Ranking The Top 5 Best Fighters Of All Time In EACH DIVISION

[@lucastracymma8764]

Time Stamps: 0:00 Intro / Criteria 1:02 Flyweight 7:07 Bantamweight / Difficult To Rank 21:48 Featherweight 28:00 Lightweight 37:17 Welterweight 42:34 Middleweight 52:03 Light Heavyweight 55:07 Heavyweight

[@BlackpillMMA]

Bro has Frabricio Werdum over Fedor and Ngannou

[@MMAPOOPS]

#1 Heavyweight Volk

[@nutsackmma]

why’d you copy my vid bar for bar bruh

[@pluto5618]

Bro Weidman and Bisping never fought

[@CringyGamerz]

Poirier over Oliveira is crazy

[@juu1800]

I need someone obsessed with me like Lucas is obsessed with the goat convo.

[@novared103gaming3]

Flyweight is literally the only 5 champs its ever had

[@cheesr2k282]

Erceg > froadtoja

[@barlo90]

Lol a lucas member

[@laptv2144]

@@barlo90 why do you watch his videos?

[@MG-po6jc]

@@laptv2144 He watches them for free

[@unkiejaymma]

That's crazy... DJ and the figgy moreno quadrilogy really held up that div

[@discobites]

Any fighter with a prime before 2017 is a bum according to Flukas

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a Best of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names and records and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@itsalexhere8748]

Honestly kinda true tho

[@bigsur909]

@@ItsameAlexthe one time he beats rob? He ran thru em like he was nothing 😂

[@tiagohenriquepereira7962]

I like his analysis and takes but if im not wrong he started watching ufc in the pandemic , thats why he is clueless about the context and the impact of the fighters that came before like 2019

[@IqbalIqbal-kx9pf]

Sport evolves fast especially if it is attracting new practitioners. I doubt those pre 2017 beats any current champ

[@Zaydonnn]

Brother is cherry picking with the criteria Max early losses don’t matter But oliveiras and woodleys losses do? Armans first fight in the ufc is a top win for Islam But usmans win over Strickland isn’t?

[@s66s46]

Exactly, hes a casual

[@jakey477]

“Only using objective criteria” in a subjective manner

[@lucashipolitorv]

Lucid

[@ranjotrakkar6663]

Subjective

[@sharkfinfinds2782]

Max: I'm the best boxer, count it up. Connor vs Aldo: 1 punch, don't count it, you can't, it's just a punch.

[@joaoalmas5127]

This bantamweight list is the definition of “if my grandma had wheels she would be a bus.”

[@grimlock__2501]

merab at 2 is actually insane

[@flacortw]

@@grimlock__2501glad someone at least mentioned that 😂

[@Gfckin9]

@@grimlock__2501yeah I was looking for this comment, you dont have to like omalley but how in the hell is he not up there but merab is, its more appropriate to put cody garbrant up there rather than merab

[@weloniko]

​@@Gfckin9sean and cody have mid resumes like sean beat fraud aljo and chito and i think he lost the yan fight, if you're arguing sean should be there then so should ilia in featherweight

[@barebuttspankin]

@@Gfckin9neither of them should be there

[@exluck5478]

People forget man that Flukas has these hardcore crafty vet takes

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a BEST of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names on your record and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@titzmageex]

"We're not gonna use any bias" Then goes on to rank fighters based on who you thought should have won decisions. Spectacular.

[@jacobmackay4972]

Thinking someone won a fight is a lot different than I like this fighter more so he’s higher

[@arct1cflame536]

“Definitive top 5” “I think he won” 😭

[@yoboychris4149]

Having a different opinion than the judges to rank a list is not a crime

[@titzmageex]

@@yoboychris4149 but determining ranking off of your opinion is using bias, which he said he wasn't going to do. Not thay difficult to understand.

[@aidenfielding1348]

The judges get tons of shit wrong

[@scabu3]

Lucas has some serious recency bias

[@tiagohenriquepereira7962]

exactly, he has good takes but he started watching in the pandemic, that explains why he is kinda clueless about most fighters that fought in the 2000s and 2010s era

[@joeswanson5486]

Fr the top 5 at heavyweight should be Fedor nogueira cro cop Mark hunt Heath hearing

[@otterno.1128]

@@joeswanson5486 Lol this is a bit much... are you trolling? That's big nostalgia bias. The top 5 should be either Stipe or Fedor number one and number 2, then Nogueria, and then you can take your pick of Cro Cop, Velasquez, Werdum and maybe JDS for the other spots. Mark Hunt and Heath Herring are good heavyweights, but should be nowhere near a top 5 GOAT list.

[@MaestroJericho]

@@tiagohenriquepereira7962 idk why he's so adamant the sport has evolved. 10 years ago had Jacare/Rockhold/Gus/Rumble/Condit/Lyoto/Moose/DC/JDS/Werdum. I'd say only featherweight and below evolved so much and you could argue it's because how much people cut nowadays.

