listening to RED by TAYLOR SWIFT for the first time & hating Jake Gyllenhaal (PART 1)

[@hthazee]

Hey y'all, firstly I'd like to apologize. I realize that the beginning of the video makes it seem like we're about to RED TV and as the songs start obviously this is the old version. I'm sorry that the beginning edit makes it look misleading. The reason I filmed the old version was because this week I was getting married and despite my personal life I still needed to upload in a timely manner for this HUGE release. I thought that since I've still never heard RED from back in 2012, that I could film in two parts. Part 1 being for the songs that were on the original (and now redone on TV) and the newly added ones from TV and The Vault. Since filming this video I have also filming a separate video listening to the ACTUALLY TV but it might be a while since that comes out. Having a life and trying to be a full time youtube is very stressful and seeing a ton of comments about how Im "supporting her stolen records" and in that way Pooper Braun is the last thing I need for my mental heath so please consider this message before leaving your comment. Thank you

[@briandaitzel]

Congratulations on your wedding!! 👑

[@syidann]

Oh that's really okay. Thank you for clearing this up and sorry for those who says awful things about you reacting to the Red og. I hope you don't really think too much about it and I really do hope you have a great week! Oh, also happy wedding!

[@juliamccurley07]

i'm so sorry for the negativity people are sending your way. Congratulations on the wedding and can't wait for part two!

[@Hsviss87]

Haha as I’m hearing State of Grace I’m thinking “this doesn’t sound like current Taylor”. Big congrats on your wedding!!!

[@YourvitamineD]

I didn't realize this until I heard girl at home since she did switched the production. But it means that Taylor really succeeded to make this re-record cause I don't fucking aware of it, like I've been listening to RED tv everyday.

[@bettyboyd7907]

"is this a fall album?" Sir, it is THE fall album.

[@burgundy16]

1.1k likes without comment, let me fix that

[@khloe4656]

no evermore is

[@junainahrahman4156]

@@khloe4656 Evermore seems more winter tbh . But to each their own

[@emmamcvicker173]

Red and evermore will always be the best fall albums to me! They're also my favorite albums

[@SachinSharma-im9eq]

@@khloe4656 evermore is November album

[@DanisDiamonds]

someone pointed out to me that Taylor probably manifested 22 into being an iconic age because of how shitty her 21st birthday was and I have truly never been the same

[@bandrade7302]

I realized this a few days ago!

[@its_rrachel]

Bruh……that realization just gave me chills how did I not realize this earlier wow. And it worked, too. Her powerrrrrrrr

[@YassG23]

im turning 22 april next year and i can't wait to listen to 22 by her and just dance my ass off :D

[@Jaseyrae213]

It does make the song 22 hit in a painful way all of the sudden 😅

[@tommygault2293]

honestly same, lockdown birthdays suck :(

[@calemcclure2573]

troy: "ehhh i mean he had an obligation" troy, 30 minutes later: "YEAH YOU SHOULD'VE BEEN THERE BITCH" I lived

[@nishthagupta1357]

Lol yes😆🤣😂😭💗

[@kerrichristian7991]

Growth 😂

[@MrsCullen12100]

I was hoping someone commented this 😂

[@prism_7738]

Character development

[@milagrosstengel1680]

Taylor said once that she made "We are never ever getting back together" the most obnoxiously pop song possible so that JG would have to hear the music he critizised her for doing everywhere. Queen move.

[@sweetlids2898]

And it’s still a vibe

[@lukemamamoblue9978]

And WANEGBT was written when her ex's friend came, as she was writing Message In A Bottle

[@saraa7841]

Who’s JG?🤔

[@milagrosstengel1680]

Jake Gylenhall!!@@saraa7841

[@kittyneko90]

@@saraa7841 Jake Gyllenhaal

[@stephnes2505]

Even after hearing this version for years, it’s so weird hearing “you tell me ‘bout your past thinking your future was me” and not having “AND YOU WERE TOSSING ME THE CAR KEYS ‘FUCK THE PATRIARCHY’” follow up

[@yieshyeah]

frrr

[@Mandamf]

Same

[@sage8357]

i paused the video and sang it

[@haleighknipping7175]

Ikkk I started singing it

[@jmoricca1]

Right??? Lol so true

[@jem9490]

i love how he transitioned from "oh i don't care about these exes" to literally giving jake the double middle finger during all too well

[@HiSummerWasHere]

Chef’s kiss

[@sparksflylove]

As he should

[@victoriaoconnor3196]

the 10 minute version is gonna absolutely take you out. it’s devastating.

[@starjmac]

I can’t stop listening to the 10 minute version of all too well

[@sav4815]

i can’t wait to watch him cry 🥰

[@annikazara1367]

@@starjmac same i’ve been looping it the whole day 🥲

[@tortugapoet]

Right? Buckle the f*** up, Troy. 😂

[@kat632]

@Taylor Swift Archives they know, they're saying the 10 m is GOING to take him out lol

[@17chloen]

10-minute All Too Well made me realize how kind Taylor was to Jake in releasing the original. It's brutal.

[@ellaocean]

Nah... I wanted her to go Full on Diss Track on #That POS

[@michaellarockwell6126]

Ikr!! Compared to the 10-minute version, she might as well be writing him a love letter💀

[@gabby7015]

FR IVE ONLY EVER LISTENED TO 10 MIN VERSION AND I WHEN HE PLAYED THIS ONE IT WAS SO CHILL

[@kyoka1528]

That's why I like the 10 Minute version better because I love brutal 😁

[@ashleypg1708]

The 10 minute is THE ONLY VERSION. And probably the only 10 minute song I like every second of. It murders me.

