LIVE! Boone Trial Gets Explosive On Day 5 - Defense Accuses The State Of Misconduct

[@emilyfulkerson3340]

Sarah used the police when she supposedly felt threatened..why didn't she call police and leave apartment instead of poking him with the bat and leaving him?

[@ninabean100]

“Poking”

[@shundiin8]

“She always does this like ‘boy who cried wolf’ kind of thing.” 🤪

[@Classifiedgatorfan]

As soon as they started this morning I was like 😮I can't wait to hear what Peter says!

[@leslievasquez2645]

@@Classifiedgatorfan same!!!

[@BeebesFave]

Same!

[@leslievasquez2645]

Peter, the cop was actually yelling at Sarah because she was yelling from across the parking lot, he was telling her that she was interrupting. I was crying by the end of the videos with Jorge. 😢

[@riannarodriguez9759]

Today was truly heartbreaking with those videos.

[@DocTJB]

So was I!

[@Murkikins]

I dont think that was very clear in the redacted video shown today. I saw the whole video last night where you can hear her yelling at the cop before he yalls back at her.

[@leslievasquez2645]

@@Murkikins gotcha!

[@H.P.93]

I think the videos the state ended with today are their strongest argument against her defense. George seemed genuinely afraid of her in some of them and she seemed like she was egging him on, trying to get him to hit her, where she did not appear afraid of him in anyway. I mean, there's a video where she's literally coaching him on what to say to her out of a DV charge. Those videos made me think that maybe he was the one suffering from BSS and that any violence he engaged in was because of that (which the state seems to have been implying).

[@MrMancreatedgod]

Idk. To me the videos only showed there is a long and documented history of dv between the two. If I didn't know better I would've thought it was part of the defense

[@talia_neah]

​@MrMancreatedgod What? It is proof she wasn't in fear of him. It was proof that she pushed him into reacting. The defenses whole argument is that Sarah is horrified of Jorge hurting her but she was more than happy to berate him daily? Wake him up and shit talk him?

[@nancyosullivan7625]

My favorite phrase “what’s up everybody” the tone is everything 😂❤

[@CultyClips911]

WHAT'S. 🧢 UP. 👨🏽‍⚖️ EVERYBODY!

[@daniellenicole8712]

I truly believe she was so drunk and doesn’t remember. But has to come up with something…

[@Ashley-w6h]

Absolutely

[@mariee.5912]

Yes.

[@fourofcats5803]

But she remembers him threatening her and getting his hand out, remember? Why does anyone believe anything that comes out of that despicable creature’s mouth? I don’t get it. She lies. She literally lies all the time, constantly. She destroys her own lies within minutes of them by lying about something else. What we know about that night is she videotaped herself mocking a trapped and suffering man who died. That is what should be believed.

[@kimberlyconk3318]

THANK YOU Peter for your AWESOME breakdown of today! It was a Wild Day. Absolutely L❤VE The Lawyer I Know

[@-Ryans]

Stating the Obvious BUT *She’s *COOKED*

[@vesscalleja]

Peter I watched a lot of the case until the early hours of the morning here in Australia. It was a WILD day, but eventually fell asleep so didnt see the last lot of videos etc. Thank you so much for daily summaries, explanatians etc. So appreciate and thoroughly enjoy your channel. Blessings to you and yours

[@Mila_Brearey]

You have got to go back and watch the rest.

[@angel.unaware8529]

Thank You Peter!!! Blessings and Peace for another Day!!! ♥️

[@Julie-gt7dr]

Love this judge!

[@anyone_but_me]

The videos Sarah took of Jorge show that she’s clearly the abuser. They are horrific.

[@felixchu7656]

3 points i thought after watching the videos. 1. For me its clear who the person in charge was. SB. She treated him like a kid. 2. I became inclined to believe that his death was either premeditated or she knew she could kill him at some point. Why would you get so much evidence? Unless you wanted to use it for something. 3. She calling the police was the same as some couples use "divorce" as a threat

[@Murkikins]

The cops was 100% yelling at Sarah because she kept trying to insert herself in his and Jorge's convo

[@cathybarela4304]

Peter I was not swayed, No one deserves to die inside a suit case. Even drunk drivers are punished for drunk driving and injuring or killing people. If you can't handle the drink you should not drink and to act this way for two 40 yr. olds is devastating. I feel sorry for all involved but these were adults they had called the police numerous times. They were both a menace to society. They both should have joined AA before it got to this. They had to know they both had a problem with alchohol.

