EPIC Showdown: Nautilus VS Royal Oak VS Overseas - Who Wins?

[@TheoTheodorou]

Vacheron is the connoisseurs choice. The other two are now driven by hype. Love all 3 but the guy with the VC in the room is the one I would want to talk to first.

[@therealcarsandchrono]

💯

[@TagmatonDomestikon]

I personally really love the Overseas Tourbillon with the blue dial. Something about VC's tourbillon design, it looks like something out of a jewellery stores Christmas display. Really elegant.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Overseas Tourb is a grail for sure! The peripheral rotor and overall movement combine with the dial and maltese cross tourbillon cage.. it's just phenomenal 😍🔥

[@ernestoruiz296]

I love it, also! But the price on the tourbillon is wild for me right now. Eventually in the near future.

[@diehardgopher4253]

I'd pick the Overseas. The integration of the Matlese Cross logo into the bezel and bracelet gives it a better look than the RO's octaganol bezel with screws or the Nautilus's port hole style bezel. I like the pointed hands on the Oversea's better, I like the blue suburst dial of the oversea's over the other two, I like the busier minute track over the other two, I like the applied Maltese Cross logo better than AP's logo and no applied logo for patek. Lastly, I just like the brand better with it being not as mainstream as Patek or AP but having just as much if not more history and tradition as the oldest continuously running brand in the world.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Right there with you for all the reasons stated 😁🙌

[@troycote4503]

​@@MarcoFerranteWatchesOverseas also. Preferably the Perpetual Calendar or 5500 Chrono definitely in Blue, Nautilus second

[@seanfurey5766]

yes totally agree on every point highlighted.. VC Overseas any day!

[@JeffJacquesmd]

I’ve had all three, the Overseas is my choice. The quality is as high, the design is beautiful, the movement is beautiful and the dial is superior to the RO and the Nautilus. The Overseas is really three watches in one with the excellent quick change system and I rarely see an Overseas when I go to a RedBar/GTG meetup. They are all beautiful, but my personal experience says the Overseas.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Great insight! I'm right there with you for all the reasons you stated. Overseas is just top notch 😁🙌

[@ChristopherJMBrown]

Vacheron has the best blue dial in a sports watch. Hands down. It's absolutely stunning!

[@travelandwatches8]

I love the Vacheron Overseas especially gen. 3 with the ability to change strap in less than 30 sec. without tools and with the maltese cross bracelet which was introduced on the gen 2. Gen 1 Overseas had a complete different bracelet design back when it was introduced in 1996.

[@artcloud18]

100%. Side story: tried seeing what price LB would offer my VC for a trade in, Marco gave me the most scammy quote (like 50% below market) I don't trust anything this kid says since, he just tries to rip off watch collectors.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

You know I'm with you 100%. Overseas is so good 😍🔥

[@JayandSarah]

@@artcloud18 trading watches in is like trading a car in, what exactly do you expect? If you want market pricing, you need to sell it yourself.

[@Rob02138]

I have an Overseas steel/black and a Nautilus (5726). The Overseas is a much better watch imo. I like the black because putting on a black alligator strap (in seconds) transforms the watch instantly into a very classy dress watch for the evening. The other thing that can’t be overstated (and I appreciate that it was mentioned) is that the Nautilus is an absolute scratch magnet. It doesn’t matter how careful you are, dozens if scratches make the bezel and bracelet look very beat up in short order. The Overseas has none of that…you can wear the hell out of it and use it as true sports watch (also with better water rating than Nautilus) and it looks great, no visible scratches. I’ve been out boating with my Overseas on rubber strap, come home wash it in the sink to get the salt water off, pop on the black alligator strap and ready for dinner out. Vacheron makes the best watches in the world.

[@jaivittalshetty6218]

Vacheron overseas blue dial . Affordable , durable and super compatible watch

[@stylebenderskodak1858]

Super compatible? Please elaborate

[@jaivittalshetty6218]

@shishir sk super compatible because it's goes with any outfit easily and vc gives you 2 additional straps I.e leather and rubber strap .