[@tamarbendor9468]

"The Last Time" is CRIMINALLY underrated. It so perfectly encapsulates how hard it is to let go of a relationship that was both incredible and not good for you. And the fact that it's a duet.. it can't be more perfect. Red reigns supreme!

[@christopherdelabra]

Criminally overrated? The Last Time? Yes, but not at all like Holy Ground.

[@camilleduong2818]

I’ve recently discovered how epic it is listening the The Last Time and then immediately Exile, back to back. Creates a beautiful narrative.

[@samstoffer4891]

The Last Time is my favorite song off of RED, along with Sad Beautiful Tragic

[@hellemelhus5140]

And it is A HUNDRED times better in taylors version!! It was almost a shock to hear the version in this video bc omg its so much better in tv

[@jessicakendall3208]

taylor’s version hits SO much harder tho

[@alainapartin8503]

You will be pleased to know that there is a theory that Maroon is Taylor looking back on her "Red" relationship and reflecting on how much darker it actually was now that she's older

[@cristinahaller4055]

Maroon is Red’s older sister who lived abroad and had a love affair with a European person, at least that’s how I’ve heard some people describe it

[@sarahhandberg5185]

Ohhhh I love that theory. And it’s also stabbing me in the heart but the best Taylor does

[@burnt.toast17]

I always listened to it and thought it didn't sound like it was about joe and that theory has to be correct😂

[@kimrrb3665]

Maroon is gay

[@tvil8]

Maroon feels like it's about harry. Red was one person, then maroon is what that red faded into. The 1989 vault tracks told us she was also guilty of being with other people so fits the "the mark you saw on my collar bone" line. The only other person that line could b about is calvin but he didn't leave a legacy, She forgot he even existed. Who would she see every day? The most famous ex. Who has left a real legacy? Well. I think we know.

[@ML-hg8uy]

Hey fellow swifties: why are we bullying troy when this is exactly how we experienced red? We listened to the stolen version first, too. And we wouldn't have been able to appreciate the perfection of taylor's version if we didn't. I know there are some of us in the fandom who can be quite aggressive, especially since we want to be alongside taylor in her fight to own her work, but troy literally just got married and still managed to put out good quality content for us. I hope we don't get too carried away in our emotions that we end up being jerks.

[@daniellaLmiller]

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Personally I’m kinda happy he will have the full mind blowing experience when he gets to TV, you need to see the before to appreciate the full glow on that went there

[@zminah_]

I agree!

[@shannaelynne]

❤️❤️

[@ashleem63]

Well said!

[@Chaotic_charot]

You have a fair point we need to have a press conference

[@sophdoeslife]

I can’t wait to see the reaction to All Too Well 10 minute version, you will not be well

[@hibaz5157]

Omg love you Soph!!!

[@rebecca-clairehynd6361]

Hi soph! ❤️

[@roseover340]

Oh my gosh you’re a swiftie tooo…girl I love you

[@wrigley4247]

fancy seeing you here soph

[@nishthagupta1357]

Lol yes😂

[@jessbrown24]

Him dry heaving at "reminds you of innocence" had me legit laugh crying. I stan.

[@valenfigurka]

Every time anyone refers to ANY song on Red as it being “about Harry” it makes my blood boil because SHE DATED HARRY DURING THE RELEASE/AFTER RELEASING RED!! (Not your fault though king, it’s Genius’ fault here)

[@Professional_amateuridk]

Omg I have been screaming this for a decade!!!!!

[@loganu4664]

EXACTLY!!! There’s more songs on 1989 about him then there are on Red, because THERE AREN’T ANY SONGS ABOUT HIM ON RED

[@ragecleaner]

I'M TWO MONTHS LATE BUT THANK YOU. Nothing triggers me more than this claim lmao i was BULLIED in school for liking taylor by one direction fans for this AND NONE OF IT LITERALLY CAN BE TRUE

[@anacarolinalorena]

Yeeess. The video of I knew you were trouble might have some reference to harry (though, it has much more to john) but I doesn't mean it was written for him.

[@gracethome6959]

no literallyyyy time simply does not work that way!!

[@edpotter1170]

Lmao the way this album turned someone who's like "maybe jake is just doing his job" to "fck gyllenhall"

[@PolliitoAle]

The moment I knew just does that to you 😅 he said he'd be there!!!

[@anica7438]

HAHAHAHAHA- sorry ngl but this is me after this album-

[@juanabasalem4604]

Dude I couldn’t even tell you I wasn’t even a fan of him before spider-man far from home now I fell guilty every time I laughed watching his interviews from back then

[@brynniefresh9746]

i mean the fact that his friends were at the fucking birthday party and he wasn't, and his friends were like yo are you okay says A LOT

[@vicesandvirtues8]

troy: i simply do not care who this is about, i couldnt care less, soz also troy, by the end of the album: painfully invested, checking every back story and planning to build a gyllenhaal piñata 😂

[@tabathaarria9558]

fastest character development 😂

[@tortugapoet]

The character arc was EXPONENTIAL. 😂

[@shannaelynne]

We love growth 😻

[@Katiegirl1313]

Now I need a Gyllenhaal piñata at my birthday 🤣

[@brittniic13]

Troy: “I’ve heard this is a breakup album and I honestly don’t really care who it’s about.” Also Troy: *reads intensely about Haylor drama*

[@nithyavishwas9873]

Me as hell though

[@brittniic13]

@@nithyavishwas9873 SAME

[@cthwildflwr]

me

[@brittniic13]

@@cthwildflwr no literally

[@biancaalves6143]

your reaction to Stay Stay Stay actually made my entire day, thank you for that. I haven't laughed so much in days.