[@MrMancreatedgod]

I don't understand your point.

[@tammykelsey7877]

I wish that they had the same psychiatrist that they has in the Johnny Depp trial! He was HILARIOUS!!!

[@boanoah6362]

I actually liked that the expert didn't get bogged down, she focused on Sarah's actual testimony of the events and her medical records. It was very concise and simple, 'Sarah said X happened and X doesn't meet any requirements of battered spouse involvement', boom, easy peasy. Also her statement wasn't "Sarah wasn't in imminent danger" it was "As Sarah described it nothing in her testimony would flag/indicate a battered spouse response", aka there was no build up, there was no fear response, there was no altercation or argument. By her own admission what she did wasn't because of any battered spouse symptoms or triggers so it doesn't apply to the events as described.

[@MrMancreatedgod]

I don't think you heard right. She 100% conceded that Sarah has battered spouse syndrome. She even supported that.

[@SandyOhNo]

​@MrMancreatedgod she also stated Sarah was the aggressor in this situation.

[@talia_neah]

​@MrMancreatedgod so you're a Boone supporter? Got it

[@Sunflower57-n6t]

Peter I wait for you ever day bc you have the best insight

[@woodhound0072]

The only one who ambushed Owens was Sarah Boone!! Justice for Jorge!!

[@MrMancreatedgod]

Time served. Don't face stomp your gf. Don't lay hands on your gf. EVER

[@talia_neah]

​@@MrMancreatedgodBruv.

[@srahlizabeth42]

Can’t remember if I already made a similar comment, but thank you for everything you do Peter! I am a 3L and watching your channel has been enormously helpful during my law school journey.

[@JanzZone]

Can you tell me about your mic set up? The sound you have is one of the best and simplest on my ears

[@mihnster1362]

Thanks for the video, nice to hear your side

[@tishwitch]

Its so very sad that Jorge said he loved her to death... that hit hard. 😢

[@Julie-gt7dr]

Neither expert impressed me. The videos form Sarah’s phone sealed it for me. Jorge was the one abused.

[@carmenross1077]

Psychologist reminds me of a very bad experience many years ago.got an appt to one,after few minutes of talking,I realized this psychologist is snoring,actually I made him sleep. I walked out and the secretary asked me if I want to make a f/u and I said you have to ask the psychologist,btw he fell asleep wait till he woke up. I left that office never to come back ever again to anyone.

[@dorkydragon5055]

pfft sorry that's horrible and a hilarious mental image

[@1Life2Live007]

She encouraged him to call his daughters while drinking. Is for one reason and one reason only. She wanted the daughters to know what was going on. Get people to not like him. She wants him to tell the brother how he pulled her down the stairs. I bet you she took what she did to him in that suitcase and turned that story to benefit her. When telling the cops. Narcissist

[@TheTuffOnes]

@1Life2Live007 It is my very firm belief that this was premeditated murder, that the suitcase was the transportation for the body, the phone calls were to "prove" that he was alive while in his presence, and the phone call to her ex-husband was because she was probably going to load up the suitcase with his dead body in it and have him drive her some place saying that she had an argument with Jorge at which time she would have disposed of Jorge's body. I 100% totally and completely believe this was premeditated right down to the suitcase being the tool to transport his dead body in. She was highly disappointed when the ex-husband hung up on her and, feeling defeated, probably didn't even sleep that night but spent trying to plan what she could possibly come up with. I believe that when she called her ex-husband that Jorge was already dead. I believe that she beat AND suffocated him to death. Remember, when he was begging to be let out because he couldn't breathe, he was not saying that his hands were hurting or broken. She did that to make him shut up. This was absolutely premeditated first degree murder. ABSOLUTELY

[@MrMancreatedgod]

Sure. Jorge was father and husband of the year.

[@pamelaoliver8442]

​@@MrMancreatedgodthat's not the point. At all. Nobody said Jorge was a saint or any of those things. I'd love to hear how he deserved what he got. She had 10000 other options. I say that as a DV survivor. She's appalling.