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Totally agree! The versatility, build quality and overall look is just so good 😍🔥

[@zacharypalczynski8450]

Love my Patek P 5270G (white gold) dress watch is 2023, but I love Vacheron Constantin over seas with that blue dial. Love you guys

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Thanks so much! No doubt 5270G is phenomenal!! Overseas is my pick also 😁🙌

[@NicholasCFranklin]

Almost like you spoke it into existence: VC now tapers the bracelet down to 18mm.

[@MrJeremy9835]

The Chopard Alpine Eagle is also very well built with lots of details

[@DavidJZribi]

VC overseas has the best looking (blue dial), it is more versatile (with 1 bracelet and 2 straps, we have 3 watches for the price of 1). We can argue about the finishing (whether the Nautilus or the Royal Oak have better finishing), but the fact that the overseas is much cheaper than the Nautilus and the Royal Oak makes me think that it is a no-brainer: the overseas is the best option. Last but not least: as a brand, VC is for me the best watchmaker. It is not a one-watch company. It has several models in portfolio (overseas, harmony, fiftysix, metier d'art, American 1921...). AP is only known for its Royal Oak model and Patek Philippe for its Nautilus lineup (some may argue that PP also has Calatrava and the Auquanaut but they are not as popular as the Nautilus).

[@sadersan9860]

it is amazing to see how much you guys love your job, I would pass out from talking about exactly same 3 watches for million times

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Haha well I'm glad to hear our passion resonates. Hope you enjoyed this 🙏

[@therealcarsandchrono]

Nice vid. No surprise but VC wins for me. Classy, high horology, versatility, and love that’s its more under radar and less hyped than other brands. Patek 5990 my fav nautilus but tapering bracelet feels flimsy.

[@jerryonly1138]

Vacheron Overseas 4500 the best of the 3. Higher tech specs, caliber refinements, versatility, quick change, … .

[@acehigh1504]

Why do I love the VC so much!? Prob my favorite watch brand. That blue dial! I will literally never be able to afford one but at least I can look at them online….

[@ryanyu102]

I love the overseas black dual time as well. I'm actually torn between the white or the black dial. With the black dial though, it does remind me a lot of the galactic empire emblem on starwars

[@johnprosser5035]

Got my name down for the VC Dual Time Black dial. Was chatting to the AD and they said the wait list was now down to 6-8 months which is exciting!!! Hope to get that call.

[@DueceHagertyTv]

Wow you guys opened my eyes to The Overseas, who knew it could compete with the top 4 watch giants. Love the pictures of each timepiece mentioned, great work fellas!!

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Awesome to hear this! Thanks so much for your support!! 😁🙌

[@Dranreb865]

Who are your 4 watch giants? Im assuming you're gonna say : patek, ap, rolex, rm? It's actually the big 3: patek, ap, vacheron. Those skanky rolexes and Richard mille are not in the same league.

[@DueceHagertyTv]

@@Dranreb865 I’m aware of the top 3 high horology watch producers that every one refers to, tbh the top 4 are where they are not because I put them there, the people decided. Don’t assume or jump to conclusions my guy, although I do think Ap, Patek, Vacheron, Rolex & Omega all make exceptional watches. There are other brands that also make high-quality watches but at a lower price point that’s not on everyone’s radar. Imo certain RM watches are to gaudy and gimmicky for my taste. My number one favorite watch brand is A Lange & Söhne.

[@gustavorivero5653]

Overseas… it is not in the video, but the Rose gold Overseas with the Boat in the back case is just beautiful!!! Great video!!!

[@TheWatchHangout]

Great video guys! Overseas blue dial is amazing for sure and that model is probably the most durable of the 3. The Overseas bracelet does taper.. just not enough imo

[@maximl8820]

Totally agreed

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Thank you! I love the versatility of the Overseas and that blue dial is the best in the biz. I also prefer its movement to the Royal Oak and Nautilus. That makes the lack of bracelet taper easier to handle 😁🙌

[@maximl8820]

@@MarcoFerranteWatches I just noticed that bracelet doesn't really taper on mine. Just shows this was Never an issue

[@timeisahumanconstruct9251]

@@MarcoFerranteWatches can't beat the JLC 920 though and only the very rare and hard to find ultra thin OS has it.