[@fayesversion]

Same! I was literally rolling on my bed laughing 😂

[@MysteryWillow.2013]

I was laughing so hard 😂

[@satsuki914]

i was in tears XD

[@melissacallery883]

The way I couldn't breathe 😂😂

[@taetay_love2772]

Same!!! I need that gun lmao 🤣🤣🤣

[@korijohnson2788]

Him crying, sobbing, moving around a bunch is EXACTLY how I'd want someone to react to "the moment I knew"! lolol

[@joellem625]

“The last time” walked to “exile” can run!!! I get chills every time I hear Gary and Taylor sing together! Finally that song is getting recognition it deserves!

[@limuelcruz6259]

Yeah that song is really heartfelt

[@jaz8582]

Yes!! My 11 year old self was bawling to this lmfao it needs more attention!!!!

[@idontknowanymore6588]

MYTZZZZZ

[@mccall5473]

Jaz my 15 year old self also cried!! And then I got to see RED as my first ever concert & Taylor and Gary also played The Last Time live together for the first time! It broke me, just felt like you would understand lol

[@LimeIsTheName]

After re-listening to Red, I've noticed how many times she referenced that birthday party and how much it effected her. Man, Jake really did a number on her. I'm glad she's in a better place now with someone who will go to all her birthday parties. :)

[@narru9603]

im sorry but if a boy you dated for two months not showing up to your birthday party was the worst moment of her life it really shows how privileged she is. Also- the guy was at a work obligation, she sounds like a child

[@relent-lass7510]

@@narru9603 it’s not only that he TOLD her he’d be there. She even mentions it Plus she was reallly in love And she gave him everything She had

[@moniquej2997]

@@narru9603 I think considering that you’re all speaking about something we know nothing about shows how childish you are. Js

[@moniquej2997]

@@narru9603 also it’s music. There’s most likely some exaggeration

[@narru9603]

@@moniquej2997 which is exactly why it sucks that swift's fans cyberbully everyone she's ever dated over songs that likely have fictional elements and only tell one side of the story. The way they've treated Jake is so messed up.

[@burntblueberrywaffles]

Knowing “All too well” and “the moment I knew” are the ones that got to him the most, I just know he’s going to be wrecked by *that* line in ATW 10 mins

[@delfis4704]

YES

[@shannaelynne]

His innocence will be gone too 🕊🥰

[@itszeee5868]

The way Ik what line you’re talking about 😭

[@i.m1ss.y0u.s0.f4r]

Is your profile picture Tom houston and becky Barnes?? cause if so, love it 🥰

[@burntblueberrywaffles]

@@i.m1ss.y0u.s0.f4r yes, it’s a fanart of them I made a while ago

[@LouisaWatt]

“You don’t feel pretty, you just feel used” that one hit hard… damn she’s a good lyricist

[@joycemai3083]

“Speak to me banjo man” I love how over the course of this album he slowly falls in love with a banjo and then realizes it might be a ukulele in sad beautiful tragic

[@natalieee7015]

i didn't read the pinned comment until state of grace was almost over and i was like "damn she really does sound exactly the same on these re-records!!" but i'm glad you're experiencing the original for the first time now so you can compare it to the version she owns when you listen :)

[@dia3756]

my exact reaction help

[@Jakerski]

Hahahahah my reaction was “omg she has improved a lot”. I should dig my own grave at this point

[@hayleyjoness]

YOU’VE GIVEN STAY STAY STAY A WHOLE NEW NARRATIVE FOR ME AND I ACTUALLY LIKE THE SONG NOW LMAOOO

[@zminah_]

LMAOO SAMEE

[@clementine5053]

LIGIT ACTUALLY CRACKING UP

[@paolaaguilargarza1038]

I laugh a lot 🤣🤣

[@swiftiejones9576]

Sameeeee! 🤣🤣🤣

[@kmf3594]

That part was sooo funny i can only think of that image/scene when i listen to the song now 🤣🤣

[@justiceskerritt3497]

I disagree with people who have said her re-recordings sound identical to the old ones! One of the best parts of her re-releasing her albums is new & better production and her vocals are MUCH stronger and more mature! The re-recordings stay mostly true to the originals but there are differences.