[@courtgood52588]

Im no sarah boone fan but i think her lawyers have done a great job for her 🤷‍♀️ owens especially

[@pamelaoliver8442]

She can't ever say she wasn't defended with vigor

[@lisaboone5719]

Strange witness. This is a professional psychiatrist? She's just parroting what Sara told her . What's the point

[@ianking2542]

The first witness said umm literally a thousand times

[@courtgood52588]

& Smacking her lips after saying it 🙄 I wasn't a fan of her

[@ASocialCurrency]

Guilty. The last two videos shown in court sealed it for me today. Before them I was still completely open to a not guilty or lesser charge. Not anymore. I don’t see how the jury wouldn’t feel the same. Heartbreaking. After seeing the last two videos how could anyone think Sarah was scared of Jorge. You don’t antagonize and berate an abuser. You don’t coach and abuser to lie for you in court. Sarah Boone is the abuser.

[@Sunflower57-n6t]

Peter you open your eyes

[@patriciapreciado3952]

I dont think they were playing hide and seek,, I think she made him get in the suitcase..

[@fourofcats5803]

Yep. Absolutely

[@MrMancreatedgod]

How? Yall are hilarious

[@pamelaoliver8442]

​@@MrMancreatedgodlisten to the 911 call. She flat says she put him in there. The ME can help explain how. She beat the crap out of him.

[@Luvscience069]

It could be possible she ordered him to get into the suitcase. BS Hide and seek

[@barbaraking7069]

He gotto mad to ask for anything. He changed the whole room of the court room.

[@breanapadilla3661]

Ambiguous questions/statements drives my autistic mind nuts. I will literally shut down wracking my brain on where to even start with an answer or understand the statement. Same reason why I don't use the American 12-hour (See you at 8! 8am or 8pm?!?!).

[@metroteacher]

She was ASKED TO RETELL WHAT SARAH TOLD HER ABOUT THE EVENT- DUH

[@ClaudiaGutierrez-um7ub]

Peter, the discovery violation pales in comparison with the videos at the end.

[@pamelaoliver8442]

And I think that's why the state seemed so lackluster...they knew what they had. Those videos...my God.

[@TheBackStory22]

I have been 100% lock her up and throw away the key, BUT after the last two days... I can clearly understand how someone adamantly could give Sarah Boone the benefit of the doubt. The prosecution put on a better defense in the end. Dr. Warner was so unlikable and biased without having the info to offer a credible opinion.

[@justjo6305]

He reminds me of Gabby P. Truly sad. RIP

[@Klove10501]

Doesn’t it matter what Dr. Warner was asked to evaluate SB for? If not to diagnose PTSD but whether PTSD contributed to the event?

[@myopinionmatters]

40:23 the Valium found in suitcase was prescribed to Jorge

[@trudyedwards5311]

The videos show it all. The way she talked to.Jorge, she made him mad. He seems he was a nice person he just drank to much. Both of them did. Crazy drunk. She called the cops so if something did happen it would saw Jorge always going to jail. TV smash they did that together. I guess it was broke. So they smashed it. She yelled at accused him for taking her keys all the time. She was awful to him. He did not deserve to die or die like that. She knew he was in suit case. As smart she think she should of known he would die. He was telling her over and over he could not breath. She.killed him

[@myopinionmatters]

31:02 respectfully I think Owen’s asking vague questions was too much! For example he should say are there any thoughts about X. X being whatever is relevant. How would an expert know what he is looking for. I think he was WAY too aggressive with her!

[@EliseSmith-jn9qh]

I don’t think the psychiatrist was saying SB wasn’t in an eminent threat..I think her opinion was she wasn’t acting like she was in an eminent threat. JMO

[@ChristyBaird-lz5ug]

He should never got in that suitcase

[@BarbaraStirling-q9v]

I think she knocked him out and put him in the suitcase. He didnt climb in a suitcase.

[@mariee.5912]

​@BarbaraStirling-q9v probably. She admitted he was trying to get out, and she forced him back in.

[@fourofcats5803]

Victim blaming is ugly and ignorant.

