over the place.

[@rosestewart1606]

just remember the jury has to sit and watch everything they say. it really depends on whether they found him believable and whether his side met the burden of proof...so far they have, so far it sounds like common sense that he lost income. I think tying it to the one article may be problematic but juries can vote however they like. it may not be an issue for them

[@ballet07]

Loved watching Elaine get flustered!

[@catfunksfabulousfinds]

She never should of said he kept beating her in the face over & over. A womans face would be all swollen up and no way she could go on TV the next day.

[@infinitygatekeepers8455]

She has fooled only herself ~ Another thought about Johny and the painting on the walls with his finger after being injured: I think Johny writing on the walls with his blood and then later with paint - was an artistic person who was in shock and (just like those who use graffiti to be seen), was his way of telling his story, to have a voice. - After all, he uses his artistic talents to create stories in film for a living - While this does not seem to make sense to most of us, it does make sense if you are so frustrated by another person trying to control your life, infantilize you, demean you, and make you feel guilty and feel "sick of myself" and who gives you no breathing room - and now has just injured you in a brutal way! It may have made sense to someone who is not sober and who is artistic - and who may feel invisible at that moment.

[@marthisa5800]

I absolutely see it that way…

[@rodneylee4026]

The James Franco thing really bothered me. She knew he wouldn't be fine with that and a love scene to boot. The same way they got together. I think she did it to manipulate.

[@cherylyoung7658]

Watching post from Melbourne Australia my understanding is the our authorities are re opening the investigation into AH committing pergory when testifying as to whether she knew it was an offence to bring pistol and boo into Australia without the proper documentation and without quarantining them love your channel love the content I heard about you on popcorned channel ❤️

[@abird1539]

I saw a news article stating that, too. Official investigation.

[@charlottemartin683]

Can they play the recording to amber in cross and ask why she admitted to starting physical fights when she testified that you’re not meant to hit a man or a woman?

[@hall2ify]

The Kate moss thing is that she opened the door to jd team to question her about her prior DV with her ex wife

[@annikajohansson9171]

I really hope the guys in jury don't fall for her 'damsel in distress' act as she bats her eyelashes at them while fake pouting.

[@ThePatynight]

Strange relationship, recording each other all the time. Lack of trust on each other. Who wants a relationship that?

[@willygonutz9687]

I don't know for certain, but I remember hearing that that was their psychs idea. Told them to tape themselves and listen to it in the morning when they had calmed down.

[@jimmmyz169]

Was like watching Blair witch trial. If she lied about the finger, what won't she lie about?

[@pugnacious6290]

I was listening to LegalBytes reacting to the trial earlier. At one point Amber said she’d never played guitar before. One of the guests was able to find a video of her playing guitar. There’s nothing she won’t lie about!

[@jackattack_8]

If she lied about giving money to a CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL, she will lie about ANYTHING

[@jodisacca2233]

I love your channel and your thoughts as well as the others comments from your subscribers.

[@pastywhite6669]

There's a reason why people are advised to get a lawyer and don't talk to the cops. Talking is like digging a hole. In this analogy, A.H. is digging herself a big, fat crater by talking WAY too much. A true narcissist.

[@SA-Bean-Bean]

She's digging as deep as her fillers are! 😅

[@alicedoopa1325]

I sure hope the jury sees what we all see. When one has to try this hard to sell a product, the product is a failure.

[@PrincesaMelao]

It was the most horrific bad acting over the top fake emoticones rollercoaster ! I’ve ever seen. I was overwhelmed and tired… at one point I paused it! Wow ! Yeah Camille was amazing she earned her $$

[@eternaljewelleryuk]

I’ve watched every day of the trial but actually cannot watch her testifying, she’s so disgusting & is making a mockery of real DV victims 🤮

[@PrincesaMelao]

@@eternaljewelleryuk exactly

[@hardhirbajwa542]

I think the first day they didn't object Made them comfortable And today they started objections and threw them off. Very good lawyer work

[@cherylmccloud8709]

HI from Australia!😊👋(From a lawyer, with a law perspective but without your vast Court experience). I agree with most of all that of which you determine during and after!.(even when i am piss*d off with "fact ", POL & cannot help my bias 😂) ..you are my "go to" after all the media bla bla bla & all the youtube telecasts, (live or after the event) to have your clear legal analysis, your court expertise and POV. Lol it makes me feel quite smug when we draw same conclusions. ("Ergo ego" common to legal profession😂🤣) *Cannot wait for Curry to be re-called to stand, [rebuttal] which should deservedly decimate Hughes. It is quite frightening 😱🥺 to see the danger "paid expert witnesses" can present without experienced Attorneys on hand to question "PAID expert testimonials". Sadly" money can speak loudest " without "money" to counteract it. Vicious circle in American Law System. Keep up your good work!! 👏👏💥.

[@ingridcarter4360]

Your words are ringing very true.