[@MaestroJericho]

@@otterno.1128 Yeah top HW GOATs would be Fedor/Stipe/JDS/Werdum/Nog/Cain/Reem/etc. Only Aspinall currently makes the list. "sport has evolved" is so dumb since you get guys like Almeida and Gane who got exposed but would handily beat majority of today's HWs.

[@alecsbizarrememes7862]

Lucas is the definition of a walking recency bias

[@hakim65163]

Cry a river about it

[@cronenberg-esque]

bro farted at 38:26 and kept it moving

[@محمدسعد-ك6ت]

its the chaire broken hand 😂

[@millenpotter576]

Literally was only looking for this comment

[@justina5688]

Was looking for this comment lmap

[@bxnn22]

i‘m dying😭

[@XbeforeYZ]

Bro i was not ready for that😭

[@jamesfitzirish]

"He's 14-1 on a 15 fight win streak"

[@TastyCookie.]

lol im pretty sure islam is on 14 fight winstreak in ufc now. So Flukas Glazy is wrong there.

[@matierk637]

He probably meant he has 15 wins in total and is on a 14 fight win streak

[@aduriteking2155]

Either ways Islam and Khabib are the goats of their division

[@timurjack8773]

Tibau win should added also.

[@yussefcheaitou]

he was saying he doesn't remember if its 14-1 or 15-1

[@GoatOfMMAForever]

Nobody does long format mma content better than Glazy

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a BEST of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names and records and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@RomeroMero255]

Okay mr “joined 5 days ago” type beat

[@10mmseb]

@@RomeroMero255you joined a year ago…

[@RomeroMero255]

@@10mmseb my other account called “HR 07” has been on this platform since 2018, and before that my oldest oldest account was from 2015

[@gabe4164]

Reading this in the same tone as Dana White defending Jon Jones lmfao

[@LeftLaneMMA]

Lucas calling kopylov the 3rd greatest middleweight ever is a crazy take 😮

[@lucastracymma8764]

one more win and he's 1

[@smiley_8001]

@@lucastracymma8764hell yeah bro 😂

[@seravaMMA]

Please tell me he didn’t actually say this

[@asparrow_]

@@lucastracymma8764broski wym

[@anthonyontv]

@@seravaMMAjust eat your Food kid

[@richreacts8814]

55:08 Fedor is the heavyweight GOAT. Shelt (4x K1 champ), Crazy Horse Herring, Big Nog 3x (arguably was winning 2nd fight before head collision), Iron Head Fugita, Karate Goodridge, Coleman 2x, CRO COP, Mark Hunt, Arlovski… the last emperor’s reign is unmatchable

[@imcgonigle2006]

Old heads and middleweights 😂

[@ryantino9897]

Poirier above Charles is CRAZY

[@renzo1745]

If you counted Arman for Islam, you should've counted Max as a good win for Connor.

[@zarifinator1327]

@@renzo1745 I agree as an Islam fan, Ngl I think he just forgot put to max there

[@frogprinceceo9609]

EXACTLY WHAT I THOUGHT TOO

[@محمدسعد-ك6ت]

islam was young as well its not like islam was the champ and beat arman on a debut

[@aduriteking2155]

Islam went on to become a beast, Connor never did. There are levels to this game and islam is an elite level fighter. End of story

[@linustehminus]

@@aduriteking2155 ??? that has absolutely nothing to do with the video format. what a clown

[@futureufcchampion9293]

When mma was the driest. My goat posted🥺. We love you lil guy

[@zacharyav5277]

To be fair Jon jones just got arrested again

[@stevennlmb579]

@@zacharyav5277and the reward is another women’s fight night for the 2nd week in a row. Not a good reward

[@zacharyav5277]

@@stevennlmb579 true

[@kingt0295]

PookasTracy 🔛🔝

[@glitchedfish4615]

The atomweight goat

[@Rubbitybumper]

Merab at #2 bantamweight is insane

[@timurjack8773]

If he wins the belt maybe, but until then he shouldn't even be in top 5.

[@joeswanson5486]

@@timurjack8773why not? He’s the only fighter to ever not rob or beat Yan by DQ. He also beat Jose Aldo and Henry Cejudo which are 2 pretty good wins and he has a decent win streak. 2 might be a little crazy but putting him under 5 is😂

[@Gfckin9]

@@joeswanson5486because an honest top 5 would be cruz, omalley, aljo, yan and TJ…thats an objective top 5, id put cody over merab as of rn

[@Gfckin9]

@@joeswanson5486and omalley beat yan, you can look up the fight and watch it as you can see omalley got the win…

[@Amrgoated-n6f]

@@joeswanson5486Sean omally is kicking his ass

[@kingt0295]

“Vitor was a good fighter, Belfort was a good win”

[@youngclueless7364]