[@ChristyBaird-lz5ug]

So 😢 sad

[@ChristyBaird-lz5ug]

Why in the world did she do that

[@shundiin8]

Someone should be “Sarah trying to hug a cop” for Halloween. Terrifying stuff 😅

[@TheTuffOnes]

I ❤ KYN but have to admit I think he's wrong about the Psychiatrist's testimony today. She was being as honest as she possibly could be without showing prejudice in either direction. The only reason that she was giving off somebody language was because she was exasperated, as we ALL were, with Owens. I wanted to scream at Owens, "do you have a hearing deficiency or is your short-term memory shot as well?". He kept asking the same question expecting a different answer.

[@courtgood52588]

Who is KYN?

[@anthonypeluso3775]

I don’t think I am going to get a answer but I do have a question why not get the testimony stricken instead of attempting to impeach her with inconsistent prior statements which is the angle the defense takes just seems like a risk we’re now if you don’t hit home on impeaching them your allowing fairly damming evidence to be introduced. Unless I have misunderstood what I have been watching the state wants to prove there was no prior action that day which could of given her a reason to require defending herself and that she was the aggressor and the defense wants to say she suffered from ptsd with battered wife syndrome being included in that diagnoses I feel like that part was almost overlooked here. Yet the expert clearly says that ptsd and bss is a included and accepted causation of a form of ptsd which she agrees Sarah had but not at that specific time is it normal to not have something like this struck I am not a lawyer I don’t know how common these things are

[@kass794]

It was her or him that night, she knew she was done if she let him out, she should have taken the deal🤦‍♀️

[@bryantconley1971]

Are we going to reach a verdict before the weekend?

[@pamelaoliver8442]

That's up to the jury as to how long they deliberate. The case will probably go to them tomorrow.

[@CultyClips911]

Yes police are in a tough situation entering a DV scene. But a couple of them on Sarah's videos weren't good at asking questions and had tones that didn't help

[@TheKsipiora]

I haven’t played hide and seek in at minimum 30 years…. But tag your it, was never how that game started…… someone wound count to a number and everyone else runs. In what universe does tag your it not start the game TAG vs hide and seek, Hell I’d be champion of this hide and seek back in the days considering all have to do is hit someone shout tag and then watch where everyone runs to

[@misxfitx]

personally i was so nervous during the testimony of this expert, her way of doing things seems so scummy and she really needs to learn to control her facial expressions. the whole situation was extremely off-putting and it felt to me like we were 2 seconds away from her saying something that would create a major legal issue

[@courtgood52588]

Who's the dude sitting by judge? Is he training someone?

[@Pebbles64]

Peter, your happy place is teaching. 🤔

[@jelef001]

I’m a professor and I totally agree. i’d love to have him as a colleague

[@breanapadilla3661]

Wait ...as an expert witness she can't give her expert opinion?

[@daniethegirl029]

I was watching live and I didn’t get it, I thought she said the same thing in the depo as on the stand -not enough info for a finding- but I must be wrong or there wouldn’t have been so much hullabaloo. I am so curious what really happened that night. Was he hiding in the suitcase upstairs bc she threatened to call the cops and she found him, zipped it up and pushed it down the stairs?? Did she beat him unconscious and put him in the suitcase? Did she call Brian at 11:45 bc Jorge was dead? (I sure think so)

[@Julie-gt7dr]

She works 7 days a week so her time is limited.

[@Meganmama]

That psychiatrist was AWFUL. I’m a licensed counselor and I think this doctor was extremely unprofessional and a terrible witness. She was rude and wildly unprepared. The defense was right, someone’s life and freedom are on the line here and the “expert” didn’t have time to watch videos or testimony.

[@fourofcats5803]

Jorge lost his life. That, surely, matters.

[@Murkikins]

I would agree she was unprepared, but she picked up this case on the 7th of this month...2 weeks ago. I'm not surprised she didn't come to a conclusion the next day at the depo. She also was a lot better after the last break in her testimony, too much sass with Owen's before that.

[@charliebrown1796]

She only got this case two weeks ago, and she sees patients 7 days a week. Now you’re expecting her to have reviewed all the evidence, interviewed multiple people, prepared her testimony word for word etc while still having to manage a full case load? Would that not be neglectful and unprofessional towards her patients who presumably need her help urgently? She reviewed and spoke to who she needed to in order to draw her conclusion wrt BSS (which was the only material diagnosis since that’s her defence), and was honest when she didn’t have enough information to make additional diagnoses etc.