[@aaronmauer7225]

I find that having the royal oak being so impactful for AP is actually more of a shortcoming on the brand than a praise of the watch

[@choyayahyah]

A great conversation! Personally, I would go for the Nautilus just because it is my favorite brand, and I actually appreciate the fact that it is more of a sports watch for Patek, unlike AP where it is the brand and Patek doesn't throw all their most complicated movements into the watch. And for those reasons I look at the AP and 3rd for me. I happen to have the blue Aquanaut that I was given from an AD at retail and I have a skeleton perpetual calendar Overseas that I also got from and AD. I do lime the Vacherons and I appreciate their level of finishings.

[@deruhrtyp0112]

Vacheron for me

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Me too 😁🙌

[@JulioVillavicencio-ru2sn]

Thanks for great review. Love my 2014 VC and 2016 AP. Never interested in the PP Nautilus and prefer the 5227R.

[@artisans_watches]

VC overseas for me

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Me too 😁🙌

[@markclayden7654]

I have 2 Royal Oak's, a patek 5711/1R and a 5726/1A, but the Vacheron is still top of my "want one" list. Amazing watches.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

All 3 are no doubt phenomenal! The VC is my personal pick due to the overall versatility and its finishing which I think is just a notch above the Royal Oak and Nautilus. But no doubt all 3 are phenomenal 😁🙌

[@markclayden7654]

@@MarcoFerranteWatches I want the Overseas Tourbillon, thats just a jem of a watch, but its SO expensive 😶

[@JayandSarah]

@@markclayden7654 sounds like a first world problem

[@markclayden7654]

@@JayandSarah It is, and proud of it 😁

[@JayandSarah]

@@markclayden7654 enjoy it while you have it, many have come before you that found themselves back to zero. I have seen this first hand with a $50 million pound fortune to bankrupt - in the family!

[@SuperAmo87]

I really fell for the Vacheron .. ultimate class

[@jimlees8234]

Overseas in a heartbeat, not even close.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Right there with you 😁🙌

[@watchdork]

Royal oak saved the mechanical watch industry. Hands down my favorite design. The bracelet design is undeniably the best

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

No doubt it is one of the most important watches ever made and one of the best looking watches ever made also 😍🔥

[@davidelliott948]

Great video, gents! I love my RO Chrono, but appreciate the other two. The VC interchangeable bracelet system was a great idea. In today’s market, the PP perpetual chronos seem like a bargain.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Agree with all your points! Thanks so much for the support on the video 😁🙌

[@boldold]

Overseas black dial dual time is the one. Was my grail, got it at retail before the hype, could not be happier.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

It's phenomenal no doubt! Enjoy it in good health 😁🙌

[@underdog5081]

I have the AP 15500 black dial and the Overseas blue dial dial time. Both great watches. For me it’s a toss up! In regards to the Overseas, totally agree about the Dual Time having more character on the dial than the three hander.

[@abrahamwann1586]

I love all 3 to be honest. But if I could only pick 1 , it would have to be the 39mm royàl oak in gold. That would be my choice. Great video Marco and Adrian. Awesome details with all three brands. Lots of love from Australia. Abs.

[@Harpreet06]

Overseas dial color is better but there's no texture

[@govtfunded]

Everest, K2, Annapurna. The VC Overseas in some variants is available at or below retail. Marketing and hype are crazy.