Tracy Lucas: I'm counting robberies in my list Also Tracy Lucas: Anderson has a win over Derek Brunson

[@aidenfielding1348]

Probably didn't watch the fight

[@bruhdude5505]

I’m sorry but if Cejudo “lost” to Benavidez, then Whittaker “lost” to Izzy in the second fight. Flukas literally did not watch that fight

[@bruhdude5505]

Good vid tho lol fan of the content

[@harshatomas835]

​@@bruhdude5505Whittaker beat gynobender. He beat him in R5 clearly and edged out R2,R4

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a BEST of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names on your record and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@RayaneTawil]

​@@harshatomas835he absolutely didn't

[@champhugeballs7389]

@@harshatomas835 "Clearly" Izzy outstruck Robert in RD 2 and RD 5, and I doubt anyone thought Robert won Rd 1

[@baconkenns8603]

Bantamweight rankings actually unhinged

[@bjh1202]

whats yours then??

[@loganmiller4248]

@@bjh1202Cruz, aljo, yan,merab and then either dillashaw or O’Malley

[@loganmiller4248]

@@bjh1202I already changed my mind lmao. O’Malley lowkey hasn’t done much yet besides 2 maybe 3 good wins but chito wasn’t too impressive

[@joeswanson5486]

@@loganmiller4248yans above Aljo. He beat Aljo the first fight and barely lost the rematch.

[@joeswanson5486]

@@loganmiller4248I wouldn’t mind Suga at 5. If he beats merab though put him at 2 ?🤷‍♂️

[@Oroffjrneks]

Lucas, you uploaded this at the perfect time. I just finished eating a big ol’ bucket of KFC with Shamil the Blob after we practiced imposing our will’s on a treadmill. Watching this while plotting home !

[@LB-eh7sr]

😂😂

[@paulcowie3348]

Weidman vs Bisping was such an underrated fight, people forget man..

[@Liranlevi395]

I love that every close fight he gives to his more liked fighter

[@willb8636]

Another win that peolle don't really include for Silva is Nate Marquardt, who besides just being another old head name for Rogan to say is a killer in his prime, actually went on to beat Tyron Woodley for the strap in Strikeforce so it ages pretty well

[@snandrew6094]

bro that Marquardt finish against Woodley is one of the nastiest KO's, I still go back to rewatch the finishing sequence from time to time to this day it was brutal.

[@yehwanlee1720]

The bantamweight list is outrageous. Not putting Suga there when he has wins over 2 of those guys is posposterous.

[@JasimSinatra]

Agreed

[@GooGooGadget]

Hes counting the yan vs sean fight as a win for yan thats why.

[@StricklandsBurner223]

Didn’t beat yan

[@DouglasCarter69]

Suga never beat yan

[@MG-po6jc]

I guess according to Glazy's way of thinking, Sean is undefeated

[@easingthroughspace194]

The amount of hoops you had to jump through to justify Aljo is fucking insane…

[@lykastannis7662]

Aljo's entire championship reign kind of has an asterisk next to it. 0 valid wins

[@blahhhh1223]

⁠@@lykastannis7662how is his win against cejudo not valid

[@lykastannis7662]

@@blahhhh1223 Split decision

[@weeny1240]

So much inconsistency in this list

[@travismenchinton3401]

"This isn't about bias" *Proceeds to be bias for an hour* 🤣🤣

[@MrPunjabproductions]

No Patchy Mix? Such a casual maaan

[@PercSlushy]

Patchy Mix is the REEAL hardcore goat of 135

[@dreballl]

no we’re just not 100 yrs old

[@zeze-oo2rh]

@@dreballlpatchy mix isn’t an old fighter, he’s the Bellator champ that people call better than Omalley and Yan to seem hardcore

[@julianjdc5907]

@@zeze-oo2rh you just regurgitate what lucas tracy says. i agree but thats the same thing lucas said bum

[@zeze-oo2rh]

@@julianjdc5907 wasn’t making it out to be my original take, the guy above me didn’t understand that it’s an inside joke on Lucas’s channel that patchy mix is the best

[@humanexister]

Beating Yan is nothing like beating Volk, Volk is a long reigning champion with wins over the two other goats of his division. Yan lost the belt in his first defense and lost the rematch, then got 50-45 smashed by Merab. You're cooked.

[@lykastannis7662]

Yan only ever lost to Merab. He is more skilled than Volk too. Volk is passed his prime too. Beating him now is easier than you think. I think Arnold Allen would beat him. All the lightweight contenders beat him too. Volk was dominant because of his speed and movement. That goes with age

[@humanexister]

@@lykastannis7662 huh, weird, I could swear I watched him lose to Aljo since I'm not a biased coper who understands losing the first three rounds means you lose

[@lykastannis7662]

@@humanexister I thought Yan won the first round of the rematch. Landed way better shots. Blocked most of Aljos too. This is a valid opinion. 1 judge even gave Yan round 1. Stop acting like Yan winning wasnt a valid potential result.