[@mainlyyogurt]

better production for sure, but she now uses the very pop idea of squaring off her vocals in the EQ so everything is volume matched. Personally it would feel so much better if she left it like the original and let the highs and lows actually be highs and lows. Now i absolutely love the new version and always will. Just my personal opinion

[@AllTheArtsy]

Yeah, the original sounds so much better

[@vanessav1997]

I thinks it’s meant more as a compliment when they say they almost sound identical

[@AdityaJain-cc7yk]

But for a lot of song emotions are harder in og like my first taylor song is blank space and tv doesn't hit that way so I always listen to og

[@AdityaJain-cc7yk]

​@@AllTheArtsyI agree but for a lot of songs tv sound better like tell me why, out of woods , I know places , welcome to New York, red all these rerecord are better

[@YunaElphabaLovegood]

your "interpretation" of "Stay Stay Stay" is hilarious. New head cannon. Thank you. Glad to see someone enjoy music and rocking to it :)

[@ashblu3]

i’ve not laugh cried this hard for SO long

[@ashblu3]

on top of me pausing the video to say the exact same things about the youtube copyright free music and the “hey guys!” comments and then hearing him say them 😭

[@juhyaoz]

YOU GOTTA LISTEN TO SPEAK NOW it’s my all time fav album from her and has similar vibes to the songs you like from red!! it’s a masterpiece

[@ooooscarm]

it’s the way i’m so EXCITED for speak now TV ♥️♥️

[@kellylewis6060]

I needs Speak Now TV. I needs it. Ugh. All the 32 lines will kill me. I need it this year.

[@twicequeens6055]

Yeah the lyrics on speak now!! It's a lyrical masterpiece plus it almost a rock album...I hope Taylor will now make speak now tv!! Omg it's my fav album from her

[@anki5156]

@@kellylewis6060 hey sorry, what do you mean with 32 lines?

[@swlenation]

​@@kellylewis6060 istg I'll cry so much with dear john tv

[@afterglowsunshine6820]

y’all i’ve been a swiftie for 15 years and i STILL think people should hear the ORIGINAL SONGS FIRST… before taylor’s versions. because honestly? they ARE different. i firmly do not think people should stream the stolen versions but they should hear them just once before they listen to the new renditions.

[@caliiinoel]

no, i agree. been here since 2006 and strictly only listen to TV versions now

[@user-pn4uo6pk6x]

i listened to the stolen versions on KZbin for the first time and now I only listen to her version on Spotify

[@macymiller3417]

I own the physical copies of her old albums and I agree. I will forever use my cd and vinyl (they have already been paid for) for the old versions if I want to hear it. I only stream TV. Definitely different though between the versions.

[@imawakemymindisalive13]

same i heard the TV first for a lot of them and the ones i actually listened to first hit harder in TV

[@zeenoash.8805]

I pirate them XD

[@idontevenknow2717]

a little random fact: the reason jake didn't go to taylor's21st birthday party was because he decided to be a groupie and join Mumford and sons on tour and hang out with them. imagine hanging out with a bunch of dudes, not because they're your friends, but because you like their band instead of going to your girlfriend's birthday party like you promised her you would.... this man was a grown-ass 30-year-old at the time...

[@Jakerski]

I believe this happen because he didn’t want to ruin her birthday, because he thought she hated him for breaking up with her? They were broken up at that point, weren’t they?

[@reggienaah]

I can't even imagine how devastated Taylor was. Damn that man. He deserves the 10 minute All Too Well version indeed.

[@ally_roro1482]

How funny that now she records in their studio and Marcus Mumford sings backup vocals on cowboy like me.

[@broojie8191]

@@Jakerski no they didn’t break up till January and then they were on & off after that I believe

[@anu15155]

lol and now taylor has a song with Mumford and sons

[@spudothy]

on the eras tour, she sang "the lucky one" as a surprise song and introduced it as a song about "how terrible it is being famous" lolll so you're spot on with this analysis. trivia: 13 has been her lucky number through her whole life. the lucky one is track 13 and she says "lucky" 13 times!

[@naniyomihayo8501]

This is a pop country album, I love how Taylor prepared us when she goes fully pop

[@serendipitydae443]

i always thought that 22 after all too well didn't make sense but after the all too well 10 min version, i just want to say i am sorry taylor. i'll never question you ever again.

[@MrsMadisonrose]

I want to like but you have 666 likes so

[@sam_sa09]

Why??

[@ndalisian4386]

​@@sam_sa09there's a lyric in all too well 10min version that's not in the original about her not having a good 21st bday and overall a crappy experience that year because of that relationship

[@iagooliveira3045]

can you believe that taylor literally wrote "so casually cruel in the name of being honest"? i know it has been 9 years but still i don't actually believe it

[@oxitocyn]

NOT YOU APOLOGIZING WHEN YOUR WERE LITTERALLY GETTING MARRIED !!!! CONGRATS 🙏🏽 Don't worry about it, we totally understand why you reacted to the Original RED before, that's sooo fair, your reaction is priceless

[@katbatson]

Probably didn’t like it when she wore high heels because she is a 5’11 goddess and he couldn’t handle being a temporary short king

[@abbie_cae06]

i love the way she put we are never getting back together after i almost do because she’s like “u we’re asking me if we could try again and i kinda want too but i know it’s bad for me” and then like “yea no. that’s not happening. no more thinking involved on that matter” i just love it

[@kelcib4515]

Hey Troy, I'm sorry people have been cruel in the comments. Sometimes Swifties are...a lot. Thanks for putting this video out at all!! Love watching your reactions. Can't wait for part 2! And congratulations on getting married!! That is definitely the priority!

[@zminah_]

As a fan I agree. Really appreciate his video

[@shannaelynne]

❤️❤️

[@autumdew3253]

Ed wasn’t big in US UNTIL THE RED TOUR. He opened for her. There is where he took the chance and ran with it.