[@keeponjumping5000]

All great watches. But the choice must be clear: 5711 is by far the most desirable

[@zzzz-nd7cl]

There is also the Patek Sculpture, Nautilus and Aquanaut looks

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Awesome 😁🙌

[@petemorbius3936]

should also put in daytona (white gold blue dial)

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Not a bad one for sure! 😁🙌

[@petemorbius3936]

@@MarcoFerranteWatches :)

[@samarthmehta9]

Overseas all day everyday

[@danchapman5944]

I have all 3 and if one was totally objective, and put value retention and hype aside, the VC is a comfortable winner.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Awesome feedback! Personally I agree also 😁🙌

[@danielsierra4768]

As of right now the overseas has the lowest retail and you can still get it for around 5 to 10k over retail new the ap and pp you pay 30 to like 80k above retail

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Yea it's pretty nuts all things considered especially since I think the Overseas very well may be the best of the 3 😍🔥

[@kleinchesleryutankin9750]

When I started with my watch journey, I was obsessed with the Royal Oak and nothing else. As time goes by, my love for it has been chiseled down a lot from AP making all these variations and just butchering the Royal Oak. Don’t get me wrong, innovation is great but you take a single design, a blank canvas, and smother literally all the colors in the world on to it and you’re left with just total chaos. Adrian mentioned it and you literally see ALL complications have been slapped on to the Royal Oak and that takes away the mystery of it. The romance is gone. One time, I’ve owned a Royal Oak (15400ST) and I was the happiest camper in the world but later on, I knew what I felt and I just had to sell it. Bought a Vacheron Constantin Overseas Dual Time (black, of course) cos I knew on paper, it was just a better watch and didn’t really expect too much from it but it rekindled my love again, almost the same feeling I had when I discovered the Royal Oak. The Overseas is not perfect but that to me is why I love it.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

@luxurybazaargift_on_nicegram- great insight here! AP is phenomenal but I do agree the Overseas is a newer, fresher and improved sports watch. It's so good 😍🔥

[@atreidis3946]

My choice. Vacheron Constantin Overseas Blue Dial.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

It's incredible 😍🔥

[@The_real_Mr_Ghost]

Great job guys @Marco 👌👊🏼 IMO Overseas wins as the best watch. Quality, finishing, durability and more water resistant. And so much more comfortable than RO and Nautilus with the extension link 👍

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

I tend to agree! The Overseas is just an absolute stunner 😍🔥

[@acgagaclan]

I can't find any source saying the vc overseas dial is made in the same factory as the fpj chronometre bleu. Where did you guys get that from?

[@bulhesh]

Yes its same factory

[@thewatchguyinc.7429]

Love these 3 but I suggest you do the same comparison with the GP Laureato it’s also a watch with a huge history and similar aesthetic

[@chaosphizzle]

Too much tpg

[@thewatchguyinc.7429]

@@chaosphizzle I’m not sure what this tpg is or means

[@adrianjd32]

Marco killed it this video, he is very impressive for his age

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Thanks very much! Appreciate the kind words and your support 😁🙌

[@MrJeremy9835]

I prefer the IWC ingenieur and the Girard Perregaux Laureato over the 3

[@singaporewatchcollector6262]

Nautilus for sure. It’s the refinement of a royal oak. An improved and better version. Royal oak looks nice but more rough and industrial. Nautilus on the other hand is sleek , smooth and refined.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

I do agree they are somewhat different for sure. One is more industrial and one definitely a more refined sports watch. Both have their merits for ownership for sure 😁🙌

[@sumitkar8146]

Marco is a watch encyclopedia- as Ben Afleck said of Matt Damon in Good Will Hunting “ My boy is wicked smart” - no schtick, no BS, just a guy talking watches- a true content creator. Not in the same league as these watches, but from a criticality to a brand - the Speedmaster for Omega is up there

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Haha I really appreciate that! No doubt Speedmaster is an iconic sports watch. The Submariner also. So many amazing pieces that are incredibly iconic 😁🙌

[@a004]

Nautilus all day, every day

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Phenomenal piece 😍🔥

[@tondo6912]

Problem with Nautilus is fragility compared to Vacheron.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

I completely agree.. very flimsy bracelet was so underwhelming when I first tried this watch in person. It shocks quite a few people actually 👍

[@0xl30]

Can’t beat the Overseas. The other two are great watches, but they feel so cheap.