[@s66s46]

He didnt lose his first defence, he lost to a bs rule

[@s66s46]

​@@lykastannis7662casual

[@Adityasaurus]

Ah, yes. I remember when Weidman fought Bisping and poked him in the eye, causing Bisping to lose the eye.

[@LvelheysDaLionhearth]

You forget makhachev on Pantoja best Win

[@seanrun4228]

Lmfao

[@aduriteking2155]

Are you hating on Makachev?

[@imcgonigle2006]

You do know MaKachev whooped him right? 😂

[@joeswanson5486]

@@imcgonigle2006Pantoja koed mackecev retired came back and won the flyweight belt.

[@dirty2287]

​@@aduriteking2155makachev is a n word

[@schelpplayer3680]

DP above Charles Oliveira is BIZARRE, the top 3 is Khabib, Islam and Charles

[@zarifinator1327]

DP def has a better resume than Charles but idc about the order as long as top 2 is Islam and khabib and top 4 has dp and Charles

[@Tomas-wm3pk]

@@zarifinator1327não mano porier perdeu pro charles e nem se quer foi um campeão legítimo linear

[@goofybaII]

Nah, Dustin over Oliveira is correct, it's close though

[@timurjack8773]

Oliveira's before title wins didn't age well, who did Oliveira beat? He beat Nik Lentz that Makhachev also beat. Oliveira beat Kevin Lee who lose to Iaquinta 2 times, and he beat Ferguson after Gaethje beat him, as Khabib said Ferguson was finished after Gaethje, Ferguson lose to everyone even to Paddy Pimblett after that. Oliveira beat Dariush but then Dariush lose to Arman as well.

[@Tomas-wm3pk]

@@goofybaIIdustin literalmente nunca foi campeão mano e foi finalizado pelo Oliveira,khabib,islan aonde você quer chegar? Oliveira defendeu título

[@NotYamiii]

What a great video idea! surely everyone will agree with every pick and theres no arguments in the comment section!

[@aduriteking2155]

😂

[@kingspart9828]

Bro added Adesanya to Rob's and Romero's best wins 😂

[@clkgtr12]

bro making his own happiness let him be

[@lucastracymma8764]

Robberies exist. Judges can get fights wrong.

[@WhiteBoyTariq]

Hes a bit delusional

[@paolothorpe1461]

@@clkgtr12bros in his own blissfullness

[@kingspart9828]

@@lucastracymma8764 both fights were competitive and close,drop the gimmick that Adesanya brutally robbed Rob and Romero,not even Rob's own corner thought he won

[@Chips9999yt]

1:02 I already knew this whole video was gonna be a W💪🏽🔥❤

[@ivank9792]

its crazy how in 2025 ilia topuria is #2 on the fw list and doesnt even feature on it 5 months ago

[@LegitPlays777]

I would put Yan over Merab because if you look at their fights with Jose, Yan beat him convincingly while Merab just held Aldo against the fence because he knew he couldn't beat him

[@tibiaots24]

Do you know Merab beat Yan 50-45?

[@Robert96902]

@@tibiaots24lol exactly, why compare their wins over someone else when they have literally fought each other 🤣

[@joeswanson5486]

@@Robert96902fr even if they never fought mma math doesn’t work. You could say look at Justin’s fight against Dustin and Islams😂

[@zeze-oo2rh]

Yan is by far my favorite bw but even I wouldn’t do these mental gymnastics to ignore that he got smoked when they fought 😂

[@mikemorris9902]

Cejudo only had 2 losses at flyweight and one of em was against DJ and the other one was a robbery to Joe Benavidez. Cejudo was deducted a point on some BS

[@zarifinator1327]

True, the fight against Benavidez was razor close and cejudo arguably won

[@krypttt]

flukas “the coin flip” tracy uploads and i suddenly start falling to my knees and crying tears of joy into a bucket to fund salt water for pyfer and saltymal hill at the spitoon, god is good.

[@youngclueless7364]

Are we just gonna ignore the fact that Lucas tried to gaslight us into thinking that Weidman has a win over Bisping? 😭😭

[@lucastracymma8764]

i had vitor belfort at the 5 spot before weidman and i forgot to delete that win lol

[@connormcelroy7727]

And bisbing wasn't in gsps biggest win!

[@brxcefxde663]

Honestly a good list, I see a lot of people make fun of your takes in our community but i took a listen on this video. Super unbiased I feel

[@Liminy_snickers]

Lucas out here giving us hope in a time of despair

[@Constantine-316]

How is Cro Cop not on Fedors best wins?

[@lucastracymma8764]

i forgot to put him in there. I don't mind him at the 2 spot either

[@Nero-mg7en]

Same with Kevin Randleman

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a BEST of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names on your record and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@haygrayk]

@@Nero-mg7en KEVING RANDLEMAN gtfo bro hes a can.