[@emmettseggsack]

Her and Joe Jonas dated for a few months and she wrote a few songs about him that were very… sad to say the least but holy ground was written after her came to one of her shows during speak now tour and looked back at it as a happier experience. Also the line from invisible string about sending her ex’s baby a present was about him and his wife’s baby!

[@PolliitoAle]

I feel like they both were dumb teens, made mistakes and now that they grew they can see each other eye to eye, we quiet literally can see their relationship develop through 4 albums. John Meyer and Jake Gyllenhaal were both adults who were careless with her.

[@tortugapoet]

Agreed! I think that's how she feels with Harry, too. And they're also cool now.

[@madisonahlstrom5970]

Aly and aj song potential love song is also about joe i think he regrets hurting these girls 🤣🤣

[@anibindi3752]

Is vigilante shit ‘picture me thick as thieves with your ex wife’ about Joe and Sophie too? I presumed but haven’t looked into it 🤣

[@lisastrazzeri1124]

The Moment I Knew is a heartbreaking masterpiece and is underrated

[@StefanieTaylorsVersion]

This album broke me. I came to the party late, but found Red while going through my divorce😢😢😢. Taylor healed my soul, for real!

[@ashplayssims]

At least you showed up to the party 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@shilohivy4590]

Legendary song writing ability. Between this and Adele I’m gonna need life support soon

[@Hyacinth77]

Sameeeeeee

[@nothannahstarr]

I laughed so fucking hard when you were singing Stay Stay Stay with the imaginary gun that I choked on a noodle. I will be suing, thank you.

[@swiftiejones9576]

Dude! I was cracking him up too! And now that’s what I’m gonna believe the song is about.

[@Cassiecatlovesbeauty]

Y’all he literally is posting the reaction to her version this week. He had never experienced red so he did the old version to appreciate and understand the growth the new album. Also the man just got married I’m shocked we are getting content at all!! ❤️🧣 thanks Troy

[@davishughes5992]

Congrats Troy

[@moawabamtori]

THE FACT HE JUST PULLED OUT A GUN FOR STAY STAY STAY PLEASEE STTORP

[@denvermadison9985]

Not sure if someone has pointed this out already, but one of the most beautiful things about being a Taylor fan is all the easter eggs and call backs, one of my favorite being the imagery of the birthday party all throughout the album to then have her blowing out the candles in her music video of 'Lover' with her "lover", symbolizing that he'll be at every birthday party of hers and it was an awesome way to show the night and day difference between this relationship and the beautiful one she's in now

[@jasminewilliams3351]

I love that you heard the original All Too Well before the ten minutes version!! It's so gorgeous on its own and feels like its own thing.

[@HiSummerWasHere]

When this album came out and I listened to the album version of All Too Well, it was super relatable for my relationship that had just ended and I felt like the lyrics had come out of my own head. BUT THEN the 10 minute version came out and it was VISCERAL

[@iguess9424]

My experience with Red: When the album came out me and my sister drove around listening to it at 10 PM while drinking milkshakes and I felt like punching someone and hugging someone and crying all at the same time. Great experience, highly recommend

[@sofialatorre1048]

the thing i needed to do but i didnt knew until you wrote it, thank u babe

[@kaitlynnbecker9645]

happy free confused and lonely at the same time?

[@iguess9424]

oh yeah

[@adriana-es6tm]

OMG YES I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS

[@zuzanna2722]

Dude, we can’t forget! YOUR WEDDING!! Wishing you all of the best with your lovely wife so happy for you ❤️ you both looked sooo good

[@KayCDani]

Super disheartened to see this comments section was filled with negativity. Everyone should hear OG first in my opinion. While I exclusively stream TV now, I started off a swiftie with her debut album which means I listened to her OG recordings for YEARS. Everyone deserves to hear it. Just saying. With that being said, Thank you Troy for listening to her albums and giving us your reactions! You are not obligated to do so and I enjoy and appreciate it! And thank you for putting out a video so close to your wedding! Insane. Thank you 💜

[@loganu4664]

Your reaction to all the sad songs slowly getting more and more emotional as the album progresses is exactly the correct reaction to this album. Kudos, Troy. Kudos

[@barbarasalviano388]

Troy at first: I mean him not going to the party is not that bad he had a work thing Also Troy: balling his eyes out listening to the moment I knew

[@mksketchms]

"i mean he probably had prior commitments that's why he couldn't show up" The Moment I Knew plays : ~has a full breakdown~

[@mariestraub6690]

To anyone bullying over the fact it's the old version of the album in this video: Let's not pretend like most swifties have stopped listening to the albums that have not yet been re-released. Good job if you did, but personally I could not have gone two years without All too well in my life. It's amazing Troy managed to put out a video in such an important week in his life, also that way he gets to know the differences between Red and Red TV. ALSO, the important thing to note is that, despite common belief, Taylor IS getting paid when people listen to the original versions. She has songwriting copyrights, which Scooter can never own. So yes, Scooter is getting money but so is Taylor. So Troy is not listening to Taylor's work without giving her credit and I think that's what's most important while we wait for him to experience the magnificence that is Red TV, and -I'm sure- then proceeds to never give the original album another listen in his life!

[@relent-lass7510]

That’s exactly what I did

[@michellemadison2539]

I don't go a week without listening to reputation. I'm sorry Taylor. It's too good

[@audreyardrey]

Trueeee

[@wandom2153]

Yea. I like Speak Now too much to leave it be. Never got the physical copy, alas.