[@fardocad]

I don't like vc overseas's hour hand because it overlaps hour markers

[@ernistifer]

4500v wins for me. The reason why it’s not as popular is because it has not been marketed is like the other watches.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Right there with you! Love the look and versatility of it 😁🙌

[@bok92]

AP Royal Oak Offshores, the new 43mm variant will be my favourite. So wearable even for small wrist and not a scratch magnet like the typical Royal Oaks SS.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

So good! Do love the new design and also the quick change strap system 😁🙌

[@almatt8310]

Tissot PRX 👏

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

The best haha 😁🙌

[@johnsmith-i5u]

A Lange & Sohne Odeysseus, H Moser Streamliner, Czapek Antarctique, Urban Jurgenson One, Parmiagiani Tonga? what about these as a possible choice to compare? Honestly, the holy trinity is too old school, commonplace.... If you ask anyone who never heard of the holy trinity, any of the other watches, when compared, is equally if not better, made than the H trinity.

[@hectorrios5402]

I used to wear a 5711 in places I wouldn’t want to wear my Rolex GMT 😵‍💫

[@kesselbrenner]

Overseas isn’t iconic yet. AP is a one watch company so it is only logic they will put into it any complication they make. PP has the best case and dial design. AP has the more beautiful bracelet while VC has the more functional bracelet with the micro adjustments and quick release system. VC has the better movement but has the poorest dial design especially with the date window and the rail tracks also the date change isn’t instantly which is annoying. VC is thicker which for me is a con. I wish it was possible to have a watch with PP case and an AP bracelet with VC quick release system and VC caliber.

[@hamachiwustin622]

I go VC. If you are not show off personal

[@stephenbrown5672]

A no am watching this drunk but more marko and Adrian please 🇬🇧👍👍💙

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Haha thank you! 😁🙌

[@thefreshprinceofbelleairbeach]

Overseas dual time or perpetual ultrathin for me

[@dimitrisbastas739]

At the year 1999 the comparison was: 1st gen overseas, nautilus 3800 and royal oak 14790st. The overseas won easily. Superior design, robust, heavy and the best ever safety clasp.

[@hamachiwustin622]

Once you experienced all three you will agreed VC is the winner

[@kingxerxes3139]

Piaget polo 80s in yellow gold.

[@simonassouline1230]

The biggest flaw with VC Overseas, their’s no Hacking seconds! Expensive watch, with a simple complication needed!

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

I get where you are coming from but personally I don't think it's a deal breaker. The Nautilus didn't have hacking seconds until recently 🤷‍♂️

[@johnlim4289]

I'd toss a dice between the Nautilus and Overseas. Having a smaller wrist, the Royal Oak is the least comfortable. I tried on the dual time and it felt like a brick.

[@superkjell]

If it was my money to spend and for a watch to wear: Overseas, if it was a watch to keep for more financial reasons: Nautilus

[@AdamEve-ie3yr]

VCO!

[@carlosoruna7174]

Of these 3 nautilus

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Nautilus is no doubt phenomenal 😍🔥

[@abcdLeeXY]

Overseas for enthusiasts Royal oak and nautilus for grey market salespeople

[@Doaibuabah]

ROYAL OAK🔥🔥🔥

[@Thelustigclub]

I have the dual time Overseas. I love this watch. I have 8 straps which I alternate depending on what I wear. Awesome. I also like AP and PP but the fact that you cannot buy them unless you do a “journey” with the brand is a total joke. Vaults in the secondary markets are full of these AP and PP. Sad because these watches should be on a wrist and not in a vault.

[@notaflightreactsfan3706]

im a simple man, i see roman sharf, luxury bazaar upload and i click....easy as that

[@adrianjd32]

Where did you see Roman Sharf?

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Thank you!! 😁🙌

[@notaflightreactsfan3706]

@@MarcoFerranteWatches as always!