[@aduriteking2155]

@@ItsameAlexI'm sorry but you just confused me even more 😭

[@lucastracymma8764]

I don't have strong reasoning for Alex Pereira being top 5 all time but he's undefeated at LHW with 4 wins all over former champions. I don't mind putting someone else in like Rumble or Gus. LHW was the hardest one in regards to doing #4 and #5

[@Youssef-hd5bl]

Alex should not be in that list, you said in the beginning that there's no recency bias and that is exactly what you did with the LHW, like those 3 former champions he beat didn't even defend the belt and got the belt by beating an old glover.

[@spoogyboogy]

I don't think its that crazy, Pereira is the first LHW to defend his title more then once since DC and Jones.

[@mitech7258]

My man lucas talking 20 mins about how people are gonna complain about dillashaw being low when he did not put suga on the list...

[@zarifinator1327]

Gus atleast is def top 5 over alex, he beat shogun, texeira and jan and beat jan much more convincingly than alex, and arguably beat jones and took dc to a split decision

[@spoogyboogy]

I agree about Gus, I would put him above Pereira and kick out Glover from top 5. Gustafsson smoked both Jan and Glover.

[@pettyjones]

Liddell over rampage is insane

[@flame-sky7148]

Yea, I think Lucas is too young to understand. Many of us saw it when it happened. Even Rashad Evans was better than Liddell. Rashad's best wins were over Rampage, Liddell, Tito, Forrest Griffin, Dan Henderson, Sonnen

[@Skynertia]

Saying Islam's wins are better than Khabib's is certainly a take... Khabib faced almost everyone at their peak. Poirier (5 fight win streak, disregarded NC), Gaethje (4 fight win streak), RDA (5 fight win streak), Barboza (3 fight win streak), and McGregor (who was 9-1 with one avenged loss to Nate Diaz in a different weight class). The only other thing he could've done was beating Tony.

[@alex222toxic]

i love edgar bro but #4 at 145? thats insane. he'd be #4 at 155 if anything

[@zarifinator1327]

He should be #5 at lw. I dont think the top 4 is arguable (you can shift them around but i think those 4 specifically belong there) but Edgar beat Penn 2x, Maynard, Sherk, and Bendo if we're counting robberies because the second fight def was. He has a ton of good wins at fw tho.

[@alex222toxic]

@@zarifinator1327 ive been a fan since like a infant lol, my top 5 at 155 is penn,pulver,gomi.islam/khabib tied, then edgar.

[@zarifinator1327]

@@alex222toxic honestly Penn lost to Edgar 3 times in total which is why I can't put him higher than him. How is Pulver better than khabib, Edgar and Islam tho?

[@alex222toxic]

@@zarifinator1327 Ima be real, i thought he had a better resume in my head.

[@otterno.1128]

@@alex222toxic Penn is so good because of his Welterweight wins over like likes of Matt Hughes, and fighting in all weight divisions. He also did have an amazing lightweight run, but he's so good for his multiple weight division all-time wins. Also Takanori Gomi is a legendary fighter, but he should absolutely not be in a top 5 lightweight GOATS list.

[@julifilmstv6308]

I think Dan Henderson could be in the top 5 of middleweight or LHW. At least in terms of resume. He beat Shogun twice. Wanderlei, Big Nog, Vitor, Rich Franklin, Bisping and did that in his late 30s till mid 40s. And he arguably won the second fight against Bisping.

[@Janintong]

I can never see Merab's win over Aldo good, he literally just dry humped Aldo's leg for 3 rds I agree with Cory when he says "that wasnt a fight"

[@zappersolo7588]

He won and controled aldo

[@Lg10273]

He only controlled him the 2nd round the fight was mostly on the feet rewatch the fight. Only 5 minutes of control.

[@timurjack8773]

Its up to Aldo to do something about it as he know he was going to lose if he let Merab holding him, Aldo needed to take more risks to win the fight.

[@Janintong]

@zappersolo7588 not saying Aldo got Robbed, I'm saying Merab's win over aldo should be discounted the way people discount Cejudo's win over Cruz, and Aljo's win over TJ... it wasn't a fight, it was merab scraping a win (its a gamrot victory) I'm not trying to write essay

[@zappersolo7588]

@@Janintong no robbery wins arent wins boring wins are still wins

[@alexanderokak5112]

I'll be honest Lucas, this was a great overall list and a very entertaining video. I don't think you were being controversial on purpose either, you had really good justifications for your risky/less mainstream picks.

[@WWEWRESTLERDATA]

Oliveira Should be In Top 3 😮

[@I777-w3e]

Fr beat all of the top 5 at the time

[@SublineYT]

I really think you should rewatch GSP vs Hendricks, R1 is closer than most people remember. I personally scored it for GSP. R2/R4 were clearly Hendricks', R3/R5 were clearly GSP. So I disagree with you so casually calling it a loss, since you at least questioned the other close fights for other fighters here.