[@twilightdream]

@@michellemadison2539 same

[@jessicascaffidi1685]

Wait til you find out she freestyled all too well during a rehearsal for her previous tour right after the breakup because she was heartbroken and just needed to feel it through a song 🥲

[@imfromneverland3692]

I literally had to laugh out loud when you heard the "they are all singing happy birthday to you" 😂😂 like the delay and everything and it sinking in is just wonderful 45:49

[@ylopez9654]

his whole reaction to the moment i knew had me crying😭

[@nikemaraje5]

💀💀💀

[@livrose3567]

Holy sh*t your reaction to the moment I knew was everything I never knew I needed. That song has been so critically under appreciated and you gave it the love and tears and screaming it deserves thank you for that

[@brooklynn5011]

IM SAYING

[@Bloodmoonwitch13]

Yesssss thank you!! His reaction was EXACTLY how I felt the first time I heard it and every time I hear it lol it’s sooo good makes anyone in the world experience that situation 😭

[@laridams]

i just love how he changed from "common, it's his job" to dying while the moment i knew was playing... THAT'S THE FEELING!!!!!! can't wait to the taylor's version reactionnn

[@stillfangirlingtoday1468]

Omg, the "stay stay stay" featuring "overly attached girlfriend" never occurred to me and I'm LIVING for it, lmao!!

[@AndreaRodriguez-cu7yn]

Same! I was laughing SO HARD! 🤣💀

[@carolann500]

I don't know why I think it's so funny, but that thing with the gun was hilarious!

[@arpitaanand5349]

Same girl😂😂😂😂

[@mehlev]

Ikr hilarious, the crazy eyes put me over the edge .. and the youtube intro had me rofl

[@jessaii.xoxo143]

but it was also sad because it was just a daydream of her in a perfect relationship but there's also some juvenility in her idea of a perfect relationship

[@martinamenescal2710]

"When you turn 22 this song WILL be on your Instagram story, you don't even have to be a taylor fan, it's part of life now"

[@abrowncat]

you can really hear the differences between the stolen version of red and the music its so much better now im so proud of her her vocals have also improved so much its so nice to watch her grow

[@gabsolstice]

seeing you bawling your eyes out to all to well and then jamming to 22 is such a mood she gave us all the emotions with this album.

[@alexisringler160]

‼️ATTENTION‼️ because know someone is bound to say something and idk if he mentions it In this video or not, but on his Instagram the other day. He stated that he did not listen to read Taylor’s version, because he wanted to get this video edited and filmed in time for him to go get married. He also mentioned that he does not want to discredit Taylor or anything, again he just wanted to be able to go have his wedding and have a great time and not have to worry about editing this video anymore. So please be kind, also not everyone is aware that Taylor is re-recording. So instead of attacking them for not using Taylor‘s version. Explain the situation to them.‼️

[@gabbytheartfriend]

The ten minute version of _All Too Well_ also addresses the age difference in the relationship much more clearly and it hurts so much more.

[@amandacarvajal2904]

the lucky one is such a masterpiece by ms swift, she starts the song off talking about a girl who has it all and she seems to envy the fact this girl has so much attention and always seems to just be loved by everyone. I love it when she says in the second verse "Now it's big black cars and Riviera views, and your lover in the foyer doesn't even know you" I love the comparison between this young girl who has it all but true love. She continues this idea again when she says "And they tell you that you're lucky, but you're so confused, 'Cause you don't feel pretty, you just feel used". When all in your life thing come from being beautiful and you see people treat you different, when taylor sings this, she represent the feeling that comes along with constantly being valued for your ever fleeting beauty. You no longer feel beautiful you feel like thats all your identity is and feel unwanted for who you are and used. The song then changes the point of view making taylor the new pretty artist that everyone is obsessed with and she begins to understand how hard it is to value who you are when you feel like anything anyones paying attention to are the shallow details of your life and mistakes you made. Later in the song swift says "'Cause now my name is up in lights, but I think you got it right" referencing how now she's famous but at what cost, she wonders how long her beauty will keep her relevant.

[@sierrawilson7675]

I also had a terrible 21st birthday experience so I feel Taylor in 'the moment I knew' and this album is SO good!!! Rips my heart out every time. 😭❤

[@dualapeeps]

i have 3 things to say abt red tv 1. it enhanced the album IN SO MANY WAYS that red is now my second fave taylor album which is a really big thing bc folklore and rep were my n.1 and n.2 and they were impossible to go down top 2 but red totally surpassed reputation by a mile with the taylor’s version, still not going to be my fave rn bc folklore will always be my fave but god this is so amazing, red was my n.4 fave bc its the album which i became a swiftie in 2013 so it has also a huge sentimental value 2. i loved everything except the “weeeee” on wanegbt but i think im gonna get used to it soon update: I already got used to it and don't mind it 3. it made me HATE jake even more than what i did before

[@isbravesun]

SAME, red is now my 3rd favorite (folklore and evermore are still number 1 and speak now n2), this version is so much more than the original

[@justincera1770]

@@isbravesun I can't wait for Speak Now TV!

