Some nice points made, but two nits here: 1) "Chapter 6 is all about fear" is seriously overstated, as you can see at least at three points: 1.1) During the meeting, Ralph repeatedly holds fear in check and speaks reason: "This is more than a hunter's job" -- "Now think, Jack." -- "If the beast isn't there we'll go up the mountain and look; and light the fire." -- "We'll eat first. Then go." These are not the words of one consumed by fear. Sure, there is considerable fear, but the children still master it, make partially sound plans, and carry them out in a systematic manner. 1.2) When going alone into the castle, Ralph "realized with surprise that he did not really expect to meet any beast". So even in this extreme situation, Ralph is still able to act in cold blood rather than feeling his blood run cold. 1.3) Finally, Ralph and Jack discuss further actions when they find the castle empty: "We'll have to go back and climb the mountain. That's where they saw the beast." -- "The beast won't be there." -- "What else can we do?" Those are not the words of boys scared out of their minds. Rather, they simply stick to their more or less reasonable plan to systematically assess the situation and relight the fire if possible. Right afterwards, Ralph's problem isn't at all to cheer frightened children, but rather to stop them from wasting their time in idle play; fear is almost completely forgotten at this point. In conclusion, while chapter 6 is the first chapter where the general direction of the boys' actions is based on their mounting (irrational) fears, those actions, in detail, are still carried out with quite some rational deliberation. So there isn't any landslide from rationality to panic; rather, fear is slowly expanding its range and effect, not continuously, but in fits and starts: two steps ahead, one step back... 2) It's not quite true that none of the boys notices that society at large is just as flawed as their own micro-society on the island. Apart from Piggy's remarks in chapter 1 ("They are all dead"), Simon, as usual, exhibits an amazing perceptiveness in chapter 6: "However Simon thought of the beast, there rose before his inward sight the picture of a human at once heroic and sick." If only Simon would have had the verbal power to express himself to the others, or if only the others would have had the patience and listening skills to understand him... Failure at communication, cooperation, and using different talents in concert rather than in rivalry is among the main reasons for the downward spiral into disaster.
@artix24688 жыл бұрын
Very nice
@outofthegoldfishbowletcete7627 жыл бұрын
Ingo Schwarze good for you. This is not Mr b's best I'm afraid.
@JamesHoyle.6 жыл бұрын
You’re litterally addicted to proving Mr Bruff wrong lol
@outofthegoldfishbowletcete7626 жыл бұрын
James Hoyle yes and he's doing a great job. Mr B is not God's gift to GCSE English students. He's a good starting point after you edit out all the woffle and irrelevant crap
@axaelx79676 жыл бұрын
+outofthegoldfishbowl etcetera can you make some LOTF videos please? I think you are a better teaching so can you teach us all since you say Mr Bruff isn't great? Thanks
@زهراءساكورا-ض3ز5 жыл бұрын
While you were talking about the language and the way their language has changed, I noticed that our languages are becoming the same !
@SREdits1238 ай бұрын
rs
@taahakhalifa80729 жыл бұрын
can you make an analysis of the whole of the novella 'Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde'?
@mrbruff9 жыл бұрын
Yes. EBook study guide coming before Christmas
@maryruff26347 жыл бұрын
Very helpful! Thank you!!
@litradity74518 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much!!
@riazrehman52023 ай бұрын
Good effort
@mrbruff3 ай бұрын
I recommend my new and improved video on 'Lord of the Flies': kzbin.info/www/bejne/anzGdHqkesR6jrM
@زهراءساكورا-ض3ز5 жыл бұрын
I would be afraid of the insects !
@raghaadnoori6797 жыл бұрын
IF I'm on deserted island I'd be most afraid of dying their
@dred_dreamr3 жыл бұрын
@@jakepaterson6857 3 years late but yikes that was uncalled for
@outofthegoldfishbowletcete7627 жыл бұрын
You keep going on about the innate evil blah blah but this is crap. The younger boys are far less evil than the older ones so surely this implies innate innocence, right? And that evil is learned through aging... The adults are killing each other too.
@cubershil62985 жыл бұрын
I would be afraid of the pain of dying and the affect on my family
@amalali3605 жыл бұрын
good analysis but STOP SPOILING !!!!!!!!
@the-neand-nlybwappy4 жыл бұрын
Just don't watch the damn video then. People use this for help.