[@zarifinator1327]

Most people who call it a robbery havent even seen the fight, i still think hendricks won r1 but it was extremely close

[@ngonimandizha7738]

Agree with you both. That fight is lowkey a draw imo. Hendricks was also on steroids btw, so GSP shouldn’t be looked down upon for arguably losing to a cheater.

[@ngonimandizha7738]

@DarrenReddix-iv4um Exactly, that fight was one of the most clear 49-46s I’ve ever seen

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a BEST of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names on your record and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@dirkdookies6418]

Tbh Hendricks pre usada and post usada are two different fighters so I don’t think many people count that against gsp

[@Rickgrimes_10]

Skipped to middleweight to see how you’d hate on Izzy this video and you got Izzy as one of Whittaker’s best wins lmao

[@lucastracymma8764]

lol because i think Whittaker beat him in the rematch

[@RealMrSmile]

​@@lucastracymma8764 And I think Holloway beat Volk in the rematch Does that mean that I go out there and pretend that that was an actual win for Max?

[@Rickgrimes_10]

@@lucastracymma8764 yeah you’re high

[@Rickgrimes_10]

@@lucastracymma8764 if Izzy lost to rob volk lost to chad mendes

[@Idk-gy3xu]

@@RealMrSmilevolk easily won 3-2 while rob won 3-2 in a very close fight

[@mostly_ghostly9889]

I love listening to your videos at work. whenever I see an hour long video I get excited

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a BEST of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names on your record and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@david-ft7fn]

Same bro

[@exbelleenthusiast2315]

You are such a casual HW fan lol. How can you not include overeem??? Overeem wins: Werdum 2x, JDS, Lesnar, Pavlovich, Mir, Arlovski Easily makes top 5 lmao especially since you rate Werdum so highly

[@s66s46]

Damn overeems resume is way better than I thought

[@ssglbc1875]

True but I think Werdum and overeem because of the losses shouldn’t be so high.

[@sandrakiefler4649]

You know what my dude…here I was legitimately upset about the rankings for the first few weight classes BUT as we moved through I gotta say that I honestly think (while still iffy I had to admit that if nothing else you are extremely consistent with the way that you are coming up with these rankings😉👍) I’m getting slightly swayed by your arguments here…it’s kinda funny really but regardless of everything, and even tho I’m not 100% in agreement with the lists, I’m loving the way that you are explaining your choices my dude! I mean like seriously tho…I got to the end of the welterweight list and I thought damn! Ok I see you…paused the video and went and immediately SUBBED ffs!? It’s kinda crazy that I have never come across any of your other content but I’m here for it man, even if I don’t 100% agree on these lists of yours I still have to admit that it’s great to see that you have solid, fairly unbiased and well rounded opinions and regardless of whether I’m with you on some things I can’t not sub for such thoroughly researched content man, looking forward to checking out the rest of your content bro🤷‍♀️🤔😉👌

[@orlandohernandez6903]

First time i’ve ever seen someone recognize how good GSP’s win over Jake Shields was

[@SkrimpKing]

I dont understand why or how you consider Aldo was in his prime at 32 when he clearly wasn't. Jot every fighter is in their "prime" from 29-33. Aldo's prime was 100% before he was 32. The dude was already a champ for years and years by the time he was 27, he got into MMA and fighting much younger than most guys and had waaaaayyyy more fights than guys do nowadays. Some fighter peak early...just like some peak later in their career. You as an MMA fan should know this. Like how Volk started MMA later and therefore peaked later because he didnt have as many fights, injuries and everything else that fighters who start when they are young so

[@Dschww]

Great comment. Yeah, Aldo stated he was already competing on Vale Tudo in brazil at age 16. I think this dude thinks age and prime are the same thing lol.

[@s66s46]

Aldo has a lot of wins after his losses

[@s66s46]

​@@Dschwwyet aldo got multiple wins after his losses

[@ssglbc1875]

@@Dschwwhe might not of been at his physical best but he wasn’t old or washed.

[@I777-w3e]

Dustin over Charles is crazy.

[@tomsawyer6380]

I actually really like the top 5 hw that you did, and personally I don’t even have Cejudo top 5 125ers all time, although I have him at almost a tie with joey b at 5

[@StxrmFrm819]

Lucas is so good at ranking, he jus turns into this interesting teacher i could listen to all day

[@aryamanmani4025]

Agree with all the lists, also think Izzy and Whittaker are very close to becoming 1 and 2 especially if they beat DDP and Strickland respectively. Great job as per usual

[@joeswanson5486]

If Izzy wins his next 3 you could make a case

[@joeswanson5486]

But let’s be real Stephan Bonner is levels above beating Whittaker and Romero

[@iceyizo3]

Lucas with the clutch upload

[@Glaberra]

Aint no way bro just dropped this banger 💀

[@nobody8739]

he did

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a BEST of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names on your record and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@nobody8739]

@@ItsameAlex you’re not cooking

[@rileyhiga7952]

Rampage not being in LHW is crazy.