[@dualapeeps]

@@justincera1770 it’ll probably be the next re-recording bc she has teased so much things abt it but it could also be 1989 so just like she said on champagne problems, “we’re f*cked in the head” trying to figure it out

[@samaramurray5583]

omg i thought no one else noticed the weee on wanegbt, i rlly did not like it

[@dani.p]

OMG! Folklore and Rep are my n.1 and n.2!!!! I don't consider myself a swiftie BUT with the pandemic I was like ok, I'm going to listen to folklore (even when I'm not a fan but everyone says is so different and prrrr) and after loving it sooo much it was like: Ok, this is it, this is how I enter to the Swift universe xD Then I listen to Lover (I liked like 3-4 songs but as an album it wasn't my cup of tea; then from 1989 I reaaaally liked 6 songs, but again, is not an album that I listen from top to bottom) and THEN I listened to Reputation and OMG, SO GOOD!!! I did something Bad, Don't Blame Me, Getaway Car, ... Ready For It?, King of My Heart, Delicate, New Year's Day??!!! Absolutely favs and they probably are going to appear in my "Spotify Wrapped" from this year xD Red wasn't my thing back in the days but now with her experience-mature voice plus the new production made me enjoy this album a lot (I mark as fav 17 from the 30 tracks) and I sobbed with the All Too Well 10 min. version.

[@followingwaves]

Justice for The Last Time. It's her best duet, I won't hear any arguments at this point. The new version hits even more! The Last Time walked, so Exile could run.

[@nicolettemaloy]

So “I knew you were trouble” actually isn’t about Harry (I’m pretty sure no song on red is about him) because they were all written before they even started dating because they dated during the red era im pretty sure (another swiftie can fact check me lol) but “I knew you were trouble” is in fact about John Mayer probably :)

[@burntblueberrywaffles]

I thought“come back... be here” was about Harry though?

[@nicolettemaloy]

@@burntblueberrywaffles I don’t think it is since it was written before they dated but I could be wrong

[@jen-pu1oq]

@@nicolettemaloy i read somewhere that they had a fling in early 2012 but i doubt that’s true

[@tangyjenna]

she said that ikywt and treacherous are about the same person, and when she performed ikywt live at the Brits, she got interviewed and said it was easy to access that emotion because the person she wrote it about was in the crowd. john nor jake were there, but harry was. she dated him a bit before red came out I believe??

[@Willtheyreadme]

@@tangyjenna she never said that. She never said 'the person is in this crowd' and what she said in the acceptance speech 'the person who knows exactly who he is' was for John Mayer cuz after the release of dear john he said her songwriting is cheap

[@whitneyhendrix8075]

You can tell with these songs that quality time is her love language so it hurts extra hard when people don’t show up to things or leave her alone

[@OISHIROSE]

About Girl at Home: I heard a theory that this could've been about Zac Efron. Taylor and Zac voiced an animated movie together (The Lorax), went on Ellen together around that time too. Apparently it's known that Zac turns off his phone during movie shift hours or something. Anyway, at that time he was supposed to have been in a relationship with an actress, I can't remember who. But they broke it off pretty soon after and it was speculated that the dating/relationship vibes were for PR. None of this is confirmed, obviously.

[@claragomesmartins2498]

the EMOTIONAL ROLLERCOASTER that he went through with all too well was the most relatable thing in this channel and that's saying something

[@teresagreen-e]

honestly, i'm very glad you decided to listen the original versions first. for me, listening to this album for the first time was literally a religious experience and i'm glad you got to experience this too :) i feel like listening to this one and then taylor's version lets you appreciate the re-recording more. awesome video and the best reactions as always. enjoy married life dude!!

[@kevinnguyen1249]

it hits different now that 22 is right after all too well now, now that we know Jake missed her 21 birthday and was sad and was like "turning 21 is supposed to be fun" so for turning 22 all she wanted to do is have fun and forget about heart break

[@themetalchica]

I was having a devastating night: 2 am, extremely depressed and thinking dark thoughts, but this video and your reaction made me smile and laugh and even cry, in the good way. I survived another night. Thank you so much. 💓

[@pw427]

I hope you’re feeling better now. Sending love❤️

[@joycemai3083]

Oh no, I hope your doing better now but I can sympathize, sometimes days don’t go your way but sometimes someone being silly and being in love with things that you love too can make it better

[@shonagillies5072]

I am SO here for The Last Time appreciation. It's one of my all time favourites and I always feel it's under appreciated

[@DanielaGonzalez-io2gr]

Just so you know: I Knew You Were Trouble and Treacherous could not be about Harry Styles cause they weren't dainting by the time she wrote this. Before, I tought IKYWT was about John Meyer (cause he's an assssssss) but after listen to the All Too Well (10 minutes version) I could tell is about Jake, actually. And I never had a doubt: Treacherous, for me, was always about Jake

[@nacton37]

i’ve never understood people saying there were songs about harry on this album. on her red tour she literally said that she went through a break up and wrote a WHOLE album about him.

[@lillitaylor3765]

thank u for this comment i came to say this

[@kaydence1313]

Actually they are about him. The secret message for treacherous is lyrics from a band that Harry had tattooed on him. Also her and Harry met in March of 2012 at the kids choice awards, they had a thing going and then he drunkly made out with another girl and that's when Taylor made I knew you were trouble.