[@Sunflower57-n6t]

Question can he used this to get a new trial

[@debsmith1956]

Ypu were suppose to go to the trial. We wpn that so what are u gonna do to makr it up???

[@Oliver-le1us]

It seems like she actually abused him.

[@Sunflower57-n6t]

Which side did she help or hurt

[@Sunflower57-n6t]

Wait her turned off and on as needed

[@kimr808]

I did not like the attitude of the prosecution expert at all. Especially her non verbals to the jury.

[@Sunflower57-n6t]

Moms r made for this bc we go with the flow

[@rhondathompson5082]

Your "like" button isn't working!!

[@newkindathing8136]

1st degree murder for sure 👍

[@lauraw.1087]

um... and, um....and they um, um, um, um. drives me nuts its SO distracting that it's most difficult to follow what she is saying. This is a terrible speaking habit as a professional.

[@tiatherese3312]

Didn’t she cause one his brothers to beat him up..then he felt bad because it was not true that he had hurt her..I think it was Mo.

[@jelef001]

Am I the only one surprised race hasn’t come up at all in this trial?

[@MrMancreatedgod]

Nice self report bruh

[@Bevan69]

Sarah was beaten make no mistake about it. If she defended her self then where is the harm. She was aggressive I admit but I would have been the same if I was beaten like she was, Jorge got given what he gave out. Some people can't see that 😮

[@PeacefulMAMAS]

I am not happy judge allowed her in. Not the main stream of thinking about this case, I understand that.. But lost respect for prosecutors today. lead detective sitting in trial when she knew better also not cool. I felt Sarah's case was actually helped by the videos today as a survivor of domestic abuse.... I saw her more as a victim today after watching the videos. She might have lied during police interrogation, but I truly feel that she is still numb to her abuse and all the videos of Jorge actually supported Sarah IMO. The prosecutor's expert WAS NOT Credible IMO. @Peter.. why was she allowed to sit in the witness box while they debated her testimony. She was prepared for her own rebutall with Owens.. it felt so wrong

[@christinametal1071]

interesting the videos to me show she's the abuser she has the control she uses 911 to control jorge. she was never scared and she always had the upper hand, SB is a master manipulator, their relationship was toxic I believe they abused each other there was numerous statement said that jorge hurt Sarah so she wouldn't hurt him he said that on video and she didn't even deny it. Sarah said she wanted to get rid of him and she did it's premeditated imo she deserves long term sentence

[@fourofcats5803]

I don’t believe you actually watched the videos today then, if that’s your take away. You should, even if you don’t come back here to admit it. Defending an abuser, a clear and openly abusive abuser, is not healthy.

[@jessika702]

You felt sorry for Sarah watching her berate him, belittle him, call him disgusting, gaslight him, attempt to instigate him, use law enforcement as a weapon against him..? She's a terrible person & an abuser. We must not be watching the same trial. 🤯 Also a DV survivor here. And I would NEVER have done any of that to my ex

[@charliebrown1796]

How do those videos support Sarah? I don’t think you understood what you watched. Either that or you’re also suffering from a Cluster B disorder and your perception is warped by that.

[@sngray11]

Thank you Peter for keeping us updated on this trial! 🫶🏽 I love your nightly recaps… especially on the days that I didn’t get a chance to watch the trial live. Thank you for your unbiased discussion of these cases while educating all of us on the legal system here in the States. 💞

[@courtgood52588]

QQQ--- @lawyeryouknow - why was the witness aloud to stay on the stand while the lawyers were going back & forth about her testimony ????

[@daniethegirl029]

I’m not a lawyer but I think it was bc she was categorized as an “expert” witness.

[@user-sh8id2ei2q]

Allowed?? Lol

[@shundiin8]

Anyone else following this trial on 4-5 different channels 😅 LYK is my fav though. It’s the Libra in me 🥹

[@r_and_a]

dr berry, tanika's 2 cents, just a lazy gamer, kerryctures, emily d baker's quick bits & probably a few others i'm not thinking of, lol