[@LucasButtschardt]

The fact that the bantam weight entry is so debatable is a testament to how competitive that division is and has been even in its youth.

[@Price-kl3lb]

I honestly can’t bring myself to put porier above Olivera after Olivera clearly beat him while Dustin was in his prime.

[@zarifinator1327]

@@Price-kl3lb Fair enough, but Dustin has beaten more champions.

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a BEST of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names on your record and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@timurjack8773]

Its not clearly, Oliveira hold Poirier's glove to get him to the ground, before that Poirier was beating Oliveira badly in the 1st round. Right now Poirier is improved his wrestling defense better after BSD fight, I don't think he would let Oliveira hold his glove again.

[@filipeocean2858]

​@@timurjack8773Makachev literally hold gloves almost every fight if you look closely , does that take away from his wins too?

[@zarifinator1327]

@@filipeocean2858 no he does not lmao, stop tryna gaslight

[@sweetshoez]

Performance-based rankings over W/L rankings is actually a good idea. It's pretty high effort though so I don't expect that there's enough knowledgeable people that could consistently debate that kind of thing. For example I think DP gained stock for his fight vs Islam. He clearly lost (was submitted) but I'm higher on him after than I was before

[@zarifinator1327]

@@sweetshoez yeah he gave Islam a harder fight than Charles, maybe Charles and dp should have a rematch

[@marcstamos8973]

people complain about the bantamweight list... but wtf is that lightweight list after khabib entry

[@seabass5484]

An hour of UFC content amidst this absolute drought. You’re our hero.

[@kyzerkurosaki4999]

Putting Poirier above Charles who beat him is crazy to me... one had the belt and defended it, and the other never succeed in a title fight. Charles also has a bunch of record.

[@azayfhossain5713]

merab is crazy

[@Jimmy-is8js]

Fr I thought I was the only one who thought that was way to overrated

[@imcgonigle2006]

He’s right

[@timurjack8773]

No one should be ranked as Goat top 5 without winning the belt first, at least an interim belt is needed.

[@joeswanson5486]

@@timurjack8773so yoel Romero chad mendes or Frankie edger can’t be top 5 in their weight divisions. Sure merab at 2 is crazy but he’s def top 5. Only fighter to really beat Petr yan then long win streak with Aldo and Cejudo

[@Slim-Clips]

Not including Benavidez exposes you as a casual.

[@GoatOfMMAForever]

Bro said Silva was on thin ice 💀

[@Totalnikkadeath]

He is. Id izzy beat strickland and ddp hes overtaking him

[@kent_kast]

Silvas about to fall out of the top 10

[@DCshandle]

@@kent_kastonly cause resume prime Silva would make mvp look lost

[@JT76912]

A decision machine, wet blanket like GSP who lost his belt multiple times throughout his reign can stay in the top 3 without a doubt, But 16 fight win streak, longest title reign in UFC history Silva who KOed damn near everyone who challenged him for the belt, sprinkled with a couple submissions, is "about to fall out of the top 10".

[@Totalnikkadeath]

@@JT76912 boring vs exciting doesnt matter. Plus silva was boring as well. Plus gsp fought better competition

[@z.k.r2615]

Prtr Yans’ arguments to be the goat of bantamweights just got better after dominating Figgy Plus where would you rank Topuria and Belal after their last wins ?

[@headClock]

Bantamweight list is wild. Gotta get some hot takes out there though to stir the pot.

[@colosseumtalk]

“his win over whittaker was a little bit more decisive” 😂😂😂 like izzy didn’t starch him twice in 1 fight lmfao. he absolutely took your boys soul and you clearly haven’t recovered

[@Totalnikkadeath]

That was a joke

[@krayzyelfenomeno04]

Jans son perieras son stricklands son robs son yoels son u clearly haven't recovered cry tho dog fiddler

[@mehal4581]

Glad I'm not the only one who noticed that. He said "a little more decisive" like we aren't comparing a close decision to a 2nd rd KO 🤣

[@JT76912]

Not to mention Adesayna dropped Rob in the second fight too,

[@UFCThoughts100]

38:26 did you just poop Flukas

[@sgtandyboy4377]

While I agree khabib wins aren’t great, you can’t ignore the dude never lost a round, maybe 1. And they way he smothers his opponents makes them look humiliated as the other thing they can do is look up at the clock to see if the round is ending. I feel like if he never retired, he would’ve continued smothering everyone

[@ElbanAsari]

Glesion tibau

[@hamcam4571]

When I needed long form videos for work one man posted when no one else would

[@BigBuxLeo]

There’s no way Lucas put Dustin over Charles

[@gabeharrison7683]

Nutsack mma did this video and it was a banger, you could only dream of making a video as based as his

[@lucastracymma8764]

lol i been telling you guys i was about to make this for 2 days now 🤣

[@zarifinator1327]

@@gabeharrison7683 Ayo another nutsack MMA enjoyer in this comment section, crazy lmao

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a BEST of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names on your record and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@willavery5124]

McGregor beat Holloway at featherweight also

[@Ja_M100]

Exactly wtf.