[@GabeFelix-uy2dt]

So interesting boy I like all for different reasons. But I will say none are my top five all time. I prefer other Patek watches and vacheron watches. Regarding the royal oak to me that is that brands staple. Without it they loose a lot.

[@laurenttuf8272]

As I am not a rapper with a gold tooth to get an PP😂 I will go for a Vacheron more exclusive than the others

[@bekind1784]

Not just because of the hype on these models, but all three are star sports watches: attractive styling, functional and solid quality/horology for time/date only watch.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Totally agree! Each in their own right can be a perfect one and done watch collection 😁🙌

[@Smitlors]

This kid is like the rainman of watches 😂 big fan of the channel guys love the show

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Thanks so much!! Appreciate your continued support 😁🙌

[@marcozuleta133]

Dont know if this is an unpopular opinion, but the Nautilus is waaay better looking and elegant than the Royal Oak. The RO looks very unrefined and rough (specially with those hideous screws on the bezel) whilst the Nautilus has a more elegant and luxurious look to it. The RO looks like a $800 watch compared to a $10.000 look of the Nautilus

[@rootedrotor525]

Royal Oak ftw - and it's not close.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

It's amazing no doubt 😍🔥

[@ahz8976]

VC0 for me

[@ItsMe-ky1km]

audio really bad. nobody mixing it?

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Thanks for the feedback. Will work on improving it 🙏

[@cookingwithwatches]

Как по мне VC самые интересные.

[@jedkleebaum7235]

Gen 3 overseas was 2016. Gen 1 was 1996.

[@sinjinadams2862]

If I had to pick one it would be the Royal Oak but honestly I have no interest in any of these watches. Informative episode though.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Fair enough! Glad you enjoyed this 😁🙌

[@jobjafetbadilloruiz2761]

I would normally pick Overseas but I keep thinking of Cartier Santos

[@kaiserphoenix01]

Nautilus, overall the best design and best made. AP Royal Oak, the most iconic and most beautiful bracelet. Vacheron OS, the least iconic and probably the least well finished of the three but the best daily wear option.

[@frankphilpot3492]

Okay, it's time to show some love. The 5711 1A is the best of the best of the Nautilus line. The AP Royal Oak is a very beautiful watch, but I still lean towards the Patek. 👍

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Totally fair! I don't think there is a bad choice in this bunch 😁🙌

[@verde629]

The VC is a few celebrities or influencers to wear to blow up lol

[@patrik3450]

Overseas

[@nr1416]

Overseas bracelet that doesn't taper is a deal breaker for me. It's just way to bulky like Adrian mentions

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Fair enough.. I think not a big deal and the 3 bracelets gives it a versatility the others dont. Also the blue dial and movement is just 😍🔥

[@turdferguson7686]

casioak ftw. can get a custom cased one for like $300. obviously the way to go.

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Haha nice! 😁👍

[@robertosanchez4021]

Sports watch with 50 meters water resistance? No quick set date until just recently? for me the RO is no sports watch, and its bracelet is not as comfortable as the VC and the Nautilus...the most iconic sports watch is the Rolex Submariner by far...

[@MarcoFerranteWatches]

Rolex Submariner is definitely iconic in its own right no doubt. The 15202ST released for the 40th anniversary was done in 2012. All of the points you listed really weren't a priority to collectors until recently which is why it didn't really matter 👍

[@kevinhan721]

Odysseus

[@jackhummell]

Royal Oak is the king

[@DonLee1980]

The overseas blue dial is beautiful, but the black dial is meh... I have the black dial, and because it reflects like a mirror, all i can ever see is my sapphire being dirty with marks and finger prints. meanwhile when i look at my royal oak and nautilus, they look always look great

[@BiografWien-zx6tf]

Submariner is the only iconic watch … these are like dress watches that nobody needed untill recently.. you guys know nothing

[@navarrolevel7]

Nautilus for me. Best of the 3, the best fitting, thinnest, most blingy in both a sporty and elegant way. Royal oak no 2. Overseas is like the prx of the 3, and even the prx has a nice taper on the bracelet that overseas doesn’t