[@lily_28_13]

⁠@@kaydence1313and Taylor released red on January 1 2012

[@lily_28_13]

@@kaydence1313so no songs on red could possibly be abt Harry styles

[@hurricanecatrina9548]

Bruh the hostage perspective during Stay Stay Stay had me wheezing I will NEVER hear it any other way now

[@danah-hx6mk]

the gradual descent into simultaneous anger and sadness really describes the experience while listening to "all too well" lmfao (edit: damn i JUST realized my typo on "too" that's embarrassing lol)

[@declancheetham]

watching your reactions to Taylors albums made me realise how numb I've become to her lyrics, man I WISH I could still get this emotional listening to her songs

[@audreyt01]

the way i thought this won't get anymore feels till the end to me because of your reaction, you give us : 49:57 "put em in his place" 50:10 yes shoulders 50:33 "Illegal. Locked up" 51:22 yes, it is. and the growth to going in with pushing the Going to her Birthday party agenda😌✋🏼

[@ZehraShafqat]

No because the face he made when he heard the birthday line in The Moment I Knew is EVERYTHING like you can see him putting all the pieces together and his reaction to that song is perfect 😁

[@mrsscatania]

I actually love that you heard this version first, in no way you are being disrespectful towards taylor or anything, this WAS her album and it was an amazing experience on the first listen! Good luck on your married life man!!🤍✨

[@hannaelisa4736]

can’t wait to see u cry to all too well 10 min version😌PLS TELL ME UR WATCHING THE SHORT FILM ITS INCREDIBLE

[@Ella.Sunflower]

He's listening to the original red album so there won't be the 10min version or the short film😢😭😭😭

[@hannaelisa4736]

@@Ella.Sunflower i dont think so…why would he do that, now that taylors version is out?

[@moonlightbae_]

@@hannaelisa4736 he’s reacting to Taylor’s version of the album not the short film

[@saoirse1844]

@@hannaelisa4736 I think he said because he hasn't listened to the actual album, he wants to do that first

[@alexisringler160]

@@hannaelisa4736 He mentioned it on his Instagram the other day. Not sure if you follow/that but he has not listen to the original album, and he wanted to get it filmed and out before his wedding.

[@kaitlyngooch7041]

honestly it’s fine that you listened to scOoters version since you’ve never heard it and you wouldn’t have anything to compare her version to. i even got one last listen to the original before i switched over:)

[@marykatedoyle9574]

“Is this a fall album!?” No sir. It is THE fall album.

[@AllySheehan]

you showing love to my fave and most underrated taylor song, holy ground, made my week 🫶

[@sydneyschmidt8350]

Taylor and Ed never dated they are just really great friends. 💕 *Fun fact- Taylor helped Ed climb to the legendary status he is known for now. She took him on tour with her as an opener when he was starting out in the U.S. after A Team popped off!

[@mercsrue]

ed sheeran was known in england before taylor? dont get me wrong love taylor im a massive swiftie but saying that taylor bought him to sucess is just blatently ignorant

[@cinnamonroll3492]

@@mercsrue”when he was starting in the US” and “to the legendary status is known for now” they aren’t saying she made him popular in the UK. But she 100% made him famous here in the UK

[@mercsrue]

@@cinnamonroll3492 he was known globally but okay!

[@lesalee1234]

I’ve literally never sat through an entire reaction video but dude, I can’t stop watching. I’m obsessed with Taylor. So proud of her. And it’s mind blowing she wrote these songs that have such depth at 22. Have fun at your wedding!!

[@teuntje_esle]

Hey! I just want to say it's totally okay that you first listened to the old album, I get it. I would want to compare them too if I never heard either. Always really love watching your reactions and am looking forward to part 2 of this

[@brunetteXer]

it's funny how the re-record of ATW still sounds like she's 19, but the ATW10tv sounds very mature. oh and you still don't know Taylor Lore...... track 5 is always EXTRA. there's something about Track 5s, they've become the private taylor-fan songs, never singles, and they are now legendary. ATW is the #1 track 5, but I contend that YOYK from Midnights is the next #2 track 5.

[@raylynne5280]

And yes, I get where you're coming from, that IS his job and he HAS to do whatever that entails, absolutely. Why she was SO gutted was because not only was it her 21st birthday (which come on, that means a LOT to a young person, especially a young woman) but he PROMISED he'd be there, that he would finish up and go RIGHT over to her but he didn't, he didn't go or call, he just left her alone on her birthday looking like a fool when he gave his word he'd be there for her.

[@thamycarvalho5840]

“…we’ll have a piñata with Gyllenhaal’s face on it!”. I’m dying 😂😂😂😂

[@shannaelynne]

I just hope I get invited 😂😂😂😂

[@sarahhewitt14]

Is this a fall album? IS THIS A FALL ALBUM?!?! Taylor literally invented scarves.

[@PrincessAsher22]

Real

[@callmewtvruwant]

Ngl I teared up a bit hearing the 2012 version after streaming Red TV for a few days. It’s crazy how different yet still the same it sounds. The lyrics still hits hard af but the pain isn’t there as much as it was, like a memory. It feels amazing reliving songs from my childhood again. (That Stay Stay Stay part is making me die of laughter though 😭💀)

[@AllTheArtsy]

The original version sounds so much better. The mix in Red TV is just... too loud, the vocal is too forward, and she almost ruined her most popular singles. Weird move

[@kaileyrosemahan8101]

I just want to say that you’re the only reaction channel where I re-watch your album reactions. Your sense of humor, honesty, and “production” ;) make it super entertaining. So I love rewatching because it’s just fun to go through it with you over and over. :)

[@DeanBactung]

We stan a dude who can feel his feelings. Loved this reaction!