Live: Is Mance Rayder actually Arthur Dayne? Let's Discuss

[@williamhermann6635]

Arthur is the Sword of the Morning. Its not just a guy with a sword. Its an office or a title that certainly has to do with the Long Night. So he goes north as Mance to fulfill his duties by uniting the wildlings and getting them south of the wall in time. I really dont understand why people think this theory is so unbelievable when this story is full of people in disguise under assumed identities and/or glamoured. Even Mance gets glamoured.

[@schrubber98]

My dude, Hunger Games ist THE best YA fiction! 😍 And they’re all good!

[@TheGreaseGoblins]

I finished the prequel today and man reading that ending tore me up. What a perfect book and my favorite of the series and in my top 10 books I have read easily!

[@VRILL-MASTER369.]

[ why don't I see the live chat ]

[@FlorianMark]

The best argument is that there are people at the wall that are longer there than the rebellion. All these people must know the stroy of Mance growing up at the wall is false. People talk. It would have came out. Maester Aemon would also know he is Arthur and would have told Jon when he became Lord commander.

[@Vi2cci]

Ehhhh, Robert thinks Arthur stood by as Rhagaer r@ped Lyanna for months. After kidnapping her. I don’t think he would forgive him, pardon him, or let him take the Black.

[@galdo06]

Howland used a net....... check that theory. Is A LOT BETTER than what it sounds

[@MrMike0817]

Might be late saying this but there is a new smite youtuber and streamer Snaddy who is looking for video editing and twitch emoji help. Not sure if that is up your alley for you to get some experience. But thought I would just let you know

[@TheGreaseGoblins]

Oh interesting especially since I am quite familiar with Smite I may look into it.

[@jaybees5734]

Mance is Arthur Morgan

[@frankleyJ]

No

[@three-eyedmonkey7344]

Arthur Dayne is dead. But he didn’t die at the Tower of Joy.

[@williamhermann6635]

Nah hes Mance for sure. The scene of Mance destroying Jon with a 2 handed great sword while glamoured as Rattleshirt cements it. Its by far the best example of swordwork shown on page in any of the books. Hes not some randon wildling. Dude is the baddest man in this universe and Arthur just so happened to be the best knight anyone ever saw.

[@three-eyedmonkey7344]

He’s Qhorin Halfhand. A renowned badass, more so than Mance. The clues are legion, for example several dawn references associated with Qhorin. The parallel between Qhorin and Jaime’s swordhands. Qhorin sharing memories of a wedding with Jon, which is a reference to R+L. And even Mance knows Qhorin is Dayne, which is why he sings about tasting the Dornishman’s Wife, which is a reference to tasting Qhorin’s sword.