[@MelissaBartoli]

I didn't see tears

[@michellemcglashing5592]

What is the significance of AH mentioning Kate Moss and the staircase on day 2 of trial. Jonny and Mr. Chew made a celebratory jester after she said it? What am I missing?

[@willygonutz9687]

I've heard 2 thoughts. One is that Kate Moss may be available to debunk it. But the most likely seems to be that it has opened the door for JDs team to bring up past partners: JDs, who only have good things to say about him. And AHs, who have made abuse allegations against her. The judge had previously said info on past partners were inadmissible.

[@lindalou6169]

MR.TRAGOS - Riddle me this .. How can one have minimal communication w/ their personal assistant who they had employed for years, as AH testified to? How would you approach the line of questioning in your cross examination? THANKS! 💜

[@crystalsmith5330]

Camille just killed it today. Calm, collected, to the point and on the ball

[@ZOEYANDFRIENDS673]

That psychologist need to apologize to all those men, victims of abuse. what an embarrassment for describing an abuser..

[@kellystarlight7025]

Great job on legalbytes!! Love to see you all EXPLODING!!

[@rchambers1993]

She comes across unbelievable because her words sound like they came from an old Perry Mason episode

[@eefgilbert9468]

😂

[@loreenrobinson3922]

How did she paint three canvases in her busy two days of being flung around and beaten

[@amydraughon7632]

Great point

[@berniceconklin5058]

I'm a domestic abuse survivor I'm also a recovered heroin addict I used for 12 years I'm coming up on 8 years clean as of June 2 I remember everything my ex did to me it was years ago that I was abused I'm happily married for 18 years now and loving life amber Heard was all over the place makes me so sick with all her lies this is ridiculous

[@irenebradshaw9613]

So glad you have a good life now be happy😀

[@lareinedubois]

Thank you my son died recently from fentanyl . He did IV heroin for 25 years . thank you for stopping, please don't go back. Love Mom

[@theresabrown5395]

She is doing more damage to true victims that it is criminal.

[@nGUNNARp]

These types of trials should always be public in my opinion...It's so much easier to tell and trust your intuition on who is honest and dishonest when we actually get to see and listen to them, as opposed to reading a tweet or a transcript that tells us absolutely nothing...if I just read the words that amber spoke I would be much more inclined to believe her...getting to see her testify made her lose every ounce of credibility

[@gilllinsley1559]

If some comment is objected to but the jury still hear it how can they NOT take it into consideration even if it is subconsciously

[@danielx555]

It's interesting, isn't it. Attorneys kind of play with this sometimes, but if they're too obvious, they get smacked down.

[@kishakisha17]

Thanks for the recap

[@reddawn8161]

She was making all the faces and vocals but hardly any tears. Acting springs to mind.

[@TricommStrategies]

Bad acting? yes. But what got me was the way she never really talked about herself in a realistic way. She rarely spoke about how she was actually feeling but rather it sounded like she was explaining how the main character felt when she was hit by the bad guys. And the pictures? ha! If she had endured the amount of punching she says she was, she should have been a bloody pulp. I mean good lord!

[@nGUNNARp]

i keep noticing how all her stories start with something like 'suddenly, i was...' or 'I found myself ....' and end abruptly by just immediately talking about the next day...it's so bizzare, there's no setting the scene or anything

[@pendizzy6352]

The most unbelievable testimony ever.

[@delmarmel]

The first 30 minutes that Amber was on the stand on the fist day I thought maybe she was going to change my mind. But then the acting took over. There were so many details that are not in your consciousness when you are fighting someone off. For the level of violence that she describes, on multiple occasions, there is no police or medical evidence to back it up and no photos. She gets very vague on the actual details of the assault in certain parts. The photos that were submitted don't back up the level of violence she describes. Most of that looked like it could have happened during a tussle or any of the moments he was trying to protect himself or restrain her. In terms of defamation, unless something major is presented, I don't think AH has any business writing about being a victim of domestic violence unless she writes it from the perspective of being in a toxic relationship in which she was also an aggressor. I do believe she played a major part in damaging his reputation and affecting his work. I do not like outright lying, exaggeration and malicious intent to damage someone on any level. If she doesn't get some sort of consequence from this it sends the message that people can get away with it and AH is not going to stop.

[@joysmith6729]

Also the day after the horrible incident in Italy she went on the red carpet in the backless dress she described and you can clearly see on TikTok pictures of that and her back is totally fine completely??

[@kauilanidumaoal6179]

Opening statement= The Talented Mr. Ripley Bottle scene= Paris Trout Hmmm… what else? Boy her lawyers must be feeling really awkward right now. This girl is certifiable.

[@TheBeautifulWindsofAragon]

Gone Girl?

[@kauilanidumaoal6179]

She is not directly quoting or repeating verbatim the lines from these movies. But, I do feel that she is using scenes from various movies to create her stories of abuse and make them sound more vivid and believable. My sister used to use stories from my life and twist them into her own for people to feel sympathy for her, or to impress people for attention. It was both annoying and creepy. 😕