[@gatto481]

Holloway was like 21 lmao this fight mean nothing

[@Ja_M100]

@@gatto481 no it does buddy he beat him with 1 leg and Conor would beat him today too 🤷‍♂️

[@gatto481]

@@Ja_M100 Conor would beat Max Holloway today ? Thats hilarious

[@Ja_M100]

@@gatto481 why is it a flex for Holloway to beat Conor now ( past his prime ) but it’s not ok for Conor to beat him when they were both young ?

[@Wwyou617]

Dustin over Charles is genuinely laughable Charles went on one of the best win streaks in LW history and held the title and defend it against porier who btw never won undisputed how tf is he above him

[@samlight95]

Where do you have Topuira on the Featherweight list now mate? I think he has to be at least top 3, based on now having wins over the top 2 (I agree with your list based on the time you made it also)! Great vid

[@moshimoshi8283]

Yan>Merab. Yan has a higher quantity of tough opponents, and I feel like he’s gonna get more points for having such a close match against O Malley especially if O Malley ends up sleeping Merab like I think he will. Merab did dominate Yan though so I can see him being higher without having too much of a issue with it

[@j.m9555]

Prime Cain Velasquez would have destroyed Stipe Miocic, Fabricio Werdum, Fedor Emelianenko and Francis Ngannou...

[@Tomas-wm3pk]

Cain não venceria fedor é werdum finalizou ambos

[@j.m9555]

@@Tomas-wm3pk Fedor himself thinks that Cain is the best heavyweight ever. And we all know that Werdum beat Cain only because they fought at high altitude in Mexico.

[@joeswanson5486]

@@j.m9555it’s out of respect I mean cains even said fedor is the best hw ever.

[@joeswanson5486]

I think prime vs prime Cain would beat Werdum Fedor and stipe which stipe is a really tough fight and I know he’s better than Francis but I don’t think Cain would be able to deal with Francis big guy with big power. Francis is much better than lesnar

[@Sanji_Vinsmoke_69]

Nah, Aldo > Max and Oliviera > Dustin

[@davidditonto6161]

This was surprisingly great 👍

[@Jtaguines]

No fucking way in hell Dustin is higher all time than Charles, who lost to literally everybody on the list

[@honorylealtad5596]

His brain dead logic is something beyond our understanding

[@WhiteBoyTariq]

Aint no way he added Izzy to Rob and Romero's wins 💀 (still love you Flukas)

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a BEST of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names on your record and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@harindergill4358]

Chris Wiedman never fought Michael bisping tho or am I missing somehting? 😂

[@lucastracymma8764]

I had Vitor Belfort at the 5 spot and forgot to delete his win over bisping when I put weidman’s resume in lol

[@harindergill4358]

No worries mate jus keep up the izzy slander

[@ItsameAlex]

I think this is a GREATEST of all time list, not a BEST of all time list. Difference? Greatest is about names on your record and body of work, best is who would beat most fighters in a one on one fight regardless of record e.g You might put Ilia Topuria at number 1 for featherweight. You might put Dricus above Robert Whittaker for middleweight (not necessarily, maybe you think their fight was the one in three where dricus wins). I would like Lucas to make a best of all time list at some point (rather than this greatest list)

[@hitomukawakami7124]

38:25 bro just sharted his pants.

[@goldeternal]

how he kept a straight face is impressive and continue yapping with soiled pants

[@emillennstrom6297]

Hey man good video, male sure to look into the camera while talking. It keeps your audience engaged

[@Melquiades_]

Not having BJ Penn in your top 4 lightweights of all time is criminal

[@Melquiades_]

Tyron Woodley over Matt Hughes is also criminal

[@ssglbc1875]

@@Melquiades_is it? Other than lightweight champs and a young gsp who he is 1-2 with he didn’t beat anyone. Could you imagine if Hughes had to fight someone his own size from pride like sakuraba who was beating middleweights and light heavyweights? Ufc was at a weak state and at that point didn’t even have the best mma fighters in the world

[@Melquiades_]

@@ssglbc1875 I’m telling you bro I literally watched these guys. Trust me man Penn and Hughes were both absolute monsters.

[@Zaydonnn]

How is poirier above Charles😭

[@matthewgagliardi8429]

bros resume is way deeper poirier fought the two goats and charles fought my boy zero fight iq mike for the bellt they arent the same

[@drizzyeu7948]

@@matthewgagliardi8429poirier fought the 2 best and lost and furthermore he lost to Charles as well u guys think fighting someone adds to their resume regardless if they lose and get dominated